₦airaland Forum

SUMMARY:

The Story of Salim and Sahla: It details a narrated event involving Sahla bint Suhail, her husband Abu Hudhayfa, and their freed slave Salim. According to the narration, Muhammad advised Sahla to breastfeed Salim (an adult) so that he would become her Mahram (a legal relative), allowing him to enter their home freely.

Aisha’s Perspective: The video cites reports suggesting that Aisha, one of Muhammad’s wives, viewed this not as a unique exception for Salim but as a general rule. It mentions that she allegedly encouraged her relatives to breastfeed men she wished to host.

Opposition from Other Wives: It highlights that most of Muhammad's other wives disagreed, believing the instruction was an "indulgence" specifically and only for Salim, and they refused to adopt the practice.

The "Missing" Quranic Verses: The video discusses Hadiths claiming that verses regarding adult breastfeeding were once part of the Quran but were lost—specifically citing a narration where a sheep or goat purportedly ate the parchment containing them after Muhammad's death.

Modern Interpretations: It references contemporary controversies, such as a 2007 incident involving a professor at Al-Azhar University who suggested the practice could be a solution for gender segregation in the workplace, and different views on whether the milk must be taken directly or can be served in a cup.

Critical Perspective: The video concludes with a critical stance, framing the practice as problematic and examining its implications for women's rights and social norms.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5vP1sPlG0qQ

honesttalk21, rashduct4luv, lukgaf, budaatum, basilico, kukutente23

A leader is seated on a stool surrounded by his subjects who can do anything for him.
He knows that. So he tells them to perform a ridiculous act like suckling on breasts .
Later on the conversation is recorded, it sticks out like a sore thumb.

Another ridiculous command. Out at the fields , someone complains of being unwell - stomachache or something like that. He tells them to drink camel urine. I'm certain there are PhD level desertations on benefits of camel urine.

DeepSight:
SUMMARY:

The Story of Salim and Sahla: It details a narrated event involving Sahla bint Suhail, her husband Abu Hudhayfa, and their freed slave Salim. According to the narration, Muhammad advised Sahla to breastfeed Salim (an adult) so that he would become her Mahram (a legal relative), allowing him to enter their home freely.

Aisha’s Perspective: The video cites reports suggesting that Aisha, one of Muhammad’s wives, viewed this not as a unique exception for Salim but as a general rule. It mentions that she allegedly encouraged her relatives to breastfeed men she wished to host.

Opposition from Other Wives: It highlights that most of Muhammad's other wives disagreed, believing the instruction was an "indulgence" specifically and only for Salim, and they refused to adopt the practice.

The "Missing" Quranic Verses: The video discusses Hadiths claiming that verses regarding adult breastfeeding were once part of the Quran but were lost—specifically citing a narration where a sheep or goat purportedly ate the parchment containing them after Muhammad's death.

Modern Interpretations: It references contemporary controversies, such as a 2007 incident involving a professor at Al-Azhar University who suggested the practice could be a solution for gender segregation in the workplace, and different views on whether the milk must be taken directly or can be served in a cup.

Critical Perspective: The video concludes with a critical stance, framing the practice as problematic and examining its implications for women's rights and social norms.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5vP1sPlG0qQ

You are basically looking for trouble with this opening of one of Islam's cankerworms. 😂

Let's see how they respond👀.

basilico:
A leader is seated on a stool surrounded by his subjects who can do anything for him.
He knows that. So he tells them to perform a ridiculous act like suckling on breasts .
Later on the conversation is recorded, it sticks out like a sore thumb.

Another ridiculous command. Out on the fields , someone complainsnof being unwell - stomachache or something like that. He tells them to drink camel urine. I'm certain there are PhD level desertations on benefits of camel urine.

Yeah, the same with dipping of flies into one's drink🤧. Allah surely knows best.

Gabrielshow26:
You are basically looking for trouble with this opening of one of Islam's cankerworms. 😂

Let's see how they respond👀.

They will not. They always ignore such things and pretend they dont exist.

DeepSight:
They will not. They always ignore such things and pretend they dont exist.

Honesttalk21, would most likely attempt this as he is their "current" champion. He actively loves to defend Islam. Another person would be explore2xmore. The rest are just shy👀. Qasim6 is salladin to antichristian's, Gokbori. He too can try to attempt it. Lukuluku69 is another specialist, although he would most likely use deflections but since you are not a Christian, there is nothing to deflect to🤧. He might just stay away👀. Ohyoudidnt, abutwins, and JimRohn are the last bunch. The rest are either inactive or prefer to look away.

However, their cowardice would stem from the fact, that you are agnostic and they have nothing to deflect to. Hopefully, one of them shows up and saves Islam😮‍💨.

Gabrielshow26:
Honesttalk21, would most likely attempt this as he is their "current" champion. He actively loves to defend Islam. Another person would be explore2xmore. The rest are just shy👀. Qasim6 is salladin to antichristian's, Gokbori. He too can try to attempt it. Lukuluku69 is another specialist, although he would most likely use deflections but since you are not a Christian, there is nothing to deflect to🤧. He might just stay away👀. Ohyoudidnt, abutwins, and JimRohn are the last bunch. The rest are either inactive or prefer to look away.

However, their cowardice would stem from the fact, that you are agnostic and they have nothing to deflect to. Hopefully, one of them shows up and saves Islam😮‍💨.

Thank you.

Gabrielshow26:
Honesttalk21, would most likely attempt this as he is their "current" champion. He actively loves to defend Islam. Another person would be explore2xmore. The rest are just shy👀. Qasim6 is salladin to antichristian's, Gokbori. He too can try to attempt it. Lukuluku69 is another specialist, although he would most likely use deflections but since you are not a Christian, there is nothing to deflect to🤧. He might just stay away👀. Ohyoudidnt, abutwins, and JimRohn are the last bunch. The rest are either inactive or prefer to look away.

However, their cowardice would stem from the fact, that you are agnostic and they have nothing to deflect to. Hopefully, one of them shows up and saves Islam😮‍💨.

Muslims truely wish that Islam is TRUE, unfortunately it isn't, therefore Muslims have to resort to manipulating existing Islamic history and knowledge in defence of their religion

TenQ:
Muslims truely wish that Islam is TRUE, unfortunately it isn't, therefore Muslims have to resort to manipulating existing Islamic history and knowledge in defence of their religion

What unambiguously straight forward points do you have and do you support your claim with?

Explore2xmore:
What unambiguously straight forward points do you have and do you support your claim with?

Simple question una no go answer

All una top debaters don run or convert

Read the Quran and hafiths and you will see the chaos and depravity


Tueeehhh

What can you say about the breastfeeding?

BlackfireX:
Simple question una no go answer

All una top debaters don run or convert

Read the Quran and hafiths and you will see the chaos and depravity


Tueeehhh

What can you say about the breastfeeding?

Where's the unanswered simple question? Your spitting shows your disdain and skewed place of interest in getting answered if at all.

You obviously don't like the truth said straight to you.

Explore2xmore:
Where's the unanswered simple question? Your spitting shows your disdain and skewed place of interest in getting answered if at all.

You obviously don't like the truth said straight to you.

alfa jubreel

who wrote thr Quran?

where is shahada in the Quran?

where is hijra of muslim refugees from mecca to medina?

one good thing about Qutham a.k.a muhamed?

where is 5 pillars of faith in The Quran ?

In their prophet's defence
It's quite logical
This women are called the mother of believers
Now what do we humans do when we first set eyes on our mothers? We suck their breasts
That's what we do. That's why the companions are the best of believers cause they suckled directly from the Mommas while the relatively fake Muslims of these days have to make excuses for being excluded from suckling
Though I wonder how Abraham and other folks would fare on this ladder since we're not sure of their posture on suckling Momma's breasts

BlackfireX:
alfa jubreel

who wrote thr Quran?

where is shahada in the Quran?

where is hijra of muslim refugees from mecca to medina?

one good thing about Qutham a.k.a muhamed?

where is 5 pillars of faith in The Quran ?

When you arrogantly abuse in starting are you honestly asking or truthful in seeking answers of me?

I will answer when you provide irrefutable proof that Qutham is the same as prophet Muhammad pbuh.

Explore2xmore:
When you arrogantly abuse in starting are you honestly asking or truthful in seeking answers of me?

I will answer when you provide irrefutable proof that Qutham is the same as prophet Muhammad pbuh.

So you are clueless ---- you don't have an answer

Now run along go and play with kids in the sand area

Kukutente23:
In their prophet's defence
It's quite logical
This women are called the mother of believers
Now what do we humans do when we first set eyes on our mothers? We suck their breasts
That's what we do. That's why the companions are the best of believers cause they suckled directly from the Mommas while the relatively fake Muslims of these days have to make excuses for being excluded from suckling
Though I wonder how Abraham and other folks would fare on this ladder since we're not sure of their posture on suckling Momma's breasts

My fiery brother on fire!

I too would like to hear more from Muslims on this.

You see how you hide your ignorance when probed? I gave just one condition based on your reckless oral oh hand diarrhea which you can't meet. Indeed your capacity for sound discussion is absent.
Provide irrefutable proof that Qutham is the same as prophet Muhammad pbuh then my position is wrong.

BlackfireX:
So you are clueless ---- you don't have an answer

Now run along go and play with kids in the sand area

Explore2xmore:
You see how you hide your ignorance when probed? I gave just one condition based on your reckless oral oh hand diarrhea which you can't meet. Indeed your capacity for sound discussion is absent.
Provide irrefutable proof that Qutham is the same as prophet Muhammad pbuh then my position is wrong.

What is this one saying?

Check my conversation with you ... you have been incoherent and scared


Where is shahada in the Quran?
Who wrote the Quran?
Where is hijra of muslim refugees from mecca to medina?
One good remarkable thing about Qutham a.k.a Muhammad as a prophet?

Choose any of the topic

Do you understand English and the words coming out of my mouth?
Now don't panic

BlackfireX:
What is this one saying?

Check my conversation with you ... you have been incoherent and scared


Where is shahada in the Quran?
Who wrote the Quran?
Where is hijra of muslim refugees from mecca to medina?
One good remarkable thing about Qutham a.k.a Muhammad as a prophet?

Choose any of the topic

Do you understand English and the words coming out of my mouth?
Now don't panic

This isn't a platform to rehearse bits of a movie line besides I can only read what you type and can't hear you. Asking for proof on one of your questions doesn't necessitate going through nairaland archives. You are just grand standing in diversion. Specifically because others have given you responses you totally reject because of your fixation.
I don't know if you're seeking praise or just mischief.

Explore2xmore:
This isn't a platform to rehearse bits of a movie line besides I can only read what you type and can't hear you. Asking for proof on one of your questions doesn't necessitate going through nairaland archives. You are just grand standing in diversion. Specifically because others have given you responses you totally reject because of your fixation.
I don't know if you're seeking praise or just mischief.

It seems your bone of contention is about Mohammed being named Qutham👀 and not on the "breast feeding verses". Can this not be categorized as deflection?

For clarity, are you arguing that such narratives can't be found in your books?👀You might want to think this one deeply, given our previous conversations, you seem to have this predisposition of throwing your scholars under the bus😅.

Explore2xmore:
This isn't a platform to rehearse bits of a movie line besides I can only read what you type and can't hear you. Asking for proof on one of your questions doesn't necessitate going through nairaland archives. You are just grand standing in diversion. Specifically because others have given you responses you totally reject because of your fixation.
I don't know if you're seeking praise or just mischief.

You sound like you are hungry or lack understanding?


Who answered me---- they brought conjectures that future exposes them .... check the topic there for yourself

BlackfireX:
You sound like you are hungry or lack understanding?


Who answered me---- they brought conjectures that future exposes them .... check the topic there for yourself

Are you sure? Please show me how

Explore2xmore:
Are you sure? Please show me how

Jumping Jumping

I asked questions----you didn't answer

And you are dancing around



Tell me one good remarkable thing about Qutham a.k.a Muhammad?

Simply getting better understanding of your questions. Starting with clarity about your reference to Qutham as the prophet pbuh. Knowing this isn't mistaken will better position your other questions.

BlackfireX:
Jumping Jumping

I asked questions----you didn't answer

And you are dancing around



Tell me one good remarkable thing about Qutham a.k.a Muhammad?

Explore2xmore:
Simply getting better understanding of your questions. Starting with clarity about your reference to Qutham as the prophet pbuh. Knowing this isn't mistaken will better position your other questions.

Now let me lecture you---- Muhammad is a title not a name----- a divine title ---- that means--- One worthy of praise


Guess who were using that title and whom it was used for?

I will create a thread for it--- after my debate with baba shuaib from Ghana.

Now clap for me.

Now get on with it

What is the remarkable good thing about Qutham a.k.a Muhammad that is so remarkable and good----just 1?

Don't panic

How does this show Qutham = Muhammad? Seems you actually can't prove that.

BlackfireX:
Now let me lecture you---- Muhammad is a title not a name----- a divine title ---- that means--- One worthy of praise


Guess who were using that title and whom it was used for?

I will create a thread for it--- after my debate with baba shuaib from Ghana.

Now clap for me.

Now get on with it

What is the remarkable good thing about Qutham a.k.a Muhammad that is so remarkable and good----just 1?

Don't panic