President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship - Foreign Affairs (8)

President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship - Foreign Affairs (8) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Foreign Affairs › President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship (41952 Views)

1 2 3 ... 5 6 7 8 9 Reply (Go Down)

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by koboko69: 2:49pm On Jan 21, 2025

TWoods:
An EO is not intended to change the Constitution, it is simply an Executive decision (that the executive branch of government must comply with - including those issuing US passports), so long as it does not violate any rights. The EO was intended to bait someone with standing to file a SCOTUS suit. The lack of standing is why no one has filed a 14th Amendment suit until now. They think they will have 5 justices to overturn the Wong Art Kim decision. At that point, it's game over.

The EO does not overturn the 14th Amendment. It is intended to force a court to reinterpret the meaning of "subject to the jurisdiction thereof." There is already information indicating that the writer of the amendment did not intend it to be interpreted broadly.

Lol. Any EO that goes againt the constitution is always overturned. He tried several of this kind of nonsense in his first term and many were overturned in the courts for going against the constitution. Imagine a democrat trying to use EO to nullify the 2nd Amendment. That is exactly what trying to use EO to end the 14th Amendment is. U said no one as sued? Hahaha. Relax. Anyone can sue, state AG, civil right groups, immigration right groups, just anyone. He is not baiting anyone; he knows they will sue. He just likes throwing red meat to his base.

1 Like

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by Successlane: 2:51pm On Jan 21, 2025

Olachase:
As them no born me for America

Sheh I die 😀😀😀

Giving birth in U.S na over-do Nigeria day ok

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by luminouz(m): 2:58pm On Jan 21, 2025

galserv:
Did the native Americans drop from heaven Did they not also migrate there from somewhere

Before them ..there was no one....so they were the original settlers

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by galserv: 3:01pm On Jan 21, 2025

luminouz:
Before them ..there was no one....so they were the original settlers

@bolded How do you know huh

They were settlers still. Everybody is a settler.

1 Like 1 Share

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by chopnaira: 3:51pm On Jan 21, 2025

BigDawsNet:
O ti lo

Your kids can still get a US citizens if the dad or mum is a US citizens during the child birth

And how many fall into that category grin

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by DMerciful(m): 3:55pm On Jan 21, 2025

He cannot do that. It will be overturned by the Supreme Court.

The constitution has to be amended first

CoronaVirusPro:
End of the road!

A lot of litigations will follow, but with a Republican parked SCOTUS, I kinda see it as a done deal.

Those morafvckers will flip anything for Trump.

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by emmyN(m): 4:06pm On Jan 21, 2025

DrAda:
For illegal immigrants

Nope. Illegals as well as those on temporary visas. Tourists, students, work visas are included in ban.

1 Like

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by DrAda(f): 4:08pm On Jan 21, 2025

emmyN:
Nope. Illegals as well as those on temporary visas. Tourists, students, work visas are included in ban.

So undocumented immigrants?

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by emmyN(m): 4:10pm On Jan 21, 2025

DrAda:
So undocumented immigrants?

They are banned as well.

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by wirinet(m): 4:42pm On Jan 21, 2025

Calitoscassius:
Well... Every Countries constitution can be re written including the US. If it appears the true reason for the previous constitution is been abused. The Democrats want the same but they want Trump to be blamed for stopping birthright citizeship in America.

Then let the US constitution be rewritten to abolish birthright citizenship. Till then any executive order or act abolishing birthright citizenship is unconstitutional.

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by IkePeters(m): 4:45pm On Jan 21, 2025*

This was only a matter of time. America is the only 1st World Country permitting Birth Right Citizenship. Somehow we knew this Promo was going to run it's course, especially after being massively oversubscribed.
Trump will need to amend the Constitution to give this backing. Which means majority of the States' Senate have to approve the amendment.

DrMB:
What does this executive order mean for Nigerians and other developing countries?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mZ8k1yrhHtA

Related Topics:

President Trump Signs Executive Order, Exits U.S. From WHO & Paris Climate Deal https://www.nairaland.com/8322537/president-trump-signs-executive-order

President Trump Signs Executive Order for Tiktok 50/50 Profit Sharing Formula https://www.nairaland.com/8322529/president-trump-signs-executive-order

1 Like 1 Share

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by BigDawsNet: 5:03pm On Jan 21, 2025

chopnaira:
And how many fall into that category

Millions

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by MasterTeeUSA: 5:04pm On Jan 21, 2025

An attempt to change the existing amendment can only be done through a new constitutional amendment, which requires either a joint resolution passed by two-thirds of both the House of Representatives and the Senate, or a convention called by Congress in response to two-thirds of state legislatures requesting one.

However, Trump's order doesn't change the wording. Instead, it attempts to reinterpret a clause in the amendment to no longer apply to large numbers of people that it used to.

https://www.palmbeachpost.com/story/news/politics/elections/2025/01/21/trump-ends-birthright-citizenship-executive-order-can-he-do-that/77845018007/

DrMB:
What does this executive order mean for Nigerians and other developing countries?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mZ8k1yrhHtA

Related Topics:

President Trump Signs Executive Order, Exits U.S. From WHO & Paris Climate Deal https://www.nairaland.com/8322537/president-trump-signs-executive-order

President Trump Signs Executive Order for Tiktok 50/50 Profit Sharing Formula https://www.nairaland.com/8322529/president-trump-signs-executive-order

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by UncleJJ(m): 5:06pm On Jan 21, 2025

havenz:
The full meaning of DONALD TRUMP is BUSINESS that will make America GREAT AGAIN. All Nigeria must give birth in Nigeria now.

In saner clilmes grin

1 Like

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by Calitoscassius(m): 5:10pm On Jan 21, 2025

wirinet:
Then let the US constitution be rewritten to abolish birthright citizenship. Till then any executive order or act abolishing birthright citizenship is unconstitutional.

I agree. i guess abolishing birthright is within Trump's executive orders power to abolish hence his action.

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by Chetas81(m): 5:13pm On Jan 21, 2025

ceejay80s:
I wonder how that boy missed that assassination attempt?

what is your gain, the black Africans refuse to stop roaming around the globe, trump called Nigeria shithole in 2018, im waiting for next name to give Nigeria.

1 Like 1 Share

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by ceejay80s(m): 5:15pm On Jan 21, 2025

Chetas81:
what is your gain, the black Africans refuse to stop roaming around the globe, trump called Nigeria shithole in 2018, im waiting for next name to give Nigeria.

lol
and tinubu, church pastors , house of rep etc are truping in USA for his inauguration?
Nigeria is really a shit hole

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by wirinet(m): 5:16pm On Jan 21, 2025

Calitoscassius:
I agree. i guess abolishing birthright is within Trump's executive orders power to abolish hence his action.

Then you guess any other constitutional rights is within Trump's executive orders to abolish.

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by Nobody: 5:16pm On Jan 21, 2025

DMerciful:
He cannot do that. It will be overturned by the Supreme Court.

The constitution has to be amended first

The fact that you mentioned Supreme Court should tell you all you need to know.

If you relying on Supreme Court, it’s a done deal

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by Calitoscassius(m): 5:18pm On Jan 21, 2025

wirinet:
Then you guess any other constitutional rights is within Trump's executive orders to abolish.

So it appears. isn't it?

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by Yankee101: 5:26pm On Jan 21, 2025

CoronaVirusPro:
Same Supreme Court that he owns.

You underestimate Trump’s reach. Was the constitution changed before a convicted felon became president? Was it changed when an insurrectionist became president?

If you counting on SCOTUS, then it’s a done deal.

The US Constitution sets out relatively few eligibility requirements for presidential candidates: they must be at least 35, be a “natural born” US citizen and have lived in the US for at least 14 years. There are no rules blocking candidates with criminal records.

2 Likes 1 Share

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by Nobody: 5:30pm On Jan 21, 2025

Yankee101:
The US Constitution sets out relatively few eligibility requirements for presidential candidates: they must be at least 35, be a “natural born” US citizen and have lived in the US for at least 14 years. There are no rules blocking candidates with criminal records.

An insurrectionist.

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by Yankee101: 5:52pm On Jan 21, 2025

CoronaVirusPro:
An insurrectionist.

Jack Smith was still in court with the charges
Like I said earlier, America dosent work with hearsay
Na law. If he wasn’t convicted by Election Day then he is still assumed innocent until proven guilty

1 Like 1 Share

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by DMerciful(m): 5:57pm On Jan 21, 2025

You know, they put that law when they created their constitution to make their children to be Americans because they all came from Europe to the new world so werent Americans at the time

CoronaVirusPro:
The fact that you mentioned Supreme Court should tell you all you need to know.

If you relying on Supreme Court, it’s a done deal

1 Like 1 Share

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by DaddyCoool(f): 6:10pm On Jan 21, 2025

Mynd44:
The issue here is can you overrule the constitution with an executive order?

The answer is of course a BIG, FAT, EMPHATIC NOOOO!!

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by luminouz(m): 8:05pm On Jan 21, 2025

galserv:
@bolded How do you know

They were settlers still. Everybody is a settler.

*Sighs*

This one doesn't read

Pele o..settler!!!

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by Julius1995(m): 9:06pm On Jan 21, 2025

Jokes. For all immigrants.

DrAda:
For illegal immigrants

Re: President Trump Signs Executive Order To End U.S. Birthright Citizenship by Skydivine: 9:36pm On Jan 21, 2025

Doylestown92:
Don't mind him or her. Probably from Cameroon. He should know that "Tor" is a Hausa way of agreeing with someone. We the Yoruba borrowed it from them.

What is this one saying again? Someone is outrightly telling you about “tor” as a contraction of “ Otor” in Yoruba language. But here you are, jumping into the express without looking left and right.