₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,308 members, 8,522,325 topics. Date: Friday, 20 November 2026 at 11:36 PM

Toggle theme

If Islam Means Submission, Who Submitted And To Whom? - Christianity Etc - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › If Islam Means Submission, Who Submitted And To Whom? (168 Views)

1 Reply (Go Down)

If Islam Means Submission, Who Submitted And To Whom? by Kukutente23(op): 5:19pm On Sep 10
I'll like any Muslim to point me to anywhere in the Qur'an where Allah gave a direct command to Muhammad which Muhammad seemed to be uncomfortable with yet he complied.
We have multiple instances though of Allah submitting to Muhammad's will and I'll cite a few examples

1. When Muhammad desired Zaynab the wife of his adopted son, Allah released a quranic revelation to approve his desire and gave him the go ahead to take her for a wife.

2. Muhammad was praying towards Jerusalem in his bid to win the Jews over to his side. When it became obvious that the Jews had no interest in recognising his prophethood, Muhammad wanted to turn towards his hometown in prayer towards the idol house known as Kaaba. Allah obliged this desire and that's why till today, all Muslims turn towards Mecca in prayer

3. Allah forbade all Muslims from marrying more than four wives. Only Muhammad was given a wildcard to marry 11 and also since he already practiced sexual slavery, it was also approved by Allah for all Muslims

4. Even in banditry, Muhammad was given the go ahead to attack caravans since he claimed that he left Mecca with nothing. This approval is one of the roots of banditry and terrorism today in Islam

5. Even in prayer. Allah initially wanted Muslims to pray 50 times daily but since Muhammad was uncomfortable with the idea, Allah ultimately reduced it to 5 which suited Muhammad better.

6. Even when Muhammad was commanded to read, he said he couldn't read and Allah left him alone. He made no effort to learn how to read in submission to Allah's command and it was all cool with Allah.

Now note the shahada. It says there's no god but Allah AND Muhammad is his messenger. This means to be a true Muslim, you must accept Allah but not only that, you must accept Muhammad as his messenger. This shahada already conflicts with the claim that Islam had other prophets before Muhammad since those prophets never had a shahada which inserted them as consort with Allah and more importantly, they never knew of Muhammad as a messenger of Allah.

Finally, the conclusion is that if you submit to Allah, you're invariably submitting to Muhammad since all the actions and words of Muhammad were approved for the Muslims to follow by Allah.

Thus it begs the question again. In Islam, who do Muslims submit to between Muhammad and Allah?
Re: If Islam Means Submission, Who Submitted And To Whom? by Nukilia: 5:25pm On Sep 10
Stop reading all these brainwashing books and focus on catering for the needs of your family. The bl**dy Arabs never takes a black man serious...
Re: If Islam Means Submission, Who Submitted And To Whom? by FIRDAUS3(m): 5:38pm On Sep 10
A RESPONSE TO THE CLAIM: “IN ISLAM, WHO DO MUSLIMS SUBMIT TO—MUHAMMAD OR ALLAH?”

The question sounds challenging, but it rests on several historical and Qur’anic misunderstandings. Islam does not teach Muslims to submit to Muhammad *instead of* Allah. The Qur’an repeatedly establishes that **Allah alone is the ultimate authority**, while Muhammad ﷺ is His Messenger whose authority comes from Allah.

Allah says:

“Say: Indeed, my prayer, my sacrifice, my living and my dying are for Allah, Lord of the worlds. He has no partner.
> — Qur’an 6:162–163

So the foundation is clear: **submission is ultimately to Allah.**

The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ was not a second god, a partner with Allah, or an independent lawgiver. He was a servant and messenger of Allah.

1. Zaynab and the claim that Allah “approved Muhammad's desire”

This argument assumes the very thing it is trying to prove.

The Qur’an actually records Muhammad ﷺ being **corrected by Allah**, which completely undermines the idea that Allah simply manufactured revelations to satisfy Muhammad's personal desires.

Regarding Zaynab, the Qur’an says:

“You concealed within yourself what Allah was to disclose, and you feared the people, while Allah has more right that you fear Him.”
> — Qur’an 33:37

Notice what is happening: Allah is **criticising His Prophet**, not obeying him.

The marriage had a broader legal and social purpose: eliminating the pre-Islamic assumption that an adopted son was identical to a biological son for purposes of marriage and lineage.

The same verse explicitly says:

“…so that there would be no discomfort for the believers concerning the wives of their adopted sons…”**
> — Qur’an 33:37

And the Qur’an elsewhere makes the distinction explicit:

“Nor has He made your adopted sons your [true] sons.”**
> — Qur’an 33:4

Calling this simply “Muhammad wanted another man's wife and Allah approved it” strips the passage of its actual context.

More importantly, if Muhammad were inventing revelations whenever convenient, why would the Qur’an preserve revelations that rebuke him?

For example:

“He frowned and turned away because there came to him the blind man…”**
> — Qur’an 80:1–2

And:

“May Allah pardon you! Why did you give them permission [to stay behind] before it became evident to you who were truthful…”**
> — Qur’an 9:43

A person fabricating divine revelations to glorify himself would have little obvious reason to preserve public corrections of himself.

---
2. The change of the Qiblah

The claim that Muhammad ﷺ changed the direction of prayer simply because the Jews refused to accept him is an interpretation imposed upon the Qur’an.

The Qur’an itself gives the reason for the change and describes Muhammad ﷺ repeatedly looking toward the sky, waiting for Allah's command:

“We have certainly seen you turning your face toward the heaven, and We will surely turn you to a direction of prayer that will please you.
> — Qur’an 2:144

The crucial point is this:

Muhammad did not independently change the Qiblah. Allah commanded the change.

And the Qur’an immediately frames it as a test of obedience:

“…And We did not make the direction which you formerly faced except to distinguish those who follow the Messenger from those who would turn back…”**
> — Qur’an 2:143

If the argument is that Muhammad was simply making Allah conform to his wishes, then the burden is on the claimant to demonstrate that from the text. The Qur’an does not say, “Muhammad commanded Allah to change the Qiblah.”

Rather, it presents Muhammad as **waiting for revelation**.

---

3. “Allah forbade four wives, but Muhammad was allowed eleven”

This statement is factually wrong.

The Qur’an does **not** say that Allah permitted ordinary Muslim men to marry only four wives in all circumstances and then gave Muhammad an arbitrary “wildcard.”

Qur’an 4:3 says:

“Marry those that please you of [other] women, two or three or four. But if you fear that you will not be just, then [marry only] one…

Then Muhammad ﷺ received **specific marital regulations applicable to him**, just as prophets can have specific obligations and restrictions that do not apply identically to every believer.

But notice something important: **being given a special rule does not make someone God.**

Prophets throughout religious history received particular commands.

The Qur’an itself says:

“The Prophet is closer to the believers than their own selves, and his wives are their mothers.”**
> — Qur’an 33:6

His position therefore involved responsibilities and regulations different from those of ordinary Muslims.

And Qur’an 33:52 actually demonstrates that Muhammad ﷺ was **restricted**:

“It is not lawful for you [to marry additional] women after this…”**

So the picture is not simply “Muhammad wanted women and Allah approved everything.”

---

4. “Muhammad was given permission for banditry and terrorism”

This is a serious historical accusation and should not be made by collapsing warfare, raiding, terrorism and ordinary commercial activity into one category.

The early Muslim community faced persecution, expulsion, confiscation of property and armed conflict. The Qur’an's first permission concerning armed fighting is explicitly connected to people who had been wronged:

“Permission [to fight] has been given to those who are being fought because they were wronged…”**
> — Qur’an 22:39

And the Qur’an establishes limits:

“Fight in the way of Allah those who fight you but do not transgress. Indeed, Allah does not like transgressors.”**
> — Qur’an 2:190

Whatever one's interpretation of individual events in Muhammad's biography, it is intellectually dishonest to take the word “caravan” and automatically translate it into the modern concept of **terrorism**.

Modern terrorism is a specific political and legal category involving deliberate violence against civilians to create fear or achieve political objectives. Applying the word indiscriminately to seventh-century Arabian warfare does not prove anything about Islamic theology.

Indeed, the Qur’an expressly prohibits transgression.

---

5. The story of fifty prayers becoming five

This argument is based primarily on **Hadith**, not on a Qur’anic verse.

But even within the traditional Islamic account, the conclusion does not follow.

According to the famous narration, Moses advised Muhammad ﷺ to ask Allah for a reduction, and Muhammad returned to Allah repeatedly until the obligation was reduced to five daily prayers, while the reward remained equivalent to fifty.

Whether someone accepts the narration or debates its interpretation, it certainly does **not establish that Muhammad controlled Allah.

Quite the opposite: Muhammad had to **petition Allah**.

The servant asks.

Allah decides.

That is submission—not the other way around.

---

6. “Allah commanded Muhammad to read, but Muhammad refused”

This is another misunderstanding of the Arabic word **“Iqra’.”**

The opening revelation is traditionally rendered:

“Read/Recite in the name of your Lord who created.”**
> — Qur’an 96:1

The Arabic verb *iqra’* can carry the meaning **“recite,” “read,” or “proclaim,”** depending on context.

The text does not say Muhammad was commanded to go to school, learn literacy, and then deliberately refused.

In fact, the Qur’an describes Muhammad as **“ummi”** (7:157; 7:158), commonly understood in Islamic scholarship as unlettered/unscriptured, although the precise semantic discussion is more nuanced.

The purpose of the first revelation was not an ordinary literacy lesson.

It was the beginning of revelation.

And again, the fundamental point remains: Muhammad was receiving a command; he was not commanding Allah.

---

THE SHAHADA DOES NOT MAKE MUHAMMAD A PARTNER WITH ALLAH

This may be the biggest conceptual misunderstanding in the entire argument.

The Shahada is:

أشهد أن لا إله إلا الله وأشهد أن محمدًا رسول الله**

“I testify that there is no deity worthy of worship except Allah, and I testify that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah.”**

Look carefully at the wording.

It does **not** say:

“There is no god but Allah and Muhammad.”**

It says:

Allah is the only deity worthy of worship. Muhammad is His Messenger.**

The Qur'an itself repeatedly distinguishes between Allah and His Messenger:

“Muhammad is only a messenger of Allah…”**
> — Qur’an 3:144

And Muhammad himself is commanded to say:

“I am only a human being like you, to whom it has been revealed that your god is One God.”**
> — Qur’an 18:110

So Muhammad's inclusion in the Shahada actually reinforces his status as **Messenger**, not deity.

---

“BUT WHAT ABOUT PREVIOUS PROPHETS?”

The argument that previous prophets could not have been genuine prophets because they did not pronounce Muhammad's Shahada misunderstands Islamic theology.

Muslims believe that **the fundamental message of all prophets was submission to the One God.**

The Qur’an says:

“And We certainly sent into every nation a messenger, [saying], ‘Worship Allah and avoid false gods.’”**
> — Qur’an 16:36

Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Muhammad were not preaching different gods.

Their historical communities had different laws and circumstances, but the central call was worship of the One God.

The Qur’an even describes Abraham as one who **“submitted”** to Allah (2:131).

And Jesus is described as calling people to worship Allah:

“Indeed, Allah is my Lord and your Lord, so worship Him. This is the straight path.”**
> — Qur’an 3:51

Therefore, Muslims do not believe that Muhammad invented the concept of submission to Allah. They believe he **completed and confirmed the prophetic message**.

---

SO, WHO DO MUSLIMS SUBMIT TO—ALLAH OR MUHAMMAD?

Allah.

But the question contains a false choice.

Muslims submit to Allah **by following the Messenger whom Allah commanded them to follow.**

The Qur’an says:

“Whoever obeys the Messenger has indeed obeyed Allah.”**
> — Qur’an 4:80

Why?

Because Muhammad is not being obeyed as a god.

He is being obeyed **as Allah's Messenger.**

There is a huge difference between:

“I obey Muhammad because Muhammad is God.”**

and:

“I obey Muhammad because Allah commanded me to follow His Messenger.”**

Islam teaches the second.

And the Qur’an makes the hierarchy unmistakable:

“O you who believe! Obey Allah and obey the Messenger…”**
> — Qur’an 4:59

Allah is the source of ultimate authority.

Muhammad ﷺ is the Messenger through whom that guidance was conveyed and whose example explains how it is to be lived.

---

THE DEEPER PROBLEM WITH THE ARGUMENT

The argument repeatedly takes:

“Allah gave Muhammad a command”**

and somehow transforms it into:

Allah was obeying Muhammad.”**

Those are not the same thing.

If a king grants an ambassador authority to negotiate, the ambassador does not become the king.

If a government gives a judge authority to issue judgments, the judge does not become the government.

And if Allah gives His Messenger authority to teach, judge and implement revelation, the Messenger does not become Allah.

The Qur'an explicitly warns Muhammad himself:

f he had attributed to Us some false sayings, We would have seized him by the right hand; then We would have cut from him the aorta.
— Qur’an 69:44–46

That is hardly the picture of Allah being controlled by Muhammad.

The Prophet is repeatedly presented as **Allah's servant, messenger, recipient of revelation, and accountable servant.**

So the intellectually honest conclusion is not:

Muslims choose between Allah and Muhammad.”**

It is:

Muslims worship Allah alone and follow Muhammad because Allah commanded them to follow His Messenger.**

That distinction is at the very heart of Islamic monotheism.

Allah is the One worshipped.
Muhammad is the one who delivered the message.
Allah is the Master.
Muhammad is the Messenger.
Allah is the ultimate authority.
Muhammad ﷺ is the servant and Messenger who conveyed His authority.**

Confusing the Messenger with the One who sent him is precisely the theological error Islam itself warns against.
Re: If Islam Means Submission, Who Submitted And To Whom? by CodeTemplar: 5:46pm On Sep 10
You get to submit to the anti-christ and appease them from stage to stage, replacing smallers problems with tough/subtler ones.

Have you ever heard of islamic revival before? Or that a community that has been in bondage for 600 years, worshipping stones and streams, suddenly are free after Islamic intervention by some malams or imams?
Re: If Islam Means Submission, Who Submitted And To Whom? by tunnyl(m): 8:03pm On Sep 10
If not for the sake of discussion theres absolutely no need to respond to posts like this.

Those who truly worship God via the Abrahamic route careless about pointless argument because they know the might of God.

Whether Muslim or Christian God is God
Re: If Islam Means Submission, Who Submitted And To Whom? by illicit(m): 8:10pm On Sep 10
I can be very submissive in bed if need be...
Re: If Islam Means Submission, Who Submitted And To Whom? by Kobojunkie: 8:13pm On Sep 10
tunnyl:
➜If not for the sake of discussion theres absolutely no need to respond to posts like this.
Those who truly worship God via the Abrahamic route careless about pointless argument because they know the might of God.
Whether Muslim or Christian God is God
This is, of course false! The God of Abraham AND Isaac AND Jacob, cannot possibly be the Allah of Islam, the same way that Islamists do not consider their Allah the same entity as Zeus, God of the Greeks or Obatala, God of the Yorubas. 😒😒
Re: If Islam Means Submission, Who Submitted And To Whom? by tunnyl(m): 9:46pm On Sep 10
Kobojunkie:
This is, of course false! The God of Abraham AND Isaac AND Jacob, cannot possibly be the Allah of Islam, the same way that Islamists do not consider their Allah the same entity as Zeus, God of the Greeks or Obatala, God of the Yorubas. 😒😒
They are called Abrahamic faith because they stemmed from Abraham‘s covenant with God. So God of Abraham is the same God of the Jews and Christian.

The dispute among the religions s who Jesus is but who God is is not a dispute
Re: If Islam Means Submission, Who Submitted And To Whom? by Kobojunkie:
tunnyl:
➜They are called Abrahamic faith because they stemmed from Abraham‘s covenant with God. So God of Abraham is the same God of the Jews and Christian.
➜ The dispute among the religions s who Jesus is but who God is is not a dispute
. This is wrong! They are all called Abrahamic faiths merely on the grounds that they all claim(without verified evidence) to be related to the YHWH of Israel. However, when the evidence is considered, none of the 3 religions are mentioned as being a direct result of any of the 2 Covenants that are contained in the Book. 😒😒

2. None of the 3 religions are mentioned in the Book. The 2 covenants revealed in the book specifically established 2 nations - the ancient nation of Israel and the Kingdom of God- into which only the children of Israel and their ancestors are welcomed. 😒😒
Re: If Islam Means Submission, Who Submitted And To Whom? by Kukutente23(op): 9:43am On Sep 11
FIRDAUS3:
A RESPONSE TO THE CLAIM: “IN ISLAM, WHO DO MUSLIMS SUBMIT TO—MUHAMMAD OR ALLAH?”

The question sounds challenging, but it rests on several historical and Qur’anic misunderstandings. Islam does not teach Muslims to submit to Muhammad *instead of* Allah. The Qur’an repeatedly establishes that **Allah alone is the ultimate authority**, while Muhammad ﷺ is His Messenger whose authority comes from Allah.

Allah says:

“Say: Indeed, my prayer, my sacrifice, my living and my dying are for Allah, Lord of the worlds. He has no partner.
> — Qur’an 6:162–163

So the foundation is clear: **submission is ultimately to Allah.**

The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ was not a second god, a partner with Allah, or an independent lawgiver. He was a servant and messenger of Allah.

1. Zaynab and the claim that Allah “approved Muhammad's desire”

This argument assumes the very thing it is trying to prove.

The Qur’an actually records Muhammad ﷺ being **corrected by Allah**, which completely undermines the idea that Allah simply manufactured revelations to satisfy Muhammad's personal desires.

Regarding Zaynab, the Qur’an says:

“You concealed within yourself what Allah was to disclose, and you feared the people, while Allah has more right that you fear Him.”
> — Qur’an 33:37

Notice what is happening: Allah is **criticising His Prophet**, not obeying him.

The marriage had a broader legal and social purpose: eliminating the pre-Islamic assumption that an adopted son was identical to a biological son for purposes of marriage and lineage.

The same verse explicitly says:

“…so that there would be no discomfort for the believers concerning the wives of their adopted sons…”**
> — Qur’an 33:37

And the Qur’an elsewhere makes the distinction explicit:

“Nor has He made your adopted sons your [true] sons.”**
> — Qur’an 33:4

Calling this simply “Muhammad wanted another man's wife and Allah approved it” strips the passage of its actual context.

More importantly, if Muhammad were inventing revelations whenever convenient, why would the Qur’an preserve revelations that rebuke him?

For example:

“He frowned and turned away because there came to him the blind man…”**
> — Qur’an 80:1–2

And:

“May Allah pardon you! Why did you give them permission [to stay behind] before it became evident to you who were truthful…”**
> — Qur’an 9:43

A person fabricating divine revelations to glorify himself would have little obvious reason to preserve public corrections of himself.

---
2. The change of the Qiblah

The claim that Muhammad ﷺ changed the direction of prayer simply because the Jews refused to accept him is an interpretation imposed upon the Qur’an.

The Qur’an itself gives the reason for the change and describes Muhammad ﷺ repeatedly looking toward the sky, waiting for Allah's command:

“We have certainly seen you turning your face toward the heaven, and We will surely turn you to a direction of prayer that will please you.
> — Qur’an 2:144

The crucial point is this:

Muhammad did not independently change the Qiblah. Allah commanded the change.

And the Qur’an immediately frames it as a test of obedience:

“…And We did not make the direction which you formerly faced except to distinguish those who follow the Messenger from those who would turn back…”**
> — Qur’an 2:143

If the argument is that Muhammad was simply making Allah conform to his wishes, then the burden is on the claimant to demonstrate that from the text. The Qur’an does not say, “Muhammad commanded Allah to change the Qiblah.”

Rather, it presents Muhammad as **waiting for revelation**.

---

3. “Allah forbade four wives, but Muhammad was allowed eleven”

This statement is factually wrong.

The Qur’an does **not** say that Allah permitted ordinary Muslim men to marry only four wives in all circumstances and then gave Muhammad an arbitrary “wildcard.”

Qur’an 4:3 says:

“Marry those that please you of [other] women, two or three or four. But if you fear that you will not be just, then [marry only] one…

Then Muhammad ﷺ received **specific marital regulations applicable to him**, just as prophets can have specific obligations and restrictions that do not apply identically to every believer.

But notice something important: **being given a special rule does not make someone God.**

Prophets throughout religious history received particular commands.

The Qur’an itself says:

“The Prophet is closer to the believers than their own selves, and his wives are their mothers.”**
> — Qur’an 33:6

His position therefore involved responsibilities and regulations different from those of ordinary Muslims.

And Qur’an 33:52 actually demonstrates that Muhammad ﷺ was **restricted**:

“It is not lawful for you [to marry additional] women after this…”**

So the picture is not simply “Muhammad wanted women and Allah approved everything.”

---

4. “Muhammad was given permission for banditry and terrorism”

This is a serious historical accusation and should not be made by collapsing warfare, raiding, terrorism and ordinary commercial activity into one category.

The early Muslim community faced persecution, expulsion, confiscation of property and armed conflict. The Qur’an's first permission concerning armed fighting is explicitly connected to people who had been wronged:

“Permission [to fight] has been given to those who are being fought because they were wronged…”**
> — Qur’an 22:39

And the Qur’an establishes limits:

“Fight in the way of Allah those who fight you but do not transgress. Indeed, Allah does not like transgressors.”**
> — Qur’an 2:190

Whatever one's interpretation of individual events in Muhammad's biography, it is intellectually dishonest to take the word “caravan” and automatically translate it into the modern concept of **terrorism**.

Modern terrorism is a specific political and legal category involving deliberate violence against civilians to create fear or achieve political objectives. Applying the word indiscriminately to seventh-century Arabian warfare does not prove anything about Islamic theology.

Indeed, the Qur’an expressly prohibits transgression.

---

5. The story of fifty prayers becoming five

This argument is based primarily on **Hadith**, not on a Qur’anic verse.

But even within the traditional Islamic account, the conclusion does not follow.

According to the famous narration, Moses advised Muhammad ﷺ to ask Allah for a reduction, and Muhammad returned to Allah repeatedly until the obligation was reduced to five daily prayers, while the reward remained equivalent to fifty.

Whether someone accepts the narration or debates its interpretation, it certainly does **not establish that Muhammad controlled Allah.

Quite the opposite: Muhammad had to **petition Allah**.

The servant asks.

Allah decides.

That is submission—not the other way around.

---

6. “Allah commanded Muhammad to read, but Muhammad refused”

This is another misunderstanding of the Arabic word **“Iqra’.”**

The opening revelation is traditionally rendered:

“Read/Recite in the name of your Lord who created.”**
> — Qur’an 96:1

The Arabic verb *iqra’* can carry the meaning **“recite,” “read,” or “proclaim,”** depending on context.

The text does not say Muhammad was commanded to go to school, learn literacy, and then deliberately refused.

In fact, the Qur’an describes Muhammad as **“ummi”** (7:157; 7:158), commonly understood in Islamic scholarship as unlettered/unscriptured, although the precise semantic discussion is more nuanced.

The purpose of the first revelation was not an ordinary literacy lesson.

It was the beginning of revelation.

And again, the fundamental point remains: Muhammad was receiving a command; he was not commanding Allah.

---

THE SHAHADA DOES NOT MAKE MUHAMMAD A PARTNER WITH ALLAH

This may be the biggest conceptual misunderstanding in the entire argument.

The Shahada is:

أشهد أن لا إله إلا الله وأشهد أن محمدًا رسول الله**

“I testify that there is no deity worthy of worship except Allah, and I testify that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah.”**

Look carefully at the wording.

It does **not** say:

“There is no god but Allah and Muhammad.”**

It says:

Allah is the only deity worthy of worship. Muhammad is His Messenger.**

The Qur'an itself repeatedly distinguishes between Allah and His Messenger:

“Muhammad is only a messenger of Allah…”**
> — Qur’an 3:144

And Muhammad himself is commanded to say:

“I am only a human being like you, to whom it has been revealed that your god is One God.”**
> — Qur’an 18:110

So Muhammad's inclusion in the Shahada actually reinforces his status as **Messenger**, not deity.

---

“BUT WHAT ABOUT PREVIOUS PROPHETS?”

The argument that previous prophets could not have been genuine prophets because they did not pronounce Muhammad's Shahada misunderstands Islamic theology.

Muslims believe that **the fundamental message of all prophets was submission to the One God.**

The Qur’an says:

“And We certainly sent into every nation a messenger, [saying], ‘Worship Allah and avoid false gods.’”**
> — Qur’an 16:36

Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Muhammad were not preaching different gods.

Their historical communities had different laws and circumstances, but the central call was worship of the One God.

The Qur’an even describes Abraham as one who **“submitted”** to Allah (2:131).

And Jesus is described as calling people to worship Allah:

“Indeed, Allah is my Lord and your Lord, so worship Him. This is the straight path.”**
> — Qur’an 3:51

Therefore, Muslims do not believe that Muhammad invented the concept of submission to Allah. They believe he **completed and confirmed the prophetic message**.

---

SO, WHO DO MUSLIMS SUBMIT TO—ALLAH OR MUHAMMAD?

Allah.

But the question contains a false choice.

Muslims submit to Allah **by following the Messenger whom Allah commanded them to follow.**

The Qur’an says:

“Whoever obeys the Messenger has indeed obeyed Allah.”**
> — Qur’an 4:80

Why?

Because Muhammad is not being obeyed as a god.

He is being obeyed **as Allah's Messenger.**

There is a huge difference between:

“I obey Muhammad because Muhammad is God.”**

and:

“I obey Muhammad because Allah commanded me to follow His Messenger.”**

Islam teaches the second.

And the Qur’an makes the hierarchy unmistakable:

“O you who believe! Obey Allah and obey the Messenger…”**
> — Qur’an 4:59

Allah is the source of ultimate authority.

Muhammad ﷺ is the Messenger through whom that guidance was conveyed and whose example explains how it is to be lived.

---

THE DEEPER PROBLEM WITH THE ARGUMENT

The argument repeatedly takes:

“Allah gave Muhammad a command”**

and somehow transforms it into:

Allah was obeying Muhammad.”**

Those are not the same thing.

If a king grants an ambassador authority to negotiate, the ambassador does not become the king.

If a government gives a judge authority to issue judgments, the judge does not become the government.

And if Allah gives His Messenger authority to teach, judge and implement revelation, the Messenger does not become Allah.

The Qur'an explicitly warns Muhammad himself:

f he had attributed to Us some false sayings, We would have seized him by the right hand; then We would have cut from him the aorta.
— Qur’an 69:44–46

That is hardly the picture of Allah being controlled by Muhammad.

The Prophet is repeatedly presented as **Allah's servant, messenger, recipient of revelation, and accountable servant.**

So the intellectually honest conclusion is not:

Muslims choose between Allah and Muhammad.”**

It is:

Muslims worship Allah alone and follow Muhammad because Allah commanded them to follow His Messenger.**

That distinction is at the very heart of Islamic monotheism.

Allah is the One worshipped.
Muhammad is the one who delivered the message.
Allah is the Master.
Muhammad is the Messenger.
Allah is the ultimate authority.
Muhammad ﷺ is the servant and Messenger who conveyed His authority.**

Confusing the Messenger with the One who sent him is precisely the theological error Islam itself warns against.
You did not negate anything I wrote with your thesis
You only framed it differently. The bottomline still remains that Allah was submitting to Muhammad's desires and then he commanded Muslims to submit to Muhammad as well. So ultimately, you're submitting to Muhammad not Allah since Allah himself submits to Muhammad.
Take for example your argument about the shahada. Why should it be Muhammad that will be mentioned in the shahada out of all the other prophets? Why not Adam is his messenger? Or Ibrahim is his messenger? Or Musa is via messenger? Or Isa is his messenger? Why did the shahada have to carry Muhammad alone as Allah's messenger? That shows a special place reserved for Muhammad above all other prophets.
In conclusion, you can't point to anywhere in the Qur'an where Allah gave Muhammad a command he was uncomfortable with and he had no choice but to carry it out!
Re: If Islam Means Submission, Who Submitted And To Whom? by TenQ: 5:03am On Sep 12
FIRDAUS3:
A RESPONSE TO THE CLAIM: “IN ISLAM, WHO DO MUSLIMS SUBMIT TO—MUHAMMAD OR ALLAH?”

The question sounds challenging, but it rests on several historical and Qur’anic misunderstandings. Islam does not teach Muslims to submit to Muhammad *instead of* Allah. The Qur’an repeatedly establishes that **Allah alone is the ultimate authority**, while Muhammad ﷺ is His Messenger whose authority comes from Allah.

Allah says:

“Say: Indeed, my prayer, my sacrifice, my living and my dying are for Allah, Lord of the worlds. He has no partner.
> — Qur’an 6:162–163

So the foundation is clear: **submission is ultimately to Allah.**

The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ was not a second god, a partner with Allah, or an independent lawgiver. He was a servant and messenger of Allah.

1. Zaynab and the claim that Allah “approved Muhammad's desire”

This argument assumes the very thing it is trying to prove.

The Qur’an actually records Muhammad ﷺ being **corrected by Allah**, which completely undermines the idea that Allah simply manufactured revelations to satisfy Muhammad's personal desires.

Regarding Zaynab, the Qur’an says:

“You concealed within yourself what Allah was to disclose, and you feared the people, while Allah has more right that you fear Him.”
> — Qur’an 33:37

Notice what is happening: Allah is **criticising His Prophet**, not obeying him.

The marriage had a broader legal and social purpose: eliminating the pre-Islamic assumption that an adopted son was identical to a biological son for purposes of marriage and lineage.

The same verse explicitly says:

“…so that there would be no discomfort for the believers concerning the wives of their adopted sons…”**
> — Qur’an 33:37

And the Qur’an elsewhere makes the distinction explicit:

“Nor has He made your adopted sons your [true] sons.”**
> — Qur’an 33:4

Calling this simply “Muhammad wanted another man's wife and Allah approved it” strips the passage of its actual context.

More importantly, if Muhammad were inventing revelations whenever convenient, why would the Qur’an preserve revelations that rebuke him?

For example:

“He frowned and turned away because there came to him the blind man…”**
> — Qur’an 80:1–2

And:

“May Allah pardon you! Why did you give them permission [to stay behind] before it became evident to you who were truthful…”**
> — Qur’an 9:43

A person fabricating divine revelations to glorify himself would have little obvious reason to preserve public corrections of himself.

---
2. The change of the Qiblah

The claim that Muhammad ﷺ changed the direction of prayer simply because the Jews refused to accept him is an interpretation imposed upon the Qur’an.

The Qur’an itself gives the reason for the change and describes Muhammad ﷺ repeatedly looking toward the sky, waiting for Allah's command:

“We have certainly seen you turning your face toward the heaven, and We will surely turn you to a direction of prayer that will please you.
> — Qur’an 2:144

The crucial point is this:

Muhammad did not independently change the Qiblah. Allah commanded the change.

And the Qur’an immediately frames it as a test of obedience:

“…And We did not make the direction which you formerly faced except to distinguish those who follow the Messenger from those who would turn back…”**
> — Qur’an 2:143

If the argument is that Muhammad was simply making Allah conform to his wishes, then the burden is on the claimant to demonstrate that from the text. The Qur’an does not say, “Muhammad commanded Allah to change the Qiblah.”

Rather, it presents Muhammad as **waiting for revelation**.

---

3. “Allah forbade four wives, but Muhammad was allowed eleven”

This statement is factually wrong.

The Qur’an does **not** say that Allah permitted ordinary Muslim men to marry only four wives in all circumstances and then gave Muhammad an arbitrary “wildcard.”

Qur’an 4:3 says:

“Marry those that please you of [other] women, two or three or four. But if you fear that you will not be just, then [marry only] one…

Then Muhammad ﷺ received **specific marital regulations applicable to him**, just as prophets can have specific obligations and restrictions that do not apply identically to every believer.

But notice something important: **being given a special rule does not make someone God.**

Prophets throughout religious history received particular commands.

The Qur’an itself says:

“The Prophet is closer to the believers than their own selves, and his wives are their mothers.”**
> — Qur’an 33:6

His position therefore involved responsibilities and regulations different from those of ordinary Muslims.

And Qur’an 33:52 actually demonstrates that Muhammad ﷺ was **restricted**:

“It is not lawful for you [to marry additional] women after this…”**

So the picture is not simply “Muhammad wanted women and Allah approved everything.”

---

4. “Muhammad was given permission for banditry and terrorism”

This is a serious historical accusation and should not be made by collapsing warfare, raiding, terrorism and ordinary commercial activity into one category.

The early Muslim community faced persecution, expulsion, confiscation of property and armed conflict. The Qur’an's first permission concerning armed fighting is explicitly connected to people who had been wronged:

“Permission [to fight] has been given to those who are being fought because they were wronged…”**
> — Qur’an 22:39

And the Qur’an establishes limits:

“Fight in the way of Allah those who fight you but do not transgress. Indeed, Allah does not like transgressors.”**
> — Qur’an 2:190

Whatever one's interpretation of individual events in Muhammad's biography, it is intellectually dishonest to take the word “caravan” and automatically translate it into the modern concept of **terrorism**.

Modern terrorism is a specific political and legal category involving deliberate violence against civilians to create fear or achieve political objectives. Applying the word indiscriminately to seventh-century Arabian warfare does not prove anything about Islamic theology.

Indeed, the Qur’an expressly prohibits transgression.

---

5. The story of fifty prayers becoming five

This argument is based primarily on **Hadith**, not on a Qur’anic verse.

But even within the traditional Islamic account, the conclusion does not follow.

According to the famous narration, Moses advised Muhammad ﷺ to ask Allah for a reduction, and Muhammad returned to Allah repeatedly until the obligation was reduced to five daily prayers, while the reward remained equivalent to fifty.

Whether someone accepts the narration or debates its interpretation, it certainly does **not establish that Muhammad controlled Allah.

Quite the opposite: Muhammad had to **petition Allah**.

The servant asks.

Allah decides.

That is submission—not the other way around.

---

6. “Allah commanded Muhammad to read, but Muhammad refused”

This is another misunderstanding of the Arabic word **“Iqra’.”**

The opening revelation is traditionally rendered:

“Read/Recite in the name of your Lord who created.”**
> — Qur’an 96:1

The Arabic verb *iqra’* can carry the meaning **“recite,” “read,” or “proclaim,”** depending on context.

The text does not say Muhammad was commanded to go to school, learn literacy, and then deliberately refused.

In fact, the Qur’an describes Muhammad as **“ummi”** (7:157; 7:158), commonly understood in Islamic scholarship as unlettered/unscriptured, although the precise semantic discussion is more nuanced.

The purpose of the first revelation was not an ordinary literacy lesson.

It was the beginning of revelation.

And again, the fundamental point remains: Muhammad was receiving a command; he was not commanding Allah.

---

THE SHAHADA DOES NOT MAKE MUHAMMAD A PARTNER WITH ALLAH

This may be the biggest conceptual misunderstanding in the entire argument.

The Shahada is:

أشهد أن لا إله إلا الله وأشهد أن محمدًا رسول الله**

“I testify that there is no deity worthy of worship except Allah, and I testify that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah.”**

Look carefully at the wording.

It does **not** say:

“There is no god but Allah and Muhammad.”**

It says:

Allah is the only deity worthy of worship. Muhammad is His Messenger.**

The Qur'an itself repeatedly distinguishes between Allah and His Messenger:

“Muhammad is only a messenger of Allah…”**
> — Qur’an 3:144

And Muhammad himself is commanded to say:

“I am only a human being like you, to whom it has been revealed that your god is One God.”**
> — Qur’an 18:110

So Muhammad's inclusion in the Shahada actually reinforces his status as **Messenger**, not deity.

---

“BUT WHAT ABOUT PREVIOUS PROPHETS?”

The argument that previous prophets could not have been genuine prophets because they did not pronounce Muhammad's Shahada misunderstands Islamic theology.

Muslims believe that **the fundamental message of all prophets was submission to the One God.**

The Qur’an says:

“And We certainly sent into every nation a messenger, [saying], ‘Worship Allah and avoid false gods.’”**
> — Qur’an 16:36

Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Muhammad were not preaching different gods.

Their historical communities had different laws and circumstances, but the central call was worship of the One God.

The Qur’an even describes Abraham as one who **“submitted”** to Allah (2:131).

And Jesus is described as calling people to worship Allah:

“Indeed, Allah is my Lord and your Lord, so worship Him. This is the straight path.”**
> — Qur’an 3:51

Therefore, Muslims do not believe that Muhammad invented the concept of submission to Allah. They believe he **completed and confirmed the prophetic message**.

---

SO, WHO DO MUSLIMS SUBMIT TO—ALLAH OR MUHAMMAD?

Allah.

But the question contains a false choice.

Muslims submit to Allah **by following the Messenger whom Allah commanded them to follow.**

The Qur’an says:

“Whoever obeys the Messenger has indeed obeyed Allah.”**
> — Qur’an 4:80

Why?

Because Muhammad is not being obeyed as a god.

He is being obeyed **as Allah's Messenger.**

There is a huge difference between:

“I obey Muhammad because Muhammad is God.”**

and:

“I obey Muhammad because Allah commanded me to follow His Messenger.”**

Islam teaches the second.

And the Qur’an makes the hierarchy unmistakable:

“O you who believe! Obey Allah and obey the Messenger…”**
> — Qur’an 4:59

Allah is the source of ultimate authority.

Muhammad ﷺ is the Messenger through whom that guidance was conveyed and whose example explains how it is to be lived.

---

THE DEEPER PROBLEM WITH THE ARGUMENT

The argument repeatedly takes:

“Allah gave Muhammad a command”**

and somehow transforms it into:

Allah was obeying Muhammad.”**

Those are not the same thing.

If a king grants an ambassador authority to negotiate, the ambassador does not become the king.

If a government gives a judge authority to issue judgments, the judge does not become the government.

And if Allah gives His Messenger authority to teach, judge and implement revelation, the Messenger does not become Allah.

The Qur'an explicitly warns Muhammad himself:

f he had attributed to Us some false sayings, We would have seized him by the right hand; then We would have cut from him the aorta.
— Qur’an 69:44–46

That is hardly the picture of Allah being controlled by Muhammad.

The Prophet is repeatedly presented as **Allah's servant, messenger, recipient of revelation, and accountable servant.**

So the intellectually honest conclusion is not:

Muslims choose between Allah and Muhammad.”**

It is:

Muslims worship Allah alone and follow Muhammad because Allah commanded them to follow His Messenger.**

That distinction is at the very heart of Islamic monotheism.

Allah is the One worshipped.
Muhammad is the one who delivered the message.
Allah is the Master.
Muhammad is the Messenger.
Allah is the ultimate authority.
Muhammad ﷺ is the servant and Messenger who conveyed His authority.**

Confusing the Messenger with the One who sent him is precisely the theological error Islam itself warns against.
Mohammed is actually pseudo-Allah and vise versa.

1. Mohammed used the name of Allah for his benefits

To prove this,
Quran 33:36
"And it is not for a believing man or a believing woman, when Allah and His Messenger have decided a matter, that they should have any option [or choice] about their decision. And whoever disobeys Allah and His Messenger has certainly strayed into clear error."


If Allah is indeed the God of Mohammed, it is Allah who should decide NOT Allah and Mohammed.

2. Law of Blasphemy against Allah and Mohammed.

According to your Sharia, Blasphemy against Mohammed results in EXECUTION with no opinion of forgiveness

However, Blasphemy against Allah may be subject to forgiveness IF the offender recount/repent.

3. Even Aisha noticed that Allah was quick to please Mohammed. Allah wanted whatever Mohammed desired Quran 33:51

Sahih al-Bukhari 4788
Narrated Aisha: I used to look down upon those ladies who had given themselves to Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) and I used to say, "Can a lady give herself (to a man)?" But when Allah revealed: "You (O Muhammad) can postpone (the turn of) whom you will of them (your wives), and you may receive any of them whom you will; and there is no blame on you if you invite one whose turn you have set aside (temporarily).' (33.51) I said (to the Prophet), "I feel that your Lord hastens in fulfilling your wishes and desires."

4. Mohammed ALONE had EXCEPTIONS to the law/rules Binding other Muslims especially wrt SEX and MONEY.

I am sure you know of the 16 privilegs of Mohammed alone. (Al-Khasa'is al-Nabawiyya)

Other than Mohammed, tell me the name of a single prophet who has these kinds of special privileges.

If you like we can look in detail at Tafsir Al-Qurtubi on Surah Al-Ahzab (33:50)



5. Association of the the NAME and KNOWLEDGE of Allah with that of Mohammed.

Examples
a. In your shahada you associated the name of Allah and Mohammed
b. In your Sunnah, you associate the knowledge of Allah and Mohammed. You say "Allah and his apostle know"

Sorry!!!
Re: If Islam Means Submission, Who Submitted And To Whom? by tunnyl(m): 9:15am On Sep 12
Kobojunkie:
. This is wrong! They are all called Abrahamic faiths merely on the grounds that they all claim(without verified evidence) to be related to the YHWH of Israel. However, when the evidence is considered, none of the 3 religions are mentioned as being a direct result of any of the 2 Covenants that are contained in the Book. 😒😒

2. None of the 3 religions are mentioned in the Book. The 2 covenants revealed in the book specifically established 2 nations - the ancient nation of Israel and the Kingdom of God- into which only the children of Israel and their ancestors are welcomed. 😒😒
My brother! I concur!
Re: If Islam Means Submission, Who Submitted And To Whom? by Kobojunkie: 3:07pm On Sep 12
tunnyl:
➜My brother! I concur!
You agree, yet earlier you claimed that the YHWH of Israel was the same as the Allah of Islam and that the 3 religions, which have absolutely nothing to do with anything in the Book, as they instead cater to ideas foreign to the Book, are of the Book? Come on naw! How can you concur when you are clearly contradicted by your own submissions?😒😒
1 Reply

What If Islam/arab Culture Had Spread Throughout Africa? • Is "Islam Means Peace" An Irony? Picture Prove • Submission: Who Is Wrong Between Bishop Oyedepo And Daddy Freeze?- Bisi Adewale • 2 • 3 • 4

Open Heavens Daily Devotional Of 06/11/2026 • Daily Communion With God || Pastor D.A. Taiwo • Prayer Points On Today's Open Heavens:thursday , April 16, 2020