₦airaland Forum

SSpeter:
2024 is already gone, hence Martin should go to court to demand the 2025 budget be presented before him 😂

The supreme court has ruled on the matter despite Fubara's team wanting to withdraw their appeal before the court.

What this means is that Fubara acted contrary to the constitution by :

1. Presenting the budget before a House that did not meant up to the minimum members that should form a quorum.

2. By the judgement above, that means the suspended members are expected to resume back to their sits in the House and you should expect them to first sack the current five man kangaroo assembly and reinstate the former Speaker. After this is done, Fubara will face impeachment for operating an illegal budget for the fiscal year 2024.

Dem dey set trap for Fubara.

Judolisco:
who will d state government pay the money to?

Guy many youths mumu no be small, bunch of ignorant things, no wonder they are suffering in the abundance of water, the fool is thirsty.

What a rat race.

caracas:
Oga stop wasting your time explaining nonsense... APC have has taught everyone to interpret judgements as they do please ...
Fubara will interpret this as he so wishes n nothing will happen....

stop masturbating and be serious for once, fubara is jerking right now

SSpeter:
2024 is already gone, hence Martin should go to court to demand the 2025 budget be presented before him 😂

Same 2024 budget that all 3 courts from the High, Appeal & Supreme have ruled was null & void ab initio?

Fubara is just a confirmed DUNCE.

SSpeter:
Supreme Court has to dismiss the case because the budget can no longer be represented ( it is a void case, it is like getting a ruling to make a contractor build your house, but the contractor went to the court to challenge the ruling, while the case was on the contractor filed bankruptcy), and withdrew his challenge. What do you want the court to rule on? The contractor can no longer fulfill that requirement hence the court will dismiss his challenge. 2024 is gone with the wind

Supreme Court dismissed the case??

Fubara withdraw his appeal nah......abeg read the judgement again ooo.

Fubara appeal judgement against him.....he withdrew talk say hin no do case again which automatically means he accepts the previous judgement.


I guess you didn't read the post.

SSpeter:
There is nothing left to adjudicate, 2024 is gone hence Fubara case will be dismissed ( Fubara has already implemented budget, case closed). Martin should now request through the courts that 2025 budget be presented before him

it doesn't work that way, dis ruling as already affirmed him as speaker... That's why I'm asking who will fubara pay 2 million to and nobody is answering me

Bobodee09:
Supreme Court dismissed the case??

Fubara withdraw his appeal nah......abeg read the judgement again ooo.

Fubara appeal judgement against him.....he withdrew talk say hin no do case again which automatically means he accepts the previous judgement.


I guess you didn't read the post.

Don’t mind that obnoxiously dull Thing.

yarimo:
Never ever allow Obidients to support you oo e get why 🤣🤣

Laughing at your own calamity is the worst form of deformity....😁😁

Arostar2023:
Nawa oO. Nigeria is in serious trouble, if the so called masses cannot read in between the lines despite claiming to be educated. This is a masterstroke from Fubara. He knew from the beginning that he was going to win the case, yet he took it to court to buy time. This is 2025. 2024 budget has all been implemented...money spent. Which was what he was after in the first place.

You are wrong on many fronts. Number one the faction recognised is not the one aligned to him. Number two it is an impeachable offence to spend without a budget. If I am not mistaken I think it has even been criminalised. Meaning his accountant general can be picked up and jailed.

alfajohn:
You are wrong on many fronts. Number one the faction recognised is not the one aligned to him. Number two it is an impeachable offence to spend without a budget. If I am not mistaken I think it has even been criminalised. Meaning his accountant general can be picked up and jailed.

arostar2023 u should be very ashamed of yourself for exhibiting such a level. I hope u have been informed, your exhibition must be amongst the height of cluelessness? Tufiakpa.

APCHaram:
No. It's you that is basking in your own ignorance.

The fact that the plaintiffs requested that the case be struck out and dismissed despised Fubara officially withdrawing the suit before the Supreme Court should tell you that a legal precedence and court ruling has been established from the High Court up to the Supreme Court. And the ruling being that Fubara erred in presenting the 2024 appropriation budget for Rivers state before a five man assembly is null and void.

What this means going forward is that Fubara can not present the budget for 2025 to his five man assembly and must thus recognise and present the 2025 budget before the full house with the remaining 27 members of the House reinstated and included in the day to day activities of the House.


That is an automatic win for the plaintiffs who will now storm the Rivers assembly and begin impeachment moves on the Speaker and other remaining four members. From there, the reinstated speaker will now begin the process of removing Fubara from office for passing the appropriation budget without the House as stated in the Supreme court ruling.

Like I said earlier, Fubara knew all these already. He knew he will be thrashed in court, hence the appeal. He cannot represent 2024 budget. So he won in that aspect.

EmeeNaka:
This case is no longer useful to Fubara as 2024 budget is fully spent and concluded. This is 2025. If Amaewule want Fubara to present 2025 budget to him, he should go back to Federal high court to start new application

The ruling by the Supreme court has affirmed that Fubara operated an illegal budget for 2024.

If you think this has passed, you need your head examined.

Going forward , Fubara can not repeat what he did in 2024 in the 2025 appropriation bill .

He is screwed . The Apex court, by this ruling which Fubara's team attempted to avoid by withdrawing their appeal before the court, has made it clear that the 2024 Appropriation Bill for Rivers state was illegal.

There's a reason why Fubara's team attempted to withdraw their appeal, and that was because they intended to repeat the same illegality in 2025 and then refile the appeal at the supreme court at a convenient date in future so as to continue operating the budget as they did with that of 2024.

blacknp:
arostar2023 u should be very ashamed of yourself for exhibiting such a level. I hope u have been informed, your exhibition must be amongst the height of cluelessness? Tufiakpa.

I don't know what you are talking about. I am not a Fubara fan neither am I a Wike's fan. I am simply analysing the case. If you have a superior argument bring it on, so that others can learn. Btw, you u are the one that should be ashamed of yourself.

EmeeNaka:
This case is no longer useful to Fubara as 2024 budget is fully spent and concluded. This is 2025. If Amaewule want Fubara to present 2025 budget to him, he should go back to Federal high court to start new application

This is not true

The case is not centred around the date 2024 but rather what constitutes defection and whether a minority can ratify legislation contrary to the constitution.

To think that the respondents has to go back and start again in 2025 is layman's thinking. The SC rulings have general application.

The word "dismissed" is important as well because there is a differen between dismissal and striking out - which is usually for procedural defects and which do not preclude the apellant coming back again.

Any state house must take notice of the ruling at the Appeal court level at the minimum.

Arostar2023:
Like I said earlier, Fubara knew all these already. He knew he will be thrashed in court, hence the appeal. He cannot represent 2024 budget. So he won in that aspect.

Yes Fubara has won in his foolishness, he has given the 26 member house the reason to impeach him for spending money that was not duly appropriated.

Arostar2023:
I don't know what you are talking about. I am not a Fubara fan neither am I a Wike's fan. I am simply analysing the case. If you have a superior argument bring it on, so that others can learn. Btw, you u are the one that should be ashamed of yourself.

Next time , learn to read other people's comment here before rushing to expose your stark ignorance.

APCHaram:
Next time , learn to read other people's comment here before rushing to expose your stark ignorance.

The level of ignorance that dude shamelessly exhibited is appalling.

Fubara is a confirmed Mumu, must they go down the pit with him?

Arostar2023:
Like I said earlier, Fubara knew all these already. He knew he will be thrashed in court, hence the appeal. He cannot represent 2024 budget. So he won in that aspect.

But he can be held accountable by the House for operating an illegal budget for the year 2024.

blacknp:
The level of ignorance that dude shamelessly exhibited is appalling.

Fubara is a confirmed Mumu, must they go down the pit with him?

Seriously, what was Fubara thinking ?

If he wanted to fight Wike, he should have splashed money on the aggrieved House Assembly Members and make them his own men.

The constitution does not allow for a one man show at any level of the executive branch from LGA to State to Federal, there must be checks and balances.

APCHaram:
Next time , learn to read other people's comment here before rushing to expose your stark ignorance.

Stark ignorance, you say? Everyone mustn't agree with you, and everyone mustn't think you have great perspectives to issues. Humble yourself and learn from others too.

Nemere2020:
https://www.thisdaylive.com/index.php/2025/02/10/scourt-dismisses-fubaras-appeal-against-judgment-ordering-representation-of-2024-budget-to-amaewhule-led-assembly/?amp

Misleading title. “The case was dismissed after Fubara withdrew it”. Abeg make this make sense. Oluwole propaganda mill on overdrive

Arostar2023:
Stark ignorance, you say? Everyone mustn't agree with you, and everyone mustn't think you have great perspectives to issues. Humble yourself and learn from others too.

Pls tells us how this is in any way a win for Fubara when the Supreme Court has ruled that the 2024 Appropriation Act did not meet up to the constitutional process of getting a budget approval.


Pls, tell me how Fubara won with this supreme court ruling that has affirmed the decisions of the High Court and Appeal court that Fubara was dragged to by the aggrieved House Assembly Members?

Someone lost a case from the High court all the way up to the Supreme court and an illegality was established on his side and for some reason you say this is a "win"?

Pls, let me learn from you how and when Fubara "won".


I am waiting

EmeeNaka:
This case is no longer useful to Fubara as 2024 budget is fully spent and concluded. This is 2025. If Amaewule want Fubara to present 2025 budget to him, he should go back to Federal high court to start new application

Damn, that guy go tey for Prison, EFCC will feast on him if he doesn't win second term. Thats when he'll know the G in FG is not the same with the one in state government. How can you who is UNDER LAW, present a budget to a 5 man house of assembly against a 27 members house of assembly. Dude will cry REAL TEARS by the time a battalion of soldiers descend on him if he doesnt win SECOND TERM which he's not going to win. Wike will not even let that happen. BETTER START IMPORTING YOUR MUNITIONS IN CASE YOU SUPPORT FUBARA.

He's lucky Tinubu is not even like Obasanjo.

APCHaram:
Pls tells us how this is in any way a win for Fubara when the Supreme Court has ruled that the 2024 Appropriation Act did not meet up to the constitutional process of getting a budget approval.


Pls, tell me how Fubara won with this supreme court ruling that has affirmed the decisions of the High Court and Appeal court that Fubara was dragged to by the aggrieved House Assembly Members?

Someone lost a case from the High court all the way up to the Supreme court and an illegality was established on his side and for some reason you say this is a "win"?

Pls, let me learn from you how and when Fubara "won".


I am waiting

Stop rushing to comment before reading in between the lines. Fubara, yea,was clutching at a straw. He needed money to spend and buy time to fight...he got what he wanted. Call it whatever you want.

Does this imply that Fubara spent money in 2024 without a budget?

Does this constitute an impeachable offence in 2025?

APCHaram:
Seriously, what was Fubara thinking ?

If he wanted to fight Wike, he should have splashed money on the aggrieved House Assembly Members and make them his own men.

The constitution does not allow for a one man show at any level of the executive branch from LGA to State to Federal, there must be checks and balances.

The man is very useless weak man that was given power on a platter, the prosperity of fools will definitely destroy them, immediately he got the power he became fixated on betraying & undermining those that made him Governor of The State.

Arostar2023:
Stop rushing to comment before reading in between the lines. Fubara, yea,was clutching at a straw. He needed money to spend and buy time to fight...he got what he wanted. Call it whatever you want.

Deliberating delaying to buy time? what nonsense, buy time to spend an illegal budget is that what u are purportedly insinuating?

Bobodee09:
illiterate plenty for NL.

If any educated person doesn't understand that this just prove fubara is a clown then the person need to cover his/her face in shame.


Nah river state people I pity the most.....just wasting there money on useless political battles.

How does this prove Fubara is a clown

Did Rivers people ask for your pity? When Wike was using Rivers money to sponsor Aso ebi for G5 you did not pity Rivers people o

Just say you're in pains let's get bucket for your tears

Arostar2023:
Nawa oO. Nigeria is in serious trouble, if the so called masses cannot read in between the lines despite claiming to be educated. This is a masterstroke from Fubara. He knew from the beginning that he was going to win the case, yet he took it to court to buy time. This is 2025. 2024 budget has all been implemented...money spent. Which was what he was after in the first place.

Fubara is teaching zombies politics 101

blacknp:
Deliberating delaying to buy time? what nonsense, buy time to spend an illegal budget is that what u are purportedly insinuating?

Unfortunately, yes. It's now that it has been determined as "illegal" by the supreme Court. Someone once said that Nigeria was a big crime scene. A lot of unchallenged illegalities... don't feign ignorance of this fact.

Bobodee09:
Waooo that how court case works.

A judgment given at high and appeal court becomes useless.

Please oooo......are you a lawyer??

E shock you abi

When you talk about the interpretation of law in Nigeria, you should have the same mentality that the survivors of the 2nd world war have as to the where about of Adulf Hitler immediately after the war