Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,215,068 members, 8,024,336 topics. Date: Monday, 09 December 2024 at 09:00 AM

JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 - Religion (2) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 (10493 Views)

Part 3: JW PIMO Reconsiders Trinity Doctrine / Part 2: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine / The Trinity Doctrine Is a False doctrine and it is Unbiblical. (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) ... (33) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Janosky: 9:41pm On Aug 16
Kingsempires:
Go and ask God that question
Petalss:

You could have just told me where the third person will be. Do you know?
Where the 3rd person will be,Your 3 deities refused to release that expo

3 spirits in one being & no Trinitarian knows where the 3rd person stays.

You guys are clowns.

Man made invention of Nicene removed una sense.

grin grin grin grin

2 Likes

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Kingsempires(m): 9:48pm On Aug 16
Janosky:

Where the 3rd person will be,Your 3 deities refused to release that expo

3 spirits in one being & no Trinitarian knows where the 3rd person stays.

You guys are clowns.

Man made invention of Nicene removed una sense.

grin grin grin grin
Guy I no understand you ooo
Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Kingsempires(m): 9:48pm On Aug 16
Petalss:

Apology accepted.
thanks grin
Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Janosky: 9:51pm On Aug 16
Sand2022:
As a JW, one teaching I was opposed to was the trinitarian doctrine. I cannot see how Jesus can be God. I feel they are distinct persons and that Jehovah is the only God. That only Jehovah should be worshipped. When I became a JW, I was further told the meaning of Trinity, and I came to have more hatred for the doctrine. From what the witnesses taught me, I told myself that I didn't even believe this trinity even while I was in the church. Three persons in one God is contradictory to me.

I knew the proves the witnesses have against Trinity. As an elder I taught this from the platform then. But recently, I revisited that doctrine. This time through a personal scriptural analysis to see what the Bible has to say. But before I tell you what I found out scripturally, let us first look at the meaning of Trinity which for many years I never knew.

I found out that Trinity doesn't mean three persons inside one God. Rather three persons that has one Nature. The nature aspect is what I had missed for many years. I never understood it that way before.

Their are three persons, but they have one nature. From what I understand, when we think about God, we mean the creator of heaven and earth, MOST importantly, when we think of God, we mean our Deity. Now what trinitarians are saying is that there are more than one persons who match that description, but all of them possess the same features we have in mind when we say God. In other words they have the same Nature, but they are not one person.



Let's say it another way. When you say Human. You obviously know that the feature of humankind is not possessed by just one person. There are many, but they all have the same human features. So when you think about God, you are thinking about a nature. In that nature are three persons that possess it.

This is a huge game changer in my Trinity journey. You may have noticed that I have avoided Trinity subject in this board. This is deliberate. Prior to this time, I never believed that doctrine. And for some time, I delved into it, and started to see things differently. My approach to this subject might be different from what you have ever heard before on this subject because I did my study, and i also tried to view the subject from a JW perspective and saw that even from JW teaching, you cant run away from this one nature shared by the three, especially the two, father and Son.

In my part 2 of this trinity series, We will start from John 1:1. Let's trace Jesus origin once more. Check in next week Thursday.


Jesus Christ resident in heaven & later born on earth as a Jew ,he (Jesus) has proven that Sand2022 you are deceiving yourself.

John 5:44 & Deuteronomy 6:4.

Jehovah our God is one Jehovah, not 3 equal deities sharing same nature.


Sheep wey done lost no dey listen to his master's voice.

2 Likes

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Janosky: 9:56pm On Aug 16
Kingsempires:
Guy I no understand you ooo

Where will the 3rd person be?

This simple question choke Trinitarians.


grin

1 Like

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Janosky: 10:02pm On Aug 16
Steep:
you are right God is a nature or a being who exist in three individuals. In other words the same God who is the Father is the same God who is the Son but a different person and the same God who is the Holy Spirit who is a different person from the Father and Son.


You worship 3 deities invented at Nicene.

Deuteronomy 6:4 & John 5:44 is not in your heart.

Una just dey deceive yourselves.

2 Likes 1 Share

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Petalss(m): 10:04pm On Aug 16
Kingsempires:
thanks grin
You're welcome brother
Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Petalss(m): 10:10pm On Aug 16
Janosky:

Where the 3rd person will be,Your 3 deities refused to release that expo

3 spirits in one being & no Trinitarian knows where the 3rd person stays.

You guys are clowns.

Man made invention of Nicene removed una sense.

grin grin grin grin
It is just unfair to the third person, 3 in 1 buh only 2 have a throne to sit on.

1 Like

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Janosky: 10:25pm On Aug 16
Courz:


Nice one Sand2022. As a former JW myself, when I woke up, I decided to read the Bible for myself without the JW interpretation. I made sure to dump the New World Translation Bible of JW and read different Bible versions. I also used to think the Trinity doctrine was foolish and made no sense as a JW. But when I read the Bible for myself, I saw instances where Jesus is called God. I also noticed that Almighty God, Jesus and the Holy Spirit always act together. They are separate of course but whenever one does something, it is the 3 of them doing it. This was what I kept seeing in the Bible.

For example, in the Bible, it is said God raised Jesus from the dead. It is also said Jesus told the Jews Destroy this temple and in 3 days , I will raise it up again. The temple is his body. Meaning, Jesus raised his body back to life. Then in another verse, it says the Holy Spirit dwelling in us is the same Spirit that brought Jesus back to life. See? This is God, Jesus and the Holy Spirit acting together. They are truly One even though separate.

I don't know if you have watched Near Death Experiences. There are testimonies of Christians who went to heaven when they died. I have one testimony of a very young boy although it isn't a Near Death Experience. It is an experience of seeing heaven made possible by Jesus himself. This boy should be 7 or 8 years old. The boy was narrating his vision of heaven to his parents. He said he saw Jesus and saw God as described in the Bible but he couldn't see God's face as that's not possible. He said he noticed that God and Jesus would merge together to be one and at some point would separate. I found this interesting because it lines up with what Jesus said: I am in the Father and the Father is in Me. It also lines up with the verse that says Jesus is the exact representation of his Father in Divinity. Also, the same Bible says The Holy Spirit dwells in us once we accept Jesus. It also says Jesus dwells in us. It then says our body is the temple of God. The three always act in Unison. This is the only way to explain The Trinity doctrine that aligns with the Bible.

.

John 17:21
I pray that they will all be one, just as you and I are one—as you are in me, Father, and I am in you. And may they be in US
so that the world will believe you sent me

Jesus talk say:
'the disciples are one just as you (the Father) and I (Jesus) are one"

Jesus still talk say:
You are in me &I am in you. May they (disciples) be in US"

Nutshell:
The disciples are one with God & Jesus.

Jesus no mention holy spirit in John 10:30 & John 17:21!

Why?


Because Trinity nah man made invention.

1 Like

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Janosky: 10:29pm On Aug 16
Petalss:

It is just unfair to the third person, 3 in 1 buh only 2 have a throne to sit on.

This same folks will say their 3 deities are equal.
Make Dem dey deceive themselves.
grin grin grin

2 Likes

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Janosky: 10:38pm On Aug 16
FxMasterz:


Wow! I'm so edified.
Courz:


I don't believe the Holy Spirit is God though that should be worshipped since the Bible never said so. But these verses have made me to realise that Jesus is more than a messenger. He is so much more. He is Mighty God as he created everything. Almighty God is also God and our creator. The same Holy Spirit was in action during creation. God, Jesus and the Holy Spirit are truly One
.

Courz post
" I don't believe the Holy Spirit is God though that should be worshipped since the Bible never said so"


FX Masterz is "so edified" that Courz refused to worship him 3rd person deities.


All of una,all Trinitarians are confused by the 3rd ghost giving una conflicting contradictory revelations.
grin grin grin grin

2 Likes

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by MightySparrow: 10:50pm On Aug 16
Sand2022:
As a JW, one teaching I was opposed to was the trinitarian doctrine. I cannot see how Jesus can be God. I feel they are distinct persons and that Jehovah is the only God. That only Jehovah should be worshipped. When I became a JW, I was further told the meaning of Trinity, and I came to have more hatred for the doctrine. From what the witnesses taught me, I told myself that I didn't even believe this trinity even while I was in the church. Three persons in one God is contradictory to me.

I knew the proves the witnesses have against Trinity. As an elder I taught this from the platform then. But recently, I revisited that doctrine. This time through a personal scriptural analysis to see what the Bible has to say. But before I tell you what I found out scripturally, let us first look at the meaning of Trinity which for many years I never knew.

I found out that Trinity doesn't mean three persons inside one God. Rather three persons that has one Nature. The nature aspect is what I had missed for many years. I never understood it that way before.

Their are three persons, but they have one nature. From what I understand, when we think about God, we mean the creator of heaven and earth, MOST importantly, when we think of God, we mean our Deity. Now what trinitarians are saying is that there are more than one persons who match that description, but all of them possess the same features we have in mind when we say God. In other words they have the same Nature, but they are not one person.


Let's say it another way. When you say Human. You obviously know that the feature of humankind is not possessed by just one person. There are many, but they all have the same human features. So when you think about God, you are thinking about a nature. In that nature are three persons that possess it.

This is a huge game changer in my Trinity journey. You may have noticed that I have avoided Trinity subject in this board. This is deliberate. Prior to this time, I never believed that doctrine. And for some time, I delved into it, and started to see things differently. My approach to this subject might be different from what you have ever heard before on this subject because I did my study, and i also tried to view the subject from a JW perspective and saw that even from JW teaching, you cant run away from this one nature shared by the three, especially the two, father and Son.

In my part 2 of this trinity series, We will start from John 1:1. Let's trace Jesus origin once more. Check in next week Thursday.


..
I have had discussions with some JWs myself and discovered that what they understand by Trinity is sometimes modalism. Their claims, apart from, scriptural harassment are not correct.

1 Like

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Janosky: 10:52pm On Aug 16
MightySparrow:

..
I have had discussions with some JWs myself and discovered that what they understand by Trinity is sometimes modalism. Their claims, apart from, scriptural harassment are not correct.


Is Jesus Christ a Trinitarian?

Modalism was invented by your fellow Trinitarians

The heresy of modalism has been around since the third century AD. Proposed by bishop Sabellius, this doctrine asserts that God exists as one Person who shifts between three faces: one for the Father, one for the Son, and one for the Holy Spirit.21 Mar 2023
https://www.christianity.com › wiki
What Is the Heresy of Modalism? - Christianity.com



Oga, continue WAILING and deceiving yourself.

2 Likes

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Courz: 11:01pm On Aug 16
Janosky:



Courz post
" I don't believe the Holy Spirit is God though that should be worshipped since the Bible never said so"


FX Masterz is "so edified" that Courz refused to worship him 3rd person deities.


All of una,all Trinitarians are confused by the 3rd ghost giving una conflicting contradictory revelations.
grin grin grin grin



Scattered brain Janosky with your Maggot infested Brain, do you even know what we are discussing? Mumu. Go and argue with Almighty God who testified that Jesus is indeed God. Go and argue with him. Your foolish Governing body saw that God called Jesus God and went to twist the Bible verse to confuse gullible idiots like you. You need to dump that your Satanic Bible that is filled with manipulation of Bible verses. You JWs are cursed. Demons are following you everywhere you go. That's why you keep getting rejected.
Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Courz: 11:17pm On Aug 16
Janosky:




Because Trinity nah man made invention.

Mumu. Why do you baptise people in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit?
Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Kingsempires(m): 11:27pm On Aug 16
Courz:


Mumu. Why do you baptise people in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit?
am also asking that question

1 Like

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Courz: 11:35pm On Aug 16
Kingsempires:
am also asking that question

Gbam. Mumu Janosky will either run away or start typing his usual gibberish after smoking Igbo. Jehovah's witnesses love to trash Trinity. They can argue rubbish but their foolish Governing body never tells them that their baptism is actually the Trinity in action. Your life as a Christian is the Trinity in action. Even we as Created beings came about because of the Trinity. I don't blame them. Dem no dey teach them anything for that Kingdom hall. Na only Watchtower dem dey read. Dem no dey read Bible . They only read Bible verses they have twisted and manipulated by their foolish Governing body. There is a Bible verse where Almighty God called Jesus GOD and they went to change it to deceive themselves.
Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by MightySparrow: 11:47pm On Aug 16
Janosky:


Is Jesus Christ a Trinitarian?

Modalism was invented by your fellow Trinitarians

The heresy of modalism has been around since the third century AD. Proposed by bishop Sabellius, this doctrine asserts that God exists as one Person who shifts between three faces: one for the Father, one for the Son, and one for the Holy Spirit.21 Mar 2023
https://www.christianity.com › wiki
What Is the Heresy of Modalism? - Christianity.com



Oga, continue WAILING and deceiving yourself.

This topic is brought up by your fellow hall goer. Why not face him?
Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Janosky: 11:48pm On Aug 16
Courz:


Mumu. Why do you baptise people in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit?

I challenge you to use your own Bible and show this forum:
Which believer was baptized according to that verse "baptise people in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit?"

Oga, mention that believer or get outta here with your IBERIBEISM.


grin

1 Like

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Courz: 11:49pm On Aug 16
Janosky:


I challenge you to use your own Bible and show this forum:
Which believer was baptized according to that verse "baptise people in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit?"

Oga, mention that believer or get outta here with your IBERIBEISM.


grin

Mumu. Why do you baptise people in the Name of the Father, and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit?
Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Janosky: 11:53pm On Aug 16
Kingsempires:
am also asking that question
Nobody,no believer in the entire Bible from Genesis to Revelation was baptized with that formula.

Many Bible scholars doubt the authenticity of that verse.

1 Like

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Janosky: 11:54pm On Aug 16
Courz:


Mumu. Why do you baptise people in the Name of the Father, and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit?


Courz WAILING WAILER, grin grin
Oga ,Show evidence from your Bible and tell us the name of the believer baptized with that formula.

1 Like

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Courz: 11:55pm On Aug 16
Janosky:



Courz WAILING WAILER, grin grin
Oga ,Show evidence from your Bible and tell us the name of the believer baptized with that formula.




See your Bible from JW org. What Is it saying there? What Is the Trinity doing there?

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Courz: 11:57pm On Aug 16
Mumu Janosky, what is this below in your own Bible?

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Janosky: 11:59pm On Aug 16
MightySparrow:


This topic is brought up by your fellow hall goer. Why not face him?

Iscariot was physically in & mentally out & you know how he ended up.

Job 38:1-7, Jehovah God has explained to Job what he did at Genesis 1:26-27.

Please embrace the holy scriptures or cling tight to your Trinitarian delusion debunked by Yahweh.

grin

1 Like

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Janosky: 12:00am On Aug 17
Courz:



See your Bible from JW org. What Is it saying there? What Is the Trinity doing there?

Courz WAILING IBERIBEISM.

In your own Bible which believer was baptized with that formula?
Name that person or continue WAILING your IBERIBEISM.


grin grin grin grin

1 Like

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Courz: 12:02am On Aug 17
Janosky:


Courz WAILING IBERIBEISM.

grin grin grin grin

What Is the Trinity that you hate so much doing in your own Bible?

1 Like

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Courz: 12:03am On Aug 17
Mumu Janosky, are you saying that you are against the formula written in your own Bible? Are you against the command of Jesus in that verse?

1 Like

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Janosky: 12:07am On Aug 17
Courz:


What Is the Trinity that you hate so much doing in your own Bible?

Which verse in your Bible is the word 'trinity' found?

Waa za gha !!!!!

1 Like

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Courz: 12:14am On Aug 17
Janosky:


Which verse in your Bible is the word 'trinity' found?

Waa za gha !!!!!

Why did Jesus ask us to baptise in the name of the father and of the son and of the Holy Spirit? You disagree with this formula, meaning you disagree with Jesus command. Yes or no?
Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by Courz: 12:27am On Aug 17
Janosky:


Which verse in your Bible is the word 'trinity' found?

Waa za gha !!!!!

Look at the first bible verse in each screenshot below. Is that not Trinity in action? Why are you against these Bible verses? Why are you against the command by Jesus regarding baptism?

1 Like

Re: JW PIMO Reconsiders The Trinity Doctrine. Part 1 by GoodJohn: 2:07am On Aug 17
The analysis is concise

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) ... (33) (Reply)

I'm A Christian And I Smoke Herbs / Thought Provoking Questions For Atheist. / Can Gospel Music Substitute Praying In The Morning??

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 108
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.