|
Beaf
|
@Negro_Ntns.
Fortunately for me. I learnt the history of Benin (and a host of other places) DIRECTLY from a Bini high chief and a host of other bearers of oral tradition.
What is on wikipedia about Ekhaladeran (Oduduwa) is not even detailed.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Negro_Ntns (m)
|
For political sponsorship from the powerful North, it is creative and a smart move that people on the frontier borders between political rivals should associate and identify with the mainstream power as their roots. Its only practical that they do so. How many times have you heard Americans suddenly discover overnight and then declare their Irish or Italian ancestry. The Irish and the Italians controlled mainstream power then. Jews are increasingly making inroads. Nowadays, same people that were Irish yesterday are now discovering that they are in fact Jewish. Go figure! 
|
|
|
|
|
|
Negro_Ntns (m)
|
Thats good Beaf. Yes please and encourage other truth seekers as well to get it direct. Thats Great you did that!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Beaf
|
Thats good Beaf. Yes please and encourage other truth seekers as well to get it direct. Thats Great you did that!
I gave a very tiny summary on this thread (which you were also part of) here http://www.nairaland.com/nigeria/topic-157544.0.html#msg4067244I forgot to mention that, aside from being a phd, the Bini chief I mentioned is also a direct descendant of Ekaladerhan (Oduduwa). He is also given as a reference for this page of very detailed Edo history http://www.edo-nation.net/origin.htmSome things that never seem to be considered are the relative ages of the Oduduwa myths (and creation of the World), the age of Edo history (2000+ years), the point in time in Edo history that coincides with the point in time of the Oduduwa myth. When those are considered, the Edo version is by far the more plausible (there are no myths, no climbing from the sky etc).
|
|
|
|
|
|
Negro_Ntns (m)
|
Oduduwa is no myth. The climbing or descending from heaven is allegoricalanot to be taken literally as one descending a flight of steps suspended from heaven to earth. He was by no means disembarking a UFO mothership. He descended from heaven would also mean he descended from divine origins as in the worshipping beliefs of the Kushites, where he was factually linked. The relationship between Kush and Egypt is analogous to the relationship between Ife and Bini. One came out of the other.
Bini has never denied that they were one of the seven states of Yoruba nation.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Ifygurl
|
Tunde and MANY ILORIN Kwarans, feel they are fulani and but speak yoruba (Northerners) "Is anybody aware that Tunde Idiagbon was a Fulani? Indeed, he was. Two Fulanis (head of state and his deputy) once ruled Nigeria!" http://www.nigerdeltacongress.com/warticles/who_owns_kano_ilorin_and_the_cri.htm"Formerly a predominantly Yoruba town, Ilorin is now a multiethnic city, harboring, among others, Hausa and Fulani settlers from northern Nigeria. "The city of Ilorin, grew in importance in the early nineteenth century as a frontier emirate of the Sokoto Caliphate (in Northern Nigeria), and amassed a large population of slaves. Control of this slave population was of enormous importance to the city elite" (188). Historically, the Hausa-Fulani took control of Ilorin during the nineteenth-century era of the Islamic (Fulani) jihad or holy war, hence a strong influence of Islam arose there." http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-515949_ITMyou like lying to yourself There are many people who speak yoruba but aren't yoruba Fulanis in the north took hausas', land and language why not do the same to Yorubas? THERE IS NO OBA OF ILORIN, ITS ONLY EMIR OF ILORIN, THAT IS PART OF THE SOKOTO CALIPHATE!!!!One thing i hate is when someone is wrong and they just can't admit it. You tellin me there no fulanis that speak yoruba is like saying there is no yorubas that speak hausa(which many do) or there is no ijaws who speak igbo(which many do) it all depends on regions. You do know there are Yoruba's living in Illorin? Right? You do know those Yoruba's in illorin do not see themselves as Fulani-Hausa right? Illorin was discovered by Yoruba's but Fulani-Hausa took it from them. That doesn't mean there aren't any Yoruba living in Illonis. According to the website created by illorin government Illorin contains YORUBA, Hausa, Fulani, etc tribes living there. http://www.ilorin.org/tribes.phpThey trade and do business in Yoruba but the language spoken in that state is Hausa http://www.ilorin.org/languages.phpThey should know about their own state alot more than anybody else. Anambra used to be an igala state. it was discovered by igala's but igbo's took the state from them. There are still Igala's in Anambra. Anambra speaks igbo mostly and some does trading in Igala. That doesn't mean Anambra does not have igala people living there? NO Anambra tribes is igbo and igala. Illorin tribes is Yoruba, Fulani, Gobir, Tapa/Nupe ,Baruba, Hausa etc. (according to the illorin government). Thank you. I had to go research Illorin because i didn't know much about that state. It still goes back that Tunde Must be one of the Yoruba's in Illorin. I highly doubt there own government is lying that Yoruba reside there. The Yoruba's in ilorin do not see themselves as fulani. if so they wouldn't be calling themselves "Yoruba". it is believed that alot of igbo people now-a-days weren't igbo people but another tribe that migrated to igboland. They saw themselves as igbo and started calling themselves "igbo". http://www.qub.ac.uk/schools/SchoolofEnglish/imperial/nigeria/origins.htmP.P.S: They speak Hausa. They only use Yoruba to trade and do business but they speak HAUSA. The same way, some Anambra's use Igala to trade and do business but speaks Igbo. Get off that High horse you fool. I hate when people try to deny their own people. It's sad really. I guess Tunde didn't do a good job as vice-president that's why you are trying to deny him .
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Beaf
|
Oduduwa is no myth. The climbing or descending from heaven is allegoricalanot to be taken literally as one descending a flight of steps suspended from heaven to earth. He was by no means disembarking a UFO mothership. He descended from heaven would also mean he descended from divine origins as in the worshipping beliefs of the Kushites, where he was factually linked. The relationship between Kush and Egypt is analogous to the relationship between Ife and Bini. One came out of the other.
Bini has never denied that they were one of the seven states of Yoruba nation.
How can that be, when Edo predates Ife and its civilisation by a thousand years? Ife welcomed Ekaladerhan (Oduduwa) around 1087 AD which coincides neatly with Ekaladerhan leaving Ughoton for Ife. The Edo version is easier to believe because of the level of detail they give (rather than falling out of the sky and similar). Edo's also ruled as far as Ghana not too long after the Ekaladerhan (Oduduwa) period. They were militarily superior to every other ethnic group sorrounding them and even farther afield. You will note that the Oba of Benin and senior Benin chiefs wear battle amour which is unknown among sorrounding ethnic groups. Dahomey got its name from an Ishan (Edo) general called Isidahome and when they want to change their name to Republic of Benin, they sought permission from the Oba of Benin. Calling Edo one of the seven states of Yoruba nation, ridiculous beyond belief. This is the list of Ogiso's up till father (the last one). I'll leave this argument (let Edo's take up their own mantle) with an example of the sort of detail that is proof to me. This list is from a thousand years ago.- Ogiso Obagodo
- Ogiso Ere
- Ogiso Orire
- odionwere (republican Ogiso)
- Ogiso Odia
- Ogiso Ighido
- Ogiso Evbobo
- Ogiso Ogbeide
- Ogiso Emehen
- Ogiso Akuankhuan
- Ogiso Ekpigho
- Ogiso Efeseke
- Ogiso Irudia
- Ogiso Etebowe
- Ogiso Odion
- Ogiso Imarhan
- Ogiso Orria
- Ogiso Emose
- Ogiso Orhorho
- Ogiso Irrebo
- Ogiso Ogbomo
- Ogiso Agbonzeke
- Ogiso Ediae
----Orriagba Dynasty begins here--- - Ogiso Orriagba
- Ogiso Odoligie
- Ogiso Oduwa
(maybe we can form a new myth around this) - Ogiso Ehenneden
- Ogiso Ohuede
- Ogiso Oduwa
(maybe we can form yet another new myth around this) - Ogiso Obioye
- Ogiso Arigho
- Ogiso Owodo - Ekaladerhan's (Oduduwa) father (circa 1000 AD)
|
|
|
|
|
|
No2Atheism (m)
|
@Beaf
Is there a detailed academic book about the Edo history that i can get and reference and study.
1. Either yorubas are lying and making up history
or
2. Edos are lying and making up history.
They both cannot be true.
How far back can Yorubas trace their own history, and how far back can Edos trace their own history.
|
|
|
|
|
|
sjeezy8
|
You do know there are Yoruba's living in Illorin? Right? You do know those Yoruba's in illorin do not see themselves as Fulani-Hausa right? Illorin was discovered by Yoruba's but Fulani-Hausa took it from them. That doesn't mean there aren't any Yoruba living in Illonis. According to the website created by illorin government Illorin contains YORUBA, Hausa, Fulani, etc tribes living there. http://www.ilorin.org/tribes.phpThey trade and do business in Yoruba but the language spoken in that state is Hausa http://www.ilorin.org/languages.phpThey should know about their own state alot more than anybody else. Anambra used to be an igala state. it was discovered by igala's but igbo's took the state from them. There are still Igala's in Anambra. Anambra speaks igbo mostly and some does trading in Igala. That doesn't mean Anambra does not have igala people living there? NO Anambra tribes is igbo and igala. Illorin tribes is Yoruba, Fulani, Gobir, Tapa/Nupe ,Baruba, Hausa etc. (according to the illorin government). Thank you. I had to go research Illorin because i didn't know much about that state. It still goes back that Tunde Must be one of the Yoruba's in Illorin. I highly doubt there own government is lying that Yoruba reside there. The Yoruba's in ilorin do not see themselves as fulani. if so they wouldn't be calling themselves "Yoruba". it is believed that alot of igbo people now-a-days weren't igbo people but another tribe that migrated to igboland. They saw themselves as igbo and started calling themselves "igbo". http://www.qub.ac.uk/schools/SchoolofEnglish/imperial/nigeria/origins.htmP.P.S: They speak Hausa. They only use Yoruba to trade and do business but they speak HAUSA. The same way, some Anambra's use Igala to trade and do business but speaks Igbo. Get off that High horse you fool. I hate when people try to deny their own people. It's sad really. I guess Tunde didn't do a good job as vice-president that's why you are trying to deny him . not really, like i said ilorin folks are all of the tribes you mentioned and can swing either way from tribe to tribe so what your problem? I simply said : those in ilorin are mixed, but as i said not everyone that speaks yoruba is yoruba. Depends on the individual, ilorin folks can claim yorubas this day and fulani the next.But who can tell them right, other than themselves? no one. Im sure Babatunde AT THE TIME SAID HIS FULANI STORY like Dr Olusola Saraki and his son govenor.i personally think your arguing the wrong point.  my point is Tunde could have been fulani yoruba or mix and during the time Fulanis where in power, he could have claimed fulani just like Saraki did. I have no need to DENY him he denied him self like i've always said yorubas claim eachother even Theives like OBJ hes a yoruba man
|
|
|
|
|
|
Negro_Ntns (m)
|
Beaf,
read my response to Tpia. It is common to use Edo and Bini interchangeably but the two are distinctly separate. Edo is the ruled, Bini is the ruler. Edo is the land owner, Bini is the conquering ruler.
There is no Edo state in the Yoruba Nation but there is Bini State. Similarly, Awori is the land owner in Lagos and Asikpa Dynasty is the conquering ruler. Asikpa was not installed Oba but instead was called Eleko of Eko because it was forbiden for a Prince of Bini to be enthroned a King before the Crown has been vacated. It was a taboo. So he was skipped and rituals were made to ward off the taboo and allow one generation to elapse before a Crown was transported to Lagos for a new Dynasty to be established there.
Prior to the reign of Obas in Bini, the Edos had the Ogisos. Prior to the reign of Obas in Lagos, the Aworis had the Idejo Chiefs.
So Edo may possibly precede Yoruba Nation which was founded only after Oduduwas arrival in Ife. But it is wrong to say Bini preceded Yoruba.
The problem is knowing to use the two in the correct context of historical account. Do not mix Edo ancestry and roots or timeline with Bini history even though they are collocated.
|
|
|
|
|
|
tpia@
|
Tpia,
You have a point there. If Bini is an offshoot of Ife, then Lagos monarchy is by root an extension of Ife by way of Benin. Sometimes I get Edo and Bini mixed up. They are sometimes used interchangeably but thanks for pointing out that I should correctly identify Akinsemoyin and OlogunKutere as Bini names and not Edo.
Akin, Akhen and Aken is the same. Olorogun and Ologun are the same. Akin is a Bini name and so is Olorogun.
I think far too many things are getting mixed up these days. Akin is a Yoruba name. Binis/Edos may have a different version with a different spelling, but 9.8 times out of ten, when you see a Nigerian with the name Akin, he's Yoruba. A few may be from Benin Republic. Olorogun is a Yoruba word, or a Yoruba title. What does it mean in Edo or Urhobo?  Some of these names and titles are the result of intercultural borrowing, or are loan words shared between languages. Eg you have Oba of Benin. Oba is a Yoruba word meaning king. Akinsemoyin is Yoruba. What does it mean in Edo? In Yoruba it translates to Crown and honey. http://correlator.sandbox.yahoo.net/index.php/people/OlorogunOlorogun is also related to the Ogboni fraternity, as you can see from the website above. http://www.absoluteastronomy.com/topics/Oba_(ruler)
|
|
|
|
|
|
tpia@
|
na wa- see how the info page and link was removed as soon as I posted it here. Naijas and whoever should keep fooling themselves. Everybody wants rewrite history and rule the world. Oba, (pronounced Or-ba), means King or ruler in Yoruba. Obas are the traditional heads of Yoruba The Yoruba word, 'oba', has also been adopted by some non-Yoruba ethnic groups.
there are some non Yoruba ethnic groups who are also ruled by obas. The most well known is the Oba of Benin or Omo N'Oba.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Beaf
|
@Beaf
Is there a detailed academic book about the Edo history that i can get and reference and study.
1. Either yorubas are lying and making up history
or
2. Edos are lying and making up history.
They both cannot be true.
How far back can Yorubas trace their own history, and how far back can Edos trace their own history.
As far as I know, Yoruba history (Ife) can be traced back a about thousand years and Edo history can be traced back two thousand plus years. It is unfair to say one side or the other is lying, there are two sides to a coin and both are telling the same story from their own perspective. The question to ask i, which story is more accurate? The one with only vague mysteries or the one with all sorts of minute detail? You might find this book useful, The history of ancient Benin Kingdom and Empire (Daniel Nabuleleorogie Oronsaye).
|
|
|
|
|
|
Beaf
|
Beaf,
read my response to Tpia. It is common to use Edo and Bini interchangeably but the two are distinctly separate. Edo is the ruled, Bini is the ruler. Edo is the land owner, Bini is the conquering ruler.
There is no Edo state in the Yoruba Nation but there is Bini State. Similarly, Awori is the land owner in Lagos and Asikpa Dynasty is the conquering ruler. Asikpa was not installed Oba but instead was called Eleko of Eko because it was forbiden for a Prince of Bini to be enthroned a King before the Crown has been vacated. It was a taboo. So he was skipped and rituals were made to ward off the taboo and allow one generation to elapse before a Crown was transported to Lagos for a new Dynasty to be established there.
Prior to the reign of Obas in Bini, the Edos had the Ogisos. Prior to the reign of Obas in Lagos, the Aworis had the Idejo Chiefs.
So Edo may possibly precede Yoruba Nation which was founded only after Oduduwas arrival in Ife. But it is wrong to say Bini preceded Yoruba.
The problem is knowing to use the two in the correct context of historical account. Do not mix Edo ancestry and roots or timeline with Bini history even though they are collocated.
Sorry, but you could not be more wrong. Bini means the people of Benin (originally Idu); it has no further meaning. It is the capital of Edo land; the history of Edo (Benin kingdom) is the history of Bini people. How could the Edo capital be a Yoruba state, but the Edo nation was not a Yoruba state? Its an unworkable argument.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Negro_Ntns (m)
|
Lamurudu was believed to have come from the region of Kush to settle in Ife. Pharaohs of the 18th Dynasty were believed to be the rulers of Kush. There was a particular King of Egypt called Akhenaten and out of all the Dynasty Kings this is the only one they have not found trace of his remains. I am not saying this was Lamurudu but I am about to lay facts for you on the connection of the name Akhen, Aken and Akin. First, I don’t know what AKHEN transliterates to in Egyptian, Ethiopian or Hebrew language but I do know that ATEN in Hebrew transliterates to ADON. From here you get ADONAI, meaning The Lord or My Lord. Kings in olden times were addressed as My Lord.
Through etymology languages go through transformative changes where sometimes vowels are dropped or modified or consonants picked up where none previously existed. Going bythe above, if I would rewrite the name of this King I will write out like this. . .AKHENADON, instead of AKHENATEN,
Lamurudu came into Ife with an entourage of emigrants and they were far outnumbered by the indigenes of the land they settled on. How did he become King? This is a quest for another day but even in those early times of their settlement two names were exclusive to his dynastic court – AKIN and ADE.
Subsequently, with the growth of the new Yoruba Nation, Bini was born. A new dynasty was formed and Oba replaced Ogiso. Oba of Bini adopted the customary names of AKEN and ADE for his court.
In Ife, ADE (Crown) was reserved for nobility. AKIN (Gallantry) was reserved for warlords. In Bini, AKEN was reserved for nobility and I don’t know what happened to ADE.
The Lagos Dynasty followed in the footsteps of both Bini and Ife and adopted both AKIN and ADE for nobility. It’s a hybrid of both. But in my earlier post, I contend that the first 10 or so Kings of Lagos were named exclusively in Bini names. You have Akinsemoyin and Akitoye.
The Lagos title of Olorogun takes roots from the Bini adaptation and is titular First Class Chiefs in the Akarigbere White Caps. The functions is the same with the Ife adaptation except that they also have administrative titles. So you could have a noble blood that is both heir to the throne and same time a titular Olorogun, as was the case with Ologun Kutere.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Beaf
|
^Stop making stuff up. You're only trying to pull my legs aren't you?  "Bini was born", its all so vague and far out.
|
|
|
|
|
|
tpia@
|
The Lagos Dynasty followed in the footsteps of both Bini and Ife and adopted both AKIN and ADE for nobility. It’s a hybrid of both. But in my earlier post, I contend that the first 10 or so Kings of Lagos were named exclusively in Bini names. You have Akinsemoyin and Akitoye.
The Lagos title of Olorogun takes roots from the Bini adaptation and is titular First Class Chiefs in the Akarigbere White Caps. The functions is the same with the Ife adaptation except that they also have administrative titles. So you could have a noble blood that is both heir to the throne and same time a titular Olorogun, as was the case with Ologun Kutere. You still failed to address the issue of these names which are Yoruba. What do Akinsemoyin, Olorogun and Kutere mean in Edo? The only known meaning is Yoruba, and Olorogun in particular is an Ogboni title. Ku is a common Yoruba prefix and most times linked to a ritual.
|
|
|
|
|
|
tpia@
|
I dont know of any Edo influence can't believe it was said Mind you edo is the only language i've heard that is quite different from yorubas in Oyo, Osun,EKO,Ogun,Ekiti,Ondo so obviously edo didn't influence anything besides SS Benin's presence in lagos seems to be linked to the Portuguese exploration of the west African coastline, in which case it (benin) was probably there only to facilitate the export of slaves. Dahomey kingdom was also founded for this express purpose. Benin likewise traded slaves with Ghana around that time before the Oba stopped the export of male Bini slaves. Am open to read from anyone with more info.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Negro_Ntns (m)
|
I dont speak Edo and Im sure the spellings are not exactly the same either. If I spoke Edo I can tell you. I do not dispute Yoruba as the root of the names and if you followed my argument all along I said "Lagos adopted the customs of Bini" for the same name and rituals practiced through the several Yoruba states. Example: Eletu is the same as Olotu. Generally in Yorubaland Olotu is advisor to the Chief or King. The Lagos adaptation is the Bini custom.
I can string it together in a way that illustrrates what im sayingvbetter. Each child civilization shall look to its parent civilization for guidance. So that Ife begat Bini and gave it Ife's cultures. In the course of long history those cultures were embellished and evolved. Then Bini begat Lagos and gave it Bini's customs. Under the first 10 to 12 reigns of the Lagos dynasty, Bini's customs survived but gradually wore off.
Notice I never said Bini gave Lagos a culture. . .but instead I used customs. The culture is uniform, but distinct customs.
|
|
|
|
|
|
No2Atheism (m)
|
Lamurudu was believed to have come from the region of Kush to settle in Ife. Pharaohs of the 18th Dynasty were believed to be the rulers of Kush. There was a particular King of Egypt called Akhenaten and out of all the Dynasty Kings this is the only one they have not found trace of his remains. I am not saying this was Lamurudu but I am about to lay facts for you on the connection of the name Akhen, Aken and Akin. First, I don’t know what AKHEN transliterates to in Egyptian, Ethiopian or Hebrew language but I do know that ATEN in Hebrew transliterates to ADON. From here you get ADONAI, meaning The Lord or My Lord. Kings in olden times were addressed as My Lord.
Through etymology languages go through transformative changes where sometimes vowels are dropped or modified or consonants picked up where none previously existed. Going bythe above, if I would rewrite the name of this King I will write out like this. . .AKHENADON, instead of AKHENATEN,
Lamurudu came into Ife with an entourage of emigrants and they were far outnumbered by the indigenes of the land they settled on. How did he become King? This is a quest for another day but even in those early times of their settlement two names were exclusive to his dynastic court – AKIN and ADE.
Subsequently, with the growth of the new Yoruba Nation, Bini was born. A new dynasty was formed and Oba replaced Ogiso. Oba of Bini adopted the customary names of AKEN and ADE for his court.
In Ife, ADE (Crown) was reserved for nobility. AKIN (Gallantry) was reserved for warlords. In Bini, AKEN was reserved for nobility and I don’t know what happened to ADE.
The Lagos Dynasty followed in the footsteps of both Bini and Ife and adopted both AKIN and ADE for nobility. It’s a hybrid of both. But in my earlier post, I contend that the first 10 or so Kings of Lagos were named exclusively in Bini names. You have Akinsemoyin and Akitoye.
The Lagos title of Olorogun takes roots from the Bini adaptation and is titular First Class Chiefs in the Akarigbere White Caps. The functions is the same with the Ife adaptation except that they also have administrative titles. So you could have a noble blood that is both heir to the throne and same time a titular Olorogun, as was the case with Ologun Kutere.
I would appreciate if someone could help answer the following. From the Bini version - it is said that eklahadren left Bini to somewhere. - how did they know where he went to. - how did they know is new name. - did ekalahadren leave alone or together with some other people. - I find no connection between the old name and the new name. - who was eklahadren's father. - did his father also leave Bini. - around what time did the use if the title Oba start in Bini and why. - who are the Ogiso and why did they become replaced. - around what time were they replaced. From the Yoruba version,- Is there a more detailed history of Lamurudu. - Did Lamurudu have other children. - Is there detailed accounts of Lamurudu from other cultures. - Did Lamurudu and Oduduwa come to Yorubaland together or not. - Was Oduduwa an only child or how come we have not heard of the other children of Lamurudu. - How can we be sure the Lamurudu is Oduduwa's father. - Around what time did the use of the title Oba start in Yorubaland and why. - Is there an historical trace of the footsteps of Lamurudu and Oduduwa that goes back to Kush i.e. are there not supposed to be traces of their journey along the way from Kush if they actually came from Kush.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Negro_Ntns (m)
|
Lmao. To be honest, we had a topic some months back and I thin it was titled "Where did Oduduwa come from" or something like that. Itwas opened by Aloy. Look for it in culture. It answers the Yoruba part of your questions. In fact, it gives more answers than you have questions. 
|
|
|
|
|
|
tpia@
|
I dont speak Edo and Im sure the spellings are not exactly the same either. If I spoke Edo I can tell you. I do not dispute Yoruba as the root of the names and if you followed my argument all along I said "Lagos adopted the customs of Bini" for the same name and rituals practiced through the several Yoruba states. Example: Eletu is the same as Olotu. Generally in Yorubaland Olotu is advisor to the Chief or King. The Lagos adaptation is the Bini custom.
I can string it together in a way that illustrrates what im sayingvbetter. Each child civilization shall look to its parent civilization for guidance. So that Ife begat Bini and gave it Ife's cultures. In the course of long history those cultures were embellished and evolved. Then Bini begat Lagos and gave it Bini's customs. Under the first 10 to 12 reigns of the Lagos dynasty, Bini's customs survived but gradually wore off.
Notice I never said Bini gave Lagos a culture. . .but instead I used customs. The culture is uniform, but distinct customs.
I have to disagree. The customs couldnt wear off if they were never there. Legend has it when the Portuguese arrived in lagos, they said they met some Bini soldiers there. Not that they met Bini people as a whole. Its like meeting UN or ECOMOG soldiers somewhere and assuming the region is the ethnicity of the foreign soldiers. The Portuguese actually first heard of Benin and the Oba through the Itsekiris, who told them that name- Benin. what were they called before Oranyan named them Ile Ibinu which they say the Portuguese corrupted to Benin? Olotu will have a Yoruba meaning beginning with Olu I'm sure. Whats the meaning in Edo? The Lagos adaptation of Olotu is a Yoruba one, not Bini. Many of these titles are linked to Ogboni, as I keep pointing out. and besides, you're right about the cross cultural borrowing, eg Yoruba word for mother is Iya while the Bini version is Iye, but for the political titles, there's more to be considered.
|
|
|
|
|
|
FL Gators
|
Wherever you see Negro_ntns and N02Atheism, you know there WILL be essays 
|
|
|
|
|
|
Beaf
|
Edo people founded Eko as a kingdom. The only reason why the Edo are not all powerful over the whole of SW, SS and maybe SE today is their total destruction after they lost their war with the British (maybe we non-Edo's wouldn't be screaming "Arewa" now). The battle for Lagos between Akintoye and Kosoko was part of that war (the British supported Akintoye and Tinubu). Kosoko lost and his son Olojo ran back to Benin. The street called Lagos street in Benin contains the piece of land given to Olojo as an Edo prince. His descendants today bear the surname, Olojo. Before the death of Akintoye, all Eleko of Eko (they were not called Oba until the 1920's) were buried in Benin. Akintoye was buried in Lagos because the British insisted that Lagos was now British territory and coerced Oba Dosunmu to sign the article of annexation of Lagos. " Prior to the Portuguese name of Lagos being adopted, Lagos was originally called Eko, which stems from either Oko (Yoruba: "cassava farm") or Eko ("war camp"), by its Bini conquerors. History has it that the Oba of Bini sent various trade expeditions to Ghana where spices were traded and one of his traders complained about the way she was being treated by the Awori's. The Oba of Bini then sent a trade expedition by sea. Ironically, the leader of the expedition arrived in the evening at a time when the people who were predominantly fishermen were either wading into the water or getting into their boats to gather their catch. He declined to engage them further and returned to what is now called Benin City where he reported to the Oba of Bini that they were attacked. This prompted the Oba of Bini to constitute a war expedition led by Ado, a Bini Prince to go to Lagos and demand an explanation. This was over 650 years ago. However, on getting there, they were well received. The people were so enamored with Ado they asked him to stay and lead them. He agreed on the condition that they surrendered their sovereignty to the Oba of Bini to which they agreed. The Oba of Bini was told this and he gave his permission for the expedition to remain. The Oba of Bini later sent some of his chiefs including the Eletu Odibo, Obanikoro and others to assist Ado in the running of Eko. Till today, the Oba of Lagos is the head of all the Kings in Lagos State and his status is different from other Oba's most of whom were later given back their crowns and staff of office only within the last 40 years and have various classifications. Suffice it to state that those who got their crowns back were the original land owners. These were Olofin's children. Moreover, modern day Lagosians have so intermingled that no single tribe or people can claim it even though the predominant language is Yoruba. The present day Lagos state has a higher percent of this sub-group who allegedly migrated to the area from Isheri along the Ogun river."http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_LagosI don't 100% agree with this, but its a good source http://www.edo-nation.net/beneko.htm
|
|
|
|
|
|
Beaf
|
I would appreciate if someone could help answer the following.
From the Bini version - it is said that eklahadren left Bini to somewhere. - how did they know where he went to. - how did they know is new name. - did ekalahadren leave alone or together with some other people. - I find no connection between the old name and the new name. - who was eklahadren's father. - did his father also leave Bini. - around what time did the use if the title Oba start in Bini and why. - who are the Ogiso and why did they become replaced. - around what time were they replaced.
From the Yoruba version, - Is there a more detailed history of Lamurudu. - Did Lamurudu have other children. - Is there detailed accounts of Lamurudu from other cultures. - Did Lamurudu and Oduduwa come to Yorubaland together or not. - Was Oduduwa an only child or how come we have not heard of the other children of Lamurudu. - How can we be sure the Lamurudu is Oduduwa's father. - Around what time did the use of the title Oba start in Yorubaland and why. - Is there an historical trace of the footsteps of Lamurudu and Oduduwa that goes back to Kush i.e. are there not supposed to be traces of their journey along the way from Kush if they actually came from Kush.
Ekaladerhan was very popular and ran away with several soldiers, friends and court staff. He and his followers founded a town in the forest far away from Benin. The town was called Iguekaladerhan (land of Ekaladerhan), that place is now called Ughoton or Gwato. Ogiso Owodo who became the last Ogiso of Igodomigodo ascended the throne about 1068 following the death of Ogiso Arigho his father. Owodo had some physical defects which affected his personality and behavior. He was a hermaphrodite with fully developed male and female organs, which gave him conflicting emotions. (There are other known cases in history and their behaviors brought crisis and disaster to their people. Examples are Emperor Nero of Rome and King Henry VIII of England (1491 - 1547). Even before his installation he was known to have an erratic character. He had murdered his mother and because of this known problem, his father Ogiso Arigho covered it up. He had a secret wife Imade who bore his only son Ekaladerhan, and did not take her into his harem until he was persuaded to do so. He had a strong passion for his late father's senior wife Esagho and fell under her influence. Esagho was known to be a huge woman believed to be a witch who practiced lesbianism. In addition to Esagho, he married ten of his father's wives, murdered two and sent the rest packing from the palace. He also married many other women into his harem. Owodo also committed a lot of political blunders because of his erratic ways. From the beginning of his reign, he failed to cultivate the required loyalty and support of the Edion Uzama led by the Oliha. He bypassed and overruled them in the performance of the many ritual ceremonies connected with his installation. This made some of these ceremonies incomplete. A glaring example was his neglect and refusal to consult the Iso Temple. The Oliha and Edion Uzama's various attempts at bringing Owodo into line were met with rebuff and physical assault. In one of his fits, he is reported to have spat on the Oliha's face, though he apologized later. The biggest problem of Owodo was the failure of his numerous wives to bear children for him. This caused a lot of quarrels between the wives and Owodo, before he was persuaded to consult the oracle. Owodo sent Esagho and three men to consult on his behalf. After consultation, the Obiro instructed that Esagho should be executed. But Esagho bribed the three men to report that Owodo's only child Ekaladerhan was the cause of the problem and he should be executed. But Ekaladerhan was a powerful mystic who was destined for greater things and could not be so easily killed. This was known to Esagho and she secretly advised Owodo to banish Ekaladerhan and his mother instead. Moreso, Ekaladerhan was known to have a lot of strong allies who could destabilise Owodo's administration. Prince Ekaladerhan and his mother were taken into the forest and banished about 1084 A.D. But the Edion Uzama led by the Oliha did not leave matters entirely in the hands of Ogiso Owodo, as they were doing other things to safeguard the throne for Ekaladerhan. For so many years after the wives of Ogiso Owodo remained barren. He sent another team to the Obiro about 1087. This team found out that Esagho was the cause and should be executed, while the Ogiso should consult the Obiro. Owodo ordered the execution of Esagho which was done, but he failed to consult Obiro as was instructed. Due to this failure to consult the Obiro, Owodo could not be instructed on how to atone for the abominable adulterous acts of lesbianism coupled with sapphism which the executed Esagho had practiced with her co-wives. Since the wives of Owodo did not perform the atonement at the Iso temple with a bearded she-goat and other items to the spirit of Owodo's father, they remained barren. This greatly distressed Owodo, especially after he realised that he has been misled into banishing his only child. He then sent soldiers to capture and bring back Ekaladerhan from Ughoton. But the soldiers did not return. These developments further worsened Owodo's condition as he was always having abnormal fits. He started executing people, especially women at random. In one of his fits in about 1091, he executed a pregnant woman, an abominable act known as Kirikuvua. This led to the peoples rebellion against Ogiso Owodo. They invaded his palace, drove him out and banished him from Ile - the capital of Igodomigodo. He fled to the village of Ihinmwirin with only three of his old wives and nobody knows where he died in misery as a farmer.http://www.edo-nation.net/beneko.htm
|
|
|
|
|
|
Ifygurl
|
not really, like i said ilorin folks are all of the tribes you mentioned and can swing either way from tribe to tribe so what your problem? I simply said : those in ilorin are mixed, but as i said not everyone that speaks yoruba is yoruba. Depends on the individual, ilorin folks can claim yorubas this day and fulani the next.But who can tell them right, other than themselves? no one. Im sure Babatunde AT THE TIME SAID HIS FULANI STORY like Dr Olusola Saraki and his son govenor.i personally think your arguing the wrong point.  my point is Tunde could have been fulani yoruba or mix and during the time Fulanis where in power, he could have claimed fulani just like Saraki did. I have no need to DENY him he denied him self like i've always said yorubas claim eachother even Theives like OBJ hes a yoruba man You know i'm done arguing. This is my last comment. You switch from one thing to another. You are the one who denied him, not the other way around. I told you he was Yoruba. You came out and claim he was Fulani. His name is clearly a Yoruba name, maybe he's full or maybe he's mixed. Who knows? All i said was "He was Yoruba", you were the one who kept screaming he wasn't. In my eyes, that's denying your own people. Please provide an article where Tunde claimed he wasn't Yoruba. Assuming he denied his people doesn't mean he did. You provided an article from the Kwenu website that claimed he was Hausa-Fulani. Tunde himself didn't write that article, neither did the author write that statement in a quotation meaning he said it. The author assumed he was Fulani-Hausa. Another article which i provided claimed he was Yoruba. You latched out when i showed you that article. He didn't deny his heritage(unless you show me some kind of quote from him saying he's fulani). You denied his heritage, not the other way around. Aren't you the one who kept screaming that people in illorin aren't Yoruba people but Hausa-Fulani that speaks Yoruba. You were actually denying the whole Yoruba population in illorin. Unless you provide a prove, i'll keep saying "You were the one who denied him.". How am arguing at the wrong end? Since the beginning my whole argument was he was Yoruba. Which He is. Whether he's full or mixed, i don't care. All i know he was a Yoruba. Even if he's mixed, he's still Yoruba. Omotola Jalade is a mixed Yoruba(half Yoruba, half delta igbo), she's Yoruba. Banky W is mixed Yoruba(half Yoruba, half Calabar), he still Yoruba. That's been my whole point since the beginning of the argument(whether or not the man was half Yoruba or full Yoruba). He has always been and still Yoruba hence the reason i said "I can't stand when people deny their own people". The thing pissing me off right now is "you" are blaiming him for denying his people. When you don't even have prove that he did just something you assumed. it's pissing me off that you are passing your blame to him.  Unless you provide some kind of prove where he stated he wasn't Yoruba---i've not seen seen one so technically he never denied Yoruba. You denied him.
|
|
|
|
|
|
No2Atheism (m)
|
Ekaladerhan was very popular and ran away with several soldiers, friends and court staff. He and his followers founded a town in the forest far away from Benin. The town was called Iguekaladerhan (land of Ekaladerhan), that place is now called Ughoton or Gwato. Ogiso Owodo who became the last Ogiso of Igodomigodo ascended the throne about 1068 following the death of Ogiso Arigho his father. Owodo had some physical defects which affected his personality and behavior. He was a hermaphrodite with fully developed male and female organs, which gave him conflicting emotions. (There are other known cases in history and their behaviors brought crisis and disaster to their people. Examples are Emperor Nero of Rome and King Henry VIII of England (1491 - 1547). Even before his installation he was known to have an erratic character. He had murdered his mother and because of this known problem, his father Ogiso Arigho covered it up. He had a secret wife Imade who bore his only son Ekaladerhan, and did not take her into his harem until he was persuaded to do so. He had a strong passion for his late father's senior wife Esagho and fell under her influence. Esagho was known to be a huge woman believed to be a witch who practiced lesbianism. In addition to Esagho, he married ten of his father's wives, murdered two and sent the rest packing from the palace. He also married many other women into his harem. Owodo also committed a lot of political blunders because of his erratic ways. From the beginning of his reign, he failed to cultivate the required loyalty and support of the Edion Uzama led by the Oliha. He bypassed and overruled them in the performance of the many ritual ceremonies connected with his installation. This made some of these ceremonies incomplete. A glaring example was his neglect and refusal to consult the Iso Temple. The Oliha and Edion Uzama's various attempts at bringing Owodo into line were met with rebuff and physical assault. In one of his fits, he is reported to have spat on the Oliha's face, though he apologized later. The biggest problem of Owodo was the failure of his numerous wives to bear children for him. This caused a lot of quarrels between the wives and Owodo, before he was persuaded to consult the oracle. Owodo sent Esagho and three men to consult on his behalf. After consultation, the Obiro instructed that Esagho should be executed. But Esagho bribed the three men to report that Owodo's only child Ekaladerhan was the cause of the problem and he should be executed. But Ekaladerhan was a powerful mystic who was destined for greater things and could not be so easily killed. This was known to Esagho and she secretly advised Owodo to banish Ekaladerhan and his mother instead. Moreso, Ekaladerhan was known to have a lot of strong allies who could destabilise Owodo's administration. Prince Ekaladerhan and his mother were taken into the forest and banished about 1084 A.D. But the Edion Uzama led by the Oliha did not leave matters entirely in the hands of Ogiso Owodo, as they were doing other things to safeguard the throne for Ekaladerhan. For so many years after the wives of Ogiso Owodo remained barren. He sent another team to the Obiro about 1087. This team found out that Esagho was the cause and should be executed, while the Ogiso should consult the Obiro. Owodo ordered the execution of Esagho which was done, but he failed to consult Obiro as was instructed. Due to this failure to consult the Obiro, Owodo could not be instructed on how to atone for the abominable adulterous acts of lesbianism coupled with sapphism which the executed Esagho had practiced with her co-wives. Since the wives of Owodo did not perform the atonement at the Iso temple with a bearded she-goat and other items to the spirit of Owodo's father, they remained barren. This greatly distressed Owodo, especially after he realised that he has been misled into banishing his only child. He then sent soldiers to capture and bring back Ekaladerhan from Ughoton. But the soldiers did not return. These developments further worsened Owodo's condition as he was always having abnormal fits. He started executing people, especially women at random. In one of his fits in about 1091, he executed a pregnant woman, an abominable act known as Kirikuvua. This led to the peoples rebellion against Ogiso Owodo. They invaded his palace, drove him out and banished him from Ile - the capital of Igodomigodo. He fled to the village of Ihinmwirin with only three of his old wives and nobody knows where he died in misery as a farmer.http://www.edo-nation.net/beneko.htmThank you for the response. Nevertheless the response only answers a few questions. - it talks about Ekalahadren and the town he went to ( Ughoton or Gwato). - it talks about Ogiso Owodo and the village he went to ( Ihinmwirin) - it talks about Ekalahadren going to a far far away forest (how far away is this forest) since we are still mentioning Ughoton or Gwato and how exactly did Bini people know this forest since Ekalahadren was supposed to disappeared without a trace according to the claim. Notice the following. 1. Ogiso Owodo never went along with Ekalahadren 2. Hausas are not factored into the account, instead it is restricted to the internal politics of Edo. 3. It still does not mention how Ekalahadren is related to Oduduwa or how Ughoton or Gwato is related to Ile-Ife.The contradiction with the Yoruba account is this: 1. Hausas are factored into the account given by the yorubas. 2. Lamurudu is an active component of the story of Oduduwa. 3. I have not heard in the yoruba account that Lamurudu was a farmer nor is there an account that says his nameis Ogiso Owodo. 4. there seems to be no phoenitcal connection between Ile-Ife and Ughoton or Gwato.
My conclusion: - Ogiso Owodo is not the same person as Lamurudu
Further Questions that still need answering: --------------------------------------------------------- From the Bini version - Where is Ughoton or Gwato located and how does it relate to Ile-Ife. - How did they know where he went to i.e. how did they know he was in Ughoton. - Did Ekalahadren change his name from Ekalahadren to Oduduwa. - I find no connection between the old name and the new name. - Around what time did the use of the title Oba start in Bini and why. - Around what time were the Ogiso's replaced with an Oba. - How are were sure Ekalahadren and Oduduwa are even the same person, considering that Lamurudu and Ogiso Owodo are different people. From the Yoruba version,- Is there a more detailed history of Lamurudu. - Did Lamurudu have other children. - Is there detailed accounts of Lamurudu from other cultures. - Did Lamurudu and Oduduwa come to Yorubaland together or not. - Did Oduduwa come to Ile-Ife direct or from somewhere else where he first settled down. - Was Oduduwa an only child or how come we have not heard of the other children of Lamurudu. - How can we be sure the Lamurudu is Oduduwa's father. - Around what time did the use of the title Oba start in Yorubaland and why. - Is there an historical trace of the footsteps of Lamurudu and Oduduwa that goes back to Kush i.e. are there not supposed to be traces of their journey along the way from Kush if they actually came from Kush.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Negro_Ntns (m)
|
The only reason why the Edo are not all powerful over the whole of SW, SS and maybe SE today is their total destruction after they lost their war with the British (maybe we non-Edo's wouldn't be screaming "Arewa" now). The battle for Lagos between Akintoye and Kosoko was part of that war (the British supported Akintoye and Tinubu). Kosoko lost and his son Olojo ran back to Benin. The street called Lagos street in Benin contains the piece of land given to Olojo as an Edo prince. His descendants today bear the surname, Olojo. Before the death of Akintoye, all Eleko of Eko (they were not called Oba until the 1920's 1630) were buried in Benin. Akintoye was buried in Lagos because the British insisted that Lagos was now British territory and coerced Oba Dosunmu to sign the article of annexation of Lagos.
There was only one Eleko of Eko. Esikpa, Prince of Bini of Eweka Dynasty. He was succeeded by Oba Ado in 1630.
"Prior to the Portuguese name of Lagos being adopted, Lagos was originally called Eko, which stems from either Oko (Yoruba: "cassava farm") or Eko ("war camp"), by its Bini conquerors. History has it that the Oba of Bini sent various trade expeditions to Ghana where spices were traded and one of his traders complained about the way she was being treated by the Awori's. The Oba of Bini then sent a trade expedition by sea. Ironically, the leader of the expedition arrived in the evening at a time when the people who were predominantly fishermen were either wading into the water or getting into their boats to gather their catch. He declined to engage them further and returned to what is now called Benin City where he reported to the Oba of Bini that they were attacked. This prompted the Oba of Bini to constitute a war expedition led by Ado Esikpa, a Bini Prince to go to Lagos and demand an explanation. This was over 650 years ago. However, on getting there, they were well received. The people were so enamored with Ado they asked him to stay and lead them. He agreed on the condition that they surrendered their sovereignty to the Oba of Bini to which they agreed. The Oba of Bini was told this and he gave his permission for the expedition to remain. The Oba of Bini later sent some of his chiefs including the Eletu Odibo, Obanikoro and others to assist Ado in the running of Eko. Till today, the Oba of Lagos is the head of all the Kings in Lagos State and his status is different from other Oba's most of whom were later given back their crowns and staff of office only within the last 40 years and have various classifications. Suffice it to state that those who got their crowns back were the original land owners. These were Olofin's children. Moreover, modern day Lagosians have so intermingled that no single tribe or people can claim it even though the predominant language is Yoruba,it continues to be a Yoruba domain. The present day Lagos state has a higher percent of this sub-group who allegedly migrated to the area from Isheri along the Ogun river
|
|
|
|
|
|
Negro_Ntns (m)
|
Legend has it when the Portuguese arrived in lagos, they said they met some Bini soldiers there. It is common when merchants sailto make reference to seaports and coastline. When the Portuguese arrived, there was noplace called Lagos. It was called EKO. So the visitors may have landed in Porto Novo and thought they were in what was later to become Lagos. They could equallyhave landed in Warri and mistook it for what later was known as Lagos. Without navigational landmarks for a new found territory, yet to be identifiably named until much later, we really cannot accredit this account as credible as told bythe portuguese. At best. . .they were lost and any coast line to them is Lagos, if it had a body of lagoon water in it. Do you not agree?
|
|
|
|
|
|