I Am A Christian, But... - Christianity Etc (2) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › I Am A Christian, But... (2392 Views)
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by Moremii(op): 11:52am On Jul 06, 2025 |
MaxInDHouse:First, my calling you a pastor was just me teasing you, I didn't mean it literally Second, you'll have to do more than this to show your point instead of just breathlessly mumbling that I'm wrong. Third, my written Yoruba is not good, but the fact that it's the best response you've produced here tells me you're clueless on the overall topic. |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by Moremii(op): 11:54am On Jul 06, 2025 |
tctrills:Well that's not how I read him. He easily comes across as the most enlightened that has graced this thread so far, so I guess that's just your opinion. Like i said, I'll be waiting |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by tctrills: 11:56am On Jul 06, 2025 |
Moremii:You have made his day. I am sure he is celebrating your comments |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by tctrills: 11:58am On Jul 06, 2025 |
Moremii:Again to summarize your point because the new testament emphasized on love much more than the old, Christians worship Yaldaboath. This is your idea of sound reasoning? |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by Moremii(op): 12:02pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
Goosethetruth:Yes Sir, I'm actually very familiar with Marcion. Although the difference between I and him in terms of ideology is that I don't know if he supports the Tripartite doctrine of the pneumatic soul (spirit) from the Valentinian ideology, because I do and I believe it's perfectly explainable with relation to how people behave today. I could be wrong about Marcion there though. Maybe I missed something in my reading. Please keep reading. There'll probably be more to add here if time permits me later today. |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by Moremii(op): 12:08pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
tctrills:You're not getting my point. Are you not seeing the ontological contradictions? There's no point being reductive and summarizing what I'm saying if you're not even going to get the point. My God transcends creation. Your god actively involves himself in it and obsessively controls it through violence and law, while being prejudiced and hypocritical. If you want to insist that they're still the same "God", then you're indirectly saying that God's nature can change which will go against the doctrine of divine immutability (God is eternal). I'm sure you know this. |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by Moremii(op): 12:12pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
tctrills:Well I'm honored to have do so |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by DeepSight(m): 12:20pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
Moremii:This is so simple and so clear it is tiresome that it can be disputed. That the god of the Old Testament is really a blood thirsty pagan Jewish mountain deity is no news. And no one with a conscience could find it within themselves to worship such a barbaric entity. By contrast the teachings of Christ are illumined with higher and noble principles far beyond the highest reach of the monster of the Old Testament. I personally do not even believe that that monster existed at all, but was the creation of the patriarchal human minds who wrote it into existence with their desperation for dominion, conquest and control. I am nonetheless aware of several interesting schools of thought, some of which for example suggest that Yahweh was actually an extra terrestrial being of a sort, which, along with other aliens, participated in the early set up of mankind on Earth for very different reasons than advanced in the Bible. The school of thought you advance, which tallies with that of Yahweh being the Demiurge, is also very interesting and something I don't discountenance. |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by Moremii(op): 12:48pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
DeepSight:Indeed, your conscience serves you well to abandon the worship of such a draconian and malevolent being. I believe true gnosis begins when you start to see all these potholes in mainstream "Christianity". The only thing I might assert here though is that it is more likely that the Demiurge operates through these patriarchal human minds to warp the reality of our universe, and not the other way round. Afterall, I do believe that beings exist that transcend our known universe and govern all the forces in it. Surprisingly I think the theory of Yahweh being an extraterrestrial being technically still aligns with gnostic cosmology because the Apocryphon of John describes the Demiurge as the creator of humans in the material through genetic manipulation, and he was assisted by his archons. So I guess one could interpret this as aliens, but it's still non-human intelligence shaping our world for whatever purposes or non-purposes, haha. |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by DeepSight(m): 12:58pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
Moremii:Very well said again, nothing to dispute. You have indeed made my day, even if that be to the chagrin of tctrills. PS: The bold is eminently possible. |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by Kobojunkie: 2:11pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
A Religion that viayss of over 46,000 different interpretations/idols/images of Jesus Christ of Israel, none of them confirming with any of what He is recorded to have said if Himself, and of His Father, from about 2000 years ago. Christianity is on a roll . ![]() |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by Dtruthspeaker: 2:19pm On Jul 06, 2025*. Modified: 3:05pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
Moremii:From your response I glean that your problem in and wth Christianity is the one promoted and advertised by pastorprenuers and I perceive, something that has to do with the of testament but you have not made it clear. in which case you ought to contend with the messenger rather than lump both the message and the messenger together. |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by MaxInDHouse(m): 2:35pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
Moremii:Well the whole thread is just a joke until you can prove Yahweh to be different from the God who sent Jesus! |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by Dtruthspeaker: 2:41pm On Jul 06, 2025*. Modified: 6:16pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
Moremii:Ehen! So another of your problems is with what is called "old testament". To answer you, I ask, would you be happy if you hear a bomb was dropped on bandits/kidnappers camp? Moremii:If your salary say ₦145k is stolen, what is the just is that you would demand/require! While at it, if your wife and daughters are raped and your sons murdered, what is the just is for these things? Moremii:Since your brother and neighbour are made in the image of God, why do you complain and go to court that she stole your husband? Moremii:I don't know what you mean by Hebrew Bible but the Bible did say "An hypocrite with his mouth destroyeth his neighbour: but through knowledge shall the just be delivered." So, no where did the bible prevent people from getting knowledge where in fact it is also giving Knowledge itself |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by FreeIgboho: 2:46pm On Jul 06, 2025*. Modified: 4:25pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
DeepSight:I take it you and Moremii believe the NT. How do these excerpts below not totally contradict your thesis? Who's prophets and commandments do you think Jesus was talking about? Also, do you know that after Nicea Arianism actually became very popular and was the state religion of Europe till the 6th century? So you see, what you are leaving out of your equation is GOD! In the end the truth triumphs. Same way they couldn't eradicate Christianity because God was behind it, Nicea could do nothing unless God supported it, and God would not support it unless it was true. (Maxindhouse and Janosky, that's part of the reason you know Jesus is God). Also, you are wrong, Constantine did not manipulate Nicea. The bishops had a three-day debate after which they took a vote. Here are the scriptures (If Jesus is not of Yahweh why was he so obsessed with fulfilling everything of Yahweh?) Mathew 5 17 “Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them. 18 For truly I tell you, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished Mathew 15 24 He answered, “I was sent only to the lost sheep of Israel.” 25 The woman came and knelt before him. “Lord, help me!” she said. 26 He replied, “It is not right to take the children’s bread and toss it to the dogs.” Luke 4 “The Spirit of the Lord is on me, because he has anointed me to proclaim good news to the poor. He has sent me to proclaim freedom for the prisoners and recovery of sight for the blind, to set the oppressed free, 19 to proclaim the year of the Lord’s favor.” 20 Then he rolled up the scroll, gave it back to the attendant and sat down. The eyes of everyone in the synagogue were fastened on him. 21 He began by saying to them, “Today this scripture is fulfilled in your hearing.” Instead of pretending about Jesus of the Bible, the honest thing for you folks to do is, forget the Jesus of the Bible entirely and create a new Jesus that is devoid of Yahweh and has only elements palatable to you! |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by Dtruthspeaker: 2:51pm On Jul 06, 2025*. Modified: 4:20pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
Moremii:Did you not read that Jesus came to save mankind? From what and from Whom was He trying to save man from? Then the question is, is it justified that man should get the punishments and destruction awaiting him? With these we will know whether you speak reasonably or you are speaking because you know that are not worthy of salvation. For even Jesus too Said that He is Coming back to destroy all these who refused salvation, so running to Jesus is still not an escape, Paul's friend Demas did it and he fell by the wayside |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by Dtruthspeaker: 3:07pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
FreeIgboho:Exactly! Whose Commandments did Christ Say that people did not obey? See, people deceiving themselves with cut and join gospel |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by Moremii(op): 3:20pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
MaxInDHouse:I already did. If you can't see the proof or want to pretend that you didn't see it, then the joke is on you. |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by FreeIgboho: 3:23pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
Dtruthspeaker:Instead of pretending about Jesus of the Bible, the honest thing for them to do is, forget the Jesus of the Bible entirely and create a new Jesus that is devoid of Yahweh and has only elements palatable to them! |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by FreeIgboho: 3:26pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
Moremii:So let's see your response to my post |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by Moremii(op): 3:31pm On Jul 06, 2025*. Modified: 4:00pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
Dtruthspeaker:Then you don't understand what I've been saying since. This is more than just corrupt pastors changing and distorting pure doctrine. The real problem here is that the institutional "message" itself was compromised centuries ago from the moment the proto-orthodontists decided to join Christ's pneumatic revelation with the Hebrew scriptures. The "messenger" you are defending canonized texts that not only contradict the pneumatic gospels that existed before the Nicean Council, but served as a narrative to support their political ambitions by demanding blind obedience and submission to lies. If you want to talk about shooting the message and not the messenger, then you should know that the authentic teachings of Christ was systemically suppressed over time by the very "fathers" who claimed to preserve it. In this case, you cannot seperate the message and the messenger because the messenger has wilfully altered the true meaning of the message. |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by MaxInDHouse(m): 3:42pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
Moremii:OK now i understand you're just joking! ![]() |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by Dtruthspeaker: 4:17pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
Moremii:I have seen where you clearly show what issues are making you think this way and I addressed them. So let me more over to see how you responded to my address Modified! I see you have still not responded to my rebuttals. |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by Dtruthspeaker: 4:19pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
FreeIgboho:It is still the same pretence and self deceit. Exactly like writing your own question paper simply because you cannot answer the ones put before you. What a massive way to fail |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by Moremii(op): 4:31pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
Dtruthspeaker:Nawa. These your questions are very funny sha, but let me try and answer you. To start with, please put some context into your comparisons. Your god ordered the mass genocide of the Amorites, Jebusites, Hittites, and countless other clans in the Canaanite region in a bid to expand Israel's territory as part of his divine mandate. He explicitly ordered the killing of every living thing in those regions. So unless you have a way to justify that the women and children in all those regions are as morally bankrupt as the bandits and kidnappers you mention, you don't have any argument here and your question is irrelevant. Your god commanded the murder of women and children who have committed no crimes. And I know that even your own modern ethical intuitions recoil from this. That is why you you have no choice but to retreat into metaphors about "bandits". The true Christ consciousness never operates through mass slaughter. Mindless killing like that is purely in the domain of Yaldaboath alone, the blind fool who mistakes his own violent impulses for righteousness. So stop trying to defend genocide, you hear? Good. Dtruthspeaker:If someone steals from me, justice requires that they should face the consequences if/when they are caught. Injustice (and lack of common sense) is when I decide to punish an innocent party. Anyone who calls me a fool or a wicked person in that case has the right to do so because I have acted unfairly. Let me now ask you, since you brought up rape. If your friend raped somebody and I punished you, just because you are his friend, am I being fair to you? Is that justice in your world? If you say no, then why can't you see that this is the exact same problem your so-called "god" has? Why is he always looking for a scapegoat? Why can't he punish people directly and just leave their wives and children and generations of unborn children alone? The answer is because he's a false god. He cannot forgive freely. There always has to be a cost... a sacrifice. Dtruthspeaker:LOL. Well, that's not something I'd do personally if we want to be realistic. However, what's the problem here? People experience a lot of emotional pain because of cheating wives and husbands and thankfully, legal systems exist to address practical injustices right there in the moment but it doesn't contradict the rejection of unnecessary religious intermediaries, especially when communing directly with the divine is easily granted. Dtruthspeaker:You try. But this doesn't really address my point satisfactorily. Adam and Eve were punished from eating from the Tree of Knowledge. The builders in the Tower of Babel were confused and sabotaged by your god. Deuteronomy forbids seeking wisdom from foreign sources. There's a verse from the book of Ecclesiastes that declares that "in much wisdom is much grief". I could probably give more examples, but I'm sure you get the point. Or at least I hope you do. You have to at least admit that there's been a consistent pattern of epistemological suppression throughout the Bible today. Obviously there are passages that exalt knowledge, but they are few and far between, especially in comparison with the books that were deliberately excluded from canon. |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by MaxInDHouse(m): 4:32pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
Yahweh is the Creator of all things, Jesus is Yahweh's firstborn son so both of them have spent uncountable years together before Yahweh decided to make more creatures. He gave His only begotten Son the privilege to work with Him in the creation of other things. So by the time other things were created Yahweh made it clear to His Son that this project belongs to him (the Son) and that made this Son so happy that he began to examine all these creatures but among all the only creature that appeals to God's only begotten Son is humans! Proverbs 8:31 But then one of God's spirit sons in heaven decided to pitch his own tent separately as a God on his own {Isaiah 14:12} while still giving him the chance to experience the consequences of His actions for others to learn a lesson this spirit son convinced the first human couple to join him in the rebellion against God and he succeeded! Genesis 3:1-5 From that moment Yahweh (the ever happy God) became saddened and He regretted creating man because majority among humans proved to be like Satan (God's rebellious spirit son) Genesis 6:5-6 The only begotten Son of God couldn't stand anything that will make His father sad so as God's representative he began teaching humans how to stay clean from hurting his father emotionally {Psalms 78:41} that was why he began setting matters straight by destroying whoever stands on the way to redeem obedient mankind back to God. So all the act you might have read in the Old Testament about Yahweh being vengeful and destructive was carried out by Jesus himself that's why it was difficult for Israelites to believe him when he (Jesus) started telling them the real qualities of his father, God Himself promised the Israelites that whatever rules they got from Moses is just to correct certain things but He will send Jesus like a human to exhibit His own attributes and by that time whoever disobey Jesus will not be forgiven! Deuteronomy 18:18-19 compare to John 3:17-19 So Jesus was the angel of God who was brutally destroying anyone standing on the way to redemption you can check his comment: “Jerusalem, Jerusalem, the killer of the prophets and stoner of those sent to her—how often I wanted to gather your children together the way a hen gathers her chicks under her wings! But you did not want it" Matthew 23:37 From the above statement who was the angel of God representing Yahweh by leading the Israelites out of Egypt? Exodus 13:21; 14:19 Who was the angel that destroyed all the firstborn in Egypt? Exodus 12:29 Who was the angel that stood beside Shadrach, Meshak and Abednego in the fiery furnace? Daniel 3:24:25 Well all of you may continue to doubt it but i'm telling you today that it's the same Jesus the angel who always stands for the salvation of faithful people! Daniel 12:1 But when he's given the privilege to walk in the midst of humans as a man sent to display his father's attributes {John 14:9} this spirit son couldn't do what he was doing angrily again now he must display his father's real personality! I remember the day Pharisees came with hoodlums to arrest Jesus with clubs and weapons this same Jesus got angry and said with his old voice: “I am Jesus" John 18:6 They all fell to the ground! WHY? Because he used his original voice the archangel's voice! 1Thessalonians 4:16 So don't think Jesus is gentle it's what his father told him to do that changed him the real Jesus is a destroyer who is coming to kill all those who oppose the personality he exhibited in the first century! Luke 19:27 |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by DeepSight(m): 4:41pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
@ Moremii Assuming that the Demiurge exists as Yaldaboath, as per your posts. What is the hope of escape from Yaldaboath's physical creation, for human souls. Do you believe in reincarnation and the cycle of Samsara and do you take a Hindu approach to breaking that cycle and attaining nirvana. |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by DeepSight(m): 4:42pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
MaxInDHouse:How is an ominscient and perfect God capable of regret? Can you not see the contradiction inherent in this? |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by MaxInDHouse(m): 4:56pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
DeepSight:Please where is the highlighted written in God's word? ![]() Well God never claimed to be omniscient these are His own words: “The outcry against Sodʹom and Go·morʹrah is indeed great, and their sin is very heavy. I will go down to see whether they are acting according to the outcry that has reached me. And if not, I can get to know it.” Genesis 18:20-21 “Do not harm the boy, and do not do anything at all to him, for now I do know that you are God-fearing because you have not withheld your son, your only one, from me.” Genesis 22:12 You can read these in any version of your choice. Please is the God speaking in those verses OMNISCIENT as you people often claim? ![]() |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by DeepSight(m): 4:57pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
MaxInDHouse:Let me rephrase it. How can a perfect God take actions which he then comes to regret. |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by MaxInDHouse(m): 4:59pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
DeepSight:Before we continue, do you believe the Bible or not? ![]() |
| Re: I Am A Christian, But... by DeepSight(m): 5:00pm On Jul 06, 2025 |
MaxInDHouse:Stop this. You believe Yahweh is perfect do you not? |
Christian But Fornicating.... • Kamala Harris Claims She's A Christian But Supports Killing Babies In Abortions • The Best Prayer Position As A Christian! • 2 • 3 • 4
I Wanted To Be Known With A Church, Which One Of Them? • This Girl, 13, Recites 255 Biblical Verses Off-hand • Question For The Theologians, Atheist And Agnostics


