What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! - Islam (4) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Islam › What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! (10949 Views)
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by Sterope(f): 4:23pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
. |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by dederocs(m): 4:35pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
simpleseyi:Those were in barbaric times, we live in civilised times. What do most terrorists proffess now, what religion? |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by indigenous234(m): 4:37pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
I’m not sure most of these quotes are true. Eg, those attributed to Napoleon. No way that’s true. |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by olabrad: 4:46pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
simpleseyi:I challenge you to mention where people were unalived in the name of Jesus Christ |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by sreamsense: 5:08pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
simpleseyi:Out of that millions, just list 10 where they shout "in Jesus name" and killed their victims; just like " uncountable numbers of terrorists" will shout Allah Akbar and killed their victims. If only what your religion does is to buy mansions without cutting their victim heads off or stone them to death, then; we will all agree your religion is peaceful and not pieces-full |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by Munashak: 5:14pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
Angel gabrailu gave Muhammad a revelation about things that were already in existence and documented in the bible hundreds of years before prophet Muhammad was born🤣🤣🤣.how comes almost all islamic prophets are jews ? The only reason christianity is the most disrespected religion is because everyone is free to ask ,challenge and disagree on many things. Plus the bible is readily written and preached in many languages. They should translate the quaraan and hadith in english and preach it. Let us ask questions on sensitive topics an ordinary muslim will avoid |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by skuribeebo: 5:26pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
Napoleon wasn't a reliable man . He was a failure . |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by chiboycue: 5:34pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
Sterope:Genesis 16:11 - 12 states that - And the Angel of the Lord said to her: “Behold, you are with child, And you shall bear a son.You shall call his name Ishmael,Because the Lord has heard your affliction. He shall be a wild man. His hand shall be against every man, And every man’s hand against him.And he shall dwell in the presence of all his brethren.” According to the above Bible verses (Genesis 16: 11- 12), what does it mean when the Angel of the Lord prophesy and describes Ishmeal as "a wild man" and that his hand shall be against "every man" ?? |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by olabrad: 5:47pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
CorperKola:Quran specifically told Muslims to hate their non-muslim neighbors |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by Sterope(f): 6:26pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
I love the Judeo-Christian interpretation lol. Now, Let’s interpret it without your bias: 1. Wild donkey not wild man: The phrase describing Ishmael actually means a “wild donkey” . Why a donkey? Donkeys are usually tamed and in servitude, and, according to the Bible, Hagar was a slave. But Ishmael wouldn’t be; he would be free and independent, reflecting the Bedouin lifestyle. See Job 39:5–8, where God describes the wild donkey as free and joyfully surviving in the desert. 2. Not all Muslim majority countries are Arabs genetically,: when people discuss Middle Eastern conflict, they lump all Muslim-majority countries together and label them as “Arabs.” Politically, that is right but genealogically and genetically, it is not accurate. Afghans, Iraqis, Syrians, Egyptians, Lebanese, and Palestinians are not necessarily descendants of Ishmael, despite common assumptions about fighting or “wild” traits. Historical and genealogical traditions trace Ishmael’s descendants more reliably to regions like Saudi Arabia, Qatar, UAE, Kuwait, Jordan, and several other parts of the Arabian Peninsula. Which again calls your claim about them being wild into question. 3. Finally, the grammar in the verse about Ishmael’s dwelling deserves attention. For example other interpretations: New American Standard Bible (NASB): “he will live to the east of all his brothers.” King James Version (KJV): “he shall dwell in the presence of all his brethren.” English Standard Version (ESV): “he shall dwell over against all his kinsmen.” chiboycue: |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by chiboycue: 6:58pm On Sep 05, 2025*. Modified: 10:57am On Sep 06, 2025 |
Sterope:Genesis 16:12 according to New King James Version is a prophecy delivered by the Angel of the Lord to Hagar about her unborn son, Ishmael, stating that he will be a wild, untamed man whose hand will be against everyone and everyone's hand against him. The verse describes Ishmael's nature and the future condition of his descendants as a people known for their fierce independence and constant conflict with others, but also mentions he will become a great nation, as seen in the verses that you mentioned earlier on. Nature of Ishmael: He is described as a "wild man". The term "wild man" (Hebrew: pere adam) can be understood as someone who is independent, untamed, and free-spirited—like a wild donkey in the wilderness His Relationship with Others: His hand will be against everyone, and everyone's hand will be against him, meaning he will live in constant conflict and hostility with others. His Dwellings: He will dwell "over against all his kinsmen" or "in hostility toward all his brothers," indicating his separation and ongoing friction with his relatives and kinsmen. Fulfillment: Commentaries connect this prophecy to the future of Ishmael's descendants, such as the Arabs and Saracens,who were known for their wild and warlike ways, eventually becoming a great nation but often in conflict with other people groups. |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by Sterope(f): 7:01pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
I love the Judeo-Christian interpretation lol. Now, Let’s interpret it without your bias: 1. Wild donkey not wild man: The phrase describing Ishmael actually means a “wild donkey” . Why a donkey? Donkeys are usually tamed and in servitude, and, according to the Bible, Hagar was a slave. But Ishmael wouldn’t be; he would be free and independent, reflecting the Bedouin lifestyle. See Job 39:5–8, where God describes the wild donkey as free and joyfully surviving in the desert. 2. Not all Muslim majority countries are Arabs genetically,: when people discuss Middle Eastern conflict, they lump all Muslim-majority countries together and label them as “Arabs.” Politically, that is right but genealogically and genetically, it is not accurate. Afghans, Iraqis, Syrians, Egyptians, Lebanese, and Palestinians are not necessarily descendants of Ishmael, despite common assumptions about fighting or “wild” traits. Historical and genealogical traditions trace Ishmael’s descendants more reliably to regions like Saudi Arabia, Qatar, UAE, Kuwait, Jordan, and several other parts of the Arabian Peninsula. Which again calls your claim about them being wild into question. 3. Finally, the grammar in the verse about Ishmael’s dwelling deserves attention. For example other interpretations: New American Standard Bible (NASB): “he will live to the east of all his brothers.” King James Version (KJV): “he shall dwell in the presence of all his brethren.” English Standard Version (ESV): “he shall dwell over against all his kinsmen.” chiboycue: |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by Kuginzi: 7:52pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
BlackfireX:At this level, you can't continue to remain dependent. You can make a difference by improving yourself in research. |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by IPDGP: 7:52pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
CorperKola:Do you read verse 1 and 2 |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by Kuginzi: 7:53pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
BlackViper:I feel your pain.
|
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by olabrad: 7:55pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
Kuginzi:Mention 5 characteristics of Muhammad that makes him the best human ![]() Why will somebody just wake up start deceiving himself?! Something that you and I know is a lie! ![]() |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by Nobody: 8:00pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
Sterope:Mrs common sense, in your earlier comment you outrightly said thieves and armrobber. You did say "if I call you" |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by Kuginzi: 8:04pm On Sep 05, 2025*. Modified: 8:28pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
olabrad:You're not asking this question for knowledge sake but for the selfish interest you want to achieve and for argument sake The character of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ 1. His honesty and integrity The Prophet ﷺ was a person whose honesty was common knowledge to those around him. In fact, his clansmen had officially titled him al-Amīn (the Trustworthy). 2. His simplicity and humility. The simple, austere lifestyle of the Prophet ﷺ is a major indication that his mission could not have been self-serving, especially when contrasted with the decadent, extravagant lifestyles of so many false prophets in world history. 3. His mercy and compassion The Prophet’s ﷺ “character was the Qur’an,”[28] as described by his wife, ‘Āishah (rA). He ﷺ practiced everything that he preached, and since the Qur’anic message preached mercy above all, this quality was more pronounced in his practice than anything else. The Prophet’s ﷺ call to mercy was therefore not mere words, but rather teachings that he held to be sacred and felt he must embody better than any other adherent of Islam. |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by Sterope(f): 8:05pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
Mr Common sense I didn't want to call you a thief....,,,,,. How about I shouted thie...,,,,f at you and my people lynce....,,,,d and burned...,,,, you, without due process? Would that be alright? FaAbData: |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by babajero(m): 8:11pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
Rashduct4luv:you are posting and blushing about people praising muhammed, but when another person will write or say what they feel about muhammed and his atrocities, you people will start looking for the person to kill him/her. |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by Nobody: 8:20pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
Sterope:A thief understands the consequences of his act of stealing with arm, especially in Nigeria. You don't appear like someone a thief has dealt with before, I pray u don't experience those raw devil's, your view will change.. In America etc their thieves hardly kill their victims or torture them . Here a thief can kill u because of ir phone or 10k or ur bike. A thief here is different from a thief in America. Here you aren't assured of Justice or proper rehabilitation of the thieves when handed to the authorities. This is not the case in your America. People that do jungle justice aren't animalistic |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by CorperKola: 8:39pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
IPDGP:So?? How does that excuse total annihilation of a people People have been fighting wars since forever, they win they loot, take slaves or whatever not total annihilation as the goal of war |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by teniboss(m): 10:14pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
IPDGP:Here’s your prove:: Go to ChristianUniversalism r/ChristianUniversalism 2 yr. ago [deleted] Join Luke 19:27: Jesus calls for the murder of non-believers Luke 19:27 “But those enemies of mine who did not want me to be king over them—bring them here and kill them in front of me.” |
| Re: What Non-muslim Scholars Said About Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)! by IPDGP: 10:32pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
teniboss:Dont get it wrong, Jesus was saying a parable there explaining what will happen to unbeliever on judgment day. Jesus did not in anyway command us to kill, get it right |
These Verses Affirm Tolerance and forbid unjust killings Towards Non-muslim • Ruling On A Muslim Man Marrying A Non-muslim Woman And Vice Versa • Here Are The Phone Numbers Of Some Muslim Scholars In Nigeria • 2 • 3 • 4
What Happens To The Soul When Someone Dies? • Through Thick And Thin: A Great Lesson From Prophet Ayoob • The Eagle That Characterizes The Nigerian Coat-of-arms Is A Symbol Of Christ

