₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,172 members, 8,521,580 topics. Date: Thursday, 19 November 2026 at 03:23 PM

Toggle theme

Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching - Islam (2) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Islam › Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching (907 Views)

1 2 Reply (Go Down)

Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by honesttalk21: 3:00pm On Oct 28, 2025
DeepSight:
Lets take it one step at a time.


:
Let us revisit the Sword Verses and quote the entire context.

A declaration of immunity from God and His Messenger to the polytheists with whom you had made a treaty.

So travel the land for four months, and know that you cannot escape God, and that God will disgrace the disbelievers.

And a proclamation from God and His Messenger to the people on the day of the Greater Pilgrimage, that God has disowned the polytheists, and so did His Messenger. If you repent, it will be better for you. But if you turn away, know that you cannot escape God. And announce to those who disbelieve a painful punishment.

Except for those among the polytheists with whom you had made a treaty, and did not violate any of its terms, nor aided anyone against you. So fulfill the treaty with them to the end of its term. God loves the righteous.

When the Sacred Months have passed, kill the polytheists wherever you find them. And capture them, and besiege them, and lie in wait for them at every ambush. But if they repent, and perform the prayers, and pay the alms, then let them go their way. God is Most Forgiving, Most Merciful.

And if anyone of the polytheists asks you for protection, give him protection so that he may hear the Word of God; then escort him to his place of safety. That is because they are a people who do not know.

How can there be a treaty with the polytheists on the part of God and His Messenger, except for those with whom you made a treaty at the Sacred Mosque? As long as they are upright with you, be upright with them. God loves the pious.

How? Whenever they overcome you, they respect neither kinship nor treaty with you. They satisfy you with lip service, but their hearts refuse, and most of them are immoral.

They traded away God's revelations for a cheap price, so they barred others from His path. How evil is what they did.

Towards a believer they respect neither kinship nor treaty. These are the transgressors.

But if they repent, and perform the prayers, and give the obligatory charity, then they are your brethren in faith. We detail the revelations for a people who know.

But if they violate their oaths after their pledge, and attack your religion, then fight the leaders of disbelief—they have no faith—so that they may desist.

Will you not fight a people who violated their oaths, and planned to exile the Messenger, and initiated hostilities against you? Do you fear them? It is God you should fear, if you are believers.

Fight them. God will punish them at your hands, and humiliate them, and help you against them, and heal the hearts of a believing people.


------------------

Above is Sura 9 Vs 1 - 15.

I think you should begin to tell us exactly what you think this treaty was and the origin and basis for it. I understand that treaty to be the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah, signed in 628 CE (6 AH) between the Prophet Muhammad and the Quraysh of Mecca.

It would appear that the verses are saying that these people had violated the treaty and thus should be killed.

My question is this: why are the verses specific when they say that those who disbelieve should be killed, and that those who repent, or ask for direction or protection, should be spared? Does this not specifically show that the motivation behind these verses is religious: because it appears that the verses are still made out against those who disbelieve in Islam/ Allah.

Besides the portions I have highlighted and underlined show that the issue here was really about acceptance of Allah/ Islam.

This is underscored by Sahih al-Bukhari, Vol. 8, Book 75, Hadith 387 (and other versions): "I have been commanded to fight the people till they say: 'None has the right to be worshipped but Allah.'

This corroboration makes it clear that this is not just about treaties and violations but about a general direction in which the Muslims are commanded to fight to establish the worship of Allah.

For further corroboration let us go to Surah 47:4. But because you insist on context I will quote all the verse from 1 - 12. Here goes:

1. Those who disbelieve and repel from the path of God—He nullifies their works.

2. While those who believe, and work righteousness, and believe in what was sent down to Muhammad—and it is the truth from their Lord—He remits their sins, and relieves their concerns.

3. That is because those who disbelieve follow falsehoods, while those who believe follow the truth from their Lord. God thus cites for the people their examples.

4. When you encounter those who disbelieve, strike at their necks. Then, when you have routed them, bind them firmly. Then, either release them by grace, or by ransom, until war lays down its burdens. Had God willed, He could have defeated them Himself, but He thus tests some of you by means of others. As for those who are killed in the way of God, He will not let their deeds go to waste.

5. He will guide them, and will improve their state of mind.

6. And will admit them into Paradise, which He has identified for them.

7. O you who believe! If you support God, He will support you, and will strengthen your foothold.

8. But as for those who disbelieve, for them is perdition, and He will waste their deeds.

9. That is because they hated what God revealed, so He nullified their deeds.

10. Have they not journeyed through the earth and seen the consequences for those before them? God poured destruction upon them, and for the unbelievers is something comparable.

11. That is because God is the Master of those who believe, while the disbelievers have no master.

12. God will admit those who believe and do good deeds into gardens beneath which rivers flow. As for those who disbelieve, they enjoy themselves, and eat as cattle eat, and the Fire will be their dwelling.


Is this not clear enough? Why is it that Islamic scholars like to introduce to the text interpretations in brackets which are not in the text. The text and context are clear enough here. It is abundantly obvious that what is at issue here is the worship of Allah and Allah is expressly commanding the execution of those who do not believe in him.
:
How does this tally with the claim in the same Quoran that there is no compulsion in religion?



:
It is contradictory to say there is no compulsion in religion and to also prescribe death for apostates.


:
What treason to be specific please?
And secondly how did that justify not just the murder of all men but the sale into slavery of all women and children?


:
It is not true that the injunction to kill apostates is so qualified. It is specific, and it is from a Sahih (authentic) hadith.
You’re reading war verses as if they were missionary verses and that constitutes the first mistake. The so-called sword verse; Qur’an 9:5, came after the Quraysh had broken multiple peace treaties, tried to assassinate Muhammad, and attacked Medina even after agreeing to truce. It was a wartime directive, not a religious order to kill unbelievers. Going through Quran 9:4–6 you see it protects those who kept their word and even commands that any pagan seeking asylum be safely escorted. Does that sound like forced conversion?

Surah 47:4 too is about battlefield ethics stating strike when you meet them in battle… then release them by grace or ransom. It doesn’t say kill all who don’t believe. The Qur’an actually says the opposite which is there is no compulsion in religion (2:256) and to you your faith, to me mine (109:6).

The Prophet’s record proves this. Jews, Christians, and even pagans lived under Muslim protection in Medina and later under caliphate rule. If Islam commanded believe or die, how did these communities survive for centuries inside Muslim lands?

The hadith about fighting until they say none has the right to be worshipped but Allah refers to ending the armed oppression that banned Islam in Arabia not forcing belief. The war was against tyranny, not faith itself.

So the issue isn’t contradiction; it’s selective reading. These weren’t kill-for-belief orders, they were defensive commands in a world where breaking treaties meant survival or extinction.
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by honesttalk21: 3:05pm On Oct 28, 2025
LordReed:
I always hear this but in practice it tends to be quite different depending on certain factors. A person in certain places CANNOT openly declare that they have left Islam, they will be kill or prosecuted. Where is the "no compulsion"?
Indeed that’s a fair concern but it’s important to separate Islam from how some people or regimes misuse it. The Qur’an clearly says, there is no compulsion in religion (2:256), revealed when Muslims already held power proving it wasn’t about weakness or convenience. Later jurists linked apostasy with treason in political contexts, not simple disbelief. That is culture and politics, not divine command. In Islam, faith is a matter of conscience not coercion.
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by LordReed(m): 3:54pm On Oct 28, 2025
honesttalk21:
Indeed that’s a fair concern but it’s important to separate Islam from how some people or regimes misuse it. The Qur’an clearly says, there is no compulsion in religion (2:256), revealed when Muslims already held power proving it wasn’t about weakness or convenience. Later jurists linked apostasy with treason in political contexts, not simple disbelief. That is culture and politics, not divine command. In Islam, faith is a matter of conscience not coercion.
You cannot separate do that separation honestly without launching into a no true Scotsman fallacy. Are these people Muslims practicing Islam? YES, they are. They believe their holy book commands them to do it, and they are following it to the point they even commit state resources to fulfil it. Your answer barely addresses the reality, you sound kinda idealistic and I wish that was the case, but it isn't.
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by TV01(m): 10:18pm On Oct 28, 2025
LordReed:
You cannot separate do that separation honestly without launching into a no true Scotsman fallacy. Are these people Muslims practicing Islam? YES, they are. They believe their holy book commands them to do it, and they are following it to the point they even commit state resources to fulfil it. Your answer barely addresses the reality, you sound kinda idealistic and I wish that was the case, but it isn't.
Show me one committed to the defence of islam or, an ardent apologist, and I will show you a liar. No matter how amenable they sound or courteously they present, there will be lies. But that's allowed - taqiyya is perfectly acceptable and encouraged in islam.


TV
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by DeepSight(op): 7:39pm On Oct 29, 2025
TV01:
Show me one committed to the defence of islam or, an ardent apologist, and I will show you a liar. No matter how amenable they sound or courteously they present, there will be lies. But that's allowed - taqiyya is perfectly acceptable and encouraged in islam.


TV
Islam is truly questionable on these matters.

Re: Taqiyya. Personally I see no sense in dying over a scenario which a white lie would avoid, for instance. The concept of Taqiyya is not a blanket authority to lie.
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by ArkofEnock: 1:32am On Oct 30, 2025
Imam Mahdi is here

https://www.iponder.co

Investigate the evidence this is a major test and blessing from Allah

https://www.iponder.co/library

Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by honesttalk21: 8:26pm On Oct 30, 2025
LordReed:
You cannot separate do that separation honestly without launching into a no true Scotsman fallacy. Are these people Muslims practicing Islam? YES, they are. They believe their holy book commands them to do it, and they are following it to the point they even commit state resources to fulfil it. Your answer barely addresses the reality, you sound kinda idealistic and I wish that was the case, but it isn't.
That’s actually a misuse of the no true Scotsman fallacy. It only applies if someone redefines Islam to exclude wrongdoing but that’s not what’s happening here. The point is that the Qur’an itself never commands killing for disbelief or apostasy; it explicitly says, there is no compulsion in religio. The distinction isn’t about true vs false muslims. It’s about the difference between Islamic teaching and political abuse done in its name.

As for taqiyya; a group quickly abuse and misinterprete, it’s not a permit to lie but a narrow, defensive allowance used historically to protect one’s life under persecution. Claiming that all Muslim apologists lie ignores both context and sincerity. Critique should target distortions not assume deceit is the norm.
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by LordReed(m): 10:23pm On Oct 30, 2025
honesttalk21:
That’s actually a misuse of the no true Scotsman fallacy. It only applies if someone redefines Islam to exclude wrongdoing but that’s not what’s happening here. The point is that the Qur’an itself never commands killing for disbelief or apostasy; it explicitly says, there is no compulsion in religio. The distinction isn’t about true vs false muslims. It’s about the difference between Islamic teaching and political abuse done in its name.

As for taqiyya; a group quickly abuse and misinterprete, it’s not a permit to lie but a narrow, defensive allowance used historically to protect one’s life under persecution. Claiming that all Muslim apologists lie ignores both context and sincerity. Critique should target distortions not assume deceit is the norm.
I don't think you know what the no true Scotsman fallacy is.

The "no true Scotsman" fallacy is an informal logical fallacy where a generalization is defended against a counterexample by arbitrarily changing the definition of the group to exclude the counterexample. Instead of revising the initial claim, the person dismisses the individual as not being a "true" or "pure" member of the group. This is a form of appeal to purity or moving the goalposts

You are claiming some people are not practicing proper Islam because they claim that their holy book commands them to kill anyone who leaves the religion. The question you should be tackling is why they think they are given that command not trying to claim they aren't practicing proper Islam.

Not sure why you are mentioning taqiyya cos I didn't say anything about it.
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by DeepSight(op): 10:26pm On Oct 30, 2025
ArkofEnock:
Imam Mahdi is here

https://www.iponder.co

Investigate the evidence this is a major test and blessing from Allah

https://www.iponder.co/library
:
Please I need the number of your dealer.
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by DeepSight(op): 10:30pm On Oct 30, 2025
honesttalk21:
That’s actually a misuse of the no true Scotsman fallacy. It only applies if someone redefines Islam to exclude wrongdoing but that’s not what’s happening here. The point is that the Qur’an itself never commands killing for disbelief or apostasy; it explicitly says, there is no compulsion in religio. The distinction isn’t about true vs false muslims. It’s about the difference between Islamic teaching and political abuse done in its name.
:
Are you suggesting that Sahih Hadiths are not also Muslim Scripture?
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by honesttalk21: 11:32pm On Oct 30, 2025
LordReed:
I don't think you know what the no true Scotsman fallacy is.

The "no true Scotsman" fallacy is an informal logical fallacy where a generalization is defended against a counterexample by arbitrarily changing the definition of the group to exclude the counterexample. Instead of revising the initial claim, the person dismisses the individual as not being a "true" or "pure" member of the group. This is a form of appeal to purity or moving the goalposts

You are claiming some people are not practicing proper Islam because they claim that their holy book commands them to kill anyone who leaves the religion. The question you should be tackling is why they think they are given that command not trying to claim they aren't practicing proper Islam.

Not sure why you are mentioning taqiyya cos I didn't say anything about it.
How is this qualified? This isn’t a no true Scotsman misunderstanding. I’m not denying that those people are Muslims; I’m questioning their interpretation. The Qur’an clearly says no compulsion in religion and nowhere commands killing for disbelief. So the real issue isn’t who is a true Muslim, but whether their actions align with what the book actually teaches and by the Qur’an’s own words, they don’t.

The following statement is addressing the responses to your response to mine.
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by TV01(m):
honesttalk21:
The Qur’an clearly says no compulsion in religion and nowhere commands killing for disbelief. So the real issue isn’t who is a true Muslim, but whether their actions align with what the book actually teaches and by the Qur’an’s own words, they don’t.
The hadith nko?

20 The Chapters on Legal Punishments
(1)Chapter: It Is Not Lawful To Shed The Blood Of A Muslim Except In Three Cases(1.00)باب لاَ يَحِلُّ دَمُ امْرِئٍ مُسْلِمٍ إِلاَّ فِي ثَلاَثٍ
It was narrated from Abu Umamah bin Sahl bin Hunaif that:
`Uthman bin 'Affan looked at them when they spoke of killing. He said: “Are they threatening to kill me? Why would they kill me? I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say:[b] “It is not lawful to shed the blood of a Muslim except in one of three (cases): a man who commits adultery when he is a married person, then he should be stoned; a man who kills a soul not in retaliation for murder; and a man who apostatizes after becoming Muslim.' [/b]By Allah (SWT), I never committed adultery either during Ignorance days nor in Islam, and I have never killed a Muslim soul, and I have not apostatized since I became Muslim.”
حَدَّثَنَا أَحْمَدُ بْنُ عَبْدَةَ، أَنْبَأَنَا حَمَّادُ بْنُ زَيْدٍ، عَنْ يَحْيَى بْنِ سَعِيدٍ، عَنْ أَبِي أُمَامَةَ بْنِ سَهْلِ بْنِ حُنَيْفٍ، أَنَّ عُثْمَانَ بْنَ عَفَّانَ، أَشْرَفَ عَلَيْهِمْ فَسَمِعَهُمْ وَهُمْ، يَذْكُرُونَ الْقَتْلَ فَقَالَ إِنَّهُمْ لَيَتَوَاعَدُونِي بِالْقَتْلِ فَلِمَ يَقْتُلُونِي وَقَدْ سَمِعْتُ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم يَقُولُ ‏ "‏ لا يَحِلُّ دَمُ امْرِئٍ مُسْلِمٍ إِلاَّ فِي إِحْدَى ثَلاَثٍ رَجُلٌ زَنَى وَهُوَ مُحْصَنٌ فَرُجِمَ أَوْ رَجُلٌ قَتَلَ نَفْسًا بِغَيْرِ نَفْسٍ أَوْ رَجُلٌ ارْتَدَّ بَعْدَ إِسْلاَمِهِ ‏"‏ ‏.‏ فَوَاللَّهِ مَا زَنَيْتُ فِي جَاهِلِيَّةٍ وَلاَ فِي إِسْلاَمٍ وَلاَ قَتَلْتُ نَفْسًا مُسْلِمَةً وَلاَ ارْتَدَدْتُ مُنْذُ أَسْلَمْتُ ‏.‏
Grade: Sahih (Darussalam)
Reference : Sunan Ibn Majah 2533
In-book reference : Book 20, Hadith 1
English translation : Vol. 3, Book 20, Hadith 2533
2532

From here - https://sunnah.com/ibnmajah:2533

And how is it congruent to prescribe kpaiing for leaving and not at once determine the same for not joining?


TV
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by TV01(m): 1:55am On Oct 31, 2025
TV01:
The hadith nko?
Aside the fact that it appears to me to be largely false assertions, fake claims, fabrications, wholesale plagiarism, lies and a rear-guard attempt to build a plausible narrative around an obviously made-up religion\ideology, one of the many issues I have with this faith is the manoeuvrability and hence, the widely variable interpretations of its scripture that are possible.

Do we read the main text with or without the hard teeth? Wait, there is no universal agreement about which hard teeth are authentic – within or between sects? Further, they are graded and, for some reason each believer can pick and choose which ones he or she accepts, if any – which is often done tactically.

It is nigh on impossible to articulate the prevailing practice without reference to the hard teeth, yet the whole notion of “hard teeth science” is itself a misnomer. It is simply impossible to apply the requisite academic rigour or scientific principles. No honest scholar gives them real credence other than on a “matter of faith” basis.

These are writings collected no earlier than 200 years after the demise of the claimant, by people who had no proximity or direct relationship with him. True, some of them may well be authentic, but the wholly contrived “chain of narration” authenticator does not pass muster
In rough numbers only about 1% (approx 6k of 600k) of the hard teeth writings have not been discounted. Many were written to push a certain doctrinal\theological position, or to gain a political edge.

From the main text, we add abrogation to the mix, the meccan vs. medinan postures, the need to rollback parts that either contradict each other or, invalidate the attempt to piggy-back off the torah and injeel (after all, in all honesty, the kindest thing you could say about it, is that it is a Christian heresy). It’s one big mess.

Having said that, to me, the primary case against it, is it’s outworking. The practical effects of the faith in society. To me that is the most damning.

Christianity progressively eliminated societal scourges (slavery, the oppression of women (child marriage, secs slavery, polygyny, child labour etc. Introduced, universal suffrage, agency and welfare and enshrined human rights, civil liberties and personal freedoms. Not to mention laying the foundation for critical thought and rational enquiry that has led to literally all modern-day technological advancement (even in post-Christian times!)

By comparison, the “other” religion still embodies all the evils and practices and none of the good. Add the thirst for instilling terra and the letting of sanguine fluid and you have a veritable blight and scourge on humanity.

No? Ok, explain this small one - https://www.nairaland.com/8349907/notable-women-early-marriages-bible#134323939


TV
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by LordReed(m): 10:32am On Oct 31, 2025
honesttalk21:
How is this qualified? This isn’t a no true Scotsman misunderstanding. I’m not denying that those people are Muslims; I’m questioning their interpretation. The Qur’an clearly says no compulsion in religion and nowhere commands killing for disbelief. So the real issue isn’t who is a true Muslim, but whether their actions align with what the book actually teaches and by the Qur’an’s own words, they don’t.

The following statement is addressing the responses to your response to mine.
Tell us where they get the idea then that they are commanded to kill.

You should have given that response to them then since I didn't mention anything about taqiyya.
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by honesttalk21: 10:37am On Oct 31, 2025
TV01:
The hadith nko?

20 The Chapters on Legal Punishments
(1)Chapter: It Is Not Lawful To Shed The Blood Of A Muslim Except In Three Cases(1.00)باب لاَ يَحِلُّ دَمُ امْرِئٍ مُسْلِمٍ إِلاَّ فِي ثَلاَثٍ
It was narrated from Abu Umamah bin Sahl bin Hunaif that:
`Uthman bin 'Affan looked at them when they spoke of killing. He said: “Are they threatening to kill me? Why would they kill me? I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say:[b] “It is not lawful to shed the blood of a Muslim except in one of three (cases): a man who commits adultery when he is a married person, then he should be stoned; a man who kills a soul not in retaliation for murder; and a man who apostatizes after becoming Muslim.' [/b]By Allah (SWT), I never committed adultery either during Ignorance days nor in Islam, and I have never killed a Muslim soul, and I have not apostatized since I became Muslim.”
حَدَّثَنَا أَحْمَدُ بْنُ عَبْدَةَ، أَنْبَأَنَا حَمَّادُ بْنُ زَيْدٍ، عَنْ يَحْيَى بْنِ سَعِيدٍ، عَنْ أَبِي أُمَامَةَ بْنِ سَهْلِ بْنِ حُنَيْفٍ، أَنَّ عُثْمَانَ بْنَ عَفَّانَ، أَشْرَفَ عَلَيْهِمْ فَسَمِعَهُمْ وَهُمْ، يَذْكُرُونَ الْقَتْلَ فَقَالَ إِنَّهُمْ لَيَتَوَاعَدُونِي بِالْقَتْلِ فَلِمَ يَقْتُلُونِي وَقَدْ سَمِعْتُ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم يَقُولُ ‏ "‏ لا يَحِلُّ دَمُ امْرِئٍ مُسْلِمٍ إِلاَّ فِي إِحْدَى ثَلاَثٍ رَجُلٌ زَنَى وَهُوَ مُحْصَنٌ فَرُجِمَ أَوْ رَجُلٌ قَتَلَ نَفْسًا بِغَيْرِ نَفْسٍ أَوْ رَجُلٌ ارْتَدَّ بَعْدَ إِسْلاَمِهِ ‏"‏ ‏.‏ فَوَاللَّهِ مَا زَنَيْتُ فِي جَاهِلِيَّةٍ وَلاَ فِي إِسْلاَمٍ وَلاَ قَتَلْتُ نَفْسًا مُسْلِمَةً وَلاَ ارْتَدَدْتُ مُنْذُ أَسْلَمْتُ ‏.‏
Grade: Sahih (Darussalam)
Reference : Sunan Ibn Majah 2533
In-book reference : Book 20, Hadith 1
English translation : Vol. 3, Book 20, Hadith 2533
2532

From here - https://sunnah.com/ibnmajah:2533

And how is it congruent to prescribe kpaiing for leaving and not at once determine the same for not joining?


TV
Do you have any evidence that Uthman ibn Affan was accused of apostasy? Because even in that narration he is quoting the Prophet to prove his innocence, not to justify killing anyone. The rebels who killed him never charged him with disbelief; their grievances were political claims of favoritism, administrative decisions, and wealth disputes, as recorded by al-Tabari and Ibn Kathir. And even then, the hadith he quoted outlines narrow judicial exceptions for state authority, not a license for individuals or mobs to shed blood.
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by honesttalk21: 10:53am On Oct 31, 2025
LordReed:
Tell us where they get the idea then that they are commanded to kill.

You should have given that response to them then since I didn't mention anything about taqiyya.
That’s a pretty unfair assumption, as it implies I was part of the decision. Those who claim Islam commands the killing of apostates or non-believers are not following the Qur’an itself but later interpretations shaped by politics, not faith. In history, some rulers amid chaos and rebellion mistke or equate apostasy for treason, but I’m yet to find where any rightly guided leader ever issued such an order.
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by LordReed(m): 5:30pm On Oct 31, 2025
honesttalk21:
That’s a pretty unfair assumption, as it implies I was part of the decision. Those who claim Islam commands the killing of apostates or non-believers are not following the Qur’an itself but later interpretations shaped by politics, not faith. In history, some rulers amid chaos and rebellion mistke or equate apostasy for treason, but I’m yet to find where any rightly guided leader ever issued such an order.
That is a very funny interpretation of what I said.

Is there any Muslim who follows the only Quran and excludes the Hadiths entirely?
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by TV01(m): 5:30pm On Oct 31, 2025
honesttalk21:
Do you have any evidence that Uthman ibn Affan was accused of apostasy? Because even in that narration he is quoting the Prophet to prove his innocence, not to justify killing anyone. The rebels who killed him never charged him with disbelief; their grievances were political claims of favoritism, administrative decisions, and wealth disputes, as recorded by al-Tabari and Ibn Kathir. And even then, the hadith he quoted outlines narrow judicial exceptions for state authority, not a license for individuals or mobs to shed blood.
...and anything the prophet of islam says is gospel - forgive the pun - is it not? A not even clever attempt to sell a dummy. Like I said, show me a committed defender of islam...


TV
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by DeepSight(op): 5:32pm On Oct 31, 2025
honesttalk21:
That’s a pretty unfair assumption, as it implies I was part of the decision. Those who claim Islam commands the killing of apostates or non-believers are not following the Qur’an itself but later interpretations shaped by politics, not faith. In history, some rulers amid chaos and rebellion mistke or equate apostasy for treason, but I’m yet to find where any rightly guided leader ever issued such an order.
+
For the second time, I ask you - are you suggesting that Sahih Hadiths are not scripture for Muslims?
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by honesttalk21: 5:44pm On Oct 31, 2025
LordReed:
That is a very funny interpretation of what I said.

Is there any Muslim who follows the only Quran and excludes the Hadiths entirely?
Most Muslims follow both the Qur’an and Hadith but they’re not equal. The Qur’an is God’s word and the ultimate standard; Hadith are human reports meant to explain it, not override it. So when the Qur’an says no compulsion in religion, that principle must guide how any Hadith is understood. True faith means reading Hadith through the Qur’an not against it. Then you should look at the hadith properly and in context.
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by honesttalk21: 5:53pm On Oct 31, 2025
DeepSight:
+
For the second time, I ask you - are you suggesting that Sahih Hadiths are not scripture for Muslims?
Now you are counting? You understand the question you ask very well and know the answer. Hadith are certainly respected, but they don’t hold the same divine status as the Qur’an, which the direct word/revelation of God. Muslims appreciate Hadith when they resonate with the teachings of the Qur’an, but they never take precedence over it.
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by DeepSight(op): 5:55pm On Oct 31, 2025
honesttalk21:
Now you are counting? You understand the question you ask very well and know the answer. Hadith are certainly respected, but they don’t hold the same divine status as the Qur’an, which the direct word/revelation of God. Muslims appreciate Hadith when they resonate with the teachings of the Qur’an, but they never take precedence over it.
+
You do know that the hadith which prescribes death for apostasy is a Sahih hadith?
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by honesttalk21: 5:57pm On Oct 31, 2025
TV01:
...and anything the prophet of islam says is gospel - forgive the pun - is it not? A not even clever attempt to sell a dummy. Like I said, show me a committed defender of islam...


TV
You already include that this is pun so really I should ignore.
In Islam, even the sayings of the Prophet pbuh are evaluated against the Qur’an, just as he himself stated, compare what I say with the Book of Allah. His words aren’t standalone scripture; they serve as guidance that aligns with the revelation. So, to truly defend Islam, we need to clarify what the text genuinely teaches, rather than glossing over it.
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by honesttalk21: 6:05pm On Oct 31, 2025
DeepSight:
+
You do know that the hadith which prescribes death for apostasy is a Sahih hadith?
I’m not dismissing or denying existence of hadith, but question the context you apply it to. Did you consider how it fits with the Qur’an’s principle of no compulsion in religion before jumping to the conclusion that it calls for death for disbelief? Do you boldly say your view of the hadith supersedes the Quran?
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by LordReed(m): 6:17pm On Oct 31, 2025
honesttalk21:
Most Muslims follow both the Qur’an and Hadith but they’re not equal. The Qur’an is God’s word and the ultimate standard; Hadith are human reports meant to explain it, not override it. So when the Qur’an says no compulsion in religion, that principle must guide how any Hadith is understood. True faith means reading Hadith through the Qur’an not against it. Then you should look at the hadith properly and in context.
Dude can you answer the question I asked? Again, is there any Muslim who follows only the Quran and excludes the Hadiths entirely?
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by DeepSight(op): 6:31pm On Oct 31, 2025
honesttalk21:
I’m not dismissing or denying existence of hadith, but question the context you apply it to. Did you consider how it fits with the Qur’an’s principle of no compulsion in religion before jumping to the conclusion that it calls for death for disbelief? Do you boldly say your view of the hadith supersedes the Quran?
Are you suggesting that that prescription as a Sahih (authentic) hadith is invalid?

Because the mere statement "there is no compulsion in religion" cannot abrogate it, when there are several Quranic verses which appear to corroborate such, including the verses which urge fighting until all believe in Allah and his prophet.

I think it's better you come out and say that that prescription in that hadith is void.
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by honesttalk21: 8:13pm On Oct 31, 2025
DeepSight:
Are you suggesting that that prescription as a Sahih (authentic) hadith is invalid?

Because the mere statement "there is no compulsion in religion" cannot abrogate it, when there are several Quranic verses which appear to corroborate such, including the verses which urge fighting until all believe in Allah and his prophet.

I think it's better you come out and say that that prescription in that hadith is void.
I’m not arguing that the hadith is invalid; I just believe it’s important to consider its context rather than treating it as a universal rule. Each hadith should be interpreted in light of the Qur’an. The Prophet’s words never supersede it. The verses about fighting focus on defense rather than forcing belief. So, if a hadith seems to contradict the idea of no compulsion in religion, the real issue lies in our interpretation of it, not in the Qur’an itself.
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by DeepSight(op): 8:15pm On Oct 31, 2025
honesttalk21:
I’m not arguing that the hadith is invalid; I just believe it’s important to consider its context rather than treating it as a universal rule. Each hadith should be interpreted in light of the Qur’an. The Prophet’s words never supersede it. The verses about fighting focus on defense rather than forcing belief. So, if a hadith seems to contradict the idea of no compulsion in religion, the real issue lies in our interpretation of it, not in the Qur’an itself.
+
Why don't you rather say the real issue lies in such an obviously obnoxious Sahih Hadith?

This is important when you put the reality of the comments by LordReed into focus: namely that Muslim fundamentalists have actually killed people relying on not just these verses but also the Quranic verses you are claiming are only defensive in nature.
Re: Issues Concerning Muhammad & Islamic Teaching by honesttalk21: 4:29am On Nov 01, 2025
DeepSight:
+
Why don't you rather say the real issue lies in such an obviously obnoxious Sahih Hadith?

This is important when you put the reality of the comments by LordReed into focus: namely that Muslim fundamentalists have actually killed people relying on not just these verses but also the Quranic verses you are claiming are only defensive in nature.
-
Dismissing a Sahih hadith as obnoxious without providing context is a bit of an oversimplification. The words of the Prophet pbuh often spoke to specific legal situations or wartime events, rather than issuing open-ended commands. Extremists take these teachings out of context to justify their acts of violence and that’s their distortion, not the essence of the teaching itself. The core message of the Qur’an is about moral freedom and justice, never about coercion. The way radicals misuse these teachings shows their misunderstanding of Islam, not a failure of Islam itself.
1 2 Reply

What Is The Ruling Concerning A Husband Calling His Wife "Ummuh" ? • Rulings Concerning Music In Islam • The Truth Concerning The Prophet's Marriage To Safiyyah Bint Huyay Ibn Akhtab • 2 • 3 • 4

Mosque In The Red Sea.... • The Purpose And Aim Of Creating The Human Being • Qur’an 9:29 Commentary