₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,345,838 members, 8,519,761 topics. Date: Monday, 16 November 2026 at 06:13 PM

Toggle theme

Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu - Politics (7) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu (30466 Views)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Reply (Go Down)

Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by lildush(m): 3:44am On Aug 31
BATified2023:
Tinubu get sense pass all of u

He will keep u busy with this till he wins again n after winning he will tell them to release it so u can know u are phuuuls

grin grin grin grin grin
And you think trump will seat and watch all this happen? Why is this happening again at this time that election is close? Don't you think something is cooking? You need to wake up n smell the trees bro. Trump n d US Congress does not like tinubu. He has 2 strong cases... 1 the Christian genocide he is denying and claiming it's not happening. The US came and saw it all. He is not fighting insecurities in his country but can fight for other countries and resolve everything in less than 1 hour

2 the drug case.. you know trump doesn't like anything drug related.... You can't be president and be dealing drugs in a 3rd world country.. trump will take you out. Just wait.. n see
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by lildush(m): 3:51am On Aug 31
CharlesCNG:
Morning. Yes — and thank you for asking because the documentary proof is actually quite explicit.

First, on whether this ever went beyond a Glomar response:

On April 8, 2025, U.S. District Judge Beryl A. Howell ruled in Greenspan v. Executive Office for U.S. Attorneys, Civil Action No. 23-1816, that the FBI and DEA’s Glomar responses concerning Tinubu were IMPROPER and “must be lifted.”

Even more importantly, her conclusion ordered: “The FBI and DEA must search for and process non-exempt records responsive to the FOIA requests.”

The CIA’s Glomar response, by contrast, was upheld. So there is really no ambiguity here: the FBI/DEA matter went beyond Glomar by express order of the federal court.

Here is the judgment itself:
[Judge Beryl Howell’s April 8, 2025 memorandum opinion](https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/district-of-columbia/dcdce/1:2023cv01816/256792/48/?utm_source=chatgpt.com)

Secondly, you asked an excellent question: when exactly did the U.S. Government “publicly acknowledge” that Tinubu was a subject of the wider investigation? Was there a press conference?

No. And this is where the legal meaning of “official acknowledgment” matters. The acknowledgment came through OFFICIAL U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE COURT FILINGS in 1993.

On July 26, 1993, DOJ filed a verified civil forfeiture complaint in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois. That complaint expressly incorporated by reference the affidavit of IRS Special Agent Kevin Moss.

Judge Howell ruled that because DOJ incorporated the Moss affidavit into its own complaint, DOJ legally adopted the affidavit’s statements as its own. She further explained that public DOJ court filings constitute official acknowledgment binding DOJ components such as the FBI and DEA.

Then comes Howell’s crucial finding:
Taken together, she held, those materials constituted an “official acknowledgment that Tinubu was one subject of a criminal investigation” involving, among others, the FBI and DEA.

That is why the FBI and DEA could no longer say: “We can neither confirm nor deny that such an investigation existed.”

DOJ itself had already confirmed it through its own public court filing. One important qualification, however:“Subject of an investigation” is NOT “criminally convicted.”

The ruling establishes that an investigation existed and defeats the FBI/DEA’s blanket Glomar response. It does NOT magically convert an investigation into a criminal conviction of Tinubu.

And none of this is unusual in American law. That is precisely why I cited the Donald Trump Mar-a-Lago case: courts can compel disclosure, reject blanket secrecy, and still permit lawful redactions protecting privacy, witnesses or investigative methods.

FOIA opens files. It does not pronounce guilt. So the documentary position is actually very clear:

YES — FBI and DEA originally issued Glomar responses. YES — Judge Howell expressly ruled those Glomar responses improper and ordered them lifted.

YES — Judge Howell held that DOJ had officially acknowledged Tinubu as one subject of the wider investigation and ordered the FBI and DEA to process responsive non-exempt records. But keep the calendar in view.

We are talking about an investigation dating back to 1992–93 — roughly 33 to 34 YEARS AGO — not a fresh FBI investigation of Tinubu in 2025 or 2026.

And about a decade after that investigation, in February 2003, the U.S. Consulate in Lagos responded to an inquiry from Nigeria’s Inspector-General of Police after an FBI National Crime Information Center check. The result was negative for any criminal arrest record, want or warrant concerning Bola Tinubu.

That 2003 letter does NOT prove there was never an investigation — Judge Howell’s ruling now confirms there was one. But it does make an important distinction: INVESTIGATED IN THE EARLY 1990s does not mean ARRESTED, WANTED OR A FUGITIVE.

And today's FOIA litigation is about disclosure of records from that decades-old investigation. It is not evidence that the FBI has suddenly reopened a criminal case against Tinubu 33 years later.

NO — that official acknowledgment did not come from a press conference. It came from DOJ’s own publicly filed 1993 forfeiture complaint incorporating the Moss affidavit.

And NO — none of that is itself a criminal conviction.

I hope that helps your discussion with Ottersberger. The judgment itself is the best evidence because we don't have to rely on what either Tinubu’s supporters or opponents say. Judge Howell wrote it in black and white.
Forget this long story bro we don't want someone with a criminal record as our president.and that is final. Tinubu is a criminal. Sowere always say this you think he doesn't know wat he is saying? Even the people involved in that FBI case that Time were bought over.. and that is final. Maybe that is what is delaying the release..
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by Cromagnon: 7:40am On Aug 31
Ayofe2028:
By snatching, grabbing and running away with it? You guys are now celebrating criminality.
no
Just stating the facts
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by Cromagnon: 7:41am On Aug 31
MEGAWATCH:
Hiding personal information about president is now a good thing in your region abi?


Hypocrisy is part of your culture anyway.


🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
How
You already believe he's guilty
Vote accordingly
Instead of wasting time on a distraction
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by Cromagnon: 7:42am On Aug 31
MEGAWATCH:
The EFCC who blocked the state account, the police who arrested many Accord party members, the APC people who were with guns and were released all these federal agencies who were active were all under the instructions of Atiku?


Yeye dey smell!


😂😂😂😂😂😂
And now the state is under their control
As planned
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by Cromagnon: 7:43am On Aug 31
mukthar2000:
I never said such bro, and I will never say any of Nigeria politicians has good past.
I they refer to upcoming youths.
like who
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by Cromagnon: 7:44am On Aug 31
mukthar2000:
I never said such bro, and I will never say any of Nigeria politicians has good past.
I they refer to upcoming youths.
like who
Will you vote then
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by Cromagnon: 7:45am On Aug 31
Yet you couldn't defend your intellectual self 😂
Lifediary:
You quoted the wrong person.

My opinion was for intellectuals.

Thank you.
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by Cromagnon: 7:47am On Aug 31
israelmao:
You know what I meant by this statement.
No
I don't
You've already condemned the man
Wetin remain
You think it will convince ppl that will vote for him at this late hour?
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by Cromagnon: 7:47am On Aug 31
Lifediary:
Whenever I see talks like this, I know Nigeria has failed.
You mean you have failed
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by Cromagnon: 7:50am On Aug 31
DeepSight:
1. If the US wanted to unseat him, that would be only one of a thousand moves they would make.
2. What do you mean the North could not? The North made him president with 5.6 Million votes in 2023. The next test is still ahead. He hasnt been nice to them so lets see how it plays.
I thought you lot said the north used and dumped him and yet he won
Now you've moved to 2031
I used to talk like this since 2003
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by Cromagnon: 7:53am On Aug 31
lightwind:
How old are you ?

You are asking a Nigerian wetin concern am for him country matter ?
what does Tinubu portions school affect your country after he had been in power for 26yrs
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by whippersnapper(m): 8:46am On Aug 31
BATified2023:
how much is full chicken?

grin grin grin grin

Poor man n him way of reasoning
I thought e-warriors salary is 30k. If you buy chicken 15k how much go remain for your salary.
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by bigcasava1(m): 10:34am On Aug 31
My guy man go pay dollars tire just to cover the report. US knows what they are doing, they will turn my guy man to stooge. Innocent Nigerian will be the one to suffer it. No evidence is coming out
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by aswani(m): 11:14am On Aug 31
lildush:
And you think trump will seat and watch all this happen? Why is this happening again at this time that election is close? Don't you think something is cooking? You need to wake up n smell the trees bro. Trump n d US Congress does not like tinubu. He has 2 strong cases... 1 the Christian genocide he is denying and claiming it's not happening. The US came and saw it all. He is not fighting insecurities in his country but can fight for other countries and resolve everything in less than 1 hour
The same Trump that commended him particularly for letting the US carry out joint operations against Islamic militants only a few months ago, you people are experts at clutching at straws sha.
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by ottersberger(m): 8:14pm On Aug 31
aswani:
You are welcome to disagree.

We had the same argument on the Kio Amachree thread where you disagreed and I was proven right as nothing came out of it by way of proof.

I believe same will happen again, nothing will come out of this as your position is one based on speculation without proof.
I do disagree, and please allow me to restate the case.

Now, it appears preposterous to me that you are adamantly working to obfuscate what is, by the available record, obvious.

If this matter were playing out in Nigeria, you and the camp you belong to might reasonably expect to succeed in muddying the waters. Fortunately, however, this proceeding is before a U.S. federal court, outside the reach of Nigeria’s notoriously compromised law enforcement and judicial institutions.

The relevant facts are not matters of speculation simply because some people find them inconvenient.

The case exists. The FBI and DEA issued a Glomar response to the records request. The plaintiffs challenged that response. President Tinubu then intervened in the proceedings. His intervention is itself a matter of public record and, at the very least, provides powerful confirmation that the dispute concerns records relating to him.

More importantly, the FBI has sought to submit a 399-page dossier concerning the President for in-camera consideration. The matter is now before U.S. District Judge Beryl Howell.

And the involvement of the DEA is hardly an incidental detail. Anyone familiar with the functions and jurisdiction of U.S. federal law-enforcement agencies understands why the presence of both the FBI and DEA in a records dispute of this nature is significant. It does not, by itself, establish criminal wrongdoing by Tinubu, and it would be irresponsible to claim otherwise. But neither does it justify pretending that there is nothing substantive here to examine.

That distinction is crucial.

No one is saying that the existence of an FBI or DEA file automatically proves guilt. The argument is much simpler: there are records, there is litigation over those records, the president has intervened to oppose their disclosure, and a substantial classified or otherwise protected submission has been placed before the court for in-camera review. Those are facts that should be confronted, not obscured through semantic gymnastics.

What remains to be explained is why the president of Nigeria is expending legal resources in a U.S. federal court to prevent the disclosure of law-enforcement records concerning him.

That, to me, is the more disturbing question.

Tinubu is not an ordinary private citizen. He is the number-one citizen of Nigeria and occupies an office whose legitimacy depends substantially on public confidence. If the records contain nothing capable of embarrassing or incriminating him, disclosure, subject to whatever legitimate privacy protections the court considers necessary, could potentially put the matter to rest.

Instead, he is fighting their release.

There is, of course, a difference between having a legal right to oppose disclosure and having an ethically compelling reason to do so. The fact that lawyers can advance a legal argument for secrecy does not answer the public-interest question. A president should be held to a higher standard than the minimum protection the law affords a private individual.

Indeed, the comparison with Peter Obi is instructive. When Obi sued Kenneth Okonkwo over allegations concerning him, he sought to compel Okonkwo to substantiate what he claimed to know. That is a fundamentally different posture from attempting to prevent the public from seeing official law-enforcement records that concern you, as Tinubu is engaged in.

So the question remains unavoidable:

If Tinubu is confident that these records contain nothing that should concern Nigerians, why is he fighting so hard to keep them from being released?.

He does not have to prove his innocence merely because an investigative file exists. But neither should Nigerians be asked to regard their president's determined effort to suppress access to those records as irrelevant.

The public is entitled to ask questions. The courts are entitled to decide what can lawfully be disclosed. And the president is entitled to defend himself within the law, but not to prevent access.

But when the president himself intervenes to prevent access to records that could resolve questions about his past, Nigerians are equally entitled to view that conduct as a matter of public accountability, political responsibility, and ethics.

At this point, the continued effort to manufacture confusion around the basic facts begins to resemble an attempt to create deniability rather than establish truth. What should worry every Nigerian is why their president is groveling before a US district judge in an attempt to prevent the release of his FBI/DEA records.

As the saying goes, it is easier to wake a sleeping man than one who is pretending to sleep.
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by aswani(m): 8:52pm On Aug 31
ottersberger:
The case exists. The FBI and DEA issued a Glomar response to the records request. The plaintiffs challenged that response. President Tinubu then intervened in the proceedings. His intervention is itself a matter of public record and, at the very least, provides powerful confirmation that the dispute concerns records relating to him.

More importantly, the FBI has sought to submit a 399-page dossier concerning the President for in-camera consideration. The matter is now before U.S. District Judge Beryl Howell.
Good day to you and thanks for your response, I will try responding to some of your own kindly and respectful response. We can then go on from there.

I have two sections in bold, with the ones from the first paragraph, I will be grateful if you could bring proof as no one else has. Especially the one that is a matter of public record.

From the second paragraph, we know that figure stemmed from the lobbyist a few days ago. Some are now running hard with it despite no proof. Same as the private review.

To reiterate, this case started and ended with a glomar response. Greenspan moved on with his life while Hundeyin flogged the dead horse. He gave up in the end just as Ikeamafuna van Ndigbo picked it up and he is running really hard with it.

What exactly are you seeing in all this fake stuff that is making you think is true? I genuinely would like to say I am wrong and you are right, just give me something, anything.
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by ottersberger(m): 10:58pm On Aug 31
aswani:
Good day to you and thanks for your response, I will try responding to some of your own kindly and respectful response. We can then go on from there.

I have two sections in bold, with the ones from the first paragraph, I will be grateful if you could bring proof as no one else has. Especially the one that is a matter of public record.

From the second paragraph, we know that figure stemmed from the lobbyist a few days ago. Some are now running hard with it despite no proof. Same as the private review.

To reiterate, this case started and ended with a glomar response. Greenspan moved on with his life while Hundeyin flogged the dead horse. He gave up in the end just as Ikeamafuna van Ndigbo picked it up and he is running really hard with it.

What exactly are you seeing in all this fake stuff that is making you think is true? I genuinely would like to say I am wrong and you are right, just give me something, anything.
Good evening.

I appreciate the invitation to “give you something, anything.”

I will do precisely that: the court record, rather than social media commentary, lobbyist claims, or partisan interpretation.

And I think this is where your argument unfortunately collapses.

You say, “The case started and ended with a Glomar response”. That is demonstrably false.

1. Tinubu’s intervention is not a rumor. It is on the docket.

The case is Aaron Greenspan v. Executive Office for U.S. Attorneys, et al., Civil Action No. 23-1816 (BAH), before Judge Beryl A. Howell of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.

The docket records that on October 31, 2023, Judge Howell granted counsel permission to appear for the purpose of representing Bola A. Tinubu, who has moved to intervene in this action. Two days later, counsel formally entered an appearance on behalf of Bola A. Tinubu.

That is not a lobbyist's allegation. It is a federal court docket entry.

https://foiaproject.org/case_detail/?case_id=36111

And it did not end there. The docket records another appearance by counsel for BOLA A. TINUBU in July 2025.

https://foiaproject.org/case_detail/?case_id=36111

So when I said Tinubu intervened, I was not speculating, and I certainly did not need a lobbyist to tell me so. It is a matter of public court record.

You asked for proof. There it is.

2. More importantly, your claim that the case “ended with a Glomar response” is contradicted by Judge Howell herself.

This is the most important point.

On April 8, 2025, Judge Beryl Howell issued a written memorandum opinion in this very case.

Her ruling begins by identifying the case, the plaintiff, the FBI, DEA and CIA, and the records sought concerning Bola Ahmed Tinubu and Abiodun Agbele. The court expressly records that the FBI, DEA and CIA had issued Glomar responses and that Greenspan challenged those responses.

https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/district-of-columbia/dcdce/1:2023cv01816/256792/48/

But then comes the part that completely destroys the assertion that the matter “started and ended” with Glomar:

Judge Howell ruled that the FBI and DEA's Glomar responses were improper and had to be lifted.

The court expressly stated:

“The Glomar responses asserted by defendants FBI and DEA are improper and must be lifted.”

That is the ruling of the judge presiding over the case, not Greenspan, not Hundeyin, not I, Ottersberger, not Peter Obi, and not any Nigerian politician.

https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/district-of-columbia/dcdce/1:2023cv01816/256792/48/

So the proposition that Greenspan was merely “flogging a dead horse” after a case that had already ended is simply incompatible with the judicial record.

A dead case does not produce a 2025 Memorandum Opinion granting the plaintiff relief against two federal agencies.

3. And the judge went considerably further.

Judge Howell did not merely say, “We cannot tell whether records exist.”

She addressed the government's claim that privacy justified the Glomar responses concerning Tinubu.

Her opinion records that the Department of Justice had officially acknowledged that Tinubu was criminally investigated as part of a broader investigation involving both the FBI and DEA.

The judge concluded that this official acknowledgment pierced the Glomar responses. She specifically held that because the FBI and DEA are components of the Department of Justice, they were bound by that official acknowledgment and could no longer refuse to confirm or deny the mere existence of an investigation of Tinubu.

https://app.midpage.ai/document/greenspan-v-executive-office-for-10840997?utm_source

[url]https://cases.justia.com/federal/district-courts/district-of-columbia/dcdce/1%3A2023cv01816/256792/48/0.pdfts=1744185838&utm_source[/url]

That is an extraordinary fact to simply wave away as “fake stuff.”

Indeed, Judge Howell went directly at the government's privacy argument. She distinguished between:

1. Tinubu's privacy interest in keeping secret the fact that he had been investigated, and
2. his privacy interest in the contents of investigative files.

Her point was that the first could no longer sustain a Glomar response because the fact of the investigation had already been officially acknowledged.

https://app.midpage.ai/document/greenspan-v-executive-office-for-10840997?utm_source

So here is the empirical sequence:

FOIA request → Glomar response → appeal → federal lawsuit → Tinubu enters the case → federal judge adjudicates the Glomar issue → judge finds FBI and DEA's Glomar responses improper → judge orders that those Glomar responses be lifted.

That is not an interpretation. That is the procedural history of the case.

4. You are also conflating two entirely different questions.
Nobody serious is arguing that a Glomar response proves that Tinubu committed a crime.

It doesn't.

Nor does the existence of an FBI or DEA file, by itself, establish guilt. But that can also be interpreted as the endgame. A sort of catch and kill strategy if the agencies and Tinubu are under the same bedsheets.

But that is an entirely different proposition from saying that there was no case, no investigation, no records dispute, or no judicial development beyond Glomar.

The 2025 judgment alone makes that position untenable.

And Judge Howell's opinion actually describes the underlying FOIA requests in extraordinary specificity. One FBI request sought:

“The entire FBI file for Bola Ahmed Tinubu”

Another sought FBI Form 302 interviews with Tinubu from 1992 to 1993, identified by a specific FBI case number. The court records the FBI's responses to both requests and the subsequent appeals.

https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/district-of-columbia/dcdce/1:2023cv01816/256792/48/

You can dispute what those records ultimately contain.

You can dispute whether they establish anything incriminating.

You can argue that some or all of them should remain protected under applicable FOIA exemptions.

But you cannot honestly reduce the entire litigation to “a Glomar response” and declare the case dead. The judge's own published opinion says otherwise.

5. As for the 399 pages, I will be more careful than you are.

You are correct about one thing: the 399-page figure should not be treated as established merely because a lobbyist or news outlet reported it.

The recent reports say the FBI made an ex parte, in-camera submission to Judge Howell on August 28, 2026, and that the submission reportedly concerned 399 pages.

https://atlanticdigest.com/politics/fbi-seeks-secret-review-of-tinubus-withheld-records-nigerians-ask-why-a-presidents-file-needs-a-closed-door-hearing-to-explain/?utm_source

https://nnnewsmedia.com/tinubu-secret-us-fbi-drug-trafficking-records-hit-399-pages-as-call-grow-to-make-file-public/?utm_source

But because that material was submitted privately, it would be wrong to claim that we know the substantive contents of those pages. Nor would I claim that “399 pages” proves criminal wrongdoing. It does not.

That is precisely why I have specifically separated what is proved by the public docket from what is being reported about sealed material.

And that distinction actually strengthens my argument rather than yours.

Because even if we throw the 399-page claim completely out of the discussion, everything I have said about the existence and development of the case remains standing on the court record.

6. So what exactly am I “seeing”?.

I am seeing a real federal FOIA lawsuit.

I am seeing official FOIA requests for records concerning Tinubu.

I am seeing FBI and DEA Glomar responses.

I am seeing appeals of those responses.

I am seeing Tinubu enter the litigation.

I am seeing Judge Howell issue a substantive opinion concerning those very records.

I am seeing that the judge expressly concludes that the FBI and DEA's Glomar responses were improper and had to be lifted.

And I am seeing the litigation continue after that ruling.

Those are not things I believe because David Hundeyin, Aaron Greenspan, Peter Obi, Atiku Abubakar, a lobbyist, or anybody else told me to believe them.

They are things I know because they are documented in the United States federal court record.

So if you genuinely want to establish that I am wrong, there is a remarkably easy way to do it.

Don't tell me that Greenspan “flogged a dead horse.”

Don't tell me Hundeyin “ran with it.”

Don't tell me a lobbyist invented 399 pages.

Show me the part of Judge Howell's April 8, 2025 opinion where she says the case ended with a Glomar response.

You won't find it.

In fact, you will find the opposite.

And that is the fundamental problem with the argument you are advancing: it asks us to disregard the actual judicial record in favor of a narrative about what the case supposedly was.

The court record is not a narrative.

It is the evidence.

A particularly useful point here is that you don't actually need the disputed 399-page claim to win the factual argument. The 2025 opinion is considerably stronger evidence because it is a signed judicial opinion by Judge Howell herself.

Judge Howell's April 8, 2025 Memorandum Opinion
https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/district-of-columbia/dcdce/1:2023cv01816/256792/48/

Case docket showing Tinubu's intervention and counsel appearances
https://foiaproject.org/case_detail/?case_id=36111&style=foia&title=on&utm_source

My friend, I am committed to resolving this issue truthfully, and I hope you will agree that considerable effort has gone into articulating the above position to further this discussion and, more importantly, to inform our readers of the validity of the conclusion I reached.
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by aswani(m): 4:25am On Sep 01
ottersberger:
So here is the empirical sequence:

FOIA request → Glomar response → appeal → federal lawsuit → Tinubu enters the case → federal judge adjudicates the Glomar issue → judge finds FBI and DEA's Glomar responses improper → judge orders that those Glomar responses be lifted.
Once more I thank you for taking your time, alas a not so lengthy rebuttal to match your response, please note that it is not an indication of my respect for all the work you put in

I think you know my opinion on the FOIA links, someone is typing away stuff with no supporting documentation. Anyone can type anything to support anything.

As per the justia link, they have added this proviso to an unsigned document without a court seal (which tells me all I need to knows d suspected):

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

As for links from obscure Nigerian media houses, I refuse to dignify them by clicking on them or bringing them up in a discussion.

We have a "case" where no one is seen going in and out of court rooms, names of legal representatives are not listed, actual official Court dockets for Judge Howell on the dates aren't listed.

Orders with a court seal, signed by the Judge and counter signed by various parties don't exist and never have.

Every so often, we are told the case is postponed, the next iteration of the case doesn't reference what happened during the last hearing, we just repeatedly read the same thing about Judge Howell bring angry and telling whoever to obey an order, no punishment for not doing so, rinse and repeat. For 3 years, the Judge has been angry, she nor dey tire ni.

You and I interacted in the Kio Amachree thread where he claimed he saw documents and after the hearing on July 1, the whole world will see it. July 1 came and went, Kio Amachree moved on and we didn't see the documents he saw.

Greenspan who is the actual plaintiff in the case and has a prescence on social media doesn't say pim about it.

Ikemefuna suddenly turns up, about a month ago, and is the one that is giving various narratives and updates on the case. A case he is not a party to. He too has seen documents, presumably the same ones Kio Amachree saw, and is going to put them in front of Trump or in front of someone to put in front of Trump.

Ikemefuna is the one that knows that there is a private hearing for documents to be shown to the judge to be reviewed. He is the one that knows there are exactly 399 pages. He was the one that knew said Judge gave a 10 day ultimatum, another one, and DOJ gave 4 days. DOJ are not a party to the case and only started getting a mention a month ago. Again more deadlines have passed with nothing being released.

A so called lobbyist whose organisation presumably has a website and has physical offices doesn't call press conferences. He doesn't add information with links to his websites, only to his social media page, that is where he is putting up to date info on a case he is not a party to. The actual people in the case who are on social media are not updating their own handles or official websites.

I knew it was a charade, albeit a well thought out one, ages ago when Hundeyin claimed the FBI released the papers and only redacted President Tinubu's name. This was a day after he said they had refused to release them and the judge was angry with them with no court date in between. What sense does that make? Remember he was telling us 500 pages were going to be released once a week for however long. He then claimed the FBI had wasted his time and money in a nudge nudge, wink wink attempt to encourage Obidients to help his hustle.

With the amount of relatively new monikers on here dilligently copying links from Ikemefuna's Twitter account and pasting on here as well as these obscure one man online Nigerian "news journals" getting the scoop (one actually tripped up by only having news info as far back as June), it is clear to me that Ikemefuna is on a blitz on the matter.

Not forgetting new monikers that suddenly have an opinion on the matter or a slight variation on another, guess what, new monikers opinion.

As with when Hundeyin ran with it, it will amount to nothing because it is based on a falsehood.

I must stop now, thanks once more for responding without the typical Obidient insults and abuse like others have (as it happens, that is another yardstick for knowing we are dealing with BS).
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by lildush(m): 4:57am On Sep 01
aswani:
The same Trump that commended him particularly for letting the US carry out joint operations against Islamic militants only a few months ago, you people are experts at clutching at straws sha.
We rear chicken and goats and at some point they become our pets.. but Wen Christmas and New year comes what happens ? We slaughter that same chicken we have been keeping as pets... u gerit? Just wait and see.
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by aswani(m): 8:29am On Sep 01
CharlesCNG:
Morning. Yes — and thank you for asking because the documentary proof is actually quite explicit.

First, on whether this ever went beyond a Glomar response:

On April 8, 2025, U.S. District Judge Beryl A. Howell ruled in Greenspan v. Executive Office for U.S. Attorneys, Civil Action No. 23-1816, that the FBI and DEA’s Glomar responses concerning Tinubu were IMPROPER and “must be lifted.”

Even more importantly, her conclusion ordered: “The FBI and DEA must search for and process non-exempt records responsive to the FOIA requests.”

The CIA’s Glomar response, by contrast, was upheld. So there is really no ambiguity here: the FBI/DEA matter went beyond Glomar by express order of the federal court.

Here is the judgment itself:
[Judge Beryl Howell’s April 8, 2025 memorandum opinion](https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/district-of-columbia/dcdce/1:2023cv01816/256792/48/?utm_source=chatgpt.com)

NO — that official acknowledgment did not come from a press conference. It came from DOJ’s own publicly filed 1993 forfeiture complaint incorporating the Moss affidavit.

And NO — none of that is itself a criminal conviction.

I hope that helps your discussion with Ottersberger. The judgment itself is the best evidence because we don't have to rely on what either Tinubu’s supporters or opponents say. Judge Howell wrote it in black and white.
Not sure if I responded to you but on that link you sent, it says :

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes

Adding this to the fact that the document there doesn't have a official court seal and is unsigned suggests to me that is not a reliable document, especially one to be treated as a court order.
The court case referenced in the 90's, that was the forfeiture case where he was investigated and he could prove the monies in the account weren't his, hence the forfeiture. I actually believe it was him that dragged the FBI to court so they could unfreeze all his accounts which they did on the basis of that forfeiture.

I am certain if they were able to find a plausible link to drugs, they would have thrown him in jail, not unfreeze his various accounts and let him carry about his business.

I am afraid no one is yet to prove this case went past a glomar response. Someone somewhere must have an actual signed and court sealed order, hopefully they will let us see it.

Greenspan is the plaintiff even if we know the FBI wouldn't show us their signed and court sealed copy. By now someone could have offered him money to get a copy from him (if indeed it existed).
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by CharlesCNG: 10:15am On Sep 01
lildush:
Forget this long story bro we don't want someone with a criminal record as our president.and that is final. Tinubu is a criminal. Sowere always say this you think he doesn't know wat he is saying? Even the people involved in that FBI case that Time were bought over.. and that is final. Maybe that is what is delaying the release..
WHO exactly are the “WE”?

Speak for yourself. You have not been appointed spokesman for 200 million Nigerians. And please stop converting allegation into conviction by repetition.

The Chicago matter arose from proceedings more than three decades ago. Tinubu was not criminally convicted in that case.

In fact, when Nigeria’s Inspector-General of Police formally asked the U.S. Consulate about Tinubu in 2003, the FBI’s National Crime Information Center check returned NEGATIVE for criminal arrest records, wants or warrants.

Then you invoke Sowore as though: “Sowore said it, therefore it is true.”
Should we now accept EVERYTHING Sowore says?

Because Sowore has also described Peter Obi as a “packaged fraud” and said Obi is part of the same old political system he has fought for years.
So which Sowore are we accepting? Sowore on Tinubu = gospel? Sowore on Obi = suddenly unreliable? 😂
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by lildush(m): 7:24pm On Sep 01
CharlesCNG:
WHO exactly are the “WE”?

Speak for yourself. You have not been appointed spokesman for 200 million Nigerians. And please stop converting allegation into conviction by repetition.

The Chicago matter arose from proceedings more than three decades ago. Tinubu was not criminally convicted in that case.

In fact, when Nigeria’s Inspector-General of Police formally asked the U.S. Consulate about Tinubu in 2003, the FBI’s National Crime Information Center check returned NEGATIVE for criminal arrest records, wants or warrants.

Then you invoke Sowore as though: “Sowore said it, therefore it is true.”
Should we now accept EVERYTHING Sowore says?

Because Sowore has also described Peter Obi as a “packaged fraud” and said Obi is part of the same old political system he has fought for years.
So which Sowore are we accepting? Sowore on Tinubu = gospel? Sowore on Obi = suddenly unreliable? 😂
I don't have anything to say to. Since Ur a supporter of evil stay very far away from me.
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by CharlesCNG: 8:08pm On Sep 03
lildush:
I don't have anything to say to. Since Ur a supporter of evil stay very far away from me.
This is a PUBLIC discussion forum; if you want people to “stay very far away,” perhaps a public forum is a rather ambitious choice of residence. 😂

And about “supporting evil”: when your only evidence of evil is that someone supports a politician you dislike, perhaps the real evil threatening Nigeria is the murder of basic reasoning.
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by lildush(m): 11:13am On Sep 04
CharlesCNG:
This is a PUBLIC discussion forum; if you want people to “stay very far away,” perhaps a public forum is a rather ambitious choice of residence. 😂

And about “supporting evil”: when your only evidence of evil is that someone supports a politician you dislike, perhaps the real evil threatening Nigeria is the murder of basic reasoning.
Ur last statement is very true. Ur reasoning is a treath to good things about to happen in this country. How can U be supporting evil openly? If U love evil den U are also evil. I don't hate tinubu but I dis like wat he does.. his way of life. I like the man as a person but his ways... 😔😔😔😔 Is a no no for me. Even if it's my father I will tell him the truth..
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by aswani(m): 6:45am On Sep 22
ottersberger:
Good evening.

I appreciate the invitation to “give you something, anything.”

My friend, I am committed to resolving this issue truthfully, and I hope you will agree that considerable effort has gone into articulating the above position to further this discussion and, more importantly, to inform our readers of the validity of the conclusion I reached.
Good morning, please do you know what the situation is with this case right now?

There were deadlines of September 10 and 18 that were (supposedly) directed at the FBI and the intervenor respectively that has come and gone with nothing reported.

Nothing reported in the media, nothing from the defendants or plaintiff or intervenor in an interview, no press releases. Even Ikeamafuna that was pushing hard on this has fallen silent, Hundeyin gave up ages ago, Kio Amachree that saw the files has said nothing, Greenspan has social media accounts, nothing on there.

It's as if it was all BS in the first place and there is no case. This is another deadline that has passed, along with the previous ones.

A lot of news outlets, some reputable, incredibly carried the news. Not one of them have been bold enough to follow it up to find out what has happened on the day and what will now happen. They couldn't as they had no (valid) source or even a mole feeding them information, they all indulged in data mining from Ikeamafuna's Twitter page.

At best, we can call this lazy, unethical journalism. It is one thing Obidients being fooled because they are desperate to believe whatever, it is another for journalists and news agencies to get information without editors attempting to verify it's authenticity.

The case that Greenspan raised ended at a glomar response.
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by aswani(m): 11:56pm On Sep 30
ottersberger:
Let the judge examine the records. Let the law determine what can be released. And, most importantly, let the evidence speak for itself.
Any news on the records?
Re: Four Reasons US Shouldn’t Release My FBI Records – Tinubu by aswani(m): 8:04am On Oct 31
ottersberger:
My dear friend and brother. You called me, as usual.

In my village, a man once stole a cock and hid it inside his sack. Having witnessed the theft, the village youths gathered around him, calling him a “thief.” The man, seeing another adult nearby, beckoned him over. “Come and look inside the sack,” he said. “You can determine for yourself whether I stole the cock.”

The adult looked inside. Sure enough, the missing cock was there.

But instead of addressing what was plainly before him, the adult turned to the youths and reprimanded them. “Go home,” he said. “Nothing to see here.”

That story comes to mind whenever I read anyone trying to dismiss the FBI records concerning Bola Ahmed Tinubu as though the underlying FOIA case does not exist or in this form.

It does!.

And the timeline matters.

On March 29, 2023, Aaron Greenspan submitted a FOIA request seeking FBI records concerning Tinubu. When the FBI initially refused to confirm or deny the existence of responsive records, a position commonly known as a “Glomar” response, Greenspan challenged that position in federal court.

We are now well beyond simply asking whether the FBI has records.

In the litigation, the FBI ultimately identified 399 pages of potentially responsive material and asked the court to review the records “under seal, ex parte, and in camera.” In plain English, the government is asking the judge to examine the records privately before deciding what, if anything, can be released publicly.

That is a very different situation from saying, “There are no records or a glomar response.”

And this distinction matters.

I am a fair-minded person, and to be clear, the existence of 399 pages does not prove that Tinubu committed a crime. Nor does a FOIA proceeding amount to a criminal finding against him. Those are claims that require evidence, and we should not manufacture conclusions that the court has not made.

But the opposite claim, that there is nothing here, or that the entire matter is fabricated, is equally difficult to sustain in light of the now available court record.

The obvious question is therefore not whether the records exist. The question is: what do they contain, and why were they generated?.

If the records contain nothing of consequence, transparency should settle the matter. If they contain information relevant to Tinubu's past legal trouble, Nigerians and the wider public should be allowed to understand that information and draw their own conclusions.

And 399 pages is not a trivial amount of material. It is substantial enough to warrant serious public interest and scrutiny.

This is why dismissing the issue outright does a disservice to the very person being defended and the defenders. Credibility is not strengthened by pretending the evidence does not exist. It is strengthened by confronting the evidence directly.

The United States is an open-records system with judicial mechanisms for challenging government secrecy. That process is precisely what is happening here. On the face of it, the claim that lives will be at risk because of these files makes it even more intriguing and compelling. Who is our president?. What had he done?.

So, my dear friend, let us not be like the adult who opened the sack, saw the cock, and then told everyone:

“Nothing to see here.”

Open the sack.

Let the judge examine the records. Let the law determine what can be released. And, most importantly, let the evidence speak for itself.
A day over 2 months on, and it is like this never happened.

The tumbleweed of Judge Beryl Howell, FBI files numbering up to 399 pages, intervenor application, private viewing, documents on President Tinubu that Kio Amachree has seen, that same tumbleweed is blowing down the street with no one even bothering to cast a second glance.

One day, Hundeyin and Ikemefuna will come out to admit the part they played in attempting to delude people that this was a total hoax post glomar response.

At least Hundeyin rolled with the falsehood for a couple of years, Ikemefuna only did it for a few months and has now moved on.

I am sure there be another go at this before elections early next year. I can't wait to join the army of diligent posters in slapping the nonsense down.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Reply

2027: Judge Me By My Records, Tinubu Tells Nigerians • CSU Records: Tinubu Submitted Forged Documents To INEC, Atiku’s Aide Alleges • 2 • 3 • 4

Tinubu, Akande Made My Appointment Possible – Lawal, SGF • Buhari Appoints His Own 'reuben Abati' • President Buhari Meets With Governors In Aso Rock (Photos)