|
MT
|
@buttyelele, Thank you so much for taking me to the classroom again. Our tertiary institutions would be more than willing to employ you as a lecturer. You r simply great and thorough!. You examples make it so clear. However, I must tell you that as at now, I have grabbed the mathematical aspect of how to calculate EPS, PE & PAT ( interestingly within such a short period on this thread ooo), but the only area remaining is how to use these 3 parameters as tools to forecast the future value of a share and how to use them to establish if a value is under-valued or over-valued. Then, I will still like to know the full meaning of PE please Lastly, you stated that The PE ratio is only a comparison between the market price and the EPs, derived by dividing the market price by the EPS e.g if the market price is 45k and the EPS is 32k the PE ratio will be 45 divided by 32, which will give u 1.41. a coys EPS should not be too low in comparison to the market price.
Do you mean to state that " a coys PE (and not EPS) should not be too low in comparison to the market price?.  PS : It is interesting to note that nairaland is now my virtual classroom, and I'm so eager and willing to learn. Always on the look-out for my lecturers on this thread.
Also, that I can read the prospectus of coy with clear understanding and interpretation is such a soothing relief.
Thank you all.
|
|
|
|
|
|
buttyelele
|
hi again mt, u see ratio is all about comparison. PE ratio means price earning ratio, by definition it is regarded as an indicator of future performance, that is if u follow the trend. to derive PE ratio u dvide the market price by the EPS, the actual comparisom is between the market price and EPs, so if the mps is 100 and the eps is 20, that coy is not dong well as the margin is way too high.The market is more or less the benchmark if the market price is a certain figure, your coys EPS should be close to the market price, and from this i.e MPS and EPS we derive the Price earning ratio.
if you look at the trend and a coys PE ratio is low continously for a period u can determine where the coy is going, u cannot seperate EPS and PE ratio, if your EPS is low it will affect your PE ratio and vice versa, low and high EPS And PEratio is however relative i.e to the asking price in the market i.e MPS
|
|
|
|
|
|
dremoney (m)
|
hmmmmn,
learned a lot from this thread!!!!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
elsirich
|
@poster
Thanks for the thread. Please does anyone in the house know if intercontinental bank has given out shares certificate for the last ipo which they did?.I bought some shares and have not receive certificte from them and i do know how to go about it because i don't bank with them.Any information about this will be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance to all nairalanders
|
|
|
|
|
|
teena (f)
|
It'll be better to sign the form for him now, make a photocopy of the form and when the share certificate is out, you'll have to fill out the transfer form to his CSCS account with the same signature used in buying the shares then. It's also better to open a stockbroking account with a broker "they'll assist him on opening the CSCS account as well" which will make all his/her transaction easier to handle. I do this most time for people - though not in Nigeria but my broker handles it effortlessly , most times @alanbolo, thank you very much for the immediate reply and your explanations.
|
|
|
|
|
|
abott
|
Nice topic. Most people really don't understand the terms used. Anyway, lets take for example, access bank public offer of 4,721,839,130 ordinary shares of 50k each at N14.90 per share. (i) The 4,721,839,130 Ordinary Shares represent the number of shares the company is offering to the public, i.e. the public is allowed to subscribe up to that number of units for that particular offer. (ii) the 50k means that each of the company's share has an actual/book/nominal value of 50k each, this means that for each unit of shares bought, its actual value of 50k in the books (balance sheet) of access bank plc. now, lets get this well, this simply means that the company is supposed to sell this shares to the public at 50k, however, most companies due to their perfomance and market perception do not sell their shares at its book value, companies sell at a premium i.e a price above the actual/book/nominal value. (iii) the 14.90k is the price to be paid to buy 1 unit of share. hope u understand, for more info, u can reach me on olawoyina@accessbankplc.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
MT
|
@ Contributors, Thanks for all your excellent contributions, most especially, ABOTT, BUTTYELELE, KINGZY, BABAIFE However this is becoming challenging but there seems to be a logical twist to this. I understand summarily from Buttyelele's post that :
- the MPS (Market Price ) is the relative bench mark to the EPS and PE
- IF the PE of a company is too low continuosly over a period of time, then the company is not doing well
- If the gap between the EPS and the MPS is too wide, then the share is not regarded as being ok
Now the twist is this, according to the principle of mathematics, since PE = MPS divided by EPS , therefore, in order to get a high value for PE then EPS MUST be low (ie the denominator must be very low comared to the numerator before very high value could be gotten. For instance 10 divided by 5 will give you 2 while 10 divided by 2 will give u 5) What I'm driving at is that , I think there's a bit of contradiction because if we want the PE to be high (which indicates good performance), then I think the EPS has to be really lower compared to the MPS, and this again indicates wide margin between the EPS and MPS which in turn lead to non-performance. It's logical and seems contradictory ( my own thought ooo)if carefully followed. Please can you make clarifications on this logic? Another fresh question is this, will i be right to say that the share is Over valued if the earning per share is far lower than the market price . eg EPS = N1.20 and market price = N60 ? Then if the above statement is correct, what condition will trigger a share being UNDER VALUED ?I'm sorry for asking too much questions oooo
|
|
|
|
|
|
chbabs (m)
|
my reply goes to MT. first the 50k for instance is the nominal value as it is being called on the shares, while the other price is the say N17.80k is the Public offer quoted price, the price you normally see in the dailies are the current market price of those shares. the difference between the quoted public offer price and the current market price is like a profit to you as a buyer. is just like a seller bringing a goods to you offering you less of what is obtained in the market.
|
|
|
|
|
|
surugede
|
una dey try jare, more vasline to una fingers
my Question: if one buys share that was in "offer to the public" which process do he need to pass true in other to star enjoying the benefits of his share or at least know what is going on with his share
note i just bought the last Access bank share, i don't have a brooker, i don't know all these u call CSS or some thing
educate me please
|
|
|
|
|
|
walcolm (m)
|
una dey try jare, more vasline to una fingers
my Question: if one buys share that was in "offer to the public" which process do he need to pass true in other to star enjoying the benefits of his share or at least know what is going on with his share
note i just bought the last Access bank share, i don't have a brooker, i don't know all these u call CSS or some thing
educate me please
i will suggest you read this thread from the beginning and also go to the 'Business' section of the nairaland site and read through any thread that mentions STOCKS, SHARES, CSCS, STOCKBROKING, PUBLIC OFFER etc in the topic. you shld be able to pick up a lot of background info from answers to people who have asked the same questions in the past
|
|
|
|
|
|
ehie007 (m)
|
Hi guys, this is really a nice topic, must confess i learnt some things here.
Please this is to announce that Fidelity Bank Shares are still open at N8 per share. As you all know, we in Fidelity have individual targets, so i av my personalised offer form that i can send to your various emails addresses once u request for it.
IF you are interested in buying into Fidelity, please contact me through email (ehie007@yahoo.com) i will send you my personalised offer form. I can also be reached with 08030513655 or in my office (Fidelity Bank Plc 23 Awolowo Road Ikoyi) Dept: Business Process.
Awaiting your requests fellow nairalanders.
Thank you.
|
|
|
|
|
|
chbabs (m)
|
If u're a big guy with lots of dough, buying and holding stock should not be the best for u, let your money work for u, CSCS only help u to monitor your stocks, the trends and authenticity of u being the holder of the stock. if u want to enjoy returns on your stocks, get a reliable stock broker, contact him regulaly at least twice a week to let u know the downward or upward trends of the stocks u hold. there're some that move faster, within a short period makes u earns much when u sell them at that moment, before they start going down. I've been opportuned to enter into the floor of stock exchange during one of my researches then, it's such a lovely place to be, where u see big men, guys, women, e.t.c using phones to monitor stock prices from outside, ordering to sell or buy more stocks for them. note this is for big time biz. if u're just starting, maybe buy little, hold for a while and see what the future brings for u. good day guys 
|
|
|
|
|
|
fun4me2 (f)
|
[tr]@poster Thanks for the thread. Please does anyone in the house know if intercontinental bank has given out shares certificate for the last ipo which they did?.I bought some shares and have not receive certificte from them and i do know how to go about it because i don't bank with them.Any information about this will be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance to all Nairaland users To answer your question,I got my share certificate about 3 weeks ago 4m intercontinental and also my dividend warrant. So I can say YES its out. Thanks. Dis is a very educative thread, I am highly impressed.quodos to our one and only seun for putting up such a site like this. No place like nairaland joooooooo. otipoju 
|
|
|
|
|
|
profy2k4 (m)
|
i love this questions and answer page. for any one who want to start investing in equity shares investment. he/she must be focus and be active. for fidelity shares,it is good to buy because very soon, the bank will go for capital reconstruction and the current price will appreciate and soar high like that of bankphb. so if u ve money, go and buy.likewise japul oil maritime. it is also good to buy. get all this stock for your tommorrow. thanks. for futher information, call me on 08027411928 or mail me on jide_tosin2001@yahoo.com or if u are in abeokuta,u can get in touch with me in my office at suit 373 obalipede market at kuto abeokuta ogun state. the name of my company is priestfield webberlink international coy . am jide .just call the phone line for information,if u want to be investing. thanks
|
|
|
|
|
|
MT
|
@ Contributors,
Thanks for all your excellent contributions, most especially, ABOTT, BUTTYELELE, KINGZY, BABAIFE
However this is becoming challenging but there seems to be a logical twist to this.
I understand summarily from Buttyelele's post that :
- the MPS (Market Price ) is the relative bench mark to the EPS and PE
- IF the PE of a company is too low continuosly over a period of time, then the company is not doing well
- If the gap between the EPS and the MPS is too wide, then the share is not regarded as being ok
Now the twist is this, according to the principle of mathematics,
since PE = MPS divided by EPS , therefore, in order to get a high value for PE then EPS MUST be low (ie the denominator must be very low comared to the numerator before very high value could be gotten. For instance 10 divided by 5 will give you 2 while 10 divided by 2 will give u 5)
What I'm driving at is that , I think there's a bit of contradiction because if we want the PE to be high (which indicates good performance), then I think the EPS has to be really lower compared to the MPS, and this again indicates wide margin between the EPS and MPS which in turn lead to non-performance.
It's logical and seems contradictory ( my own thought ooo)if carefully followed. Please can you make clarifications on this logic?
Another fresh question is this,
will i be right to say that the share is Over valued if the earning per share is far lower than the market price . eg EPS = N1.20 and market price = N60 ?
Then if the above statement is correct, what condition will trigger a share being UNDER VALUED ?
I'm sorry for asking too much questions oooo
Please I still dey await response oooo
|
|
|
|
|
|
easimoni (m)
|
Please I still dey await response oooo
No single indicator is an absolute guide to the value of a share and quite frankly, the true value of a share IS IMPOSSIBLE TO DETERMINE. What we all try to do is predict the price in the future and buy if we believe it should go up and sell if vice versa. PE is a double edged sword. Let's consider you proposal. If EPS is 1.20 and price is 60, PE is 50. Most people would scream overvalued. What is the annual earnings growth rate is 400%? Next year the EPS will be 1.20 X 5 = 6 and the PE would have dropped to 10 (if the price held constant). Forward PE takes the growth factor into account and should be the basis of an investment decision. For the above example, current PE may be 60 but forward PE is 10. It's clearly cheap going forward. When the PE becomes too high relative to the growth rate and similar companies, the market tends to sell and the price will adjust downwards. So, we don't like high PEs (ever!) but a high PE could indicate that the company has a lot of potential and people are willing to pay extra to watch that potential become reality. You should consider a share undervalued when it meets your minimum investment criteria. For ME, a company is undervalued if: 1) the forward PE is less than 20. Last yr I used 10 but the market is more "expensive" now 2) the growth rate is >60%. Lots of high growth companies on the NSE. Why waste my money on a stagnant one? These 2 rules are for very quick screening. Of course, you MUST consider the issues affecting that industry, the quality of management, competition, profit margins, primary market activities etc. Ulimately, the market decides what value a company's share is worth. The game is forsee the info the market is mssing before it becomes obvious. That way you can make a buy/sell decsion before the market can respond.
|
|
|
|
|
|
MT
|
@Easimoni, PE is a double edged sword. Let's consider you proposal. If EPS is 1.20 and price is 60, PE is 50. Most people would scream overvalued. What is the annual earnings growth rate is 400%? Next year the EPS will be 1.20 X 5 = 6 and the PE would have dropped to 10 (if the price held constant). Forward PE takes the growth factor into account and should be the basis of an investment decision. For the above example, current PE may be 60 but forward PE is 10. It's clearly cheap going forward.
Thanks for your comments, but how did you calclutate the earning growth rate and the forward PE in the above example? Please you can use my previous example as an illustration PS:- We still await the other Gurus contributions , likes of Shigidi, frankriri etc 
|
|
|
|
|
|
easimoni (m)
|
@Easimoni, Thanks for your comments, but how did you calclutate the earning growth rate and the forward PE in the above example? Please you can use my previous example as an illustration PS:- We still await the other Gurus contributions , likes of Shigidi, frankriri etc  Earnings growth the the fine art of investing. If a company makes N100M in 2006 but makes N75M in the 1st quarter of 2007, do you consider the 75M as an aberration or a sign the company will make N300+M this year? If you choose the former and the 2,3 & 4Qs go back to normal, the company will make 75+25+25+25=150, if the latter, then you have a 200+% growth rate. If the company has 1B shares and is selling for N5ea, the current (trailing) EPS is 75M + the earnings over the last 3Qs of 2006 = 150M/1B shares = 15K. Current PE = N5/15k = 33 The forward EPS (if u believe the company will make N300M) is N300/1B = 30k, Forward PE becomes N5/30k = 16.7 THe difficulty is in predicting future earnings. No one can do it with a reasonable degree of success. Several companies have projected well and done poorly while others have projected poorly and released amazing results resulting in a stampede (been watching Costain?)
|
|
|
|
|
|
MT
|
@ easimoni,
That was an amazing job u did. Thanks for taking your time to explain vividly
@all
For those asking about intercontinental share certificate, I got mine today (but no dividend warrant o). I suggest you exercise a bit of patience . I learnt that they are doing it according to surname's alphabetical order.
Thanks
|
|
|
|
|
|
RoughCut (m)
|
Earnings growth the the fine art of investing. If a company makes N100M in 2006 but makes N75M in the 1st quarter of 2007, do you consider the 75M as an aberration or a sign the company will make N300+M this year? If you choose the former and the 2,3 & 4Qs go back to normal, the company will make 75+25+25+25=150, if the latter, then you have a 200+% growth rate.
If the company has 1B shares and is selling for N5ea, the current (trailing) EPS is 75M + the earnings over the last 3Qs of 2006 = 150M/1B shares = 15K. Current PE = N5/15k = 33
The forward EPS (if u believe the company will make N300M) is N300/1B = 30k, Forward PE becomes N5/30k = 16.7
THe difficulty is in predicting future earnings. No one can do it with a reasonable degree of success. Several companies have projected well and done poorly while others have projected poorly and released amazing results resulting in a stampede (been watching Costain?)
And don't forget as easimoni said there are other factors that affect share price movements that do not have anything to do with how well the company is doing(fundamentals). Some companies have mastered the art of manipulating share price i mean there are companies that have not declared or released any resûlts that we can look at in the last 3 years and their share prices are skyrocketing(market irrationality) but that should not be your basis for determining which stocks to invest in. Use the figures you can lay your hands on and financial reports and that way you have a fairly good idea how well a stock is performing. All these quantitive ratios give us an idea of how the stock is likely to behave at any given point in time(it does not mean that will be the case) so in summary there is no substitute for doing a bit of reasearch and that way you have the info you need before you make your investment decision Happy investing!
|
|
|
|
|
|
MT
|
@ Roughcut & easimoni, Thanks for your contributions. You 've enlightened some man here 
|
|
|
|
|
|
buttyelele
|
this is a rejoinder to our discussion on PE ratio, EPs,MPs etc. What i failed to tell u that will clear the air on PEratio before we all miss the mark is that PEratio is measured in years.
so go back to all i have said on the topic.
When u divide mps over eps, whatever u get is the PE ratio, which is known as a future indicator of the performance of the company. It is so because it tell u the number of years it takes a company to recoup their present investment if the earnings remains constant, hence if a coy has a PEratio of 1.4, it means it will take the coy 1.4 years to recoup its present investment.
so a coy with a peratio of 2 is better than a coy with a peratio of 5.therefore a coy is doing well if its PEratio is lower compared to another coy.
|
|
|
|
|
|
buttyelele
|
again mt, if i were to use your example of 60 and 1.2,if u divide u will get 50, it means it will take the coy 50 years to recoup its investment and that is not a good indicator. so your eps should be close to your mps, so that u derive a low value, u do not need a high peratio.
if i have confused in my previous post please take correction
|
|
|
|
|
|
sabastine
|
Please can someone help me out here?
I do not have a stock broker and I want to buy shares from public offer, just have very little amount. Now there is this stock broker that wants me to buy through his firm so that at long run when I must have bought large units, they can open an account with it for me. Please I want to know if its a good deal, I don't want to loose my little penny.
Thanks to all contributors.
|
|
|
|
|
|
MT
|
@buttyelele, Thanks for that rejoinder. Moreso, thanks for correcting that mistake in your previous posts. Everything is now crystal clear and I can now do some proper evaluations using PE, EPS & PAT on stock now. However, please always keep an eye on this thread as there could be some questions from other people that we can learn from. You have a great skill in teaching!  Thanks , you will always be remebered for good!.
|
|
|
|
|
|
ATTAHDYE (m)
|
web master go to www.cashcraft.comit is the most informative of all the sites I have visited
|
|
|
|
|
|
babaife (m)
|
@ all, I have never been so glad than i am now with the response am getting from this thread. i really appreciate the efforts of all posters to this thread as we are doing great jobs to ensure nigerians are more financially educated.
However, i need to make one or two clarification:
1. The relationship between the PE, EPS and MPS. i believe i do not need to define these terms any longer. but what implication, if the PE is HIGH or LOW?. an HIGH PE signifies that the company MPS is appreciating to the DELIGHT of SHORT TERM INVESTORS. it further shows that the MANAGEMENT is doing "GREATLY". Dont forget that the objective of every management decision is TO INCREASE SHAREHOLDERS WEALTH OR INVESTMENT VALUE. a low PE on the other hand means that the company management are deficient in certain areas. the implication of a low PE is that it could be "acquired" by a stronger comapany.
to illustrate my point, we all could remember the hostile romance of ACCESS BANK to AFRIBANK, because the former perceived the latter as being TOO WEAK AND INEFFECTIVELY MANAGED. that hostile romance WOKE UP the management of AFRIBANK and the result is available for all to see.
as an investor, it is advisable to look for company's with potential high PE else you may wait a bit longer to sell your shares. because management efficiency is measured by the PE of their company's, some management put UNDUE PRESSURE on the market price of their shares through a). Artificial scarcity b). propagada c). creative accounting d). hired speculators e). dividend payment from capital etc. the danger in all these is that soon or later, the price is expected to reflect the true PRICE but i doubt the Nigerian Stock Market.
|
|
|
|
|
|
angel123
|
please how do i open a cscs account.can i do it online.please help.
|
|
|
|
|
|
zz top
|
What's all this PE talk. Are we talking about the stock market or the gym.All that academic stuff doesn't mean much in the real world. What does Warren Buffet know about PE. Warren Buffet buy stocks that he have an understanding of (Coca Cola, Gillette etc). If you make some observation that a particular product or company is doing well, then investigate further,you may stumble upon information which has not yet reached the market.Buy the hell out of the stock. Soon or later the market will catch on.That's how you make money in the stock market. Due Diligence. Take banks for example. What products are they offering? Which bank product do you think is more attractive. When you've got the answer buy the hell of the stocks and the late comers will follow.
Remember the early bird catches the worm.If we are to believe the Efficient Market Hypothesis all that fundamental data (PE, market cap etc) is readily available and so there will be no opportunity to profit from any inefficiencies because everyone has got same the information. But of course with my method above you exploit the inefficiencies because the stock market is not in Ijebu Ode, or Shagamu and they don't see what I see, By the time the news reach Lagos or Abuja or wherever the stock market is, I would have already made my money and on to the next.
|
|
|
|
|
|
frankiriri (m)
|
What's all this PE talk. Are we talking about the stock market or the gym.All that academic stuff doesn't mean much in the real world. What does Warren Buffet know about PE. Warren Buffet buy stocks that he have an understanding of (Coca Cola, Gillette etc). If you make some observation that a particular product or company is doing well, then investigate further,you may stumble upon information which has not yet reached the market.Buy the hell out of the stock. Soon or later the market will catch on.That's how you make money in the stock market. Due Diligence. Take banks for example. What products are they offering? Which bank product do you think is more attractive. When you've got the answer buy the hell of the stocks and the late comers will follow.
Remember the early bird catches the worm.If we are to believe the Efficient Market Hypothesis all that fundamental data (PE, market cap etc) is readily available and so there will be no opportunity to profit from any inefficiencies because everyone has got same the information. But of course with my method above you exploit the inefficiencies because the stock market is not in Ijebu Ode, or Shagamu and they don't see what I see, By the time the news reach Lagos or Abuja or wherever the stock market is, I would have already made my money and on to the next.
Chairman, Warren Buffet knows a whole lot about PE. A Knowledge of these theories would enable you to take appropriate action.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Baby love (f)
|
 my fellow landers, I am a JJC in world of shares. I wanted to buy some so somebody advise me to first have a CSCS account, on getting to a stock broking firm I was told that one most have 300thousnd naira o shares worth that amount n I don't ve either. please advise me, thank you.
|
|
|
|
|
|