Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,150,433 members, 7,808,546 topics. Date: Thursday, 25 April 2024 at 01:17 PM

British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System - Politics - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Politics / British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System (14813 Views)

Hilarious Photo Of Government Vs People (pics) / Ahmed Musa Ibeto, Niger Deputy Governor Ejected Out Of Government House / Pictures Of Government House Owerri & its Environs (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (Reply) (Go Down)

British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by Nobody: 8:15pm On Sep 21, 2014
Hello Guys

I was just wondering if any body has knowledge on parliament vs congressional system of government, and tell us which is preferable with proof

where are all my politicians?

Thank You
Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by ilohemmy(m): 10:10pm On Sep 21, 2014
@Donnypool, politically i must let u know the fact that any system of government is perfect is perfect and preferable when it has a good runing by the government,,, so weda parliamental or congressional is preferable

5 Likes

Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by datguru: 6:29am On Sep 22, 2014
to me, they both suck

1 Like

Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by kurajordan(m): 6:29am On Sep 22, 2014
.
Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by tempest01(m): 6:29am On Sep 22, 2014
Following
Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by alaladakosta(f): 6:29am On Sep 22, 2014
Both not bad

1 Like

Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by Blaqsmith(m): 6:29am On Sep 22, 2014
I will go for the American's Congress system of Government because it makes for equal representation and well passage of bills.

British's is more dictatorial in nature and the issue of collective responsibility is also a lapse.


I stand to be corrected.

7 Likes

Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by CharlieMaria(m): 6:30am On Sep 22, 2014
I don't have an idea sorry.
Let me ask makazona wait......
Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by iceberylin(m): 6:30am On Sep 22, 2014
Who cares undecided

1 Like

Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by yinkarh187(m): 6:30am On Sep 22, 2014
k
Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by Heyliesha(m): 6:30am On Sep 22, 2014
Booked
Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by ZUBY77(m): 6:31am On Sep 22, 2014
You shouldn't be caring about what works for other nations.

Find what works for you and let them emulate you too.

2 Likes

Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by danaiks(m): 6:31am On Sep 22, 2014
It is true however that the UK political system is seen to give the prime minister too much power due the fusion of powers. USA system has a separation of powers so therefore the judiciary the executive and the legislature are completely separate and in the UK some people are part of two. This is sometimes seen as too much power. USA seems to be better

4 Likes

Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by Nobody: 6:31am On Sep 22, 2014
Well, here it is briefly

In the British system....the people vote for their representatives, who take their seats in parliament, the equivalent of our national assembly.
Then said representatives from the Party which has the higher number of seats choose the Party Leader(who is also a member of Parliament) as the Prime Minister.(If the majority Party does not get above a certain threshold of seats...it may either form a minority government...Labour's 1976 govt, or a Coalition government....the current Conservative-Liberal Democrat Government).

Also, the British system is bi-camereal...two houses...the House of Commons which is (commonly)referred to as the Parliament or just plain Commons, and the House of Lords , which is made up of the hereditary Lords (or traditional chiefs, roughly speaking). Commons chooses the Prime Minister...who is then approved by HM the Queen.(in a formal ceremony known as kissing of hands). Lords used to be more powerful and could overrule the Commons, but reforms brought in in the 90's have reduced its powers.(one of Tony Blair's good ideas).

The Americans have Congress, which is bicameral...the House of Representatives and the Senate. The Representatives and Senators are chosen by direct election. The President of the US is chosen by a separate election. Unlike the UK...the President need not come from the majority party in Congress....and the majority party in the Senate may be different from the majority party in the House. (Like right now...the Democrats control the Senate...and the Republicans the House)

I have no preferences. Though in the Nigerian setup, the American system works better because the Parliamentary system unfortunately gets easily compromised by tribalism.The American system also forces the Opposition to compromise with the Ruling party or vice versa.

54 Likes 1 Share

Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by lonngmann(m): 6:32am On Sep 22, 2014
is dis an assignment? undecided

3 Likes

Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by yinkarh187(m): 6:33am On Sep 22, 2014
kk
Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by Nobody: 6:34am On Sep 22, 2014
Na GCE Question?

1 Like

Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by ajibadeol(m): 6:35am On Sep 22, 2014
of what importance is that to you and how does it cure ebola undecided


story for d gods angry
Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by Kayendy(m): 6:35am On Sep 22, 2014
Op go get a government textbook... Maybe comprehensive government or any oda one.. It will help u

1 Like

Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by Oceemo(m): 6:35am On Sep 22, 2014
Ok
Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by SafetyFirst(m): 6:37am On Sep 22, 2014
h
Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by Nobody: 6:38am On Sep 22, 2014
donnypool: Hello Guys

[s]I was just wondering if any body has knowledge on parliament vs congressional system of government, and tell us which is preferable with proof

where are all my politicians?[/s]

Thank You
Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by Swagavillage(m): 6:38am On Sep 22, 2014
wait first

Naija guy banging 2 Ghana girls and he leaks the video online, download here

READ HERE http://l4u.in/AOPdc
Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by Iceking1(m): 6:39am On Sep 22, 2014
I jst dey observe
Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by habex050: 6:39am On Sep 22, 2014
ilohemmy: @Donnypool, politically i must let u know the fact that any system of government is perfect is perfect and preferable when it has a good runing by the government,,, so weda parliamental or congressional is preferable

I support you
Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by Cpumping(m): 6:40am On Sep 22, 2014
Kk


*In an unrelated development, it is my birthday*.

Happy bday to me

6 Likes

Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by Nobody: 6:42am On Sep 22, 2014
The American-style Presidential system of government is more suitable for multi-ethnic, and multi-racial countries such as Nigeria , South Africa, the US etc. This is because the concept of Federalism is usually embedded within their constitutions.
However, in the case of Nigeria, the FG is by far the most powerful tier.

On the other hand, the Parliamentary system is more suited to mono-ethnic, small (by population) nations. In this system, both the Executive and legislative branches are one and d same. The Head of State in a Parliamentary system is usually a monarch or a ceremonial President/Emperor.

So I would say that the Congressional/Presidential system is ultimately the best for Nigeria. If the basis of federalism is further improved, the states would have more powers than they current do. For instance, they (states) could have their own constitutions, police forces, set the salaries of their political office holders, and conduct elections for the office of Governor and House of Assembly.

7 Likes

Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by Nobody: 6:43am On Sep 22, 2014
iceberylin: Who cares undecided
yinkarh187: k
Heyliesha: Booked
Sexslave01: xx
yinkarh187: kk
Oceemo: Ok
SafetyFirst: h

All hail the members of the Revolutionary and Socialist Party of Space Bookers!
Motto: Workers of the World...BOOK SPACE!
Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by TRADELYN: 6:44am On Sep 22, 2014
grin

This will be very educative.
.
.
.
.
.

*Research Mode Activated*
Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by Lucasbalo(m): 6:44am On Sep 22, 2014
bushdoc9919: Well, here it is briefly

In the British system....the people vote for their representatives, who take their seats in parliament, the equivalent of our national assembly.
Then said represntatives from the Party which has the higher number of seats choose the Party Leader(who is also a member of Parliament) as the Prime Minister.

Also, the British system is bi-camereal...two houses...the House of Commons which is referred to as the Parliament, and the House of Lords , which is made up of the hereditary Lords (or traditional chiefs, roughly speaking). Commons chooses the Prime Minister...who is then approved by HM the Queen.

The Americans have Congress, which is bicameral...the House of Representatives and the Senate. The Representatives and Senators are chosen by direct election. The President of the US is chosen by a separate election. Unlike the UK...the President need not come from the majority party in Congress....and the majority party in the Senate may be different from the majority party in the House. (Like right now...the Democrats control the Senate...and the Republicans the House)

I have no preferences. Though in the Nigerian setup, the American system works better because the Parliamentary system unfortunately gets easily compromised by tribalism.The Aerican system also forces the Opposition to compromise with the Ruling party or vice versa.
You are 100 percent right. Nothing more to add.

1 Like

Re: British Parliamental System Of Government Vs The American Congressional System by Symphony007: 6:47am On Sep 22, 2014
I think the british parliamentary system is better! It makes for more accountability as party leaders get to debate themeselves regularly. It is more efficient as the ruling party governs without obstruction from the opposition. Elections are fought over ideology and performance of a party, not if you like who will be the prime minister because he can be changed by the party anytime.

Congress Is a cumbersome and slow governing system. There is also a tendency that no single party will control the presidency, senate and house of representatives, so it gives the opposition powers to obstruct the policies of the ruling party( this has been the hallmark of the obama presidency)... Elections are at times not fought over policies but which presidential candidate is more likable or has nicer hair. The president is not accountable to congress, only his cabinet ministers are. Governing is very slow as every bill must pass two houses of congress and it's harder when two parties control each house. There are many more.....

7 Likes

(1) (2) (3) (4) (Reply)

Donald Duke: I Left PDP Because The Umbrella Was Breaking / NIN-SIM Linkage: FG Threatens Enforcement As Deadline Expires / Fela On Buhari - Beasts Of No Nation

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 35
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.