RingimKabir:
My Best and Most Favourite Qur'anic Reciter Was, Is and Will Always Be:

MUHAMMAD SIDDIQ AL-MINSHAWI

apacheguy:


I thought u wanted having some debate because u are knowledgeable, i never knew you are a time waster and ignorant just as OKIN himself.

I will not argue or debate what disqualifies OKIN as a reciter, ( I'll only argue with someone of equal knowledge and not an ignorant person on the subject of discourse) rather i'll help your ignorance in the best way i can through some suggestions.

a) Seek knowledge, go and learn from qualified Scholars or Qualified Islamic Schools. Make it clear that you wish to learn Tajweed. Sincerely i don't know which Islamic school to recommend to you as most of the Islamic schools in SW are not qualified to teach Tajweed. ( Mind you am not saying all, but most. How i wish i can tell a short story).
With that you can independently pick out his wrong recitations.

b) Get someone who knows how to recite the Quran with Tajweed and he'll pick the faults in Okin's recitations without spending much time and efforts

c) Lastly, this is a lazy way out, if you've been to "ile kewu" and can read some arabic text correctly, pick any reciter and compare the recitation with Okin's recitation. You should be able to figure out some faults.

I would have loved to actually point out those faults to you myself but it can't be made over the internet, it can only be made one on one or if i should make a video of it.

On a more serious note, My brother, Our religion of Islam is based on adequate Knowledge and understanding which is not based on what we do our society or what is popular so that we can resolve all our life issues with Obedience to Allah and the Prophet (SAW).

balash:


I already saw your initial post it was an outright condemnation then u were quoted and you still continued. It's so unfair

apacheguy:

Brother this is not about opinion but knowledge, if someone is not qualified, there's no two ways about it, he's not qualified. There are many other indigenous Quran reciters who are good, i doubt if you know someone called Sarumi? He used to recite for Sheikh Abdulahi Salaty before his death, Sarumi is a million times better than Okin though he has some short comings as well. But his makharijal huruf is in order, and he follows basic Tajweed as much as i know. Just as i earlier said, Okin is no where near it, so please stop celebrating mediocrity. Can i shock you with something? The world acclaimed Abdulbasit Abdus Samad is usually not accorded the respect of a Qari by the scholars who specialize in Tajweed. What
would you say about that? Abdulbasit is recognised Quran reciter through out the world, his recitation earned him reputation, he's celebrated and had visited different countries in the course of his Quran recitation, he has the knowledge, his Makharijal huruf is sound and he follows tajweed, but due to his negligence of some aspects of tajweed in preference for the elongation he does, in some quarters he's not recognised as a sound reciter. And you are here arguing about Okin. Please go and seek knowledge of the Quran.

Abujabir24:

Some are already spewing the trash. I really don't understand what I wrong with non Muslims. You'll never see a Muslim posting in a Christianity thread except if the thread involves Islam which is when they'll do it intelligently. But in the contrary, non Muslims are always looking for trouble in Islamic threads.

Kbraims:
Brother datz her own choice u can deprive it from her...nd okin too is trying at least he compete among the best in africa

NOETHNICITY:
pls if I send u my number cud u wassap to me any. Of his recitation?

Empiree:
www.assabile.com

NOETHNICITY:
thanks brother, but it refuses to download! It jus continues to redirect me to other sites!

yusufbida:


Broda it seems you don't understand the topic being discuss....

The topic is simply

Who is ur best reciter?

Whether Okin knows Tajweed or not d Broda said his best reciter is Okin dat s All

Deris difference btw our,your and mine.

carinmom:

Yes he is fast,that's why sometimes i prefer Shuraym. But if i want to listen to tartil, then Khusary or Minshawy are my favourites.

apacheguy:


Y are u people so obsessed with the issue of OKIN not qualifying as a reciter? Do u really understand what Quran recitation actually means? It involves alots of things which the least is correct pronunciation of the huruf. The prophet (SAW) said people will be reciting the Quran and the Quran will be cursing them, this happens because they recite it wrongly thereby changing its meaning. Do u call such a person reciter of the Quran? OKIN recites the Quran with wrong pronunciation of the ahruf of the words and by so doing changes the message of Allah. This issue is a very serious issue in islam. Quranic words are not to be joked with but accorded with reverence and seriousness. Its Allah's words, The creator. So the issue of ur favourite or mine doesn't occur so far the person in question doesn't qualify.

Empiree:
Slight Resemblance Sheikh Sudais Recitation

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bAl2Qq8HLwU

apacheguy:


I thought u wanted having some debate because u are knowledgeable, i never knew you are a time waster and ignorant just as OKIN himself.

I will not argue or debate what disqualifies OKIN as a reciter, ( I'll only argue with someone of equal knowledge and not an ignorant person on the subject of discourse) rather i'll help your ignorance in the best way i can through some suggestions.

a) Seek knowledge, go and learn from qualified Scholars or Qualified Islamic Schools. Make it clear that you wish to learn Tajweed. Sincerely i don't know which Islamic school to recommend to you as most of the Islamic schools in SW are not qualified to teach Tajweed. ( Mind you am not saying all, but most. How i wish i can tell a short story).
With that you can independently pick out his wrong recitations.

b) Get someone who knows how to recite the Quran with Tajweed and he'll pick the faults in Okin's recitations without spending much time and efforts

c) Lastly, this is a lazy way out, if you've been to "ile kewu" and can read some arabic text correctly, pick any reciter and compare the recitation with Okin's recitation. You should be able to figure out some faults.

I would have loved to actually point out those faults to you myself but it can't be made over the internet, it can only be made one on one or if i should make a video of it.

On a more serious note, My brother, Our religion of Islam is based on adequate Knowledge and understanding which is not based on what we do our society or what is popular so that we can resolve all our life issues with Obedience to Allah and the Prophet (SAW).

Kwatisco:
sheikh khalil khusarey

apacheguy:


I thought u wanted having some debate because u are knowledgeable, i never knew you are a time waster and ignorant just as OKIN himself.

I will not argue or debate what disqualifies OKIN as a reciter, ( I'll only argue with someone of equal knowledge and not an ignorant person on the subject of discourse) rather i'll help your ignorance in the best way i can through some suggestions.

a) Seek knowledge, go and learn from qualified Scholars or Qualified Islamic Schools. Make it clear that you wish to learn Tajweed. Sincerely i don't know which Islamic school to recommend to you as most of the Islamic schools in SW are not qualified to teach Tajweed. ( Mind you am not saying all, but most. How i wish i can tell a short story).
With that you can independently pick out his wrong recitations.

b) Get someone who knows how to recite the Quran with Tajweed and he'll pick the faults in Okin's recitations without spending much time and efforts

c) Lastly, this is a lazy way out, if you've been to "ile kewu" and can read some arabic text correctly, pick any reciter and compare the recitation with Okin's recitation. You should be able to figure out some faults.

I would have loved to actually point out those faults to you myself but it can't be made over the internet, it can only be made one on one or if i should make a video of it.

On a more serious note, My brother, Our religion of Islam is based on adequate Knowledge and understanding which is not based on what we do our society or what is popular so that we can resolve all our life issues with Obedience to Allah and the Prophet (SAW).

Empiree:
Juma'h Juice

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MwPWQR05_YA