AbdelKabir:
jazakAllaah khayra,

Meanwhile,

a sufi will soon come for your head.....

AbuHammaad:


The early generation did not congratulate one another on Fridays, so we should not introduce anything that they did not do.

If anyone suggests that this is permissible, then that may imply that it is prescribed to say du‘aa’s and congratulate one another after having done the five daily prayers and other acts of worship, and du‘aa’ at these times was not done by the early generations.

shawl:


Misguided fatawa (as usual).

AbuHammaad:

The early generation did not congratulate one another on Fridays, so we should not introduce anything that they did not do.

AbuHammaad:

If anyone suggests that this is permissible (sayin jumuah mubarak), then that may imply that it is prescribed to say du‘aa’s and congratulate one another after having done the five daily prayers and other acts of worship, and du‘aa’ at these times was not done by the early generations.

shawl:
^



That is not a proof.

The prophet, sallAllahu alaihi wa sallam, never said what me and my sahaba, radiyAllahu anhum, did not do is an "introduced" thing (bid'a). That is an erroneous understanding of what constitutes bid'a.

How can the prophet, sallAllahu alayhi wa sallam, declare a day as a day of 'festival' and someone is trying to declare the main substance of it, the greeting of festivity bid'a? This is a clear deficiency in understanding what constitutes bid'a and trying to make the deen look contradictory in its composition.

Abu Darda (RA) narrates that the Prophet (salallaho alaihi wasalam) said: whatever Allaah has permitted in his book is halaal, whatever he has forbidden is haraam, and anything over which there is silence is pardoned, so accept the pardon of Allaah, for Allaah cannot be forgetful. Then he recited this verse: "and your Lord is never forgetful".

The act of greeting one another on the day of Juma'ah is well accomodated in the above hadith and conforms to practices encouraged on the days of festivities.



...Do repent to Allah for your sins and supplicate with raised hands at the times of prayer as these are the best times, during which Allah Almighty looks at His servants with mercy. Allah Answers if they supplicate, Responds if they call, Grants if He is asked, and Accepts if they entreat. O people! you have made your conscience the slave of your desires.

- (Sermon Of Ramadan) Ibn Khuzaimah, Al Baihaqi.

madridguy:
Asalam alaikum yah ikwani;
Thanks so much for your contribution. Do you ever ask yourself why Islamic/Muslim topics hardly made one page not to talk of two pages on NL. This is one of the reason, you will be amazed as if there is no grace for us as a Muslim since everything is tagged as Bid'a. Allah SWT will help us with some many barbaric teachings circulating everywhere.

Jummah Mubarak

HAH:
Thank you, to them everything is bidia

The Wahabis have hijacked the islamic section and propagating their skewed views

I have seen no problem in wishing someone, good morning, good afternoon, happy friday, happy sallah, etc etc is just a gesture, please make this religion attractive and beautiful.

By the way when did text message even come into existence that your ulama are already making fatwa on it.

My friend I grew up to see my people saying Barka Da Jumma'a and no ibn tayyimiyah or qayyim will make me stop it.

My people, Happy Friday Barda da Jumma'a

Rashduct4luv:

Since it is proven that saying this is not from the culture of the best generations, what do we want to gain from it?
Lets Ponder!

Rashduct4luv:

You greet people and then you get no reward for doing that. If you think that greeting is an act of worship, then you earn sins!

AbuHammaad:

He replied:

The early generation did not congratulate one another on Fridays, so we should not introduce anything that they did not do.


https://islamqa.info/en/134741

AlBaqir:


# This is a Wahabism, Salafism opinion not entire Muslim reasoning. Be as it may, the above bolded summarize the whole argument. And I say that is a double standard on Salafism thinking. Why?!

# The phrase "Radi'Allahu anhum" has full reference in the Quran where Allah used it for some righteous Sahabah. However, there is no command of it in any hadith (be it authentic, weak or fabrication) that once any sahabi name is mentioned, that the phrase should be said. Meaning that:

* Nabi Never practiced it

* None of the Sahabah ever practiced it

Unlike sending salat and Salam upon the prophet and his household. Quran command it, Prophet command and practiced it and in turn all Sahabah except the Munafiqun from amongst them practiced.

Question: We believe that despite the fact that Nabi and his Sahabah never command or repeat the phrase "Radi'Allahu anhum" after the mention of any Sahabah, all Muslims practiced it today especially the salafi. Why did the salafi accept this but reject the saying, "Jumu'ah Mubarak" which majority of the Muslims see as a form of greetings among each other, the fact that both phrases attract same condition?

# That is a double standard. Therefore, there is absolutely nothing wrong greeting each other Jumu'ah Mubarak.

Rashduct4luv:



The answer to your logical question is simple.

Allah used "Radi'Allahu anhum" for the Sahabas in Qur'an 98:8 and we follow this example.

Show us "Jumu'ah Mubarak" in the Qur'an as an example to follow!

shawl:


It will be nice if you can give me an evidence about a muslim who greeted based upon the felicity of Friday and got rebuked for it from among the salaf salihin, that would be a proof. In the absence of that, the prophet, sallAllahu alaihi wa sallam, declaring Friday Eid day and the hadith of Abu Darda, radiyAllahu anh, above suffice.



What happens to "Actions are judged according to intentions" at the very least. The intention clearly is to felicitate among ourselves on the festival day of Friday.

Rashduct4luv:




1. Such innovations were not present during the time of the Prophet and if their was any benefit in it we would have been informed. Except if you know better than him salallahu alayhi wasalam.

AbuHammaad:
All these people that are always quoting me know I won't reply them so why do they bother ?

AlBaqir:


# You should rather show us where Nabi and the Sahabah ever repeated or commanded that the phrase "Radi'Allahu anhum" should be used after the mention of any sahabi, despite the fact that Quran used the phrase for some righteous Sahabah?

Or are you accusing the Nabi and the Sahabah of not following Quran?

# There was a command of sending salat and Salam upon the Prophet in the Quran, and both Nabi and his Sahabah practiced it.

usbcable:
Seems Nairaland is promoting fanatism with this kind of posts that get to front page.

Not every religious post shoudl be promoted just because the person has quoted the Quran and/or hadith.

Later the mods will be wondering why self radicalization is popular in europe and americas.

The terrorist started somewhere similar.

from seeing everything as black and white.
--to castigating views and opinions different to their as evil.
--to preaching against it
--to wanting to enforce it
--to going full trottle terror

Peps need be careful of what they consume via the internet.

Rashduct4luv:


Hmmm, well......logically...

Who do you expect to say "Radi'Allahu anhum" during the time of the Prophet?

Do you expect a Sahaba to say such for another Sahaba?

Or you expect the Prophet to say such for his companions?

I still dont get u.

AbuHammaad:
AbdelKabir it's interesting to know our resident nl scholars know more than Shaykh Saalih Al fawzaan

Allaahul musta'aan