Yes, schools use them for diverse reasons and not only for someones race. Your high school can also be used as a factor when gaining admission into college( students from very competitive prep schools and public high schools compete for a limited number of spaces) My roommate at my university attended a highly prestigious public school(the best in america) and he got a perfect score in the SAT's but he wasn't special in his school because everyone there got very high SAT scores. So, he got rejected at Yale and Harvard.In fact in my chemistry class I was talking to a student from duke university who came to my school to take classes. He told me that duke would probably start using quotas for my roommates high school because 25 students from my roommates high school got into Duke's freshman class. Anyway I got very high sat scores but most people think I got in because of the color of my skin. However, I don't think AA should be stopped
I'm 99.9% sure quotas are illegal. It's true that being a URM or coming from a state like Alabama or Missisippi (depending on whatever region it is your applying to) might give you an edge or make you look better but if quotas were set, the percentages wouldn't flunctuate every year (do the same number of students from that high school get into that Uni. every year?) even worse, people would sue. and, nowadays guys are minorities in colleges and universities so if there were quotas the gender ratio will be 50/50 rather than the ~ 60/40 it is at now.
Many colleges check to see your High School profile (i think that's why they have the CEEB codes) they know if the school is competitive/rigorous or not. They even check to see the classes offered so they know if you took challenging ones or not. So if your SATs are high and your GPA or class rank is lower, they'll understand. So i'll assume your roommate got rejected for some other reason. maybe he didn't challenge himself enough w/ the classes he took. He had the opportunity of attending a prep school and they probably expected him to take those. SATs are only a small part of the addmision process (State, huge schools are exceptions) your school transcript mean the most.
Many students from my school get into Brown and some don't even end up going there so i don't think there are any quotas.
I used to want to go to Duke but i kind of prefer a small liberal arts school now so yeah. I don't care about name,
us news rankings and all that as long as i learn as much as i can and my future employers/ med school know about it, i'm fine.
there are so many good colleges so few people know about and i don't see why +25 people from the same school will want to attend one single college. of course Duke can't accept them all. lol
And about people thinking all black people got in because of Affirmative Action, you already said it yourself that most whites feel a sense of superiority so they probably assume all blacks are dumb anyway and even if Affirmative action is eliminated, they will still look for an excuse out of their close-mindedness.