Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,148,602 members, 7,801,742 topics. Date: Thursday, 18 April 2024 at 09:44 PM

FRSC ‘can No Longer’ Impose Fines, Court Rules - Car Talk - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Car Talk / FRSC ‘can No Longer’ Impose Fines, Court Rules (1349 Views)

9 Steps For Payment Of Fines By Traffic Violators – FRSC / LASTMA Traffic Fines Lists / Lagos To Impose New Taxi Rules To Clamp Down On Services Like Uber (2) (3) (4)

(1) (Reply) (Go Down)

FRSC ‘can No Longer’ Impose Fines, Court Rules by FlyboyZee: 5:13pm On Apr 18, 2016
This is for your information and necessary action...


A federal high court in Lagos has declared void powers of the Federal Road Safety Corps (FRSC) to impose fines on motorists for traffic offences.

John Tsoho, a judge, held that the commission could not turn itself into a court of law by punishing those who commit traffic offences.

Tope Alabi, a lawyer, had approached the court to declare that only a court of competent jurisdiction could pronounce a person guilty under section 10 (4) and 28 (2) of the FRSC Act 2007.

Other defendant in the suit was the attorney-general of the federation.

The judge also awarded N1million damages in favour of the plaintiff because officials of the FRSC had confiscated his vehicle and driver’s licence.

Tosho said while FRSC was statutorily empowered to arrest and fine traffic offenders, a closer look at the definition of the word “fine” meant a pecuniary criminal punishment or civil penalty payable to the public treasury.

“In the instant case, however, the involvement of the element of arrest takes the imposition of fine by the FRSC to the realm of criminal punishment,” he said.

“From these definitions, it is obvious that the act of sentencing is a judicial action or exercise, and imposition of fine connotes conviction for an alleged offence.

“It is, thus, very clear that the FRSC, not being a court of law, cannot impose fine, especially as it has no powers to conduct trial.

“Hence, the exercise of the statutory powers given to the defendant under the Act as pertain to imposition of fine is clearly a usurpation of judicial powers exclusively vested in the courts.

“In the circumstances, I endorse the plaintiff’s submission that by virtue of section 1(3) of the constitution, the power to impose fine conferred on FRSC by the enabling act is null and void to the extent of its inconsistency with the constitution.”

Tsoho held that the FRSC resorted to “legislative absurdity” when it imposed a fine of 3,000 on the plaintiff, rather than the N2,000 statutorily prescribed.

“FRSC’s function should not go beyond issuance of mere notices of offence,” he ruled.

“It is a cardinal principle of natural justice that no person can be condemned without being heard.

“It is in observance of this that a person alleged to have committed an offence has to respond to such allegation before a court of law during trial.”

According to the judge, the plaintiff was issued a notice of offence Sheet on April 4, 2013, but FRSC did not take him to court for five months before the plaintiff filed his suit on September 9, 2013.

“The vital question to ask is how long would it take the FRSC to reasonably commence prosecution of a traffic offence?” he asked.

“The plaintiff was not under obligation to wait indefinitely for redress due to FRSC’s inaction or laxity.

“I hold the view that the confiscation of the vehicle was unnecessary in the first place, though the FRSC spiritedly sought to justify it.”

The judge then granted 11 of the 14 reliefs sought by the plaintiff, awarding N1million in his favour instead of the N10 million prayed for.

http://spynigeria.com/2016/04/in-case-you-missed-this-frsc-can-no-longer-impose-fines-court-rules/
Re: FRSC ‘can No Longer’ Impose Fines, Court Rules by sofiabelgrade(f): 5:48pm On Apr 18, 2016
Walahi, this long overdue.
Re: FRSC ‘can No Longer’ Impose Fines, Court Rules by Ferdinandu(m): 5:54pm On Apr 18, 2016
Chai What of VIO. Those guys are Rogues
Re: FRSC ‘can No Longer’ Impose Fines, Court Rules by princemillla(m): 6:07pm On Apr 18, 2016
I swear this sweet my belly.
Someone need to treat Vio Bleep up soon also

3 Likes

Re: FRSC ‘can No Longer’ Impose Fines, Court Rules by royallord1(m): 9:47pm On Apr 18, 2016
make sense
Re: FRSC ‘can No Longer’ Impose Fines, Court Rules by GAZZUZZ(m): 11:02pm On Apr 18, 2016
but nothing stops them from impounding vehicles. Better to pay the fine o!
Re: FRSC ‘can No Longer’ Impose Fines, Court Rules by kingreign(m): 11:30pm On Apr 18, 2016
GAZZUZZ:
but nothing stops them from impounding vehicles. Better to pay the fine o!

I'm telling you bro. Mehn! embarassed
Re: FRSC ‘can No Longer’ Impose Fines, Court Rules by Specialist900(m): 10:07am On Apr 19, 2016
Good move. Waiting for who will take VIO to court too
Re: FRSC ‘can No Longer’ Impose Fines, Court Rules by Nobody: 7:13am On Apr 22, 2016
Can't thisbbe moved to the frontpage?


I like the fact that the plaintiff stood up for himself by suing their ass. Block-headed fools. He must have refused to bribe them.

That's how one idiot chased me with a bike by 10pm saying I ran a red light. Told him it was on yellow when I passed the light, they'd have none of it. Kept on and on. Long story short... I was allowed to go after speaking grammar grin

One million just like that cool
Re: FRSC ‘can No Longer’ Impose Fines, Court Rules by Nobody: 8:47am On Apr 22, 2016
All these unnecessary rumours angry

Which website is spynigeria?

Bloggers angry

(1) (Reply)

How I Was / How Much Can I Get A Tokunbo VW GOLF3? / HELP: Ford Galaxy 2004 Veva 2.3

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 14
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.