|
mrpataki (m)
|
Now we are getting somewhere, where has the government provided the basic amenities you mentioned, shelter, good roads, job opportunities, where???
It can not be the duty of the citizens to maintain infrastructures, it may be the duty of the citizens to ensure they are used properly and not vandalised, but in maintanace the govt has that duty, either it decides to do it directly or indirectly it is the duty of the appropriate tier of govt to maintain, eg roads how can the citizen maintain roads?
My reference to tax, should be revenue, be it tax or income form crude oil or whatever source, theres revenue accruing to govt, what is it been used for. And talking about tax, salary earners pay tax, the FIRS is constatntly expanding its tax base, so we can/should start talking about how our taxes are utilised.
What is the money spent on?
Please don't force yourself to sound intelligent on this matter. I would suggest you try to educate yourself on your civic rights and duty as a citizen of the country. Go through my posts here, I no where indicated the government is a functional one at the moment as it ought to be, but the greatest problems lie with the citizenry in itself. I still insist, who are those that are paying tax? The civil servants and who else?
|
|
|
|
|
|
buluti (m)
|
@ seun001, good point, why can't the people be given that alternative. Why must policy always be against the market man/woman as if they are not human beings and have no rights. You want to build a complex, provide for them in the complex, charge them what is needed to maintain it to standard and see if the people wont protect it. Your last statement is so true, the local govt is always charging tenement rate or whatever they call it, that is a form of taxation, what has the tenement rate being used for? The citizens of oluwole have a right to demand what their tenement rate or developmental levy has been used for. No one is abinitio anti govt why should we be, but we are calling for responsible and accountable actions from the govt. If you collect money from the people you owe it to them to tell them what it is used for and if you want to demolish where they are for whatever reason, you owe it to them to provide an alternative. @ mrpataki, if am sounding intelligent (coming from someone addressing issues) to you then please be objective and give way to a superior arguement compared to your spoon feeding. I also didnt suggest you said the govt was functional, am opposed to your view of a lazy citizenry, waiting to be spoonfed, thats untrue and again seems you have issues on civic duties and responsibilities, thats a given, we need not touch on that. I could enlighten you some more if you want.  . My civic duties can not and doesn't include maintaining roads, my tax provides for that.Geezzz Just to recap what i said above and in providing an obvious answer, salary earners of respectable companies pay tax, the shops on the streets, market men/women pay tenement rates and several levies, theres Company income tax, VAT, its not only PAYE thats considered taxation. Please the tax base is wide. I think i should ask, do you mrpataki pay tax, as you think people don't pay tax, a lot of us do and its a lot.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Neyoyo (m)
|
It's a two-edged sword.By this action, government may have made business hard for the forgers but what about the innocent residents who have now been made homeless. I dare say business like that of Oluwole thrive only because we have a failed government.
|
|
|
|
|
|
presido1 (m)
|
Demolishing Oluwale is a very good idea but from all that i have read they way it was carried out made it a bad idea. If the Govt had promised to relocate the residents(forggers not included) for the past 3 years why then did they not provide the said accomodation before the demolition. They must find somewhere to reside thereby creating another OLUWALE. That is very simple. Mrpataki please rethink on your line of argument because it lacks cohesion. If the goverment is not responsible for the provision of all that you mentioned please let us know how many kw of electricity you generate, how many roads you have tarred and maintained as a good citizen.
|
|
|
|
|
|
prince_onx
|
Guys! guys!! (you know yourself) I still don't get the base of your argument. Is it that hard to know that Nigerian government has failed millions of its citizens? We don't have laws in Nigeria PERIOD. We have them written somewhere as constitution just like anyother country but Laws/constitution is nothing if nobody abide to it. You don't just wake up one morning and demolish where people make their living without notice or arranging for a new place! to me it just creating more areaboys out there! Do you know how many business premises the government demolish every year with the promise of building a mall and turn around and sell them to some rich guy? do you know how many banned goods seized by our government everyday and turn around and sell them back to us? what kind of government is that? True enough you don't sit and wait for the government to feed you or find you a job but lets be realistic here! what about simple things that everyday life need to go on like Good roads, water even if its a top per street not even everyhouse?, schools, hospital, and electricity? do citizens have to take a blame for not having these things in a country like NIGERIA? And by the way which government are we even talking about here? NIGERIAN GOVERNMENT? I think it about time to call that thing something else than government! una dey here dey talk of tax! pay am to who? a thief? in the name of government! I'll rather be robbed with a gun not with a pen!
|
|
|
|
|
|
prince_onx
|
No be me call the name oh! I said guys! na presido1 call am oh! wey my helment 
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sweet T (m)
|
Another set of armed robbers will soon hit the lagos streets.
|
|
|
|
|
|
iykrion (m)
|
The government has to encourage enabling enviroment, so that the private sectors can create jobs which will inturn put these smart rogues out of business. Demolishing Oluwole will only affect their location and certainly not their illegal transactions.
The various governments in Nigeria always engage in punitive reforms instead of corrective ones. That is why they will rather demolish a settlement inhabited by poor people on the excuse that robbers use it as a hideout.
Warri man will say 'siddon dey look na dog name'. We don siddon dey look them
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
dasarge (m)
|
All hail Buluti. Mr. Pataki you should realise you are contesting with an intellect. You are both right just that Mr Buluti is more knowledgable on this issue so i really see no reason you are quarelling over it. Its the governments responsiblity to maintain infrastructure not just to get them in Place. Maintenance is more important. Simple and there so many means of government revenue not just tax besides Ifueko Omiigu the FIRS Boss is doing a wonderful work with her duties and realising a lot of revenue for the government. People should never forget also that the government revenue from Oil and Gas is 40% underated and underquoted in the budget so far. What happens to the excess from the budget? the fact remains that we have thieves and illiterates in power and we should definitely no rely on and base our budget expectations on one source. What hapened to agriculture, tourism, sports etc? Cant we break down our plans to milestones? Cant we start from Food? Cant we enhance the agric sector to produce for our subsistence before embarking on over ambitious exports? People get broke in the UK but food is the cheapest commodity you can find here.
PLease people like Buluti can expansiate on this and not for us to fight over this its a dialogue
|
|
|
|
|
|
nigeriaone
|
What?? All footballer for Nigerian go suffer, na that place them they go make document to come play ball for Europe, No more future kanu, OK joke apart, How can someone buy one of this oluwole land since we all know No shopping centre is coming out of it, They told us the same story about Maroko, who they live their na, No be big man, Ko to think of it , me too be big man for Nigeria, This may be good thing for all of us big man, Na joke, So how do i get my own share of this good news my fashola, if no land for me, My friend sowore, would be after all of you people, So make sure We see Shopping centre or I would run to be governor or senator, since the Area boys at oluwole were the ones politician use to rigged the election,  Of late I have been think about this politics think O? since most of you Governor can not manage Nigeria well or defend the common man, I know what Awolowo would want Lagos to look like, I believe in him and can make it happen, I am going to think about this thing of going into politics since all of you are not defending our people, If Awolowo was alive he would have wanted me to run, You politician are making me feel like I should run for office.
|
|
|
|
|
|
prince_onx
|
Who change the topic? or am I in the wrong room? hold on, 
|
|
|
|
|
|
Pamperme
|
In as much as i don't support demolishing people's house without giving alternative, i really support this one, let's face it, people are doing illegal businesses there and some people feel there is nothing wrong with that. What i really want is the government to please relocate those that has residential houses there not relocating those who are doing sharp practices. On another note, the government should have waited till after the Xmas because these boys need money to spend at their villages and with no Oluwole, i guess everybody knows what they will resort to  . God help us in Lagos 
|
|
|
|
|
|
tetede
|
Oluwole was a business place where they were selling wears not just for duplication of document but that was what made the place popular sha.
i don't understand why some people are wasting their grammar on this case. check this pix out sure the government that demolished Oluwole and distablised the traders was too busy to notice this abi?
The activity on the street where this building is situated has been suspended till this building takes its decision which may be anytime .
we have blind leaders and crippled gov.
deaf and dump leaders and i don't know again.
What is the same goverment doing about railway market in Oshodi?
what about Yaba?
please stop being selfish and face reality.
The shopping center will be sold out per lock up shop at N4 million.
Is that the way to help the masses?
|
|
|
|
|
|
debosky (m)
|
The picture you have placed is a subject of contention between the Federal Government and the LASG, LASG wants it demolished and the land reverting to Lagos, but the FG is fighting this. Please get yourself informed before making unsubstantiated claims. The original owners of property in Oluwole have been compensated, so I don't know what you're talking about and you're mentioning Yaba and Oshodiwill the government tackle each and every single problem at the same instant? CBD Lagos used to be the heart of the city, now that has shifted into V/I-Lekki axis, its time to bring back order and sanity to the heart of Lagos. The 'masses' can trade at other locations, Downtown areas around the world are the most expensive locations to own shops, I don't see why Lagos should be different. For the 'masses' I guess one benefit is if you go to school and finish with a good degree, you now have to worry less about some criminals in Oluwole forging a certificate for some other dude to take your place  Urban renewal is needed on Lagos Island, this is part of the painful but necessary process to achieving that.
|
|
|
|
|
|
buluti (m)
|
The picture you have placed is a subject of contention between the Federal Government and the LASG, LASG wants it demolished and the land reverting to Lagos, but the FG is fighting this. Please get yourself informed before making unsubstantiated claims. The original owners of property in Oluwole have been compensated, so I don't know what you're talking about and you're mentioning Yaba and Oshodiwill the government tackle each and every single problem at the same instant? CBD Lagos used to be the heart of the city, now that has shifted into V/I-Lekki axis, its time to bring back order and sanity to the heart of Lagos. The 'masses' can trade at other locations, Downtown areas around the world are the most expensive locations to own shops, I don't see why Lagos should be different. For the 'masses' I guess one benefit is if you go to school and finish with a good degree, you now have to worry less about some criminals in Oluwole forging a certificate for some other dude to take your place  Urban renewal is needed on Lagos Island, this is part of the painful but necessary process to achieving that. Please can you expand on that statement. The original owners have been compensated, in addition please provide evidence to show that, you just might be right, but the dailes stated the opposite, that they have not be relocated as promised by the govt. I am thinking and you can help, from a developmental perspective as a government should i be interested only in the land owners but on ensuring that there is an affordable means of commerce in this case shop outlets that is affordable key word affordable, to ensure a certain income bracket (low income) can afford. As a govt can i put a scheme in place to empower this people and offer them the opportunity to pay over a time period as they make sales etc. Does this arguement really have to do with the owners of the land compensated or that there should be affordable shops.
|
|
|
|
|
|
tetede
|
like i said earlier Oluwole was a business place but became popular for the illegal activites.And who told you that the illegal activity has ben demolished just because those buildings were demolished? That is not the best measure to curb the activities of the boys and sure was not done for that.
i don't know if you are one of the people that are handling the case that you were fast at getting at me but if you are please tell your people to be fast about their decision and do something about the building that has been like that for MONTHSSSSS. do u need to be told that the activities on part of marina street is being affected just because some folish people are slow at using their FISH BRAIN.
Yes talking about masses, if government is demolishing Oluwole for shopping center then why does a lock up shop have to go for 4million naira? do you know what a lock up shop is?
Check your fingers boy!
|
|
|
|
|
|
buluti (m)
|
hello tetede, was that to me or debosky, i assume debosky.
|
|
|
|
|
|
debosky (m)
|
Let me expoundThe compensation process has begun, and land/funds set aside for such a purpose. Each and every inhabitant/property owner may not have received his/her portion, but adequate provision has been made. This is not a case of unplanned movement hatched overnight without planning.
On the issue of affordable shops, you raise a very important issue. Now is this Oluwole location the best place for these low-income bracket traders to be located? Isn't there a higher value use that this land (prime land if I might add) could be put to?
In most cities, the revenues from the downtown core/CBD's are usually used to subsidize services/amenities in other locales because the companies/entities in the downtown can afford to pay more than these low income earners, thereby freeing up cash to provide some assistance to this group.
In addition, certain areas of Lagos CBD have been designated as 'street trading' locations, where some of these displaced folk can relocate to. Other initiatives like these will go a long way to ease some of the difficulties. I see no reason why as a matter of compulsion, the Oluwole traders must become the new owners of whatever shops are built on the location. A government is within its rights to zone and allocate costs according to how it deems fit, given the overall level of investments or general ambiance or clientèle within a given location. For example, property taxes on Wall Street will definitely not be the same as what you might pay in Queens in New York.
Even in light of all the above, the truth is that change will always be resisted, even when the govt makes provisions, these cries of 'the masses' will always come up. Change is painful, Lagos CBD has been allowed to deteriorate for too long and needs renewal. The government may not get each and everything right, but they are definitely moving in the right direction.
@ tetede what is the value of a shop in a downtown location? Why must they insist on remaining in that spot, if all the traders move to another location, their customers will follow suit and there will be no problems. I have no interest in the project beyond my desire for real change not hamstrung by wrong perceptions and a warped sense of entitlement. If I can afford a shop in Oluwole, then I will pay for it, if not move elsewhere.
|
|
|
|
|
|
buluti (m)
|
@ debosky Let me expoundThe compensation process has begun, and land/funds set aside for such a purpose. Each and every inhabitant/property owner may not have received his/her portion, but adequate provision has been made. This is not a case of unplanned movement hatched overnight without planning.
Okay agreed the compensation process has began, but my question is when should the demolition commence is it at began or completed stage. A sincere and serious govt would complete the process announce it, if possible publish the beneficiaries of relocation for all to see. Yes it might not be unplanned but it is definately a wrong implementation of a good idea. Secondly you raised certain issues but don't you think we run the risk of still excluding the same set of people. Agreed in this case the inhabitants must not occupy the new shops since as you put it this might be a prime location. But my question is this why can't they inhabit it, why must they be always be excluded, do we want to continue this division, a clear difference of shanty markets and expensive markets eg Oshodi/Shoprite. My opinion is that what you suggest would seek to continue the process that should be changed. We have a delicate process on hand, a system where there is no confidence in the govt. We need to create an environment of empowerment and a sense of belonging to the development of the nation in the minds of the so called miscreants, they must have a stake, if not its them against us leading to armed robbery, political thugs and all sorts. We do not wish to isolate them. Agreed they might not be able to afford the sophisticated shops, but why keep building multibillion complexes. Why can't there be cost effective alternatives in the so called prime areas. Abinitio building street markets with the same target clientele would expand shanties, street markets can exist but there should be ways of managing and coordinating this, the crime rate in those places would still be high if not careful, doesnt that immediately tell us that we will have this same Oluwole problem again in the new street market. @ debosky i am for change, but please this has nothing to do with resisting change, Nigerians are all for change just talk to the average ibo man he will tell you he will go anywhere just give him a secured shop to sell his goods. The cries of the massess comes up because the government is not alive to its responsibilities, this people have a right to be heard and heard fairly not just trivalised away as cries of the masses.
|
|
|
|
|
|
debosky (m)
|
Well said buluti
I am not trivialising the cries of the masses at all, I simply believe there is a cost/value to be placed on something and that needs to be taken into consideration at all times.
I do appreciate that the process may be flawed, but that should not truncate it. I repeat, there is no sacrosanct need for the traders to insist/want to remain at a given location. If the laws/planning edicts are changed, they will need to follow suit. While their needs need to be considered, that cannot override the greater good of Lagos just for the sake of a couple of traders.
There are lots of multiplier effects that a clean and decent downtown location bring - investment, big business and companies which provide knock on opportunities for these masses you speak of. Now if we allow them to only trade everywhere, how does that help in the long run?
I believe that the street trading concept will be properly deployed, and that the authorities will carry people along.
I don't know if you read my post fully, but the high costs being paid for prime locations often subsidizes the other less prosperous ones, that is how governments work to redistribute wealth. I don't see how the shanty traders will be able to afford the new shops, simply because they really didnt have shops in the first place, merely wooden contraptions or slots in old buildings way past their sell by date.
No simple traders can occupy a 20 storey building for example, but that is usually the kind of developments suited for such prime areas. That is the truth of the matter, and we cannot run away from that. I repeat, unless they are claiming this land as 'ancestral homes' there is still no firm hold they can have to this land. Redevelopment must occur to raise the profile of the area as a whole.
let me give an example, someone is willing to pay 4million in Oluwole for A SINGLE SHOP, government makes 2million off that, and is able to build 4 shops that cost 500,000 at another location which provides opportunities for 5 PEOPLE, while accomodating the 500k trader in Oluwole would benefit just one person. That is the kind of redistribution I'm talking about.
The government has decided to provide ample shopping facilities in other locations, maybe not at a price wholly affordable to these folk and that I admit is lackingbut a government MUST prioritize and carry out its projects accordingly. Many of these issues you raise are teething problems that can be settled and improved upon as part of the 'process' you speak of
|
|
|
|
|
|
buluti (m)
|
@ debosky thanks for your input, good points raised.
I agree that the current Oluwole was long overdue for demolition, but relocating traders should be priority first before demolition. Again maybe a total removal of all those structures from the lagos Island would ease up space, help the traffic flow and several other advantages. I am not insisting that they remain there as you said a govt considers a lot, what am calling for is a proper cost effective structure when they are relocated not a shanty market so we don't end up just moving a problem form one location to another, as long as the maintanance scheme is in place, its possible to sustain this cost effective structures.
You know the multibillion complexes are better suited for virgin areas, leads to higher multiplier effect, because you can develop along side schools, homes etc, totally new towns.
We are all watching, my earnest prayer is that the govt gets it right,i really want them to, we all would be happy for a better and safer lagos island, you know let get things right for a change, we are tired of all this bad implementation issues just because someone refused to think the process/project through at times one can't help but insinuate that its planned to be implemented wrongly.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EmekaNaija (m)
|
Lagos state Govt. has manage to put all ibo boys in lagos out of business. Grin Grin I wonder what they will do now @Sweet T. What is wrong with you? You must be a nuisance wherever you are. Why would you suggest that Oluwole is only Igbos (not Ibo)? Haba, that is not fair. is Oluwole not lagos again in which Yorubas claim to be their land? is Oluwole not in lagos Island again ooo. If it were in onitsha, i for understand. this Nigerian attitude of blaming the Igbos of all problems in very unbecoming. in Niger Delta they claim igbos are the militants. Just the way some fools started insinuating that Obasanjo was born to an Igbo man so I guess they'll soon claim that the criminals/militants (Asari) are also Igbos.
|
|
|
|
|
|
nayalee (m)
|
THINK OF WAT You CAN DO FOR UR COUNTRY AND NOT WAT YOUR COUNTRY CAN DO FOR You ALL THE TIME- THE DEMOLITION OF OLUWOLE CAME AS A SURPRISE AND I AM VERY SURE THERE MUST HAVE A PRIOR NOTIFICATION BEFORE ITS DONE AND MORESO BOTH THE GOVT AND THE MASSES SHOULD BE BLAME, BBLAME THE GOVT BCOS NO RESERVATION WAS MADE AND THE PUBLIC BCOS OF THEIR DISOBEYANCE, MAY GOD HELP US ALL
BUT GOVT SHOULD HAVE EXTENDED HIS MERCY TILL NEXT YEAR FOR THEM TO MAKE SOME SALES THESE YULETIDE
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sweet T (m)
|
@EmekaNaija
Nna, whatever. Everybody knows that Oluwole was being ran by the ibo boys. Nobody is blaming ibos for anything but you guys needs to slow down when it comes to chasing money.
|
|
|
|
|
|
iykrion (m)
|
@EmekaNaija
Nna, whatever. Everybody knows that Oluwole was being ran by the ibo boys. Nobody is blaming ibos for anything but you guys needs to slow down when it comes to chasing money.
Let's start with you. Are you gathering stones where you are?  The Igbos are only being enterprising. QED 
|
|
|
|
|
|
presido1 (m)
|
@EmekaNaija
Nna, whatever. Everybody knows that Oluwole was being ran by the ibo boys. Nobody is blaming ibos for anything but you guys needs to slow down when it comes to chasing money.
When a fool talks we all know, why una the weste space for this idiot that don't know his origin. Igbos dey chase money Yorubas dey chase sand.
|
|
|
|
|
|
oge4real (f)
|
As usual Govt, agencies in Nigeria have good agenda for development but lack cushioning effect of the policies on the masses.
|
|
|
|
|
|
folahann (m)
|
Every disappointment is a blessing, If the house of the king gets burnt; a better structure is put in place (ile oba t'ojo ewa lo busi)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sweet T (m)
|
@EmekaNaija
Enterprising my @ss, Ibo boys just 419 you blind. I don't know what's enterprising about that.
|
|
|
|
|
|
presido1 (m)
|
@EmekaNaija
Enterprising my @ss, Ibo boys just 419 you blind. I don't know what's enterprising about that.
Fool go and watch 60 minutes australia and let us know the tribe in the video. Its in You-tube.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sweet T (m)
|
@presido1
Whatever, Fred Ajudua .
|
|
|
|
|
|