₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,345,845 members, 8,519,794 topics. Date: Monday, 16 November 2026 at 07:34 PM

Toggle theme

Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? - Politics - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? (435 Views)

1 Reply (Go Down)

Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by helinues(op): 1:58pm On Jan 06, 2025
If you are supporting the bill, give your reasons and if you are against as well, tell us why

Enough of all this back and forth arguments about the bill
Re: Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by Maazieze(m): 2:08pm On Jan 06, 2025
For, alongside recent developments with LGA autonomy, this maybe the first steps towards true fiscal federalism.
Re: Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by givedemwotowoto: 2:08pm On Jan 06, 2025
That tax bill should NOT pass! It should be sent back to the presidency to change the VAT portion of it.

States (especially oil/gas producing states like Abia and Imo) may lose billions of naira monthly in VAT share if that bill passes! Most of their oil/gas revenue is shared among other states, but when those states invest the oil/gas money and generate VAT, you want the states to retain most of their VAT. This is unfair.

Amend the VAT system so that companies can pay VAT to the states of consumption, but keep the sharing formula the same for now let’s see the difference for like 3 to 6 months, by that time we know if truly states will earn more VAT share as they claim, or if this was just a ploy to make Lagos richer

The people who are claiming that VAT reform will make states work harder, has FG done their job of providing security? How will indigenes of a place like Benue go back to their farms when they have been sacked from their villages for many years now, unable to go back home?
Re: Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by helinues(op): 2:24pm On Jan 06, 2025
givedemwotowoto:
That tax bill should NOT pass! It should be sent back to the presidency to change the VAT portion of it.

States (especially oil/gas producing states like Abia and Imo) may lose billions of naira monthly in VAT share if that bill passes! Most of their oil/gas revenue is shared among other states, but when those states invest the oil/gas money and generate VAT, you want the states to retain most of their VAT. This is unfair.

Amend the VAT system so that companies can pay VAT to the states of consumption, but keep the sharing formula the same for now let’s see the difference for like 3 to 6 months, by that time we know if truly states will earn more VAT share as they claim, or if this was just a ploy to make Lagos richer

The people who are claiming that VAT reform will make states work harder, has FG done their job of providing security? How will indigenes of a place like Benue go back to their farms when they have been sacked from their villages for many years now, unable to go back home?
Is it only Imo and Abia state that are oil producing states in Nigeria?

You can't be talking about the gas which is yet untapped
Re: Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by Zooposki(f): 2:44pm On Jan 06, 2025
Re: Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by givedemwotowoto: 2:59pm On Jan 06, 2025
helinues:
Is it only Imo and Abia state that are oil producing states in Nigeria?

You can't be talking about the gas which is yet untapped
But when Imo and Abia are among the lowest VAT generation states and you want to take away their share of VAT, you should also give them back their oil/gas revenue which other states didn’t generate for them.

Since we’re talking about self sustenance let everyone find their own local resources and feed themselves
Re: Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by helinues(op): 3:12pm On Jan 06, 2025
givedemwotowoto:
But when Imo and Abia are among the lowest VAT generation states and you want to take away their share of VAT, you should also give them back their oil/gas revenue which other states didn’t generate for them.

Since we’re talking about self sustenance let everyone find their own local resources and feed themselves
Why have they been generating low VAT for quite some time?
Re: Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by DeLaRue: 3:21pm On Jan 06, 2025
A big YES.
Re: Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by givedemwotowoto:
helinues:
Why have they been generating low VAT for quite some time?
Your original question has been answered with valid reasons. That tax bill should NOT pass, period!

40% of the lowest 10 VAT generating states are oil/gas producing states. Ask Abia, Cross River, Imo, and Ondo why:

10. Jigawa 1.59 billion
9. Nasarawa 1.47 billion
8. Ondo 1.45 billion
7. Enugu 1.08 billion
6. Cross River 1.08 billion
5. Bauchi 691.28 million
4. Kebbi 665.17 million
3. Abia 663.42 million
2. Zamfara 432.80 million
1. Imo 235.41 million
Re: Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by Charly68: 3:53pm On Jan 06, 2025
Every progressive minded person in the country will support the tax reform bill.
Re: Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by nedu666: 4:05pm On Jan 06, 2025
Is this the senate. Your support or otherwise is useless
Re: Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by MadamExcellency: 5:45pm On Jan 06, 2025
givedemwotowoto:
Your original question has been answered with valid reasons. That tax bill should NOT pass, period!

40% of the lowest 10 VAT-generating states are oil/gas producing states. Ask Abia, Cross River, Imo, and Ondo why:

10. Jigawa 1.59 billion
9. Nasarawa 1.47 billion
8. Ondo 1.45 billion
7. Enugu 1.08 billion
6. Cross River 1.08 billion
5. Bauchi 691.28 million
4. Kebbi 665.17 million
3. Abia 663.42 million
2. Zamfara 432.80 million
1. Imo 235.41 million
VAT is a consumption tax. How many States do you think the majority of the consumption took place more, not who collected the VATs?

How many States in Nigeria buy luxury goods and services than Imo State?

Just say you don't understand the politics of VAT generation and why Imo State is supporting the tax reforms.
Re: Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by givedemwotowoto: 5:52pm On Jan 06, 2025
MadamExcellency:
VAT is a consumption tax. How many States do you think that consumption took place apart from who collected it?

How many States in Nigeria buy luxury goods and services than Imo State.

Just say you don't understand the politics of VAT generation and why Imo State is supporting the tax reforms.
Very ignorant entitled statement.

Read this my post if you don't understand what the problem with the VAT reform is about: https://www.nairaland.com/8284004/vat-reform-how-proposed-vat

After reading it, since you fully understand the VAT reform, answer this question in my post here: https://www.nairaland.com/8283744/simple-question-vat-reform-supporters
Re: Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by MadamExcellency: 6:01pm On Jan 06, 2025
givedemwotowoto:
Very ignorant entitled statement.

Read this post if you don't understand what the problem with the VAT reform is about: https://www.nairaland.com/8284004/vat-reform-how-proposed-vat

After reading it, since you fully understand the VAT reform, answer this question in my post here: https://www.nairaland.com/8283744/simple-question-vat-reform-supporters
Is like you are part of those who graduated from university without on-the-job experiences but like to use figures you know nothing about for arguments.

States supporting the tax reforms like Imo State know why. If you have been part of the sales and consumer department of any multinational in Nigeria, you wouldn't refer anyone to those figures. The tax reform bill is correcting the dubious figures you quoted.
Re: Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by givedemwotowoto:
MadamExcellency:
Is like you are part of those who graduated from university without on-the-job experiences but like to use figures you know nothing about for arguments.

States supporting the tax reforms like Imo State know why. If you have been part of the sales and consumer department of any multinational in Nigeria, you wouldn't refer anyone to those figures. The tax reform bill is correcting the dubious figures you quoted.
You clearly don't know what you're talking about. I don't even know if you understand the bone of contention here, if you understand the difference between VAT revenue (total VAT collected) vs VAT share (How much received as share after total VAT collected is shared among FG, States, and LG). Your argument is based on "trust them because they said so". How ignorant!

So you trust the same people who played you with electoral reforms and electronic voting? Clap for yourself.

I have made myself clear. I am NOT AGAINST the tax reform, but the VAT portion of the bill is controversial. Some claims should be validated by the proponents. Show me how the reform will increase the VAT Share (read definition of VAT share above) of states as you claimed. Show me some proof

As for me, I do my own research, and if you have zero informed argument with some data other than "trust them", we have nothing to discuss on this matter. GTFO!
Re: Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by Thomthom(m): 6:21pm On Jan 06, 2025
My problem with Tax reform bill is the increment of VAT to 10% everything go just go up. If you load 1000 recharge card E go be like 200 naira. Meaning we have to face the suffer of increase of petrol to goods and services. Am from the South if the VAT is not left alone the ways it was before I don't support. Let Lagos State be enjoying the tax alone.
Re: Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by Paraman: 6:32pm On Jan 06, 2025
I'm for the bill. And the bill shouldn't be withdrawn from the national assembly, if it's withdrawn, it will end up like the PIB
Re: Tax Reform Bill: Are You For Or Against? by helinues(op): 10:42pm On Jan 06, 2025
Paraman:
I'm for the bill. And the bill shouldn't be withdrawn from the national assembly, if it's withdrawn, it will end up like the PIB
Bro what was the governor's visit for if not for the tax reform bill
1 Reply

Tinubu's tax reform bill only favours Lagos - Borno Gov, Zulum • The Layman’s Understanding Of The Proposed Tax Reform Bill • Northern Governors Oppose Proposed Tax Reform Bill, Ask NASS To Reject It • 2 • 3 • 4

Security Operatives Killed 32,000 Civilians, Extorted N3trn In South-east • Thiefinubu Nepotism In Ministerial And Permanent Secretary Appointments • Rivers Politics: The Ijaw Assembly Members Should Impeach Amaewhule