₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,345,946 members, 8,520,319 topics. Date: Tuesday, 17 November 2026 at 04:35 PM

Toggle theme

Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions - Politics (2) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions (6556 Views)

1 2 3 Reply (Go Down)

Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by ViceGovernor: 9:50am On Jul 24
They gave them TV while the remote control is in Abuja.

Operate am make I see na.
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by ViceGovernor: 9:52am On Jul 24
Exactly 💯 percent.

These people are funny 🤣.
runsapp:
Total rubbish. Then just leave it. That’s federal police not state lol
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Openyamind111(m): 9:57am On Jul 24
It’s a welcome development but for as long as the state will be financing them they will easily be bought but then it’s a very good development
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by honor4me: 10:00am On Jul 24
ProudBoy:
Bill removes President, Governors from National Police Council
Sets conditions for Federal Intervention
Legislation retains Federal Police until States are ready
Preserves officers, institutions, bars automatic conversion of vigilante groups




https://guardian.ng/news/state-police-bill-bars-governors-from-controlling-police-commissions-introduces-direct-funding/
Fundamental Lacunae & Challenges (Compared to Existing Nigerian System)
1. The Fiscal Sustainability Paradox
• The Gap: The bill provides for direct allocation to state police services under Section 121. However, it does not specify minimum funding thresholds or formulaic allocations relative to a state’s overall revenue.
• Impact: High-revenue states (e.g., Lagos, Rivers) will easily fund heavily equipped police services, whereas fiscally challenged states may starve their police departments despite "direct payment" guarantees. This risks creating vast geographical disparities in security capabilities across Nigeria.
2. Composition & Political Dynamics of the Reconstituted National Police Council (NPC)
• The Gap: The bill removes the President and 36 Governors from the NPC, replacing them with state Attorneys-General, retired officers, and civil society members.
• Impact: While intended to insulate the police from partisan politics, removing elected chief executives creates an accountability vacuum. In democratic governance, elected executives are politically accountable for national security. Stripping them of direct council membership while leaving them responsible for public safety could lead to friction between political leadership and non-elected operational heads.
3. Operational Standards vs. State Bureaucracy
• The Gap: The bill empowers the National Assembly to set "national minimum standards" for recruitment, equipment, and training, but state police commissions retain control over hiring and promotion procedures within their borders.
• Impact: Without a unified enforcement body to audit state adherence to minimum standards daily, state political elites could bypass these minimum qualifications through localized patronage hiring—effectively turning local forces into state-funded private militias despite formal constitutional bars.
4. Transition Period Risks & "Vigilante Integration" Friction
• The Gap: The bill expressly prohibits existing vigilante groups (e.g., Amotekun, Ebube Agu, local hunter associations) from automatically absorbing into State Police forces.
• Impact: While this prevents undisciplined militia integration, it risks creating a security void during the transition. Current state security outfits are deeply entrenched locally; sidelining them without a clear legal pathway for qualified individual re-screening and recruitment could trigger institutional resistance or push armed vigilantes into illegal activities.
5. Jurisdictional Conflicts and "Fresh Pursuit" Gray Areas
• The Gap: Clause 16 restricts state police operations exclusively within their home state, except during "fresh pursuit" or under reciprocal policing agreements.
• Impact: Interstate criminal syndicates (such as kidnapping rings crossing state lines) can exploit procedural bottlenecks. If state police forces lack interoperable real-time intelligence networks or pre-signed cross-border protocols, armed criminals could easily escape jurisdiction while federal intervention processes drag through constitutional notifications.
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Esc2ctrl: 10:16am On Jul 24
FG WILL REMOVE STATE POLICE FUNDS BEFORE CREDITING THE STATE THEIR MONTHLY ALLOCATION

vacanci:
he who pays the piper must dictate the tune.

so the question is, "WHO WILL PAY THE STATE POLICE?"
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Rilwayne001: 10:43am On Jul 24
Eba50:
governors are waiting to recruit their thugz and killers into full time professional and official pawns
You guys don't know what you want.

Thought everyone was shouting state police
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Eba50: 11:01am On Jul 24
Rilwayne001:
You guys don't know what you want.

Thought everyone was shouting state police
minus me sir. i have always talked about straightening the npf in recruitment and finance local community security, and neighbourhood
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by TheOldGods: 11:34am On Jul 24
kiltoko1:
Who is going to funds the state police?so if as a governor I fund you and you will not obey me... story
they can make a law that the states funds the police by default and there is nothing you can do about ir asa governor
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Ttipsy(f): 11:47am On Jul 24
State police in disguise
lol
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Neoteny(m): 12:06pm On Jul 24
kiltoko1:
Who is going to funds the state police?so if as a governor I fund you and you will not obey me... story
Recipe for anarchy.

The governor is funded by the federal administration. He too should do what the Feds tell him.
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by bentenny(m): 12:22pm On Jul 24
There are two things required to make the federal and state policing structure effective.
The first is uninterrupted access to financial resources and total independence.

If for any reason,the appointment of the state commissioner of police or other recruitments are done under the control of political office holders,nothing will happen and arnachy will be inevitable.

True independence is when our institutions esp enforcement is free from the control of political office holders.


Lastly,when will the public finally have access to the state policing bill before it's passed?
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by commoditiesnig(m): 12:46pm On Jul 24
Welcome development.. to mitigate excessive Governors powers
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by seunayantokun(m): 12:49pm On Jul 24
Federal police to fight terrorism, cybercrimes etc while State police is to protect lives and properties. The knot must be untied. If state police can't fight terrorism which is one of the reasons for demanding it, how do they protect lives and properties? Things have to be well defined. The president should do the needful so that we don't end up having a boy scouts group rather than a real police department.
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by frog12: 1:03pm On Jul 24
The President is required to authorise any intervention in writing, stating its grounds, duration and territorial scope, while notifying the Governor, Speaker of the State House of Assembly, National Police Council and National Assembly within 48 hours.
like how dem remove Fubara from rivers ? shocked shocked
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Parachoko: 1:09pm On Jul 24
Esc2ctrl:
FG WILL REMOVE STATE POLICE FUNDS BEFORE CREDITING THE STATE THEIR MONTHLY ALLOCATION
A lot of people who commented on the first page didn't read the article
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by frog12: 1:11pm On Jul 24
e be like still federal police grin grin grin
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Parachoko: 1:12pm On Jul 24
seunayantokun:
Federal police to fight terrorism, cybercrimes etc while State police is to protect lives and properties. The knot must be untied. If state police can't fight terrorism which is one of the reasons for demanding it, how do they protect lives and properties? Things have to be well defined. The president should do the needful so that we don't end up having a boy scouts group rather than a real police department.
Oga, state police can also fight terrorists operating within thier states
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Parachoko: 1:13pm On Jul 24
frog12:
e be like still federal police grin grin grin
How e still b like Federal Police?
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by seunayantokun(m): 2:19pm On Jul 24
Parachoko:
Oga, state police can also fight terrorists operating within thier states
We just can't assume things and place ourselves at the mercy of a wicked ruler tomorrow. What we can do now before the bill becomes a law is to ensure the jurisdictions of responsibilities of state police vs federal police are clearly defined now.
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Zoftels: 3:23pm On Jul 24
Good job, state reps, you have allay our fear of Fulani president (God forbid that again) in future by using federal might to install fulanis as state commissioner of police in all states.
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by MIKOLOWISKA: 4:35pm On Jul 24
We have 36/774
Stop making excuses regions
Basicend:
I apllaud the careful restraints that are being applied to the bill.

However, if they will not allow the governors to have an influence over the CP, then it is definitely not a state police.

Yes, our governors are not yet there. We all know most will misuse the power. But, the recent proposal of State policing is one of the reasons why the Fulani herdsmen and bandits have calmed down a little.

We must move towards regionalization. That's the only way the brain of the sponsors of terror from the North will reset.

If they want us to be together, they shld behave, otherwise we regionalize.
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by kiltoko1(m): 8:30pm On Jul 24
Let wait and see
Neoteny:
Recipe for anarchy.

The governor is funded by the federal administration. He too should do what the Feds tell him.
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Justnation: 9:11pm On Jul 24
Each state should be allowed to fund and control their state police.
If the federal government is funding and indirectly controlling the state police then it can no longer be called state police.
Allowing the federal government to fund the state police will make states to recruit massive officers and pile the bill of the federal revenue.
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Kukutente23: 7:41am On Jul 25
Dogalmighty17:
Abeg brain dey pain me. Who get summary of that long thing wey dem write up there?
But brain no pain you when you wan type o
You see how you are now? One way traffic
Everywhere cho cho cho but to read na wahala
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by lawani(m): 8:06am On Jul 25
Justnation:
Each state should be allowed to fund and control their state police.
If the federal government is funding and indirectly controlling the state police then it can no longer be called state police.
Allowing the federal government to fund the state police will make states to recruit massive officers and pile the bill of the federal revenue.
All those are irrelevancies. Is the FG doing the appropriation? Are they appointing the leadership? Are they making the recruitment? Can they stop the state from approving more money? Etc etc
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Kukutente23: 8:43am On Jul 25
Parachoko:
Oga, state police can also fight terrorists operating within thier states
Who has responsibility for terrorism based on the constitution amendment in view
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Parachoko: 9:36am On Jul 25
Kukutente23:
Who has responsibility for terrorism based on the constitution amendment in view
State Police can tackle all issues within their jurisdiction.
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by pharmagba:
I completely disagree with the first point.
I think our reps are being too myopic and all seems to be sleeping and facing the same side
I will rather recommed at least at least at the federal level the president should have some influence in the police comission.
We cant leave the police not under some measure of poltical control at the federal we cant have a situation where powerful opposition, ememy of state or even foreign interest hijack our police.
Like what we have today in journalism ehere the opposition has taken over all reasonable repportage and misinformation and partisanship been peddled
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Kukutente23: 11:24am On Jul 25
Parachoko:
State Police can tackle all issues within their jurisdiction.
That's not true
Go and get yourself educated on the bills passed
State police cannot tackle cybercrime
That's what the new bill is about
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Parachoko: 12:29pm On Jul 25
Kukutente23:
That's not true
Go and get yourself educated on the bills passed
State police cannot tackle cybercrime
That's what the new bill is about
It's all about common sense bro
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Kukutente23: 1:11pm On Jul 25
Parachoko:
It's all about common sense bro
Your common sense is not what the police uses to operate
Police operate with the law not your common sense
Re: Reps State Police Bill Bars Governors From Controlling Police Commissions by Parachoko: 1:13pm On Jul 25
Kukutente23:
Your common sense is not what the police uses to operate
Police operate with the law not your common sense
Alright
1 2 3 Reply

Bill Bars Voters From Contesting Candidates’ Certificates In Court • Dapo Apara: Stop Tinubu From Controlling Alpha Beta - Ex-MD Begs Court • Coronavirus: FG Blocks Five Governors From Flying Out Of Nigeria • 2 • 3 • 4

Reno Omokri’s ₦3,000 Claim Detached From Reality — Onoh • GEJ Vows To End Theft Of Crude Oil • We ‘re Cause Of Our Problems In The North – Sultan