Bungalow Vs Duplex: Which Is Better.

I raised this topic in order to compare a Bungalow to a duplex in terms of cost, aesthetics and efficiency, in order to determine which is better and under what conditions.

A bungalow is a type of single-story house that originated in India. It originated from the word Bengali and Such houses were traditionally small, only one story and thatched, and had a wide veranda.
In Nigeria a bungalow is referred to a one-storey house without regards for style of size.

A duplex originally defined as a two unit apartment,  a house that is capable of accommodating two different families on the same plot. But within the Nigerian context it is erroneously defined as a two storey family house, which should rightfully be called a detached house.

So lets start our comparism of the two;

In terms of cost which is the most important factor in the considerations, it is obvious that a bungalow is cheaper to build than a duplex all other factors like area, specifications and  finishes being equal. The problem is by what ratio is duplex more expensive than a bungalow. Here is my analysis;

The most telling cost factor of a duplex is the cost of the decking and  beams + pillars to support the decking. The extra cost of concretework for  an average 4 bedroom duplex ( 1 bedroom down and 3 bedrooms upstairs) would cost around N2million depending on the concrete mix

Also the Foundation would be a major cost factor in water logged areas where raft foundation would have to be used, which can add up to an extra N1.5 million to the cost of foundation.

But the Bungalow will occupy at least 40% more ground space that would be occupied by the duplex, so in effect the cost of foundation would be approximately 40% more for the bungalow. so also would be the roofing. 

Now in areas where the land is very expensive, this extra 40% would be a major factor. Imagine a site where land is N60m per plot, the cost of land per square meter would be 92,000/m2. In such a place a bungalow would not make sense.  Furthermore even in relatively cheaper site, the value of having extra space for landscaping, parking and recreation is priceless.

In terms of aesthetics, i agree that a bungalow can have quite an appealing beauty, especially with an architect that can make use of the horizontal emphasis presented by the bungalow. But duplexes can also offer a compact look. Often a lot of architects combine the two effects to get the best of both worlds, by having a sprawling ground floor and a small compact upper floor.

In terms of efficiency of distribution of spaces, i believe you cannot beat a duplex. A duplex allows you to distribute and segregate spaces more efficiently. You can separate the private spaces from the public spaces and even the circulation spaces better. Then there is the added advantage of having balconies on the top floor overlooking the surroundings.

So i will only advice bungalow over duplex in situations where we have ample land, and the land is very cheap.

Let me hear what others think.

mansion

I like bungalow but for security reasons, duplex is better any time

@poster your idea is a good one and thoughtful as well, its all about rationalizing between the cost of land and affordability.

How is a duplex more secure?



The poster has only expressed his view and wants to find out what others think. I think we need more of such intelligent discourse on this section rather than just adverts. In my estimation, only about 1% of the threads in this section are of such intellectual discourse. Please note, I have nothing against the adverts.


In your opinion, which one is Meat Pie and which one is Agidi?  I think we should make out posts clear.

@poster,
For an elderly couple,  a bungalow may be ideal as the stress of climbing stairs may be too much.

There are still neighborhoods in naija where all the thief needs to do is point his gun through the window.

Besides it is easier to see what goes on within and without the perimeter of your property when you live in a duplex.

There have been cases where robbers come in through the roof of a bungalow.

Finally you can make target practice of prospective robbers and pluck them at your convenience from a duplex.

Yes, and questioner, you are on ya own!

Methinks, this is a fantastic post, well done poster! It allows people who have something to talk and think about come out of the woodwork and, it does it nicely too, well done again, poster!   

We have this penchant for 'big is right' this side of the planet.

When you mention bungalow, I think what readily comes to mind is 'face-me-I face-you.'

The cost of decking a duplex is enough to really dress up a bungalow.

@paragonpro
I like your analysis.

However, if you are considering the kind of risk you have mentioned then you also need a security door or burglar proofing for the stairs leading upstairs in a duplex. Aesthetically, that may be a no-no.

Other controls like trained dogs/security personnel, motion detection cameras, etc would be necessary.

In a gated community with motion detection cameras and cctv , a bungalow may still be okay.

My two cents!

depends on how u want it
some duplex are berra off bungalow and vice versa
depends on what u want and your taste sha,  size of family included!

SHALOM

I prefer bungalow.

I think the most important thing here is House not name. Bungalow or Duplex, house na house.

well it depends on choice and cash. one may have money but prefers bungalow. i have seen people that have money to build duplex but went for bungalow just because of personal preference.

i'd say any is ok with me but like the poster said, the area & some other prevailing conditions will greatly influence my final choice.

like the post as it's a huge deviation from naija issues, tribal & religious typicuffs!!!

  

a-beg-i,  this is year 2010,   no more clumsy buildings that prevent rescue operations during disasters.  Please think upward.

Bungalow is cheaper. I prefer, bungalows.

But, u seem to have answered  your question.