Bonetoy's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Bonetoy's Profile › Bonetoy's Posts
1 2 (of 2 pages)
Weah96:This is putting limitations on God. You are claiming that it has to be one way or another or he doesn't exist (he is limited to one outcome). Omnipotent means not having any limitations.This is not a paradox. Weah96:What frustration? I have not lost my temper in any of my posts. I have been arguing with respect toward every one. In all honesty I am doing this because it relaxes me. I have free time at work so I hop on and research, type, research, type, research, and type. If people get upset reading things that are contrary to their belief they should avoid reading them. Again, nothing I have typed proves that God exists. All I have done is disprove claims that state God does not exist. |
davien:Notice your first sentence contradicts the end of your last sentence. You quote how it had nothing to do with the takeover of the human population, then you quote that her dna was superior in taking over the world. Yes scientists argue the findings from this study, just like other scientist argue the findings of the fossil studies. Bold statement - not being interbred, so her offspring repopulated the world through inbreeding. davien:You admit that I left that part out. This is your own evidence. "these effects (defects) are mainly due to an increase in the frequency of homozygous genotypes at the expense of heterzygotes, which is caused by inbreeding." The increase of the frequency is caused by inbreeding. Not the defect. |
davien:http://www.mhrc.net/mitochondrialEve.htm "Many suggest that Eve must have had some vast superiority because her offspring are thought to have conquered the whole world without any evidence of any interbreeding." The name Eve is not used to describe the Biblical Eve, but Mitochondrial Eve. davien:A quote from your own link. "The incidence of metabolic disorders, structural abnormalities and inherited disease conditions, caused by harmful recessive genes, increases following inbreeding." Caused by harmful recessive genes INCREASES following inbreeding. Inbreeding does not cause the defects. This is what I have been arguing this whole time. Yet you still want to claim it does. It's obvious that no amount of evidence I present you will be sufficient. So I will leave it at this. You can choose to believe what you want to believe that is your choice. But trying to force people to believe what you believe by twisting evidence in your favor is wrong for either side to do. Everything that I have posted only leads up to the conclusion that you cannot prove or disprove the existence of God. I will force no one to follow my beliefs. I just think that every one should have facts that are not doctored to come to their own conclusions. |
davien:Read your statement here, she isn't the first woman, she is the first female... davien:Not once did I ever state that mitochondrial eve was biblical eve. If you even read my post you would notice that I removed the Holy Bible from that evidence all together. And again, I didn't say that inbreeding didn't lead to birth defects or sterilization, I said it doesn't cause them. But obviously you didn't read my post thoroughly. davien:You try to discredit my posts through insults and derogatory remarks. Where is your credibility? |
LordBabs:For any one who has truly read and studied the Holy Bible it is known that the passage doesn't imply we were created in God's physical likeness. God is spirit. John 4:24 "God is a Spirit" this is the likeness that we are created in. God gave man a soul. Being created in the likeness of something is not being made exactly the same way. Definition of likeness "the state or quality of being like; similarity" Definition of similar "two things that have characteristics that resemble each other but are not exactly alike." Webster's New World College Dictionary. LordBabs:Yes it would be wrong to assume that man must be perfect because God is perfect. As I stated before being made in the likeness of something is not being made the exact same way. Your last statement you ask how can a perfect being create an imperfect being? Then you try to rationalize that they both have to be prefect otherwise God doesn't exist. This is not a logical argument. LordBabs:This argument also falls under the assumption that men are supposed to be exactly the same as God. I have already showed how this reasoning is wrong. LordBabs:(a) still in the likeness, just imperfect and flawed. (b) man is not adopting a new image. (c) translation of what you wrote. "if it is impossible for man to make God why should it be possible for God to make man" ... All you did here was use ambiguous wording to try and make this seem logical. |
davien:First of you failed to acknowledge mitochondrial eve, scientific (not biblical) evidence that all humans descended from one common mother. So weather you believe in evolution or creationism we all come from one mother. Inbreeding does not cause birth defects or sterilization. It gives certain traits more opportunity to appear. So as new generations are born a negative trait will surface. Some defects are minor and don't interfere with the survival of the race, while others are more serious and can decrease the chances of survival. Now again science (not the Holy Bible) explains how the species continues to survive. Natural selection weeds out those genetic defects that hinder human survival. The defects stay in the gene pool but when ever it does pop out those humans would most likely die. If they do manage to survive their chances of reproducing are very low. So, survival of the fittest. As societies advanced, and medicine evolved we began to save the lives of those people who would have died. This is why those traits begin to become more and more common. So the idea that you cannot populate the world through incest is incorrect. |
[size=18pt]15) A problem of a literal Adam and Eve.[/size]This does not disprove anything. Incest happened to populate the world. It was not looked down upon in that day because it was necessary. Later God gave new laws against incest in Leviticus 18:6, as he tells Moses his new laws, "None of you shall approach to any that is near of kin to him, to uncover their unclothedness:" b) Biologically impossible for 2 people to populate the earth into billions of the present dayThere was obviously no research done for this claim. Even science points to all humans descending from one mother. Research Mitochondrial Eve. [img]http://t.qkme.me/pbv.jpg[/img]I usually leave the images out, but this one here shows that, again, there was no research done to validate this claim. Genesis 5 3-4 "And Adam lived an hundred and thirty years, and begat a son in his own likeness, and after his image; and called his name Seth:" "And the days of Adam after he had begotten Seth were eight hundred years: and he begat sons and daughters:" |
LordBabs:Before I start I want to reference one of my prior posts. Bonetoy:Now with this in mind I will continue LordBabs:God did not force the Pharaoh to turn from God. The Pharaoh was already denying God. God hardened the heart of the Pharaoh to prevent him from changing his mind. Remember if we had too much proof that God existed people would start to act good just because "God is watching" So with the events that were taking place the Pharaoh would have let the Jews go because there was no doubt that God existed. He would not have let them go because he was a good person. LordBabs:Simply put, if that is what happened then people would have just assumed that the Pharaoh was generous and give no credit to God for the actions that took place. LordBabs:Even if your assumption was true that God does not honor his word and will pick and choose who he wants to enter heaven. Your assumption is that it is better to just do what you want on this world and go to hell rather than be a good person and take a 50% chance of going into heaven. Either way you look at this question it is not logical. LordBabs:First, this is not a question, its a statement with hypothetical questions. You make the assumption that God had no other way of getting the Jewish people released from the Pharaoh. That God "needed" to appeal to him. This is nothing more than a statement with no valid evidence to prove it's worth. If you were to ask why did God bother with the whole exodus? Which is what I can get from your statement, then the answer would be this... “For the scripture saith unto Pharaoh, Even for this same purpose have I raised thee up, that I might shew my power in thee, and that my name might be declared throughout all the earth” (Romans 9:17) God used this event to help spread his name across the world. |
[size=18pt]13) The forgiveness loophole[/size]This falls under the belief that God can be fooled, in which case God would not be all powerful, therefore not God. Anyone who willfully sins thinking he can just repent and get away from it is only insulting God. What’s worse is that that person truly believes in God. This is considered blasphemy. The definition of blasphemy is "profane or contemptuous speech, writing, or action concerning God or anything held divine. Any remark or action held to be irreverent or disrespectful. (deliberately mocking or contemptuous (scornful) of God)" "Webster's New World College Dictionary" Mark 3:28, 29, 30 "Verily I say unto you, All sins shall be forgiven unto the sons of men, and blasphemies wherewith soever they shall blaspheme:" "But he that shall blaspheme against the Holy Ghost hath never forgiveness, but is in danger of eternal damnation:" Because they said, He hath an unclean spirit. What this says that if a person truly accepts God and believes in him, then purposely and willfully denies and insults God he is committing blaspheme against the Holy Ghost, and this is unforgivable. So by denying and refusing to truly accept the Holy Ghost this leaves your spirit unclean. So this person is truly worse off than the atheist. The atheist can be forgiven for the denial of God because he is not purposely denying God, he does not believe in God. This does not say that once someone accepts God that they must live a perfect life. Humans are imperfect, and we will always sin on this earth. As long as a person is truly making the attempt to prevent those sins from happening God knows and understands our struggles. But if we just think that God will give us salvation without us keeping our end of the deal we are mistaken. |
negativecreep:Considering I woke a half year old forum. I expect people to eventually reply, I just hope its civil. |
[size=18pt]12) A problem of borrowed prophets in Islam[/size]This does not prove God does not exist. All you did was argue that Islam is wrong. Now I am not Muslim and don't follow Islam. But In it's defense Muslim means one who submits to the laws of God. Its a label not a religion. The religion is Islam. |
[size=18pt]11) Problems with an omnipotent intelligent designer and his designs[/size]To sum up your claim, you are saying that since God is supposed to be perfect then his creations should be perfect. The problem with this claim is that you conclude that God did not intend to create us the way that we are. The truth is we are designed to be flawed. This world is not meant to be perfect. As I stated in an earlier post, we are told that we will suffer on this world, only through this experience can we truly understand and appreciate paradise. a) CircumcisionThe necessity was not because God forgot to do something, it was an action in the Old Testament to show your loyalty and faith to God. This was no longer necessary after the New Covenant created with Jesus. b) AbortionFirst you try to state that all miscarriages are God's fault. So every time a woman was punched in the stomach, it was God's fault she had a miscarriage, every time there was an accident... God's fault. You can get where I am going with this. So my question to you would be If God does not exist, who do you blame for these tragedies? Trying to use the flaws of man is not a valid argument to disprove the existence of God. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt that sometimes miscarriages happen when there seems to be no cause. It is known that the female body will force a miscarriage when it knows that something is wrong with either the fetus or the pregnancy all together. So babies die, and people suffer. Death is a huge part of this world, it does not discriminate. Is it fair, no. Life on this world will never be fair. As I have stated before, we are told that we will suffer in this world according to the Holy Bible. Not agreeing with how the world was created does not disprove the existence of God. |
[size=18pt]10) Did God come out of nothing?[/size]What you are trying to do here is place God under the same rules that we are bound by. The definition of omnipotent is "having unlimited power and authority."(Not limited by anything)(Webster's New World College Dictionary). God is omnipotent, so the idea that he is eternal does not contradict his own existence. He is not bound by time, and therefore does not have or need a beginning. You cannot place limits on God in the attempt to create a paradox that disprove his existence. |
[size=18pt]9) Why can't God heal amputees? [/size]This question has nothing to do about the restoration of an amputee's lost limb or digits. Ultimately what it comes down to is why God doesn’t reveal himself. If God were to let everyone know that he existed, most people would stop doing evil things just to act like a good person. God does not want us to do what is right because he is telling us to do the right thing. He wants us to do what is right because we want to do the right thing. Look at it this way. If you invite a friend over to your home he or she will be a good guest while you are in the room watching them, but if you leave the room will that person still be good or will s/he steal from you? You can agree that you would rather have a friend who you can trust to do the right thing no matter what the circumstances are over someone you have to always watch over. God is inviting us into his home, his kingdom. He does not want people who just pretend to be good to enter his house. I stated in a prior post that God does not reveal himself to us because that would interfere with his plan for us. If he were to perform obvious miraculous miracles such as restoring the limbs or digits of amputees that would be too much proof that he exists. God gives us just enough proof to have faith in him. Now as far as the amputees go, that is part of their life. We all have to face different struggles in this world to test our worth. Is it fair? No, but as I explained in an earlier post God is not fair, he is just. To answer your question, it’s not that God cannot restore limbs or digits, it's that he won’t; At least on this Earth. |
[size=18pt]Eight) Debunking the claim that morality comes from God; an objective law giver[/size]You use the term "objective" to try and describe God. The definition of objective is "without bias or prejudice; detached". This does not describe God as is written in the Holy Bible. John 3:16 "For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life." So God loves us according to the Holy Bible, therefore he is not objective in any way. There are many problems with this line of thought;My first statement eliminates this claim. In any case all this states is that humans are limited in our ability to be objective. b) Moral objectivity does not exist both in the purest sense and in the religious scriptureAgain my first statement nullifies the argument of moral objectivity because your first assumption was incorrect that God is morally objective. You also claim that people interpret the Holy Bible and the Quran which creates division between those religions. This has nothing to do with disproving the existence of God. It only validates what is said in the Holy Bible that men are fallible. People have been twisting both the Holy Bible and the Quran to fit their needs of their agenda for hundreds of years. c)We can not understand a true objective moral giver (God)Minus the term "objective" you have just summed up the existence of our world as described by the Holy Bible. As far as the misinterpretations, I explained that in my prior statement. Men are flawed, so we will make mistakes and get things wrong. And as I stated in one of my earlier posts, we can not understand God. If we were able to understand God then he would not be God. d) God is a subjective experienceAgain this claim is also nullified based on my first statement. God is not objective. |
cyrexx:This was just a lot of words to say that you believe religion was made by man and not by God because it fits the cultures of those men that created it…. As I ended my last statement, religion was not the creation of God, it was created by man. (Religion only mentioned 7 times within the whole bible and 6 times it was negative) God wants us to have faith in him and honor his word. It’s as simple as that, he doesn’t want us to make religions, war, or hate anything that doesn’t comply with his word. cyrexx:The term Christian can be classified more as a label than a religion. Christianity is only labeled as a religion due to its ultimate origins of the Old Testament. Christianity itself is a faith that focuses on the salvation of man through Jesus. The Christian mission is to try and save as many people as possible in this world, it doesn’t focus on how the universe was created. There are many different “religions” that fall under Christianity such as Baptist, Protestant, Catholic, and so on. I have already made a statement on how I do not agree with religion because men corrupt the word of God through religion. So trying to judge Christianity because of a small part is like labeling all atheist evil because a few atheists are evil. You try to state that Christianity is just a blend of other cultures and ideals. One the Holy Bible does not teach us to fear, but to rejoice and be hopeful, so the term “apocalyptic fears” is very invalid. Just because there is scary stuff in the Holy Bible does not mean it is preaching fear. “Jewish monotheistic ideals” Yeah, we believe in one God, the same God that Jews believe in, there is no argument there. “Greek ethical philosophy”… You’re claiming that the Holy Bible stole its work from Greek society. I already touched this topic above about how some try to use this idea to disprove God does not exist. This link can help explain the connection between the Holy Bible and Greek philosophy. https://biblethingsinbibleways./2013/07/14/paul-and-his-use-of-greek-philosophy/ . Just because philosophies agree with each other does not mean that one copied the other. If two societies come to the same philosophical conclusion on separate terms, all that proves is the philosophy can be valid. “worship practices and beliefs of the mystery cults” There are no “practices” of Christianity that come from mystery cults. This claim is nothing more than a wild accusation with no evidence at all. Your last sentence, as with much of what is written is just an inflated statement. You claim that God is not necessary and the idea of God does not explain the origins of Christianity. The simple counter to this is God is necessary and perfectly explains the origins of Christianity. Either way it is put it does nothing to prove or disprove the existence of God. cyrexx:You are only making false claims that Christianity and Judaism approve of human slavery as we see it today, and the unequal treatment of women. The truth is that Christianity is a huge proponent to the abolition of slavery as well as the equal treatment of women. If you ever opened a text book you would be able to find this easily. (By the way I am a history teacher) As far as the Slavery question is concerned I can refer you to this link to explain more about the slavery topic. http://www.gotquestions.org/Bible-slavery.html . You can look at this link to find out more about the equal treatment of women. http://www.christianbiblereference.org/faq_womensrights.htm cyrexx:What you are asking for is to have a perfect society on this planet. To sum up this statement you claim that if God exists then this world would be perfect. This is not a reasonable claim. And the simplest research into the Holy Bible counters this belief. This world is just a big test. And just like any test you have to study and do your research. Timothy 2:15 Study to shew thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth. cyrexx:Again man created religion, man is flawed and this has led to the society we live in today with war and suffering. IF you were to claim that God is bad because he allows all the bad stuff to happen, who do you blame if there was no God? The only thing you have to blame is man. As explained in my prior posts, this world is just a test. It is the way it is for a reason. Not agreeing with that reason does not prove God does not exist. cyrexx:Again there is a lot of fluff in this statement to say one simple thing. Believing in God can only lead to chaos because it doesn’t require critical thinking. This is just an opinion; it is not a fact or a reasonable assumption. Your final statement is that believing in God explains nothing…. In actuality it explains everything, if you do your research. You just choose not to believe it. cyrexx:“But atheism does not have the luxury of infinitely imaginative explanations unconstrained by fact” You are claiming that believers don’t use facts with their reasoning. I have given you nothing but facts with direct quotes from the Holy Bible. I understand you do not believe the Holy Bible. The fact of the matter is that the Holy Bible has not been proven unreliable with its references to events that can be compared with other historical documents. There are many other Roman documents that give details of Jesus and back up if not prove his existence. All it takes is research and you can find the truth out for yourself. This whole argument could have been summed up into a couple of sentences. But the author wanted to use ambiguous (unclear) wording to try and make his logic seem undeniable. I could have easily just dismissed his claims, but I wanted to make sure to clearly show where he was flawed in his thinking. |
cyrexx:I will tackle each section in this claim individually since there is a lot written. cyrexx:God does not neglect these people according to the Holy Bible. First I want to give you a foundation for this explanation. God came to us as Jesus to give us an easy way to salvation. He wants us to spread his word to the world so as many people possible can get the chance to accept this sacrifice. Now for what the Holy Bible says about those that we cannot reach through preaching. In Romans 2:12-15 it talks about how everyone has God’s law written into their heart. You might not call it God’s law but you can agree that we all have a conscience that tells us what is morally right and wrong. Then it states “their conscience bearing witness, and their thoughts ultimately accusing or defending them. In the day when God will judge the secrets of men by Jesus Christ,” So it states that men will be judged based on how they followed their conscience. Being judged is not the same thing as being condemned so those that never get to hear the word still have their chance to get into heaven. The only difference is they do not get the easy way into heaven, no this is not fair, but remember as stated above God is just not fair. cyrexx:I answered for the first part of this paragraph in my above statement. One thing I wanted to touch on in this was your statement “no man gets to Heaven without Jesus Christ, which implies that all those millions of people who lived and died without ever hearing of him were all damned through no fault of their own” The actual text is “no man comes to the Father, but by me.” This does not mean that if you don’t know about Jesus then you are condemned. What this means is that no man is worthy to enter heaven because of our sin, but God paid the price for our sin by coming to us as Jesus; suffering then dying for our sin. So every one of us, past, present, and future are able to enter heaven, all that has to be done is either accept what God did for us (truly accept it in our hearts, not just saying the words), or if you do not hear about Jesus, be judged for your actions in this world. cyrexx:“Lacking biblical guidance” I just gave you direct passages and broke it down to the meaning. The guidance is there, it’s your choice to ignore it. You quoted small sections of the Holy Bible that prove your argument, by leaving out the rest of what the Holy Bible says you are twisting the truth in your favor. (Lying by omission) You then ask “Why do Christian groups today go to all the effort of sending missionaries to other countries if they will only tell people what they already know?” Now you are making the statement that everyone already knows about God and Jesus. Having a conscience (having the law in your heart) is not the same as knowing God. As a Christian it is our obligation to spread God’s word so that as many people as possible get the easy way into heaven. Is it fair that not everyone gets to hear about it? No, but as I stated earlier it’s not about fairness. Your final statement would only be valid if our argument was true that there were people who were ignored by God. Which I have proven is not the case by what is written in the Holy Bible. Remember I’m not saying that you have to believe in God or Jesus. I am showing you that the Holy Bible does not contradict itself. And the answers to your questions are there. cyrexx:Yes God reveals his message to those he knows will reject it. But he still gives them the choice to reject it. This does not mean that he should just skip everything and send people to hell and heaven because he knows what will happen. We are given the opportunity to live this life so that we can better appreciate eternity in heaven. And we are given free will because God wants us to love him because it’s what we want to do, not because he made us do it. So by skipping everything and just placing people in heaven and hell he is removing two things that are fundamentally necessary for our existence, free will and the experience of a mortal life. By no way is this inconsistent or unjust. All this sums up to is that you don’t agree with how God runs the world. This does not disprove the existence of God. cyrexx:What you are getting into now is finding out which religion is the right choice. All three religions have the same origin. The main difference is that Islam only perceives Jesus as a prophet. And Judaism has widely mixed feelings about him. Considering that Jesus was a Jew and was trying to correct the corrupt religious leaders in the Jewish community, it can be believed that the Jewish leaders would not want to give up their power and position. This can explain why the Jewish faith does not acknowledge Jesus. And with Islam Jesus is claimed to just be a prophet. Within the Quran prophets do not lie, in which case when Jesus said that he was the son of God he would be telling the truth. I AM NOT TRYING TO FORCE ANYONE TO BELIEVE WHAT I BELIEVE. I am only explaining why I, and many others, believe in Jesus. Just because religions contradict each other, that does not mean God does not exist. As I stated in an earlier post, the term religion is only used 7 times within the bible. And 6 out of 7 it is in a negative aspect. Religion is man’s creation not God’s. |
cyrexx:Your biggest argument here states that it is not fair that some people get more evidence than others to believe. Something that is pretty much agreed upon in this world is the simple fact that life is not fair. Even the Holy Bible does not give concern to fairness in this life. Read Mathew 20 for more understanding on that. You then might argue that if God is not fair then he isn’t a good God. My response to that, which is also detailed in the Holy Bible, is that God is just. Deuteronomy 32:4 [He is] the Rock, his work [is] perfect: for all his ways [are] judgment: a God of truth and without iniquity, just and right [is] he. Just and fair are similar but different in one very important way. Being just deals with morality while fair is only concerned with equal treatment. I’ll give you an example, the public school system. While teaching children it would be fair that all children get the same work and assignments. But it would be just to modify the work for children with mental disabilities. It then becomes unfair for the other students who have to do the harder assignments. “Even if Jesus' life happened exactly as the Bible describes it, the Bible itself is the only witness to that fact, and our historical knowledge is so murky and the evidence so scanty that some people have argued that Jesus never existed at all.” The existence of the Holy Bible is evidence itself for the existence of God. It has already been proven that the Holy Bible has survived for thousands of years unchanged with the exception of a few minor spelling and punctuation errors. (Research the Dead Sea Scrolls) For any book to survive for as long as the Holy Bible, and to have become as popular as it is today, shows that there is something special about it. Some try to claim that the Holy Bible is just stories taken from other “religions” or cultures. These are just claims from those who try to disprove the existence of God. The fact that other civilizations have stories similar to what is written in the Holy Bible is further evidence of its validity. Early civilizations entertained themselves by telling stories. They didn’t write down their stories and were only able to pass on tales orally. So it is understandable that tales of the same account would change from storyteller to storyteller. But as I stated above, the Holy Bible has not changed since its original creation. Here is more information on the Holy Bible and when it was written. http://www.biblica.com/en-us/bible/bible-faqs/when-was-the-bible-written/ And for further proof, the Holy Bible is not the only evidence of the existence of Jesus. There are many Roman documents that give details of Jesus and his actions. http://coldcasechristianity.com/2014/is-there-any-evidence-for-jesus-outside-the-bible/ “Why should God pick a small number of people and overwhelm them with so much first-hand evidence that their coming to the correct conclusion is virtually assured, while all the rest of us are forced to subsist on scraps of handed-down hearsay? “ Let’s put it this way, if God were to reveal himself to the world, how many people would instantly switch from being liars, cheaters, and criminals to being “good”. In their hearts they would still be those liars, cheaters, and criminals. But because they know that God is watching they will put on a show to try and get into heaven. God does not reveal himself to us because he wants us to do what is right because it is the right thing to do. And as far as the evidence, there is enough to come to the conclusion that God might exist at a minimum. It all comes down to the choice we make as individuals to accept or deny God. For the majority of the world there is enough evidence to conclude that God exists. Wanting more evidence is not a valid reason to say God does not exist. |
I had to break this argument into several posts. It was too long for one. cyrexx:First things first, definition of religion – Belief in a divine or superhuman power or powers to be obeyed and worshiped as the creator(s) and ruler(s) of the universe. (Webster’s New World College Dictionary) Many try to claim that religion is just a set of organized beliefs, this is not true. It directly relates to the belief that a supreme being created the universe. This argument makes the claim that all “religions” have different origins BECAUSE they start at different time periods and or in different locations. This reasoning is not correct for several reasons. Example, Judaism, Islam, and Christianity 3 of the largest “religions” in the world all start in different time periods and locations, but they all have the same origin. (Now I am not trying to tell you that you must believe in one of these 3. I am just giving facts.) Now there are multiple other belief structures that do have different origins, but many can be ruled out as true “religions” for the fact that they do not believe in God or a supreme all powerful being. For example, Buddhism completely different belief structure practiced by hundreds of millions, but ultimately it’s not a “religion”. Other “religions” would be classified under a different structure all together because they believe in more than one Supreme Being. Cutting through the lecture, we will end at the point where atheist’s main focus is against the belief structure of one God. We can come to this conclusion because belief structures that do not believe in a supreme being do not affect atheist, and if atheists can disprove the existence of a single supreme being then the belief in multiple gods can be easily dismissed. cyrexx:You make the claim that God desires to be believed in. First off you come off pretty self-righteous to be able to assume to know what a god would desire and how it should go about achieving that desire. If you read the Holy Bible you would realize that this claim is completely invalid. God does not want our belief, he wants our love. And the easiest way to explain this would be to reference the movie “Bruce Almighty” The main character asks God “How do you make someone love you without affecting free will?” God replies “Welcome to my world”. Next, just like with many other arguments as to why God does not exist, this claim falls under the same rule of “Just because you disagree with the way God runs things, does not mean he does not exist. “There can be no doubt that any religion that had it right would be universal.” This sentence can be broken down many different ways. First you are just assuming that your statement is a fact in which case the claim of the statement is true. As I break down the statement all you are saying is that “There can be no doubt that all religions are wrong”, then I can further break it down to the statement that “There can be no doubt that God does not exist.” If I translate that statement into a theistic claim it would say this. “There can be no doubt that God exists.” This proves nothing for either side of the argument. Therefore the foundation of your first claim is not sturdy enough to build a strong argument against the existence of God, but I will continue. “It therefore follows that any god which founded a religion would probably provide its initial revelation to multiple peoples - preferably scattered throughout time and space, to ensure as wide a distribution of followers as possible - or, failing that, the initial revelation would be given to one group of people with instructions to spread it to others” First things first, God did not create religion, man did. I will explain this later on. Next this statement describes the exact events that take place within the Holy Bible. Throughout the Old Testament God reveals himself to different people and peoples throughout the world at different times. In the New Testament he commands people to spread his word to the world. So your atheistic claim just validated the Holy Bible. But no, this does not prove God exists. (Please remember I am not trying to force any one to believe what I believe. I am just showing that there is no undeniable proof that God does not exist.) “It would be extraordinary for people from across the globe and throughout history who had no contact with each other to independently invent the exact same religion, without a god giving them all the same information through revelation.” Your claim here makes the assumption that civilization does not have one single origin. You are assuming that people just popped up around the world and have never had any connection to each other. Both creationism and the theory of evolution agree that man started at the same origin point on earth and spread out over time. So if you go back far enough everyone is connected by that |
negativecreep:I agree, there is no evidence that proves or disproves the existence of God. My purpose is not to try and force people to believe what I believe, but to counter the arguments given in this post. Even though I hope that people would believe and find God, ultimately it is up to each individual to come to their own conclusion about the Argument. |
6) A Problem of tragedy, evil and natural disastersThe above scenarios are not the only options for an explanation of the relationship between God and man. Example, you claim that if he is able but willing or not willing that he is either malevolent, or evil should be eliminated. Just because God does not prevent bad things from happening to us does not mean that he is malevolent. You just assume that there is no reason for what is allowed to happen. You are asking why is he not willing, when a more precise question would be WHY does he allow it, which you ask below. So trying to use the above statements to disprove God is invalid. And now we move to those questions below. A great question people ask when tragedy and natural disasters happen is where is God? Religious theists can not answer this question adequately as it provides a great problem with the theory of a "good and just" God.You claim that theist “cannot” answer these questions adequately. The truth is that most atheists do not accept the answers that are given. They are dismissed as “illogical” or just nonsense. Now, I am not asking you to believe in God. All I am asking is for you to understand the reasoning behind the answers I give to you. I get that you believe that if an all-powerful God existed then he should eliminate evil. But there is a reason for this. There are four flawed religious answers to these questionsThis world was originally designed to be perfect. (I know you don’t believe what the Holy Bible states but bear with me) The Garden of Eden was paradise, but the actions of man ended paradise on this Earth. You then think that a Good God should just forgive us and allow us to still live in paradise. My response to that is that it must be earned. Unless you are communist you believe that people should earn what they have. And to earn paradise all that is required is that you believe and trust in God. For Christians that is believing that God came to us as a man and died for our sins. So all we have to do is accept that salvation. So getting paradise back is not difficult. (Yes I know you do not believe this, but this is the explanation for why the world is the way it is) Back to the communist statement, if you are communist then… you don’t believe in God. True communism prevents the belief in any religion because it prevents people from fully submitting to the state. And history has proven that communism does not make this world a better place. Millions of people have been murdered by communist regimes and this was all done in the name of... man? This is evidence that God cannot be blamed for the bad events that take place in society. Men commit evil against men. (I will explain why this is allowed in the next question) You then try to state that free will is an invalid excuse because nature does not have free will. As stated above nature is the way it is due to the actions of man. (why do people die in hurricanes, next question) You then try to claim that freewill is an illusion because God knows what is going to happen. Just because God knows what is going to happen does not make freewill an illusion. We are all still free to choose whatever we want to do in this life. If our lives were predetermined then it wouldn’t matter what we did because it would turn out the way God planned anyway. They whole purpose of freewill is that God wants us to love him on our own. (I know you don’t believe in God but again please try to understand the reasoning) Another counter to your statement is that you try to put a restriction on an omnipotent being. Remember the definition of an omnipotent being means that it has not limitations to what can and cannot be done. Laws do not apply to anything that is or would be omnipotent. 2) God is punishing the wicked (Gays destroy society false argument )You will never hear a true Christian blame or accuse gays of destroying society. We might believe that being gay is wrong but we should not hate anyone because of it. Our commandments tell us to love others as we love ourselves. This did not say “unless they are gay, or don’t believe what you believe” The greatest way to sum up the world with evil and why it is the way it is to compare it to a test. In our society we give tests for everything. They are to check to see if people are worthy of a title or a position in our society. The lives we live today are just that. This is just a test to see if we are worthy to enter God’s kingdom. Since we are not omnipotent, what better way to get us to understand and appreciate paradise than by knowing and understanding suffering? It states in the bible that we will suffer, but it is not a bad thing. It would only be bad if there was no afterlife. Romans 5: 3-5 More than that, we rejoice in our sufferings, knowing that suffering produces endurance, and endurance produces character, and character produces hope, and hope does not put us to shame, because God's love has been poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit who has been given to us. James 1: 2-4 Count it all joy, my brothers, when you meet trials of various kinds, for you know that the testing of your faith produces steadfastness. And let steadfastness have its full effect, that you may be perfect and complete, lacking in nothing. Again I know this means nothing to an atheist, but this is an explanation as to why things are the way they are. (Refer to my last statement) 3)God is doing in for a greater good! We are not omnipotent and so we can't judgeAs stated above, this life is temporary. Suffering for a brief moment in life is nothing compared to an eternity in paradise. Without that suffering we would never appreciate what is given to us after this world is gone. (Refer to my last statement) If God does not exist you still run into a problem with your argument because suffering still exits, who do you blame then? Who do you accuse and persecute for the pain that still exist? Why is it still allowed? Without God there is no answer to any of your questions that you just asked. 4) God is not involved in these tragedies!Ultimately what it comes down to is that you do not agree with the reasons on how God runs things. This is not proof that God does not exist. Not agreeing or not understanding why something is the way it is does not prove its does not exist. |
[size=18pt]5) The Law Maker Argument against religious books[/size]You are trying to make an assumption that the laws in the Holy Bible and Quran are invalid because society changes. Society may change but what is considered right and wrong within those societies do not change. Most people who don't believe in God will agree that at a minimum the Holy Bible is a guidebook at how to live a good life. It was wrong to murder thousands of years ago, it is wrong to murder today. It was wrong to steal thousands of years ago... and so on. So trying to say that that Holy books should change their rules is saying that we need to reevaluate what is morally right and wrong. You may try to argue against the laws in the old testament such as putting to death those who commit adultery. But the new testament overturns most of the laws stated in the old testament. All but the 10 commandments. There were only two commandments added in the new testament. Love thy God with all your heart, and Love thy neighbor as you love yourself. For most people these commandments are not disputed. Atheist and theist will agree that the commandments are just as valid today as they were thousands of years ago. (all but the ones dealing with God that is) The problem is very simple; religious books like the Quran and Bible will continue to be outdated naturally, no matter how many times they are interpreted because laws by nature have to change with the advance of societies and technology or we will be looking at arnarchy from loopholes.As stated above, no advancement in society will alter what is morally right and wrong. If the words/laws of an eternal being can not be eternal, what is the point? Why not focus on laws that work?This assumption is invalid for one reason. The laws created for man on this earth can not be eternal because man will not live forever. Eventually human beings will become extinct this is unavoidable. The laws, or commandments, in the Holy Bible do work even to this day. |
[size=18pt]4. The Paradox of omniscience[/size]This is claiming just because God cannot forget then he does not know how it feels. This is flawed reasoning. If he knows all things then he knows all things. Just because you claim he cannot experience something doesn't mean that he does not know it. Another flaw with your argument is that God is omnipotent, this means that he has no limits to his abilities. If he wants to forget something he can forget something, he can also recall it after forgetting it. You cannot place limits on an omnipotent being. [Edit] The married bachelor metaphor falls in the same reasoning as placing God under the laws we are bound by. |
ooman:You obviously do not understand what Omnipotent is, I have already explained why you're argument is invalid. Try reading it again. And not once have I insulted atheist in any of my posts. Not once have I tried to persuade any one to believe in God. All I am doing is answering questions and correcting mistakes in flawed ideas and statements. If you can not handle an intellectual conversation on the forums I would recommend that you go somewhere else. You're only going to get more upset as time goes on. None of you arguments are based on any facts or evidence. Its evident that your writing purely out of emotion. Until you give me something other than hate I will not respond to any more of your messages. |
[size=18pt]3)DEBUNKING PASCAL'S WAGER[/size]Simply put Pascal's Wager is wrong if you are a theist or atheist. Any "religion" and I use the term lightly will agree that believing in God because it's a safe bet will not get you into heaven. Pascal's Wager is not an argument that any true believer would use. So this can be discarded. As for the rest of your post you greatly deviated from your original topic. Everything you have explained saying that believing in God causes nothing but strife, pain, and suffering. You are glad to mention that the people following orders in "the name of God" do so blindly and happily. But you fail to mention those people in charge who are pulling the strings. Throughout history MEN have used the Holy Bible to manipulate and control the masses to do THEIR will not God's. During the dark ages people were forbidden to read the Holy Bible for themselves and the Church would have Priest "interpret" God's word. The Catholic church is probably the most guilty organization in this action. But if you really do your research Catholicism does not fully follow Christianity or the Holy Bible. This is true for all religions. There has always and will always be people who will take advantage and manipulate others using "religion" I myself do not believe in religion, I believe in God through faith. Religion was created by man. In the Holy Bible it mentions the words religion and religious only 7 times. And of those 7 mentions only one of them is used in a positive manner. James 1:27 "Pure religion and undefiled before God and the Father is this, To visit the fatherless and widows in their affliction, and to keep himself unspotted from the world." So I will agree with you that religion is not a good thing. In conclusion nothing you stated in your argument can be used to disprove the existence of God. You are only stating your opinion as to why people should not believe in God. |
ooman:You are confusing omnipresence with omnipotence. They are two completely different meanings. Omnipresence - Being present everywhere at the same time Omnipotence - Having full unlimited power and authority. So being omnipotent means that you are not bound by any laws or regulations ever. So anything and everything is possible. |
ooman:This is a huge argument used by many atheists and it is an invalid one. Lack of belief is the exact same thing as not believing. And if you continue to try to argue this case, then all you are saying is that; it’s not that you don’t believe in God, it’s that you refuse to acknowledge him. And if that’s the case then you must believe in God. The other option is that you're saying you don't care whether he exists or not, which would mean that you cannot make the claim that God does not exist. ooman:I never stated that because more people believe in God it is a valid belief. I stated that it's not illogical. As far as your cosmetologist (cosmologist)statement, they believed the universe was static because the stars did not change, this did not make it valid but it was logical at the time. And until God is proven not to exist it is still logical to believe that he exists. ooman:Already hit the belief topic, And as far as your faith argument, all you did was validate my point. Again science has not shown us God is not necessary to understand everything in nature. There are countless subjects and events that science cannot explain or even come close to explaining in nature. If we have not figured out how our planet works, as well as the universe, in its entirety, how can we claim that science disproves God? Science can neither prove nor disprove the existence of God. If there was actualy ground breaking scientific evidence that God does not exist this would be spread across the world like wildfire. Trying to compare the existence of God to an invisible flying pig on Mars or an invisible pink unicorn is another big argument atheist like to use. Let's talk about this. So you're claiming that if God exist then there has to be such a thing as an invisible (insert description) animal. My first argument would be that the animal is not omnipotent it is bound by laws and therefore cannot violate those laws. If you want to claim that that animal could be omnipotent, then you would be saying that it is a god, in which case you would believe in a god if not God. ooman:All you're doing here is using semantics. Theory is a theory is a theory. Scientific theory is just a theory that is closer to being proven a law, but it still is not a fact. Hypothesis is just the first step of a theory. So when relating to God, my hypothesis would be the universe was created by something, my theory is that God created the universe. My experiments or evidence to further prove and advance my theories would be miracles in medicine, this just takes my theory closer to law, but still is not a fact. ooman:Yes that is the Christian definition, but if you do your research all religions that deal with the belief of one God have similar definitions to God. Please forgive any errors I'm not an expert in the Quran and I believe that to fully understand it I would have to learn the language it was originally written in, but the Quran describes God as the one and only, absolute existence. This is very similar to the Christian religion, as well as all religions that believe in one God. |
[size=18pt]2) The paradox of omnipotence[/size]Omnipotence is not just the ability to do all things, it is having unlimited power. Not having any limitations or restrictions. -However, some abilities are contradictory to each other. or some actions negate each otherYour claim is that because God can do all things that it contradicts certain aspects of his being. First you are trying to place God under the same laws and rules that we are bound by on this Earth. This type of thinking is invalid because if God were restricted to these same laws then he would not be God. (Refer to Omnipotence definition) God has the ability to be everywhere. he is omnipresent. However, that means that he doesnt have the ability to leave a certain place or the ability to be absent.Next you claim that he does not have the ability to leave a certain place or to be absent. This is where you are wrong. If you have done any research about God or the Bible you would find out that there is such a place where God is not present. Hell is that place. This is not because God cannot be present in Hell, this is because he chooses not to be present there. This argument is not very strong to disprove the existence of God. It’s only used to try and stump theist who have not done their research. |
[size=18pt]1) The fundamental atheist argument[/size]Within your own definition you are admitting that it’s just a belief and not a fact. You can claim the same thing about people who do believe, but you also take care of that argument for me in the next paragraph when you claim that “The existence of God is taken on FAITH”. The term faith can only be used to show trust or belief in something or someone without any evidence to back up your belief. So if you claim to be atheist then you cannot have faith in anything. If you try to argue that you can have faith that an elevator will take you to the top floor safely and not crash you are wrong. You believe that you will be safe based on statistics and your own experiences with elevators. The fundamental argument for atheism is that there is no evidence or proof for God. There is no solid or tangible evidence for God nor a logical argument for God. The existence of God is taken on faith and not by evidence.You try to claim that there is no logical argument for God. Since when did it become illogical to believe in God? Even today there is a greater number of people in the world who believe in the existence of one God than those who do not believe. They range from the very poor to the very rich, highly intelligent to the simplest minds, gays and straights, old and young. Let’s put that aside though and focus on another part of that claim. You want to claim that believing in God is illogical if that is true then you are saying the same for disbelieving in God. Both sides are making a judgment based off of no “scientific” evidence proving either side. Then I refer you back to Faith for the theist belief. -God can not be proven by science which is the main way we study and understand our universe or natural world. There is no theory of GodNext, you try to state that science backs up the atheist belief that God does not exist. All you stated is that God cannot be proven by science. On that same note, as I stated above, science cannot prove that God does not exist. Your next statement is also very flawed, “There is no theory of God”. First, theory is defined as an idea that is intended to explain facts or events but has not been proven to be true. So your claim that there is no theory of God is completely false. When people believe in God it’s not called a theory even though it can be categorized as one. -There is no conclusive logical argument forthe existence of God. His/her existence is continuously debated.Again you try to use logic to back your claim, I have already argued that case above but I will touch on another part of it. You state that the existence of God is continuously debated. This does not prove that God does not exist. A theist can simply claim that because people continuously argue about Gods existence means that God must exist. But I will just call this debate another tie that cannot prove or disprove the existence of God. -There is no comprehensive definition of God. There are many definitions for the same God as there are many gods. This is problematic if one is to ascertain the characteristics of God to judge if God exists or not.Your last point is that there is no comprehensive definition of God. I can simply put this to rest by quoting the Holy Bible. “I am Alpha and Omega,” first and last letters of the Greek alphabet. This means that he is our beginning and our end. Now I know that this means nothing to atheist, but that is the definition we have for God. I am just arguing your claim. The next part of your claim is that because there is no definition that we cannot judge if God exists or not. I can counter this by stating that we cannot understand God. It would be impossible for us to truly understand God as defined by the Holy Bible. If we could understand God then he would not be God. So your claim that not being able to understand God means he does not exist is flawed. |
1 2 (of 2 pages)

.