₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,345,845 members, 8,519,789 topics. Date: Monday, 16 November 2026 at 07:26 PM

Toggle theme

Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished - Politics - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished (2269 Views)

1 2 Reply (Go Down)

Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by nairalanda1(op): 10:09am On Aug 31
By Halimah Nuhu Sanda


For three years, Nigerians have been told to endure the pain of fuel subsidy removal because the country could no longer afford the old system. We were told that the resources previously spent subsidising petrol would be redirected towards infrastructure, healthcare, education, security and other investments capable of producing a stronger economy.

Three years later, the subsidy debate has returned with renewed force, this time as one of the emerging fault lines of the 2027 presidential contest. Atiku Abubakar says he will restore subsidy. President Bola Tinubu says bringing it back would be economically reckless. Peter Obi says subsidy removal was necessary but its proceeds have been badly managed. Other presidential contenders have offered variations ranging from targeted intervention to a complete rejection of the assumptions underlying the current policy. Beneath all these political arguments, however, lies a much simpler question ordinary Nigerians have every right to ask: what exactly are we getting in return for the sacrifice?

Atiku’s intervention has reopened a wound that never really healed. He has insisted that if elected, he would restore petrol subsidy, although his position has subsequently been framed as targeted support rather than a return to the old import-subsidy regime. Atiku argues that Nigerians are carrying the consequences of higher energy and transportation costs and that government must restore purchasing power. His argument resonates because the consequences of subsidy removal have travelled far beyond the price displayed at filling stations. Fuel costs have affected transportation, food, small businesses and household budgets. For many Nigerians, the reform is experienced not as an abstract fiscal adjustment but as the reason virtually everything costs more.

Yet Atiku’s position deserves scrutiny as much as the government’s does. He supported subsidy removal during the 2023 presidential campaign, making his current position an obvious target for criticism. His camp has also spent part of this week clarifying whether the proposed subsidy would be temporary or open-ended before Atiku himself reiterated that his position had not changed. A subsidy may provide relief, but Nigerians deserve to know how much it would cost, who would benefit, how it would be funded and how the country would prevent the corruption and opacity that characterised the old system.

President Tinubu’s argument, on the other hand, is that Nigeria could not continue with a system that placed an enormous burden on public finances while creating opportunities for abuse. The administration maintains that subsidy removal was a necessary reform and that returning to the old model would simply recreate the problems Nigeria had decided to confront. According to the Finance Ministry, the reforms associated with subsidy removal and foreign-exchange liberalisation generated N15.8 trillion in additional resources for the Federation between June 2023 and December 2025, with N5.4 trillion accruing to the federal government and N10.4 trillion distributed to states and local governments.

But this is where the government’s argument encounters the reality of the Nigerian household. A fiscal improvement is important, but it cannot be the only measure of a successful economic reform. If government tells citizens that a painful policy is necessary because it will free resources for development, citizens are entitled to ask where the development is. Government has explained that the resources have been absorbed by increased expenditure, debt servicing, higher wages and other fiscal pressures. Yet the ordinary Nigerian is not measuring the reform by government accounting. They are measuring it by the cost of getting to work, feeding their families, sending their children to school and accessing healthcare.

Peter Obi’s intervention is therefore significant because he refuses to accept the easy argument that hardship automatically proves subsidy removal was wrong. Obi has explicitly said that he still supports subsidy removal and that the mismanagement of the proceeds should not be a reason to reverse the policy. His criticism is that Nigerians were not given an adequate alternative use for the resources recovered from subsidy.

That distinction deserves much more attention. Perhaps the greatest weakness of Nigeria’s subsidy reform was not that the government removed the subsidy, but that it failed to build a sufficiently visible social contract around the reform. When citizens are told that they must pay more today so that the country can become stronger tomorrow, tomorrow cannot remain an indefinite promise. People need to see the connection between their sacrifice and better public transportation, functioning hospitals, stronger schools, food security and opportunities for productive enterprise.

The other presidential contenders make the debate even more interesting. Omoyele Sowore represents the argument that subsidy itself should not necessarily be treated as the enemy and that the real problem is the corruption and inefficiency surrounding its administration. His position provides an important counterpoint to those who regard subsidy removal as inherently necessary.

Seyi Makinde, meanwhile, has criticised the simultaneous removal of subsidy and floating of the naira as a double shock that required stronger cushioning measures for Nigerians. His argument moves the conversation towards sequencing and social protection rather than simply asking whether subsidy is good or bad. Gbenga Olawepo-Hashim has offered another variation, arguing for a more targeted and transparent intervention rather than a return to the old system. These positions remind us that the choice is not necessarily between unlimited subsidy and complete abandonment of government intervention.

And then there is Donald Duke, whose argument I find perhaps the most intellectually provocative. Rather than simply accepting the language of the debate, Duke has challenged the premise itself, questioning whether what Nigeria called fuel subsidy was ever a genuine and transparent subsidy system in the first place. His intervention forces us to ask a more fundamental question: what exactly are we trying to remove or restore? If the system itself was opaque and corrupt, simply arguing about whether to bring it back may be missing the point.

Taken together, these positions reveal that Nigeria’s political class is not actually debating one question. They are debating several. Should government subsidise petrol? Should it subsidise vulnerable Nigerians instead? Should the savings from subsidy removal be invested in public services? Should domestic production be supported to bring prices down? Should government intervene temporarily during periods of economic shock? And perhaps most importantly, how do we protect citizens from the consequences of necessary economic reform without recreating the fiscal leakages that made the old system unsustainable?

This last question deserves to become the centre of Nigeria’s conversation.

Subsidising petrol is not necessarily the same thing as subsidising Nigerians. A universal subsidy benefits everyone who buys petrol, including those who can comfortably afford its true market price. A targeted social protection system could instead concentrate scarce public resources on poor households, public transport users, farmers, small businesses and other groups most exposed to energy-price shocks. Such a system could be accompanied by investment in mass transportation, domestic refining, food production, healthcare and other measures that reduce the transmission of fuel prices into the cost of living.

This is where the subsidy debate should ultimately take us. Nigeria does not have to choose between pretending that petrol can remain artificially cheap forever and abandoning citizens to absorb every consequence of market reform. There is a middle ground, but it requires something Nigeria has historically struggled to provide: transparent, accountable and disciplined government.

The question, therefore, should no longer be simply whether subsidy should be removed or restored. The harder and more important question is what kind of economy Nigeria wants to build after subsidy.

If government chooses to remove subsidy, it must demonstrate what Nigerians are receiving in return. If an opposition candidate promises to restore it, that candidate must explain how it will be financed, targeted and protected from the corruption of the past. If another candidate supports its removal, that candidate must explain how the resulting fiscal space will translate into better lives. And if someone proposes a middle path, Nigerians deserve to see the numbers, the safeguards and the implementation plan.

Because Nigerians do not necessarily need cheap petrol forever. They need an economy in which they can afford the petrol they buy.

The success of subsidy removal was never going to be measured simply by whether government could stop paying the subsidy. It should be measured by whether the country could turn that difficult sacrifice into a more productive economy, stronger public services and a better quality of life. Until Nigerians can see that connection, the subsidy debate will continue to return, election after election, because the real issue has never been only the price of petrol. It is the price Nigerians are being asked to pay for reform, and whether anyone can convincingly show them what that sacrifice is buying.
Source: DAILY TRUST

Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by nairalanda1(op): 10:10am On Aug 31
Sorry for taking first to comment, but this article is brilliantly written, and summarizes a lot of stuff.
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by Sheuns(m): 10:28am On Aug 31
Until politicians start making the same sacrifices they ask the people to make and honestly channel the funds into developing the state and people before they can be taken seriously or trusted.
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by Nobody: 10:31am On Aug 31
Between the two major opposition presidential candidates, who is right about subsidy?

Atiku or Obi?

Should it be reinstated, or should it remain removed?
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by Gotocourt: 10:31am On Aug 31
Developed countries give subsidy on food ,transport, security, businesses, education.

Tinubu is after our lives

Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by nairalanda1(op): 10:33am On Aug 31
99thEnemy:
Between the two major opposition candidates, who is right about subsidy?

Atiku or Obi?

S
Obi supports subsidy removal, and also supports using the savings for targetted relief for the masses. Something which many economists have supported.

He has my vote because of that.
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by BrickandLace(f): 10:35am On Aug 31
keep your hope alive

You are a patient taking a bitter medicine

Tinubu is the only president bold to take hard decisions

Nigeria is broke.

Jonathan ruined Nigeria

I don't have control over the population

My Bold reforms is already yielding results...

Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by nairalanda1(op): 10:36am On Aug 31
Gotocourt:
Developed countries give subsidy on food ,transport, security, businesses.

Tinubu is after our lives
Developed countries also pay very heavy taxes for the pleasure of those subsidies, which go to the poorest of the poor. Even when everyone is benefitting, like free education, the tax eats half the income. As bad as Nigeria is, no government has levied a tax that takes half one's salary or income

Even things like railways that are subsidised, the system is in debt, leading to a disucssion as to how long it can continue (Germany has this problem, UK removed railway subsdies in the 1990's..as a result a train journey in the UK is expensive).

Finally subsides given to industires and businesses are production subsides, not consumption subsides, which is what our fuel subsidy was an example of. (Another example of a consumption subsidy is the SNAP programme,in the USA, which is given to very poor people only..for food and other things).
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by Inspirer1: 10:39am On Aug 31
If the stoppage and associated benefits had been judiciously managed to the benefit of all Nigerians, we won't be going back to it possibly by next year.
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by iwaeda: 10:40am On Aug 31
The money wasted on giving 1kg of rice, beans and garri as palliatives much more than what Buhari claimed to pay on subsidy. All the saving on subsidy removal, where are the savings. People are getting poorer, politicians are getting richer. grin grin grin grin grin
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by ogolemati: 10:40am On Aug 31
BrickandLace:
keep your hope alive

You are a patient taking a bitter medicine

Tinubu is the only president bold to take hard decisions

Nigeria is broke.

Jonathan ruined Nigeria

I don't have control over the population

My Bold reforms is already yielding results...
grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin na so you hate Nigeria

Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by BrickandLace(f): 10:43am On Aug 31
ogolemati:
grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin na so you hate Nigeria
I'm glad you know that only someone who hates Nigeria will tell you that .

Many of them are reading this thread.
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by akile21(m): 10:44am On Aug 31
This is an unbiased analysis. I won't mind have an intellectual conversation on this matter...

Someone needs to be partisan to fathom the basis of the write-up.
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by nairalanda1(op): 10:47am On Aug 31
Here is the best part of the article...

Peter Obi’s intervention is therefore significant because he refuses to accept the easy argument that hardship automatically proves subsidy removal was wrong. Obi has explicitly said that he still supports subsidy removal and that the mismanagement of the proceeds should not be a reason to reverse the policy. His criticism is that Nigerians were not given an adequate alternative use for the resources recovered from subsidy.

That distinction deserves much more attention. Perhaps the greatest weakness of Nigeria’s subsidy reform was not that the government removed the subsidy, but that it failed to build a sufficiently visible social contract around the reform. When citizens are told that they must pay more today so that the country can become stronger tomorrow, tomorrow cannot remain an indefinite promise. People need to see the connection between their sacrifice and better public transportation, functioning hospitals, stronger schools, food security and opportunities for productive enterprise


Nothing more to add. Obi is not perfect, but of the three candidates, he gets it a bit.
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by anonimi: 10:49am On Aug 31
99thEnemy:
Between the two major opposition presidential candidates, who is right about subsidy?

Atiku or Obi?

Should it be reinstated, or should it remain removed?
Was it ever removed or was the name changed for payment in a clandestine way huh

anonimi:
NNPCL’s subsidy payment jump by 47.9% to N7.1trn in 2024

November 26, 2025

The Nigerian National Petroleum Company Limited (NNPCL) paid a total of N7.1 trillion as subsidy for premium motor spirit (PMS) in 2024, this sum represents a 47.9 percent increase from N4.8 trillion recorded in 2023.

This is despite the government’s announcement of subsidy removal in 2023.

The company explained that the amount, which it termed ‘energy security expense’ arises when there is differential between the exchange rate used to freeze the premium motor spirit ex-coastal price and the prevailing rate at the point of import settlement.

According to the report, government had instructed that NNPC Limited cannot sell its PMS above a certain regulated price. It added that the cost of petrol import is usually much higher that the regulated price.

https://businessday.ng/news/article/nnpcls-subsidy-payment-jump-by-47-9-to-n7-1trn-in-2024/?amp
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by Nobody: 10:52am On Aug 31
anonimi:
Was it ever removed or was the name changed for payment in a clandestine way huh
It was only partly removed.
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by anonimi: 10:53am On Aug 31
BrickandLace:
keep your hope alive
You are a patient taking a bitter medicine
Tinubu is the only president bold to take hard decisions
Nigeria is broke.
Jonathan ruined Nigeria
I don't have control over the population
My Bold reforms is already yielding results...
It's been 27 years of Tinubu reforms in Lagos, what has it yielded? Worsening water supply, worse feeder roads, worse ratio of government schools to private one?

How will 20 years of his reform in the entire country yield any different result huh

anonimi:
July 29, 2026

Nigeria loses 47% of dollar millionaires, retains 4th position in Africa

Nigeria has lost nearly half of its dollar millionaires over the past decade, with the population of high-net-worth individuals falling by 47 per cent between 2015 and 2025, according to the 2025 Africa Wealth Report by Henley & Partners in collaboration with New World Wealth.

Despite the sharp erosion in private wealth, Nigeria retained its position as Africa’s fourth-largest hub for dollar millionaires, with 7,200 millionaires, 20 centi-millionaires (individuals with investable wealth of at least $100 million) and three billionaires, trailing only South Africa, Egypt and Morocco.

The report showed that South Africa remained the continent’s wealthiest country by number of dollar millionaires, with 41,100 millionaires, 112 centi-millionaires and eight billionaires. Egypt followed with 14,800 millionaires, 49 centi-millionaires and seven billionaires.

https://www.vanguardngr.com/2026/07/nigeria-loses-47-of-dollar-millionaires-retains-4th-position-in-africa/
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

anonimi:
The eyesore on Bourdillon Road
2nd January 2025

Beyond his neighbours, there is something about the sight of people hanging around a president’s residence that does not speak well of his leadership capabilities. Maybe no one has nudged him to see it, but the impression that spectacle on Bourdillon Road generates is that Tinubu enjoys the sight of suffering humans and thrives in—and through— their poverty.

If all these years, impoverished people hang around you and you remain comfortable enough to keep them just so they can be handed tokens of your large heart, then it means you have a pro-poverty mindset. Such a frame of mind is oriented toward cultivating poverty rather than stimulating abundance.

That is why he could unproblematically relate the story of his “friend” who went from using five Rolls Royce to a far-less valued car and not consider the import of the nonsense he was saying. That spurious account was an indication that this is a man for whom poverty—of others, not himself—is an ideal.

https://punchng.com/the-eyesore-on-bourdillon-road/
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by ogolemati: 10:55am On Aug 31
BrickandLace:
I'm glad you know that only someone who hates Nigeria will tell you that .

Many of them are reading this thread.
grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin you are right

Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by BrickandLace(f): 10:56am On Aug 31
anonimi:
It's been 27 years of Tinubu reforms in Lagos, what has it yielded? Worsening water supply, worse feeder roads, worse ratio of government schools to private one?

How will 20 years of his reform in the entire country yield any different result huh


@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
🎵If you ask me.....na who I go ask.... ?🎵
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by Desyner: 10:57am On Aug 31
Nobody takes this poster serious again. Germany has subsidy. Why shouldn't Nigeria do?
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by nairalanda1(op): 11:03am On Aug 31
Desyner:
Nobody takes this poster serious again. Germany has subsidy. Why shouldn't Nigeria do?
Germans also pay nearly half their income as tax, so should Nigeria do the same?

Germany has a diversifed economy, that is industrial, and that exports goods worth trillions of naira annually? Nigeria does not have that kind of economy.

Thus germany has monies for subsidy, Nigeria does not have money for subsidy. Even without corruption.

What part don't you understand, old man? Is telling the truth hard for you? We don't have the money, and the corrupt APC government is making matters worse by not making NIgeria an industrial economy, and fighting corruptoon.

SO, how can I be a tinubu supporter?

LOL.
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by simpleseyi: 11:06am On Aug 31
No, No, No. Tinubu has closed that chapter.
Atiku, AdaObi, Rufai Oseni and Nigeria's jobless youths can keep on debating it.
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by shadyLP(m): 11:06am On Aug 31
BrickandLace:
keep your hope alive

You are a patient taking a bitter medicine

Tinubu is the only president bold to take hard decisions

Nigeria is broke.

Jonathan ruined Nigeria

I don't have control over the population

My Bold reforms is already yielding results...
And why did Tinubu frustrated Jonathan from doing it when Jonathan initially removed the subsidyhuh

Evil people
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by QuickStandard: 11:09am On Aug 31
I will vote Atiku if he will reinstate Subsidy. Tinubu and APC are criminals that should never happen again.

We should be hungry while his goons are living fat with our resources. Using our resources to sponsor city boy movement. Spit
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by nairalanda1(op): 11:13am On Aug 31
QuickStandard:
I will vote Atiku if he will reinstate Subsidy. Tinubu and APC are criminals that should never happen again.

We should be hungry while his goons are living fat with our resources. Using our resources to sponsor city boy movement. Spit
It is okay to vote out tinubu. I think we should all vote out tinubu.

But the problem with subsidy is, let's say government voted 10 trillion naira for subsidy for this year. Then the war in iran pushes up oil prices and subsidy costs to over 18 trillion naira or more. Where is government going to find 8 trillion naira extra at least? Borrowing.

And if government can't find the money, it would be difficult to refine and sell product...scarcity results until government finds some money...which leads to government taking money from the reserves, federal allocations, projects, etc...which lead to salary delays, project delays, and afalling forex reserve, which would bite us hard.

Also, if government tried to do subsidy by selling fuel cheap, it still means that the revenue for funding budget would fall, which could cause things like loan component of next year's budget rising drastically.

At the end, more borrowing, more debt, more risk of refinery becoming scrap.

I am not arguing for tinubu to come back. I am arguing against atiku or obi or anyone bringing back subsidy.
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by Qadaffi2idiamin: 11:17am On Aug 31
The Opoloh eye druqqie is really ditching it out hot on Nigerians.

He is bent on putting Nigeria into poverty to prove his worth to his handlers at IMF
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by shinarambou: 11:19am On Aug 31
In Summary.
Subsidy was helping the rich more than the poor. It was also opaque.

However, when Buhari removed subsidy, Poor people suffer more than the rich.

So, best thing is to give poor people money directly, e.g Nelfund
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by shinarambou: 11:26am On Aug 31
nairalanda1:
if government tried to do subsidy by selling fuel cheap, it still means that the revenue for funding budget would fall, which could cause things like loan component of next year's budget rising drastically.

At the end, more borrowing, more debt, more risk of refinery becoming scrap.

I am not arguing for tinubu to come back. I am arguing against atiku or obi or anyone bringing back subsidy.
Its the debacle people like Tinubu must Navigate and Obi/Atiku are oblivious of.

So many things that require Dollars
There is debt servicing in Dollars.
There is also importing of almost everything (Obis main business).

So they have to choose between subsidy and investi g in growth.

Tinubu seems to be investing in growth... i.e Nelfund, Rails, Major roads... those are good signs.
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by Decent09(m): 11:27am On Aug 31
nairalanda1:
By Halimah Nuhu Sanda




Source: DAILY TRUST
Una never see anything sef, next year Electricity Subsidy will be remove, it's then una go hear Wennnn
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by nairalanda1(op): 11:28am On Aug 31
shinarambou:
Its the debacle people like Tinubu must Navigate and Obi/Atiku are oblivious of.

So many things that require Dollars
There is debt servicing in Dollars.
There is also importing of almost everything (Obis main business).

So they have to choose between subsidy and investi g in growth.

Tinubu seems to be investing in growth... i.e Nelfund, Rails, Major roads... those are good signs.
He's also not fighting corruption (negative), also not dealing with insecurity (a big negative), keeping subsides and price controls on electricity (a large negative..which makes it harder to produce enough electricity to actually stimulate industrial growth) and improving government revenues (the tax reform doesn;t do enough, plus we still rely on oil and raw materials and bororwing...a large negative).
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by Kelklein(m): 11:31am On Aug 31
The man who said 'let the poor breathe, dont suffocate them' when he was campaigning is the one that hasn't allowed the poor breathe for one day since he came on May 29, 2023.

What an irony.. 🤔🤔
Re: Fuel Subsidy: The Debate Nigeria Never Finished by nairalanda1(op): 11:31am On Aug 31
Decent09:
Una never see anything sef, next year Electricity Subsidy will be remove, it's then una go hear Wennnn
Nothing in life is cheap.

Electricity subsidy is causing job losses, and investors leaving the sector because not enough money and return on investment, plus no power supply.

Better it goes so that we can attract investment to the sector, and it can grow.

Believe you me, you won't want government setting your prices. It does the opposite of what you want. Government has kept an electricity subsidy for over 50 years, and the same issues with power that we had in 1984 are the same ones we have today, and as far as I know, tinubu was not president in 1994.
1 2 Reply

Homeland Security Appointment Debate: Nigeria Must Avoid Institutional Overlap • May Nigeria Never Witness Another Buhari’s Govt — Primate Ayodele • 1957 High Schoolers Debate- Nigeria's Boniface Offokaja, Ethiopia, Ghana And SA • 2 • 3 • 4

The Elite Rise For Ibadan • Akala Evacuates 120 Beggars From Major Roads • Court Of Appeal President Ayo Salami Did No Wrong Says NJC Panel