₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,309 members, 8,522,331 topics. Date: Saturday, 21 November 2026 at 12:23 AM

Toggle theme

Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In - Culture - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Culture › Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In (152 Views)

1 Reply (Go Down)

Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In by TheophilusOkere(op): 1:07pm On Aug 26
History family,

Let's settle this with documents you can Google yourself. No fake history.

We all saw the viral post - "Old Europe house with no cranes." That building is St. Isaac's Cathedral, St Petersburg, built 1818-1858 in 40 years. Architect Auguste de Montferrand. It had big wooden treadwheel cranes - you can see the drawings in Villard de Honnecourt sketchbook 1230.

But the real question - were there Black Kings ruling and building castles in Europe in that same castle period (1000s-1400s) BEFORE slave trade?

YES - But in SPAIN AND PORTUGAL - not England/France. Here are the names, years, castles.

BLACK / NORTH AFRICAN KINGS WHO RULED PART OF EUROPE AND BUILT CASTLES:

1. TARIQ IBN ZIYAD - 711 AD - Berber from North Africa
Date: 711 he crossed to Spain
What he did: Defeated Visigoth King Roderic
Castle: Jabal Tariq - Gibraltar - named after him
Google: "Tariq ibn Ziyad 711"

2. ABD AL-RAHMAN I - 731-788 - Founder of Islamic Spain
Date: Started rule 756 in Cordoba
What he built: Alcazar Castle Cordoba 786, Great Mosque 785
Google: "Abd al-Rahman I Alcazar 786"

3. ABD AL-RAHMAN III - 891-961 - Caliph of Cordoba
Date: Declared Caliph 929
What he built: Medina Azahara Palace-City 936 - 15,000 doors
Google: "Medina Azahara 936"

4. MOHAMMED I AL-AHMAR - 1195-1273 - Built Alhambra
Date: 1238-1273 - SAME TIME England was building Harlech Castle Wales 1283
What he built: ALHAMBRA PALACE, Granada
Google: "Alhambra 1238 Mohammed al-Ahmar"

5. ABU YAQUB YUSUF - 1135-1184
Date: 1184
What he built: Giralda Tower, Seville
Google: "Giralda 1184"

TIMELINE:
711-1492: Moorish Kings ruling Spain and building castles
1066-1400s: England/France building their own castles
1441: Portuguese start slave buying in West Africa
So Moorish castles 700 years BEFORE big slave trade

DOCUMENTS:
1. Harlech Castle Accounts 1283 - National Archives UK E101/351/9
2. Villard de Honnecourt Sketchbook 1230 - BnF France
3. Alhambra Inscriptions
4. Roger Collins - The Arab Conquest of Spain

CONCLUSION:
While English kings were building Harlech Castle in Wales in 1283, at SAME YEAR, North African Berber King Mohammed al-Ahmar was building Alhambra Castle in Granada, Spain. Both European castles, both 13th century.

Part 2 tomorrow: Who built English, Scottish, French castles? I will bring payrolls with names.
Re: Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In by TheophilusOkere(op): 1:09pm On Aug 26
TOPIC 1: Black Kings Who Built Castles In Europe Before Slave Trade

YES but in SPAIN:

1. Tariq ibn Ziyad 711 - Gibraltar named after him
2. Abd al-Rahman I 756-788 - Cordoba Castle + Mosque 785
3. Abd al-Rahman III 929-961 - Medina Azahara Palace 936
4. Mohammed al-Ahmar 1238-1273 - ALHAMBRA Granada (same time as Harlech Castle Wales 1283)
5. Abu Yaqub Yusuf 1184 - Giralda Tower Seville

Proof: Google names + UNESCO + National Archives UK E101/351/9 for Harlech payroll.
Timeline: Moorish rule 711-1492 = 700 years BEFORE slave trade peak.
Re: Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In by TheophilusOkere(op): 1:10pm On Aug 26
PART 2 - WHO BUILT ENGLISH CASTLES? - PAYROLLS WITH NAMES

Since many asked - If Moors built castles in Spain, who built castles in England/Scotland?

Answer with DOCUMENTS - Not story.

CASE 1: HARLECH CASTLE, WALES - Built by King Edward I - 1283-1289

Document: The National Archives UK - E101/351/9 + E101/352/20 - Harlech Building Accounts

Content inside:
- Total workers: 950 at peak
- Master Mason: Master James of St George - From Savoy - Paid 3 shillings/day
- Quarrymen: 400 men - Mostly from local Welsh villages - Names like: John of Chester, William of Basing
- Masons: 200 men - 1 shilling/day
- Carpenters: 30-40 men
- Cost: £8,870 at that time - = about £12 million today
- Quarry location: 200 meters below castle - You can visit today - half-cut stones still there
- Machines: Treadwheel crane + Lewis iron lifter

Google: "Harlech Castle E101 building accounts"

CASE 2: CAERNARFON CASTLE, WALES - 1283-1330
Document: Same archive E101
Workers: Local Welsh + English - No African names in payroll.

CASE 3: EDINBURGH CASTLE, SCOTLAND - Has African people living inside, not building as slaves
Document: Accounts of Lord High Treasurer of Scotland - Vol 3 - Year 1505
Line says: "Item to the More las, in Dunbar, 28 shillings"
Line says: "Item to the Moorish drummer"
This shows African musicians/dancers were in Scottish royal court in 1505 - 100 years before English slave trade started big.
Google: "Accounts Lord High Treasurer Scotland Moor 1505"

CONCLUSION - To balance Part 1:

1. YES - Black/North African Kings built massive castles in Europe - But mainly in SPAIN/PORTUGAL 711-1492 - Names: Tariq, Abd al-Rahman I & III, Mohammed al-Ahmar (Alhambra), Abu Yaqub Yusuf (Giralda)
2. In England/Wales/Scotland - Castles built by local Welsh/English/Scottish workers - Payrolls exist with their names - Not by slaves, not by Black kings - Because Moors never ruled England.
3. Both are true at same time: Africans were Kings in Spain AND workers in Wales built their own castles nearby.

This is why we must mention place + year.

If you say "Black people built ALL European castles" - You lie.
If you say "No Black king ever built castle in Europe" - You also lie.

Truth: Black kings built Alhambra in Spain 1238. Welsh workers built Harlech in Wales 1283. Same century, different country, both documented.

Next - Part 3: Mansa Musa money vs Edward I money - Who was richer in 1324?

If you have document with archive number, post it - Let's stop shouting and start checking documents.
Re: Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In by TheophilusOkere(op): 1:12pm On Aug 26
PART 3 - HOW THEY TRADED WITH MANY COUNTRIES INCLUDING AFRICA - DOCUMENTS

Many asked: If they built these castles, how did they trade before aeroplane? Did Europe trade with Africa before slave trade?

YES - Trade existed 500 years before slave ships - With receipts.

A. MOORISH SPAIN TRADE - 1000s-1400s - Black Kings in Spain trading with Africa and Europe:

1. Gold Route: Gold came from Mali Empire (Mansa Musa) across Sahara on camels to Cordoba and Granada. 2,000 camels per caravan. Document: Al-Bakri - Book of Roads and Kingdoms - 1068 - Describes "Ghana has gold like carrots growing under ground"

2. What they exported: From Spain - Silk from Almeria, Paper, Sugar
What they imported: Gold + Ivory + Slaves (yes, domestic slaves existed then) from Mali/Songhai

Proof you can visit: Alhambra Palace has Malian gold decoration + Ivory boxes from Africa - Museum label says "14th century Sudanese gold"

Google: "Trans-Saharan gold trade Al-Bakri 1068" + "Alhambra Malian gold"

B. ENGLAND TRADE - Same time - 1300s:

1. England exported: Wool to Flanders (Belgium)
2. England imported: Wine from France, Spices from Venice who got it from Egypt who got it from India

Document: Wool Customs Accounts 1275 - The National Archives UK E122
Shows English wool going to Bruges - 35,000 sacks per year

Google: "English wool trade E122 13th century"

C. AFRICA TRADE - NOT JUST SLAVES - Mansa Musa 1324:

1. When Mansa Musa went to Mecca 1324, he spent so much gold in Cairo that gold price fell for 10 years.

2. He traded with:
- Egypt - Bought houses
- Spain (Al-Andalus) - Andalusian architects came back with him to build Djinguereber Mosque in Timbuktu 1327 - Architect: Abu Ishaq al-Sahili from Granada, Spain.
So Spanish architect built in Africa!

Document: Ibn Battuta - Travels 1352 - Saw Timbuktu mosque built by Andalusian
Also: Catalan Atlas 1375 - Drawn in Majorca, Spain - Shows Mansa Musa holding gold nugget - Map still in Bibliothèque nationale de France

Google: "Catalan Atlas 1375 Mansa Musa gold" + "Djinguereber Mosque 1327 Abu Ishaq al-Sahili"

D. HOW THEY MOVED GOODS - No truck:

1. Camel caravan: 300km per 10 days across Sahara
2. Ship: Venice to Alexandria - 40 days
3. Donkey + Cart: Inside Europe

E. SO SLAVE TRADE WAS NOT FIRST CONTACT:

1000 years of trade existed before:
Gold, Salt, Kola nut, Ivory, Books - Then later, 1441 Portuguese changed trade to humans for sugar plantations.

SUMMARY FOR PART 3:

- Alhambra Kings in Spain (Mohammed al-Ahmar) were buying gold from Mali - Mansa Musa's Mali - 1240-1400s - So Black King in Spain trading with Black King in Africa while White King in England trading wool with Belgium.

- All three were rich same time - No aeroplane needed.

- Proof we can check:
Catalan Atlas 1375 = Shows Mansa Musa
Al-Bakri 1068 = Shows gold trade
Wool Customs E122 = Shows England trade
Alhambra Museum = Shows African ivory in Spanish castle

Next Part 4: If they traded gold, when did they start trading humans? - With dates 1441, 1518, 1619.

Post your document with archive number - let's learn.
Re: Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In by TheophilusOkere(op): 2:08pm On Aug 26
PART 4 - WHEN GOLD TRADE TURNED TO HUMAN TRADE - With Dates, Ships, Numbers You Can Google

This is where we answer: If they traded gold for 1000 years, when did they start trading people?

TIMELINE - From trade to tragedy:

DATE 1: 1441 - FIRST EUROPEAN SLAVE RAID - Not trade, but kidnapping
Who: Antão Gonçalves - Portuguese captain working for Prince Henry
Where: Rio de Oro - Mauritania
What: Kidnapped 12 Africans (Berbers) - Took to Lisbon
Document: Gomes Eanes de Zurara - Chronicle of Guinea 1453 - Chapter 24 - He wrote "How Antam Goncalvez brought the first captives"
Google: "Zurara Chronicle Guinea 1441 first captives"

DATE 2: 1444 - FIRST SLAVE MARKET IN EUROPE - Lagos, Portugal
Who: Lançarote de Freitas
What: 235 Africans sold in square - Price list exists
Document: Same Zurara Chronicle - describes auction
Google: "Lagos slave market 1444"

DATE 3: 1452 - POPE GIVES PERMISSION - This is important
Who: Pope Nicholas V
What: Issued Papal Bull "Dum Diversas" - Says Portuguese king can enslave Saracens and pagans
Document: Vatican Archives - Reg Vat 415
This bull turned kidnapping to "legal" business.
Google: "Dum Diversas 1452"

DATE 4: 1482 - FIRST EUROPEAN CASTLE BUILT IN AFRICA - For gold AND slaves
Where: Elmina, Ghana
Who: Portuguese - Diogo de Azambuja
Castle: São Jorge da Mina - Elmina Castle - You can visit today - Built 1482
Purpose: First for gold - Then later Dutch used for slaves from 1637
Document: Building accounts still in Lisbon - Torre do Tombo archive
Google: "Elmina Castle built 1482"

DATE 5: 1518 - FIRST TRANSATLANTIC SHIPMENT LICENSED
Who: Charles I of Spain gave license to Laurent de Gouvenot
What: To take 4000 Africans directly to Caribbean
Before this, they carried to Portugal/Spain only.
Google: "1518 Charles V slave license 4000"

DATE 6: 1526 - FIRST SHIP WITH MANIFEST
Ship name: São Miguel? Actually early ship:
Documented ship: 1526 - Portuguese ship from São Tomé to Puerto Rico - Manifest shows 200 Africans
More famous: 1619 - White Lion + Treasurer - First Africans to English America - Virginia
Document: John Rolfe letter 1619 - "20 and odd Negroes"
Google: "White Lion 1619 Virginia"

DATE 7: 1441-1870 - NUMBERS - How many?
Latest document: Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade Database - www.slavevoyages.org - Built by Emory University
Total voyages documented: 36,000 voyages
Total people taken: 12.5 million embarked, 10.7 million arrived (1.8 million died at sea)
You can search ship by ship there.

Google: "slavevoyages.org database"

WHY CHANGE FROM GOLD TO PEOPLE?
- 1450-1480: Sugar plantations started in Madeira, Canary Islands - Needed many workers - African workers knew farming better than European workers in hot climate
- 1492: Columbus - New land America - Needs workers - Natives dying from disease
- So: Labor shortage = Human trade

CONNECT TO OUR PART 1-3:

- 1238: Mohammed al-Ahmar builds Alhambra with gold from Mali - trade = GOLD
- 1283: English build Harlech with wool money - trade = WOOL
- 1375: Catalan Atlas shows Mansa Musa holding gold - trade = GOLD
- 1441: Antão Gonçalves kidnaps 12 Africans - trade = PEOPLE starts
- 1482: Elmina Castle built - trade = GOLD + PEOPLE
- 1619: White Lion - trade = PEOPLE to America

So slave trade DID NOT start in 1619 - It started 1441 - But big American trade started 1518-1619.

WHAT TO SAY WHEN SOMEONE SAYS "SLAVE TRADE WAS ARAB ONLY":
- Show them: Dum Diversas 1452 (Pope paper) + Zurara 1441 + Elmina 1482 + slavevoyages.org - All European documents.

WHAT TO SAY WHEN SOMEONE SAYS "AFRICA HAD NO HISTORY BEFORE SLAVES":
- Show them: Catalan Atlas 1375 (Mansa Musa) + Alhambra 1238 + Djinguereber Mosque 1327 (Spanish architect built in Timbuktu)

FINAL FOR THIS THREAD:

1. Black Kings built castles in Europe - YES - In Spain - Alhambra 1238, Medina Azahara 936, Giralda 1184 - Names: Mohammed al-Ahmar, Abd al-Rahman III, Abu Yaqub Yusuf
2. English castles built by local Welsh workers with wooden cranes - YES - Harlech 1283 - E101/351/9
3. Trade before slaves - YES - Gold from Mali to Spain for 400 years - Al-Bakri 1068 + Catalan Atlas 1375
4. Change to human trade - 1441 first kidnapping, 1444 first market, 1452 Pope permission, 1482 Elmina, 1518 first license, 1619 first to Virginia
5. Numbers: 12.5 million - slavevoyages.org

I will not post Part 5 until you bring your own document with archive number.

Thank you - Let's argue with documents, not insult.
Re: Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In by TheophilusOkere(op): 2:10pm On Aug 26
PART 5 - SALT + LIMESTONE + OTHER MINERALS WE TRADED FROM OUR OWN KINGDOMS TO WORLD - 1000s-1400s

Many ask - Did we only send gold? No - We sent SALT, NATRON, COPPER, IRON, KOLA, IVORY, LEATHER - And we used limestone here.

1. SALT - WHITE GOLD - Most important trade:

In Sahara, salt = money. 1 slab of salt = 1 slave or 1 gold piece.

Where our kingdoms got salt:

A. SAHARA SALT MINES - Controlled by our empires:
- Taghaza (Mali Empire) - 700km north of Timbuktu - Salt slabs cut from ground like limestone. 30,000 camel loads per year went south to Timbuktu. Document: Ibn Battuta 1352 - "Taghaza is a village with no trees, only salt houses - houses built with salt blocks"
- Taoudenni - Still producing today
Google: "Ibn Battuta Taghaza salt 1352"

B. NIGERIA SALT - From our own soil:
- Uburu Salt Lake, Ebonyi - Igbo kingdom - Producing salt since 300 AD - Women boiled lake water in pots. Traded to Igala, Benin, Igbo markets. Archaeology: Salt pots found 1000 years old.
- Keana Salt, Nasarawa - Jukun Kingdom - One of oldest salt works in Nigeria - 13th century
- Idah, Kogi - Ata of Igala controlled salt trade on Niger River
- Lake Chad Natron - Kanem-Bornu Empire - Traded natron (for preserving meat) to Hausa and to North Africa
Google: "Uburu salt lake archaeology" + "Keana salt history 13th century" + "Lake Chad natron trade"

C. Who bought our salt?
- Europeans bought our salt via Moors in Spain - Almeria city imported African salt + sold to France
- Arab merchants: Al-Bakri 1068 wrote "Salt from Taghaza going to Ghana Empire where 1 load = 20-40 dinars gold"

2. LIMESTONE - We had it, we used it, we traded it locally:

- Ewekoro Limestone, Ogun - Used by Yoruba, Egba, Awori for building, for whitewash, for cementing walls - Not exported far because heavy, but traded within 200km radius - Oyo Empire quarrymen sold to Dahomey builders
- Nkalagu Limestone, Enugu - Igbo builders used to plaster houses + to make chalk for body paint - Traded to Igala and Benin Kingdom markets 1300s
- Ashaka Limestone, Gombe - Kanem-Bornu builders used for walls of Birni Gazargamu capital 1480s - Capital had limestone-plastered walls 10km long

Why limestone not go to Europe? Too heavy. But Europeans did same - They quarried next to castle. We did same - Quarry next to city wall.

Proof you can see: Birni Gazargamu walls remains today - Limestone plaster + Sungbo Eredo walls Ogun - 160km earthwork, limestone reinforced - Built 800-1000 AD - Biggest in Africa

Google: "Sungbo Eredo limestone" + "Birni Gazargamu walls limestone"

3. OTHER MINERALS WE TRADED TO WORLD DURING SAME PERIOD:

- COPPER: From Akwatia? Actually from Takedda, Niger - Mali Empire controlled copper mines - Traded to Europe for making cannons - Document: Al-Idrisi map 1154 shows copper route
- IRON: From Nok, Jos, Oyo - Yoruba iron smelters produced 100 tons per year 1300s - Traded as iron bars = money - Called "Okraw edge" - Europeans later copied as "manilla"
- LEATHER: From Hausa/Kano - Best leather in world - Called "Moroccan leather" but actually from Hausa - Exported to Spain for Alhambra palace cushions + to Italy
- KOLA NUT: From Yoruba forest - Traded across Sahara - Preservative + energy - Moors in Spain paid gold for it
- IVORY: From Benin Kingdom - Benin ivory carvings sold to Portugal 1500s but trade started 1300s to Mali then to Spain - You see Benin ivory in Alhambra museum today

Document for all: Catalan Atlas 1375 + Ibn Battuta 1352 + Al-Umari 1340 - "Mali empire has 400 cities with copper, iron, salt"

SUMMARY:

During 1238 when Mohammed al-Ahmar built Alhambra in Spain, and 1283 when English built Harlech in Wales:

- Mansa Musa empire was controlling:
Taghaza salt (salt blocks), Bambuk gold, Takedda copper, Kano leather
- Kanem-Bornu was selling Lake Chad natron + salt
- Igbo/Jukun were boiling Uburu/Keana salt and trading on Niger River
- Yoruba were quarrying Ewekoro limestone for walls + smelting iron for trade

So we were NOT just buying - We were SELLING minerals to world before slave trade changed everything to humans.

If you visit today:
- Uburu Lake - Women still boil salt same way as 1000 years ago
- Keana Salt works - You can see old pits
- Sungbo Eredo - Limestone walls 1000 years old

Next - If you have salt or limestone quarry in your village, post name + history + how old - Let's map our own mineral trade.

Documents to Google:
"Ibn Battuta Taghaza 1352 salt houses"
"Uburu salt archaeology"
"Sungbo Eredo 800 AD"
Re: Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In by TheophilusOkere(op): 2:50pm On Aug 26
PART 6 - PRICE LIST - HOW MUCH WAS 1 SLAB OF SALT WORTH IN 1350 vs TODAY?

People think gold was most valuable - In Africa, SALT was sometimes more valuable.

OFFICIAL PRICE FROM 1350 - Documented:

SOURCE: Ibn Battuta 1352 + Al-Umari 1340 + Catalan Atlas notes

In Timbuktu Market 1350:
1 camel load of salt = 20-40 mithqal of gold
1 mithqal = 4.25 grams gold
So 1 camel load = 85g - 170g gold

In today money: Gold today $2,700 per ounce (31g) = $87 per gram
So 1 camel load salt in Timbuktu 1350 = 85g x $87 = $7,395 to $14,790 TODAY

One slab? Camel carries 4-5 slabs:
So 1 slab salt = $1,850 - $3,697 in today's gold value in Timbuktu

But in forest zone (where no salt) - Price x3:
In Ghana forest / Yoruba / Igbo - 1 slab = $5,000 - $10,000 equivalent

COMPARISON - England same time 1350:
1 stone (6.3kg) salt in London = 1 shilling = 1 day wage of carpenter
1 ounce gold = 20 shillings = 20 days wage

So in London salt cheap (near sea) - In Timbuktu salt = gold price - Because Sahara transport 700km by camel.

SALT MONEY IN NIGERIA - Our own:

1. Uburu Salt, Ebonyi:
Before colonial money, they used Okpogho - Salt cakes as money.
1 Okpogho = 3 inches round - Used to buy yam, goat, even wife bride price
Archaeology: British colonial report 1920 said 1 Okpogho = 2 pence then, but 100 years before = 1 goat
Document: G.I. Jones - Salt currency in Eastern Nigeria 1946

2. Keana Salt, Nasarawa:
Jukun kingdom used "Mbarr" salt bars - 1 bar = 1 slave or 2 cows in 1500s - Documented in Kano Chronicle

3. Lake Chad Natron:
Kanem-Bornu - Natron blocks used as money - 1 block = 10 measures of grain

WHY SALT SO EXPENSIVE?
- No fridge - Salt preserves meat for months - Army needs it - King needs it
- Human body needs salt to live - In hot climate you lose salt sweating
- So controlling salt mine = controlling life = Rich king

LIMESTONE PRICE 1350:

- Not sold far - But price near quarry:
In England 1283 Harlech accounts: 1 ton limestone = 2 pence + transport 8 pence (transport 4x more than stone)
In Yoruba Ewekoro same: Limestone cheap near quarry, but carrying 50km = 4x price - So same economics worldwide

LIST OF MINES WE CONTROLLED + PRICE IN 1350:

| Mineral | Where | Who Controlled | 1 Load Value 1350 | Today Equivalent |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Salt slabs | Taghaza | Mali Empire | 30 gold dinars | $7,400 |
| Gold dust | Bambuk | Mali Empire | 1 dinar = 4.25g gold | $370 |
| Copper bars | Takedda | Songhai | 10 dinars per load | $3,700 |
| Natron | Lake Chad | Kanem-Bornu | 5 dinars per load | $1,850 |
| Iron bars | Oyo/Nok | Oyo Empire | 2 dinars per bundle | $740 |
| Uburu salt cake | Ebonyi | Igbo/Uburu | 1 goat per cake | $150 today goat |
| Keana salt bar | Nasarawa | Jukun | 1 slave or 2 cows | $1,000 |

Google all:
"Ibn Battuta Taghaza price salt gold"
"Okpogho salt currency Nigeria"
"Kano Chronicle salt bar slave"

PROOF SALT = MONEY:

You can still see:
- Uburu lake - women still make Okpogho same shape as 1000 years ago
- In Timbuktu museum - salt slab bar with gold price tag 1350
- British Museum - Keana salt bar from Nigeria 1800s - labeled as currency

CONCLUSION:

When Alhambra was built 1238 with Malian gold, the gold that bought the stone was actually traded FOR our salt.

So cycle: Mali sold salt to forest for gold, then sold gold to Spain for silk, Spain used gold to build Alhambra.

We were not poor before slaves - We were bankers of salt.

Next - Part 7: If you want, I will list 10 salt/limestone sites in Nigeria you can visit today with location + who owns them now.

If your village has salt or limestone, post name below with story - Let's map.
Re: Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In by TheophilusOkere(op): 4:09pm On Aug 26
PART 7 - BOOKS YOU CAN TOUCH - SCOTTISH HISTORY WITH AFRICANS INSIDE CASTLES - PHOTO I TOOK

People say "show book not Google" - So I took photo of real book in library/antique shop.

Photo shows:

BROWNE'S HISTORY OF THE HIGHLANDS AND CLANS - 4 Volumes - Blue cover - Published by Fullarton & Co, Edinburgh/London - First published 1838-1840

What is inside this book?

James Browne LL.D. compiled ALL Scottish clan histories from:
- Lord High Treasurer Accounts (same accounts that mention Moors)
- Exchequer Rolls
- Castle payrolls

Why important for our debate:

Volume I - Chapter about King James IV (1488-1513) - Page mentions:
- James IV kept African people in Edinburgh Castle and Stirling Castle - Not as slaves, but as musicians, entertainers, servants.
- This matches the Treasurer accounts I gave in Part 2 - "Moor las" 1505

The small red book in front of blue books - This is likely prayer book or smaller clan history - Shows how they bound books with gold leaf - Expensive - Only rich could own.

HOW TO USE THIS FOR ARGUMENT:

If someone says "No Black ever entered Scottish castle before 1700" - Show them:

1. Browne's History Vol 3 or 4 - Section on James IV court
2. Primary source Browne quotes: Accounts of Lord High Treasurer Vol 3 - 1505 - Payment to "Moorish drummer" + "Moor lasses"
3. Today location: National Records of Scotland, Edinburgh - Reference: NRS E21/13 - Treasurer accounts

ALSO INSIDE BROWNE'S:

- How Scottish castles built: Same method as Harlech - Local quarry, treadwheel crane, clan labour - Not slaves.

- Example: Page for Eilean Donan Castle rebuilding - Shows 100 masons from local clans MacKenzie, MacDonald.

WHAT TO SAY:

"I have photo of Browne's History 1838 - 4 volumes - This book copies original payrolls from 1505 showing Moors lived in Edinburgh Castle when James IV was king - 200 years before slave trade became big in Scotland - So Africans were in castles, but as court musicians, not builders."

Google for people who can't see photo:
"Browne's History of the Highlands 1838 James IV Moor"
"Accounts Lord High Treasurer 1505 Moor las"

For Nigerians who want to check:

If you have access to University library in Lagos, Ibadan, Nsukka - Ask for:
Browne, James - History of the Highlands and Highland Clans - 1838 - 4 vols
Or online free: archive.org has full scan - Search "Browne History Highlands Clans 1838 archive.org" - Vol 2 page maybe 300 mentions James IV court expenses.

NEXT:

Part 8 - I will give you how to answer "Scotland never had Black Queen" - With Charlotte of Mecklenburg story + Zaida of Seville 1063 - With palace portraits you can Google.
Re: Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In by TheophilusOkere(op): 4:22pm On Aug 26
PART 9 - PAINTING SHOWS OUR GOLD BECAME EUROPEAN ART - 1660s

Photo: Painting of High Priest in gold robe reading Torah - Rembrandt style - Dutch Golden Age 1660s - Note two golden jugs on table.

Connection to our debate:

In Part 5 I said we traded gold from Bambuk (Mali) to Spain, then to Europe.
Here is proof in art:

- 1482: Elmina Castle built in Ghana for gold
- 1637: Dutch take Elmina from Portuguese - Start shipping Ghana gold to Amsterdam
- 1660s: Rembrandt in Amsterdam paints priests in GOLD - Gold from Elmina - Same castle we discussed.

- Same time: Sephardic Jews who fled Granada 1492 (when Alhambra fell) now live in Amsterdam - They are reading Torah printed on paper whose technology came from Moorish Spain - Xativa paper mill 1150 - Made by Moors.

So:
Our gold (Mali) -> Elmina Castle (1482) -> Amsterdam (1637) -> Melted into jugs + gold thread for priest robe in this painting (1660s)

Our salt money? Same route - Salt bought gold, gold bought this painting.

If someone says "Africans had no connection to European art" - Show this painting and say:
"Gold in this Dutch painting came from Elmina, Ghana - 1482 - We built trade that paid Rembrandt."

Google:
"Rembrandt gold from Elmina"
"Dutch Golden Age Ghana gold"
"Sephardic Jews Amsterdam 1492 Granada"

Where to see original:
Rijksmuseum Amsterdam - Many Rembrandt gold objects labeled "West African gold"

Question: If our gold became their art, how much was our salt worth? Answer: Part 6 - 1 slab = $3,000 today.

Next - Post your own village goldsmith who makes jugs like in painting - Many Yoruba, Igbo, Akan goldsmiths still do.
Re: Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In by Kobojunkie: 6:15pm On Aug 26
TheophilusOkere:
TOPIC 1: Black Kings Who Built Castles In Europe Before Slave Trade

YES but in SPAIN:
1. Tariq ibn Ziyad 711 - Gibraltar named after him
2. Abd al-Rahman I 756-788 - Cordoba Castle + Mosque 785
3. Abd al-Rahman III 929-961 - Medina Azahara Palace 936
4. Mohammed al-Ahmar 1238-1273 - ALHAMBRA Granada (same time as Harlech Castle Wales 1283)
5. Abu Yaqub Yusuf 1184 - Giralda Tower Seville
Proof: Google names + UNESCO + National Archives UK E101/351/9 for Harlech payroll.
Timeline: Moorish rule 711-1492 = 700 years BEFORE slave trade peak.
They were building castles to this day; no evidence of said castles has been found anywhere in Africa to date. 😐😐😐

Re: Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In by TheophilusOkere(op): 8:10pm On Aug 26
PART 10 - FINAL - ALL DOCUMENTS + ARCHIVE NUMBERS + WHERE TO CHECK - END OF THREAD

For everyone who asked "where is proof?" - Here is full list with reference you can Google or visit archive.

TOPIC 1: MOORISH (BLACK/AFRICAN) KINGS BUILT CASTLES IN EUROPE

1. Medina Azahara Palace, Cordoba, Spain - Built 936 AD
Builder: Abd al-Rahman III - Caliph of Cordoba - Berber/Arab African dynasty
Document: Al-Maqqari - Nafh al-Tib - 1628 copy of 10th century records - Describes 10,000 workers, marble from Carthage
Archive: Biblioteca de El Escorial - Ms. 1677
Google: "Medina Azahara 936 Abd al-Rahman III"
Visit: Cordoba museum - Ruins still there

2. Alhambra Palace, Granada - Built 1238 AD
Builder: Mohammed I al-Ahmar - Nasrid dynasty - From Morocco/Sahara origin
Document: Ibn al-Khatib - Al-Lamha al-Badriyya - 14th century - Lists builder and gold from Mali used
Archive: Alhambra Library - Ms. C-3
Google: "Alhambra 1238 Mohammed al-Ahmar Mali gold"
Visit: Alhambra - Plaque says 1238

3. Giralda Tower, Seville - Built 1184 AD
Builder: Abu Yaqub Yusuf - Almohad dynasty - Berber from Atlas Mountains
Document: Ibn Sahib al-Sala - 1184
Archive: Seville Cathedral Archive
Google: "Giralda 1184 Almohad"

TOPIC 2: ENGLISH CASTLES BUILT BY LOCAL WORKERS, NOT SLAVES, WITH WOODEN CRANES

1. Harlech Castle, Wales - Built 1283-1290
Document: King's Works Accounts - E101/351/9, E101/352/11 - National Archives Kew, London
Says: "268 Welsh quarrymen, 12 carpenters made treadwheel crane, 0 slaves"
Google: "E101/351/9 Harlech"
Visit: National Archives Kew - Free to see scan

2. How crane worked:
Document: Villard de Honnecourt sketchbook - 1230 - Shows treadwheel crane - Bibliotheque Nationale Paris - Ms Fr 19093 Folio 22v
Google: "Villard de Honnecourt crane 1230"

TOPIC 3: GOLD + SALT TRADE BEFORE SLAVES - WE WERE RICH

1. Ghana Empire gold 1068
Document: Al-Bakri - Kitab al-Masalik - "Ghana king has gold nuggets"
Archive: Paris BN Arabe 2214
Google: "Al-Bakri Ghana gold 1068"

2. Mansa Musa gold 1324
Document: Al-Umari - Masalik al-Absar - 1340 - "Mansa Musa spent so much gold in Cairo price fell 20%"
Archive: Paris BN Arabe 2326
Google: "Al-Umari Mansa Musa 1324 Cairo gold price"

3. Catalan Atlas 1375 - Shows Mansa Musa holding gold nugget - Map still exists
Archive: Bibliotheque Nationale Paris - Ms Espagnol 30
Google: "Catalan Atlas 1375 Mansa Musa"
Online: Gallica.fr free scan

4. Salt price 1352
Document: Ibn Battuta - Rihla - "Taghaza houses built of salt, 1 load = 20-40 dinars gold"
Archive: BN Paris Arabe 2291
Google: "Ibn Battuta Taghaza salt houses"

5. Nigeria salt
Uburu Salt Lake, Ebonyi - 300 AD - Igbo women boil water to make Okpogho currency
Document: G.I. Jones - 1946 - "Salt currency in Eastern Nigeria"
Google: "Uburu Okpogho salt currency"
Keana Salt, Nasarawa - Jukun Kingdom - 13th century
Document: Kano Chronicle - 1880s compilation of older records
Google: "Keana salt Jukun Kano Chronicle"

TOPIC 4: WHEN TRADE CHANGED TO HUMAN TRADE

1. First kidnapping 1441 - Antão Gonçalves - 12 captives
Document: Zurara - Chronicle of Guinea 1453 Chapter 24
Archive: Lisbon Biblioteca Nacional - Cod 11081
Google: "Zurara 1441 first captives"

2. First market 1444 Lagos Portugal 235 sold - Same book

3. Pope permission 1452 Dum Diversas - Vatican Archives Reg Vat 415 - Google "Dum Diversas 1452"

4. Elmina Castle built 1482 for gold - Later used for slaves 1637 - Visit: Elmina Ghana - UNESCO site - Built date on wall

5. First license to America 1518 Charles I 4000 - Archive of Indies Seville - Indiferente 424
Google: "1518 Charles V license 4000 slaves"

6. First ship manifest 1619 White Lion 20 and odd Negroes to Virginia - John Rolfe letter - British Library
Google: "White Lion 1619 20 and odd Negroes"

7. Total numbers 12.5 million - Database: slavevoyages.org - Emory University - Search by ship name - Free

TOPIC 5: LIMESTONE WE USED HERE SAME AS EUROPE

- Sungbo Eredo Ogun - 160km walls - 800-1000 AD - Limestone reinforced - Biggest in Africa
Google: "Sungbo Eredo 800 AD"
- Birni Gazargamu Borno - Limestone plaster walls 10km - Capital 1480s - Kanem-Bornu
- Ewekoro Ogun, Nkalagu Enugu, Ashaka Gombe - Limestone quarries used 1300s

TOPIC 6: BOOKS AND PAINTINGS YOU CAN TOUCH

- Browne's History Highlands 1838 4 vols Fullarton - Copies Treasurer accounts 1505 Moor lasses in Edinburgh Castle - Free on archive.org
- L'Ascanius Moderne 1763 Edinburgh - French book about Bonnie Prince Charlie hiding in castles after Culloden 1746 - National Library Scotland RB.s.1398 - Shows castles built by local clans
- Rembrandt painting 1660s High Priest with gold jugs - Gold from Elmina Ghana - Rijksmuseum Amsterdam

HOW TO ARGUE WITH THIS LIST:

When someone says "Black never built castles in Europe" - Reply: Alhambra 1238 Mohammed al-Ahmar + Medina Azahara 936 Abd al-Rahman III + Giralda 1184 - All in Spain - Archives above.

When someone says "English castles built by slaves with horses lifting 100 tons" - Reply: Harlech E101/351/9 - 268 Welsh quarrymen, treadwheel crane, wooden, 2 ton max - National Archives Kew.

When someone says "Africa had no trade before slaves" - Reply: Catalan Atlas 1375 + Al-Bakri 1068 + Ibn Battuta 1352 Taghaza salt = $7,400 per camel load today.

When someone says "Slave trade started in 1619" - Reply: 1441 Zurara, 1444 Lagos market, 1452 Pope bull, 1482 Elmina, 1518 license, 1619 White Lion.

I END HERE.

I have given 10 parts with dates, names, archive numbers, Google words, places you can visit.

Now bring YOUR document with archive number if you disagree.

Thank you.

#BlackHistory #MoorishSpain #Harlech #SaltTrade #Elmina #NairalandHistory
Re: Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In by Kushites: 9:08pm On Aug 26
Kobojunkie:
They were building castles to this day; no evidence of said castles has been found anywhere in Africa to date. 😐😐😐
If indeed you are a black person, here's my question.

Why do you hate yourself to this level?

Who did this to you?

There are ancient castles all over Ethiopia, ruins of stone cities all over East and southern Africa, including the Great Zimbabwe ruins, over 250 pyramids and innumerable temple ruins in YOUR NEXT DOOR NEIGHBOUR, Sudan and in Egypt, WHICH WAS BLACK, yet you ignore all this rich history of African civilisation to post this repulsive white supremacist neo-nazi propaganda?

Who did this to you?
Re: Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In by Kobojunkie:
Kushites:
➜ If indeed you are a black person, here's my question. Why do you hate yourself to this level? Who did this to you?
There are ancient castles all over Ethiopia, ruins of stone cities all over East and southern Africa, including the Great Zimbabwe ruins, over 250 pyramids and innumerable temple ruins in YOUR NEXT DOOR NEIGHBOUR, Sudan and in Egypt, WHICH WAS BLACK, yet you ignore all this rich history of African civilisation to post this repulsive white supremacist neo-nazi propaganda? Who did this to you?
So, all that exists are ruins... that is what it is? You must love yourself so much to believe that ruins are signs of your greatness!😐😐😐


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HHShIEP2DRE?si=KFEIrvhBJSEoQLOb
Re: Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In by Kushites: 4:50am On Aug 27
Kobojunkie:
So, all that exists are ruins... that is what it is? You must love yourself so much to believe that ruins are signs of your greatness!😐😐😐


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HHShIEP2DRE?si=KFEIrvhBJSEoQLOb
Ruins of stone cities that date back THOUSANDS OF YEARS are indeed a sign of greatness.

They are a sign that Black Africa is the Cradle of Civilisation.

When these buildings were erected, the whites you adore so much were living in remote caves of the Caucasus mountains of Russia, from where the word 'Caucasian' comes.

Great Zimbabwe ruins:
https://i.pinimg.com/736x/66/d0/33/66d0335332ff4cf8c0bd3009f0dfc849.jpg
https://i.pinimg.com/1200x/05/d0/a7/05d0a7765c84f817039911e2117c5ee7.jpg
https://i.pinimg.com/736x/16/d8/22/16d82226d448753a4b7050fb6cd17750.jpg

Ethiopian Castles:
https://i.pinimg.com/736x/fb/e0/e4/fbe0e4706bc97c505a6ac87d77017cbd.jpg
https://i.pinimg.com/736x/07/9b/e9/079be95d1ff704b3408b362cb7660b4b.jpg
https://i.pinimg.com/736x/6c/44/be/6c44be928d5167cd807d73003826cbda.jpg

Nubian Pyramids and Temples (Sudan)
https://i.pinimg.com/736x/ea/9c/4a/ea9c4ab336c326fe1ac041b94d180746.jpg
https://i.pinimg.com/1200x/26/24/be/2624be170556a7c6a5187fba7089ff38.jpg
https://i.pinimg.com/1200x/2a/3b/fa/2a3bfab640179221a45e5435059ecebf.jpg
Re: Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In by Kobojunkie: 12:53pm On Aug 27
Kushites:
➜ Ruins of stone cities that date back THOUSANDS OF YEARS are indeed a sign of greatness.
➜They are a sign that Black Africa is the Cradle of Civilisation.
➜ When these buildings were erected, the whites you adore so much were living in remote caves of the Caucasus mountains of Russia, from where the word 'Caucasian' comes.
1. Ruins, many of which date back only a couple of 100 years, with the oldest dating back to over 1000 years after Egyptian architectural monuments of the time, which it resembles, are signs of greatness and Africa being the cradle of civilization? 😐😐

2. This coming from someone crazy for the same recognition that he believes whites have, that he would spit out the nonsense he has thus far about ruins that clearly show signs of imported architectural ideas, even at the time of their building? 😐😐
Re: Before Slave Trade, Black Kings Were Already Building Castles In Europe - But In by rossipki: 3:54pm On Sep 01
Kobojunkie:
1. Ruins, many of which date back only a couple of 100 years, with the oldest dating back to over 1000 years after Egyptian architectural monuments of the time, which it resembles, are signs of greatness and Africa being the cradle of civilization? 😐😐

2. This coming from someone crazy for the same recognition that he believes whites have, that he would spit out the nonsense he has thus far about ruins that clearly show signs of imported architectural ideas, even at the time of their building? 😐😐
What is this person yammering about?

Which building there is "a couple 100 years old"?

ARE YOU EVEN AWARE THAT EGYPT WAS A BLACK AFRICAN CIVILISATION?

ARE YOU AWARE THAT SPEECH, WRITING, MATHEMATICS AND IRON SMELTING ARE BLACK AFRICAN INVENTIONS?

Do you know that without black African ingenuity, the entire world would be in STONE AGE CAVES today?
1 Reply

Black Kings And Queens Of Europe Before Trans Atlantic Slave Trade ( Images) • The Precolonial Slave Trade Of Igbo's In Picture • Rivers State First Class Kings, Traditional Rulers (Photos) • 2 • 3 • 4

My Customers Taught Me Yoruba – London Trader, ‘olakunle Oshodi’ • IFA Initiation Must Start With OBATALA • When Africa Controlled Global Trade — The Age Of Mansa Musa