Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? - Christianity Etc - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? (1352 Views)
| Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by MrPresident1(op): 8:08am On Aug 27, 2025*. Modified: 9:03am On Sep 06, 2025 |
People from American are called Americans People from Jordan are called Jordanians People from Togo are Togolese Nigerians from Nigeria Syria for Syrians Saudi Arabia are Saudis People from Europe are called Europeans France people are called French Great British are called British But the Gazans are called Palestinians?! should Gaza people not be called Gazans? Who are these 'Palestinians'? What is their ethnicity and origin, where are they from, did they sprout from the ground? Who and where are their parent stock? Before they became 'Palestinians', what were they called? |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by MrPresident1(op): 8:11am On Aug 27, 2025 |
Next month, many nations have promised to recognise a 'state of Palestine'. What is a state of Palestine? Is it the same as state of Israeli? Just a state and not a people? Why are the people of Gaza called Palestinians instead of Gazans? Why Palestinian instead of Gazan? |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by MrPresident1(op): 8:09pm On Aug 27, 2025*. Modified: 8:11pm On Sep 04, 2025 |
Lagos people are called Lagosians Canada people are called Canadians Venezuela people are called Venezuelans Bolivia people are Bolivarians Tunisia people are Tunisians Algeria people are Algerians Morocco people are Moroccans Bangladesh people are Bangladeshi Senegal people are Senegalese Gambia people are Gambian Sudan people are Sudanese But Gaza people are Palestinians So why are Gazans called Palestinians? Who are the parent stock of these 'Palestinians'? How did Gaza become synonymous with Palestine, is Gaza t only land in Palestine? Who are the other Palestinians or Palestinians are only found in Gaza? |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by MrPresident1(op): 8:30pm On Aug 27, 2025 |
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ixbdlUhELoU&pp=ygUkZ29sZGEgbWVpciBpbnRlcnZpZXcgaSdtIHBhbGVzdGluaWFu Mrs Gold Meir clarified on 'Palestinian' If you have never heard of Golda Meir, google her name. She once occupied Netanyahu's office |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by MrPresident1(op): 8:51pm On Aug 27, 2025 |
So this 'Palestinian' state that they are all planning to recognise this September, what exactly is it? Where are the borders going to be? Would it be called State of Palestine, like we have State of Israel? |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by MrPresident1(op): 11:01pm On Sep 02, 2025*. Modified: 6:38am On Sep 05, 2025 |
This one that Countries are saying that they will recognise Palestine by this September, omo, what could be the ramification of this recognition? If Palestine is only recognised on the floor of the UN General Assembly, then there is nothing binding Any of the five permanent members of the Security Council can take the lead to veto anything. They can veto Palestine |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by triplechoice(m): 12:11pm On Sep 04, 2025 |
MrPresident1:The same reason why Lagosians are called Nigerians. The same reason Texans are called Americans. Gaza ,just like Lagos and Texas to both Nigeria and America, is a part of the proposed state of Palestine . The other part is the West Bank .So,at the moment, before the creation of their state, the national identity is Palestinian. This is the answer to your question. |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by triplechoice(m): 12:24pm On Sep 04, 2025 |
MrPresident1:There's something odd in your list above. If you can spot it, will help you answer your own question. Palestinians are also found in the West Bank. |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by MrPresident1(op): 8:42pm On Sep 04, 2025 |
triplechoice:Did you listen to Golda Meir's interview that I posted? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ixbdlUhELoU&pp=ygUkZ29sZGEgbWVpciBpbnRlcnZpZXcgaSdtIHBhbGVzdGluaWFu I doubt you did. What is the parent stock of these 'Palestinians', who were they before they became 'Palestinians'? Have they always been known as 'Palestinians'? When did Westbank and Gaza become Palestine, inhabited by 'Palestinians'? When did their national identity as 'Palestinian' begin? For example like we have the Turks, the Iranians or Persians, the Arabs, the Americans, the French, the British etc., when did their national identity as 'Palestinians' begin? |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by MrPresident1(op): 8:52pm On Sep 04, 2025*. Modified: 6:36am On Sep 05, 2025 |
triplechoice:I corrected Bolivars to Bolivarians Palestine people are called Palestinians. Who are the Palestinians? Where is the extent of Palestine, and who are the original Palestinians? |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by MrPresident1(op): 6:39am On Sep 05, 2025 |
MrPresident1:And when the state of Palestine is vetoed, all efforts become fruitless |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by triplechoice(m): 2:42pm On Sep 05, 2025*. Modified: 3:35pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
MrPresident1:1. No. That's not it. .Lagos is not equivalent to the others in your list . Look at it again. Lagos state is not the name of a country,but the name of a territory within the Nigerian state. The correct thing should be , Lagos =Lagosians=Nigerians. Gaza=Gazans = Palestinians. 2, The Palestinians are primarily descended from the indigenous population of the Levant, with a genetic and cultural continuity that dates back thousands of years . Genetic studies confirms that modern Palestinians share significant ancestry with bronze age Canaanites and other ancient levantine people. This confirms a long standing presence in the region, not a foreign one. sources ; 1. Genetic studies on Palestinian origin. Haber 2. Historical documents from the British mandate era . Meir's statements about the Palestinians people are misleading. None of it is supported by authentic history . A people don't need a state to exist as a nation . Before the British created the colonial state of Nigeria , there was no Nigerian state. But the land wasn't empty . There were clearly people living there for thousands of years. The Yorubas,Ibos Hausas, Fulanis and hundreds of other ethnic groups occupied the area. The same applies to the modern day Palestinians. Their land wasn't empty before the creation of the modern state of Israel. It's a myth that it was. |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by triplechoice(m): 3:20pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
MrPresident1:I have seen the video before. However, Golda Meir' 's claims in it do not prove that the Palestinians didn't exist. Instead, they prove that she wanted a gullible public to believe they didn't exist. It was a strategic move to legitimize her own people's claim to the land of Palestine following the creation of the Jewish state in 1948. A quick Google search will help you answer your other questions. |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by MrPresident1(op): 10:36pm On Sep 05, 2025*. Modified: 11:00pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
triplechoice:Writing a long epistle does not mean that you are correct. You are wrong. There was never any people distinctly called Palestinians, they were all Arabs and Jews and other tribes living in that geographical location and they were all Palestinians as of that time. Golda Meir carried a Palestinian passport, consistent with the fact that she was Palestinian. A modern day distinct nationality and tribe of people called Palestinians is a lie. Before Nigeria, there was Igbo, Yoruba, Hausa, Tiv, and they all became Nigerians. But there was never any tribe or race or nation called Palestinians that are going to be the nationals and citizens of a soon to be declared state of Palestine. Before this people who are quartered in Gaza and the west bank became the modern day Palestinians they were Jewish and Arabs in that land, Jewish formed Israeli and Arabs became Jordanians. Golda Meir correctly defined the geographical area of Palestine, and the people of Palestine was a mix of tribes. These modern day Palestinians, they are Arabs and their stock is in Jordan. The stock that is in Jordan, are they not Palestinians? Why were they blockaded from joining Jordan? Are Jordanians not Palestinians? |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by MrPresident1(op): 10:57pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
triplechoice:You didn't see the video. Before the British got the mandate for Palestine, was there any district tribe, race or nation of people called Palestinians? The answer is No. It was a geographical location, there was no single unified group called Palestinians, they were just a collection of various people under umbrella of the location called Palestine. Anyone can easily know who is not saying the truth. Just go to google and make your research. Ask your AI if there was ever a distinct unique tribe or nation callled Palestinians and you will find out for yourselves. Go to chatgpt and ask it there was ever any race or tribe called Palestinians. When the Ottomans ruled the area, was there a distinct Palestinian tribe? |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by MrPresident1(op): 11:02pm On Sep 05, 2025 |
triplechoice:Being these sources, we want to see them |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by triplechoice(m): 9:51am On Sep 06, 2025 |
MrPresident1:Where did I argue against this? I said the modern day Palestinians are a descendant of the Levant. I never said there was an ancient tribe in that region called the Palestinians . Anyone can easily know who is not saying the truth. Just go to google and make your research. Ask your AI if there was ever a distinct unique tribe or nation callled Palestinians and you will find out for yourselves.You're asking these questions because you're confusing the name for the people the name represents . Name can change,but the people remain the same. So, the question you should ask Chatbot if you really want to know the truth is, who are the modern day Palestinians? Ask that and come back here with your answers |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by triplechoice(m): 10:34am On Sep 06, 2025 |
MrPresident1:You have a phone. Use it. I have done my part.So, it's left for you to decide if you want to know the truth. |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by MrPresident1(op): 11:09am On Sep 06, 2025 |
triplechoice:Name the people. Did they sprout from the ground of the Levant or they rained down like rain from the skies of the Levant? Durng the time the Ottomans ruled the area, which tribe was called Palestinians? The Kurds, Arabs, Persians, Turks, Jewish? Which specific tribe or race or nationality was called Palestinians? You are not saying the truth. This is what you said, you said , The Palestinians are primarily descended from the indigenous population of the Levant, with a genetic and cultural continuity that dates back thousands of years . Genetic studies confirms that modern Palestinians share significant ancestry with bronze age Canaanites and other ancient levantine people. This confirms a long standing presence in the region, not a foreign one. I challenge you to name the indigenous populations that the modern 'Palestinians' descended from Palestinian is a modern naming and it is a cover term for all the people living in that geographical area. A mishmash of tribes, not a single ethnicity or race or tribe or nation The Jordanians are Arabs, they are also Palestinians. Jewish are Palestinians Ascribing Palestinian to a single nation or ethnicity or race or nationality is a lie and that is what you are pushing Anyone can easily find out the truth with just a little help from chatgpt |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by triplechoice(m): 12:36pm On Sep 06, 2025*. Modified: 2:03pm On Sep 06, 2025 |
MrPresident1:Golda Meir carried a Palestinian passport because, during the British Mandate, the name was used legally and geographically for all inhabitants of the land of Palestine, which included the Arabs and the Jews. But after 1948,it became the adopted national name for the Arab people living there. This is evolution, not invention, and so, not a lie . The reason for this adoption was to carve out a distinct national identity for themselves so they can rally under it as a unified front against threat to their lives and continued presence in the land after the creation of the Jewish state. You don' t know all of this because of people like Golda Meir, whose aim in the video you posted was to suppress truth . And that was why she lied by claiming the land was 'desolate ', a claim that directly contradicts historical fact. Modified. Provide the source of your claim their stock is Jordan. Jordanian Arabs are Jordanians, not Palestinians,just like Yorubas in Benin republic are beninois, not Nigerians |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by triplechoice(m): 12:52pm On Sep 06, 2025*. Modified: 1:26pm On Sep 06, 2025 |
MrPresident1:It's not what I said, but what was sourced from documented history which, unfortunately, you have stubbornly refused to consult. Please , next time try to corroborate from elsewhere what you get from chatgbt so you're not mislead. Not everything it gives you is authentic info. It sometimes produces garbage if you don't know the right set of questions to ask concerning a topic . And again, Palestinian is not the name of an ethnic group just like Nigeria is not the name of an ethnic group. Palestinian is national identity.So stop conflating it with the wrong thing if you want me to continue this conversation. |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by MrPresident1(op): 2:00pm On Sep 06, 2025 |
triplechoice:I see you now agree that the parent stock of these 'Palestinians' is Arab. Why is their silence on their Arabia origins, and what we hear always is 'Palestinians' discounting the fact that they are Arabs. Why so much noise about 'Palestinians' when the term is not absolute or unique to any ethnic group, race or nationality? This is what you said The reason for this adoption was to carve out a distinct national identity for themselves so they can rally under it as a unified front against threat to their lives and continued presence in the land after the creation of the Jewish state. But you are confused. Who or what gives them the rights to appropriate Palestinians to themselves when all the people in that place are Palestinians? I ask you again, are the Jordanians not Palestinians? Modified. Provide the source of your claim their stock is Jordan. Jordanian Arabs are Jordanians, not Palestinians,just like Yorubas in Benin republic are beninois, not Nigerians Your question is for you to answer. If there was a homogeneous Yoruba nation, the Yoruba will all be in one country and will bear one name. They will not bear West Africans because many people are also West Africans There are Arab countries, why are Arabs being called Palestinians, a name that is not unique to them or to anybody in that region? When did the name Palestinian become a unique identifier for only Arabs? |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by MrPresident1(op): 2:08pm On Sep 06, 2025 |
triplechoice:Provide your sources, put them here let us all read it. You are stubbornly refusing to provide your sources, no one is interested in your opinions, provide sources of what you are saying. Where are the links to the 'documented history' you are peddling? When did Palestinian become a unique identity for only Arabs living in Gaza and the West bank, and who made it so? When did West Africans become the unique identifier for only Yorubas? |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by MrPresident1(op): 2:13pm On Sep 06, 2025 |
triplechoice:Type: are Jordanians Palestinians on Google and read up what it says. Excerpts: Overview No, Jordanians are not Palestinians, but most Jordanian citizens are of Palestinian origin due to historical events like the 1948 Nakba, leading to the annexation of the West Bank and the granting of citizenship to Palestinian refugees by Jordan. While a large segment of the Jordanian population has Palestinian heritage, and the countries share cultural similarities, Jordan and Palestine are distinct national identities, with Jordan having granted full citizenship to many Palestinians, creating a distinct Jordanian population with a majority of Palestinian heritage. Read! |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by triplechoice(m): 3:07pm On Sep 06, 2025 |
MrPresident1:Honestly, you're confusing yourself. You claimed that the " parent stock" of the Palestinians are Jordanians,and I asked for your source. Now, read again what you just Googled and tell me how it confirms your "parent stock"claim |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by triplechoice(m): 3:27pm On Sep 06, 2025 |
MrPresident1:I have provided 2 already which you continue to ignore,and I am providing another 2 : Palestinian identity. The construction of a modern national Palestine consciousness. Rashid Khalidi. 2 Haaretz"s historical investigation. These are valid sources because they have been peer reviewed : published in reputable scientific journals. You, on your part,have been making claims upon claims,but not for once have you provided any valid source to support them.Your Google and paste and the self serving video of Golda Meir can't be relied on. |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by triplechoice(m): 3:33pm On Sep 06, 2025*. Modified: 3:57pm On Sep 06, 2025 |
MrPresident1:Oh boy na wah. What's all this "parent stock" mention for. Are you a poultry farmer.? Listen, Palestinians are not an ethnic group,but national identity which included both the Arabs and Jews in the past. The Arabs are alone now after the Jewish state was created. Your Golda Meir already confirmed she had a Palestinian passport. So what are you still arguing? And FYI, the Palestinians aren't pure Arabs. They are actually called arabized Arabs due to the fact their ancestors adopted Arab language and culture. |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by triplechoice(m): 3:41pm On Sep 06, 2025*. Modified: 4:07pm On Sep 06, 2025 |
MrPresident1:Arabs in Palestine have chosen that name to represent their national identity in that region which is also their homeland. Talking about rights, there are no international laws barring them from choosing Palestinians or Palestine. |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by MrPresident1(op): 4:06pm On Sep 06, 2025 |
triplechoice:Your Palestinians are Arabs. There is no indigenous ethnicity or race called Palestinians. They are better called Gazans not Palestinians. But we keep hearing Palestinians in the news. The better term to describe them is Gazans When the nakhba occurred in 1948, the Arabs fled to Jordan. Before Jordan was created in 1946, was Jordan not part of Palestine? Jordanians are Arabs. Large Percentage of Jordanians have Palestinian heritage. The stock of Arab Palestinians is in Jordan. You cannot understand |
| Re: Why Are Gaza People Called Palestinians? by triplechoice(m): 4:15pm On Sep 06, 2025 |
MrPresident1:They aren't " my Palestinians". And who said Palestinians are an ethnic group or race? Me or you? And again, they cannot be called just Gazans because they're are also found in the West Bank. Yes! Until you understand the concept of nationhood,it will difficult for you to make sense of my contributions on this thread. |
Pope Leo Urges End To Terror, Destruction And Death In Gaza • Russia-Ukraine, Israel-Gaza crises will lead to global calamity–Primate Ayodele • Supernatural Move Of God In Gaza More Than 200 Reportedly Meet Jesus In Dreams • 2 • 3 • 4
Did Jesus Or His Companions Celebrate Christmas? • A Bishop's Bombshell At Fellow Pastors • The Consequences Of Christianity (hell) And The Good Atheist