FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 - Politics (5) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 (9673 Views)
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by Jakarta: 7:01pm On Aug 01*. Modified: 9:31pm On Aug 01 |
reddingtonblack:Would you prefer the government paying subsidy for darkness? Do you still remember the state owned telecom company called NITEL, how far today? How would you rate the country's telecoms sector a non subsidised sector Vs the subsidised power sector? Do you remember people bought SIM cards for 50k as far back as early 2000's how much is same SIM card today? Way back then owning a cable TV was considered a luxury, the government even came up with a subsidised version called STAR TIMES, where is same star times today? If you check carefully our most successful sectors are those sectors with very little or no involvement of the government. Anything wey our government involve for this country dey always get comma. As for our current low power generation, it will only get worst with time as far as subsidy is involved. Investors don't want to invest in our power sector because the government still controls it, nobody wan throway money inside pit. The government should focus more on incentives and regulatory roles instead of the current father christmas roles that favours only a selected few this is what developed nations do. |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by yemre: 8:17pm On Aug 01 |
Jakarta:I blame the minister of power for this because it shows lack of control! We need someone like Wike or Keyamo in that sector, all of them will sit up. |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by yemre: 8:25pm On Aug 01 |
Jakarta:I agree with you. Imagine the subsidy-free petrol market today! I can't remember the last time I queued for an hour to buy fuel simply because the government says he's not doing again, and the players can freely compete. It's tough, I know. But for us to get this electricity thing right, the government needs to wash it's hands off it completely! Let the principle of demand and supply dictate the price and let the market be saturated and give the consumers multiple options to choose what serves their needs. |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by sulaak(m): 9:26pm On Aug 01 |
AdolfHitlerxXx:How can you industrialise? When Nigeria is borrowing billions of dollars to subsidise imported fuel and protect the Naira. The government policies of removing all subsidies are the best approach to industrialisation. Now the government must reduce the interest rate to single digits to support local credit |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by reddingtonblack: 11:39pm On Aug 01 |
Loop Jakarta:Coming from a Nigerians, i thought you said you pay for security, wire, transformer, viligante n every basic needs and you are happy that Govt has no Contribution directly into your life. You can"t tell me you are a normal person ...You must be part of these roguesWould you prefer the government paying subsidy for darkness? Do you still remember the state owned telecom company called NITEL, how far today?If i can endure paying for darkness tell me why govt shouldnt endure tew ... After all what is good for the goose What kind of citizen wil not want Govt contribution in any form, so what is the usefulness of govt .. When i am a govt on my own ... I did my own gutter, contribute to grade our road, pay for viligante so what is my gain from govt if subsidy is completely off the table If you are in lagos, we pay waste management dem no kum pick waste .. people like you would jump online to blame it on subsidy ..assuming it exists. Smh |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by Jakarta: 12:56am On Aug 02*. Modified: 1:43am On Aug 02 |
reddingtonblack:Ogbeni na wa for you oh!!. Your teacher for school try oh!! even though he/she teach brick wall. So according to you, the usefulness of a government is by paying subsidies that will end up impoverishing her citizens even more, U don pass 14 so? There is no free food even in freetown, this shouldn't be too hard for you to understand. Yes corruption exists no doubt about that, but subsidies will only give more room to this same corruption. DisCos are already using it as a yardstick , if you no be small pikin this thing nor suppose too hard for you to understand. Should I be paying for the things you listed above and the government is still paying subsidies for these same thing, of what benefits is the so called subsidy to me then? Subsidy payment is not an investment in new infrastructure or maintenance, rather it is a bailout mechanism to cover massive commercial financial shortfalls within a broken, debt ridden supply chain. Despite the huge subsidy projection about #1.2T for 2026, the funds merely patch up systemic leaks instead of expanding the power grid. I would prefer the government investing such amount in same sector, instead of using it to pay debts that her citizens stand to gain very little or nothing from. The government still owes GenCos over ₦6.2T, gas suppliers over $1.3B. GenCos are complaining that they are paid as little as 10% of their actual invoices, as such they lack the money to maintain turbines or buy gas, forcing Nigeria’s available electricity to hover at a low 4,000 - 5,000 megawatts. Can't you see the subsidy is causing us more harm than good? These things no suppose too hard for person wey don pass 14 to understand na, ebabo. We should be more concerned about how the government intends to utilise the funds saved from non subsidy payments. The questions we should be asking are; how will these funds be utilised, how do we hold DisCos, GenCos, and the government accountable, what cautionary, and incentive measures does the government intend implementing? PBAT wan open mouth wa and say subsidy is gone again without planning for the adverse effects? These should be our source of concern not it's removal. |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by reddingtonblack: 4:25am On Aug 02 |
[quote author=Jakarta post=140213201] Ogbeni na wa for you oh!!. Your teacher for school try oh!! even though he/she teach brick wall. So according to you, the usefulness of a government is by paying subsidies that will end up impoverishing her citizens even more, U don pass 14 so?I should be redirecting those statement at you ... I can't thank your teacher cos you don't even know brought about creation of govt, when you define democracy you notice people as more repetition cos it about people Across the world esp. Develop countries you wil see govt intervention in Basic needs of life to the citizen, healthcare, schools and majorly food .. Hence food can never be ur problem in Uk, Us, e.t.c it like govt oversubsidize if its not evil there why should subsidy be Evil according to govt in Nigeria. A not sustainable but we can sustain pilgrimage nd opulence within short time Yes corruption exists no doubt about that, but subsidies will only give more room to this same corruptionHere we go again, blaming " subsidy for " human defect" .. The fact that subsidy is not corruption coated in foreign nations till now means we can have a corruption free " subsidy" you can cure headache without cutting off ur head, thats my point. Have we tried to reform or restructure "subsidy route" big No. So your conclusion is baseless n invalid . DisCos are already using it as a yardstick , if you no be small pikin this thing nor suppose too hard for you to understandDo you know that even in america or uk, if there are no security measures in place, people wil just wana commit crimes for fond of it ... You see south africa using xenophobia to steal n loot shops my point, its Govt responsibility to have created advance security measures by now to disuade any antics of corruption. Disco no be issue, your govt neva do weytin dem suppose do nii . Should I be paying for the things you listed above and the government is still paying subsidies for these same thing, of what benefits is the so called subsidy to me then?this guy funny sha, which one be should i be paying, you are paying for those things and you are not getting cost reflective services, why you chose to be a cunny here doesnt add up to me, are you one of them the benefit of subsidy is not in service rather it in cost relief, discount to your financial burden. maybe you are a billionaire money na water but it matters to most Nigerians. Subsidy payment is not an investment in new infrastructure or maintenance, rather it is a bailout mechanism to cover massive commercial financial shortfalls within a broken, debt ridden supply chain.uncle i shame for you in short Subsidy cover the payment of "discounted balance" on actual cost to consumers book no hard na you no wan read nii. @ bailout 🤣 imagine Despite the huge subsidy projection about #1.2T for 2026, the funds merely patch up systemic leaks instead of expanding the power grid. I would prefer the government investing such amount in same sector, instead of using it to pay debts that her citizens stand to gain very little or nothing from.Here we go again, alaroye ... subsidy is not to patchup leaks ... what you dont know you dont know. Hence of subsidy is to take up the balance of " discounted billing to the people" and govt intentional do it to ease burden on households n businesses. Subsidy removal on fuel see how everything jump up in price The government still owes GenCos over ₦6.2T, gas suppliers over $1.3B. GenCos are complaining that they are paid as little as 10% of their actual invoices, as such they lack the money to maintain turbines or buy gas, forcing Nigeria’s available electricity to hover at a low 4,000 - 5,000 megawatts. Can't you see the subsidy is causing us more harm than good? These things no suppose too hard for person wey don pass 14 to understand na, ebabo.If Govt is not paying how is subsidy is the to be blame,. have you ever seen Govt ever complain in our history they dont have money to continue finance there opulence lifestyle, it as always being what benefit the people that they are always broke about , something as paying salary is now a campaign achievement The chose to owe Disco becos govt fail to effectively plan for it. Govt owe salaries is salary to be blamed ![]() We should be more concerned about how the government intends to utilise the funds saved from non subsidy paymentsPerhaps you are just one of them, the subsidy removal funds how have that benefited us today, is it not i have giving More Money to your Governors we hear as defence .. Our sacrifice/pain is it worth it .. I have given it to your governors You talk as if you dont even see All that as happen, do Nigerians have a say in Tinubu govt kini WE fé dá.. The questions we should be asking are; how will these funds be utilised, how do we hold DisCos, GenCos, and the government accountable, what cautionary, and incentive measures does the government intend implementing?They whine yourself, all the ones we hav ask down which one have they replied, even when they reply is a reply abi fight back ...we are in a situation We say what we wana say they Do what they want to do. shout from now til tomorrow PBAT wan open mouth wa and say subsidy is gone again without planning for the adverse effects? These should be our source of concern not it's removal.What will your " concern chronicle" change, electoral laws amended we raised concern, no be so dem rush am pass am, Tax reform we raised objective concern yet they rush to pass nd sign it If you dont learn from antecedents, or events, some adults do ![]() |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by anonimi: 7:25am On Aug 02 |
epainos:Why should we sit tight for subsidy removal that has failed to reduce debt burden and has failed to improve basic government services and utilities like education, healthcare, law & order, security etc? What is the wisdom in doing that for those who are not Stockholm syndrome sufferers ![]() https://www.nairaland.com/7815993/analogy-oppressor-foolish-citizens#125340351 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7WzbBqAWPfI Aug 29, 2023 Minister of Finance and Coordinating Minister for the Economy, Mr. Wale Edun made this known at the end of the inaugural Federal Executive Council meeting in Abuja. Mr. Edun said that the benefit of the subsidy removal will be plough back into various sectors to improve business environment for local and foreign investment. He added that with the increased revenue from subsidy removal, various palliatives have been made available to cushion its effect on a short, medium and long-term basis. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bn29b0SkCWU?si=s_-vTlCqSlykI0BX Ofunaofu: |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by Josywhyte: 9:41am On Aug 02 |
nairalanda1:Your perspective though |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by nairalanda1(m): 10:20am On Aug 02 |
Josywhyte:There is no subsidy though. You better read about it, and how it works |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by Jakarta: 11:51am On Aug 02 |
[quote author=reddingtonblack post=140213775][/quote]I don't want to write lengthy epistles in order not to make my response too long thereby making it more difficult for you to comprehend. According to you, the benefit of subsidy is "cost relief". Ogbeni look around you: what is the financial relief of a subsidised electricity tariff when you are spending #10 - 5k daily on petrol just to power your house? You think you are getting a discount, but you are paying double. You pay via the National Treasury (1.2T from the federation account) and still pay out of your pocket for generators, inverters, and prepaid units that give you an almost zero stable light. If you cannot see that this so called "discount" is a psychological trap designed to keep you quiet while the sector decays, then I pity the innocent teacher who truly wasted their time on a brick wall. Defending the current electricity subsidy is like pouring water in a basket and praising the government for buying more water The subsidy mechanism is the very headache; it removes the need for DisCos to become efficient. Why should a private DisCo invest its own capital into fixing and distributing meters, stopping energy theft, when they know the federal government will always write a trillion naira check? Subsidy protects corporate incompetence at the expense of the citizens. You dey argue to keep the very disease wey dey kill the patient. Doctor: That limb is cancerous, and it is getting rotten; we need to cut it off so it doesn't spread more. Patient: No, keep the rotten limb and give me subsidised painkillers. This will only lead to a catastrophic end. Your entire defence of the subsidy has now degenerated into: "Since the government will steal the savings anyway, let them just keep the subsidy" What kind of backward slave mentality is that? You dey use the corruption of PBAT and state governors as an excuse to support a broken economic policy, ogbeni you well so? Instead of holding those governors accountable, your brilliant solution is "Oya let's go back to the old scam, because we are too cowardly to fight the new one" Ogbeni, use that thing wey dey stay for head na!! You are complaining that they don't listen to our concerns, even if we shout from now till tomorrow. Bro, if you want to lay down and surrender to bad governance, do it quietly. Don't come online trying to wrap ur defeatism in a pseudo economic argument. The #1.2T subsidy projection is a monument to institutional failure. It keeps Nigeria trapped at a pathetic 4-5k megawatts, while South Africa, with a smaller population, generates over 50K megawatts. Let me know if you want me to ELI5 how subsidy should work in Nigeria, instead of the current open blanket Father Christmas approach our government is using |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by Skydiv: 1:56pm On Aug 02 |
reddingtonblack:Bro, I don't think you are getting the point that jakarta is trying to make. The current electricity subsidy will only cripple our power sector, not revive it. It is making DisCos very inefficient and lazy; imagine a child from a wealthy home whose parents use money to buy him grades in his exams, odds are that child will not want to read his books, because he believes his parent's money will give him the needed grades. But what if the parents say to the boy, Pass your exam in flying colours, and we will buy you a PS5. Yes, it will be difficult for the child initially, but with time, reading his book and aiming to get good grades will almost become a normal target for him with time. Discos are now seeing subsidy payments as free money and not wanting to invest in their business from their own pocket; as such, when the free money doesn't come, everything collapses. Let's use South Africa as a case study. First, the power companies invested in infrastructure (turbines, transformers, meters and all others); this should be their non negotiable responsibility from the onset. After all that, power is evenly distributed to all households, albeit at a very high cost which most poor homes couldn't afford. The government then came in and said ok being your government, this is what we will do to help you. First we will verify the truly poor homes, then we will help you in paying certain power unit e.g we will help you pay 60Kwh every month, anything beyond that will be paid by you. With such a system in place, the subsidy payments now look more targeted, the more customers on the grid, the more connected poor homes which will lead to even more guaranteed state backed sales. These one caps fit all open blanket subsidies Nigeria is practising are just a ticking time bomb that are guaranteed to explode. Nigeria DisCos are using subsidy to scam the Nigeria government and her citizens. |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by reddingtonblack: 2:41pm On Aug 02 |
[quote author=Skydiv post=140217507] Bro, I don't think you are getting the point that jakarta is trying to make. The current electricity subsidy will only cripple our power sector, not revive itI think i have ask ...what do you take subsidy is cut on actual cost, You mean subsidy negate " Profit ... Cos why will else wil you blame " subsidy instead of seeing DEBT is the problem. Let me ask Should Govt keep up to date with subsidy do you believe discos wil still be on shortfalls ... Its important we clear that 1st so we know what we are really discussing . It is making DisCos very inefficient and lazy; imagine a child from a wealthy home whose parents use money to buy him grades in his exams, odds are that H6ADYE will not want to read his books, because he believes his parent's money will give him the needed grades. But what if the parents say to the boy, Pass your exam in flying colours, and we will buy you a PS5. Yes, it will be difficult for the child initially, but with time, reading his book and aiming to get good grades will almost become a normal target for him with time.🤣🤣 You kmow what i find very funny ... these was how midnight professors were discrediting subsidy on fuel ... Postulating Nnpc wil be efficient, production will boom, competition, blah blah ...3yrs after howfar ?? If not dangote refinery, we for don see shege. Some of learn lessons from past, and some just never learn |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by Jakarta: 3:43pm On Aug 02 |
Skydiv:Ogbeni don't waste your time on the Hollodo uprising class prefect, one day his elder broda or a more learned fellow will go throgh his phone and see these posts, then dem go explain to am like atakara students. |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by Skydiv: 4:50pm On Aug 02 |
reddingtonblack:Yes if the government kept up to date with subsidy payments the discos will still experience massive financial shortfalls, because the subsidy does not negate profits rather it protects corporate inefficiency. This is because the subsidy and the sector's structural shortfalls are two completely separate failures. NERC statistics demonstrate why up to date payments cannot fix the underlying issues which are: 1. The DisCo Collection Leak: The subsidy is only designed to cover the tariff gap which is the difference between what it legally costs to make electricity and what the government allows consumers to pay. It does not cover the money lost when DisCos fail to collect bills from their own customers.The latest NERC commercial performance data reveals that DisCos have an average collection efficiency of just 78.95%. Meaning for every ₦100 worth of subsidized electricity distributed to homes, DisCos fail to collect ₦21.In some regions like Kaduna, the collection efficiency drops to a pathetic 45.81%. Even if the government covers its 52% portion of the bill perfectly, the DisCos will still experience a shortfall on the remaining 48% because they lack the technical capability to stop energy theft, meter bypasses, and unmetered billing. 2. Up to date payments do not buy infrastructure. Subsidy is a consumption discount, not a capital investment. It is calculated based on current energy usage. If the government pays it on time, that money goes directly toward paying gas suppliers and thermal plant operations just to keep the lights on for today. It does not provide extra cash to buy smart prepaid meters for the millions of unmetered households, repair the fragile national transmission grid, which suffered multiple total collapses in early 2026 which should be the responsibility of discos. You kmow what i find very funny ... these was how midnight professors were discrediting subsidy on fuel ... Postulating Nnpc wil be efficient, production will boom, competition, blah blah ...3yrs after howfar ??The reason the fuel subsidy removal felt like a failure is exactly the same reason the electricity subsidy must be removed. You are looking at the fuel crisis and learning the wrong lesson.The fuel subsidy removal didn't struggle because removing it was bad, it struggled because the government replaced a state run subsidy monopoly with a state run import monopoly (NNPC). They didn't actually create a free market. You just admitted it yourself "Dangote Refinery is the only thing saving us from seeing shege." Have you asked yourself Why? Because Dangote is a private, independent refinery operating on commercial, unsubsidized reality Dangote proves the entire point private capacity and real infrastructure solve problems, not government subsidy handouts. Let me explain fuel comparison and tie it back to electricity NNPC vs. DisCos: The same corrupt logic The "midnight professors" weren't wrong about economic principles, they underestimated the corruption of a state monopoly. For the first two years after subsidy removal, NNPC remained the sole importer of petrol because the government kept messing with the foreign exchange window. NNPC was running a hidden back door subsidy, racking up trillions in secret debts to international traders.The exact same thing is happening with electricity. The government is using the ₦1.2 trillion subsidy to fund a state controlled, broken national grid. If you keep the electricity subsidy, you are just protecting the "NNPC model" of the power sector allowing private DisCos and government transmission managers to hide their incompetence behind federal checks. |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by reddingtonblack: 6:51pm On Aug 02 |
[quote author=Skydiv post=140219072] Yes if the government kept up to date with subsidy payments the discos will still experience massive financial shortfalls, because the subsidy does not negate profits rather it protects corporate inefficiency.C'mon !! The fact that there are developed countries practicing subsidy nd none records corporate inefficiency is why i will discard your point Bro inefficiency in Nigeria is more of attitude, interest and human input " factor" not FUND in most cases esp. In govt space when subsidy was still on fuel, Many argued subsidy is why nnpc is underperforming, why refineries are not working, why govt cant build infrastructure they painted subsidy is why Nigeria wil enjoy cheaper fuel competition could bring ... I lie 3yrs down the line subsidy is gone, howfar ?? How efficient is Nnpc now Are our refineries now working ? Do you know we now run 3 budget concurrently we cant even fund one to 50% ..despite subsidy SO when our midnite professor kum with all analog to demonize subsidy, kill it, shoot it bury it ... Lets ask ourselves what have we gained after My broda you forget there are implications .. If you remove subsidy on power, Inflation will × 3 cost of production wil jump up, already Nigerians, businesses are choking for breath you guyz are so focus on eliminating "subsidy" buh in the room we have corruption chilling fine, subsidy will be buried, high revenue generated where there is no accountability ... Funds will be looted as usual then we will realise we have suffered for nothing again just like we are on Fuel Can you see govt give proper account of subsidy savings, is it the sacrifice worth it now, i have given it to your governors, imagine I see other things you wrote, but if you get my point, we wont need to go into all that ... More revenue will not foster efficiency cos we are a corrupt nation, more revenue means more to loot, ope ooo! Our problem is mentality, human factor ..not funds |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by Skydiv: 8:07pm On Aug 02*. Modified: 8:25pm On Aug 02 |
reddingtonblack:See how you cunningly avoided the underlying issues I raised after answering your question. You keep saying developed countries practice subsidies without corporate inefficiency. You are completely ignorant about how those countries operate. In the US and UK, the government does not give blank checks to private electricity companies to cover their debts or compensate for stolen power. They subsidize the consumer directly (through energy vouchers, tax credits and refunds, or low income welfare checks). The private power companies still have to collect 100% of their money from these customers, install smart meters everywhere, and maintain their grids perfectly to survive. In Nigeria, the subsidy goes straight to the top to bail out lazy, private DisCos that fail to meter households, fail to stop energy theft, fail to collect their own money from their customers. You cannot compare a structured Western welfare system to a parasitic Nigerian corporate bailout. Just to let you know, the cost of running diesel and petrol generators is currently three to four times higher than paying a full unsubsidized cost reflective electricity tariff. The subsidy is not saving businesses; it is keeping them trapped in a cycle of buying expensive fuel because the public grid is naturally dead. |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by reddingtonblack: 11:33pm On Aug 02 |
[quote author=Skydiv post=140220831]S ee how you cunningly avoided the underlying issues I raised after answering your question.You joined a conversation, b4 you i had maintained SUBSIDY is not the cause of ineffeciency, since we removed subsidy on fuel, is Nnpc efficient now, buh money is still missing and they can't give proper account .. Our production stil below optimal ...if not for Dangote refinery What you consider underline issues are skin surface issue to me, the real underline issues we must address 1st is A. Corruption B. Human factor/mentality That subsidy worked abroad is enough proof, subsidy can't be the demon You are completely ignorant about how those countries operate. In the US and UK, the government does not give blank checks to private electricity companies to cover their debts or compensate for stolen power.Gud ! What you just explained denote measures to mitigate " corruption" ... We have being shouting corruption ova 10yrs ... Tinubu brought reforms to ensure nigerian dont escape Tax, why cant we have such reform or restructuring that wil mitigate corruption in the power sector Why not try to run like Uk or Us 1st before you conclude ? They subsidize the consumer directly (through energy vouchers, tax credits and refunds, or low income welfare checks). The private power companies still have to collect 100% of their money from these customers, install smart meters everywhere, and maintain their grids perfectly to survive.You have just wondered into my point, there subsidy is loop proofed becos of how they structured it and on our subsidy is a big pothole because of how we structure it. therefore common sense dictate restructure 1st before other conclusions In Nigeria, the subsidy goes straight to the top to bail out lazy, private DisCos that fail to meter households, fail to stop energy theft, fail to collect their own money from their customers. You cannot compare a structured Western welfare system to a parasitic Nigerian corporate bailout.Stop saying bail out, except you dont know the definition of subsidy ... Govt subsidy consumers indirectly in Nigeria... they paid a % of your actual bills ... Bailout is what you give someone outside what they merit, govt no bailout discos ... they earn the money by theory Just to let you know, the cost of running diesel and petrol generators is currently three to four times higher than paying a full unsubsidized cost reflective electricity tariff.uncle no decieve yourself, subsidy or no subsidy WE don't have infrastructure or capacity to dole out stable electricity, our transmission network can't withstand stable electricity ...lets be realistic govt removing subsidy wont guarantee light to All .. the suriest outcome is Nigerians we pay higher for darkness The subsidy is not saving businesses; it is keeping them trapped in a cycle of buying expensive fuel because the public grid is naturally dead.how fuel subsidy removal placed out nd nnpc is stil inefficient and we are not seeing any competition even though professors argued it one merit to remove subsidy ... Upon this basis is why i find your projections invalid Base on whu we are, they will remove subsidy nd inefficiency go stil rock that sector ... Oil & power sector are in poisionous hands. |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by Skydiv: 5:22pm On Aug 03 |
reddingtonblack:You are completely missing the entire point: we cannot restructure the subsidy to be "loop proof" like the US or UK because a corrupt government will never willingly build a lock on its own ATM machine.You keep saying "let's restructure the subsidy route first and put security measures in place." You are arguing for a beautiful economic fantasy that does not exist in Nigeria. You cannot use the "human factor" as your entire defense, and then turn around and expect that same corrupt "human factor" to build an advanced, un-lootable system. Let's look at the hard truth of why your arguments fall apart when hit by reality: 1. You said the US and UK structured their subsidies to be loop proof, so we should just copy them. Do you know why their systems are loop proof? It is because they have universal metering, fully audited financial tracks, and an independent judiciary that instantly jails anyone who steals a single cent. In Nigeria, the electricity subsidy is a giant pothole because the government and private operators intentionally want it to be a pothole. They thrive in the chaos. They purposefully refuse to meter millions of households so they can continue estimated billing and manipulate consumption figures on paper to claim trillions in federal payouts. Expecting a system with over 50% unmetered consumers and a debt ridden chain to suddenly become "loop proof" is like trying to build a skyscraper on top of a swamp. 2. Why "Bailout" is the absolute correct word. You claim the government is not bailing out the DisCos and that they "earn the money by theory." Oga, forget theory and look at what is happening in practice.The subsidy does not just pay a percentage of your bill; it covers the commercial losses of private companies. When a private DisCo collects electricity from the grid and allows 30% of it to be stolen through illegal connections or lost through broken cables, the government uses the subsidy to clear that debt. In a normal capitalist market, if a private company cannot collect its own revenue, it goes bankrupt and another competent company buys it out. But in Nigeria, the subsidy acts as a permanent commercial bailout that shields these private DisCos from bankruptcy, allowing them to remain lazy and incompetent forever. You are literally defending the use of public funds to protect private corporate failure. You keep chanting, "Subsidy is gone on fuel, yet NNPC is still inefficient and refineries are not working!"Exactly! You are proving my point for me without you knowing! Why is NNPC still inefficient? Because the government refused to let go of its monopoly. They kept NNPC as the sole importer, continued manipulating the foreign exchange, and ran a secret, backdoor subsidy that ruined the national treasury. But look at what happened the moment a truly independent, private entity stepped into the ring the Dangote Refinery. The entire corrupt monopoly of the NNPC began to shatter. This proves that the solution to corruption is not to keep feeding a state controlled subsidy; the solution is to completely smash the monopoly and allow open, private competition. With the current subsidy structure, we are only paying higher for darkness. You said removing the subsidy won't guarantee light and will only make Nigerians pay higher for darkness. Let's do the actual arithmetic of your daily life: Right now, because of this fake subsidy that keeps the grid broke, you are already paying the highest price for darkness on earth. We are spending billions of naira collectively every single day on petrol, diesel, generator maintenance, and inverters just to get basic electricity. The cost of generating our own power with a generator is 300% higher than paying a full, unsubsidized, cost reflective tariff.When you remove the subsidy, break up the transmission monopoly, and allow states to run independent grids (like the Aba Geometric model which is successfully delivering stable power without federal subsidy intervention), the market stabilizes. we stop buying fuel for generators, and our overall monthly spending on energy actually drops. You say the oil and power sectors are in poisonous hands. We both agree 100% on that. But your solution to dealing with poisonous hands is to keep handing them over ₦1trillion subsidy knife to stab the economy.As long as that subsidy exists, those poisonous hands have a multi trillion naira cover to explain away the darkness. When you kill the subsidy completely and force a cost reflective market, you strip them of their excuses. The DisCos will either have to deliver stable power to collect their money from consumers, or they will collapse and let competent investors take over. This is what happened with the state owned NITEL. Stop begging for a "subsidized cushion" inside a burning house. Kill the subsidy, break the monopoly, and let real infrastructure take over, class dismissed. |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by Leepeak(m): 2:05pm On Aug 04 |
Jakarta:Let’s keep it factual: Band A was designed for 20+ hours at a cost-reflective rate. That works for businesses and high-income areas. But a blanket removal of subsidy across a population where 60%+ live in multidimensional poverty isn't sustainable either. True reform isn't just throwing citizens into un-subsidized rates; it's expanding grid capacity and raising living standards so people can actually afford the power." "Imagine bragging about paying ₦209/unit in an economy where millions earn less than ₦100k. Nobody said petrol gen is cheap; the point is that policy must match reality, not just middle-class comfort. Calling people 'olodo' while confusing individual affordability with national economic policy just shows who is actually lacking perspective." So technically who be olodo uprising ![]() |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by Jakarta: 3:37pm On Aug 04 |
Leepeak:Ogbeni you are not getting it hence my use of hollodo uprising statement. The current subsidy structure is causing more harm than good to the same multi dimensional poverty people, awuf dey run belle is very true in this subsidy case. The people that really need this subsidy are not being targeted, rather it is the Discos who are using them to cash out. Imagine a father paying school fees for a child who is not attending school, but the school continue collecting school fees from the father every term, that is what is happening with electricity subsidy. Discos can't meter all their customers, can't collect all their money from those customers who owe them, can't check and punish those who are using their electricity for free all because dem put hope for subsidy payment wey government wan give them.That thing wey we dey call subsidy Na bailout and cash out format to discos. Not until the government stops it, remove monopoly, and allow the forces of demand and supply to dictate the true cost of electricity, our power sector no go ever work even if dem pay ₦10T subsidy for electricity. Go through @Skydiv posts on this thread to understand how subsidy is the main chain that is dragging our power sector backwards. |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by Leepeak(m): 4:33pm On Aug 04 |
Jakarta:Professor of economy/olodo uprising "Bro, I get the economic theory you're pushing—the classic 'let market forces dictate prices and remove government distortion.' And yes, everybody knows the old subsidy regime had leakages and that DisCos have efficiency issues. But your argument relies on a **massive economic fallacy**: treating electricity like a normal commercial good (like shoes or phones) instead of a **socially essential infrastructure Here is why your logic falls apart in real-world policy: Electricity is a Natural Monopoly, Not a Free Market You mentioned 'forces of demand and supply' and 'removing monopoly.' That shows a basic misunderstanding of power distribution. You cannot have 5 different DisCos running parallel high-voltage cables and transformers down the same street to create competition. Distribution is a *natural monopoly* by physical design. Without government regulation and price caps (or targeted subsidies), a private monopoly will simply extract maximum profit from captive consumers who have zero alternative choices. The Band A Reality: The Subsidy IS Already Targeted You claimed the subsidy isn't targeted. That’s literally the entire point of the Band A tariff migration! The government intentionally removed subsidies for Band A users (who are mostly higher-income areas and commercial hubs receiving 20+ hours of power) precisely to redirect fiscal support toward lower-band consumers who cannot absorb a 200%+ price shock overnight. That is targeted intervention. Removing Subsidies Without Purchasing Power = Mass Default, Not Efficiency In pure economics, if a population suffering from multi-dimensional poverty is exposed to full cost-reflective tariffs without income growth, they don't 'adjust to demand and supply'—they simply disconnect, steal power, or default. DisCos won't magically collect 100% of revenue just because subsidy stops; their collection losses will actually spike because poorer households literally cannot afford ₦200+/kWh. Global Precedent: Even Advanced Economies Subsidize Power Show me one developing nation that achieved 100% electrification purely on un-subsidized, free-market tariffs without government capital intervention or targeted social tariffs. Even the UK and EU spent tens of billions of Euros in energy subsidies during the recent inflation crisis to protect households and businesses from price collapse. Bottom line: Nobody is saying DisCos shouldn't be metered or held accountable for performance—they absolutely should, and the NERC needs to enforce strict regulatory penalties on them. But mistaking regulatory failure for subsidy failure, and demanding total market shock for impoverished citizens, isn't economic wisdom—it's theoretical dogma that ignores real-world poverty dynamics." You talked about "removing monopoly" in power distribution, which reveals dat u doesn't understand that distribution grids are physical *natural monopolies* (you can't build 3 sets of power poles on one road). Professor even wealthy, free-market Western countries subsidize electricity during economic stress. |
| Re: FG To End Electricity Subsidy From 2027 by Jakarta: 5:35pm On Aug 04*. Modified: 6:05pm On Aug 04 |
Leepeak:Ogbeni you no fit even edit your AI epistles, so true true you be really class prefect for Hollodo uprising class? See how ur village people use AI take embarrass you. For your information electricity is not a natural monopoly, generating it can be very competitive you dey hear me? Western countries don't subsidise electricity by writing fat checks to electricity distribution companies, their customers makes the payments, which means distribution companies must first render the service , then collect their money from these customers for the service rendered, not the government giving them fat checks, that is called a targeted subsidy not the bailout for discos inefficiencies you call subsidy here. There are people using band A and they are not paying for it, discos are then shifting the losses from those not paying to unmetered Band B, C, D, and E users which the government now has to pay. Since December last year band E users in my street have not witnessed electricity due to a vandalised armoured cable. They raised ₦4.5M to fix it, 3 days later a break in attempt was made, now they are trying to raise ₦500k to fix the issue caused by the break in. But Discos steadily dey bring estimated bill every month, and government go still pay subsidy for these bills, for light wey people no use, does it makes sense to you? Government should first remove subsidy and let Discos perform their core responsibilities, which are efficiently distributing electricity (installing poles, transformers, electric cables, etc), metering everybody, strictly monitoring for energy losses due to cable breaks, energy theft etc, all with the sole aim of receiving true cost reflective tariffs. Any Disco or Genco that don't have the financial capacity to do all these will be sold or merged to those that can (ogbeni Na weytin I mean by breaking monopoly be this). After all this can the government come in and say ok, Nigerians this is what we will do for you, we will give each household or very vulnerable and poor people electricity payment incentives inform of vouchers, tax reliefs, buying you a fixed amount of electricity units monthly, weekly, yearly, or however the case may be, only then can the subsidy be targeted to those who truly need it. Not the open market father Christmas approach we are using currently, skydiv explain these things well even pass me, go read him posts here make you ask questions for where you no understand and stop being an hollodo. |
FG To End Electricity Subsidy In 2027 • ADC Constitution Disqualifies Peter Obi From 2027 Presidential Race • We'll Deduct ₦242.53 Billion Fuel Subsidy From FAAC This Month - NNPC • 2 • 3 • 4
Nigeria, South Africa Agree On Visa-free Regime • What Is Your Favorite Quote From A Nigerian? • TCN Reconnects Aba Power Electric, Kaduna & Kano DISCOs, Gives 60-Days Grace

in short Subsidy cover the payment of "discounted balance" on actual cost to consumers 