Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History - Culture - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Culture › Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History (551 Views)
| Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by Nobody: 8:26pm On May 07*. Modified: 12:01pm On May 09 |
This paper is not talking about full ancestry. It is only looking at one narrow father-to-son line on the Y chromosome. When you see “haplotype,” think of it as a father-line genetic signature, not the total ancestry of a people. When you see “RST distance,” read it as a closeness score on the father-line test: the smaller the number, the closer the paternal lines of the group are related. The larger the number, the further away their paternal lines are related. The paper included 21 Itsekiri men, 110 Yoruba men (split into two groups: 49 Yoruba-Ibadan, 61 Yoruba-Lagos), 28 Urhobo men, 48 Bini men, 47 Mende men, and 34 Temne men. In Table 4, we see the Itsekiri sample is closer by RST distance to Bini (0.025) and Urhobo (0.025), and even closer to Temne (0.047) and Mende (0.059), than to either of the Yoruba sample. Yoruba-Ibadan (0.191), Yoruba-Lagos (0.154). This is not enough to prove or disprove any claims of origin but it shows the common claim by some, that Itsekiris are Yoruba offshoots or migrants who paternally descend from Yoruba is not necessarily the case. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article/file?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0029687&type=printable |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by lawani(m): 9:19pm On May 07 |
NaWhoTalkAm:Spirit does not care about DNA. DNA can be altered along the line because of location due to the sexual adventures of your ancestors and etc but who is incarnating in you will not change. If someone impregnates your daughter without marriage for instance the child will be an incarnate from a spirit in your line and not from the sperm donor. DNA is just clothe that spirits wear though it obviously tells a story. It is however the story passed down by your ancestors that matter. The Esan for instance are said to be the most genetically similar to the Yoruba in Nigeria as I read somewhere but they are not even Yoruboid not to talk of being Yoruba. There are white people in Brazil today who know they are Ijesa, their DNA will of course say they are not but they know they are and it is the spirits originally from there that incarnates in their kids. No reasonable person will argue with them that they are not Ijesa just because they are phenotypically white. DNA does not negate nor affirm anything and neighbors will always have similar DNA for obvious reasons |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by Nobody: 2:40am On May 08 |
lawani:We Itsekiri are Itsekiri in spirit, not Yoruba. Also the paternal line of the 21 Itsekiri in this study is not just similar to our nearest neighbours but also to Mende and Temne all the way in Sierra Leone. |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by lawani(m): 9:08am On May 08 |
NaWhoTalkAm:Your DNA can only be similar to your neighbors and not people you are separated from by vast territory. Even if you came from there originally, how many centuries of intermarriage do you need to make you similar to your new neighbours? Your submission does not align with any known science. It is like saying DNA in France aligns with DNA in Ukraine. Not possible |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by Nobody: 12:06pm On May 09*. Modified: 12:31pm On May 09 |
lawani:The study is looking at a certain part of paternal ancestry (father's paternal line) not how genetically close two groups are entirely. Furthermore, intermarriage is not enough to change this kind of paternal ancestry under a system where the woman marries into the man's society or ethnicity and not vice versa. The only thing that could change it is assimilation of outsider males into the society, thereby bringing their own paternal genetic history with them. In the Itsekiris case, given the high similarity and that there is likely no recent migration of Temne or Mende into the Niger Delta or nearby regions, I believe it is a result of long term ancestral lineage. Put in other words, some male members of an ancient population that eventually produced the Itsekiri were among the ancestral patriarchs that produced the Temne and the Mende as well, and were perhaps a more significant portion of their ancestral patriarchs than of the other groups tested. |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by lawani(m): 12:44pm On May 09 |
NaWhoTalkAm:It is not easy for me to read the paper using my phone but I will try and read it later but I am certain that paternal ancestry can not match by fifty percent between those groups and any group in the Niger Delta not even by thirty percent. They are too far apart. Any nation of human beings is composed originally of people that agreed to take up that identity and they definitely can not all have the same paternal ancestry. However they have fought wars, shed blood and defended territory over centuries for that identity and that is what matters. DNA is not really accurate all the time. Many times they just come to predetermined conclusions that they are comfortable with. For instance Kemitic Egypt is just five thousand years ago and the language they spoke was an archaic form of Yoruba language and it is agreed that modern Egyptians are more than seventy percent descended from those ancient Egyptians but there are no studies showing any correlation between their DNA and those in Nigeria like Igala, Yoruba, Itsekiri etc who speak the modern form of their old language. It is like saying there is no correlation found between German genes and English genes but we know the English have thirty percent of their DNA as Germanic in origin and their language is a Germanic language. The only difference between the two scenarios is the time gap English people and German people are separated by 1000 years. There were no German origin words being spoken in Britain 1500 years ago. They only had Celtic languages. Five thousand years ago, the language of Egypt was an archaic form of the modern Yoruba language and one would expect the relationship to also show up in the DNA as it does between Germany and Britain. There are even Egyptian paternal lines deep into Europe according to reports. However the tools they use may not be sophisticated enough for wider time gaps. So it means it is not entirely reliable. In the long run, stories and acknowledged history as well as physical evidence are more solid than DNA evidence because anybody can be sworn in to become members of any nation and your DNA does not in any way determine your social ancestors or spiritual ancestors. For example my spiritual research with IFA says majority of people in the western hemisphere have red Indian spiritual ancestry but DNA will tell you they are of European and African ancestry in the majority. |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by RedboneSmith(m): 6:03am On May 11 |
NaWhoTalkAm:What informed the choice to sample Yoruba men from Ibadan and Lagos? Given the fact that the Itsekiri are linguistically closer to Yorubas from Ondo State (the Ilaje, the Ikale and so on), a proper study should have sampled Yoruba men from there instead of distant Ibadan. |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by Nobody: 6:32pm On May 17 |
RedboneSmith:Yes, a good point. The study was not really trying to compare the genetics of the Yoruba and Itsekiri per se but was just getting some record of various West African groups. However, even if the Ilajes and Ondo groups were tested and and scored near on paternal ancestry, it still shows that shared ancient paternal ancestry is not necessarily a good way to define a group as Yoruba since the Ibadan Yorubas and Lagos Yorubas scored a far off result from the Itsekiris regardless. |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by lawani(m): 8:12pm On May 17 |
NaWhoTalkAm:So if you discover that one of your paternal uncles has a different origin Y DNA, he will no longer be a part of the family? DNA is just like clothes. The spirit of your grandfather for instance will incarnate in your kids even if your wife was impregnated by another person and if you train somebody and they see you as their father, you can come back as their descendant. Then your own biological son that matches you by DNA can be a spiritual bastard. So downplay DNA, it does not mean much. |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by Nobody: 5:09am On May 18 |
lawani:Why would one of your paternal uncles have a different Y DNA? Is Y DNA not passed down from father to son? Anyhow, you are addressing a different point than what I made. My point is that ancient paternal ancestry is not a good basis for defining who is and who is not Yoruba so you're actually proving my point if in your scenario you would consider the uncle with a different Y DNA still part of the family. |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by lawani(m): 5:17am On May 18 |
NaWhoTalkAm:With all my explanation you still can't see why DNA should not be able to divide a family? It can't divide nor can it unite a. Family |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by googi: 5:09pm On May 18 |
This reminds me of stories or history that each of these ethnic groups çame or descended from Egypt. On their way to Egypt or on their way from Egypt, they never met ? Suzerainty has caused so much dislocation within us, we are willing to claim heritage with others far from our country than within. This is how Yoruba heritage is being lost in Bini and those whose lingua fraca and names are Yoruba including Oba of Benin and their descendants are forced to choose between Yoruba or Edo. Now, the Itsekiri, the recent cousins of Yoruba in language and culture are looking for way out to claim or disown suzerainty? It doesn't make a difference because outsiders trace their history to Yorubaland. The Yoruba have no territorial pursuit. Someone just wrote the affiliation of white South Americans to Yoruba, leaving Black South Americans in wonder. |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by RedboneSmith(m): 7:31am On May 19 |
NaWhoTalkAm:Yes. I made my comment without reading the paper. I read it later and I’ve got the full context now. In your original post you were sort of trying to make the research answer a question it didn’t set out to answer. That could lead to incorrect conclusions. The experiment would have to be designed differently to answer the question of how related the Itsekiri are to the Yoruba as compared to the Edo. |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by Nobody: 1:19pm On May 19 |
lawani:I think you need to go back and read my post before responding because my exact point is that DNA should not be used as a basis to define someone as Yoruba or not. |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by Nobody: 1:26pm On May 19 |
RedboneSmith:That's fair. |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by uKnighted: 7:13pm On May 19 |
I've been trying to figure out what the Itsekiri are because they speak a Yoruba type language but there's some people who say they have no association with the Yorubas. Now, there are groups in genetic ancestry databases for "Urhobo", "Central Esan and Urhobo", "Urhobo and Itsekiri", and "Itsekiri" now: https://admixr.com/23gg This post and replies are interesting as an outsider. Some African Americans, like me, are starting to see the specific "Urhobo and Itsekiri" tribe for the first time now in our results and trying to get the history down because these companies will report we have significant Nigerian ancestry, 30-50% on avg with specific tribes now. I've talked to a guy from Ondo state who's met many Itsekiri and said he can understand the Itsekiri because of his own dialect. Does anyone know of the Olukumi people in Delta? If they may be connected to the indigenous Itsekiri before Ginuwa?
|
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by lawani(m): 4:05am On May 20 |
uKnighted:There are people who speak Yoruboid languages but don't identify with the Yoruba chief among them is the Igala in Kogi state and some groups in Eastern Nigeria. Igalas have ancient Ifes on their land. Up to four or so but their main King the Attah of Igala is not a member of the Yoruba dynasty. It is possible that some Onus in Igala land are descended from ancient Ife royal families but not the Attah. Itsekiri on their part have their leadership descended from that dynasty via Benin and Itsekiri would have been there before the establishment of Benin. They are according to them a mix of Ijebu, Ilaje and Igala The Olukumi in my opinion are from the old Benin city and are presently speaking the old language of Benin city but because the language they speak is not different from Owo's Yoruba dialect in Ondo state, many say they migrated from Owo but Owo and Benin spoke the same Yoruba dialect in the past. If Owo and Itsekiri are not exactly the same then Olukumi and Itsekiri too are not |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by Nobody: 1:28pm On Jun 30 |
lawani:Claims that the Itsekiri are a “mix of Ijebu, Ilaje, Igala, Ile-Ife,” or other such combinations of Yoruba and Igala are really modern claims, and I believe they are historically weak. They have become more popular recently because of present political tensions in Delta State and the desire by some people to attach Itsekiri identity to larger external groups for political support. I will address the actual history of the Itsekiri in more detail in another thread. On the Benin point, the idea that Yoruba was once the language of the Benin palace has no merit, and should not be stated casually without strong evidence. Benin may have had Yoruba-speaking attendants, visitors, traders, captives, priests, or people from subject/influenced towns in court circles. That would not be surprising, considering Benin’s historical influence over parts of what are now southwestern and southeastern Yorubaland. But that is very different from claiming that the Benin royal elite themselves spoke a Yoruba dialect as the palace language. That is a far bigger claim, and it does not at all fit with what we know of Benin’s political culture, court titles, rituals, royal ideology and institutions. A ruling dynasty cannot abandon its court language without leaving very clear traces in titles, ceremonies, praise names, palace organization, and oral traditions. Please, undermining other people’s culture is not the way forward for Yoruba or any other group. It makes the group doing such come across as insecure. |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by lawani(m): 1:38pm On Jun 30*. Modified: 2:10pm On Jun 30 |
NaWhoTalkAm:Leave it to the Itsekiri to determine who they are. For now they identify as part of the Yoruba. The fact that the old Benin capital was a Yoruba speaking city is self evident. If you want to wake up the empire today the only language that will be acceptable is Yoruba because that was what they used in the past and the old capital today is encircled by Yoruba speaking towns, cities and villages that have been speaking the language for centuries. The present occupiers of the city came from the suburbs. Their ancestors did not live inside the city If you argue against it you are only arguing against basic common sense |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by Nobody: 8:43pm On Jun 30 |
lawani:I am Itsekiri and we do not identify as Yoruba nor will we ever despite the attempts of a few. There is also no evidence that the language of the Benin capital was Yoruba. In fact, the evidence points the other way. What you are presenting is not history, but it is how you wish history had happened. Benin has many families who trace their descent to chiefs, princes, and royal lineages. Their oral traditions do not support the idea that Benin City was originally Yoruba-speaking. In Itsekiri land as well, there are communities, titles, and lineages connected to Benin princes and chiefs, many of which preserve Benin names and traditions. None of this points to Yoruba being the language of the Benin capital. I can go on and on but I don't see the point. Your argument seems to be that because Benin had influence over or conquered some nearby Yoruba-speaking towns, Benin itself must have been Yoruba-speaking. That does not follow. Benin also conquered or influenced nearby Igbo, Urhobo, Ijaw, and other communities. Did Benin therefore become Igbo, Urhobo, or Ijaw-speaking too? A conquering state does not automatically adopt the language of every people it rules over. Empires can dominate culturally, politically, and militarily without becoming the same as their subjects. So the claim that Benin City must have spoken Yoruba simply because there were Yoruba-speaking towns around or near it is not evidence. It is pure speculation. Even very near and related neighbors of the Benin/Edo people, such as Esan, still keep a different language and culture from that of Benin. So your claim has really no merit whatsoever. Leave the Itsekiri to define ourselves. And leave Benin history to evidence, not wishful thinking. |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by lawani(m): 9:00pm On Jun 30 |
NaWhoTalkAm:An unknown I'd on nairaland can't speak for the Itsekiri. All the real Itsekiri in public identify with the larger Yoruba. The Urhobo in Warri do speak the Itsekiri dialect and any Urhobo or Ijaw that was part of the Benin would do the same. All the Edoid people affiliated with the Benin empire mostly speak Yoruba till today. The Afemai are Yoruba in all but name and have been so for centuries. All the people to the East whose ancestors came from Benin city had ancestors that spoke Yoruba a few centuries ago. To the East of Benin today are still settlements that are still speaking the Yoruba of the Benin empire along with the Igbo they learnt a few centuries back for example the Olukunmi. There are others who know they are Yoruba but now speak only Igbo. The Yoruba spoken today in Owo, Usen, Ugbodu and etc is the Yoruba of the Benin empire |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by Nobody: 9:48pm On Jun 30 |
lawani:LOOOOL you clearly do not know anything at all of what you are talking about. A Yoruba man on Nairaland will not be the one to tell me what "all the real Itsekiri" identify as. Especially not one who believes that the Urhobo speaks a dialect of Itsekiri. Looooool. I cannot contain myself. Have you ever heard an Urhobo speak their language before? Have you heard an Ijaw speak? So all the Itsekiri, Urhobo, Ijaw in Warri who cannot understand each others native language, are just delusional? It's you Iawani that knows? And, you said Afemai speaks Yoruba too looll. Which Afemai speaks Yoruba as their native language? Afemai in Edo state or is there another one in Osun state? Lol, please learn to use evidence to come to your conclusions. Edo and Delta Igbos were not speaking Yoruba either, this is completely baseless. In fact, every you've point you've made is baseless. You mentioned a few Yoruba settlements as if to say that since there were Yoruba settlements then everyone in the region must have been speaking Yoruba. Are Yorubas that magnetic? Why wouldn't everyone speak Igbo, Ijaw or Urhobo since they also had settlements in the region? Your post reads like the wild imaginations of a Yoruba fanatic and supremacist who has not even bothered to become genuinely accustomed with the people and places he wants to speak on. If you were a child, I would have thought you were trolling me. But since you're an adult, goodluck. |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by lawani(m): 10:09pm On Jun 30*. Modified: 10:59pm On Jun 30 |
NaWhoTalkAm:The Urhobos and Ijaws inside Warri speak the Itsekiri language along with their own language originally. I never said their language is a dialect of Yoruba. The Ijaw in Ondo do speak the Yoruba dialect prevalent in the area and etc. Any Ijaw and etc that related with Benin in the past did so in the Yoruba language It is a fact that all the settlements surrounding Benin city including Yoruba and non Yoruba still have Yoruba as their lingua franca. Most of them are infact Yoruba who sometimes have another language too. They bear Yoruba marks, bear Yoruba names and practice Yoruba culture. The present Benin people were one of the many non Yoruba speakers in the empire and they used to live outside the city Call me whatever you want. It is the Olukunmi themselves who call themselves Yoruba and there are still others who don't even speak Yoruba at all but that know they were Yoruba. They were all members of the Benin empire I doubt if you can find an Afemai who does not speak Yoruba. They not only speak Yoruba, they also bear Yoruba names and practice Yoruba culture for example if they born twins they will name them according to Yoruba tradition etc |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by Nobody: 11:14pm On Jun 30*. Modified: 3:24am On Jul 01 |
lawani:Saying something is facts does not make it facts. No serious source supports your claim. Most settlements surrounding Benin do not speak Yoruba. Only in a few places around northern Edo state, mainly Akoko-Edo do they speak Yoruba and it is not even spoken as a native language but as a lingua franca. Each one of those groups have their own native language and origin story that is very different from Yoruba. It is like saying that since the north speaks Hausa as a lingua franca, then everyone in the north is Hausa. Or that since in Nigeria, we speak English as our standard language then we are all English/British. Not to mention, the groups that even speak Yoruba as a lingua franca in Edo state, are a small minority. Olukumi you cited is in Delta state, which is in fact a Yoruba group and I never denied that but it is also a very small one. How can you use small Yoruba settlements and small settlements of people who only speak Yoruba as a lingua franca to claim that the entire region speaks/spoke Yoruba? Please do proper research on your claims with verified sources before you respond to me again. Even a simple google search will disprove most of your claims. |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by lawani(m): 7:52am On Jul 01 |
NaWhoTalkAm:Akokoid people are Yoruba people in the same way the Celtic people who still speak Celtic languages are English. Are you going to say Aare Gani Adams is not a Yoruba man or Pastor T B Joshua is not a Yoruba man? The same applies to the Akoko of Edo North. You can't compare Hausa speakers in the North to the Akoko because it was the British that brought Hausa language to them. Their parents and grandparents did not speak Hausa. The numerous Akoko languages are classified as ede Ife or Ife language Yoruba is spoken as a native language among the Akoko. I wonder if you know the meaning of native language |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by Nobody: 8:52am On Jul 01 |
lawani:I'm not bothering to answer your question until you do appropriate research and what you want to speak on. You are not a kid, behave like a man. Before you respond to me next, list all the various groups that make up Akoko-Edo so I know you have some idea of what you are talking about, not Akoko-Ondo. List them by name. There are more than one group there. Akoko-Edo is a regional name not the name of the ethnicities that compromise it. |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by lawani(m): 9:17am On Jul 01 |
NaWhoTalkAm:The real name of Akoko Edo is Akoko Oke meaning the Akoko that is on the highlands. Akoko is Akoko and if they don't see themselves as one they won't have the same name. I believe you get it. Or why do you think they share the same appellation if they don't see themselves as one? All Akoko towns are Akoko in the same way all Itsekiri towns are Itsekiri, Urhobo towns Urhobo, Ijesa towns are Ijesa etc. There are Ijesa towns for instance that speak a dialect closer to Ife but they are still Ijesa. Are you the one to come and say some Akoko are not real Akoko? |
| Re: Study Leaves Room for a More Complex Itsekiri Paternal History by Nobody: 9:20am On Jul 01 |
lawani:Please go and find the name of each ethnic group/tribe that constitutes Akoko-Edo before responding to me. |
Royalty on wheel: Olu of Warri Rides Scooter Through Ode-Itsekiri(Photos /Video) • Olu Of Warri Kicks Out Ayiri, Revalidates Iyatsere, 10 Other Itsekiri Chiefs • Olu Of Warri Coronation: Tsola Emiko Walking Before Departing For Ode-Itsekiri • 2 • 3 • 4
Residential Cleaning Services • Yoruba Youth Forum,garki LG Of Jigawa.(royal Club) • Reaction To Nigerians Reaction To American Gay Ruling