A Proper Analysis Of The Non Oil Revenue Of The FG. - Politics - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › A Proper Analysis Of The Non Oil Revenue Of The FG. (203 Views)
| A Proper Analysis Of The Non Oil Revenue Of The FG. by lawani(op): 5:22pm On Jul 30 |
A proper analysis of the non oil revenue of the FG. The narrative is that the SE is too far behind in VAT and CIT generation but in the absence of a reliable census, you need to consider other data before adopting that conclusion. NIN registration figures Voter registration figures SME registration figures Active sim cards And then add any other data you can lay your hands on that are indicative of the population size. With all these data you will see that the VAT and CIT output of the SE is a bit above the weight of the zone by population when compared to other zones apart from the SW. Though I did not check properly but I checked for the SW and the NW. The NW for instance is supposed to have a clear three times of the SE but it does not have up to that. It however has far more than double. Then all the zones have economic activity according to their population size but some activities are not VATable. All activities below fifty million naira in annual revenue don't need to file VAT and that to me is not right. There is no need for barbers, fashion designers, small restaurants and etc to be excluded from filing VAT. A barber paying rent of three hundred thousand naira per annum should pay more VAT than that and etc etc. They ought to endeavor to pay VAT more than rent. It is after all paid by the consumers. Then the agricultural and trading sectors are not VATable. The sectors that are not VATable have workers and if a taxable minimum wage is imposed on all workers then the states that can't generate huge VAT will be able to generate PAYE and ordinarily states should pay a portion of their IGR to the center. Local governments too should pay to the states. Agrarian states should have produce boards and they will make more money from those boards than industrialized states make from VAT or as much and they should also pay up to the FG. That is how it ought to be and if it is efficient like that then Kano will pay in as much revenue to the FG as Lagos while Kaduna and Oyo will pay in more than Rivers state etc etc. |
| Re: A Proper Analysis Of The Non Oil Revenue Of The FG. by FSBoperator: 6:06pm On Jul 30 |
lawani:What is the point of your drive? You want the FG to tax northern farmers so you can get more free money from the central purse? |
| Re: A Proper Analysis Of The Non Oil Revenue Of The FG. by lawani(op): 1:47am On Jul 31 |
FSBoperator:The law in Nigeria does not allow the FG to tax farmers. Only states and local governments can. The point is some states even most states can't move ahead unless they tax farmers and the SE is pulling more than it's weight by population in VAT payments when compared to the NW also that the VAT net should be widened |
| Re: A Proper Analysis Of The Non Oil Revenue Of The FG. by FSBoperator: 8:49am On Jul 31 |
lawani:VAT earnings per state clearly shows the SE to be the lowest VAT generating region. Every northern state generated more VAT than your SE. So you still want FG to tax northern farmers who feed you both in vat and food produce to be taxed more on their farm produce so you can get more than the unfair share you are collecting? Mind you, SE got the highest proportion from VAT than what they collected . |
| Re: A Proper Analysis Of The Non Oil Revenue Of The FG. by lawani(op): 8:55am On Jul 31 |
FSBoperator:Whatever you share in Nigeria, the SE will get more than their fair share. Be it cash, ministers, universities, states, local government, companies, ambassadors or senators. The sharing formula favors the zone. Kano or Lagos have more population than the zone. So you either correct that or leave it like that. However my post is about getting more from the GDP to increase the lot of the whole country by devising ways to increase the tax to GDP ratio |
Pro-wike Group Moves To Use Federal High Court To Seize Revenue Of Rivers State • Tinubu’s Reinstated Fuel Subsidy Will Drain Almost Half Of Oil Revenue—IMF Warns • Niger State Demands 13% Derivation From Oil Revenue; Threatens To Shut Kanji Dam • 2 • 3 • 4
Atiku Raises Alarm Over Suspicious Credit Alert To Private Bank Account • Osun 2026: We Are The Victims — Oyebamiji Accuses Adeleke Of Playing Victim • Makinde Picks Ex DSS DG, Musa Daura As APM Presidential Running Mate