Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu - Politics (3) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu (11602 Views)
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by HacheNoire: 9:52pm On Sep 11 |
Lithiumite:You nailed it and thanks for that! The either hiding behind religion or ethnicity! When I go all out for Lagos, they call me Igbo When I criticize Peter, I am Yoruba When I support the bravery of Iranians, I am Muslim When I attack Saudi, I am Christian. I have learnt over years I cannot change my people’s perception. Everything in their head is religion. They cannot use personal instinct to decide what’s right or wrong, and make arguments or discussions without religion. |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by 1vandragon: 9:53pm On Sep 11 |
While I think Atiku's proposal requires some clarifications and tweaking, it is absurb the number of people that are actually kicking against a proposal that aims to alleviate the burden of high cost of fuel. To those who love to use the conflict in Hormuz to justify high prices, know that in the world, Nigeria had about the 3rd or 4th highest percentage increase in petrol prices... why? The per capita gdp in Nigeria in 2014 was $4000. Today, it is $1600... in what world is that progress of any sort? Why should Nigerians pay almost the same prices as developed nations? |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Lithiumite: 9:57pm On Sep 11 |
Hismajesty44:By Deeping their hands in ur foreign reserves, tinubu never did,printing more naira in form of ways and Means which is borrowing from cbn,which the results is one of the things we are suffering today. Tinubub is borrowing to build insfrastructure, gej and buhari were borrowing to pay salaries and other recurrent obligations which was no sustainable impact on our economy. |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by 1vandragon: 9:57pm On Sep 11 |
AMINDA:Some of those guys are devoid of any shred of sense. The per capita gdp in US is over $80,000. That of Nigeria is around $1600, and he thinks it is a fair that Nigerians pay almost the same gas prices as the US... |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Lithiumite: 10:04pm On Sep 11 |
amazingspiderma:You need to go back and study the nigerian oil and gas economy.......once subsidy is reintroduced ,investments in local refineries will seize,the PIA bill will become dead as its major objectives would have been undermined. The very reason dangote went ahead with the refinery was because he got assurances from the buhari govt that subsidyvwas going to end......without that ,the refinery would just have been an idea on paper. |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by AMINDA: 10:05pm On Sep 11 |
Putinofrussia:Even if you include the 20 trillion that Buhari borrowed from CBN during Covid 19 when the whole globe was shut down, he still borrowed far less money in his entire 8-year tenure than Tinubu has borrowed in just 3 years. Buhari paid various types of subsidies, Tinubu is not. Buhari delivered more tangible physical infrastructure from roads to railways to ports to bridges to power plants. Tinubu only has the 15 trillion naira coastal road to show which has since been commissioned and named after himself at 47 kilometres. Oh, and student "loans." |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Putinofrussia: 10:11pm On Sep 11 |
AMINDA:Ok. You can continue your ostrich.. |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by MasterTeeUSA: 10:17pm On Sep 11 |
Maybe you should study what subsidy is abi we are not part of OPEC anymore? You want to remove Nigeria from OPEC countries where crude production is controlled and certain amount must be sold to the market...then become Iran and Venezuela after we face our own sanctions. Crude oil is cheap inside Iran primarily because heavy international sanctions restrict its export, leaving a massive surplus within the country that is heavily subsidized for domestic consumption. Saudi Arabia produces cheap crude oil primarily because its massive onshore oil fields require very little money and effort to drill and pump If you think a company in Nigeria that can sell crude for $105 will start selling it at $70 to Dangote...you are dreaming...do you think Nigerian Govt is still in the drilling business in 2026...the same NNPCL that cannot refine without a loss. You all think like Atiku. Lekby25: |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by FatimaAbubakar(f): 10:20pm On Sep 11 |
HacheNoire:Bola Tinubu is a political fraudster. Period! |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by MasterTeeUSA: 10:20pm On Sep 11 |
Lol I hope you are not talking under Buhari where we started printing money which lead to inflation...or you forgot 1 pound used to be N2...so if you do not understand how we got here, you cannot understand what you are proposing is suicidal. If the market is saying we are headed in the right direction, and you are believing Atiku that could not privatize electricity that he will save us...then i understand why we are where we are. Under Buhari, we had to use forward sales of crude just to survive subsidy. Guess you all love your long queues at the pump. Ojuntana: |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by benardtotti(m): 10:21pm On Sep 11 |
amazingspiderma:First off , stop using western countries as yard stick for development, the West used slave labor and then colonisation to develop themselves , no African country had such luxury not even Ethiopia that escaped colonisation., nigeria doesn't have enough resources that it can readily access without heavy financial investment needed or partnership with other advanced countries to access it and they will only partner with you if it benefits them . |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by sleeknaija(m): 10:40pm On Sep 11 |
Ojuntana:They shared it in their APC data boys WhatsApp group. So they were all instructed to copy and paste it in different platforms. |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Ojuntana: 11:16pm On Sep 11 |
MasterTeeUSA:The amusing part of this conversation is how you guys keep predicting doom on all sides. Long queues disappeared because of Dangote refinery not because of subsidy removal. You guys conveniently act as if we were not having fuel shortages in supply after subsidy removal until Dangote refinery came on stream And it was under same Buhari that Dangote got huge import waivers and free dollars that hastened its completion |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Ojuntana: 11:31pm On Sep 11 |
Lithiumite:Reduce your lies na Buhari built Lagos-Ibadan rail. He completed Abuja-Kaduna rail. He resuscitated Warri-Itakpe rail. He completed Lagos-Ibadan road. Let's not mention 2nd Niger bridge so quit the lies that he was just borrowing to pay salaries Tinybu has also had cause to borrow to fund budget and pay salaries |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by jasontrigga(m): 11:37pm On Sep 11 |
Parachoko:How was they paid before ? |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Ojuntana: 11:42pm On Sep 11 |
Lithiumite:Oga stop rewriting history that opened right before our eyes just to defend Tinubu. It makes you sound clueless Dangote started building the refinery in 2013 under GEJ. It was Jonathan that gave him license to build a refinery |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by emorse(m): 12:39am On Sep 12 |
HacheNoire:Read up.. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fossil_fuel_subsidies Lookout for "Subsidies by country". |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Misterone: 1:15am On Sep 12 |
Oga Atiku is talking rubbish. Whether you subsidise production or consumption, subsidy would not work! Yes price would come down but how do you prevent diversion of finished products to neighbouring countries? Because what that means is that we are subsidising our neighbours! Or does he think the boys will not do business? There's no way he can prevent bunkering! Those creeks are porous! |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Nteogwuija(m): 6:29am On Sep 12 |
[quote author=AMINDA post=140608817]Buhari called the bluff of the IMF and his reasons are common sense. , so Buhari is way more intelligent than BAT the first class accountant? |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Inosky: 6:30am On Sep 12 |
Atiku can't give a better govt than Obi. The man who has wasted trillion of naira contesting President is coming to recover his money and not serve you. Just as Buhari never served, so will his brother with the same mentality not coming to serve. Only Peter Obi is here to sacrifice himself and serve to better Nigeria, it's obvious even to the blind. |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Lithiumite: 6:31am On Sep 12 |
Ojuntana:Very good,do you think it was only dangote that had refinery licence,there are several others......I know some people with MFB licences but dont own 1 single shop. Licencing doesn't mean commencing actual project.......the major reason all of them stalled was because govt refused to deregulate the Downstream by regulating prices........there is no way you can introduce subsidy whether consumption or production without givt determining prices and that will be taking you back to the era of inefficiency and waste of govt resources. Tinubu govt is already giving dangote crude in naira so as to mitigate shocks in the international market and impact of dollar volatility,he isn't even getting adequate supply,whether true or not we can never know......if you insist you want to sell to him below market value,he will still complain he isn't getting enough necause he also needs to meet his international obligations too and govt will be loosing money badly........in first quarter alone,he got about 52 million barrels and was still claiming it wasn't enough...... since you won't be subsidising imported fuel which will drive them out of the market,you then will be at the mercy of one man. You can't stop him from selling internationally and what happens of he says he cant sell at the govt regulated price,then we go back to the era of crisis,scarcity,hoarding and oil theft. Even dangote and other refinery owners don't want subsidy because it will end up being a loss to them. |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Lithiumite: 6:41am On Sep 12 |
Ojuntana:Yes you are partly right,with loans........still the 2nd niger bridge access roads still arent completed till date,lagos ibadan still not completed,abuja kaduna was already 90% completed by gej. Tinubu isn't borrowing to pay salaries,I agree he has budget support components in his borrowing but not to pay salaries,if he was it would have been obvious as it was with gej and buhari.......under buhari,debt servicing to revenue ratio was over 100%,under tinubu,its come down to about 60% and still xoming down and one of the major factors for this achievement is because subsidy had ended on pms and dollar which has freed up hitherto misapplied funds to more productive uses. |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Clobisman(m): 7:08am On Sep 12 |
HacheNoire:If USA didn’t subsidize there energy there are other important things the government subsidized and I can’t educate except you pay me for my services. Why didn’t you mention some other OPEC countries that are using this same model Atiku is talking about? Countries like Iran, Algeria, Libya, Kuwait, Congo and so many others. |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Truf: 7:20am On Sep 12 |
You are 1 d.u MB f. O ol. How much is minimum wage in the US? Why did fuel jump from 180 naira to 1500 naira if y'all aren't silly? Fuel isn't supposed to be more than 440-500 after subsidy removal. HacheNoire: |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Eniitankorede: 7:21am On Sep 12 |
AMINDA:You are talking like an illiterate in economics. Subsidy that does not benefit the poor is a wasted subsidy. Most of the subsidised petrol in Nigeria goes to neighbouring countries. Atiku has not told us how he would stop that. Secondly, it is easier to subsidise agricultural produce than petrol because of smuggling. Even the farmers in northern Nigeria have been moving produce to Niger. Our borders are porous and uncontrollable. Secondly, no tax has been raised for poor in Nigeria. If am wrong show us the evidence. The tax net has been widened. But the poor pay less tax. That’s the truth. |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Rayjay45: 7:26am On Sep 12 |
Brilliant article. Isn't it clear to all and sundry now that Atiku has wayyy bigger brains than Tinubu? He saw right through the gimmicks and laid the marker down here. Now think what PO has in-stock for Nigerians.. |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Reference(m): 7:28am On Sep 12 |
The only problem with this is that he has to find A LOT MORE OIL to enable Dangote and others satisfy the Nigerian market independently and end importation of unstable priced oil. I understand there are lots of oil blocks sitting idle and unallocated. Dunno what the problem in the upstream sector is. But anyway the ideology is simple. All governments around the world are anxious about the cost of energy and the effects on their economy and no government out there does not actively seek cheaper energy either through front end or back end interventions. That is the whole premise of America in the Middle East. They not only want to guarantee supplies but prices as well. |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Reference(m): 7:38am On Sep 12 |
Eniitankorede:The last paragraph is not true. Tax is tax from wherever you get it. It comes out of the people at the end, not thin air. It is a zero sum game. Whoever joins the tax bracket is either producing something or serving someone. It will lead to higher costs anywhere it is imposed or captured. The tax debate is a simple one. And to me it remains a question of either 'spending' or 'investment'. If we are simply collecting more taxes to fund recurrent expenditure (which is mainly the case) then we are going nowhere and the economy wil simply not improve. But if we are taxing for direct investment or measurable improvement in government services then the people will see their tax naira working in real terms and wil be less resistant. Right now you can hardly see anything that is measurably better than previous regimes in terms of products or services that government offers to justify the collection of more taxes. |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Morizo(m): 8:08am On Sep 12 |
iwaeda:Ever since Waziri mentioned this plan he has gotten my vote. It's doable and will bring down the cost of petrol significantly. Moreover, we won't be affected that much when there are external conflicts in other parts of the world as per petrol. This model can be replicated in some other sectors too |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Morizo(m): 8:15am On Sep 12 |
Putinofrussia:Production subsidy is coming. Debts Tinubu has incurred will be paid by probing him and his cartel and will be paid and the current salaries will have more value. Nigerians deserve to live better. This government has no timeline in its spurious economic plans. The massive looting going on by this government is enough to pay the subsidy when checked |
| Re: Dangote’s Warning Exposes Tinubu’s Falsehood On Atiku’s Subsidy Plan - Shaibu by Morizo(m): 8:26am On Sep 12 |
badoh:Forward to where Oga....are we going forward or going speedily backwards. What are the indicators in the lives of the people that we are moving forward? We are abjectly poorer that we used to be and that is a forward movement? We have more insecurities and that's foreward? The people in government live Lavishly on our collective patrimony and that's forward? City boys and Remi share trillions of our taxes to their party cronies for elections and that's forward? Or is it the increase of the cost of governance by appointment more docile ministers and expanding agencies and ministries that's forward. We are going forward with production subsidy. Let the heavens fall! We must survive this APC created austerity first before any grammar |
Trump Supports My Fuel Subsidy Plan, Says Atiku • Why Atiku’s Subsidy Gambit Rattles Tinubu- Farooq Kperogi • Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Retrogressive, Fiscally Unsustainable – Bayo Onanuga • 2 • 3 • 4
The Murder Of Obinna Okpokiri • Probe Obasanjo’s Administration, Waku Tells Buhari • Historic Background Of Joe Igbokwe And Family