₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,217 members, 8,521,820 topics. Date: Friday, 20 November 2026 at 05:57 AM

Toggle theme

On The Origin of Evil - Christianity Etc (4) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › On The Origin of Evil (7282 Views)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Reply (Go Down)

Re: On The Origin of Evil by DeepSightZ: 12:36pm On Feb 08, 2025
TheDevilsBride, I have been banned and banned and banned each time I try to post.
Let me first see if I will be banned before I respond properly to you.

Although I must say I am not encouraged to do so - reading a line which says that nothing causes a cup of cofee to come to become cold in the morning is too tiresome to contemplate responding to.
Re: On The Origin of Evil by LordReed(m): 12:58pm On Feb 08, 2025
MaxInDHouse:
He has never spoken directly to anyone who is challenging His authority so your argument is dead on arrival.
As He claimed some 2,700 years ago it's obvious now that all those gods your are trying to equate with Him are nothing but the works of man's hands.
Let their worshipers MOVE to places and TALK to people about their gods that's all we are asking if truly their gods were real like the One who is able to speak and fulfill what He promised:

No weapon formed against you will have any success, And you will condemn any tongue that rises up against you in the judgment. This is the heritage of the servants of Jehovah, And their righteousness is from me,” declares Jehovah. Isaiah 54:17

It's just a pity that you an atheist is the one trying to speak for the gods you don't even believe (trust) please where are their worshipers as in those trusting (believing) in them?

Praise Jehovah! They have all become like their gods! Psalms 115:8 smiley
Yet he supposedly spoke to Saul aka Paul when he was persecuting Christians. Look for another excuse, this one no work.
Re: On The Origin of Evil by LordReed(m): 1:03pm On Feb 08, 2025
DeepSightZ:
Although I must say I am not encouraged to do so - reading a line which says that nothing causes a cup of cofee to come to become cold in the morning is too tiresome to contemplate responding to.
If the normal flow of energy to reach equilibrium is a cause then yeah something caused the coffee to become cold. I doubt that that kind of cause is the one you are reaching for though.
Re: On The Origin of Evil by TheDevilsBride(f): 2:23pm On Feb 08, 2025
DeepSightZ:
The Devils Bride, I have been banned and banned and banned each time I try to post.
Let me first see if I will be banned before I respond properly to you.

Although I must say I am not encouraged to do so - reading a line which says that nothing causes a cup of cofee to come to become cold in the morning is too tiresome to contemplate responding to.
Hey now, don't get things misconstrued here. I never said "nothing" causes the coffee to become cold. I literally said there were no triggers necessary. The coffee cools, particularly due to the inherent nature of thermodynamic systems seeking out equilibrium.

Meanwhile, I did notice your continuous failed attempts to submit your response. The spambots are ruthless, lmao. I think you could try screenshotting your post, just right after you hit send, and just before you refresh the page. Then you could attach the original response as it was before it got hidden, as an image. Just a thought.
Re: On The Origin of Evil by TheDevilsBride(f): 2:27pm On Feb 08, 2025
MaxInDHouse:
Paul is a Jew one of God's people {Act 22:3} but he was blinded by the tradition of men {Galatians 1:14 compare to Romans 10:2-3} that is why Jesus spoke to him to show the confused man mercy {Romans 9:15} and he wasn't challenging God's authority ironically he was fighting for God's authority according to his own understanding back then.

If he was challenging God's authority he wouldn't have responded calling him "Lord" at a go! Act 9:5 wink
More cognitive dissonance, lmao.

Let's not ignore the context, please. Paul (then Saul) went out of his own way, to actively persecute Christians, whom he viewed as heretics to his own understanding of God's will, as is being argued here. So if you insist that he was indeed, fighting to establish God's authority, then perhaps we may conclude that in his fervent, albeit misguided attempts to uphold God's authority, he was, in fact, opposing it! Else, why would God himself, make a cameo in the story to smite him, correct him, and then steer him towards the right path, lol?

As for your absurd allusions to Paul's instant recognition of Jesus as "Lord", it's absolutely banal and meaningless, as it doesn't absolve the fact that prior to his epiphany, he was a staunch, and avid adversary to what he perceived as a threat to his religious convictions. Whether Paul was "confused" or "misguided", he still fits the criteria of someone inadvertently opposing divine will, and posing a direct challenge to it, whether cognizant or not. So you're just being disingenuous, as per usual.
Re: On The Origin of Evil by MaxInDHouse(m): 2:38pm On Feb 08, 2025
LordReed:
Yet he supposedly spoke to Saul aka Paul when he was persecuting Christians. Look for another excuse, this one no work.
TheDevilsBride:
More cognitive dissonance, lmao.
Let's not ignore the context, please. Paul (then Saul) went out of his own way, to actively persecute Christians, whom he viewed as heretics to his own understanding of God's will, as is being argued here. So if you insist that he was indeed, fighting to establish God's authority, then perhaps we may conclude that in his fervent, albeit misguided attempts to uphold God's authority, he was, in fact, opposing it! Else, why would God himself, make a cameo in the story to smite him, correct him, and then steer him towards the right path, lol?

As for your absurd allusions to Paul's instant recognition of Jesus as "Lord", it's absolutely banal and meaningless, as it doesn't absolve the fact that prior to his epiphany, he was a staunch, and avid adversary to what he perceived as a threat to his religious convictions. Whether Paul was "confused" or "misguided", he still fits the criteria of someone inadvertently opposing divine will, and posing a direct challenge to it, whether cognizant or not. So you're just being disingenuous, as per usual.
Mr & Mrs Atheists!
God doesn't speak to anyone who don't believe in His existence Paul believe God exists the reason why he was fighting those he thought were impostors unlike you people saying "there is no god"

So bring the example of someone who doesn't believe that God exists and how God spoke to such a person then i will agree with you that you know what you are demanding. wink
Re: On The Origin of Evil by MaxInDHouse(m): 2:55pm On Feb 08, 2025
Funny atheists!
Jehovah has promised that even His own true worshipers in the last days will hear no direct words from Him other than what has been written by prophets.
So how do we know for sure that God is in our midst?
He said:


“You are my witnesses,” declares the Lord, “and my servant whom I have chosen, so that you may know and believe me and understand that I am he. Before me no god was formed, nor will there be one after me. ‭Isaiah 43:10 NIV‬


So if God is not speaking with His own worshipers but promised us that it's our unity and peace that will serve as proof of His presence in our midst {Isaiah 2:2-4} how do you expect Him to start speaking with atheists who don't even believe He exists?
For what purpose?

OK because He lacks worshipers who will inherit what He promised shey?


You people are just funny!
Re: On The Origin of Evil by TheDevilsBride(f): 4:13pm On Feb 08, 2025
MaxInDHouse:
Mr & Mrs Atheists!
God doesn't speak to anyone who don't believe in His existence Paul believe God exists the reason why he was fighting those he thought were impostors unlike you people saying "there is no god"

So bring the example of someone who doesn't believe that God exists and how God spoke to such a person then i will agree with you that you know what you are demanding. wink
Smh, you always want to the move the goalposts, whenever you're losing steam on a particular line of conversation, lol. You just hop on to another argument like an overly excited monkey. I don't remember anyone here, remotely implying that Paul was an atheist, so that's just an absurd, defensive pivot you've conjured from the ether. We were simply talking about Paul, and whether he was challenging God's authority. I'm not even going to indulge your ridiculous demand for examples of God speaking to atheists, as it's entirely irrelevant to our original discussion about Paul's opposition to divine will. God speaking to atheists or not, has absolutely zero bearing on whether Paul was truly opposing God's authority, while believing in His existence.

Meanwhile, since you seem so fond of biblical references, why don't we talk about the fact that even the demons believe in God's existence?>>>

You believe that there is one God. Good! Even the demons believe that—and shudder.
- James 2:19 NIV

This one is not KJV, so you have no excuse, lmao grin.

Belief in existence ≠ alignment with authority.
Re: On The Origin of Evil by LordReed(m): 7:06pm On Feb 08, 2025
MaxInDHouse:
Mr & Mrs Atheists!
God doesn't speak to anyone who don't believe in His existence Paul believe God exists the reason why he was fighting those he thought were impostors unlike you people saying "there is no god"

So bring the example of someone who doesn't believe that God exists and how God spoke to such a person then i will agree with you that you know what you are demanding. wink
Yet he doesn't talk to the Muslims or the Hindus. Abegi find another excuse this one don enter soakaway.
Re: On The Origin of Evil by MaxInDHouse(m): 7:45pm On Feb 08, 2025
TheDevilsBride:
Meanwhile, since you seem so fond of biblical references, why don't we talk about the fact that even the demons believe in God's existence?
LordReed:
Yet he doesn't talk to the Muslims or the Hindus. Abegi find another excuse this one don enter soakaway.
In ancient times that God do speak to people it's only those who believe in His existence, demons believe God exists as they have heard Him several times before their rebellion, Muslims, Hindu and all other religionists believe in the existence of God/Gods.

What i asked you guys is to provide the Bible verse where God spoke to someone because the person demanded it.

You atheists are fond of demanding God should speak to you whereas God never did that for anyone just to prove His existence that's why i said there's no need claiming God never existed simply because you haven't heard or seen Him.

In ancient times the reason why He sends messengers to tell others what He wants them to do is because He only speak to believers not just someone who claims He must see or hear Him to believe He exists! wink
Re: On The Origin of Evil by MaxInDHouse(m): 7:56pm On Feb 08, 2025
After the flood God spoke only to Abraham who was a worshiper of other gods along with his father and relatives as for Job God never spoke to him until Satan failed woefully to break the man's integrity.
So if Job stood his ground despite the fact that he never heard God's voice at any time before his trial how come you atheists who doesn't even believe in God's existence are demanding He must speak with you? wink
Re: On The Origin of Evil by LordReed(m): 9:44pm On Feb 08, 2025
MaxInDHouse:
In ancient times that God do speak to people it's only those who believe in His existence, demons believe God exists as they have heard Him several times before their rebellion, Muslims, Hindu and all other religionists believe in the existence of God/Gods.

What i asked you guys is to provide the Bible verse where God spoke to someone because the person demanded it.

You atheists are fond of demanding God should speak to you whereas God never did that for anyone just to prove His existence that's why i said there's no need claiming God never existed simply because you haven't heard or seen Him.

In ancient times the reason why He sends messengers to tell others what He wants them to do is because He only speak to believers not just someone who claims He must see or hear Him to believe He exists! wink
Always changing mouth. First you said the god doesn't speak to people opposing him. Next it was the god only speaks to people who believe. Now it is he won't speak to someone de.anding him to show himself. Of course your god is the ultimate champion of hide and seek. Boju boju god. LoLz.
Re: On The Origin of Evil by MaxInDHouse(m): 5:50am On Feb 09, 2025
LordReed:
Always changing mouth. First you said the god doesn't speak to people opposing him. Next it was the god only speaks to people who believe. Now it is he won't speak to someone de.anding him to show himself. Of course your god is the ultimate champion of hide and seek. Boju boju god. LoLz.
Instead of humbly admitting you people erred in your judgement you just want to hide under LOGIC.
The one and only God who revealed the secret of the supernaturals is JEHOVAH the Bible God, He made it clear to us that no spirit will say anything to you or appear to you if you don't believe in spirits but stay away from those who are favored by spirits because dragging what their God/gods gave them with such a person or people may lead to your destruction whether you believe or not.
That's what the Bible teach there is no instance in the Bible from Genesis to Revelation where any God/gods appear or spoke to someone who just demands seeing or hearing from them. Period! wink
Re: On The Origin of Evil by MaxInDHouse(m): 6:47am On Feb 09, 2025
The only nation God consistently prove His presence to by speaking and acting is the Israelites.
After delivering them from slavery in the land of Egypt God told the Israelites:

"Now if you will strictly obey my voice and keep my covenant, you will certainly become my special property out of all peoples, for the whole earth belongs to me," Exodus 19:5

He told Moses to assemble the entire families of Israel before Him for them to hear Him speak directly from the mountains. Exodus 19:10-13

That was how God spoke directly to an assembly of people for the first time ever by telling them His commandments. Exodus 20:1-17

They have to beg Moses to go and speak with God alone because they are afraid. Exodus 20:18-19

After centuries their descendants were confused as to whether Baal is the true God or Jehovah because false prophets in Israel under Ahab and Jezebel misled the people to worship Baal this is the second time Jehovah proved Himself by answering with fire. 1kings 18:38-39

The last time Jehovah spoke directly from heaven to prove Himself is when Jesus got tired of the stubbornness of the Jews and he said to Jehovah:

"Father, glorify your name" John 12:28a

And Jehovah responded to His son:

“I have glorified it and will glorify it again." John 12:28b

Jesus said his father did that not for him but for those unbelieving Jews to know that he (Jesus) is the Christ! John 12:30

From all these experiences it's clear that God has done what you people are demanding but only for Israelites and they aren't atheists rather they were confused having false religious leaders misleading them.

So who are you people to demand for what God has done several times for a nation yet the entire nation refused to gain wisdom?

He will no longer speak or act in behalf of anyone who just feel too big to take the instructions He gave through His faithful representatives! Luke 16:29-31
Re: On The Origin of Evil by LordReed(m): 7:24am On Feb 09, 2025
MaxInDHouse:
Instead of humbly admitting you people erred in your judgement you just want to hide under LOGIC.
The one and only God who revealed the secret of the supernaturals is JEHOVAH the Bible God, He made it clear to us that no spirit will say anything to you or appear to you if you don't believe in spirits but stay away from those who are favored by spirits because dragging what their God/gods gave them with such a person or people may lead to your destruction whether you believe or not.
That's what the Bible teach there is no instance in the Bible from Genesis to Revelation where any God/gods appear or spoke to someone who just demands seeing or hearing from them. Period! wink
It's you who needs to humble himself and admit you goofed and had to switch tracks several times. I bet you a million dollars if we had found an example to counter you last excuse, you would have reached for yet another. That is not a sign of honesty or humility.
Re: On The Origin of Evil by TheDevilsBride(f): 7:28am On Feb 09, 2025
MaxInDHouse:
In ancient times that God do speak to people it's only those who believe in His existence, demons believe God exists as they have heard Him several times before their rebellion, Muslims, Hindu and all other religionists believe in the existence of God/Gods.

What i asked you guys is to provide the Bible verse where God spoke to someone because the person demanded it.

You atheists are fond of demanding God should speak to you whereas God never did that for anyone just to prove His existence that's why i said there's no need claiming God never existed simply because you haven't heard or seen Him.

In ancient times the reason why He sends messengers to tell others what He wants them to do is because He only speak to believers not just someone who claims He must see or hear Him to believe He exists! wink
It's almost poetic, that within four pages, you've managed to demonstrate four distinct ways, in which your capacity for logical thinking leaves much to be desired, lol.

So far, you have:

1> Cherry-picked biblical examples to support your claim, whilst ignoring those that counter it ✓
2> Moved the goalposts whenever you've conceded too many points on an argument ✓
3> Created strawman arguments to misrepresent what I and LordReed have been saying ✓
4> Displayed a profound, and pathetic lack of understanding about the actual nature of evidence and empirical inquiry ✓

If it wasn't clearer now than ever, that you don't care about honesty in your arguments, it sure is now. You've managed to embarrass yourself, over and over again, reinforcing every negative stereotype people have, about JW shills and Christian apologists in general. But keep going, don't let me stop you. I'm interested too see what next you're going to pull out, from your worn out bag of tricks, lmao.
Re: On The Origin of Evil by MaxInDHouse(m): 8:33am On Feb 09, 2025
LordReed:
It's you who needs to humble himself and admit you goofed and had to switch tracks several times. I bet you a million dollars if we had found an example to counter you last excuse, you would have reached for yet another. That is not a sign of honesty or humility.
TheDevilsBride:
Cherry-picked biblical examples to support your claim, whilst ignoring those that counter it.
You guys are very funny walahi talahi!

Challenging God's authority to you mean someone who is fighting for his own God against another God whereas in reality it means someone who doesn't believe in the existence of supernatural because whether it's the God of Israel or that of Greek they are all Gods so you can't equate such a person with you guys.

Do you get it now? smiley
Re: On The Origin of Evil by LordReed(m): 8:38am On Feb 09, 2025
MaxInDHouse:
You guys are very funny walahi talahi!

Challenging God's authority to you mean someone who is fighting for his own God against another God whereas in reality it means someone who doesn't believe in the existence of supernatural because whether it's the God of Israel or that of Greek they are all Gods so you can't equate such a person with you guys.

Do you get it now? smiley
Stop flogging the already dead horse.
Re: On The Origin of Evil by MaxInDHouse(m): 8:52am On Feb 09, 2025
LordReed:
Stop flogging the already dead horse.
God never spoke to anyone who doesn't believe in the existence of supernaturals! wink
Re: On The Origin of Evil by TheDevilsBride(f):
MaxInDHouse:
You guys are very funny walahi talahi!
It's flattering that even you, find our evisceration of your ridiculous arguments amusing grin.

Challenging God's authority to you mean someone who is fighting for his own God against another God
Still confusing yourself, I see. Challenging God's authority means questioning or opposing the will or commands of a deity. It has absolutely nothing, nada, zilch, to do with fighting on behalf one god, against another. You're trying your best, but it's not enough cheesy.

whereas in reality it means someone who doesn't believe in the existence of supernatural because whether it's the God of Israel or that of Greek they are all Gods so you can't equate such a person with you guys.
The way some of you so-called Christians completely disregard, sabotage your theology, just to create your own narratives, will never stop being funny to me, lol. Are you alleging that even believers, can not question God's will, or his authority, whenever they experience something that rattles them? Are you denying what the average Christian calls "spiritual struggles"? Be careful how you approach this question, as there are Christians that might be following this here exchange, lmao.

Do you get it now? smiley
I get that you're stranded, flailing about, trying to hold on to your sunken ship of an argument. I get that you're so desperate, you can't help but shift the goalposts and change the subject, whenever you encounter a glaring contradiction you can't reconcile. I get that you're wilfully dishonest, and are only interested in asserting your lies, with total disregard for honest and valid criticism. I get that you've lost the plot totally, and that you're losing this argument, and losing it badly, lol.
Re: On The Origin of Evil by LordReed(m): 10:35am On Feb 09, 2025
MaxInDHouse:
God never spoke to anyone who doesn't believe in the existence of supernaturals! wink
LoLz. Which says a lot more than you think. You are actually confirming that your god is nothing but a figment of your imagination. Bwahahahahahahaha!
Re: On The Origin of Evil by MaxInDHouse(m): 1:25pm On Feb 09, 2025
TheDevilsBride:
Challenging God's authority means questioning or opposing the will or commands of a deity.
Bible God performed signs to prove that He is the Almighty as those challenging His authority believes they have options when it comes to the God they will obey.
But in the case of you people there's nothing to establish so God won't show you any sign He will neither speak not act! wink

LordReed:
You are actually confirming that your god is nothing but a figment of your imagination. Bwahahahahahahaha!
So back to where you belong after seeing that God never did what you are demanding! wink
Re: On The Origin of Evil by LordReed(m): 1:31pm On Feb 09, 2025
MaxInDHouse:
Bible God performed signs to prove that He is the Almighty as those challenging His authority believes they have options when it comes to the God they will obey.
But in the case of you people there's nothing to establish so God won't show you any sign He will neither speak not act! wink


So back to where you belong after seeing that God never did what you are demanding! wink
I wasn't the one changing mouth upandan.
Re: On The Origin of Evil by MaxInDHouse(m): 1:37pm On Feb 09, 2025
LordReed:
I wasn't the one changing mouth upandan.
God never spoke nor act for an atheist He only act to help worshipers of lesser Gods know that the Almighty is around but when you have no ground He will never succumb to your demand! wink
Re: On The Origin of Evil by LordReed(m): 2:07pm On Feb 09, 2025
MaxInDHouse:
God never spoke nor act for an atheist He only act to help worshipers of lesser Gods know that the Almighty is around but when you have no ground He will never succumb to your demand! wink
Mmmhmm, like I said a figment of your imagination.
Re: On The Origin of Evil by MaxInDHouse(m): 2:12pm On Feb 09, 2025
LordReed:
Mmmhmm, like I said a figment of your imagination.
Yet you've been quoting the Bible to prove that you have something tangible to say before! smiley
Re: On The Origin of Evil by TheDevilsBride(f): 2:13pm On Feb 09, 2025
MaxInDHouse:
Bible God performed signs to prove that He is the Almighty as those challenging His authority believes they have options when it comes to the God they will obey.
But in the case of you people there's nothing to establish so God won't show you any sign He will neither speak not act! wink
That's not exactly a ringing endorsement of his omnipotence, though. So we're back to the question I asked you earlier, if your God clearly lacks omnipotence, then why is he called "God"? Can you give a sufficient answer this time, lol?
Re: On The Origin of Evil by MaxInDHouse(m): 2:15pm On Feb 09, 2025
TheDevilsBride:
That's not exactly a ringing endorsement of his omnipotence, though. So we're back to the question I asked you earlier, if your God clearly lacks omnipotence, then why is he called "God"? Can you give a sufficient answer this time, lol?
Back and forth shey? cheesy

He is ALMIGHTY not OMNIPOTENT! wink
Re: On The Origin of Evil by DeepSightZ:
TheDevilsBride:
I'm not sure why you've deemed it necessary, to commence your elucidation, with a preemptive strike against quantum physics. I feel like if there's any aspect, that could potentially contribute to the debate, it shouldn't be thrown out, or merely handwaved aside, without good cause. But at any rate, let's move on...
[*Prays against ban]

Thank you my friend. The reason I have taken this "pre-emptive" strike against quantum physics is simple: much of it remains in the realm of speculation and conjecture still - and even that which is certain about it is mired in deep uncertainty - surely you know this. Einstein described it as "spooky action at a distance" which was a way of indicating that it was something that still appeared to be in the realm of magic and phantoms. This is not to say that there isnt value there, it is simply to say that the science of quantum physics is still at such an elementary and rudimentary stage as yet , such that no one can claim to understand it. It will therefore be very shaky grounds on which to base concrete arguments on existential issues - especially when we are dealing with something so intrinsic to our reality as causality.

No one, for example, will rely on quantum physics in our daily life to avoid the direct consequences of their actions and the dictates of causality as we know them. It is easy enough to make a vague statement such as "towards or close to the beginning of the universe, the laws of physics as we know them break down" and thereby seek to magically invoke quantum physics to fill the gap. I humbly submit that this is no better than the "God of the gaps" which atheists often accuse religionists of. Where you dont understand something, you invoke the fairy of quantum physics as an escape. That will not do please.

This honestly sounds like a sneaky "reframing" of the KCA, that actually makes it worse, tbh. No triggers are necessary and/or required, to make my coffee cold in the morning, it's simply just a natural manifestation of the laws of thermodynamics. You can't just smuggle in assumptions about the nature of causality, from our medium-sized, medium-speed, everyday experiences, and apply them to every single phenomenon, under the sun, lmao.
As I said yesterday, I find the bold most worrisome, and statements such as that, however you may try to excuse them, are the fastest way to chase me away from a conversation. I saw that you tried to make a distinction between "nothing" and "no triggers" the other day and to be honest that only wearied me more. Because fundamentally, I am certain you know the point is that there is a cause, whatever you may describe it as - a drive towards equilibrium, the laws of thermodynamics, whatever. There is a cause and that is the point. And once there is a cause it is patently absurd to say there is no "trigger."

It occurred to me though, that perhaps by "trigger" you think I mean the agency of a person. If that is the case, please perish the thought. I am not saying that. And this goes for LordReed as well, for he said he doubts "it is the cause I am reaching for" - if either of you think that by "trigger" I refer to the agency of a person - kindly know that I do not. A trigger is simply a predeceing cause, an event or even state of affairs that causes something to happen.

This may be a good juncture at which to clarify that I dont know if the God that I am saying necessarily exists is personal, has self awareness or identity. I only know that it is something that necessarily and logically must exist for any other thing to exist. In philosophy, it is called a neccessary thing, as oppposed to a contingent thing. In philosophy, necessary things necessarily exist. I have said already that for me, infinite space and eternal time are necessary things. And therefore components of God.

I'll need to clear up a subtle, albeit unstated misconception here, before we venture too far into the deep end, and waste further time: LordReed already pointed this out, but I'll reiterate, for the avoidance of doubt, that our universe isn't an object IN space and time - it IS space, time, and everything else.
If the universe is itself space and time and everything else, into what is it expanding?
Dwell carefully on this question because it is at the very centre of much that is important in this discussion.

In fact, the many bans I received were on account of trying to post a link to an old thread where this question was discussed at length.

More importantly, we cannot pretend to know if it even "started" at all, in the first place, given that the singularity is a mathematical artifact where our current physics breaks down, and not necessarily a starting point. Planck time? Anyone?
Current best science does say that the universe had a beginning, that it expanded from the point of a singularity and that is why an age is ascribed to the universe.

Circular reasoning, my dear. Now, watch this: Ever heard the term "googwump"? No? If I define "googwump" as "everything that exists", then by definition, anything causing this googwump can't exist! Does it sound like I'm off my meds yet, lmao? If so, I hope, with all duly accorded respect and no offense intended, you can see how some of you folks sound, whenever you start these semantic games. Most of you define, or at least, seem to think of causation in the exact same way you'd think about billiard balls hitting each other. Quantum mechanics (you saw this coming, didn't you grin?) shows us that causation at the fundamental level, is absolutely nothing like our everyday life experience.
I have already explained in my intro why I cannot accept the escape of "quantum" physics or mechanics.
It explains and says nothing and is nothing but an escape.

By the way, you may believe that this universe is all that exists, but I certainly do not. And if you are to scale this hurdle you have to first tell me what the universe is expanding into.

Please dont say "nothingness" as that will take us too far out too sea, given that nonthingness, by definition, does not exist.

Smh, this is textbook special pleading, and "transcendental" is such an obtuse weasel word, void of any actual explanatory power.
There is nothing obsfucatory about the word "transcendental," it simply means that which transcends or is beyond something else.

...except you can't logically deduce anything, after making several logical leaps.

I was satisfied when I read this, as it seemed as though we've finally managed to find a mutual ground in this conversation. What I didn't expect though, was for you to mutate this reasonable observation you've just made into something far less reasonable below...
I dont expect you to just agree with me or even follow what I am trying to say. Remember I told you I have been at this for 16 years on this board with no success in terms of getting any skeptic to see what I am propounding so know that its really not every point that can be elucidated to conclusion. Somethings which are simple and obvious to me may be invisible to you and vice versa and I have learnt that quite often one has to leave it at that.

Here we can see you're still making stuff up. Can you elucidate how exactly you came about the knowledge of what non-physical things are, or aren't subject to? Have you perhaps, done extensive empirical studies of non-physical things? Do you possess a large, extensive database of non-physical objects to compare? Or are you just asserting properties about something you've invented, to solve an imaginary problem you've also invented, lmao?
Are you a strict materialist? Do you believe that only physical things exist and non-physical things do not exist?

Have you counted, just to make sure, hmmm? Besides, why is an infinite regress any more problematic to you, than your proposed solution of an eternal, uncaused cause? Ironically, the concept of "infinity" exists, for the exact purpose of questioning our intuitions, about what we think is possible.
Infinity by definition cannot be numbered. And surely it must occur to you that if there were an infinite regress of causes, no event will ever occur and no universe will ever exist. Do I have to break this down? Please dont ask me, try look up the subject in philosophy.

Mate, you're piling on every conceivable attribute, that would exempt your proposed entity from the inconvenience of having to explain itself.
Those attrributes are logically deduced. I hope you notice they do not include religious attributes such as ominiscient, omnipotent, omnipresent, good, kind, loving, merciful, forgiving, just etc.

On a lighter note, if our creator(s) have any personal attributes, I have often reflected that sadism must be one.

Again, circular logic. You cannot define something into existence by merely giving it the property of "necessary existence". Reality doesn't quite work like that, my dear.

. . . .

I'm sorry, but you're still just playing philosophical mad libs. You've taken two mathematical concepts that, for some reason, you don't seem to understand properly, and granted them mystical properties out of nowhere. Do you therefore, suppose that we should ascribe divinity to numbers? Afterall, zero and pi, are both "uncreated and self-existent", isn't it? Look, let's not get carried away here. Infinity and eternity are human concepts that we use to describe limitlessness. That's all there is to it, my dear.
I dont think you are familiar with the philosophical precepts of necessary and contingent things.
Time, for example is a necessary thing. So is space. Neither of these things can fail to exist. They are intrinsically basic to existence. They are the default state of reality.
Re: On The Origin of Evil by TheDevilsBride(f): 2:16pm On Feb 09, 2025
MaxInDHouse:
Bible God performed signs to prove that He is the Almighty as those challenging His authority believes they have options when it comes to the God they will obey.
But in the case of you people there's nothing to establish so God won't show you any sign He will neither speak not act! wink
Also, you've portrayed your God here as lacking infinite goodness. In that case, what then makes him a source of morality?
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Reply

The Origin Of Freemasonry Is North Africa Sex Worship And Human Sacrifice • What Is Your View As To The Origin Of Life? • Atheist Is An Open Declaration Of Evil Intent? Discuss? • 2 • 3 • 4

Has There Been Anyone Who Became An Atheist By Reading Arguments On NL? • Top Five Reasons why God Didn't Create The Universe • Ex-muslim Who Became A Christian Tells Us Everything...