₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,429 members, 8,523,112 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 November 2026 at 06:20 PM

Toggle theme

Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) - Health - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Health › Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) (12139 Views)

1 2 3 Reply (Go Down)

Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by ExAngel007(op): 12:40pm On Sep 01
‘It was donation, not harvesting’ – Medical expert defends Abuja doctors in kidney controversy

An Abuja-based kidney procedure involving several young men was a case of voluntary organ donation rather than illegal trafficking or forced harvesting, a Nigerian medical expert has stated.

Speaking on Channels TV, consultant surgeon Dr. Torngee Malu revealed that the young men’s own statements confirm they were fully aware their kidneys were being harvested for a patient with end-stage kidney disease.

According to Malu, the donors even swore court affidavits prior to the surgeries. Dr. Malu maintained that the medical team followed strict standard procedures, ensuring all donors were consenting adults over 18 operating in a standard hospital.

Defending the financial compensation given to the men, he drew a parallel to routine blood donations where individuals are paid daily for biological tissue. Instead of being victimised by the public, Malu argued that the doctors involved should be celebrated for saving a life.

Watch the video of him speaking below

Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by dawnomike(m):
This doctor should be arrested... So, monetary inducement/coercion is termed voluntary donation.
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by njokuuche77(m): 3:20pm On Sep 01
Chai, see what life has been reduced to in this government regime! 🤦‍♂️
Imagine a whole medical expert comparing kidney donation to blood donation just to justify this.
Blood regenerates in days, but a kidney is gone forever!
It just shows how bad things have gotten under this administration. The economy is so broken that young boys are now forced to sell their vital organs just to survive, and society is packaging it as "voluntary donation."
May God deliver us from this hardship o.
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by creolehunt: 3:20pm On Sep 01
The horrible thing about Nigeria is that anything goes.

That's why you hear people say "if you get money, you go enjoy Nigeria ".

Can this oaf, say or try this abroad?
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by buygala(m): 3:22pm On Sep 01
Make e donate im own too na.. let him use his own kidney to show us how to be legally charitable with ours undecided

Next question is...

After the Doctors harvest the kidney, how much do they charge the recipient?...or is the kidney transplant also done charitably?
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by overdrive(m): 3:23pm On Sep 01
The question is if we had a working economy would they have been tempted to sell their kidneyhuh
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by njokuuche77(m): 3:23pm On Sep 01
Chai, see what life has been reduced to in this tinubu regime.
When hunger wires people, even the unthinkable becomes "voluntary."
It's pure economic desperation driving these young men to swap their health for quick cash. The system has failed them completely, and it's sad to see medical experts sanitizing poverty as "heroism.
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by Rocky247(m): 3:23pm On Sep 01
Drama changing. Lawyers are now doing their dirty jobs
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by Juliette5803(f): 3:24pm On Sep 01
They weren't aware of the implications of their actions
That's why being learned and informed is good
They were just fixed on the financial inducements
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by Youngstar76(m): 3:25pm On Sep 01
Provided the donors were fully aware and of age to understand what they were engaging in including the involved financial compensation, I think the doctors should be exonerated.

Rather the donor scouts are to be blamed.
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by fnep2smooth(m): 3:25pm On Sep 01
you use your kidney money go play sporty bet sure 2odd , game cut. grin



if its possible to sell the second kidney, them go still sell am.

That's how the economy turn out to be, weaponize poverty.
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by emperor4love(m): 3:26pm On Sep 01
Sure now the can even claim the just gave the money for there upkeep till the recover fully from the surgery, that's the way Abuja benue and nassarawa youth are doing, na the new yahoo within there states, ignorance and illiteracy is bad, selling it cheap why this doctor have collected millions
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by LARRYOBRAIN(m): 3:26pm On Sep 01
Nigeria judicial system is dead
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by gigabyte13: 3:26pm On Sep 01
Make them investigate this Doctor well
Him na proff in that business of kidney harvesting.
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by moje4: 3:28pm On Sep 01
I agree with the doctor. The donors know fully well that they will be donating their kidney. Remember, they were not forced, they sign a document, a lawyer was there and it was done openly. The issue of giving out money to the donors doesn't have to do with the doctor. I remember a certain time that I walked into one general hospital and I donated blood. A patient called me and wanted to transfer money to me so I can buy supplement for myself. Regarding monetary aspect, the doctor shouldn't be blamed for it.
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by Dokitto001: 3:28pm On Sep 01
There is ethics in kidney transplanting .

Inducing poor people with cash is not ethical.

Who takes care of these donors long term health?
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by dododawa1: 3:29pm On Sep 01
Can you imagine








NIGERIA turned
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by fasho01(m): 3:29pm On Sep 01
You're probably culpable as well.

This doctor needs to be investigated please
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by Nobody: 3:32pm On Sep 01
Juliette5803:
They weren't aware of the implications of their actions
That's why being learned and informed is good
They were just fixed on the financial inducements
That is the same thing when one goes to the market to buy goods.

The buyer is fixed on the value of the goes and the seller is fixed on the money he will get.

One must loose eventually
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by voortrekker966: 3:32pm On Sep 01
The doctor is simply saying government should regulate the procedure instead of criminalising it. That guy negotiated and collected money and even signed a document to that effect. What is the crime of the hospital and doctors exactly? People are actively looking for where to sell their kidneys as we type.
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by emmy4real94(m): 3:32pm On Sep 01
Lets use your logic, they were given hausa names which means both the contract and affidavit are null and void
So its organ trafficking
ExAngel007:
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by Freddodoty: 3:33pm On Sep 01
The day one of your relatives will have kidney problem, that is the day you will see that that doctor save life
Kidney transplanting is all about life saving, in as much the donor is not force to donate his or her own kidney
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by favour32(m): 3:34pm On Sep 01
Person waka with e legs with normal brains, go sell one kidney....you dey blame doctor?


Blame the Nigerian state.
Blame the politicians.
Blame Tinubu wey increased hardship.


Make US court release some part of Tinubu's past.
We know who e be.

No primary school certificate.
No secondary school certificate.
No class mate.
Na former governor of Cross River State youth picture nai be Tinubu former youth picture.

The man wey nor send anyone but e reach e matter e send.


-----------------E go be for everybody.
Especially some professors wey dey falsify electoral results.
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by Famocious(m):
No lie in what Dr Malu said !

I’m sure there is general wrong conception about organ donations in Nigeria.

We can all survive on one kidney. Any systemic disease that could affect one kidney, it would also affect the 2nd one if it was there..

I’ve seen several altruistic kidney donors in abroad. They donate with no string attached, majority are areligious unlike most of us…
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by worlexy(m): 3:36pm On Sep 01
dawnomike:
This doctor should be arrested... So, monetary inducement/coercion is termed voluntary donation.
You should be arrested for lacking basic comprehension skills. Once someone presents some of you a different perspective from what you are used to, you start criminalizing the person. The people in questions are more than 18 years of age i.e. they are adults, they went to the court to swear an affidavit claiming to be who they are not, have you asked the judge whom they sworn the affidavit to to be arrested for not confirming if the oath was true? So the doctors should be the one doing the work of the legal team of the hospital and the donor? The donors were greedy, they knew what they were getting themselves into. Greed beclouded their senses of reasoning
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by Ablesam171: 3:37pm On Sep 01
Nigeria is not the UK, US, or Iran. The real question is; Is it legal in Nigeria to use money to induce or incentivize someone to donate one of their kidneys?
Definitely, it is illegal to use money to induce a donor. However, it is ultimately for the court to determine whether the donors were actually induced or incentivized with money in this particular case.
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by erad(m): 3:39pm On Sep 01
overdrive:
The question is if we had a working economy would they have been tempted to sell their kidneyhuh
All this stupid working economy nonsense...

USA has a working economy and people donate organs for money every other day. Working economy does not mean all fingers will be equal. Infact, if the economy wasn't working, it will be pointless selling their organs because whatever they get from it will still be useless.

Trying to always talk down on Nigeria over things that happen everywhere but you're too uninformed to read about is just annoying at this point.
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by georgeakins: 3:40pm On Sep 01
njokuuche77:
Chai, see what life has been reduced to in this government regime! 🤦‍♂️
Imagine a whole medical expert comparing kidney donation to blood donation just to justify this.
Blood regenerates in days, but a kidney is gone forever!
It just shows how bad things have gotten under this administration. The economy is so broken that young boys are now forced to sell their vital organs just to survive, and society is packaging it as "voluntary donation."
May God deliver us from this hardship o.
My bloda, your wailing has not started.
Come January 2027, you will wail gnash your teeth in perpetuity
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by Ashirioluwa: 3:44pm On Sep 01
Everything goes in Nigeria. Nigeria is in a deep crisis of corruption and weak law enforcement, where breaking the rules becomes a normal way to survive.
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by overdrive(m): 3:48pm On Sep 01
erad:
All this stupid working economy nonsense...

USA has a working economy and people donate organs for money every other day. Working economy does not mean all fingers will be equal. Infact, if the economy wasn't working, it will be pointless selling their organs because whatever they get from it will still be useless.

Trying to always talk down on Nigeria over things that happen everywhere but you're too uninformed to read about is just annoying at this point.
OGA calm down before you burst an artery. Drop your comments and keep on moving.
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by boxypane: 3:51pm On Sep 01
Were you expecting anything serious from Malu? Them suppose carry am from that station asap.
Re: Kidney Harvest Controversy: Medical Expert Defends Abuja Doctors (Video) by FBIBOT(m): 3:53pm On Sep 01
Lol so is it allowed to offer money and give kidney through backdoor without documentation? This just shows we don't have standards at all anything goes
1 2 3 Reply

Masturbation Boosts The Immune System Against Coronavirus – Medical Expert • Abuja Doctors Begin Strike, Amidst Coronavirus Crisis • Stop Using Saliva As Sex Lubricant - Medical Expert Warns • 2 • 3 • 4

Do You Still Bite Your Fingernails? • Enugu Fire Service Begins Decontamination Of Ogbete Main Market • Coronavirus Patient Never Attempted To Escape – LASG