₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,313 members, 8,522,338 topics. Date: Saturday, 21 November 2026 at 02:18 AM

Toggle theme

Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! - Christianity Etc (4) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! (2376 Views)

1 2 3 4 5 6 Reply (Go Down)

Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Nobody: 1:55pm On Jul 25
MaxInDHouse:
Don't waste your time with the guy he's obsessed with topics that is against the faith in Christ so he can lie boldly and even bury his conscience as long as he is arguing against anything that has to do with Christ or the Christian faith.

That is why i ignored him even though he's desperately seeking my attention!🙂
Your organisation did not agree with the existing views of earlier organisations that followed Jesus Christ, so it decided to form its own. But you now want to be the one to have the final say on Jesus Christ. Does that not make you a hypocrite and the one who buries your conscience when you meet others with the wisdom God gave Solomon?
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by MaxInDHouse(m): 2:03pm On Jul 25
AntiChristian:
You should mention one that claims they are not the true Christian organisation!
You can see that you love deceiving yourself now?

Is there not a difference between we are Christians and we are the only true Christian organization?

This is not Islam where you can't point to the only true Muslim group all of you are confused as long as members of a group are all bowing towards the black stone in Mecca they are Muslims!🙂
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by AntiChristian(op): 2:15pm On Jul 25
MaxInDHouse:
You can see that you love deceiving yourself now?

Is there not a difference between we are Christians and we are the only true Christian organization?

This is not Islam where you can't point to the only true Muslim group all of you are confused as long as members of a group are all bowing towards the black stone in Mecca they are Muslims!🙂
Islam is not by generally ascription! It is what you live by!

JW is a cult from Taze!
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by TenQ: 2:58pm On Jul 25
AntiChristian:
I don't use bead too. Using bead is not a pillar of Islam. Beads are used for counting and i do count with my fingers. Hence, it's not necessary!

Beads are not traceable to the Prophet of Islam. So all these are just rants!
Your prayer beads are used by Sunni Muslims, if you choose not to be part of it is not consequential. Did your prophet tell you to use kettle for praying? No!
Own up, Muslims use the prayer bead as their cousin Buhdishists!


AntiChristian:
Yeah, they read the Qur'an too.
Because Muslims are Buddhists too. Birds of the same feathers sharing the same father.


AntiChristian:
It's none of my business o. My business is that your God needs blood to forgive sins. But blood no dey inside coal to forgive Isaiah's sin.

Then one of the seraphim flew to me, and in his hand was a glowing coal that he had taken with tongs from the altar. And with it he touched my mouth and said: “Now that this has touched your lips, your iniquity is removed and your sin is atoned for.”

The atonement of Isaiah's sin was as a result of his lips touching that coal.

Any other thing na lie from hell!
Unfortunately, peddling deliberate or willful IGNORANCE doesn't help your case at all. Islam doesn't even have the foggiest understanding of why sacrifice was instituted for man.

Can you kindly explain why Allah need blood from the two sons of Adam Qur'an 5:27 . Can you explain why Abraham was ordered to sacrifice his son for Allah Qur'an 37:102–107 .

They said: "You got no answer except to bleat about like Ileya sacrifice!"

If your Allah do not need blood to forgive, why does he use INNOCENT Christians and Jews as RANSOM for your Muslims? Riyad as-Salihin 432
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Kobojunkie: 3:17pm On Jul 25
AntiChristian:
Islam is not by generally ascription! It is what you live by! ...
Oh, Islam definitely began as a cult, but has through violent colonization and imposition ballooned into what it is today. (The size being the only reason it no longer can be classified as a cult.)This 7th-century-esque political system threatens everything outside of it.😒😒
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by MaxInDHouse(m): 3:17pm On Jul 25
AntiChristian:
Islam is what you live by!
So as long as anyone bow to the black stone in Mecca they are living by your religion shey?😟

And a cult is doing fine in all countries throughout the world as we turn them to friends of their neighbors!Matthew 10:24-25 🙂
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Nobody: 8:18pm On Jul 25
Kobojunkie:
Oh, Islam definitely began as a cult, but has through violent colonization and imposition ballooned into what it is today. (The size being the only reason it no longer can be classified as a cult.)This 7th-century-esque political system threatens everything outside of it.😒😒
Every religion is a cult, someone that wants to worship the true God of the Original Torah, needs the true wisdom of God of the Original Torah so that they are not controlled by all these cults called religion.
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Kobojunkie: 8:23pm On Jul 25
MindHacker9009:
➜Every religion is a cult, someone that wants to worship the true God of the Original Torah, needs the true wisdom of God of the Original Torah so that they are not controlled by all these cults called religion.
Not every religion, no matter how much you loathe and hate them and would maybe like to see it replaced with yours, would qualify as such given the current definitions out there. 😒😒
A cult is a group or movement centered on a shared devotion to a person, idea, or ritual. The word usually describes groups with extreme, controlling, or dangerous practices, but it can also mean deep admiration for a pop-culture item or a specific religious tradition.
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Nobody: 8:30pm On Jul 25
Kobojunkie:
Not every religion, no matter how much you loathe and hate them and would maybe like to see it replaced with yours, would qualify as such given the current definitions out there. 😒😒
You're assuming I "loathe" or "hate" religion, which isn't what I said. I'm making a distinction between seeking God directly and following religious institutions. My point is that organised religions often require adherence to doctrines, traditions and authorities that end up controlling people rather than encouraging them to seek truth for themselves with wisdom.

As for definitions, the label "cult" is often subjective. Many characteristics associated with cults, such as exclusive claims to truth, unquestioning obedience to authority and discouraging independent thought, can be found in varying degrees within established religions. My argument is about those characteristics, not simply the popularity or age of a religion.
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Kobojunkie: 8:38pm On Jul 25
MindHacker9009:
➜ ... As for definitions, the label "cult" is often subjective. Many characteristics associated with cults, such as exclusive claims to truth, unquestioning obedience to authority and discouraging independent thought, can be found in varying degrees within established religions. My argument is about those characteristics, not simply the popularity or age of a religion.
End of discussion then! 😒😒
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Nobody: 9:07pm On Jul 25
Kobojunkie:
End of discussion then! 😒😒
The subjectivity is in your definition of the word "cult," not in whether religious organisations can exhibit cult-like characteristics.

Even the definition you quoted says a cult is "a group or movement centered on a shared devotion to a person, idea, or ritual," and that it usually describes groups with "extreme, controlling, or dangerous practices." The word "usually" doesn't mean those characteristics don't exist; it means the term is applied differently by different people.

So whether you personally choose to call a particular religious organisation a "cult" is subjective, but that doesn't mean religious organisations cannot objectively display cult-like behaviours such as control, exclusivity or unquestioning obedience.

Kobojunkie:
Not every religion, no matter how much you loathe and hate them and would maybe like to see it replaced with yours, would qualify as such given the current definitions out there. 😒😒
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Kobojunkie: 9:22pm On Jul 25
MindHacker9009:
➜The subjectivity is in your definition of the word "cult," not in whether religious organisations can exhibit cult-like characteristics.
Even the definition you quoted says a cult is "a group or movement centered on a shared devotion to a person, idea, or ritual," and that it usually describes groups with "extreme, controlling, or dangerous practices." The word "usually" doesn't mean those characteristics don't exist; it means the term is applied differently by different people.
So whether you personally choose to call a particular religious organisation a "cult" is subjective, but that doesn't mean religious organisations cannot objectively display cult-like behaviours such as control, exclusivity or unquestioning obedience.
Not all religious groups out there display even these cult-like behaviours in bold. Hence, not every religion would qualify. 😒😒
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Nobody: 9:38pm On Jul 25
Kobojunkie:
Not all religious groups out there display even these cult-like behaviours in bold. Hence, not every religion would qualify. 😒😒
Every religious organisation is a cult in the sense that its followers are required to accept and believe teachings, doctrines, traditions, and interpretations passed down by that organisation, often without evidence to verify those claims.

Examples include beliefs such as the virgin birth, the resurrection, the ascension and the second coming, which are matters of just believe rather than events that can be independently verified.

No religious organisation is going to say, "we were not there when these events happened", because that would undermine the authority of their belief system itself. That is why people should use the wisdom God gave them and examine history and original sources for themselves rather than simply accepting what they have been made to believe.

The point is whether people are seeking truth through understanding and wisdom but simply believing in what they have been instructed to believe.
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Kobojunkie: 9:40pm On Jul 25
MindHacker9009:
➜Every religious organisation is a cult in the sense that its followers are required to accept and believe teachings, doctrines, traditions, and interpretations passed down by that organisation, often without evidence to verify those claims...
Again, you keep missing the point... if worship is the base criterion we are to contend with, then not every religious group would qualify as a cult since not all religious groups require worship. 😒😒
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Nobody: 9:44pm On Jul 25
Kobojunkie:
Again, you keep missing the point... if worship is the base criterion we are to contend with, then not every religious group would qualify as a cult since not all religious groups require worship. 😒😒
Then name the religious groups that you believe do not qualify and explain why. We can then examine them individually and look at their beliefs, teachings, authority structures and practices.

The point is not simply whether the word "worship" appears in their description; the point is whether followers are required to accept a set of teachings, doctrines, traditions, or interpretations from an authority without independently verifiable evidence.

So rather than making a general claim that some do not qualify, provide examples and let us scrutinise them based on their actual beliefs and practices.
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Kobojunkie: 10:01pm On Jul 25
MindHacker9009:
➜Then name the religious groups that you believe do not qualify and explain why. We can then examine them individually and look at their beliefs, teachings, authority structures and practices.
➜ The point is not simply whether the word "worship" appears in their description; the point is whether followers are required to accept a set of teachings, doctrines, traditions, or interpretations from an authority without independently verifiable evidence.
So rather than making a general claim that some do not qualify, provide examples and let us scrutinise them based on their actual beliefs and practices.
Buddhism, Taoism, and Confucianism are just a handful of old-timey religions that do not require worship. 😒

2. I have explained over and over that shifting the goalpost never wins you a debate. Even if we are going to stick to the so-called behaviors you chose to associate with cults..
MindHacker9009:
➜....So whether you personally choose to call a particular religious organisation a "cult" is subjective, but that doesn't mean religious organisations cannot objectively display cult-like behaviours such as control, exclusivity or unquestioning obedience.
...there are today over 10,000 different religions and subsets of religions that do not exhibit any of the characteristics described of cults. I already started you off with just three up there. You can use Google to learn even more. 😒😒


Within the religion of Christianity, there are numerous denominations; out of the over 46,000 different denominations under the religion that exist almost in obscurity, not because those who hold to the particular belief do not practice their faith in their closet, but because there are no overarching powers to exert control over those who subscribe to the belief structure, and no exclusivity or unquestioning obedience to anybody. 😒😒

So, again, not every religious group out there is a cult, or can be described as one by even the definitions that you have put forth. 😒
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Nobody: 10:24pm On Jul 25
Kobojunkie:
Buddhism, Taoism, and Confucianism are just a handful of old-timey religions that do not require worship. 😒

2. I have explained over and over that shifting the goalpost never wins you a debate. Even if we are going to stick to the so-called behaviors you chose to associate with cults.. ...there are today over 10,000 different religions and subsets of religions that do not exhibit any of the characteristics described of cults. I already started you off with just three up there. You can use Google to learn even more. 😒😒


Within the religion of Christianity, there are numerous denominations; out of the over 46,000 different denominations under the religion that exist almost in obscurity, not because those who hold to the particular belief do not practice their faith in their closet, but because there are no overarching powers to exert control over those who subscribe to the belief structure, and no exclusivity or unquestioning obedience to anybody. 😒😒

So, again, not every religious group out there is a cult, or can be described as one by even the definitions that you have put forth. 😒
The point is not just about worship, it has always been about whether a religious organisation have a belief system that requires people to accept teachings, traditions and interpretations handed down without been independently verified.

As for Buddhism, Taoism and Confucianism, they still involve established teachings, traditions, texts, schools of thought and interpretations that followers are expected to learn and accept. The fact that some traditions do not centre on a creator God or use the same form of worship as others does not automatically place them outside of a cult.

If your argument is that they are not cults because they do not fit one specific definition, then your disagreement is about the definition and the standard being applied, not about moving the goalposts.
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Kukutente23: 1:34am On Jul 26
MindHacker9009:
On Deuteronomy 18:18–19, does Jesus fit what this verse describes?
Deuteronomy 18:18–19 talks about a future prophet who will say only what God tells him to say, nothing more, nothing different. The whole point of this verse is that the prophet stays true to what God already gave through Moses. Deuteronomy 4:2 backs this up directly: it says not to add anything to the law, and not to take anything away.

So if Jesus is supposed to be that prophet, his teaching should match what Moses taught, not change it. But look at what the text actually shows:
In Matthew 5:21–48, Jesus keeps saying "you have heard it said... but I say to you," and each time he changes the rule, on oaths, on revenge, on divorce.
In Mark 7:19, Jesus says all foods are now clean. That goes directly against the food laws in Leviticus 11.
In John 13:34, Jesus gives what he himself calls a "new commandment."
In Mark 2:27–28, Jesus claims authority over the Sabbath that goes against the commandment God gave through Moses.

These aren't just new explanations of the old law, they're actual changes to it. Deuteronomy 4:2 says you can't do that. And Deuteronomy 18:19 only tests whether a prophet repeats God's message faithfully, it doesn't give anyone permission to change the message. So the claim "Jesus didn't give any commandments different from Moses" doesn't match what the text says.

On Mary's ancestry:
Matthew's and Luke's genealogies of Jesus disagree on the names between David and Joseph, and the fix (one is Mary's line) isn't stated in either Gospel, it's a later patch.
Elizabeth is identified in Luke 1:5 as "of the daughters of Aaron", Levite priestly line, not the tribe of Judah where David's line runs, so kinship with her points toward Levi, not David.
Since tribal descent in this period was reckoned patrilineally and Levi and Judah are distinct tribes, being Elizabeth's cousin cannot by itself establish that Mary descended from David.
Taken together: the case for Mary's precise ancestry is contested on both sides, not settled fact.
If you read Luke 3 from the start dispassionately you'll come across this phrase "as was supposed" when the account of the genealogy of Jesus began and it came before Joseph's name was put there. Not only that, Luke focused solely on Mary from chapter 1 and did not report the part of Joseph's proposed break up and eventual adoption of baby Jesus through divine guidance.

Note also that Matthew's genealogy mentioned 3 women while Luke left out all the women. The summation of these glaring differences is that Luke sought to establish Jesus genealogy strictly through the paternal line albeit in a strictly biological sense. It was for this reason that Mary's name was left out and Joseph was used instead. Note that he was writing to a Roman and knew the importance of legitimacy. Matthew was more liberal in his approach and having established Joseph's adoption of Jesus, he went along with Joseph's lineage in giving account of the genealogy of Christ.

I'm sure you know that cousins are either maternal or paternal. Elizabeth and Mary would be maternal cousins which is why Mary was also a Levite, since she had Levite relations. Thus Mary's ancestry is very glaring as a mixture of Judah which makes her a Jew and also a Levite which makes her lineage of priestly descent.

Again, there's nowhere in Deut 18 where God said the prophet will only say what God tells him to say. There are diverse examples of prophets speaking on behalf of God in the Bible even before God asked them to speak. It started from no less than Moses himself who told the Israelites that they shall see the Egyptians no more even before God asked him to say so. Elijah also spoke on behalf of God to Ahab. Same with Elisha to Gehazi. The test God gave as proof of prophethood was if what the prophet said will come to pass or not.

You keep referring to Deuteronomy 4 when it is contextually different from 18.
Moses was telling the children of Israel not to change the laws he gave them in 4. He was not speaking as an Oracle but as a leader of the Israelites. We find Joshua doing same in Joshua 24.

Jesus in "changing" those laws as you claim was showing the Jews that they could fulfil the laws by righteous living instead of thinking that fulfilling the laws make them righteous. Note that in same Matthew 5v17 before 21 that you quoted, He told them that he was not here to change the laws but to fulfil them. So he was giving a practical approach to fulfilling the law through righteous living instead of the burden the laws had been made unto the Jews under the illusion that strict application will bring the deliverance they desired.

Again, in Mark 7, Jesus was abrogating the tradition of the Elders which had no backing in Moses laws, and nowhere did he say what you claimed. He instead told them that what goes into them cannot make them unclean as compared to what comes out of them.

Also, in Mark 2, he was also abrogating a tradition that stemmed out of sabbatical laws which had been misinterpreted and he gave an example of David there. Sabbath was made for man to rest not for man to enslave himself. That's simply what Jesus was telling the pharisees.

In summary, you've not shown where Jesus changed Moses laws. He only showed a better way of fulfilling the laws and the intention of the law as opposed to its blind and burdensome application by the pharisees
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Nobody: 1:19pm On Jul 26
You avoided this question before:
"Also, if the Comforter were to come and tell you that he brings a new commandment different from the commandments Jesus gave, would you accept it, if the comforter says Jesus only gave those commandments because the people made Him to. When Jesus also instructed John to write in Revelation that no one should add to or take away from His words."

God told Moses:
Deuteronomy 4:2
"You shall not add to the word which I command you, neither shall you diminish ought from it."

God also said about the coming prophet:
Deuteronomy 18:18–19
"I will put My words in his mouth, and he shall speak unto them all that I shall command him."
In simple terms, the prophet God promised would only speak what God commanded. He would not add to or take away from God's commandments.

Yet Jesus said:
Moses allowed divorce (Deuteronomy 24:1), but Jesus restricted it (Matthew 5:31–32; 19:8–9).
Moses taught "an eye for an eye" (Exodus 21:24), but Jesus said, "Do not resist an evil person" (Matthew 5:38–39).
Moses regulated oaths (Numbers 30:2), but Jesus said, "Do not swear at all" (Matthew 5:33–37).
Moses gave dietary laws (Leviticus 11), but Mark says Jesus declared all foods clean (Mark 7:19).
God commanded love for one's neighbor (Leviticus 19:18), but Jesus added love for enemies as well (Matthew 5:44).

Jesus also identified Himself as the Son of God. For example:
John 10:36: "I said, I am the Son of God."
John 9:35–37: Jesus said, "Do you believe in the Son of God?... You have now seen Him; in fact, He is the one speaking with you."
Matthew 26:63–64: When the high priest asked, "Tell us if you are the Christ, the Son of God," Jesus replied, "You have said so."

However, nowhere in the Torah did God say that He would send His own Son as a prophet. The promise in Deuteronomy 18:18–19 was that God would raise up a prophet from among the Israelites who would speak the words God commanded him. It does not say that God would send His own Son to change, restrict or replace the commandments given through Moses.

Therefore, if the prophet described in Deuteronomy 18 must only speak what God commands and must not add to or take away from God's law (Deuteronomy 4:2), then Jesus does not fit that description because He presented teachings that changed the application of several Mosaic commandments.

It is also clear that neither genealogy is Mary's. Both genealogies trace Joseph's ancestry, yet Joseph was not Jesus' biological father.

Kukutente23:
If you read Luke 3 from the start dispassionately you'll come across this phrase "as was supposed" when the account of the genealogy of Jesus began and it came before Joseph's name was put there. Not only that, Luke focused solely on Mary from chapter 1 and did not report the part of Joseph's proposed break up and eventual adoption of baby Jesus through divine guidance.

Note also that Matthew's genealogy mentioned 3 women while Luke left out all the women. The summation of these glaring differences is that Luke sought to establish Jesus genealogy strictly through the paternal line albeit in a strictly biological sense. It was for this reason that Mary's name was left out and Joseph was used instead. Note that he was writing to a Roman and knew the importance of legitimacy. Matthew was more liberal in his approach and having established Joseph's adoption of Jesus, he went along with Joseph's lineage in giving account of the genealogy of Christ.

I'm sure you know that cousins are either maternal or paternal. Elizabeth and Mary would be maternal cousins which is why Mary was also a Levite, since she had Levite relations. Thus Mary's ancestry is very glaring as a mixture of Judah which makes her a Jew and also a Levite which makes her lineage of priestly descent.

Again, there's nowhere in Deut 18 where God said the prophet will only say what God tells him to say. There are diverse examples of prophets speaking on behalf of God in the Bible even before God asked them to speak. It started from no less than Moses himself who told the Israelites that they shall see the Egyptians no more even before God asked him to say so. Elijah also spoke on behalf of God to Ahab. Same with Elisha to Gehazi. The test God gave as proof of prophethood was if what the prophet said will come to pass or not.

You keep referring to Deuteronomy 4 when it is contextually different from 18.
Moses was telling the children of Israel not to change the laws he gave them in 4. He was not speaking as an Oracle but as a leader of the Israelites. We find Joshua doing same in Joshua 24.

Jesus in "changing" those laws as you claim was showing the Jews that they could fulfil the laws by righteous living instead of thinking that fulfilling the laws make them righteous. Note that in same Matthew 5v17 before 21 that you quoted, He told them that he was not here to change the laws but to fulfil them. So he was giving a practical approach to fulfilling the law through righteous living instead of the burden the laws had been made unto the Jews under the illusion that strict application will bring the deliverance they desired.

Again, in Mark 7, Jesus was abrogating the tradition of the Elders which had no backing in Moses laws, and nowhere did he say what you claimed. He instead told them that what goes into them cannot make them unclean as compared to what comes out of them.

Also, in Mark 2, he was also abrogating a tradition that stemmed out of sabbatical laws which had been misinterpreted and he gave an example of David there. Sabbath was made for man to rest not for man to enslave himself. That's simply what Jesus was telling the pharisees.

In summary, you've not shown where Jesus changed Moses laws. He only showed a better way of fulfilling the laws and the intention of the law as opposed to its blind and burdensome application by the pharisees
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Kukutente23: 5:20pm On Jul 26
MindHacker9009:
You avoided this question before:
"Also, if the Comforter were to come and tell you that he brings a new commandment different from the commandments Jesus gave, would you accept it, if the comforter says Jesus only gave those commandments because the people made Him to. When Jesus also instructed John to write in Revelation that no one should add to or take away from His words."

God told Moses:
Deuteronomy 4:2
"You shall not add to the word which I command you, neither shall you diminish ought from it."

God also said about the coming prophet:
Deuteronomy 18:18–19
"I will put My words in his mouth, and he shall speak unto them all that I shall command him."
In simple terms, the prophet God promised would only speak what God commanded. He would not add to or take away from God's commandments.

Yet Jesus said:
Moses allowed divorce (Deuteronomy 24:1), but Jesus restricted it (Matthew 5:31–32; 19:8–9).
Moses taught "an eye for an eye" (Exodus 21:24), but Jesus said, "Do not resist an evil person" (Matthew 5:38–39).
Moses regulated oaths (Numbers 30:2), but Jesus said, "Do not swear at all" (Matthew 5:33–37).
Moses gave dietary laws (Leviticus 11), but Mark says Jesus declared all foods clean (Mark 7:19).
God commanded love for one's neighbor (Leviticus 19:18), but Jesus added love for enemies as well (Matthew 5:44).

Jesus also identified Himself as the Son of God. For example:
John 10:36: "I said, I am the Son of God."
John 9:35–37: Jesus said, "Do you believe in the Son of God?... You have now seen Him; in fact, He is the one speaking with you."
Matthew 26:63–64: When the high priest asked, "Tell us if you are the Christ, the Son of God," Jesus replied, "You have said so."

However, nowhere in the Torah did God say that He would send His own Son as a prophet. The promise in Deuteronomy 18:18–19 was that God would raise up a prophet from among the Israelites who would speak the words God commanded him. It does not say that God would send His own Son to change, restrict or replace the commandments given through Moses.

Therefore, if the prophet described in Deuteronomy 18 must only speak what God commands and must not add to or take away from God's law (Deuteronomy 4:2), then Jesus does not fit that description because He presented teachings that changed the application of several Mosaic commandments.

It is also clear that neither genealogy is Mary's. Both genealogies trace Joseph's ancestry, yet Joseph was not Jesus' biological father.
I believe it is common sense that it's impossible for Joseph to have dual paternal ancestry. One of Matthew or Luke will have to be wrong. But if we believe the Bible and we believe the authors know what they wrote then the only logical explanation is that one of the two is actually Mary's. This is logical because we all know Jesus Christ only shares biological relationship with Mary and not Joseph which will make Mary's genealogy the most appropriate from a strictly biological point of view. Luke recognised this fact in his genealogy which will point to that he adopted Mary's ancestry for Jesus Christ since he focused more on Mary in his first 2 chapters and referred to Joseph as a supposed father in his genealogy making it clear the genealogy is not necessarily that of Joseph.

It seems you enjoy putting your own ideas in the Bible and passing it off as the factual words there.
Below is Deuteronomy 4:1
“Now, O Israel, listen to the statutes and the judgments which I teach you to observe, that you may live, and go in and possess the land which the Lord God of your fathers is giving you.
V21-22 makes it clearer
[I]21Furthermore the Lord was angry with me for your sakes, and swore that I would not cross over the Jordan, and that I would not enter the good land which the Lord your God is giving you as an inheritance. 22But I must die in this land, I must not cross over the Jordan; but you shall cross over and possess that good land[/i]
Thus it is obvious from these verses that Moses was addressing the Israelites as their leader in chapter 4 and not God speaking through him as his Oracle. So to use chapter 4 which are Moses's words to qualify chapter 18 which are God's own words spoken through Moses is to put Moses and God on equal pedestal.

Only a heretic or blasphemer will do this. It would either be that you prove otherwise that it's God speaking in both chapters or you live with being taken as an heretic who equates man's words with God's.

If the Torah were a complete and total package of God's words as you seem to posit, we will not have other prophets through whom God spoke to Israelites. Apart from the Torah, we have 4 major prophets and 12 minor prophets whose books are preserved till these day.

Except again you seek to imply that Isaiah, Jeremaiah, Ezekiel and Daniel were false prophets and never sent by God since a good portion of their messages are not even in accordance with the Torah. God said the sacrifices he appointed were repulsive to him in Amos. In Isaiah, he declared that sin is red like blood, same blood he asked that be spilled for cleansing. He said cleansing will make sin white. Thus, the words of God is dynamic and not dogmatically tied to the Torah as you seek to claim.

Thus when Isaiah prophesied about the son of God and David also about the sun of righteousness. Do you mean their prophecy is false since there's no basis for it in the Torah? Isaiah even married a harlots!! A clear contradiction in the Torah. The Torah clearly says anyone who plays the harlot should be put to death.

So you should desist from putting into the Bible what is not there. Also, if you want to contest Jesus's sonship with God, you'll need a better premise than conflating Deuteronomy 4 and 18.

Moreover, Jesus clearly said he didn't come to abolish Moses's laws. So your subjective interpretation of his teachings concerning Moses's laws can't be taken over his own words since he is the Truth and no falsehood was found in him. Same cannot be said for you who has been going overboard to pass off lies as the truth in the Bible!
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Nobody: 8:28pm On Jul 26
You are still avoiding this question before:
"Also, if the Comforter were to come and tell you that he brings a new commandment different from the commandments Jesus gave, would you accept it, if the comforter says Jesus only gave those commandments because the people made Him to. When Jesus also instructed John to write in Revelation that no one should add to or take away from His words."

Your argument rests on assumptions that are not actually stated in Scripture.

First, regarding the genealogies, it is impossible for Joseph to have two different biological fathers. Matthew traces Joseph through Jacob (Matthew 1:16), while Luke traces him through Heli (Luke 3:23). One of these genealogies cannot be Joseph's biological ancestry.

The common explanation to patch this misinformation is that Luke records Mary's genealogy while Matthew records Joseph's legal genealogy. However, the Bible never explicitly says this. Scripture nowhere states that Luke is presenting Mary's genealogy. Luke still introduces the genealogy through Joseph, and the view that it is Mary's genealogy is a later patch rather than an explicit biblical teaching.

Furthermore, the only family relationship of Mary that Scripture explicitly records is that she was a relative (or cousin) of Elizabeth (Luke 1:36). The Bible does not provide a genealogy for Mary herself. Therefore, it is inaccurate to present Luke's genealogy as unquestionably Mary's when the text never says so.

Second, nowhere in the Torah does God ever say, "Jesus is My Son." The title "My son" in the Torah is explicitly applied to Israel:
"Israel is My son, My firstborn." (Exodus 4:22)

If you wish to argue that Jesus is God's Son, that argument was made up, because the Torah itself never records God declaring Jesus to be His Son. You cannot claim the Torah teaches something that it does not actually say.

Regarding Deuteronomy, you are conflating two different contexts. Deuteronomy 4 begins with Moses addressing Israel:
"Now therefore, O Israel, listen to the statutes and the judgments which I teach you..." The chapter continues with Moses speaking in the first person.
These are clearly Moses' own words to Israel.
By contrast, Deuteronomy 18 records God's promise concerning the Prophet whom He would raise up. Treating Moses' personal exhortation in chapter 4 as identical to God's declaration in chapter 18 ignores the distinction the text itself makes.

You also keep bringing the later prophets into this discussion. We are not discussing Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, Daniel, or the Twelve Minor Prophets. We are discussing the Prophet like Moses promised in Deuteronomy 18. That prophecy stands on its own and provides its own criteria. Applying the other prophets does not answer whether a particular person fulfills the qualifications God gave for that unique prophet. This discussion should remain focused on Deuteronomy 18 rather than being diverted to unrelated prophets.

Finally, Jesus Himself said:
"Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them." (Matthew 5:17)

However, one cannot change, replace, or set aside commandments and then claim that those changes are a fulfillment of the Law. If the commandments are from God, fulfilling them cannot mean changing them. Therefore, any claim of fulfillment must be consistent with preserving what God commanded rather than changing or removing those commandments.

Kukutente23:
I believe it is common sense that it's impossible for Joseph to have dual paternal ancestry. One of Matthew or Luke will have to be wrong. But if we believe the Bible and we believe the authors know what they wrote then the only logical explanation is that one of the two is actually Mary's. This is logical because we all know Jesus Christ only shares biological relationship with Mary and not Joseph which will make Mary's genealogy the most appropriate from a strictly biological point of view. Luke recognised this fact in his genealogy which will point to that he adopted Mary's ancestry for Jesus Christ since he focused more on Mary in his first 2 chapters and referred to Joseph as a supposed father in his genealogy making it clear the genealogy is not necessarily that of Joseph.

It seems you enjoy putting your own ideas in the Bible and passing it off as the factual words there.
Below is Deuteronomy 4:1


V21-22 makes it clearer


Thus it is obvious from these verses that Moses was addressing the Israelites as their leader in chapter 4 and not God speaking through him as his Oracle. So to use chapter 4 which are Moses's words to qualify chapter 18 which are God's own words spoken through Moses is to put Moses and God on equal pedestal.

Only a heretic or blasphemer will do this. It would either be that you prove otherwise that it's God speaking in both chapters or you live with being taken as an heretic who equates man's words with God's.

If the Torah were a complete and total package of God's words as you seem to posit, we will not have other prophets through whom God spoke to Israelites. Apart from the Torah, we have 4 major prophets and 12 minor prophets whose books are preserved till these day.

Except again you seek to imply that Isaiah, Jeremaiah, Ezekiel and Daniel were false prophets and never sent by God since a good portion of their messages are not even in accordance with the Torah. God said the sacrifices he appointed were repulsive to him in Amos. In Isaiah, he declared that sin is red like blood, same blood he asked that be spilled for cleansing. He said cleansing will make sin white. Thus, the words of God is dynamic and not dogmatically tied to the Torah as you seek to claim.

Thus when Isaiah prophesied about the son of God and David also about the sun of righteousness. Do you mean their prophecy is false since there's no basis for it in the Torah? Isaiah even married a harlots!! A clear contradiction in the Torah. The Torah clearly says anyone who plays the harlot should be put to death.

So you should desist from putting into the Bible what is not there. Also, if you want to contest Jesus's sonship with God, you'll need a better premise than conflating Deuteronomy 4 and 18.

Moreover, Jesus clearly said he didn't come to abolish Moses's laws. So your subjective interpretation of his teachings concerning Moses's laws can't be taken over his own words since he is the Truth and no falsehood was found in him. Same cannot be said for you who has been going overboard to pass off lies as the truth in the Bible!
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Kukutente23: 11:16pm On Jul 26
MindHacker9009:
You are still avoiding this question before:
"Also, if the Comforter were to come and tell you that he brings a new commandment different from the commandments Jesus gave, would you accept it, if the comforter says Jesus only gave those commandments because the people made Him to. When Jesus also instructed John to write in Revelation that no one should add to or take away from His words."

Your argument rests on assumptions that are not actually stated in Scripture.

First, regarding the genealogies, it is impossible for Joseph to have two different biological fathers. Matthew traces Joseph through Jacob (Matthew 1:16), while Luke traces him through Heli (Luke 3:23). One of these genealogies cannot be Joseph's biological ancestry.

The common explanation to patch this misinformation is that Luke records Mary's genealogy while Matthew records Joseph's legal genealogy. However, the Bible never explicitly says this. Scripture nowhere states that Luke is presenting Mary's genealogy. Luke still introduces the genealogy through Joseph, and the view that it is Mary's genealogy is a later patch rather than an explicit biblical teaching.

Furthermore, the only family relationship of Mary that Scripture explicitly records is that she was a relative (or cousin) of Elizabeth (Luke 1:36). The Bible does not provide a genealogy for Mary herself. Therefore, it is inaccurate to present Luke's genealogy as unquestionably Mary's when the text never says so.

Second, nowhere in the Torah does God ever say, "Jesus is My Son." The title "My son" in the Torah is explicitly applied to Israel:
"Israel is My son, My firstborn." (Exodus 4:22)

If you wish to argue that Jesus is God's Son, that argument was made up, because the Torah itself never records God declaring Jesus to be His Son. You cannot claim the Torah teaches something that it does not actually say.

Regarding Deuteronomy, you are conflating two different contexts. Deuteronomy 4 begins with Moses addressing Israel:
"Now therefore, O Israel, listen to the statutes and the judgments which I teach you..." The chapter continues with Moses speaking in the first person.
These are clearly Moses' own words to Israel.
By contrast, Deuteronomy 18 records God's promise concerning the Prophet whom He would raise up. Treating Moses' personal exhortation in chapter 4 as identical to God's declaration in chapter 18 ignores the distinction the text itself makes.

You also keep bringing the later prophets into this discussion. We are not discussing Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, Daniel, or the Twelve Minor Prophets. We are discussing the Prophet like Moses promised in Deuteronomy 18. That prophecy stands on its own and provides its own criteria. Applying the other prophets does not answer whether a particular person fulfills the qualifications God gave for that unique prophet. This discussion should remain focused on Deuteronomy 18 rather than being diverted to unrelated prophets.

Finally, Jesus Himself said:
"Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them." (Matthew 5:17)

However, one cannot change, replace, or set aside commandments and then claim that those changes are a fulfillment of the Law. If the commandments are from God, fulfilling them cannot mean changing them. Therefore, any claim of fulfillment must be consistent with preserving what God commanded rather than changing or removing those commandments.
The question you ask is basically meaningless and irrelevant. First of all Rev 22:18 was specifically referring to the book of revelations and not the words of Jesus. The book of revelations was revealed through the holy spirit. No part of the book was spoken of by Jesus when he was on earth. Thus, you should see how misguided and meaningless your question is since the Revelations chapter you relied on was a revelation through the holy spirit and not the words of Jesus in the flesh like we have in the gospels. Read Rev 1v1

1The Revelation of Jesus Christ, which God gave Him to show His servants—things which must shortly take place. And He sent and signified it by His angel to His servant John,
That said, if we're going to dogmatically go by your claims, Paul should have ignored the Holy Spirit in Acts 16 when he prevented them from preaching in Asia but directed them to Macedonia. This should be taken as a direct conflict to Jesus's charge to his disciples to preach the Gospel in all the nations of the earth if we're to go by your standards.

You're simply required to go back and read your Bible with an open mind so your don't keep mouthing heresy.
Luke wouldn't explicitly say such thing since he was writing to a Roman who also believed in patriarchy and will struggle to understand why a child will be recognised through his mother's ancestry. That's why Luke used the word "supposed" when introducing Joseph in the genealogy.

I already told you before the Deut 18 is not specific. It is a generic reference to prophets to come after Moses in which Jesus is among. Your claim of Jesus changing Moses' laws is your subjective inference. Jesus said he didn't come to change the laws but fulfil them and I'm sure you'll agree it's safer to believe Jesus than you in such a matter.

The Torah couldn't have declared Jesus as God's Son when Jesus was not yet on earth when it was written. But the Torah establishes the personality of God in three persons in Genesis 18 were Abraham saw God as 3 persons signifying the Godhead of the Trinity. Thus, the Son was part of the Godhead when the Torah was written and had not yet become Jesus the Son who came to earth.

The focus was on Deuteronomy 18 until you ignorantly started doing an eisegesis of Deuteronomy 4 in a desperate bid to force it to buttress your off point claims about chapter 18. Reading 18 alone, many prophets fit the bill which shows that the passage was not for a particular Prophet but for a line of prophets chosen by God to restore his people into him of which Jesus is chief among
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Nobody:
We should focus on Revelation for now:

Your response focuses on whether Revelation 22:18 was spoken by Jesus during His earthly ministry, but Revelation begins by saying, “The Revelation of Jesus Christ…” (Revelation 1:1). The message is presented as coming from Jesus, not as a separate human opinion.

So the question remains: if someone claims to be the Comforter but changes the commandments that Jesus gave, saying Jesus gave them because the people made him to, will you accept such? When Jesus also instructed John to write in Revelation that no one should add to or take away from His words.

Kukutente23:
The question you ask is basically meaningless and irrelevant. First of all Rev 22:18 was specifically referring to the book of revelations and not the words of Jesus. The book of revelations was revealed through the holy spirit. No part of the book was spoken of by Jesus when he was on earth. Thus, you should see how misguided and meaningless your question is since the Revelations chapter you relied on was a revelation through the holy spirit and not the words of Jesus in the flesh like we have in the gospels. Read Rev 1v1



That said, if we're going to dogmatically go by your claims, Paul should have ignored the Holy Spirit in Acts 16 when he prevented them from preaching in Asia but directed them to Macedonia. This should be taken as a direct conflict to Jesus's charge to his disciples to preach the Gospel in all the nations of the earth if we're to go by your standards.

You're simply required to go back and read your Bible with an open mind so your don't keep mouthing heresy.
Luke wouldn't explicitly say such thing since he was writing to a Roman who also believed in patriarchy and will struggle to understand why a child will be recognised through his mother's ancestry. That's why Luke used the word "supposed" when introducing Joseph in the genealogy.

I already told you before the Deut 18 is not specific. It is a generic reference to prophets to come after Moses in which Jesus is among. Your claim of Jesus changing Moses' laws is your subjective inference. Jesus said he didn't come to change the laws but fulfil them and I'm sure you'll agree it's safer to believe Jesus than you in such a matter.

The Torah couldn't have declared Jesus as God's Son when Jesus was not yet on earth when it was written. But the Torah establishes the personality of God in three persons in Genesis 18 were Abraham saw God as 3 persons signifying the Godhead of the Trinity. Thus, the Son was part of the Godhead when the Torah was written and had not yet become Jesus the Son who came to earth.

The focus was on Deuteronomy 18 until you ignorantly started doing an eisegesis of Deuteronomy 4 in a desperate bid to force it to buttress your off point claims about chapter 18. Reading 18 alone, many prophets fit the bill which shows that the passage was not for a particular Prophet but for a line of prophets chosen by God to restore his people into him of which Jesus is chief among
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Kukutente23: 10:14am On Jul 27
MindHacker9009:
We should focus on Revelation for now:

Your response focuses on whether Revelation 22:18 was spoken by Jesus during His earthly ministry, but Revelation begins by saying, “The Revelation of Jesus Christ…” (Revelation 1:1). The message is presented as coming from Jesus, not as a separate human opinion.

So the question remains: if someone claims to be the Comforter but changes the commandments that Jesus gave, saying Jesus gave them because the people made him to, will you accept such? When Jesus also instructed John to write in Revelation that no one should add to or take away from His words.
You seem to enjoy chasing shadows under the banner of changing focus

You started this discourse from Deuteronomy 18 which you then shifted to Deuteronomy 4. When both have been shown clearly to not fit your agenda you now shifted to Revelations 22 and now you've arrived at Revelations 1 as your new escapade. This simply shows your lack of consistency and depth on the topic you're chatting about.

Who did the Revelation of Jesus Christ pass through in chapter 1 to get to John? There must be a medium for a Revelation since it's obvious Jesus did not come down physically. So how do you propose we trust the Revelation when Jesus never mentioned that he'll be sending a Revelation to any of his disciples? And the contents of the Revelation does not bear any semblance with his words while on earth.
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Nobody:
You are the one changing the subject with your convoluted replies. The original question was straightforward, but instead of addressing it directly, you have introduced other issues and shifted the focus away from the point being discussed.

I began with a simple question about Deuteronomy 18:18-19 because that was the claim being made, that Jesus is "the prophet who is to come." Instead of demonstrating how that passage supports the claim, the discussion moved elsewhere.

My follow-up question was directly relevant to testing the claim. I asked:

If someone claims to be the Comforter but changes the commandments that Jesus gave, saying Jesus only gave them because of the people, should such a person be accepted?

That is not a change of subject. It is the natural consequence of the claim being made. If someone claims to come as the Comforter, then their teachings must be measured against Christ's own words.

That is precisely why I referred to Revelation. Jesus warns against tampering with His revelation and throughout the New Testament believers are repeatedly warned against accepting a different gospel or different teaching. The issue is consistency with Christ, not introducing a new topic.

As for Revelation 1, your question actually reinforces my point rather than weakening it.

Yes, Revelation passed from the Father to Jesus, from Jesus to His angel and from the angel to John (Revelation 1:1). But that chain does not introduce a new Comforter who revises Jesus' teachings. It delivers **"the revelation of Jesus Christ."** The source remains Jesus Himself, not someone claiming authority centuries later to alter what Jesus commanded.

You also ask why we should trust Revelation since Jesus did not previously announce that He would send it. The answer is that Revelation itself presents its authority as coming from Jesus Christ. Whether one accepts that book is a separate discussion, but it cannot be used to justify someone else changing Christ's teachings. The messenger in Revelation faithfully delivers Christ's words; he does not replace them.

So the original question still stands unanswered:

If a person claims to be the promised Comforter, yet changes Jesus commandments and teaches that Jesus' commandments were merely concessions to the people and are no longer binding, will you accept the person as the Comforter speaking for Christ rather than contradicting Him?

That is the question I have consistently been asking from the beginning and it's a simple yes or no answer. MaxInDHouse ran away from it, and you came in to stand in for MaxInDHouse, but you have been beating around the bush without answering the simple question, which requires only a simple yes or no.

Kukutente23:
You seem to enjoy chasing shadows under the banner of changing focus

You started this discourse from Deuteronomy 18 which you then shifted to Deuteronomy 4. When both have been shown clearly to not fit your agenda you now shifted to Revelations 22 and now you've arrived at Revelations 1 as your new escapade. This simply shows your lack of consistency and depth on the topic you're chatting about.

Who did the Revelation of Jesus Christ pass through in chapter 1 to get to John? There must be a medium for a Revelation since it's obvious Jesus did not come down physically. So how do you propose we trust the Revelation when Jesus never mentioned that he'll be sending a Revelation to any of his disciples? And the contents of the Revelation does not bear any semblance with his words while on earth.
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by MaxInDHouse(m): 12:41pm On Jul 27
Kukutente23:
You seem to enjoy chasing shadows under the banner of changing focus
He will continue deflecting that is why i ignored him!🥱
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Nobody: 2:43pm On Jul 27
MaxInDHouse:
He will continue deflecting that is why i ignored him!🥱
Because I do not belong to your organisation where members are not allowed to use their God-given wisdom to ask questions, only to be choked into becoming your zombies.
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by MaxInDHouse(m): 2:56pm On Jul 27
MindHacker9009:
Because I do not belong to your organisation where members are not allowed to use their God-given wisdom to ask questions, only to be choked into becoming your zombies.
🥱

Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Kukutente23: 4:59pm On Jul 27
MindHacker9009:
You are the one changing the subject with your convoluted replies. The original question was straightforward, but instead of addressing it directly, you have introduced other issues and shifted the focus away from the point being discussed.

I began with a simple question about Deuteronomy 18:18-19 because that was the claim being made, that Jesus is "the prophet who is to come." Instead of demonstrating how that passage supports the claim, the discussion moved elsewhere.

My follow-up question was directly relevant to testing the claim. I asked:

If someone claims to be the Comforter but changes the commandments that Jesus gave, saying Jesus only gave them because of the people, should such a person be accepted?

That is not a change of subject. It is the natural consequence of the claim being made. If someone claims to come as the Comforter, then their teachings must be measured against Christ's own words.

That is precisely why I referred to Revelation. Jesus warns against tampering with His revelation and throughout the New Testament believers are repeatedly warned against accepting a different gospel or different teaching. The issue is consistency with Christ, not introducing a new topic.

As for Revelation 1, your question actually reinforces my point rather than weakening it.

Yes, Revelation passed from the Father to Jesus, from Jesus to His angel and from the angel to John (Revelation 1:1). But that chain does not introduce a new Comforter who revises Jesus' teachings. It delivers **"the revelation of Jesus Christ."** The source remains Jesus Himself, not someone claiming authority centuries later to alter what Jesus commanded.

You also ask why we should trust Revelation since Jesus did not previously announce that He would send it. The answer is that Revelation itself presents its authority as coming from Jesus Christ. Whether one accepts that book is a separate discussion, but it cannot be used to justify someone else changing Christ's teachings. The messenger in Revelation faithfully delivers Christ's words; he does not replace them.

So the original question still stands unanswered:

If a person claims to be the promised Comforter, yet changes Jesus commandments and teaches that Jesus' commandments were merely concessions to the people and are no longer binding, will you accept the person as the Comforter speaking for Christ rather than contradicting Him?

That is the question I have consistently been asking from the beginning and it's a simple yes or no answer. MaxInDHouse ran away from it, and you came in to stand in for MaxInDHouse, but you have been beating around the bush without answering the simple question, which requires only a simple yes or no.
But I already demonstrated how Deuteronomy 18 fits Jesus. He's a prophet. He's an Israelite and among the brethren so described. And most importantly, those things he said came to pass and have been coming to pass which is the sure test instituted by God to know if a prophet is truly from him or not.

You refused to accept these facts. You first claimed that Jesus was not a prophet. Then you attempted to introduce doubt into Mary's ancestry in a bid to confuse the established fact of Jesus being an Israelite and a Jew. Lastly, you brought in Deuteronomy 4 and claimed that Jesus added to and changed Moses's laws in another erroneous bid to paint Jesus as fake.

You also introduced the Comforter angle as an analogy to push the narrative that Jesus changed Moses's laws.

So it's you who have been unstable and inconsistent. If you had accepted the facts of Jesus's prophethood and ancestry as well as the validity of his prophecies, we wouldn't still be here and you wouldn't still be dancing around looking for straws to hold on to.

Again, I asked you about trusting revelation in response to your meaningless riposte about the Comforter changing Jesus's message. I believe you need to rest. This discussion is obviously beyond your mental capacity and has left you dazed.
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Nobody:
You are the one that has been unstable, by just accepting Jesus as a prophet like Moses stated in Deuteronomy 18, when Joseph's ancestry is not his. The only ancestry of Mary is that she is a relative of Aaron.
Hagar was an Egyptian, and her son Ishmael was Abraham's first son, making her and her son's descendants all related to the Israelites because both Ishmael and Isaac were sons of Abraham. Abraham became the father of Israel through Isaac's son Jacob, who was named Israel.
So Mary could have been an Egyptian as we do not have her full genealogy and also it was Egypt they fled to, to have Jesus.

It's you that needs to rest as your your brain cannot handle this discuss, all your responses show you don't ask questions with wisdom you just believe what you want to believe and you expect others to do the same.

The original question still stands unanswered:

If a person claims to be the promised Comforter, yet changes Jesus commandments and teaches that Jesus' commandments were merely because the people made Him to give them and are no longer binding, will you accept the person as the Comforter speaking for Jesus Christ rather than contradicting Him?

That is the question I have consistently been asking from the beginning and it's a simple yes or no answer.

Kukutente23:
But I already demonstrated how Deuteronomy 18 fits Jesus. He's a prophet. He's an Israelite and among the brethren so described. And most importantly, those things he said came to pass and have been coming to pass which is the sure test instituted by God to know if a prophet is truly from him or not.

You refused to accept these facts. You first claimed that Jesus was not a prophet. Then you attempted to introduce doubt into Mary's ancestry in a bid to confuse the established fact of Jesus being an Israelite and a Jew. Lastly, you brought in Deuteronomy 4 and claimed that Jesus added to and changed Moses's laws in another erroneous bid to paint Jesus as fake.

You also introduced the Comforter angle as an analogy to push the narrative that Jesus changed Moses's laws.

So it's you who have been unstable and inconsistent. If you had accepted the facts of Jesus's prophethood and ancestry as well as the validity of his prophecies, we wouldn't still be here and you wouldn't still be dancing around looking for straws to hold on to.

Again, I asked you about trusting revelation in response to your meaningless riposte about the Comforter changing Jesus's message. I believe you need to rest. This discussion is obviously beyond your mental capacity and has left you dazed.
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Kukutente23: 8:55pm On Jul 27
MindHacker9009:
You are the one that has been unstable, by just accepting Jesus as a prophet like Moses stated in Deuteronomy 18, when Joseph's ancestry is not his. The only ancestry of Mary is that she is a relative of Aaron.
Hagar was an Egyptian, and her son Ishmael was Abraham's first son, making her and her son's descendants all related to the Israelites because both Ishmael and Isaac were sons of Abraham. Abraham became the father of Israel through Isaac's son Jacob, who was named Israel.
So Mary could have been an Egyptian as we do not have her full genealogy and also it was Egypt they fled to, to have Jesus.

It's you that needs to rest as your your brain cannot handle this discuss, all your response shows you don't ask questions with wisdom you just believe what you want to believe and you expect others to do the same.

The original question still stands unanswered:

If a person claims to be the promised Comforter, yet changes Jesus commandments and teaches that Jesus' commandments were merely because the people made Him to give them and are no longer binding, will you accept the person as the Comforter speaking for Jesus Christ rather than contradicting Him?

That is the question I have consistently been asking from the beginning and it's a simple yes or no answer.
You have still not told us where you got the idea of Mary being an Egyptian from. Both Islamic and Christian sources identify her as an Israelite. Isaiah even prophesied about her in chapter 7. Your futile attempt to use the flight to Egypt as evidence that Mary is from Egypt is defeated by the fact that it was the angel of the Lord who chose Egypt for the family to run to not Mary. Read Matthew 2. God also clearly rejected Ishmael as the Son of promise. So how could the Messaiah have come from a lineage rejected by God? If Mary was an Egyptian, it's virtually impossible for all the gospels to have left out that important detail. It's also impossible for a Levite of all tribes to marry a foreigner as God expressly forbade Israel from marrying from any of the nations he had rejected for them. So you need to stop rehashing the washed and ridiculous claim of Mary being an Egyptian.
The question is meaningless a meaningless question can't get a yes or no answer. It's like asking if water is still water if salt is added. It's a dumb question to ask. Your question has no scriptural or historical basis. It's a frivolous question and I recently showed you its frivolity. I reproduce it here for you.

The question you ask is basically meaningless and irrelevant. First of all Rev 22:18 was specifically referring to the book of revelations and not the words of Jesus. The book of revelations was revealed through the holy spirit. No part of the book was spoken of by Jesus when he was on earth. Thus, you should see how misguided and meaningless your question is since the Revelations chapter you relied on was a revelation through the holy spirit and not the words of Jesus in the flesh like we have in the gospels. Read Rev 1v1



That said, if we're going to dogmatically go by your claims, Paul should have ignored the Holy Spirit in Acts 16 when he prevented them from preaching in Asia but directed them to Macedonia. This should be taken as a direct conflict to Jesus's charge to his disciples to preach the Gospel in all the nations of the earth if we're to go by your standards.
Re: Solomon's Wisdom, Marriage, Concubinage And Idolatry! by Nobody:
Your claim that Israelites were simply forbidden from marrying non-Israelites is not accurate. The Torah specifically prohibited marrying from the nations of Canaan who were devoted to idolatry (Deuteronomy 7:3–4), not every person from every nation. The Bible itself records Israelites marrying foreigners. Moses married Zipporah, a Midianite woman (Exodus 2:21), and Solomon married foreign women, including women from nations outside Israel (1 Kings 11:1–2). Ruth, a Moabite woman, became part of Israel and an ancestor of King David (Ruth 4:13–17).

Deuteronomy 21:10–14
It describes a captive woman taken in war who could become an Israelite man's wife after a period of time.

Therefore, ancestry cannot simply be dismissed by saying Mary could not have had any non-Israelite ancestry. The biblical text does not provide a complete genealogy for Mary, so claims about her entire biological background go beyond what is explicitly recorded.

Stop being insulative, turning to insults shows you lack wisdom. If you cannot answer this simple question, then it's better you don't respond at all.

The original question still stands unanswered:

If a person claims to be the promised Comforter, yet changes Jesus commandments and teaches that Jesus' commandments were merely because the people made Him to give them and are no longer binding, will you accept the person as the Comforter speaking for Jesus Christ rather than contradicting Him?

That is the question I have consistently been asking from the beginning and it's a simple yes or no answer.

Kukutente23:
You have still not told us where you got the idea of Mary being an Egyptian from. Both Islamic and Christian sources identify her as an Israelite. Isaiah even prophesied about her in chapter 7. Your futile attempt to use the flight to Egypt as evidence that Mary is from Egypt is defeated by the fact that it was the angel of the Lord who chose Egypt for the family to run to not Mary. Read Matthew 2. God also clearly rejected Ishmael as the Son of promise. So how could the Messaiah have come from a lineage rejected by God? If Mary was an Egyptian, it's virtually impossible for all the gospels to have left out that important detail. It's also impossible for a Levite of all tribes to marry a foreigner as God expressly forbade Israel from marrying from any of the nations he had rejected for them. So you need to stop rehashing the washed and ridiculous claim of Mary being an Egyptian.
The question is meaningless a meaningless question can't get a yes or no answer. It's like asking if water is still water if salt is added. It's a dumb question to ask. Your question has no scriptural or historical basis. It's a frivolous question and I recently showed you its frivolity. I reproduce it here for you.
1 2 3 4 5 6 Reply

The Second Commandment And Idolatry/witchcraft. • Strong Proof satan Is Behind Atheism And Idolatry • Roman Catholicism, Mary And Idolatry • 2 • 3 • 4

Are Rumors About Olumba Olumba True? • Have You Scrutinized/criticised Your Belief System Or Do You Just Believe? • Spiritual Truth From Aladdin