Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed - Politics - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed (1033 Views)
| Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by TruthHurts1(op): 4:21pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
There is no definitive historical or archaeological evidence from Mecca that confirms the existence of a figure named Oduduwa. The claim that Oduduwa, a central figure in Yoruba mythology and history, originated from Mecca is primarily based on oral traditions and certain Yoruba migration narratives, such as those recorded in Samuel Johnson’s History of the Yorubas. These narratives suggest that Oduduwa, regarded as the progenitor of the Yoruba people, migrated from Mecca due to religious conflicts, with his father, Lamurudu, being a king there. However, several factors cast doubt on this connection: 1. Lack of Archaeological or Documentary Evidence in Mecca: No records, inscriptions, or archaeological findings from Mecca or the broader Arabian Peninsula directly reference Oduduwa or a figure matching his description. Historical records from Mecca during the period in question (often placed around the 7th to 10th centuries) are sparse, and none corroborate the presence of a Yoruba-related figure. Furthermore, research questioning Mecca’s prominence in the early 7th century suggests it may not have been a significant cultural or political center at the time, which complicates claims of Oduduwa’s migration from there. 2. Yoruba Oral Traditions and Mythological Context: Yoruba traditions often blend historical and mythical elements. Some narratives describe Oduduwa as a divine or semi-divine figure who descended from the heavens to Ile-Ife, the spiritual cradle of the Yoruba, rather than migrating from a physical location like Mecca. These accounts, such as those in Ifa corpus or other Yoruba oral histories, prioritize a cosmological origin over a geographical one, suggesting the Mecca story may be a later interpolation or symbolic narrative. 3. Alternative Origins: Other Yoruba traditions and scholarly interpretations propose different origins for Oduduwa, such as from Benin (Edo) or other regional locales like Nupe, or even as an indigenous figure from Ile-Ife itself. These competing narratives, supported by local histories and archaeological findings like those at Iwo Eleru, indicate a deep Yoruba presence in West Africa predating any potential Middle Eastern migration. 4. Historical Context of the Mecca Narrative: The Mecca origin story may reflect later cultural or religious influences, possibly introduced during interactions with Islamic traders or scholars in Yorubaland from the 11th century onward. The spread of Islam in West Africa could have led to the incorporation of Mecca into Yoruba oral traditions as a prestigious or symbolic point of origin, rather than a literal one. 5. Skepticism in Scholarship: Some scholars and online discussions, such as those on platforms like Nairaland, argue that the Mecca story lacks substantiation and may be a colonial-era or post-Islamic construct. Archaeological evidence, like artifacts predating 500 BCE in Yorubaland, supports the idea of an indigenous Yoruba culture, challenging the need for an external origin like Mecca. In conclusion, while the Mecca migration story is a significant part of some Yoruba traditions, there is no concrete evidence from Mecca itself—archaeological, textual, or otherwise—to confirm Oduduwa’s existence there. The narrative appears to be more rooted in cultural, religious, or political motivations within Yoruba history than in verifiable historical records. For a deeper understanding, exploring primary Yoruba oral traditions or archaeological studies in Ile-Ife may provide more context than Mecca-based sources.
|
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by saddler: 4:27pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
Oduduwa's origin has been found. He came from Igodomigodo in present day Edo state. As at the time of Igodomigodo, Present'-day Edo was ruled by rulers who were called Ogiso which literally means king of the sky. So when Oduduwa got to ife, they asked him who he was and he told them he is a descendant of king of the sky. That's how Yoruba mythology of Oduduwa descending from the sky started. |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by Putinofrussia: 4:37pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
saddler:lol Grok was not birthed then or is Grok a soothsayer? Ok,ask him your daddy's name. ![]() Igodomi dodo koh,Igodomi Ogede ni ![]() Igodomi dodo koh,Igodomi Ogede ni Igodomi dodo koh,Igodomi Ogede ni Igodomi dodo koh,Igodomi Ogede ni ![]() |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by Racheal45: 4:42pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
saddler:Please this is wrong Ogiso has no business with oduduwa Oba was known to be connected to oduduwa not ogiso Oba is from Ile-ife They migrated same time with the awori |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by helinues: 4:43pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
Do you need a bot to confirm that for you before? That was a fairy tale story now. Those are the story likes in the so called holy books. Like Noah building a ark that would contain all the animals in the world before the greatest flood. Eventually, Lions and Antelope were caged together without any issue.. ![]() |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by Racheal45: 4:45pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
Putinofrussia: |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by saddler: 4:46pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
Racheal45:Say what you know. And learn what you dont know. The earliest writers of Yoruba history i.e Samuel Johnson wrote emphatically that Oduduwa was a foreigner to Yoruba land that he came from Egypt or Middle East. But now we know Oduduwa came from Igodomigodo. This is the reason Oranmiyan was invited to come and rule Benin because he is a descendant of Oduduwa. |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by sreamsense: 4:47pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
All these biafrans self! Like they are just seeing AI for the first time, and they are just abusing it. They have forgotten that AI is not perfect and get information from their junkies and useless information on the internet to present opinion. If you ask AI now, who will win in 2027, AI will likely tell you Obi because Obi is a social media president. AI will take information from obidients and ipob lies to predict Obi will be president which is far from the truth. Oduduwa that has gone far into universities abroad in USA, UK,Brazil etc is what this one depending on Grok to deceive himself. |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by RealityKings1: 4:53pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
TruthHurts1:Oga Grok is a computer which just came into existence of recent and most especially, Google generated informatio. So you want a computer to determine your reality and alter what existed in the past? |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by Racheal45: 4:54pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
saddler:Bro this is totally wrong Igodo has no connection with the yorubas They came to invade the Benins |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by Tochi3(m): 5:03pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
saddler: ![]()
|
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by Thereedemer: 5:52pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
TruthHurts1:You sef ask grok about the European Jesus ifhe ask us to build church and mosque and eradicate schools, hospital companies etc in Africa to worship him. |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by Thereedemer: 5:57pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
RealityKings1:I've learnt something new today New announcement Grok is now a computer. |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by seunjungle1(m): 6:37pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
If no be say na stupid dey worry the grok (and it's founder) or what did you called it.....Na now grok wey just come to existence yesterday won tell us that the study and research on Oduduwa findings was a wasted effort. |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by APOPTOSIS: 9:59pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
So GROK is now older than Nigeria too. Even older than me🤣🤣🤣 Do you Guys think at all? This is like having someone like MOSES who was never the first human on earth or never there in the beginning of world's creation write about Genesis..🤣🤣 Honestly, Nigeria now lacks people like Chuba Okadigbo |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by OSUNADC: 10:34pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
Garbage in, Garbage out!/ Being clever by half ,asking Grok if Oduduwa came from Mecca. Why not ask objective question, like what's the root of Oduduwa in Yoruba history or at least mythology. You people have started abi, I hope you will not cry too hard or accuse Yorubas of witchhunt when you get deserved clapbacks. |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by Christistruth03: 11:02pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
His Grave is in Ile Ife for anyone who wants to verify |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by Ojiofor: 11:52pm On Aug 09, 2025 |
Before nko? Na fairy tale just like another BS Eri and Israel story they are all concerted BS. |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by ottersberger(m): 1:35pm On Aug 10, 2025 |
sreamsense:So, do you really believe that Oduduwa descended from the skies?. If you believe that, then I have the Third Mainland Bridge to sell you for 500 naira. |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by Raskimonojendor: 1:43pm On Aug 10, 2025 |
saddler:Edo people believe ogiso dropped from the sky too.
|
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by BeardedMeat(m): 1:51pm On Aug 10, 2025 |
OSUNADC:Thatfairguy, zukwanike! |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by adamusuleiman1: 2:09pm On Aug 10, 2025 |
This is a dishonest thread. Op refused to post the conclusion of grok because it does not suit his agenda. Well. I asked grok the same question and below is his conclusion.
|
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by christistruth01: 2:12pm On Aug 10, 2025 |
That is not Groks only major Mess up. Oduduwa's Grave is in Ile Ife for whoever wants to verify it His Ga descendants in Ghana even named one of their Towns after him
|
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by Ofodirinwa: 2:41pm On Aug 10, 2025 |
Odududwa is a mythical allegory. Only a hardcore idiot will think this is a real human being. Didn't Oduduwa in his story invent solid land? |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by adamusuleiman1: 2:45pm On Aug 10, 2025 |
Ofodirinwa:Same way Nri is mythical too.
|
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by Tohsynetita1(m): 4:00pm On Aug 10, 2025 |
TruthHurts1:Ask it if “ you” exist. Type your name and check. I don’t know when you will understand that AI works base on past information placed there. If any information is not online, AI cannot know it at all. |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by GodPunishOsu: 4:29pm On Aug 10, 2025 |
3. Alternative Origins: Other Yoruba traditions and scholarly interpretations propose different origins for Oduduwa, such as from Benin (Edo) or other regional locales like Nupe, or even as an indigenous figure from Ile-Ife itself. These competing narratives, supported by local histories and archaeological findings like those at Iwo Eleru, indicate a deep Yoruba presence in West Africa predating any potential Middle Eastern migration.I will like you or your grok to provide evidence of any Yoruba traditions that stated that Oduduwa came from ule Ubinu, hopefully you will provide any evidence. |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by saddler: 5:19pm On Aug 10, 2025 |
Raskimonojendor:there is a difference between believing your kings come from God and actually describing how a king climbed down with chains from heaven |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by orisa37: 5:57pm On Aug 10, 2025 |
YOU HAVE NO FAITH IN GOD. YOU ARE AN ATHEIST BECAUSE YOU DO NOT BELIEVE THAT YOUR FATHER AND YOUR GRANDFATHER EVER EXISTED.L |
| Re: Grok Says There's No Evidence That Someone Called Oduduwa Ever Existed by Raskimonojendor: 8:07pm On Aug 10, 2025 |
saddler:You go explain tire. Ogiso was worst. He dropped on his head as he fell from the sky. |
See What Grok Says About Oldest Kingdom In Nigeria • Someone Called Me 30 Times To Beg For ₦3k — Adebayo Shittu Decries Poverty Rate • EndSARS: No Evidence That Soldiers Killed Anyone At Lekki Toll Gate - US • 2 • 3 • 4
Benin People And My Take On Dr Pedro Obaseki • Femi Otedola As A Toddler In 1963 In Ibadan • Breaking News- Israel Kills New Iranian Leader
