I don't know why some Muslims failed to detect the Muhammad's lies even when it clear to see.

I creat this topic to counter a topic i saw on Muslim section,written by eninn, tittled " The Three Questions"


eninn if you are reading this thread, i am saying here that Muhammad was wrong and that his answers to those qestions proved that Islam is/was man made religion.

These were what you wrote, i will write the words that proved him wrong in capital letter

" was Muhammed really a Prophet? Was he just a convincing fake? How could they find out? These are the questions which the leaders of Quraish were continuously asking themselves. They finally decided to consult the Jewish rabbi in Yarthrib about the problem, since Jews had had more dealing with prophet in the past and the rabbi were more knowledgeble in the scriptures

The rabbi advised Quraish to ask Muhammed three quetions If he knew the answers to those questions then he was truly a prophet. The first question was about some youmg men of long ago who had left their people and had had wondrous experience.The secönd was about the travelers who had journeyed to the end of the earth in the east and the west. The third was about the Spirit, and what it was.

The Quraish hurriedly sent messanges to Muhammed to ask him these three questions. THE PROPHET TOLD THEM TO RETURN IN THE FOLLOWING DAY HE WOULD HAVE THE ANSWER FOR THEM. However, he failed to add "insha allah" that is if Allah wills. By the next day he had not received any revelation to help him answer the questions and HE HAD TO ASK THE MESSENGER TO RETURN IN THE NEXT DAY THIS WAS REPEATED FOR FIFTEEN DAYS while the people of Mecca laughed at Muhammad's inability to answer the three questions. Finally JIBRIL APEARED TO PROPHET AND TOLD HIM THE THREE ANSWERS, he also explaine the delay in surah 18;23-24, is the warning that one should not plan to do anything in the future without saying insha Allah all that we hope to do is only accomplished by the will of Allah

the first quetion is about some young men who remained steadfast in their worship of one God. While the rest of their people turned to worship idols. NO ONE IS SURE OF THE NUMBER OF THE YOUTH INVOLVED .THE KNOWLEDGE IS ALLAH'S ALONE, Although many scholar have disputed over the number.To escape the persecution, the young men hid in the cave, where Allah caused them to fall asleep for about three Hundred years (only Allah knows the exact length of time). They had a dog with them, and to anyone who happened to see them they would appeared to be awoke. And the person would have been filled with fear of them. When they finally awoke, it seem to them as if only a short time had passed. It was when one of them was sent to the town to buy food that they learned, they had slept for centuries. The account of these sleepers is in the Quran 18:9-25

the answer to the second question was about a great traveler identified has Zul-Qarnian, the owner of two horns, he had great power and had been given the ways and means to do all things. He traveled to the setting of sun, which set in a murky pool, neareby there lived a people over whom Zul-Qarnain had authority to punish or reward. He chose to purnsh those who did wrong and then send them back to Allah for further punished. Those who believe in Allah and were righteous, would be rewarded. Then he journeyed to the rising of the sun. Where he found people who had been provided with no protection against the son. Those people he left completely alone.........

Third Question about the Spirit, had the shortest answer. The Quran (17: 85) says that the Spirit come by command's of Allah, and that mankind does have the knowledge to fully understand it. The Jews disputed they have been given full knoweledge in the Torah but AllAH TELL 'US' THAT THEIR KNOWELEDGE IS VERY SMALL,IN COMPARISOM TO ALLAH'S KNOWELEDGE, which could not be recorded even if all the tree on earth were pen and all the sea were ink."

these are my rebuttals on what you wrote up there.

1. If truly Allah was the one that reaveled the answers to Muhammed he would know exactly the number of young men in the cave even their names
for Muhammed's inability to tell their names and numbers shows that it was not Allah that revealed it to hlm. In the Quran Muhamme was saying " some said they were three the dog being the fourth among them, other said they were five the dog being the six doubtfully guessing about unknow,yet other said they were seven, the dog being the eighth, say thou: my lord knowth best their number. It is but few that know their real case.Enter not therefore into controversies concerning them, except on a matter that is clear,nor consult any of them about the affair of the sleepers"( Quran the cave 3:22)

what did Muhammed mean by "some say" in the Quran verses above if truly Allah was the one that revealed it to him

2. It took Muhammed fifteen good days before he could answered those questions. The first point above and this shows that, within fifteen days Muhammed was busy looking for the person or rabbi who would tell him the story . He just used " insha allah" to cover himself
up
3 in the second story ,Allah was able to tell him the name of traveler in that story but could not tell him the names of young men in the cave story. What a lie?

4 Muhammed in third question said Allah has more knoweledge on Spirit but its ridiculous that Allah does not tell him more than that on Spirit.

5. Please can you tell us what you means by 'Jubiril apeared to him' ? are you saying Muhammed saw the Jubril face to face?

Likewise what do yo mean by "ALLAH TELL US" in the answer to third question

One thing i want Muslims to know is that, Christians and Jews were around Mecca, during Muhammed's day in Mecca and that those three questions were known by the Jewish who told Quraish to ask him those questions. So ,what make Muslims believed it was revealed to him by Allah?

To me Muhammed failed Quraish's text for not able to answer the questions imediately or within one to two days but within fifteen days a'ba!

Muhammed prophet? Hehehe!

That dude was a smart guy among the dullards of the middle east. Am sure if the Nigerians claiming to be muslims were there during his leadership they will not even listen to him.

A prophet that had more than a wife. A prophet that agreed idolatory is good to get out of prison. A prophet that lied to one of his wives that her father needed her while he conered her maid.

That nigga was a nigga!

Can we stop the religious attacks already abeg

BWOY, GOD NO GET RELIGION O.
ALL RELIGION= MAN MADE

ladyF:
Can we stop the religious attacks already abeg

MY VIRGIN GIRLFRIEND IS PREGNANT O, PLS WHAT DO I DO?

All was man-made, no exception. Elephant in the room called religion.

munchfani:
NO MIND THEM, MUMU AFRICAN PRIMITIVE SLAVE. SHEY CHRISTIANITY COME FROM HEAVEN ABI?

The OP didn't paint or talk good of any religion. He just countered a post about Mohammed. Until the time he start claiming any one of the religions to be divinely inspired, we can then point out so many flaws in it too.

It's so glaring mohammed was a fraud, it takes a lot of brain washing and self delusion for muslims to sustain the religion.