To those that have used them all have experience on the subject between Quanta and Monbat which is better?
Note : Quanta is Indian while Monbat is European product.
Thanks.

Bump!

I'm currently using quanta batteries 48v
For six years running!
Although the backup time has dropped.
I can't say of the present quality?
I wanna replace mine even with tubular this time...

ifnyioj22:
I'm currently using quanta batteries 48v
For six years running!
Although the backup time has dropped.
I can't say of the present quality?
I wanna replace mine even with tubular this time...

Thanks for the review. Please which brand of tubular battery do you want to replace them with?

Ournolly:

Thanks for the review. Please which brand of tubular battery do you want to replace them with?

sukam

ifnyioj22:
sukam

OK.
Sukam is a Chinese product, nothing special.

Amaron quanta still the best.

abidemidare:
Amaron quanta still the best.

Thanks for the info.

I have been trying to get the comparison and know the best but I couldn't get any.

darelar:
I have been trying to get the comparison and know the best but I couldn't get any.

After a few advice from dealers, I settled with Monbat.
A bit costly but working fine.
Can only review after using them more than 2 years.

Ournolly:

After a few advice from dealers, I settled with Monbat.
A bit costly but working fine.
Cna only review after using them more than 2 years.

Please where did you get the battery and how much?

datola:


Please where did you get the battery and how much?

Here at Onitsha.
The man imported it and I was on the waiting list so I got them first.

Bought both @290k, 145k each.

Ournolly:

Here at Onitsha.
The man imported it and I was on the waiting list so I got them first.

Bought both @290k, 145k each.

That's good.

Thanks!

Ournolly:

After a few advice from dealers, I settled with Monbat.
A bit costly but working fine.
Can only review after using them more than 2 years.

Thanks

Ournolly:
After a few advice from dealers, I settled with Monbat. A bit costly but working fine. Can only review after using them more than 2 years.

how are the batteries performing presently sir?

olatade:



how are the batteries performing presently sir?

Superb! No Issue at all.
Monbat should be the best battery though very expensive.

Please which is the best between Mombat vs 200ah Amaron quanta vs 220ah Luminous Tubular battery...please I need your expert advice.

Ournolly:

Superb! No Issue at all.
Monbat should be the best battery though very expensive.

Please do you have a WhatsApp contact? I’ll need your advice please

trustedward:

Please do you have a WhatsApp contact? I’ll need your advice please

Please be free to ask the question here.

trustedward:
Please which is the best between Mombat vs 200ah Amaron quanta vs 220ah Luminous Tubular battery...please I need your expert advice.

Monbat is better than Quanta but more expensive.
I did thorough research before purchasing it.
Most atm points use monbat.

Tubular battery is not maintenance free so it is entirely different from the above 2.

I will advice you to go for monbat if you can afford it but make sure you are buying brand new battery. That's what I did.

As for Tubular, I heard it's OK too but you should bear in mind the periodic change of the fluid.

Thanks.

Ournolly:

Monbat is better than Quanta but more expensive.
I did thorough research before purchasing it.
Most atm points use monbat.

Tubular battery is not maintenance free so it is entirely different from the above 2.

I will advice you to go for monbat if you can afford it but make sure you are buying brand new battery. That's what I did.

As for Tubular, I heard it's OK too but you should bear in mind the periodic change of the fluid.

Thanks.

thanks a lot for your response, I heard the maintenance is done once in 6 months and it involves refilling it with distill water, the maintenance shouldn’t be a problem for me as far it gives me good value for money, but if your preference wasn’t based on the continua maintenance associated with tubular batteries then I’ll go with the Monbat.

trustedward:
thanks a lot for your response, I heard the maintenance is done once in 6 months and it involves refilling it with distill water, the maintenance shouldn’t be a problem for me as far it gives me good value for money, but if your preference wasn’t based on the continua maintenance associated with tubular batteries then I’ll go with the Monbat.

Yeah, if you don't mind the maintenance you can go with tubular batteries.
Tubular is not that expensive for a start.

Ournolly:

Yeah, if you don't mind the maintenance you can go with tubular batteries.
Tubular is not that expensive for a start.

the cost isn’t a problem, just want the best... :

trustedward:
the cost isn’t a problem, just want the best... :

tubular batteries require more panels for effective charging. If u r using 0.45kwp to charge a 200ah normal flat plate batteries tubular will require like 0.6kwp under the same time duration.

trustedward:
the cost isn’t a problem, just want the best... :

To me Monbat is the best, with more lifespan.

I am not a solar and battery dealer, just voicing my opinion based on personal experience.

tetralogyfallot:
tubular batteries require more panels for effective charging. If u r using 0.45kwp to charge a 200ah normal flat plate batteries tubular will require like 0.6kwp under the same time duration.

wow I never knew, thanks for the valuable info, please in terms of life spam and ability to hold charge, which would you recommend?

Ournolly:

To me Monbat is the best, with more lifespan.

I am not a solar and battery dealer, just voicing my opinion based on personal experience.

thanks bro, I appreciate

trustedward:
wow I never knew, thanks for the valuable info, please in terms of life spam and ability to hold charge, which would you recommend?

I think Tubular should have slightly better DOD than dey cell batteries (minus lithium ion batteries of course).

Dey cells are mostly 50% DOD while Tubular can comfortably hit 70% DOD.

Lithium ion batteries like are on the next level tho.

Ournolly:


I think Tubular should have slightly better DOD than dey cell batteries (minus lithium ion batteries of course).

Dey cells are mostly 50% DOD while Tubular can comfortably hit 70% DOD.

Lithium ion batteries like are on the next level tho.

thanks boss, heard the lifespan of Monbat is 10-12 years, that literally blew me away..based on your recommendation, I think I’ll have to go with Monbat, please can you hook me up with your seller?