Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / NewStats: 3,148,810 members, 7,802,593 topics. Date: Friday, 19 April 2024 at 04:56 PM |
Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Health / Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? (14320 Views)
JOHESU And APHA Directive To All Members In States And LG Health Institutions To / Fear Of Ebola: Villagers Flee From The Sight Of Red Cross And Western Doctors / How Do Doctors Calculate Medical Bills? (2) (3) (4)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (Reply) (Go Down)
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by Buchianom(m): 7:22pm On May 01, 2013 |
cahnellven: I dnt think any sort of arguement should emanate 4rm dis issue . 4 a start ,it is very true that medicine is the only profesion that completes all the basic medical courses(anatomy,physiology,medical biochemistry),others simply do part of it n not d full course. Now on the issue of administration,it shud be run by the most qualified medical personell,bt as we all knw,administration entails control which makes the position kinda hard to recommend 4 anyone aside a doctor cos hospital politics is different frm wat we have else where. An ideal medical team comprises of a doctor,a pharmacist,nurse,med lab scientist,anatomist,physiotherapist,and a physiologist with each controlling basic autonomy in its own field ,bt as we knw it,a doctor z d natural head of a medical team . So my view is this . . .each proffesion should head its department,with the doctor being and remaing d CMD I wouldn't know d uni U attended, but in my own skool, physicians, med lab scts, nurses, Med. Imaging. Scts$ physitherapists all sat in one lecture room to receive Anatomy, Physiology $ Biochem lectures. Funny enuf, evry1 related as one, sm wia in same discussion groups .......etc. Dis ego/ discrimination thing just starts once dey start practising. I am in support of ur view for autonomy for all oda professionals as enshrined in dia respective scheme of service but guess wat?? The C .M. D's play the script of dia fellow physicians (in cases wia dey refuse to do so, Consultants threaten dem) $ choose not to implement wat is contained in d SOS. That's why personally I feel d post of d C. M. D shld be for health adminstrators to avoid favouritism or bias. 2 Likes |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by onagoodday1: 7:26pm On May 01, 2013 |
the problem with doctors is greed....imagin a doctor claiming to know drugs more than a pharmacist...very funny 2 Likes |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by hairyman(m): 7:27pm On May 01, 2013 |
cahnellven: I dnt think any sort of arguement should emanate 4rm dis issue . 4 a start ,it is very true that medicine is the only profesion that completes all the basic medical courses(anatomy,physiology,medical biochemistry),others simply do part of it n not d full course. Now on the issue of administration,it shud be run by the most qualified medical personell,bt as we all knw,administration entails control which makes the position kinda hard to recommend 4 anyone aside a doctor cos hospital politics is different frm wat we have else where. An ideal medical team comprises of a doctor,a pharmacist,nurse,med lab scientist,anatomist,physiotherapist,and a physiologist with each controlling basic autonomy in its own field ,bt as we knw it,a doctor z d natural head of a medical team . So my view is this . . .each proffesion should head its department,with the doctor being and remaing d CMD You may do well to research before you make any statement. Quite a lot of departments at john hopkins are managed and have been managed by non-physicians |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by Ochek: 7:39pm On May 01, 2013 |
ugochi86: @ochek. Same courses different cut off marks.don't know what luck u re talking about.leave the doctors alone and focus on making d best out of what u studied. Yeah! So true but you would also agree with me that the high demand for the course gave it that cut off mark. |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by ziga: 7:45pm On May 01, 2013 |
Too much ignorance in this post. Nigerians always claim too know pass people wey invent something sef. A lot of people quoting duty of CMD from the back seat of okada. People talking about what happens in the developed countries from inside shalanga because they don port on top dem BB. I laugh in Nairaland. 1 Like |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by ziga: 7:47pm On May 01, 2013 |
At least if you never travel overseas... Dem dey show Scrubs, House, Gray's anatomy on top DSTV. Go watch am to see whether dem CMO na Doctor or Babalawo. Shior. Kelebe. |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by timowale: 7:55pm On May 01, 2013 |
eaglechild: The doctor is the head of the medical team.On point,doctors head the medical team while nurses on the other hand head the nursing team.Each of the various subunits forming the health institution has a unit head furthermore,your submission that patients belong to doctors is untrue Every one that visit hospital is aware nurses spend the greater number of hours with the patients than all other health professionals. Finally,the position of hospital heads ought not be the exclusive preserve of only doctors cos the requisite skills for administering institution as such is an all encompassing one starting administrative public relation ,technically .....nurses and other health practtionaltoo have the aforestated requirements 2 Likes |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by ziga: 7:55pm On May 01, 2013 |
hairyman: Yep, I bet you a lot of departments are headed by non-physicians. Like dietary department, house keeping, Pharmacy, Engineering etc. But not Endocrinology, Surgery, Medicine or CMD. |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by dom(m): 8:15pm On May 01, 2013 |
it was during Prof. Olikoye Ransome Kuti tenure as minister of health that Doctors transmogrified into demi-gods in the health sector, both in gaping pay disparity and in assuming certain positions as a birthright. Presently they're agitating, among other things, for the post of Surgeon-General to be created because there is a position for Attorney-General. Forgetting that the A.G is a constitutionally guaranteed position and indeed the only ministerial position that has a constitutional backing. Such is the nature of their peremptory and importunate demands.They'll embark on strike at the drop of a hat to press home and armtwist the Government to cave in to their preposterous cravings. doctors have embarked on more strikes than any other profession in the country. Ironically they should even be the last to strike given the humanitarian nature of their job&ought to borrow a leaf from other health professions in this regard .I doubt if the so called hippocratic oath means anything. I really blame successive government administrations for treating them with kid gloves and pandering to their ever whimsical and capricious demands. nonsense. 7 Likes |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by Nobody: 8:17pm On May 01, 2013 |
kenlash1: for example if A university has BN headed by engineering professors for A long time nd now a biochemistry professor comes up to say I want to head cos its My right as well (cos he is qualified) is now a bad TN? Mind you doctors don't own d hospitals, its d ryt of every health practitioner with necessary qualification nd yrs of experiencedoctors do not own the hospitals yes i agree. but know that patients come to see doctors. doctors plan patients management ,admit patients and discharge as well. if other health professionals want to head hospitals let them start consulting. if u want administrators let administrators take over all other sectors viz engineering, pharmaceutical industries,education, power, bank etc. |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by timowale: 8:22pm On May 01, 2013 |
ugochi86: I see this as a good avenue for all non-doctors in hospitals to vent.its understandably frustrating for them beause most of them had d aspiration of becoming doctors but jamb and probably some other factors stood in their way.they should leave them(doctors) alone.they shsould have burnt the midnight candle when they still had d chance but it's never too late to purchase jamb form as someone earlier suggested.Foolish statement! 3 Likes |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by Nobody: 8:28pm On May 01, 2013 |
on a good day:u got it wrong. doctors are not greedy. it is pharmacists that are. imagine pharmacists treating patients in their stores thus acting as doctors. pharmacists know both relevant and irrelevants drugs. however doctors know relevant drugs to patients care than pharmacists. |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by Nobody: 8:31pm On May 01, 2013 |
timowale:medical team The group of physicians and health care workers who are responsible for a Pt's medical needs McGraw-Hill Concise Dictionary of Modern Medicine. © 2002 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, from the definition who should head medical team? |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by ugochi86: 8:47pm On May 01, 2013 |
@timowale.i can feel your pain. |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by hairyman(m): 8:53pm On May 01, 2013 |
ziga: You did no say head, you said manage. And again I tell you even the department of obs/gyn has been managed by a non-physician. And what we are arguing here I about hospital management. For the man who referred to gray's anamtomy as a source of information, in as much as that is infinitely unpardonable referring to a movie in this quarter, you may remember that the hospital manager was not even a physician (chief surgeon was not the highest authority in that hospital) 2 Likes |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by armadeo(m): 9:07pm On May 01, 2013 |
What theses people don't understand is that these drs will NEVER cede the position of command to anyone NEVER till christ comes again so its a lost battle. They rather quit completely from the hospital setting than answer to a non dr. That being said diff units have diff heads, a teaching hospital has a director of administration directly under the command answerable only to the cmd. Y other health workers want this post is beyond me just do ur job and forget this cmd thing cos it can NEVER happen. 2 Likes |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by Ochek: 9:15pm On May 01, 2013 |
timowale: Bless you! |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by Ochek: 9:22pm On May 01, 2013 |
hairyman: I truely wonder why one should be using a movie as a basis of his points. It's like saying that, at every hour, american security is on the chase of a terrorist about to let one bomb go off on the american soil as in season 24. And thanks for pointing out to those who know nothing about the medical hierarchy. In that movie, a surgeon was and that contradicts their basis. |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by Ochek: 9:25pm On May 01, 2013 |
Laalamed: Google up Nurse practitional and stop shouting jor! |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by Nobody: 9:35pm On May 01, 2013 |
Ochek:A nurse practitioner (NP) is a nurse with a graduate degree in advanced practice nursing. See also: Types of health care providers Information The NP is allowed to provide a broad range of health care services, which may include: Taking the patient's history, performing a physical exam, and ordering laboratory tests and procedures Diagnosing, treating, and managing diseases Writing prescriptions and coordinating referrals Providing handouts on disease prevention and healthy lifestyles Performing certain procedures, such as a bone marrow biopsy or lumbar puncture Nurse practitioners work in a variety of settings, including: Cardiology Emergency Family practice Geriatrics Neonatology Nephrology Oncology Pediatrics Primary care School health Women's health Some nurse practitioners work in clinics without doctor supervision. Others work together with doctors as a joint health care team. Their scope of practice and authority depends on state laws. For example, some states allow nurse practitioners to write prescriptions, while other states do not. Like many other professions, nurse practitioners are regulated at two different levels. They are licensed through a process that takes place at the state level under state laws. They are certified through national organizations, with consistent professional practice standards across all states. LICENSURE The laws on NP licensure vary greatly from state to state. Today, more states are requiring NPs to have a master's degree and national certification. In some states, NP practice is completely independent. Other states require that NPs work with an MD for prescriptive practice privileges or to get licensed. A few states still do not have specific nurse practitioner licenses or recognize practice by NPs. CERTIFICATION National certification is offered through various nursing organizations (such as the American Nurses' Association, Pediatric Nursing Certification Board, and others). Most of these organizations require that NPs complete an approved master's- level NP program before taking the certification exam. The exams tend to be offered in specialty areas, such as: Acute care Adult nursing Family nursing Geriatrics Pediatrics Psychiatry Women's health care To be recertified, NPs need to show proof of continuing education. Only certified nurse practitioners may use a "C" either in front of or behind their other credentials (e.g., Certified Pediatric Nurse Practitioner, FNP-C, Certified Family Nurse Practitioner). Some nurse practitioners may use the credential ARNP, which means advanced registered nurse practioner. This is a broader category that includes clinical nurse specialists, certified nurse midwives, and nurse anesthetists. Update Date: 8/1/2012 Updated by: Jennifer K. Mannheim, ARNP, Medical Staff, Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Health, Seattle Children's Hospital. Also reviewed by David Zieve, MD, MHA, Medical Director, A.D.A.M. Health Solutions, Ebix, Inc. Browse the Encyclopedia 1 Like |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by ziga: 9:37pm On May 01, 2013 |
ziga: At least if you never travel overseas... Dem dey show Scrubs, House, Gray's anatomy on top DSTV. Ochek: If una no fit read, I quote am again for those people wey never travel abroad wey dey claim say CMD's for yankee no be Doctor. Unlike our Nollywood, they try to portray some form of reality. The story might not be true, but they try to make all else as believable as possible. Naija is just so ignorant!!! |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by Nobody: 9:39pm On May 01, 2013 |
Laalamed:For ur info nursing practioners are created to solve problems of doctors shortage. They are not replacing doctors. when there are specialist doctors NP work to assist doctors. infact np job is designed to be autonomous. np practice indepedently where there is no doctor. |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by Ochek: 9:43pm On May 01, 2013 |
ziga: Who ignorant pass you? According to ur post : Some nurse practitioners work in clinics without doctor supervision. Others work together with doctors as a joint health care team. What else are you trying to prove? Try reason well abeg. 1 Like |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by Ochek: 9:45pm On May 01, 2013 |
Laalamed: There you go again. Autonomous! |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by ziga: 9:45pm On May 01, 2013 |
If Doctors, Nurses, Pharmacists, Lab scientists, Dentists have additional degrees in hospital management, the most qualified professional for the position of CMD will be the Doctor. He is the head and coordinator of the health team. And since when did people require degrees in administration to be managers/heads? What kind of mentality is that? Which other industry requires administration degree for you to be head? Our C-in-C get administrator degree? Or your bank manager or MTN chief? Leadership has nothing to do with having a degree in administration, however, the position of a doctor which already involves every aspect of a patient's care gives the broadest view and understanding of a patient's condition. Therefore Doctors are heads of their medical units in some way or another. Granted, there are times when organizations will have a non-medical administrator as an adjunct. And they work with the MD. I wonder whats with Nigeria and politicization of everything. |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by ziga: 9:46pm On May 01, 2013 |
Ochek: You don smoke igbo abi? or you are just demented? |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by Ochek: 9:50pm On May 01, 2013 |
ziga: Hahahaha! Joker!! Na the one wey you puff remain for me o! 1 Like |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by Nobody: 9:50pm On May 01, 2013 |
Dr. James Mandell, CEO Sandra Fenwick, President & COO Leadership James Mandell, MD Chief Executive Officer Sandra Fenwick President and Chief Operating Officer Gary R. Fleisher, MD Physician-in-Chief, Pediatrician in Chief, Chair of Department of Medicine James Kasser, MD Surgeon-in-Chief Michael J. Anderegg Executive Director, Heart Center Dick Argys Senior Vice President and Chief Administrative Officer Julee Bolg Executive Director, Satellite Clinical Operations Margaret Coughlin Senior Vice President and Chief Marketing and Communications Officer Naomi Fried, PhD Chief Innovation Officer Michael Gillespie Vice President of Clinical Services Josh Greenberg Vice President, Government Relations Kathy Jenkins, MD Senior Vice President, Chief Safety and Quality Officer Daniel Nigrin, MD, MS Senior Vice President and Chief Information Officer Stuart Novick, Esq. Senior Vice President and General Counsel Phil Rotner Chief Investment Officer Eileen Sporing, MSN, RN, NEA-BC, FAAN Senior Vice President, Patient Care Operations and Chief Nursing Officer (CNO) Inez Stewart Vice President, Human Resources Lynn Susman President, Children's Hospital Trust Henry Tomasuolo Vice President of Support Services Doug Vanderslice Chief Financial Officer (CFO) Jane Venti Executive Director, Satellite Administrative Operations Wendy Warring, JD Senior Vice President, Network Development and Strategic Partnerships Carol Weinrib, PhD Acting Vice President, Research Administration Charles Weinstein, Esq. Vice President, Real Estate Planning and Development Department and division chiefs Department of Anesthesiology Paul R. Hickey, MD , Anesthesiologist- in-Chief Division of Cardiac Anesthesia James A. DiNardo, MD Division of Critical Care Medicine Jeffrey P. Burns, MD Division of Pain Management Charles B. Berde, MD, PhD Division of Perioperative Anesthesia Lynne R. Ferrari, MD Department of Cardiac Surgery Pedro del Nido, MD Department of Cardiology James Lock, MD , Cardiologist-in- Chief Department of Dentistry Man Wai Ng, DDS, MPH Department of Laboratory Medicine Orah Platt, MD Department of Medicine Gary Fleisher, MD , Physician-in-Chief Frederick Lovejoy, Jr. MD , Associate Physician-in-Chief Division of Adolescent and Young Adult Medicine S. Jean Emans, MD Division of Clinical Pediatric Oncology Lisa R. Diller, MD Division of Developmental Medicine Leonard A. Rappaport, MD, MS Division of Emergency Medicine Richard G. Bachur, MD Division of Endocrinology Joseph A. Majzoub, MD Division of Gastroenterology/ Nutrition Wayne I. Lencer, MD Clinical Research Center Stavroula Osganian, MD, ScD, MPH Ellis Neufeld, MD, PhD Division of General Pediatrics Mark A. Schuster, MD, PhD Division of Genetics Christopher A. Walsh, MD, PhD Division of Hematology/Oncology David A. Williams, MD Division of Immunology Raif Geha, MD Division of Infectious Diseases Michael Wessels, MD Division of Molecular Medicine Stephen Harrison, PhD Division of Nephrology William E. Harmon, MD Division of Newborn Medicine Stella Kourembanas, MD Division of Respiratory Diseases Craig Gerard, MD, PhD Department of Neurology Scott L. Pomeroy, MD, PhD Division of Epilepsy Blaise Bourgeois, MD Department of Neurosurgery Alan Cohen, MD, FACS, FAAP Department of Ophthalmology David G. Hunter, MD, PhD Department of Orthopedic Surgery James R. Kasser, MD , Surgeon-in- Chief Division of Sports Medicine Lyle J. Micheli, MD Department of Otolaryngology Michael J. Cunningham, MD Department of Pathology Mark Daniel Fleming, MD, DPhil Department of Plastic Surgery John G. Meara, MD, DMD, MBA Section of Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery Bonnie L. Padwa, DMD, MD Department of Psychiatry David R. DeMaso, MD Division of Psychology Eugene J. D'Angelo, PhD Department of Radiology Richard L. Robertson, Jr., MD Division of Computed Tomography Michael J. Callahan, MD Division of Diagnostic Radiology Kirsten Ecklund, MD Division of Interventional Radiology Darren B. Orbach, MD, PhD Division of Magnetic Resonance Imaging Caroline D. Robson, MB, ChB Division of Neuroradiology Caroline D. Robson, MB, ChB Division of Nuclear Medicine/PET Stephan D. Voss, MD, PhD Laura A. Drubach, MD Division of Ultrasound Carol E. Barnewolt, MD Department of Surgery Robert C. Shamberger, MD Division of Gynecology Marc R. Laufer, MD Department of Urology David A. Diamond, MD Genomics Louis Kunkel, PhD Informatics Isaac Kohane, MD, PhD Neuroscience Clifford Woolf, PhD Stem Cell/Developmental Biology Leonard Zon, MD Vascular Biology Marsha A. Moses, PhD www.childrenshospital.org/about/Site1394/mainpageS1394P4.html |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by Guddy(m): 10:10pm On May 01, 2013 |
5sigma: The doctor is the leader of the health team. No matter how long an air hostess has been flying, she cannot become the pilot. The other health workers should go and write JAMB, obtain admission to study medicine and then become suitable candidates. Thing is,no matter how long the wind blows the mountain can never bow.enuf said! From your post I can see that you are very shallow-minded. 1 Like |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by Nobody: 10:12pm On May 01, 2013 |
Laalamed: Dr. James Mandell, CEO SandraBOSTON Children Hospital |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by Nobody: 10:20pm On May 01, 2013 |
Guddy:hey nurse, u can insult as u wnt but u r nt in any way beta thn hm, u r ol d same.....i suggest u luk fr oda means of pourin out ur frustration. dnt spoil dis thread wt ur stupidity.. 1 Like |
Re: Should Non-doctors Head health Institutions? by modena: 10:33pm On May 01, 2013 |
Having read some funny comments here....Am not surprised why the the health sector is thriving compared to other sectors. Not only in Nigeria, even in developed countries. Studying management does not make you a good manager. Otherwise all the failed educational, financial, enterprise sectors etc. should all be thriving under the leadership of people who study management. Recession in europe and bank failures are all as a result of mismanagement practiced by the so called management professional most of them with all the higher management quaifications you can think of..including "chattered managers". Doctors practice evidence based medicine, where treatment is given based on established evidences. And they are subjected to clinical debates, protocols and most importantly clinical reviews for criticism of why? how? when? a method or approach was carried out. Meaning there is a body that oversees processes,continous and ongoing research with literature reviews. Comparing this with other sectors where there is abosolutely no governing body conducting research, literature reviews and no protocols based on management. Decision is taken based on what the manager percieves as best approach. More of instinct, until managers develop habit of doing research and literature reviews on management approaches and not hypothesis which I will term "Evidence based management" Then they will be in better position like their medical counterparts. In summary, management qualification does not define a good manager but increases the chances of an individual becoming one. Most successful business men never had management degrees. Doctors have better chances of successfully running hospitals based on their training coupled with method and approach of providing holistic care to patients. |
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (Reply)
Use Oriflame Footscrub And Ecollagen Cream To Get Rid Of That Stretch Marks / COVID-19 Update For September 29 2020 In Nigeria -(3,815 Tested)) / Risk Factors Associated With Sudden Cardiac Arrest..
(Go Up)
Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 125 |