Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,150,294 members, 7,807,999 topics. Date: Thursday, 25 April 2024 at 02:09 AM

Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification - Politics - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Politics / Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification (7347 Views)

Breaking News: Tribunal Rules Out Petition Against Rivers Governor, Wike / Oil Deal: House Throws Out Report Clearing Diezani / Court Throws-Out Application To Stop Buhari's Inauguration (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (Reply) (Go Down)

Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by GARRIx7(m): 1:00pm On Jan 11, 2013
Supreme Court Throws Out Petition Against Oshiomhole’s Quailification

The Supreme Court has set aside the ruling of the Court of Appeal which upheld a petition filed by the governorship candidate of the People’s Democratic Party (PDP) in the last Edo state governorship election, challenging the academic qualification of Mr Adams Oshiomhole.

Justice Bode Rhodes-Vivour who delivered the lead judgment said the appellate court erred in its ruling since the petitioner did not make the issue of qualification a ground in his petition before the tribunal.

He also added that it was a blunder on the part of the petitioner not to make the issue of qualification a ground for challenging the election of Governor Oshiomhole rather than smuggling it through the back door.

The Judge noted that since a petitioner is bound by his petition, there is no ground on which the petition will stand and as such the ruling of the Appeal Court was struck out and the ruling of the tribunal upheld.

The court however ordered the tribunal to hear paragraph 30 of the petition which sought to disqualify votes in five out of the 18 local government areas in Edo state as a result of alleged electoral malpractice and corruption

www.channelstv.com/home/2013/01/11/supreme-court-throws-out-petition-against-oshiomholes-quailification/?utm_source=&utm_medium=twitter

Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by Nobody: 1:14pm On Jan 11, 2013
This is a victory for the people of Edo state and a defeat to Anenih and his pdp cohorts.congrats to Oshiomhole and edo people.I pray the tribunal delivers judgment accordingly.

1 Like

Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by qplus(m): 1:26pm On Jan 11, 2013
Dat is why we r here ...
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by thelastPope(m): 1:29pm On Jan 11, 2013
~Bluetooth:

This is a victory for the people of Edo state and a defeat to Anenih and his pdp cohorts.congrats to Oshiomhole and edo people.I pray the tribunal delivers judgment accordingly.

The Edo state PDP never joined in the suit. It was Anenih and Ileviarhe on their own. The party dissociated themselves from it. check your facts!
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by GARRIx7(m): 1:36pm On Jan 11, 2013
thelastPope:

The Edo state PDP never joined in the suit. It was Anenih and Ileviarhe on their own. The party dissociated themselves from it. check your facts!

And where did he mention Edo State PDP??

He said Anenih and his Cohorts.

Has Anenih decamped to CPC??

2 Likes

Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by ejifranks(m): 1:50pm On Jan 11, 2013
I Laugh in Greek grin grin grin grin grin grin Congrats to the man Edo people want
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by mapet: 1:50pm On Jan 11, 2013
grin grin grin grin grin grin grin ;LWKMD

We are knowing PDP house boys 1by1
GARRI (x7):


And where did he mention Edo State PDP??

He said Anenih and his Cohorts.

Has Anenih decamped to CPC??
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by Nobody: 1:52pm On Jan 11, 2013
Nice one. ACN members don't forge certificate

1 Like

Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by warrior101: 2:12pm On Jan 11, 2013
hahahhahahaha this man never seize to amaze me. him too get friends... oshio baba caryy go sha grin
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by KnowAll(m): 2:15pm On Jan 11, 2013
Thank God, Supreme Court is working. Well the Courts should be d last bastion for d common man.
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by mynaija123(m): 2:21pm On Jan 11, 2013
The Supreme Court, yesterday, set aside the ruling of the Appeal Court which ordered the Edo State Election Petitions Tribunal to hear afresh the matter of non-qualification of Governor Adams Oshiomhole for the July 14, 2012  Edo state gubernatorial election. Justice Bode Rhodes-Vivour who gave the Supreme Court judgement said the Appeal Court erred in its ruling, as the Edo Election Petitions Tribunal which earlier struck out the paragraphs relating to non-qualification was correct in doing so. The Supreme Court maintained that the respondent, Maj-Gen Charles Airhiavbere made an unpardonable blunder of not including the ground of non-qualification in the original pleadings at the tribunal. The apex court maintained that the court is not a father Christmas who dishes out what is not asked for and that a party is bound by his pleadings. The Supreme Court however maintained that there is no nexus between the issue of non-qualification and alleged corrupt practices in the election, it subsequently ordered the tribunal to hear paragraph 30 of the petition which sought to disqualify votes in 61 out of 2,642 units in the state over alleged electoral malpractice. It would be recalled that the Edo State Election petitions tribunal had, on September 27, 2012, dismissed the petition filed by Major General Charles Airhiavbere (rtd) in which he challenged the educational qualifications of Edo State Governor, Comrade Adams Oshiomhole, describing it as a wild goose chase. In his ruling, the Tribunal Chairman, Suleiman Ambursa said the petition is a pre-election matter that ought to have been dispensed with long before the July 14, 2012  governorship election. Mr. Ambursa had averred that in line with the provisions of the constitution, candidates are expected to submit copies of their documents to the Independent Electoral Commission (INEC) before the election and that the same constitution mandates the electoral body to publish the said documents in order that any other candidate that is not satisfied with the information therein contained might approach the Federal High Court for appropriate interpretation. Dissatisfied with the tribunal ruling, Airhiavbere approached the Appeal Court to quash the tribunal ruling and restore some paragraphs in the petition. In its ruling given onNovember 15, 2012 , the Court of Appeal sitting in Benin in a unanimous ruling, ordered that the petition filled by Airhiavbere be remitted to the lower Tribunal “for trial denovo.” Chairman of the three-man panel, Justice Helen Ogunwumiju said the tribunal was wrong to have said it lacked jurisdiction on Oshiomhole’s academic qualification being a pre-election matter that should be heard by the conventional court. The appellate court said by the provision of Section 177 of the 1999 Constitution as amended, the lower tribunal had jurisdiction to entertain Airhiavbere’s petition bordering on Oshiomhole’s qualification because the Court can hear pre-election and election matters on qualification. Not comfortable with the Appeal Court ruling, Oshiomhole approached the Supreme Court which in its judgment, yesterday, faulted the Appeal Court ruling and upheld the decision of the tribunal.
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by KnowAll(m): 2:23pm On Jan 11, 2013
Basically the judgement is " U cannot change d rules of a game when d match has started" good and wise judgment.
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by Skipfr(m): 2:26pm On Jan 11, 2013
Congrats oshiobaba. Mak Airhiavbere go leak black soup witout oil. Mtcheeewwwwwww
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by GARRIx7(m): 2:31pm On Jan 11, 2013
mapet: grin grin grin grin grin grin grin ;LWKMD

We are knowing PDP house boys 1by1

So LOSTHOPE is a PDP House-boy......
cheesy cheesy
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by free2ryhme: 2:45pm On Jan 11, 2013
KnowAll: Thank God, Supreme Court is working. Well the Courts should be d last bastion for d common man.

can the common afford over N1m to seek redress @ the highest court of the land ...Guy no deceive ya sef justice get price and you go need to pay cash
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by thelastPope(m): 2:46pm On Jan 11, 2013
GARRI (x7):


And where did he mention Edo State PDP??

He said Anenih and his Cohorts.

Has Anenih decamped to CPC??

He said "Anenih and his PDP Cohorts" not "Anenih and his Cohorts". Maybe you need reading glasses! See as you dey show yourself? cheesy cheesy cheesy


~Bluetooth:

This is a victory for the people of Edo state and a defeat to Anenih and his pdp cohorts.congrats to Oshiomhole and edo people.I pray the tribunal delivers judgment accordingly.

1 Like

Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by Ikc95: 2:47pm On Jan 11, 2013
PDP No way for una dis time.
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by Nobody: 2:48pm On Jan 11, 2013
D issue was thrown out on technical grounds a la; issues nt raised at 1st instance cannot be entertained on appeal. We xpected d judgement and it does nt exonerate Oshiomhole, or otherwise, of d allegation.
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by GARRIx7(m): 2:50pm On Jan 11, 2013
thelastPope:

He said "Anenih and his PDP Cohorts" not "Anenih and his Cohorts". Maybe you need reading glasses! See as you dey show yourself? cheesy cheesy cheesy

So where did you see ur "EDO STATE PDP"?

Y you go score OWN GOAL??... Its allowed sha, provided you can equalise....

cheesy cheesy
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by Engratia: 2:51pm On Jan 11, 2013
[color=#006600][/color] it clearly shows that we've grown in dis country, if Aneni n his cronies wants to take power through d judiciary, hummm they are jok!ing grin the edo people's voice is d voice of GOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!

1 Like

Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by Prowise(m): 2:59pm On Jan 11, 2013
Its a pity the judgement went this way. Though, Arhiabvere didn't file his petition properly, the fact remains that Oshiomhole doesn't have the genuine certificate. Given his boisterous character he would have long displayed it aleast to shame Arhiabvere if he actually had one. But what did he do? He spent millions, if not billions, of naira in legal fees to have the petition struck out. Whether the petition was properly filed or not; or whether its a pre-election matter or not, a substantive constitutional matter is the issue here. This is miscarriage of justice fueled by emotiöns and political interests. In a slightly similar case, involving Obama, he honourbly displayed hìs birth certificate to put to rest questiöns regarding his birth place.
This is a bad judicial precedent for upholding the tenents of our cönstitutiön. We shouldn't let emotiöns to becloud our sense of reasoning and judgement on sancrosant issues. Goodluck Oshiomhole!

2 Likes

Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by thelastPope(m): 3:01pm On Jan 11, 2013
GARRI (x7):


So where did you see ur "EDO STATE PDP"?

Y you go score OWN GOAL??... Its allowed sha, provided you can equalise....

cheesy cheesy

Trying to shift the goal post again abi? That is what you always do anytime you are caught in the act! It takes a real man to acknowledge when they are wrong! SMH!
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by OmoTier1(m): 3:18pm On Jan 11, 2013
Prowise: Its a pity the judgement went this way. Though, Arhiabvere didn't file his petition properly, the fact remains that Oshiomhole doesn't have the genuine certificate. Given his boisterous character he would have long displayed it aleast to shame Arhiabvere if he actually had one. But what did he do? He spent millions, if not billions, of naira in legal fees to have the petition struck out. Whether the petition was properly filed or not; or whether its a pre-election matter or not, a substantive constitutional matter is the issue here. This is miscarriage of justice fueled by emotiöns and political interests. In a slightly similar case, involving Obama, he honourbly displayed hìs birth certificate to put to rest questiöns regarding his birth place.
This is a bad judicial precedent for upholding the tenents of our cönstitutiön. We shouldn't let emotiöns to becloud our sense of reasoning and judgement on sancrosant issues. Goodluck Oshiomhole!
Sorry the offer they made you is now a pipe dream! Obama spent months amd after several court cases by the birthers and realizing the birthers were using it to weaken His person before He decided to release his birth certificate.

Oshiomholeh filed a certificate before INEC. The onions is on the accuser to prove His case and not the accused.

1 Like

Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by Elueme: 3:50pm On Jan 11, 2013
~Bluetooth:

This is a victory for the people of Edo state and a defeat to Anenih and his pdp cohorts.congrats to Oshiomhole and edo people.I pray the tribunal delivers judgment accordingly.
You are such a lousy talker who enjoys the privilege of a techno phone and etisalat free data, and posts nonsense full of chauvinism from a possible slum somewhere in Lagos. If you don't know jack about Edo politics, stay quiet.. If the Anenih and PDP bigwigs in Abuja wanted Oshiomohle out, he won't survive this case. An expensive information. Stop deceiving yourself
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by Prowise(m): 3:57pm On Jan 11, 2013
Omo_Tier1:
Sorry the offer they made you is now a pipe dream! Obama spent months amd after several court cases by the birthers and realizing the birthers were using it to weaken His person before He decided to release his birth certificate.

Oshiomholeh filed a certificate before INEC. The onions is on the accuser to prove His case and not the accused.

Why is anybody who expresses his/her candid informed opinion that is skewed toward PDP seen as a stooge by u guys? Well, you seem not to understand the issue here. This is the summary : ARHIAVBERE WANTS OSHIOMHOLE'S CERTIFICATE INVESTIGATED because HE IS SURE ITS FAKE, BUT OSHIOMHOLE SAID NO! What do u infer from this? Would you stop someone frm investigating ur certificate if u knw its genuine without blemishes? Case closed.
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by Demdem(m): 3:57pm On Jan 11, 2013
utumunta: D issue was thrown out on technical grounds a la; issues nt raised at 1st instance cannot be entertained on appeal. We xpected d judgement and it does nt exonerate Oshiomhole, or otherwise, of d allegation.

so u are basically going back to court right? Goodluck.
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by Mogidi: 4:28pm On Jan 11, 2013
This is not over yet, he won only on technicalities
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by Nobody: 4:39pm On Jan 11, 2013
why u come carry d issue for head like this? U be pdp spokesperson? I dey laugh ooooo

He said "Anenih and his PDP Cohorts" not "Anenih and his Cohorts". Maybe you need reading glasses! See as you dey show yourself? cheesy cheesy cheesy


[/quote]

1 Like

Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by Leofric(m): 4:51pm On Jan 11, 2013
the sodier is just a loser.....congratulation edo state
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by anonimi: 5:30pm On Jan 11, 2013
GARRI (x7):


And where did he mention Edo State PDP??

He said Anenih and his Cohorts.

Has Anenih decamped to CPC??

I hope sey you nor get that thing wey dem dey call myopia aka short-sightedness. Probably what you have is selective reading. Bros, na which one?
Or are you not talking about Bluetooth's post:

~Bluetooth:

This is a victory for the people of Edo state and a defeat to Anenih and his [size=13pt]pdp[/size] cohorts.congrats to Oshiomhole and edo people.I pray the tribunal delivers judgment accordingly.

Is it possible to make our criticism more fact based
Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by GARRIx7(m): 5:40pm On Jan 11, 2013
Elueme: You are such a lousy talker who enjoys the privilege of a techno phone and etisalat free data, and posts nonsense full of chauvinism from a possible slum somewhere in Lagos. If you don't know jack about Edo politics, stay quiet.. If the Anenih and PDP bigwigs in Abuja wanted Oshiomohle out, he won't survive this case. An expensive information. Stop deceiving yourself

Nonsense!!!

They've always wanted Oshiomole out..... Stop lying like a stvpid illiterate....

1 Like

Re: Court Throws-Out Petition Against Oshiomole's Qualification by Omexonomy: 5:48pm On Jan 11, 2013
Elueme: You are such a lousy talker who enjoys the privilege of a techno phone and etisalat free data, and posts nonsense full of chauvinism from a possible slum somewhere in Lagos. If you don't know jack about Edo politics, stay quiet.. If the Anenih and PDP bigwigs in Abuja wanted Oshiomohle out, he won't survive this case. An expensive information. Stop deceiving yourself

they have forgortten tinunbu in local gov elections durring his tenure

(1) (2) (Reply)

Ejigbo, Ikotun Residents Decry Poor State Of Road,petition Fashola / Wike Don Provoke Rivers People Ooo / Tinubu Asks Senate To Confirm 10 INEC RECs

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 44
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.