- This site is in essence, is for a sub-group of the church right? If yes, I don't see any correlation b/w the 2. the site as-is resembles something "of the world"

- Font is so small that it is hard to read
- The sections are not laid out properly
- I would expect the contact info to be isolated such that it could be easily found.
Bottomline, given the amount of content on the page, I think you have no choice but to have more than 1 page. Remember: Less is more

Should you need more info on issues with the page and/or would like me to fix them, my company offers website auditing as a service and would be glad to help,
Thanks and good luck!