Posted by:xxxxxx on the Nigeria Village Square:
What do you all think of this?
On: Feb 2, 2007 02:37 AM
*I just found this in my in-box. I have no idea who the sender is. Read and draw your own conclusions.
xxxxxx *
TRANSCORP: Buyer Beware
I am still convinced that injustice anywhere threatens justice
everywhere.
*
If you had read the news a couple of months ago, there were serious
allegations of fraud and conspiracy by various government officials.
OBJ was accused of investing in the corporation as well as other top
shots who were accused of using the corporation as a front for their
illegal loot.
What is Transcorp
Well, it is Nigeria's first "so-called" mega-conglomerate. But unlike
most conglomerates that start small and grow over a long period through
mergers and acquisitions, Transcorp started big with immense capital,
political backing from the presidency, and the questionable intention
of wanting to invest in an array of industries. Transcorp summoned some
of the countries leading moguls for its propaganda- Aliko Dangote was
conscripted. Also, wealthy individuals and those close to the president
are part of the Transcorp campaign. Just recently, Transcorp left the
borders of Nigeria targeting Nigerians at home and abroad to invest,
and thus meddle with this leper Organization.
Who Are the Owners of Transcorp
The owners happen to be those who are seriously connected to the
president. The president was given a share of 200 million naira and
various sectors in the Nigerian industry were sold to these people.
There was no fair bidding process. NITEL, Oil Blocks, etc were given
to cronies under the umbrella of Transcorp. There is nothing wrong in
having connection with the government to make money, but what I don't
agree with is arresting others who do what you do and put up all sorts
of fronts on your behalf.
*
In a recently published article, the public outcry over President
Olusegun Obasanjo's multi-million naira equity holding in Transnational
Corporation (Transcorp). It was said that two of his aides have
revealed how the promoters of the mega firm raised N200million to buy
the shares for him through a blind trust. Federal Capital Territory
(FCT) Minister, Mallam Nasir el-Rufai and Chairman of the Economic and
Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), Mallam Nuhu Ribadu, said Ndidi
Okereke-Onyuike, Jim Ovia, Festus Odimegwu and Tony Elumelu, all
Transcorp directors, cashed in on the President's interest in the
company to get the shares for him.
Also, in an interview with The Nation, situated in Abuja, Ribadu
recalled that on the day Transcorp was launched, the president
signified interest to be a shareholder and "while he was doing this,
there were some smart guys around, very smart and I call names for you.
People like Elumelu, Ovia, Odimegwu, Okereke-Onyuike, These were the
gangsters. These are the owners of Transcorp. "They took over the
opportunity. They were the ones who went and organized to say they were
going to give him loan in the United Bank for Africa (UBA). They took
N200million from UBA and they gave it to the blind trust to buy shares
for him, "They were the ones who were promoting third term* for him;
they suddenly made him do something else. It is UBA money that was
taken, He was aware of it, The fact is that he didn't know it was
something that is not acceptable." (The Nation)
*
Antitrust Laws
I see a future in Nigeria where the public will be stifled into price
monopoly and price fixing. Also, Transcorp may effectively control all
the plum allocations in the oil blocs as well as ruin the economy
through price fixing. Once you have this so-called mega-corp. that is
owned by all Nigerians, in the interest of all Nigerians, that will
share benefit to all Nigerians, communism will befall all Nigerians.
There is no need mentioning the damages that communism can inflict on a
nation. Transcorp comes to Nigeria as a sheep in Wolf's clothing and
the prospects of a true capitalist society will be threatened. I think
that there are other good viable corporations that one can support
without being an accessory to theft of the Nigerian populace.
*
The Business Argument
The business argument goes like this: We are in it to make money and
there is no conscience in Business.
I retort by asking, "are assassins not in their profession to make
money?"
*
My fellow Nigerians, I will advice, based on the history of that corp,
that we do not invest in it. We must play our part in building Nigeria.
It is not enough to blame those who mess up country, or steal from it.
By supporting Trancorp through purchase of shares, we have gently
acquiesced in the charged and alleged corruption. In legal terms, we
become "accessory to theft."
*
Whether Transcorp makes or does not make money, we would know that we
have played our part; I tell you, however, convinced that the arc of
the moral universe is long but bends toward justice, that there is a
strong likelihood that Transcorp will not survive the test of time.
Now imagine a political situation in which Buhari wins, and EFCC is
given the power to investigate Transcorp, your stocks will crash faster
than you can say "Jack Rabbit."
*
One should ask why is it that they are so desperate to sell shares just
before the election?
Did anybody at the meeting ask them about the potential antitrust
issues and the accusations that were leveled versus the president in
his hand in the corp.?
Why did they get 4 oil blocks so easily? How come they have not
improved NITEL since it was purchased? ETC
*
The Facts about Transcorp in the News
In September of 2006, an article reported that Chairman of
Transnational Corporation, Dr. Ndi Okereke-Onyuike, who is also
supposed to be the director of Nigerian Stock exchange, confirmed
speculations that President Olusegun Obasanjo holds equity shares in
the company. Her revelation came barely 48 hours after the Economic and
Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) raided the Head Office of the
company reportedly in a bid to 'investigate' the shareholding structure
and operations of the company.
Okereke-Onyuike told the House Committee on Capital Markets that "the
president had subscribed to the shares of the company when it was
established. Even though she did not specify the amount of shares held
by the president, her revelation confirmed media reports that the
president owns between 200million to 600million shares in Transcorp.
The shares are reportedly being held for the president in blind trust
by Obasanjo Holdings, the parent company for all his firms which
include Obasanjo Farms, OHL Quarry, OHL Properties and Tempo Foods and
Packaging Limited. Since Transcorp was established, it has enjoyed
tremendous presidential waivers in the different sectors of its
operations. This is apart from the preferential treatments it got in
its bid to buy some public companies like NITEL and Nicon Hilton (now
Transcorp Hilton), in the on-going privatization program of the federal
government.
The recent revelation by Okereke-Onyuike no doubt brings to question
the anti-corruption stance of the Obasanjo-led government. The many
privileges and presidential waivers that the company has enjoyed within
the short period of its existence are no doubt in question because
these waivers were given by the president to a company in which he is a
major shareholder. Transcorp upon inception got approval to build a
$250 million (about N33.25 billion) refinery in Lekki Free Port Zone in
Lagos. The company bought 75percent shares in NITEL under circumstances
which many have described as dubious since only 51percent shares of the
company were advertised for sale to a core investor. More so, this was
done even after Orascom, the Egyptian telecom company that failed to
meet the reserved price, was said to have offered to increase its offer
to meet the reserved price.
The president is said to have acquired significant shares in United
Bank for Africa (UBA) through one of his aides during the consolidation
program. When Tony Elumelu whether it was true that the president had
shares in the company, it was said that he avoided giving a categorical
answer to the question thereby raising suspicion amongst management
that the president may be a major shareholder in the company.
The recent revelation by the Chairman of Transcorp and the evidence
provided by the VP indicting the president of corrupt practices
undoubtedly raises more questions than answers on the federal
government's seeming war against corruption. This no doubt raises the
question on whether the much talked about anti-graft agency - EFCC -
can really summon the courage to investigate activities of the
president from 1999 to date.
Currently, questions are being asked as to why it took this long for
the EFCC to launch an investigation into the activities and operations
of Transcorp. The ability of the commission to conduct a sincere probe
into the shareholding structure and operations of the firm is also
being questioned.
As Nigerians wait to hear the outcome of EFCC's probe of the company,
and other possible dealings of the Commander-in-Chief, the commission
would do the nation a lot of good if it hastens its investigations and
tell the public what it has found out about Obasanjo's Transcorp shares
and the sources through which this and other investments were
financed." (at Corruption charges and Questions trail Obasanjo's Shares
in Transcorp, at
http://www.usafricaonline.com/obasanjo.transcorpdeal.html By Anas A.
Galadima in Abuja)
Recently, the EFCC published some disturbing reports involving
corruption that linked the Rivers governor, Dr. Odili, with Transcorp.
The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) has said it is
investigating Rivers State governor and presidential aspirant of the
Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), Dr. Peter Odili over misuse of public
funds to the tune N100billion. Other allegations, against Odili,
according to the EFCC are: money laundering, foreign exchange
malpractice, stealing, conspiracy and abuse of office. (Info at Our
case against Odili; Dec. 13, 2006, at
http://www.efccnigeria.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=1156&Itemid=2, by EFCC)
Who knows why Dr. Odili has been pampered by the presidency even in
the midst of the heavy allegations. The most detailed report about
Transcorp can be seen in the one of our nations top news magazines,
Newsweek.
*Newsweek reported the following:
The sale of Nigeria Telecommunications Ltd, NITEL, to Transcorp, a
company in which President Olusegun Obasanjo is said to have interest
is still generating dust. The company became more visible after its
purchase of Nicon Hilton and the controversial purchase of moribund
Nigeria Telecommunications Limited, NITEL for $750 million. The
negotiated sales strategy adopted in selecting Transcorp by the Bureau
of Public Enterprises, BPE, generated criticisms from Nigerians who
claimed that the whole issue was devoid of transparency and fair play.
*Transcorp was selected out of seven contenders that emerged from 28
expressions of interest received by the BPE. Rules are being bent to
enable the company pay after reneging on initial payment agreements.
The criticism that trailed the sale was so sharp that Aliu Wadada,
chairman of the House of Representatives committee on capital market,
said the House would probe the sale of NITEL. According to him, the
committee's concern was to see that the process was transparent.
He said Transcorp initially under-prized NITEL and its subsidiary,
MTEL with the claim that it has an intimidating debt profile but was
forced to scale its price upwards when more determined companies began
to show willingness to offer something bigger. That could probably
account for why it is yet to meet up with the payment agreement.
As sad as the situation surrounding Transcorp is, some applaud the
selection of transcorp by BPE on the ground that it is an indigenous
company. Chris Uwaje, an information technology professional said the
federal government should be commended because it would have been a
folly to sell NITEL to outsiders. "That is one of the most strategic
decisions of the federal government in the twenty-first century. It
would be folly to give it to outsiders. No person sells his heart
outside. You have Duetche telecoms, British telecoms, France telecoms,
the government should be commended because that is the backbone for the
knowledge economy of the future," he said. Chife Alloy, chief executive
officer of Socketworks, an indigenous software firm said: "Transcorp is
a local company and it has the capacity to turn NITEL around."
The reasons given by Chris Uwaje are very weak. After all we have
great corporations like Dangote Group and Adenuga that can compete with
the best in any part of the world. There is simple no justification for
what is going on concerning Transcorp activities.
Recent events now justify the fears of those who felt something was
wrong with the Transcorp deal. People report that President Obasanjo
allegedly acquired 600 million shares in Transcorp. According to
reports, more than 200 million shares were taken up by his company
Obasanjo Holdings Limited, Abeokuta while 400 million shares were
acquired by cronies. All the shares were allegedly acquired at N1 per
share by the president and his men while Transcorp shares were offered
for sale by private placement at N6 per share. And the entire N600
million arising from the share allocation was fully paid as well.
Newswatch could not confirm the names of the cronies who benefited from
the allocation as at press time last week.
But the magazine learnt that Atiku Abubakar, the vice-president was
allocated 100 million shares by the president. Immediately, the
vice-president was informed about the reserved shares for him, he
rejected it. In a letter dated May 19, and addressed to the managing
director of Transcorp, the vice-president said he was informed of some
reserved shares meant for him in Transcorp and rejected the offer. The
letter reads: "I have just been informed that some shares have been
reserved for me in your corporation for which I am expected to
subscribe. I write to formally inform you of my decline of the offer. I
thank you for the kind gesture and wish you best of luck."
A number of people alleged to be Obasanjo's men were also said to have
been allocated shares. Nasir El-Rufai and Charles Soludo, FCT minister
and CBN governor respectively were indeed alleged to have been made
offers. The CBN in Abuja said last week that they were not aware that
the president offered 100 million shares of Transcorp to the CBN
governor. One Abdullahi, a CBN staff from the corporate affairs
department told Newswatch on phone that they are hearing it for the
first time. "I don't think there is anything like that. In any case, I
wouldn't know unless they tell us," he said. He refused to disclose his
full identity. When Newswatch contacted Remi Oyo, President Obasanjo's
spokesperson, she declined to comment on the matter. She had earlier
denied the allegation in a press statement.
Newswatch also gathered that more shares of the company are to be
offered for sale soon at the price of N10 per share. Also, the
president was said to have approved the sale of NITEL to Transcorp and
not Abubakar, the vice-president who is the chairman of National
Council on Privatisation, NCP. From indication, it appears that the
vice-president was opposed to the sale of NITEL to Transcorp.
Information reaching Newswatch has it that the sale of NITEL has been
removed from NCP and BPE. It is now being handled by the national
executive council under the president.
The controversial shares are alleged to be held for the president by
his company on a blind trust. Blind trust is a legal arrangement where
a public official put his private business interest in the hands of
trustees who shield him from day to day business decisions thereby
avoiding a potential conflict of interest. But this legal arrangement
is not in Nigeria's statute books. This probably accounts for why
Obasanjo cleverly opted to protect himself personally by fronting his
company, Obasanjo Holdings Limited, OHL.
When Newswatch visited OHL, the parent company of all Obasanjo's
businesses which includes Obasanjo Farms, OHL Quarry, OHL Properties
and Tempo Foods and Packaging Limited at Quarry Road, Abeokuta last
week, Lucky Egede, the group managing director was said to have
travelled to Abuja. Newswatch was able to reach him on his mobile line.
He said he was a private business man and not a politician and declined
to respond to the allegations leveled against his company. He advised
Newswatch to extend its enquiries into other shareholders of Transcorp
by going to the Corporate Affairs Commission, CAC, for investigation
instead of limiting it to OHL. Egede, however, owned up to the purchase
of the shares for president Obasanjo under a blind trust according to a
Lagos based business magazine.
According to Newswatch, enquiries at the CAC did not reveal the names
of the shareholders and the amount of shares purchased in Transcorp,
rather it discovered that OHL was incorporated on September 18, 1986
and has 19 Onijaiye Street, Abeokuta, as its contact address. Its
registration number is 89233. The company has 5 million as its allotted
share capital with three directors. They are, Onaolapo Soleye, with 56
Quarry Road as contact address, Daniel Atsu of 3/5 Ayorinde Street,
GRA, Ibara, Abeokuta and Lucky Egede of the same address. (Info at
Newswatch, The Dirty Transcorp Deal * Aug. 28, 2006)
Even Dangote Abstained
One of Nigeria's business greats, Aliko Dangote, resigned from the
board of Transcorp. The question at this point is "why should you buy
it?"
Transnational Corporation of Nigeria Plc (Transcorp) may be heading
for crisis as one of its founding members, President and Chief
Executive Officer of Dangote Group of Companies, Alhaji Aliko Dangote
has resigned from its board. Although details of his resignation still
remained hazy as at press time, there were also indications that the
Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) may have also been putting pressure.
(Info at Thisdayonline, Crisis Rocks Transcorp, Dangote Resigns,
Pressure on Ajekigbe, others
Ayodele Aminu, Dec. 12,2006)
Conclusion
My fellow Nigerians these are the facts. You decide whether you would
hold yourself to a higher standard. You decide whether you want to be
an accomplice to what is unfair and simply unjust.
The question remains "whether you would insult fraudulent Nigerians
but yet be willing to eat the fruits of their pillaging?"
On an economic basis, we must be careful because as the facts show,
there seems to be a rush to sell these shares before the election
commences. A reasonable man should ask why?
*With the sale of the shares to us, they make a huge profit. Under
company law, you as a shareholder will bare all losses that may result
from any failure of the corp. Shareholders bare risk. It is your duty
to do your due diligence. I have given various reasons why we must no
partake in this venture. At this point, if we were to buy the shares
and the stocks crashed, the shareholders in Transcorp would make a huge
profit of our backs. As reported by Newswatch, while all the shares
were sold to the protagonists of Transcorp at N1 per share, they are
now selling it to the public at N6 per share. I imagine that they are
selling to those of us overseas at more than the N6 value.
At this point, if we were to buy the shares and the stocks crashed,
the shareholders in Transcorp would make a huge profit of our backs. As
reported by Newswatch, while all the shares were sold to the
protagonists of Transcorp at N1 per share, they are now selling it to
the public at N6 per share. I imagine that they are selling to those of
us overseas at more than the N6 value.
If we must invest in our country, we can invest in Dangote's
corporations or Adenuga or other open responsible corporation,
including the banking sector.
Even if Transcorp becomes the number 1 corp., which I doubt it would
for so many reasons than I care to go into beyond those I have given,
your conscience would be satisfied knowing that we were not part of the
problem in Nigeria.
Nitel was purchased more than a year ago by Transcorp but NITEL
remains an ineffective enterprise. What is Transcorp doing?
All the best,
The Nigerian Village Square