₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,246 members, 8,521,963 topics. Date: Friday, 20 November 2026 at 10:44 AM

Toggle theme

Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity - Christianity Etc - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity (538 Views)

1 2 Reply (Go Down)

Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Janadozz(op): 10:03pm On Jul 13
My dear sisters in Christ,

Grace and peace be unto you from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ. I write to you today not as one who has all the answers, but as a fellow traveler on this difficult journey of faith, with a heart that aches for the brokenness we see all around us. I want to speak to you about something that challenges our modern sensibilities, yet is woven into the very fabric of our biblical heritage: the practice of a husband taking another wife.

Our Biblical Heritage

Before we allow our cultural conditioning to dismiss this outright, let us look at the Word of God. We see that Abraham, our father in faith, had Sarah, Hagar, and later Keturah. Jacob, whose name was changed to Israel, had Leah, Rachel, and their handmaids Bilhah and Zilpah, through whom the twelve tribes of our faith were born. David, a man after God's own heart, had multiple wives. Even Moses had two wives.

The Law of Moses itself acknowledges this practice. Deuteronomy 21:15 speaks plainly: "If a man has two wives, one beloved and the other unloved...". Exodus 21:10 commands that if a man takes another wife, he must not diminish the food, clothing, and marital rights of the first. The Bible does not condemn these patriarchs for having multiple wives. Scripture recognizes it as a lawful practice under the Old Covenant.

A Call to Compassion

Now, I ask you to look around with the eyes of Christ. What do you see? You see women—daughters of Eve, sisters in humanity—who are forced into prostitution because they have no protector, no provider, no covering. They sell their bodies because their spirits are starving, because society has cast them aside, because there is no man to take them under his roof and give them honor.

Is it not better that a woman be called a wife than a harlot? Is it not more righteous that a man provide for a woman in the dignity of marriage than that she be passed from hand to hand in the degradation of the streets?

Reasons Why We Should Consider This Biblical Model

First, it provides for the vulnerable. When there are more women than men in the body of Christ, what is to become of the faithful sisters who have no husband? Shall they be left desolate? The Old Testament shows us that God, in His mercy, allowed this arrangement so that women would not be left without provision.

Second, it mirrors the spiritual reality. Does not Christ, our heavenly Bridegroom, have many brides? Are we not all part of the one Body of Christ, yet many members? The Church is the Bride of Christ, and we are many souls united to one Lord.

Third, it honors women who would otherwise be dishonored. In our modern world, how many women are cast aside because they cannot find a "good Christian man"? How many sit in our pews, year after year, their wombs empty and their arms aching, while their sisters are blessed with children? The story of Hannah and Peninnah, the two wives of Elkanah, shows us that God worked through this arrangement.

Fourth, it is a model of sacrificial love. When a wife agrees to share her husband, she is displaying a love that transcends jealousy—a love that says, "If I have been blessed with a good man, why should I hoard this blessing when my sister is perishing?" This is the love of Ruth, who clung to Naomi, not counting the cost to herself.

Fifth, it was never condemned by God. While the New Testament sets a higher standard for church leaders, commanding that they be the husband of one wife, nowhere does it forbid the common believer from this practice. The law regulated it but did not forbid it.

A Word to the Wives

If your husband comes to you and speaks of taking another wife to rescue her from destitution, from prostitution, from a life of shame—do not harden your heart. Remember Sarah, who gave Hagar to Abraham. Remember Rachel and Leah, who gave their maids to Jacob. These were women of faith, women who understood that the Kingdom of God is bigger than our personal comforts.

Do not let jealousy rob you of the reward that awaits you in heaven. Your reward is not in the exclusivity of your husband's bed, but in the crown of righteousness that awaits those who love the Lord and love their neighbors as themselves.

A Word to the Church

My sisters, let us open our hearts and our homes. Let us not be like the world, which commodifies women and throws them away. Let us be like our Father in heaven, who gathers the outcast and the broken and calls them His own.

If a man in your congregation has the means and the character to take another wife, let him not be condemned, but encouraged. For in doing so, he may be saving a soul from the pit of destruction.

Conclusion

I know this is difficult. I know every fiber of our modern being cries out against it. But I ask you: Is it more righteous that a woman sell her body on the streets, or that she be called a wife in a godly home? Is it more holy that she be a concubine to the world, or a covenant partner to a man of God?

The choice is before us. Let us choose life. Let us choose dignity. Let us choose to be like our mothers in the faith who understood that love is not possessive, but generous.

"He who finds a wife finds a good thing, and obtains favor from the Lord" (Proverbs 18:22). Let us pray that more women may find that favor, even if it comes through the open hearts of those who already have a husband.

May the Lord bless you and keep you, and may He give you the grace to love as He loves.

In Christ's service,

Your sister and servant.
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Dtruthspeaker: 6:47am On Jul 14
Stop talking rubbish. Did Jacob and Moses wake and say they wanted 2 wives? And was David not held guilty for not hearkening to the commandment""Neither shall he multiply wives to himself,"?

The only people who do second wifing are worr... $ and polygamy is a type of punishment
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Janadozz(op): 7:55pm On Jul 14
Brother, I receive your correction in the spirit of iron sharpening iron, but I must respectfully ask you to read the Scriptures more carefully, without the filter of modern Western tradition. Let us address your objections one by one.

1. "Did Jacob and Moses wake up and say they wanted 2 wives?"

You are correct that they did not always initiate it. But that is precisely my point: God sovereignly ordained and blessed these unions anyway.

· Jacob did not plan for Leah and Rachel—but God allowed Laban's deception, and God chose to build the twelve tribes of Israel through those very four women (Leah, Rachel, Bilhah, and Zilpah). Did God punish Jacob for this? No. He renamed him Israel and made him a nation.
· As for Moses, when his sister Miriam and brother Aaron criticized him specifically for marrying a Cushite (Ethiopian) woman (his second wife), God struck Miriam with leprosy (Numbers 12:1-10). God did not rebuke Moses for having two wives; He rebuked Miriam for speaking against His chosen servant. So, far from condemning it, God defended Moses' marriage.

2. "Was David not held guilty for not hearkening to 'Neither shall he multiply wives to himself'?"

You are quoting Deuteronomy 17:17, but you have taken it out of its context. That specific commandment is given exclusively to kings, and it says: "Neither shall he multiply wives to himself, that his heart turn not away."

Notice the reason for the command—it was to prevent foreign, pagan wives from turning the king's heart to idolatry (as Solomon later did). It was never a universal prohibition against all men.

But here is the critical point you missed: In 2 Samuel 12:7-8, God Himself, through the prophet Nathan, tells David: "I gave you your master's house, and I gave you your master's wives into your arms... And if that had been too little, I would have given you even more."

God explicitly says He gave David multiple wives as a blessing! David's guilt was never about the number of his wives. His guilt was over Bathsheba—because he committed adultery and murder to take another man's only wife (Uriah's). That was theft and bloodshed, not the lawful taking of a second wife.

3. "The only people who do second wifing are worse [worr...], and polygamy is a type of punishment."

With respect, this is an emotional statement, not a scriptural one.

· Abraham—the father of our faith—had multiple wives (Sarah, Hagar, Keturah). Was he "worse"? The Bible calls him the friend of God (James 2:23).
· Gideon, the mighty man of valor who delivered Israel, had many wives (Judges 8:30). Was he punished for it? No, God used him mightily.
· If polygamy is a "punishment," why does Exodus 21:10 regulate it with protective laws, saying that if a man takes another wife, he must not reduce the first wife's food, clothing, and marital rights? The Law does not prohibit it; it protects the women involved. A just God does not write laws to protect people in a situation He calls a "punishment."

And if taking extra wives is punishment, then God punished Jacob by making him the father of a great nation? That defies logic.

4. The Real Sin of Our Time

Let us compare the "sin" of a man taking a second wife to provide shelter, provision, and covenant honor to a destitute woman—versus the "righteousness" of a man who leaves her on the streets to be passed around by strangers.

Prostitution is an abomination to God (1 Corinthians 6:15-16). If a man opens his home to rescue a woman from that life, he is practicing the pure religion that James speaks of: "to visit the fatherless and widows in their affliction" (James 1:27).

The world tells you that jealousy is a virtue and that hoarding a good man is love. But Scripture tells us that love does not envy (1 Corinthians 13:4). If you have a good husband and you see your sister perishing without one, refusing to share your covering is not holiness—it is selfishness dressed up in religious language.

Conclusion:

Let us not accuse the patriarchs of sin that God never laid to their charge. David's sin was adultery and murder—not polygamy. Solomon's sin was idolatry—not polygamy. The issue is disobedience to God, not the number of wives.

Before we call biblical polygamy a "punishment," let us ask ourselves: Is it worse to have a godly man who provides for two women, or to have a society where women have no covering and sell their bodies for bread? The Scriptures say, "He who finds a wife finds a good thing, and obtains favor from the Lord" (Proverbs 18:22). Let us not block that favor from reaching a sister in need.
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Dtruthspeaker: 4:42am On Jul 15
Much respect brother, so lets examine these things in Truth. But please brother, Truth is accuracy, so let us treat this issue, forensically dealing with one issue before moving on to the other issues, so that each fact is seen in it's Truth. So I am concentrating on this point below

Janadozz:
1. "Did Jacob and Moses wake up and say they wanted 2 wives?"

You are correct that they did not always initiate it. But that is precisely my point: God sovereignly ordained and blessed these unions anyway.

· Jacob did not plan for Leah and Rachel—but God allowed Laban's deception, and God chose to build the twelve tribes of Israel through those very four women (Leah, Rachel, Bilhah, and Zilpah). Did God punish Jacob for this? No. He renamed him Israel and made him a nation.
If you admit that they never initiated it so why would you expect that God would punish them?
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Janadozz(op): 8:21am On Jul 15
You make a fair point—I did say the wife should initiate. But let's break it down slowly, shall we? 😏

1. Nowhere in the Bible is having multiple wives itself a sin (Abraham, Jacob, David, Solomon – all had many, and God didn't strike them for that). The sin is harlotry/adultery – sleeping with someone who isn't your wife (Prov 6:32, 1 Cor 6:9).

2. If a man has one wife and still chases harlots, he chose to sin – punishment falls on him (Heb 13:4). My suggestion is simply a preventive measure: give him more legal wives so temptation loses its pull. No one said he's forced – he still has free will to say yes or no.

3. You asked: "If she initiated, why would God punish him?" – The answer: He wouldn't, for having a second wife. He would only be punished if he stepped outside that marriage to commit adultery. The co‑wife arrangement keeps him inside the covenant, so he actually escapes punishment.

4. Also, 1 Cor 7:2 says: "Let every man have his own wife" – plural? No, but the principle is to avoid fornication. If one "own wife" isn't enough to keep him faithful, then maybe two "own wives" will. That's just practical math, not theology.

5. So really, the wife who brings in a co‑wife is doing charity – she's saving her husband from God's judgment on sexual immorality. If anything, he should be thanking her, not debating. 🙏😂

Bottom line: The punishment isn't for the number of wives – it's for the sin outside the marriage. If you eliminate the outside, you eliminate the punishment. Case closed. Now go hug your wife (or wives).
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by MaxInDHouse(m): 11:41am On Jul 15
What most Bible readers missed in the Bible is how the Author directed the affairs of His worshipers instead of focusing on the imperfection of God's servants we need to look into the primary goal of the Bible from Genesis to Revelation.
In the beginning God instituted marriage and it was between a pair which is one man and one woman they must become one flesh. Matthew 19:4-6 compare to Genesis 2:24
Now it's mandatory that both of them must not hide anything from each other just as you can't hide from your own flesh but when humans became multiple on planet earth something happened, a man named Lamech took two women and married them which is no longer the former arrangement so we may wonder why God didn't stop him. God didn't because Adam and Eve chose to do things their own way without taking permission from God {Genesis 3:1-6} so God decided to allow their descendants to follow whichever path they choose before the coming of Christ. It's when the Christ came that he told us that whoever wants to return to the Paradise God intended in the beginning must revert to the standard God set in the beginning which is One Adam and One Eve! Matthew 19:4-5

So today whoever finds it difficult to cope with the standard God set in the garden of Eden will not be able to live in Paradise: God's Kingdom!
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Dtruthspeaker: 5:46am On Jul 16
Janadozz:
You make a fair point—I did say the wife should initiate...
.
Are you saying that the wife should cmmit adultery by initiating it?
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Janadozz(op): 5:53am On Jul 16
Dtruthspeaker:
Are you saying that the wife should cmmit adultery by initiating it?
Wait, let's pause right there. 😂

How does proposing a marriage equal committing adultery?

Adultery is sexual sin with someone who isn't your spouse (Exodus 20:14). The wife isn't sleeping with the new woman—her husband will. She's just the matchmaker, not the participant. Big difference.

Let me break it down:

1. Sarah did it. Genesis 16:2 – Sarah gave Hagar to Abraham. Did God call Sarah an adulteress? Nope. He called Abraham righteous. If proposing a second wife was adultery, Sarah would've been struck down. Instead, she's a matriarch of faith.
2. Initiation ≠ participation. If I recommend a restaurant, does that mean I ate the food? No. The wife is saying, "Here's a legal alternative to the streets"—she's not joining the bedroom. She's solving a logistical problem.
3. Adultery requires a lack of covenant. The new woman becomes a wife through covenant (marriage). That makes it lawful sex, not adultery. The streets have no covenant—that's why it's sin.

So no, she's not committing adultery. She's committing wisdom. And if wisdom is a sin, then Solomon was the biggest sinner of all—which we both know isn't true. 😉
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Janadozz(op): 6:01am On Jul 16
MaxInDHouse:
What most Bible readers missed in the Bible is how the Author directed the affairs of His worshipers instead of focusing on the imperfection of God's servants we need to look into the primary goal of the Bible from Genesis to Revelation.
In the beginning God instituted marriage and it was between a pair which is one man and one woman they must become one flesh. Matthew 19:4-6 compare to Genesis 2:24
Now it's mandatory that both of them must not hide anything from each other just as you can't hide from your own flesh but when humans became multiple on planet earth something happened, a man named Lamech took two women and married them which is no longer the former arrangement so we may wonder why God didn't stop him. God didn't because Adam and Eve chose to do things their own way without taking permission from God {Genesis 3:1-6} so God decided to allow their descendants to follow whichever path they choose before the coming of Christ. It's when the Christ came that he told us that whoever wants to return to the Paradise God intended in the beginning must revert to the standard God set in the beginning which is One Adam and One Eve! Matthew 19:4-5

So today whoever finds it difficult to cope with the standard God set in the garden of Eden will not be able to live in Paradise: God's Kingdom!
Whoa, you actually brought exegesis! I respect that. 👏 But let's gently unpack where you jumped the track.

1. Yes, Eden was the ideal.
One man + one woman = God's original design. No debate there. Genesis 2:24 and Matthew 19:4–6 are clear.

2. BUT – Jesus was addressing divorce, not polygamy.
Read Matthew 19:3–9 carefully. The Pharisees asked about divorce. Jesus said, "Moses permitted you to divorce because of your hard hearts, but from the beginning it was not so."
Notice: He allowed divorce (which He hates – Malachi 2:16) because of human weakness, but He didn't say divorced people are banned from Paradise. If God accommodates divorce, why can't He accommodate polygamy as a lesser evil to stop harlotry?

3. Your "Paradise disqualification" logic has a fatal flaw.
If polygamy automatically disqualifies someone from God's Kingdom, then Abraham, Jacob, David, and Solomon are all burning in hell. But Jesus Himself said: "Many will come from east and west and recline at the table with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven" (Matthew 8:11). Abraham had multiple wives and concubines – yet he's in the Kingdom. So clearly, having multiple wives ≠ losing your salvation.

4. God didn't just "allow" polygamy – He regulated it.
In Exodus 21:10, God gave laws protecting the rights of a second wife. In Deuteronomy 21:15–17, He gave inheritance rules for sons of two wives. God never once calls polygamy sin in the Old Testament. He calls adultery and harlotry sin. If polygamy sent people to hell, He wouldn't have given civil laws for it – He would have outright banned it like He banned bestiality or incest.

5. We are NOT in Eden yet.
We live in a fallen world filled with weak men. Paul, under the Holy Spirit's inspiration, didn't say "one wife or burn in hell." He said: "To avoid fornication, let every man have his own wife" (1 Cor 7:2). If one wife isn't enough to keep a particular man off the streets, then giving him a second legal wife is a practical cure for a much greater sin (harlotry). It's harm reduction in a broken world – exactly like Moses allowed divorce for hard hearts.

6. Finally:
You said, "whoever finds it difficult to cope with the standard... will not live in Paradise." So does that mean divorced people are out? Or men who can't control their eyes? If we all had to hit the Eden standard perfectly, none of us are getting in – because we all fall short (Romans 3:23). That's why we need grace, not a marriage police.

My advice isn't "reinvent Eden." It's "stop the bleeding today by giving him a lawful outlet, so he doesn't commit a sin that is explicitly condemned – harlotry."

So tell me: Which is worse in God's eyes – a man with two lawful wives, or a man with one wife and ten side chicks? Hebrews 13:4 says marriage is honorable in all, but fornicators and adulterers God will judge. I'd rather him have two honorable marriages than one marriage plus eternal judgment. 🙂
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by MaxInDHouse(m): 6:09am On Jul 16
Janadozz:
So no, she's not committing adultery. She's committing wisdom. And if wisdom is a sin, then Solomon was the biggest sinner of all—which we both know isn't true. 😉
In past generations (God) permitted all the nations to go on in their ways. Act 14:16

There are lots and lots of blunders committed by imperfect humans in the past but since God has promised that the Christ is coming all servants of God keeps anticipating his arrival to know what we must do to QUALIFY for everlasting life:

I will raise up for them from the midst of their brothers a prophet like you, and I will put my words in his mouth, and he will speak to them all that I command him. Indeed, I will require an account from the man who will not listen to my words that he will speak in my name. Deuteronomy 18:18-19
Even after giving the Israelites laws God still told them that it's the Christ that will teach them the way of holiness. Isaiah Isaiah 35:8
That is why the Samaritan woman said to Jesus:

“I know that Mes·siʹah is coming, who is called Christ. Whenever that one comes, he will declare all things to us openly.” John 4:25

And instantly Jesus declared what he's been hiding from everyone to her:

“I am he, the one speaking to you.” John 4:26

So all those who have lived before John the baptist are lesser than John before God while John is lesser than followers of Christ. Matthew 11:11

WHY?

Because they all live by what they knew which doesn't qualify them for everlasting life! John 3:16🙂
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by MaxInDHouse(m): 6:20am On Jul 16
Janadozz:
BUT – Jesus was addressing divorce, not polygamy.
The written law covenant wasn't working that is why God promised to establish another which would be written in the hearts of faithful people. Jeremiah 31:31-33
If you won't tolerate rivalry in your marriage then don't bring in a rival for your spouse. Matthew 7:12

You must not take a woman in addition to her sister as a rival wife and have sexual relations with her while her sister is alive. Leviticus 18:18

So Jacob was WRONG but God allowed all that as the Christ has not come. Today all female Christians are sisters in Christ so let's apply Leviticus 18:18 and see how Christ will feel about Polygamy!

Janadozz:
Your "Paradise disqualification" logic has a fatal flaw.
If polygamy automatically disqualifies someone from God's Kingdom, then Abraham, Jacob, David, and Solomon are all burning in hell. But Jesus Himself said: "Many will come from east and west and recline at the table with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven" (Matthew 8:11). Abraham had multiple wives and concubines – yet he's in the Kingdom. So clearly, having multiple wives ≠ losing your salvation.
All those that lived before John the baptist are not qualified for everlasting life yet! Matthew 11:11
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Janadozz(op): 7:46am On Jul 16
MaxInDHouse:
The written law covenant wasn't working that is why God promised to establish another which would be written in the hearts of faithful people. Jeremiah 31:31-33
If you won't tolerate rivalry in your marriage then don't bring in a rival for your spouse. Matthew 7:12

You must not take a woman in addition to her sister as a rival wife and have sexual relations with her while her sister is alive. Leviticus 18:18

So Jacob was WRONG but God allowed all that as the Christ has not come. Today all female Christians are sisters in Christ so let's apply Leviticus 18:18 and see how Christ will feel about Polygamy!


All those that lived before John the baptist are not qualified for everlasting life yet! Matthew 11:11
Respect for digging deep into the text! 👏 But you just committed a classic exegetical foul—mixing spiritual metaphors with literal marriage laws. Let me walk you through it point by point:


1. On Jeremiah 31 & the "New Heart" Law

You're absolutely right—the old written law couldn't change hearts. The New Covenant writes God's law inwardly. But here's the catch: the New Covenant never explicitly bans polygamy. Instead, it gives us principles: "To avoid fornication, let every man have his own wife" (1 Cor 7:2). If one "own wife" isn't enough for a weak brother, the loving thing under the New Covenant is to help him stay within covenant rather than sin outside it. That's the heart-law—preferring mercy and restoration over rigid idealism in a broken world.


2. On Matthew 7:12 (The Golden Rule)

You said: "If you won't tolerate rivalry, don't bring one." Fair—if she's forced. But my entire premise is that she initiates willingly to save her marriage. She's not tolerating rivalry; she's choosing peace over pride. The Golden Rule works perfectly here: she'd want her husband to save her from humiliation too. So she does to him what she'd want done for her—protection, not punishment. No violation.


3. On Leviticus 18:18 & "Sisters in Christ"—This is your fatal error.

Let's read Leviticus 18:18 carefully: "You shall not take a woman as a rival to her sister, uncovering her unclothedness while her sister is alive."

· Context: This is in a chapter listing incestuous/kinship forbidden unions (mother, daughter, sister, aunt, etc.). The "sister" here refers to a biological sister—literally two daughters of the same parents.
· The Hebrew "ishah el achotah" means "one woman to her sister" – blood relation.
· Now your twist: You say "all female Christians are sisters in Christ" (spiritual). If we take that literally, then no Christian man could marry any Christian woman, because she's his "sister" in the Lord. Paul even calls Timothy his "son" (1 Tim 1:2)—does that mean Timothy can't marry anyone because all are siblings? That's absurd. Spiritual kinship ≠ biological/legal marital prohibition.

Also, if Leviticus 18:18 universally applied to all women, then God contradicted Himself—because He later gave David multiple wives (2 Sam 12:cool and called David "a man after My own heart" (Acts 13:22). He didn't call polygamy sin—He called adultery and murder sin.


4. On Jacob being "WRONG"

You said God allowed it because Christ hadn't come yet. But Jacob is in the Hall of Faith (Hebrews 11), and God changed his name to Israel—the father of the 12 tribes. God didn't just "allow" it; He blessed those marriages with the very lineage of the Messiah. If polygamy automatically disqualified him from God's plan, God wouldn't have chosen his bloodline. His sin was deception and favoritism, not the number of wives.


5. How would Christ feel about polygamy TODAY?

Let's ask Christ Himself: In Matthew 19, He addressed divorce, not polygamy. He points back to Eden as the ideal—but He also knows we aren't in Eden. The same Jesus who said "let the little children come to Me" also said "Go and sin no more" to the woman caught in adultery (John cool. He didn't stone her—He showed mercy.

Now ask: Which brings more mercy and less sin?

· A man with two lawful wives (covenant-kept, protected, provided for)?
· Or a man with one wife and 5 secret side chicks (adultery, lies, broken trust, possible STDs, and eternal judgment)?

Christ's heart is for purity. And lawful marriage—whether one or two—is pure (Hebrews 13:4). Adultery is not. My suggestion reduces adultery. Yours leaves men vulnerable to the streets with no lawful outlet.


Final verdict:
Your "sisters in Christ" interpretation is a spiritual metaphor stretched too far. If we apply it literally, Christian marriage becomes impossible. My argument isn't "polygamy is the ideal"—it's "polygamy is a practical cure for a worse sin, just like Moses allowed divorce for hard hearts."

So tell me—would you rather have your brother-in-Christ sinning in secret, or sinning less with a second lawful wife and a peaceful home? The New Covenant says "judge not, but restore gently" (Gal 6:1). I'm restoring with a solution. You're just pointing fingers. 😉
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by MaxInDHouse(m): 8:11am On Jul 16
Janadozz:
If one "own wife" isn't enough for a weak brother.
What if a sister's libido is too big for one man to satisfy her sexually can she also go for more husbands? Matthew 7:12
And if all Christians must marry only in the Lord {1Corinthans 7:39} how can you marry two Christians without obstructing Leviticus 18:18?🤔
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Dtruthspeaker: 9:11am On Jul 16
Janadozz:
Wait, let's pause right there. 😂

How does proposing a marriage equal committing adultery?

Adultery is sexual sin with someone who isn't your spouse (Exodus 20:14). The wife isn't sleeping with the new woman—her husband will. She's just the matchmaker, not the participant. Big difference...
Are you joking?
If someone proposes that you should go and rob a bank, is the person guilty or not?
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Janadozz(op): 10:33am On Jul 16
MaxInDHouse:
What if a sister's libido is too big for one man to satisfy her sexually can she also go for more husbands? Matthew 7:12
And if all Christians must marry only in the Lord {1Corinthans 7:39} how can you marry two Christians without obstructing Leviticus 18:18?🤔
Ah, I see you’re pulling out the big guns now! 😂 Fair play. But both of these are classic logical traps—let me dismantle them one by one.

On your first point: "What if a sister's libido is too big, can she get more husbands?"

Clever twist, but here’s why it doesn't fly:
1. The Bible explicitly forbids a woman from having multiple husbands.
Romans 7:2-3 says: "The married woman is bound by law to her husband while he lives... So if she joins another man while her husband is alive, she will be called an adulteress."
That’s a hard stop. No loopholes. A woman cannot have two living husbands—period. Meanwhile, the Old Testament never prohibits a man from having multiple wives; it regulates it (Exodus 21:10, Deuteronomy 21:15). That asymmetry is intentional.
2. Why the asymmetry? Because of headship and biology.
In God's order, the husband is the head (Ephesians 5:23). A man with multiple wives can still be the head of each household unit. But a woman with multiple husbands creates divided headship—who leads? Also, biologically/historically, paternity certainty was critical for inheritance laws in Israel. God's law accommodated that reality.
3. Matthew 7:12 (Golden Rule) doesn't override God's explicit commands.
The Golden Rule applies within the boundaries of God's moral law. You can't use it to justify something God outright forbids (like woman with two husbands). That's like saying, "If I want to steal, I'd want others to steal for me, so Matthew 7:12 allows it." Nope. The rule is relational kindness, not license to rewrite God's design.

So, sis can't get more husbands because God said no in the New Testament. Case closed.

On your second point: "How can you marry two Christians without obstructing Leviticus 18:18?"

You're recycling the "sisters in Christ" metaphor again, but let's nail this coffin shut for good:

1. Leviticus 18:18 is about BLOOD SISTERS, not spiritual sisters.
The Hebrew "ishah el achotah" literally means "woman to her sister"—biological siblings sharing parents. The entire chapter (Leviticus 18) deals with incestuous relationships: mother, daughter, sister, aunt, etc. It has zero to do with fellow church members. If "sisters in Christ" applied here, then NO Christian man could marry ANY Christian woman—because they're all "sisters." That would make Christian marriage impossible. Paul calls Timothy his "son" (1 Timothy 1:2)—does that mean Timothy can't marry anyone because all believers are his siblings? Absurd.
2. 1 Corinthians 7:39 says "only in the Lord"—which means believers only.
If a man marries two Christian women, he has perfectly obeyed 1 Corinthians 7:39—twice! 😂 They are both "in the Lord." There's no obstruction because they aren't biological sisters. He's not breaking Leviticus 18:18—he's fulfilling Paul's instruction to marry within the faith.
3. God Himself gave David multiple wives (2 Samuel 12:cool and called him a man after His own heart.
Were those wives "sisters in Christ"? No—they were fellow Israelites, literally sisters in the faith (Old Covenant). Yet God never condemned the multiplicity—He condemned Uriah's murder and Bathsheba's adultery. If God had a problem with polygamy per se, He would have said so plainly. He didn't.

So to answer you directly: Marry two believing women who are NOT biological sisters, and you've obeyed both Leviticus 18:18 (no blood incest) AND 1 Corinthians 7:39 (married in the Lord). No obstruction. Smooth sailing. 😉


Your arguments only work if we misread spiritual metaphors as literal law, and if we pretend God treats men and women identically in Scripture—which He clearly doesn't. Men can have multiple lawful wives; women cannot have multiple husbands. That's God's own distinction. 🙏😉
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Janadozz(op): 10:38am On Jul 16
Dtruthspeaker:
Are you joking?
If someone proposes that you should go and rob a bank, is the person guilty or not?
Nice try, but your logic has a giant hole the size of a bank vault. Let me explain:

1. Robbing a bank is EXPLICITLY a sin.
Exodus 20:15 – "You shall not steal." Period. No debate. Proposing robbery is proposing sin.

2. Proposing a second wife is NOT explicitly a sin.
You still haven't shown me one verse that says "Thou shalt not have two wives." Instead, God gave laws regulating it (Exodus 21:10, Deuteronomy 21:15-17). You don't make laws regulating something that's inherently sinful—you ban it outright. God didn't ban it. He regulated it. So proposing polygamy ≠ proposing a crime. It's proposing a lawful option.

3. Your analogy would only work if polygamy = theft.
But theft is universally condemned in Scripture. Polygamy is not. So your comparison is like saying: "If you propose I eat two apples, are you guilty of gluttony?" No—because eating apples isn't a sin. The quantity isn't the issue; the act is.

4. But let's flip your argument with your own logic:
If proposing a lawful act makes the proposer guilty, then Moses was guilty when he proposed divorce (Deuteronomy 24:1). Yet Jesus said Moses allowed it because of hard hearts (Matthew 19:cool—and Moses is in the Hall of Faith (Hebrews 11). So was Moses guilty of sin? No. He gave a concession to prevent worse evil.

Likewise, the wife proposing a co-wife isn't proposing sin—she's proposing a concession to stop her husband from committing actual, explicitly condemned sin: harlotry/adultery (Hebrews 13:4).

So to answer you directly:
Am I guilty? No—because what I'm proposing isn't a sin. It's a lawful, biblically regulated arrangement that has existed among God's people for centuries. If you want to call me guilty, you'll need a verse that actually says "Thou shalt not have two wives."

I'll wait. ⏳😉
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Dtruthspeaker: 11:21am On Jul 16
Janadozz:
Nice try, but your logic has a giant hole the size of a bank vault. Let me explain:

1. Robbing a bank is EXPLICITLY a sin.
Exodus 20:15 – "You shall not steal." Period. No debate. Proposing robbery is proposing sin.

2. Proposing a second wife is NOT explicitly a sin.
You still haven't shown me one verse that says "Thou shalt not have two wives." Instead, God gave laws regulating it (Exodus 21:10, Deuteronomy 21:15-17). You don't make laws regulating something that's inherently sinful—you ban it outright. God didn't ban it. He regulated it. So proposing polygamy ≠ proposing a crime. It's proposing a lawful option.

3. Your analogy would only work if polygamy = theft.
But theft is universally condemned in Scripture. Polygamy is not. So your comparison is like saying: "If you propose I eat two apples, are you guilty of gluttony?" No—because eating apples isn't a sin. The quantity isn't the issue; the act is.

4. But let's flip your argument with your own logic:
If proposing a lawful act makes the proposer guilty, then Moses was guilty when he proposed divorce (Deuteronomy 24:1). Yet Jesus said Moses allowed it because of hard hearts (Matthew 19:cool—and Moses is in the Hall of Faith (Hebrews 11). So was Moses guilty of sin? No. He gave a concession to prevent worse evil.

Likewise, the wife proposing a co-wife isn't proposing sin—she's proposing a concession to stop her husband from committing actual, explicitly condemned sin: harlotry/adultery (Hebrews 13:4).

So to answer you directly:
Am I guilty? No—because what I'm proposing isn't a sin. It's a lawful, biblically regulated arrangement that has existed among God's people for centuries. If you want to call me guilty, you'll need a verse that actually says "Thou shalt not have two wives."

I'll wait. ⏳😉
Is adultery not a sin?
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Janadozz(op): 11:37am On Jul 16
Dtruthspeaker:
Is adultery not a sin?
Is adultery not a sin?

Let me ask you something just as simple: Is water wet? 😂

Of course adultery is a sin! Hebrews 13:4 explicitly says: "Marriage is honorable in all, and the bed undefiled, but fornicators and adulterers God will judge." Clear. Unambiguous. No debate.

But here's where you're missing the point:

My entire argument is built on stopping adultery—not promoting it. Let me spell it out slowly:

Scenario A: A man has one wife but struggles with sexual temptation. He ends up sleeping with side chicks, prostitutes, or other women outside marriage. That = ADULTERY (a sin).

Scenario B: A man has two lawful wives. He sleeps with both within the bounds of marriage covenant. That = NOT ADULTERY (because they're his wives).

So which scenario has more sin? Scenario A. Which has less? Scenario B.

My proposal is a harm reduction strategy—like giving a thirsty man clean water instead of letting him drink from a dirty river. Both quench thirst, but one keeps him alive and healthy.

Now let's flip your question back at you:

If you know adultery is a sin, and you see a man struggling with it, what solution are YOU offering?

Are you just going to point fingers and say "stop sinning"? That's like telling a hungry man to "stop being hungry." It doesn't work. The Bible gives a practical solution: "To avoid fornication, let every man have his own wife" (1 Corinthians 7:2). If one wife isn't enough to keep him from sinning, then give him another lawful wife so he has no excuse to step outside.

That's not promoting adultery—that's preventing it.

So yes, adultery is a sin. And if you truly care about stopping it, you should support any lawful means that keeps a man from committing it. Including a second wife.

Or do you have a better solution? I'm all ears. 🎤😉
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Dtruthspeaker: 12:23pm On Jul 16
Janadozz:
Is adultery not a sin?

Let me ask you something just as simple: Is water wet? 😂

Of course adultery is a sin! Hebrews 13:4 explicitly says: "Marriage is honorable in all, and the bed undefiled, but fornicators and adulterers God will judge." Clear. Unambiguous. No debate.

But here's where you're missing the point:

My entire argument is built on stopping adultery—not promoting it. Let me spell it out slowly:

Scenario A: A man has one wife but struggles with sexual temptation. He ends up sleeping with side chicks, prostitutes, or other women outside marriage. That = ADULTERY (a sin).

Scenario B: A man has two lawful wives. He sleeps with both within the bounds of marriage covenant. That = NOT ADULTERY (because they're his wives).

So which scenario has more sin? Scenario A. Which has less? Scenario B.

My proposal is a harm reduction strategy—like giving a thirsty man clean water instead of letting him drink from a dirty river. Both quench thirst, but one keeps him alive and healthy.

Now let's flip your question back at you:

If you know adultery is a sin, and you see a man struggling with it, what solution are YOU offering?

Are you just going to point fingers and say "stop sinning"? That's like telling a hungry man to "stop being hungry." It doesn't work. The Bible gives a practical solution: "To avoid fornication, let every man have his own wife" (1 Corinthians 7:2). If one wife isn't enough to keep him from sinning, then give him another lawful wife so he has no excuse to step outside.

That's not promoting adultery—that's preventing it.

So yes, adultery is a sin. And if you truly care about stopping it, you should support any lawful means that keeps a man from committing it. Including a second wife.

Or do you have a better solution? I'm all ears. 🎤😉
So, thank God you admit and confess that adultery is a sin just like robbery

So, now that you agree that adultery is a sin, do you now confess that you are saying that a wife should commit the sin of adultery by telling her husband to go and commit adultery by him marrying the person he commits adultery with?
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Janadozz(op): 12:51pm On Jul 16
Dtruthspeaker:
So, thank God you admit and confess that adultery is a sin just like robbery

So, now that you agree that adultery is a sin, do you now confess that you are saying that a wife should commit the sin of adultery by telling her husband to go and commit adultery by him marrying the person he commits adultery with?
Nice try, but you just committed a logical fallacy—specifically, the false equivalence fallacy. Let me break it down so even a toddler could follow:

Your argument:

Adultery is a sin ✔️ (we agree)

Robbery is a sin ✔️ (we agree)

Therefore, proposing marriage = proposing adultery ❌ (WRONG!)

Here's why:

1. Adultery is defined as sexual relations with someone who is NOT your spouse.
If the man marries the woman first, she becomes his wife—legally and biblically. Sleeping with your own wife is NOT adultery. It's marital relations. The very definition of adultery requires the absence of marriage covenant.

2. So when does adultery happen?
If the man sleeps with her before marriage → that's fornication/adultery.
If he sleeps with her after marriage → that's lawful sex.
So the wife is telling her husband: "Marry her FIRST, so your relationship with her becomes lawful and sin-free." She's not telling him to commit adultery—she's telling him to avoid adultery by making it legal.

3. Your analogy fails because:

Robbery is always a sin—no context makes it lawful.

Sleeping with a woman becomes lawful once marriage is established.

So your comparison would only work if I said: "Tell your husband to go sleep with a woman and THEN marry her." But I didn't. I said: "Marry her FIRST, so sleeping with her isn't adultery."

4. You're confusing initiation with participation.
The wife initiates marriage, not sex. She's not in the bedroom. She's at the altar saying "I do" to sharing her husband legally. That's not adultery—that's sacrifice and wisdom.

5. Let's use your own logic against you:

Sarah gave Hagar to Abraham (Genesis 16:2).

Did Sarah commit adultery? No.

Did Abraham commit adultery with Hagar? No. She became his wife (Genesis 16:3).

Was God angry about this? No. He continued blessing Abraham and even named Isaac as the child of promise—through Sarah, not Hagar.

So if you want to call what I'm proposing adultery, then you're calling Sarah—a matriarch of faith—an adulteress and a madam. And I'm pretty sure you don't want to go there. 😉

Final answer:
A wife proposing a second marriage is NOT proposing adultery. She's proposing a lawful covenant that prevents adultery. If you can't see the difference, then you're not reading your Bible—you're just reading to argue.

Now, do you have a better solution to stop harlotry, or are you just here to throw stones?
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Dtruthspeaker:
Janadozz:
Nice try, but you just committed a logical fallacy—specifically, the false equivalence fallacy. Let me break it down so even a toddler could follow:

Your argument:

Adultery is a sin ✔️ (we agree)

Robbery is a sin ✔️ (we agree)

Therefore, proposing marriage = proposing adultery ❌ (WRONG!)

Here's why:

1. Adultery is defined as sexual relations with someone who is NOT your spouse.
If the man marries the woman first, she becomes his wife—legally and biblically. Sleeping with your own wife is NOT adultery.
Is the married man marrying going to a person he is not going to have sex with?
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Janadozz(op): 1:04pm On Jul 16
Dtruthspeaker:
Is the married marrying going to a person he is not going to have sex with?
Ah, now you're getting to the real question! 😏 Let me answer you plainly:

Yes, he will have sex with her. That's literally part of marriage (1 Corinthians 7:3-5).

But here's where your logic trips over itself:

1. The wife isn't telling him to commit adultery—she's telling him to legalize the relationship.
If he's going to have sex with someone outside marriage, that's adultery. If he marries her first, then sex with her becomes lawful and honorable (Hebrews 13:4). The wife is saying: "Instead of sinning in secret, do it right—make her your wife."

2. The sex isn't the sin—the context determines whether it's sin.
Sex within marriage = holy. Sex outside marriage = sin. The wife is changing the context from "sin" to "lawful." She's not promoting adultery—she's preventing it by making the relationship legitimate.

3. Let's apply your logic to Sarah and Hagar again:

Sarah gave Hagar to Abraham.

Abraham had sex with Hagar (Genesis 16:4).

Was that adultery? No. Because Hagar was now his wife (Genesis 16:3).

So Sarah wasn't promoting adultery—she was promoting legitimate marriage.

4. Your question actually strengthens my argument:
Since the man will have sex with her anyway (if he's tempted), wouldn't you rather he does it lawfully than sinfully? The wife who brings in a co-wife is being realistic and wise—she knows her husband's weaknesses and provides a lawful outlet instead of letting him fall into sin.

5. Now let me flip it back at you:
If you know a man is going to have sex with a woman anyway, would you rather:

Option A: He marries her first, making it lawful? ✅

Option B: He sleeps with her illegally, committing adultery? ❌

If you choose Option B, you're literally preferring sin over righteousness. That doesn't sound very Christian to me.

So yes, he'll have sex with her. After she becomes his wife. That's not adultery—that's marriage. And last I checked, God created marriage and called it good (Genesis 2:24).

So what's your real issue here—the sex or the number? Because if it's the sex, God's the one who designed it. If it's the number, show me where God says "Thou shalt only have one." I'll wait. ⏳😉
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Dtruthspeaker:
Janadozz:
Ah, now you're getting to the real question! 😏 Let me answer you plainly:

Yes, he will have sex with her. That's literally part of marriage (1 Corinthians 7:3-5).

But here's where your logic trips over itself:

1. The wife isn't telling him to commit adultery—she's telling him to legalize the relationship.
If he's going to have sex with someone outside marriage, that's adultery.
Good! you admit that he, married man is going to have sex with her, please what is the definition of adultery?
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by MaxInDHouse(m): 1:31pm On Jul 16
Janadozz:
Romans 7:2-3 says: "The married woman is bound by law to her husband while he lives... So if she joins another man while her husband is alive, she will be called an adulteress."
The same rule applies to men in God's congregation the reason why Paul said woman is because it's Polygamy that is prevalent but whatever they wrote is applicable to both men and women.

Back then if a man is polygamous the congregation will never appoint him as a leader {1Timothy 3:2, 12} so it boils down to the same point: no more Polygamy!

Before anyone becomes a Christian he might have had two or more wives but once he becomes a Christian Polygamy is tantamount to adultery for such a believer!
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Janadozz(op): 1:36pm On Jul 16
Dtruthspeaker:
Good! you admit that he, married man is going to have sex with he, please what is the definition of adultery?
Excellent question! Let's define it clearly so there's NO confusion:

Adultery = Sexual relations between a married person and someone who is NOT their spouse.

That's the biblical definition. Let's confirm it from Scripture:

Exodus 20:14 – "You shall not commit adultery." (Sex with someone else's spouse)

Leviticus 18:20 – "You shall not have sexual relations with your neighbor's wife." (Emphasis: neighbor's wife—someone else's property in covenant)

Proverbs 6:32 – "Whoever commits adultery with a woman lacks understanding; he who does so destroys his own soul." (The context is another man's wife)

Now apply that definition to my scenario:

A married man marries a second woman. She becomes HIS WIFE—legally, covenantally, and biblically.

So when he has sex with her, is he having sex with:

Someone else's spouse? NO.

His own spouse? YES.

Therefore, by the biblical definition, it is NOT adultery.

Now let's apply YOUR definition to your own argument:

If you're saying that a man having sex with his own wife (even if she's the second) is adultery, then you've redefined adultery to mean:
"Sex with any woman who isn't your first wife."

But where does the Bible say that?

Let's test YOUR definition:

If a man's first wife dies, and he remarries, does he commit adultery when he has sex with his second wife? NO. Because she became his wife after the first died.

What if a man's first wife divorces him, and he remarries? Jesus allowed for porneia (sexual immorality) as grounds for divorce (Matthew 19:9). But what if a man simply has two wives at the same time—both living? Is THAT adultery?

The key question:

Which of these is a wife?

The first woman? ✅

The second woman? ✅ (if lawfully married)

If BOTH are wives, then sex with either is marital, not adulterous.

Now let me ask you something:

If polygamy = adultery, then:

Abraham committed adultery with Hagar? NO—because she became his wife (Genesis 16:3).

Jacob committed adultery with Leah and Rachel? NO—because they were wives.

David committed adultery with Michal, Abigail, Bathsheba (after Uriah died)? NO—because they were wives at the time of sexual relations.

You'd have to call all these patriarchs adulterers. Yet God called them righteous.

So here's my question to YOU:

If you define adultery as "sex with any woman who isn't your first wife," then show me one verse where God says:
"Thou shalt not have sex with your second wife because she's not your first wife."

You can't. Because it doesn't exist.

My definition is biblical. Yours is cultural.

So who's really redefining adultery here?
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Janadozz(op): 1:40pm On Jul 16
MaxInDHouse:
The same rule applies to men in God's congregation the reason why Paul said woman is because it's Polygamy that is prevalent but whatever they wrote is applicable to both men and women.

Back then if a man is polygamous the congregation will never appoint him as a leader {1Timothy 3:2, 12} so it boils down to the same point: no more Polygamy!

Before anyone becomes a Christian he might have had two or more wives but once he becomes a Christian Polygamy is tantamount to adultery for such a believer!
I see you're pulling out the "leadership qualifications" card. Respect for going to Timothy. But let me stop you right there—you're making a classic error: confusing qualifications for OFFICE with requirements for SALVATION.

Let me break it down slowly:

1. 1 Timothy 3:2, 12 are about ELDERS/DEACONS, not all believers.

The text says: "A bishop/overseer must be... the husband of one wife."

That's a qualification for church leadership, not a universal command for every Christian man. If it applied to all believers, then:

All Christians must also be "temperate, sober-minded, hospitable, able to teach" (v.2).

All Christians must not be "given to wine" (v.3).

All Christians must have "ruling their children well" (v.4).

So if you're going to apply the "one wife" rule to everyone, then you must also apply all these other qualifications to everyone. That means every Christian man must be a teacher, must never drink alcohol, and must have well-behaved children. We both know that's not biblical—these are leadership standards, not universal commands.

2. Paul's instruction was contextual—polygamy was prevalent in that culture.

Paul was giving practical advice for church order. In a Greco-Roman world where polygamy was associated with paganism and Jewish leadership sometimes had multiple wives, Paul set a higher standard for leaders—just like he said elders shouldn't be "novices" (new converts) or "greedy for money." These are leadership filters, not salvation barriers.

3. Your claim that "polygamy is tantamount to adultery" is biblically indefensible.

Let's test that logic:

Abraham had multiple wives—yet God called him righteous (Genesis 15:6) and made a covenant with him.

Jacob had two wives (plus concubines)—yet God blessed him and renamed him Israel.

David had multiple wives—yet God called him "a man after My own heart" (Acts 13:22).

Solomon had 700 wives—his sin wasn't the number, but that they turned his heart away from God (1 Kings 11:3-4).

If polygamy = adultery, then God blessed adulterers and called them righteous. That would make God an accomplice to sin. So either God is holy, or your interpretation is wrong. I'll go with God being holy. 🙏

4. What about a man who had multiple wives BEFORE conversion?

You said: "Once he becomes a Christian, polygamy is tantamount to adultery."

Paul addressed this directly in 1 Corinthians 7:20: "Let every man abide in the calling wherein he was called." If a man had multiple wives when he came to Christ, Paul didn't command him to divorce them—because that would make him unfaithful to his vows and leave the women destitute. Instead, Paul said "let him remain" in his state. That's mercy, not condemnation.

Also, if polygamy = adultery, then Paul would have commanded polygamous converts to divorce their extra wives. He never did. Not once. In fact, the opposite—he told them to stay as they were.

5. Let's apply your logic consistently:

If "the husband of one wife" applies to all believers, then:

Every Christian man must be an elder/overseer.

Every Christian man must be a teacher.

Every Christian man must never drink wine.

Every Christian man must have well-behaved children.

That's reductio ad absurdum—it's ridiculous. You're taking a leadership qualification and twisting it into a universal sin prohibition. That's bad hermeneutics.

Final question for you:

If polygamy is adultery, then why did God give LAWS regulating it in the Old Testament (Exodus 21:10, Deuteronomy 21:15-17)? God doesn't regulate sin—He bans it. He regulated polygamy because it wasn't sin—it was less than ideal, but lawful.

So your argument that polygamy = adultery is not only biblically unsupported—it makes God look like He gave laws to regulate sin. And we both know that's not who God is.

So tell me: If polygamy is adultery, why didn't God just say "Thou shalt not have two wives"? He said it for theft, murder, adultery, coveting—why not polygamy? Because it wasn't a sin.

Now, do you have a verse that explicitly says "Thou shalt not have two wives"? Or are you just reading into the text what you want it to say?
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by MaxInDHouse(m): 1:46pm On Jul 16
Janadozz:
1 Timothy 3:2, 12 are about ELDERS/DEACONS, not all believers.
Of course they are setting the standard regarding closeness to salvation. The reason why Polygamy was permitted back then is because those people were practicing Judaism or other religions before then but no Christian is permitted to practice Polygamy afterwards.
In Paradise all those dead are no longer married because death has parted their marriage and each person will have to start all over again as One Adam and One Eve.
That is the standard for Paradise!🙂
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by MaxInDHouse(m):
Janadozz:
Now, do you have a verse that explicitly says "Thou shalt not have two wives"? Or are you just reading into the text what you want it to say?
Can you quote any verse that explicitly say "thou shalt not have two husbands?"🙂

Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Dtruthspeaker: 1:49pm On Jul 16
Janadozz:
Excellent question! Let's define it clearly so there's NO confusion:

Adultery = Sexual relations between a married person and someone who is NOT their spouse.
Good!
Is the person the married man wants to have sex with, his wife?
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Janadozz(op): 1:53pm On Jul 16
MaxInDHouse:
Of course they are setting the standard regarding closeness to salvation. The reason why Polygamy was permitted back then is because those people were practicing Judaism or other religions before then but no Christian is permitted to practice Polygamy afterwards.
In Paradise all those dead are no longer married because death has parted their marriage and each person will have to start all over again as One Adam and One Eve.
That is the standard for Paradise!🙂
Oh, now we're bringing Paradise into it! 😂 Let's go there. But be careful—you might not like what the Bible actually says about the resurrection.

1. You said: "Polygamy was permitted because they were practicing Judaism or other religions."

That's historically and biblically false. Abraham wasn't a Jew—he was the father of the faith (Romans 4:11-12). Jacob wasn't a Jew—he became Israel. David wasn't a Jew in the sense of "Judaism" as a formal religion—he was a man after God's own heart. These weren't pagans dabbling in polygamy. They were God's chosen people walking in covenant with Him. And He never condemned their multiple wives—He blessed them.

So you're basically saying God allowed His most faithful servants to live in sin for centuries, then suddenly changed His mind in the New Testament. That makes God inconsistent—which He is not (Malachi 3:6).

2. You said: "No Christian is permitted to practice Polygamy afterwards."

Show me the verse. Not a leadership qualification—show me a direct command to all believers: "Thou shalt not have more than one wife."

You can't. Because it doesn't exist. Paul said "to avoid fornication, let every man have his own wife" (1 Cor 7:2). He didn't put a limit on how many "own wives" a man can have. If you're going to add a limit, you're adding to Scripture—and that's dangerous territory (Proverbs 30:6).

3. You said: "In Paradise, they are no longer married—one Adam and one Eve is the standard."

Ah, you almost had me! 😄 But read the text carefully:

Jesus said in Matthew 22:30: "At the resurrection people will neither marry nor be given in marriage; they will be like the angels in heaven."

Notice: There is NO marriage at all in Paradise. Not one wife, not two wives—zero wives.

So your argument that the "standard" is "one Adam and one Eve" actually undermines your own point. If the ultimate standard is NO marriage, then why are you insisting on monogamy now? Should all Christians be celibate to match Paradise? Paul actually said celibacy is better (1 Cor 7:cool, but he allowed marriage because of temptation.

So if you're going to use Paradise as the standard, then you should be advocating for celibacy, not monogamy. But you're not. You're just cherry-picking the "one man, one woman" part and ignoring the "no marriage" part.

4. Let me flip your logic:

If we must conform to the "Eden standard" to enter Paradise, then:

No one can eat meat? (Genesis 1:29 says plants only)

No one can wear clothes? (They were naked)

No one can have children? (They didn't have kids until after the Fall)

You see the absurdity? We don't live in Eden now. We live in a fallen world with concessions—just like divorce, just like slavery, just like polygamy. God permits certain things because of hard hearts (Matthew 19:cool, but He doesn't call them sin.

5. And here's the final nail:

If polygamy disqualifies you from Paradise, then Abraham, Jacob, David, and Solomon are all out. But Jesus Himself said:
"Many will come from east and west and recline at the table with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven" (Matthew 8:11).

So Abraham—with multiple wives—will be in the Kingdom. That settles it. Polygamy ≠ salvation barrier.

So to answer you directly:

Paradise has no marriage. So the "standard" isn't monogamy—it's singleness. Since we aren't in Paradise yet, we live in a fallen world where God provides lawful outlets for human weakness. Polygamy is one of them. It's not the ideal, but it's not a sin—and it certainly doesn't keep anyone from Paradise.

So your entire argument collapses.😉🙏
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Janadozz(op): 1:59pm On Jul 16
MaxInDHouse:
Can you quote any verse that explicitly say "thou shalt not have two husbands?"🙂
Oh, you're GOOD! 😂 You saw my challenge and flipped it. I respect the hustle. But here's why your question actually backfires on you.

1. Yes, I CAN quote verses that explicitly say "thou shalt not have two husbands."

Let me give you not one, but MULTIPLE:

Romans 7:2-3 – "For a married woman is bound by law to her husband while he lives, but if her husband dies she is released from the law of marriage. Accordingly, she will be called an adulteress if she lives with another man while her husband is alive."

1 Corinthians 7:39 – "A wife is bound to her husband as long as he lives. If her husband dies, she is free to be married to whom she wishes, only in the Lord."

1 Timothy 3:12 – "Let deacons be the husbands of one wife..." (This applies to women too—they're not leaders if they have multiple husbands).

2. But here's where your question backfires:

You asked for a verse that says "thou shalt not have two husbands."

Guess what? There is NO verse that says "thou shalt not have two wives" either!

So if you're going to demand an explicit "thou shalt not" for polygamy, you're admitting that there is no explicit prohibition—which means it's not a sin.

Because if it were a sin, God would have said so plainly—just like He did for:

Adultery: "Thou shalt not commit adultery" (Exodus 20:14)

Murder: "Thou shalt not kill" (Exodus 20:13)

Theft: "Thou shalt not steal" (Exodus 20:15)

Coveting: "Thou shalt not covet" (Exodus 20:17)

God had NO problem saying "thou shalt not" when He meant it. He said it for adultery, murder, theft, coveting, and many others. But never once did He say "Thou shalt not have two wives."

3. Now let's compare:

Sin Explicit "Thou shalt not"
Adultery ✅ Yes (Exodus 20:14)
Murder ✅ Yes (Exodus 20:13)
Theft ✅ Yes (Exodus 20:15)
Polygamy (men) ❌ NO verse
Polyandry (women) ✅ Yes (Romans 7:2-3)
See the pattern? God explicitly prohibited polyandry (women having multiple husbands). But He never prohibited polygyny (men having multiple wives). That's not an accident—that's intentional.

4. Let me flip it back:

You asked: "Can you quote a verse that explicitly says 'thou shalt not have two husbands'?"

Answer: Yes. Romans 7:2-3 does exactly that.

Now I ask you: Can you quote a verse that explicitly says "thou shalt not have two wives"?

Answer: No. Because it doesn't exist.

5. Your argument just collapsed on itself.

You're trying to argue that polygamy is a sin—but you have zero explicit biblical prohibition. Meanwhile, polyandry is explicitly prohibited. That means God made a clear distinction between men and women on this issue.

If you want to say polygamy is sin, you need a "thou shalt not"—and you don't have one.

If you want to say it's not sin, you have the silence of Scripture and the regulated permission of the Old Testament.

Final question for you:

If polygamy is a sin, why didn't God just say "Thou shalt not have two wives" like He said for adultery, murder, and theft?

The silence is deafening. 😉

Now, do you have a real argument, or are we done here? 🎤
Re: Is It Better To Be A Harlot Or A Sister-wife? A Call To Biblical Generosity by Janadozz(op): 2:00pm On Jul 16
Dtruthspeaker:
Good!
Is the person the married man wants to have sex with, his wife?
Do you mean before marrying the person or after the marriage?
1 2 Reply

Samples From 'Noah’s Ark' Site Reveal Human Activity Dating Back To Biblical Era • Prophet Odumeje Buys His Wife A New Car (Video) • Nigerian Pastors And Prophets Compare To Biblical Prophets • 2 • 3 • 4

Where He Is Now, We Hope To Follow • The Family Of A Disciple • The Gardens Of The Lord