₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: RegisterLoginWith GoogleTrendingRecentNew

Stats: 3,330,923 members, 8,447,772 topics. Date: Saturday, 18 July 2026 at 11:34 PM

Toggle theme

Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ - Politics - Nairaland

Nairaland ForumNairaland GeneralPoliticsAmnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ (3938 Views)

1 2 Reply (Go Down)

Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by zero8zero(op): 10:19am On May 31, 2025
The Defence Headquarters has strongly criticised a recent report by Amnesty International, describing it as lacking contextual depth and failing to acknowledge the significant achievements of the Nigerian Armed Forces in combating insecurity across the country.

Amnesty International had, in a report on Wednesday, raised the alarm over what it describes as the Nigerian government’s failure to protect citizens from relentless attacks by armed groups and bandits.

The human rights organisation added that at least 10,217 people have been killed and 672 villages sacked in the past two years, noting that Benue State recorded the highest number of deaths with 6,896 people killed, followed by Plateau State with 2,630 deaths.

The DHQ, in a rebuttal on Friday by the Director of Defence Media Operations, Major General Markus Kangye, expressed concern over what it called “sweeping generalisations” and “unverified statistics” in Amnesty’s report.

Kangye said that while it respects the role of civil society in promoting accountability, the report disregards the asymmetric nature of the threats facing the country and the complex socio-political context within which the Armed Forces operate.

He said, “While we acknowledge the importance of civil society in promoting accountability and human rights, we must express strong reservations about the sweeping generalisations, lack of contextual depth, and the failure of the statement to recognise the monumental strides made by the Armed Forces of Nigeria under the current administration.

“The statement paints a bleak and generalised picture of national insecurity, largely ignoring the asymmetric and evolving nature of modern threats, especially those rooted in decades of socio-political and economic complexities. While there are undeniable challenges in specific regions, DHQ.”

According to him, since President Bola Tinubu assumed office in May 2023, the military has recorded several operational milestones.

These, he said, include the neutralisation of over 5,000 insurgents and bandits, the recovery of more than 350 communities previously under terrorist control, and the rescue of over 1,200 kidnapped civilians.

“The sustained presence of troops in areas such as Maru (Zamfara), Bokkos (Plateau), and Logo (Benue) has enabled displaced persons to begin returning home under military protection.

“Rescue Operations and Hostage Recovery. In partnership with local intelligence networks, the military successfully rescued over 1,200 abducted civilians, including women and children, many of whom were kidnapped in mass abduction incidents.


“Several notorious kidnapping syndicates have been dismantled, and recovery of illegal weapons caches continues weekly,” he added.

Reacting to Amnesty’s claim that 2,630 people were killed and 167 communities displaced in Plateau State in the last two years, Kangye described the data as “a concoction of falsehood.

“The state witnessed improvements in security following a reorganisation of deployments and intensified operations since July 2023. There were no mass displacements between 2023 and 2025, contrary to Amnesty’s assertion,” he maintained.

He also dismissed as exaggerated Amnesty’s reports on the Northwest, particularly in Zamfara, Sokoto, Kebbi, and Katsina States.

“In Zamfara alone, the military reported over 2,000 offensive operations in two years, leading to the rescue of 687 abductees, the neutralisation of over 1,500 terrorists, and the destruction of bandit enclaves.

“Contrary to claims, areas such as Bafarawa and Gebe in Sokoto are within reach of military Forward Operating Bases, and joint operations have cleared bandit strongholds,” the statement added.


In Katsina, Kangye cited a recent operation in which 21 bandits were neutralised, and 77 collaborators arrested, adding that troops have been engaging communities through patrols, civil-military engagements, and intelligence-sharing.

He also contested the claim that 6,896 people were killed in Benue State, calling it “humongous and misleading.

“Our records show 693 deaths in Benue during the review period, not 6,896. Furthermore, most of the alleged displacement figures are inconsistent with ground realities. Many IDP camps are now largely empty,” the statement said.
https://punchng.com/amnesty-international-report-lacks-depth-misleading-dhq/

Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by zero8zero(op): 10:25am On May 31, 2025
A foreign group that sit in their office without being in the field with the military who are facing the war, wants me to believe their c0ck and bull stories over the credible figures of our gallant military. But watch and see how some unpatriotic elements asslick amnesty international, these elements would quickly condemn amnesty international when they release figures and condemn the genocide of Isreal war crimes in Gaza. But will believe amnesty international against their own country, talking about white slaves mentality.
God bless the Nigerian Military, God bless Nigeria.
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by Putindbutt(m): 10:36am On May 31, 2025
The mission of this group in Africa is not clear yet, they hardly condem terrorists attacks , even speak more for terrorists rights when military go hard on them.
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by patrikoolar: 12:04pm On May 31, 2025
Very informative rebuttal by the DHQ.
The army has indeed made a lot of strides in combating terrorism, no doubt.
But the Amnesty report is not entirely false too. The numbers killed are too high, regardless figures, for a functioning democracy as we are supposed to believe Nigeria is.
The Army faces the daunting task of cleaning the Augean stable of terrorism in Nigeria, but it is up to the will of the political class to see it to an expeditious end soon.
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by ephraimlongkat(m):
A foreign group that sit in their office without being in the field with the military who are facing the war, wants me to believe their c0ck and bull stories over the credible figures of our gallant military.

Hmm you mean the NGOs on the field don't know what's happening? Or don't report truth.

So u believe the number of deaths as reported by the military about Benue?
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by Brendaniel:
Shame Don catch DHQ, they are still trying to defend Tinubu...
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by israelmao(m):
When you see a reaction like this,know in the heart of your hearts that amnesty report doesn't favour them.They are still struggling with insecurity with in-depth knowledge while they said, Amnesty report lacks depth.
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by Winnin009: 12:12pm On May 31, 2025
zero8zero:
A foreign group that sit in their office without being in the field with the military who are facing the war, wants me to believe their c0ck and bull stories over the credible figures of our gallant military. But watch and see how some unpatriotic elements asslick amnesty international, these elements would quickly condemn amnesty international when they release figures and condemn the genocide of Isreal war crimes in Gaza. But will believe amnesty international against their own country, talking about white slaves mentality.
God bless the Nigerian Military, God bless Nigeria.
Lol. Bro... no vex o but this thing about dem not being on ground... no talk am for where sensible people dey o.

They have a network. A network that works with other civil societies and the red Cross. When they partner with these other groups, they get the data they need, anywhere in the world.

Bro, dem dey lose staff for this their so called mumu work(red cross worker, un aid workers, journalists)... all dey collect but they still do it.

So, please don't insult them or show your ignorance by saying they just sit on their offices... they're not our government o bro.
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by callmemakaveli:
INFORMATIVE
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by CorrectionFLuid: 12:14pm On May 31, 2025
.
Time to divide Amnesty international into factions.
.
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by Successsearch90(m): 12:24pm On May 31, 2025
How are we sure?
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by Pacesetter123(m): 12:36pm On May 31, 2025
But it was still in this forum even in other credible news sources in this country that we read that about 300 people or so were massacred in a single day in plateau alone.
I think that was early this month or sometime last month.
So going by that news,if 300 people were murdered in a single day and hundreds were displaced,and the killings are still being reported in Benue and Plateau even up till now,then the figures given by amnesty int'l may not be far from the truth.

While the efforts of our security agencies in combating the menace of terrorism and banditry are highly appreciated,that doesn't negate the fact that large scale killings are not still being reported in places like Benue and Plateau expecially till today.

So to me,the report of the amnesty int'l maybe true and the report of the DHQ maybe true also.
So,both of them are correct.
Shikina!!!
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by JuanDeDios: 12:37pm On May 31, 2025
zero8zero:
The Defence Headquarters has strongly criticised a recent report by Amnesty International, describing it as lacking contextual depth and failing to acknowledge the significant achievements of the Nigerian Armed Forces in combating insecurity across the country.
How is it AI's job to highlight the army's successes? Their job is to highlight rights violations.
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by IamANigerianMan: 12:42pm On May 31, 2025
zero8zero:
A foreign group that sit in their office without being in the field with the military who are facing the war, wants me to believe their c0ck and bull stories over the credible figures of our gallant military. But watch and see how some unpatriotic elements asslick amnesty international, these elements would quickly condemn amnesty international when they release figures and condemn the genocide of Isreal war crimes in Gaza. But will believe amnesty international against their own country, talking about white slaves mentality.
God bless the Nigerian Military, God bless Nigeria.
Armnesty international is a criminal organisation mostly use by foreign countries to distablize Africa
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by chosen6(f): 12:42pm On May 31, 2025
Very detailed report by Amnesty International showing that they did a comprehensive investigation on the subject before reporting unlike the DHQ that is just defending the indefensible.
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by JuanDeDios: 12:42pm On May 31, 2025
Winnin009:
Lol. Bro... no vex o but this thing about dem not being on ground... no talk am for where sensible people dey o.

They have a network. A network that works with other civil societies and the red Cross. When they partner with these other groups, they get the data they need, anywhere in the world.

Bro, dem dey lose staff for this their so called mumu work(red cross worker, un aid workers, journalists)... all dey collect but they still do it.

So, please don't insult them or show your ignorance by saying they just sit on their offices... they're not our government o bro.

Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by PigTormentor: 12:47pm On May 31, 2025
Amnesty Nigeria is fake.
They are not rhe same as Amnesty International which is a respectable organization world wide.
The Amnesty here are more of a political paid town crieres. There only objective is to influence political power to their own advantage.
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by fuckingAyaya(m): 12:51pm On May 31, 2025
CorrectionFLuid:
.
Time to divide Amnesty international into factions.
.
divide them into Apc and Cpc abi?
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by nedu666: 12:53pm On May 31, 2025
zero8zero:
A foreign group that sit in their office without being in the field with the military who are facing the war, wants me to believe their c0ck and bull stories over the credible figures of our gallant military. But watch and see how some unpatriotic elements asslick amnesty international, these elements would quickly condemn amnesty international when they release figures and condemn the genocide of Isreal war crimes in Gaza. But will believe amnesty international against their own country, talking about white slaves mentality.
God bless the Nigerian Military, God bless Nigeria.
You did not say this when they were releasing damning reports under Jonathan rather you supported them. Hypocrites
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by Spandau: 1:04pm On May 31, 2025
Putindbutt:
The mission of this group in Africa is not clear yet, they hardly condem terrorists attacks , even speak more for terrorists rights when military go hard on them.
It's quite simple. The group is used as a conduit pipe to channel finance and weapons to terrorists and bandits with the sole purpose of destabilizing the country so they could clandestinely run illegal mining operations of rare earth minerals in Nigeria.
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by Guyman02: 1:04pm On May 31, 2025
If you continue to focus on what western institutions think it will be difficult to achieve your goals


Russia or China or India doesn't care what Amnesty reports say when Pakistani terrorists crossed the border recently and killed Indian tourists India didn't waste time to blast them inside Pakistan
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by Psoul(m): 1:09pm On May 31, 2025
zero8zero:
A foreign group that sit in their office without being in the field with the military who are facing the war, wants me to believe their c0ck and bull stories over the credible figures of our gallant military. But watch and see how some unpatriotic elements asslick amnesty international, these elements would quickly condemn amnesty international when they release figures and condemn the genocide of Isreal war crimes in Gaza. But will believe amnesty international against their own country, talking about white slaves mentality.
God bless the Nigerian Military, God bless Nigeria.
But you will believe the same foreign body if they report that the government is doing wonderfully well even when they are not on ground to experience it.

To show how shallow, ignorant and biased you are, all these foreign bodies may not necessarily be on ground to get their facts. Same way you do not expect the president to be in everywhere to get information of things happening in his country and even in the diaspora.
So, stop disgracing yourself trying to make the report look untrue just because you want to defend the government that do not care about u.
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by ChybuzzDD(m): 1:18pm On May 31, 2025
zero8zero:
A foreign group that sit in their office without being in the field with the military who are facing the war, wants me to believe their c0ck and bull stories over the credible figures of our gallant military. But watch and see how some unpatriotic elements asslick amnesty international, these elements would quickly condemn amnesty international when they release figures and condemn the genocide of Isreal war crimes in Gaza. But will believe amnesty international against their own country, talking about white slaves mentality.
God bless the Nigerian Military, God bless Nigeria.
Go and sit down, ye ye

This æssl!ck!ng, sycöphant will believe this same Amnesty International if it reports about how IPOB massacres 10million people tomorrow.
Re: Amnesty International Report Lacks Depth, Misleading — DHQ by Lovit(m): 1:21pm On May 31, 2025
Until Gen. Markus' family members are slayed by these Bandits, his body go tell am

Its only APC and Northern Terrorist sponsors that tries to defend the Nigerian Army, The Nigerian Army is a colossal failure!

Why is it that when a community summons courage to fight back this same Army that refused to defend the people suddenly comes around to arrest the locals?

Nigerian Army is controlled by Fulani Terrorist sponsors and their agreement with PBAT is just to look away and do nothing

Same reason someone like Peter Obi will not be supported by the North, these guys always look for a compromised human that will allow them continue terrorizing the South

Nigeria is ruled by Terrorists!
1 2 Reply

Lekki Massacre: Endsars Report Lacks Credibility – Islamic GroupDHQ Reacts To Report Of Soldiers Arrested By Sunday IgbohoWelcome To Hell: Amnesty International Report On SARS In Nigeria234

Army Rescues 21 Kidnap Victims In Coordinated Operations Across Kwara And KogiReps Prescribe 2-Year Jail Term, 10 Million Fine For Dual Party MembershipIgbos’ Contribution To APC’s Victory In FCT Election Huge – Party Chieftain