I try not to get into arguments, you clearly don’t know what you are talking about here, I am not just interested in broadcasting, I run a broadcast companies both in UK and Nigeria and I have built TV and Radio stations from scratch this is what we do day in day out, we installed a 10 channel automated play-out system at SoundCity (the largest implementation in Nigeria) they also bought the first set of HDV cameras from us, they paid before the cameras where even released! Apart from this I have years experience in broadcasting, my company in the UK produced all the foreign contents for AM Express until about 18 months ago when we stopped because of falling standards, it was the same reason I turned down programme requests from BEN and OBE. I am only doing this (running my mouth off ) just to help educate others out there in the industry nothing more, there is nothing we cannot do if we apply ourselves. Anybody in the industry out there that wants an impartial advice is more than welcome to contact me directly or go to any of our clients like Tunde Kelani, Patrick Oke, DJ Tee, Julius Agwu, Soundcity, Channels just to name a few. Ok here goes.
Are you seriously suggesting that there is no difference in quality between DV and Digibeta or Beta SP? I have a lot of clients like you who make wrong assumptions about formats. Most of the HD cameras they use in Nigeria are the low end ones, they are mostly ZI or JVC GY-HD251CHE. (collectively they are known as HDV. There is another class called HD Broadcast cameras which can cost about £40,000 for just the camera head, I am not aware of any production outfit that uses these in Nigeria) Secondly, most of them film in DV because the cameras are dual formats. There is NO TV STATION IN NIGERIA THAT AIRS IN HD (I have put some leading TV stations in Nigeria with their formats below, if you think I am wrong about any of them please say so)
Some independent producers film in HD, edit in HD but when it comes to transmission they step it down to DV so at the end of the day there is no much difference between them and a person who films with a PD170 or a DSR 250! Some of them have realised this now and they just simply shoot in DV and no longer buy HD tapes which cost more. DV cameras like the DSR 400 or 450 are more expensive than HD cameras like z1s, most soaps in Nigeria are shot on DSR 250 / 400/ 450 or the new 530s. This is because they have interchangeable lens and some of the lens are actually more expensive than a Z1 (The replacement for this will be the Z7E and it will have interchangeable lens) What is the point of filming in HD when you cannot transmit in HD? I always ask my clients this anytime they come rushing to buy HD. Even the UK has only got a handful of HD channels, Nigeria is still along long way away from HD transmission.
I have no interest in trading insults on line with anybody but you said …
The only difference you are seeing, if not entirely of your imagination - is the quality of the camera used, lighting, etc. Another important fact: most Nigerian shows are shot in the HDV format and not DV25…. You come across as confused. On one hand you say you can't see the difference between DV and digibeta then you say “ …quality of camera…” Are cameras not based on formats? You have DV cameras and you have Digibeta, HDCAM, XDCAM or You-Matic (outdated) VHS cameras etc. If you film and output anything in DV and I film and output anything in Digibeta or Beta SP, the difference will be glaring just like if I film and out put anything in VHS and put it beside DV. Jacobs creek appeared low quality because it was put against a higher format, of course lighting does matter.
When you say Jacobs Cross is a big budget show, you are talking from your limited context of Nigeria. You need to put it in perspective, film budgets in Nigeria are peanuts compared to what obtains in the western world. Just to give you an example the Presenter of “Have I got News for you is paid £50,000 PER EPISODE, this is even small compared to what US TV stations pay, but that is almost N17 Million per quarter for just one presenter. The most expensive talk show in Nigeria today is Moments with Mo and I know what the equipment cost because we supplied and installed them! So your big budget in Naija might just be cab fare for production crew elsewhere!
NTA = DV
AIT = DV
SILVERBIRD = DV
Channels = DV
SOUNDCITY= SDI
Multichoice= Digibeta (not 100% sure)
Always at your service
pbsfax@gmail.com