₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,345,947 members, 8,520,328 topics. Date: Tuesday, 17 November 2026 at 04:47 PM

Toggle theme

A Welfare State Can't Be Affected By Automation - Politics - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › A Welfare State Can't Be Affected By Automation (154 Views)

1 Reply (Go Down)

A Welfare State Can't Be Affected By Automation by lawani(op): 12:15pm On Apr 17
A welfare state can't be affected by automation


A state where the government looks out for everybody can not be affected by automation because there are already programs like unemployment benefits. They only need to add the right to a means of livelihood as a fundamental human right. It is important to add this right to the list of fundamental human rights because it is a basic right and a human being should be expected to commit crime if no other way to earn a living.

In a communist state, automation will be a positive for them. It will be a welcome development since it is a no one left behind society and it is only a full fledged capitalist economy with no regulations that have anything to fear from automation. The more the automation in a communist state the more it favours the workers because they will simply have more free time

Robots can not compete for managerial jobs. Robots can not do research and robots can not lead, robots can not innovate, so robots are not really competition for human beings in a sufficiently advanced society. Robots can also not take all non managerial posts. Academic work alone can employ all human beings but it will not be possible in a country with an abysmally low tax to GDP ratio.

In what I call a free market communist economy where employment is guaranteed and overtime increase in net worth is also guaranteed by statute, automation will not be a problem and government policy will actually be geared towards expanding automation.
Re: A Welfare State Can't Be Affected By Automation by Cromagnon: 12:21am On Jul 07
lawani:
A welfare state can't be affected by automation


A state where the government looks out for everybody can not be affected by automation because there are already programs like unemployment benefits. They only need to add the right to a means of livelihood as a fundamental human right. It is important to add this right to the list of fundamental human rights because it is a basic right and a human being should be expected to commit crime if no other way to earn a living.


You don't have a right to life
You have a right to not be killed

You don't have a right to food that someone else stressed himself to grow, that is slavery

In a communist state, automation will be a positive for them. It will be a welcome development since it is a no one left behind society and it is only a full fledged capitalist economy with no regulations that have anything to fear from automation. The more the automation in a communist state the more it favours the workers because they will simply have more free time


Communist only buy guns to maintain power

Robots can not compete for managerial jobs. Robots can not do research and robots can not lead, robots can not innovate, so robots are not really competition for human beings in a sufficiently advanced society. Robots can also not take all non managerial posts. Academic work alone can employ all human beings but it will not be possible in a country with an abysmally low tax to GDP ratio.

Ai says otherwise


In what I call a free market communist economy where employment is guaranteed and overtime increase in net worth is also guaranteed by statute, automation will not be a problem and government policy will actually be geared towards expanding automation.
nothing free in communism
Re: A Welfare State Can't Be Affected By Automation by lawani(op): 5:38am On Jul 07
Cromagnon:


You don't have a right to life
You have a right to not be killed

You don't have a right to food that someone else stressed himself to grow, that is slavery




Communist only buy guns to maintain power



Ai says otherwise


nothing free in communism
Maybe you need to read again. The right to a means of livelihood isn't the same thing as the right to life. The right to a means of livelihood is an inherent right and if you recognize it as a state you are helping yourself more than any other entity.

The right to a means of livelihood is just centered around the reality that someone without a job should be expected to steal to survive and the stealing is still a means of livelihood and there should infact be a separate law for that kind of case.

You don't have a right to take what someone else produced by force and if you have the right, how is it slavery? Is it the taker or the producer that is a slave? Is a tax payer a slave? Is the government that takes tax the slave?

AI can't be managers. AI does not have the intellect of a five year old and you need intellect to be a manager.

So capitalists and socialists don't buy guns to maintain power?
Re: A Welfare State Can't Be Affected By Automation by Cromagnon: 3:56am On Jul 08
lawani:
Maybe you need to read again. The right to a means of livelihood isn't the same thing as the right to life. The right to a means of livelihood is an inherent right and if you recognize it as a state you are helping yourself more than any other entity.

You read properly
You have no rights
All you have are privileged that can be taken away if You do not defend them
Nobody is fog to defend your privileges for you
You are on your own


The right to a means of livelihood is just centered around the reality that someone without a job should be expected to steal to survive and the stealing is still a means of livelihood and there should infact be a separate law for that kind of case.

If you steal then you have violated my rights and your life is now forfeit
Think am well
You do not have monopoly of madness


You don't have a right to take what someone else produced by force and if you have the right, how is it slavery? Is it the taker or the producer that is a slave? Is a tax payer a slave? Is the government that takes tax the slave?


What do you think
Monkey de work baboon DE chop
Govt taxes by force then shares to you that refused to enter farm and you think there will be peace?

AI can't be managers. AI does not have the intellect of a five year old and you need intellect to be a manager.

Are you sure about that


So capitalists and socialists don't buy guns to maintain power?
capitalists power to make
Socialist power to take
Which do you think creates prosperity
Re: A Welfare State Can't Be Affected By Automation by lawani(op): 10:32am On Jul 08
Cromagnon:

You read properly
You have no rights
All you have are privileged that can be taken away if You do not defend them
Nobody is fog to defend your privileges for you
You are on your own




If you steal then you have violated my rights and your life is now forfeit
Think am well
You do not have monopoly of madness





What do you think
Monkey de work baboon DE chop
Govt taxes by force then shares to you that refused to enter farm and you think there will be peace?



Are you sure about that


capitalists power to make
Socialist power to take
Which do you think creates prosperity
I have no rights?

I am not talking of a jungle you know nor of an all man for himself society. I am talking of a civilized society. If you are talking of a jungle then we are not on the same page, your comments are worthless here. I am talking of civilization and not barbarism


Execute a petty thief?

Civilized people respond proportionately. They will not wipe out the whole world because someone stole from them. That is part of civilization. I hope you know? Proportional response. You don't seem to know

Taxation is theft?

In civilization, government will take from you and the only thing you can do is to leave the territory. They will not stop you from doing that and you can not as a single person determine that they should not give the money to another or do you think you will be able to do that? . You are a nobody as an individual or who do you think you are? They will give what is taken from you to whoever they want and there will be peace

What creates prosperity?

Numbers!
You don't know what creates prosperity?
It is markets and one person can not say 'we have arrived'. Maybe you think it is capital under the control of one individual.

AI can't be managers. AI can only know what is already known. No new things. No original opinions. It is just better arranged google
1 Reply

Candidates Who May Be Affected By Supreme Court Judgement On The Electoral Act • By-Election Loss: Can Someone Volunteer To Perform A Welfare Check On El-rufai ? • ‘I Will Create A Welfare State’ • 2 • 3 • 4

“where Will Residents Dump Waste?” — Activists Ask Key Question As Lagos Plans • Anambra Speaker Udeze Hails Appointment Of Bishop Kukah As Coou Chancellor. • President Tinubu Approves ₦68 Billion For Maiduguri Emergency Power Plant,