₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,345,845 members, 8,519,794 topics. Date: Monday, 16 November 2026 at 07:35 PM

Toggle theme

Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan - Politics (2) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan (4875 Views)

1 2 3 Reply (Go Down)

Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by CrownedPhoenix:
razzydoo:
Stockholm ko Brussels ni. tongue angry
Na where your brain reach be that.

Once they point out your shallowness, you all go personal.

But a moment ago, you were analyzing, stay on the analysis and let's have a proper conversation, you want to trivialise it.

Brussel ko, oshi,sko ni
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by Nteogwuija(m): 9:24am On Sep 16
Lithiumite:
The problem with atiku supporters like yourself is your inability to be able to think things through properly........your 700k barrels you are quoting for Saudi Arabia,which I really doubt......Saudi produces about 7m barrels per day with a population less than a quarter of ours.

Nigeria does just 1.7m bpd and you want to take out 440 according to you for a population of over 200m people, pls do the maths,do you know how much govt will be bleeding in revenue?

Atiku should come out and tell us,how much he thinks Nigeria earns and how much his so called subsidy will cost........also there is no way you can introduce subsidy without dictating how much dangote will sell his petrol which is totally against the PIA bill......if you tamper with it,you will drive away investments in that sector,thats job losses,revenue losses,,oil theft and smuggling all in one.
Well, the uninformed electorates, the ones you people refer to as 'grassroots,' won't understand all these ure saying. Atiku is merely speaking in their language, what they'll understand.

It's thesame thing Tinubu did in 2012 when Jonathan tried to remove fuel subsidy. Tinubu spoke in 'defense' of the 'grassroots,' and the APC eventually won the election.

In 2023 what did Tinubu, the one who asked if fuel of 97 naira or dollar of 250 naira was okay, do first day in office?

He did the extreme opposite of what he protested against.

What did Tinubu say again? All is fair in politics.
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by tonididdy(m): 9:24am On Sep 16
Subsidy removal is the biggest scam in this administration.

Where do you think the extra % governors are sharing is from?

The people will suffer, while they grow richer.... Who doesn't like a Boss like that?
That's why they'll kill to ensure he remains in power
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by Gotocourt: 9:24am On Sep 16
mycar:
all what the government needs to do is to shore up the Nigerian Naira, stronger naira will bring down the price of fuel without making it cheaper to our neighboring countries
Tinubu should use the excess profit he is making from the high cost of crude to shore up the naira for the benefit of the masses.
This has only been my position. Subsidise dollar let naira have more value.
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by papagiddy(m): 9:26am On Sep 16
Talk is cheap.....very cheap....Mr desperado
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by ElSudani:
Educationalserv:
he didn't mess up when subsidy return if you lilke pay higher to show over lasting support for Failure Tinibu.

Crude oil was given free to Nigeria by God . If must be proceed in Nigeria for a Nigerian
440,000 barrels is meant to be proceed locally
Saudis process 700,000 barrels for local consumption at affordable rent .
The essence of govt is for wellbeing of citizens
Not wellbeing of Lebanese handling Costal road
Crude oil was given to us by God, this is very true. Why don't you go there and fetch it like water and use it since it is freely given to us.
Which refinery is Atiku talking about? The ones that are not working or the one somebody built with his $20 billion dollars and still rely on some imported crude to keep running?
Atiku is dreaming along with his supporters.
This is the type of populist nonsense that made it impossible for Dangote and Otedola to buy those moribund refineries in the first place.
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by BrickandLace(f): 9:30am On Sep 16
papagiddy:
Talk is cheap.....very cheap....Mr desperado
Everyone knows the name of the most desperate most dangerous politician in Nigeria.

And it's not Atku.

You're beginning to sound really desperate BTW
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by razzydoo(m): 9:33am On Sep 16
E pain you reach like that!😅
But I didn't abuse you. You even came at me aggressively so I had to defend well. You could have engaged me properly. Okay, back to the matter.
If let's say you invested 1b$ into Dangote and Atiku is campaigning with bringing back subsidy and policies against local refining and encouraging importation although now he's trying to change mouth saying the subsidy would encourage local production which we know is a lie because subsidy in Nigeria is about assisting importation, what would be your decision?
CrownedPhoenix:
Na where your brain reach be that.

Once they point out your shallowness, you all go personal.

A moment ago, you were analyzing, stay on analysis and let's have a proper conversation, you want to trivialise it.

Brussel ko, oshi,sko ni
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by 1vandragon: 9:36am On Sep 16
As much as I feel that Atiku still needs to refine his vision and factor in fx rates, he has laid out his plan and seems to be the only one that seeks to reduce current socio-economic burden on the masses.

That said, bat is a very heartless and greedy character. And those that use the Hormuz conflict as excuse for pms increases are even more disconnected in their brains.

Why can't the FG supply adequate crude to dangote?

Has the cost of extracting the crude oil from Nigerian soil increased significantly since the Hormuz conflict?

The 2026 budget was done with an expected crude oil price of $65 per barrel, and this already factors in profits. So why can't the FG continue to supply dangote at $65 per barrel so that the refined products from him can be sold domestically at significantly cheaper prices.

It is said that it is when a mosquito perches on the scrotum of a violent man that he knows that there are gentler ways to resolve conflict...
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by Osgilliat(m): 9:37am On Sep 16
Fiscus105:
Is it not govt that would curb smuggling? why did they put custom officials at the border, if they know anything can still be coming in and getting out?

Let govt of the day, jail one or two custom officials and see border tighten by others.


You people should stop supporting govt in can't function in her duty and put his negligence on the citizens to bear.
If the govt like let them put billions of customs at the border that still won’t stop fuel smuggling as long as the rewards of smuggling fuel is high Nigerians will still find a way to bribe those customs.Our borders can’t be easily manage like other countries. The only way to stop fuel smuggling is to make it less rewarding.

You said “government who can’t function in her duty”.. who is the government? Is it not you, me and all of us? We are the one sabotaging the little effort the werey government we have is giving.
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by razzydoo(m): 9:37am On Sep 16
Don't worry, I understand your frustrations. Infact I share and empathize with you. Like you said by December, we'll reexamine the reality.
BrickandLace:
When did your refinery become "our" refinery ?

That refinery is good for nothing if Nigerians, whose forex was used to build it are paying 1,500 per litre.

We know by December it will be 2000

Rubbish refinery.
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by delkuf(m): 9:38am On Sep 16
Am beginning to like atiku. I dont kbw those giving peter obi advice, he is becoming sluggish. Obi dont talk on issue base things like atiku is doing.
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by BrickandLace(f): 9:38am On Sep 16
razzydoo:
Don't worry, I understand your frustrations. Infact I share and empathize with you. Like you said by December, we'll reexamine the reality.
December isn't far.

All sleepers will awaken.
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by Thiefobi1: 9:39am On Sep 16
Atiku is begining to sound incoherent.

Maybe as a result of old-age.
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by razzydoo(m): 9:39am On Sep 16
Might be you o. grin
BrickandLace:
December isn't far.

All sleepers will awaken.
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by BrickandLace(f): 9:40am On Sep 16
razzydoo:
Might be you o. grin
But it might not be ooo cheesy
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by AMINDA: 9:46am On Sep 16
delkuf:
Am beginning to like atiku. I dont kbw those giving peter obi advice, he is becoming sluggish. Obi dont talk on issue base things like atiku is doing.
On what basis will Obi decide to come out publicly and back Tinubu's subsidy removal and naira floatation despite seeing how bad the twin policies turned out? As a leading opposition candidate, if you ever find yourself on the same side with the incumbent, then it's better to back out of the race and support their candidacy. Obi has very poor advisers. Silence would have been a better strategy. Now, his supporters find themselves arguing on the same side with Tinubu supporters in support of subsidy removal.
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by PresidentAtiku(m):
Lithiumite:
The problem with atiku supporters like yourself is your inability to be able to think things through properly........your 700k barrels you are quoting for Saudi Arabia,which I really doubt......Saudi produces about 7m barrels per day with a population less than a quarter of ours.

Nigeria does just 1.7m bpd and you want to take out 440 according to you for a population of over 200m people, pls do the maths,do you know how much govt will be bleeding in revenue?

Atiku should come out and tell us,how much he thinks Nigeria earns and how much his so called subsidy will cost........also there is no way you can introduce subsidy without dictating how much dangote will sell his petrol which is totally against the PIA bill......if you tamper with it,you will drive away investments in that sector,thats job losses,revenue losses,,oil theft and smuggling all in one.
See long story and rubbish written to justify hardship

I know it is not in the character of the devil to do anything good, allow the people with good intentions to govern Nigeria. APC CAN NEVER MAKE NIGERIA BETTER

Hardship is a trait of the APC but sadly, it is affecting everyone. It is confirmed that you people are confused and now forcing hardship as the only way out, disguised as stupid reforms.

WE WILL KICK YOU OUT
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by anonimi: 9:52am On Sep 16
Bobloco:
“I am not restoring subsidy so that Nigeria can keep paying for imported petrol. I am restoring subsidy so that Nigerians can produce more at home, pay less for fuel, and keep more money in their pockets,” he said.

The ADC candidate distinguished between what he called “import subsidy” and “production subsidy”, using the shoe-making industry in Aba as an illustration.
This right here is the difference between what the subsidy Tinubu continues to pay illegally to Malta blending plant importers and Atiku's proposal that will further unleash productivity here as it did in 1999 when PDP implemented deregulation and privatisation policies for widespread prosperity, cheap petrol without huge debt burden.

Why is petrol so expensive despite Tinubu paying subsidies to importers of petrol to destroy Dangote refinery?


"Tinubu made living in Nigeria expensive. I will make Nigeria affordable again" - Alhaji Atiku Abubakar


anonimi:
NNPCL’s subsidy payment jump by 47.9% to N7.1trn in 2024

November 26, 2025

The Nigerian National Petroleum Company Limited (NNPCL) paid a total of N7.1 trillion as subsidy for premium motor spirit (PMS) in 2024, this sum represents a 47.9 percent increase from N4.8 trillion recorded in 2023.

This is despite the government’s announcement of subsidy removal in 2023.

The company explained that the amount, which it termed ‘energy security expense’ arises when there is differential between the exchange rate used to freeze the premium motor spirit ex-coastal price and the prevailing rate at the point of import settlement.

According to the report, government had instructed that NNPC Limited cannot sell its PMS above a certain regulated price. It added that the cost of petrol import is usually much higher that the regulated price.

https://businessday.ng/news/article/nnpcls-subsidy-payment-jump-by-47-9-to-n7-1trn-in-2024/?amp

Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by lamentor78(m): 9:58am On Sep 16
One of the most stupid human being on earth are Nigerians, a politician is deceiving them about sudsidy removal but they failed to ask him how much he will sell fuel. they tend to put their hope of mere promise forgetting that once he grab power he will spend 4 years , they see the same man they have once tag has a thief as their new Messiah .
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by Reloadedisraelp: 9:59am On Sep 16
Osgilliat:
Atiku still doesn’t get it. He knows he has messed up with his declaration of bringing back subsidy now he is trying to twist the narratives. He shouldn’t be talking about supporting local refineries he should be talking about how he plans to curb fuel smuggling to other countries if he is to bring back subsidy. Because smuggling is the biggest issue in the subsidy regime.
the man is confuse....fuel subsidy/snuggling is one of the leading corruption scheme in Nigeria destroying both individuals n economy yet this man want it back just because he wants to be president... Any president that support this have a zero investment for the future and a corruption enablers.
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by Educationalserv: 10:03am On Sep 16
ElSudani:
Crude oil was given to us by God, this is very true. Why don't you go there and fetch it like water and use it since it is freely given to us.
Which refinery is Atiku talking about? The ones that are not working or the one somebody built with his $20 billion dollars and still rely on some imported crude to keep running?
Atiku is dreaming along with his supporters.
This is the type of populist nonsense that made it impossible for Dangote and Otedola to buy those moribund refineries in the first place.
when fuel is back to 500 please don't buy out of anger .
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by Educationalserv: 10:04am On Sep 16
Reloadedisraelp:
the man is confuse....fuel subsidy/snuggling is one of the leading corruption scheme in Nigeria destroying both individuals n economy yet this man want it back just because he wants to be president... Any president that support this have a zero investment for the future and a corruption enablers.
so because some dull people don't know how to tackle corruption in oil industry we 200m Nigerians will now suffer
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by Reloadedisraelp: 10:06am On Sep 16
Educationalserv:
so because some dull people don't know how to tackle corruption in oil industry we 200m Nigerians will now suffer
are u saying when subsidy was there we ain't suffering? 🤔
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by zeyt: 10:10am On Sep 16
Hi
Lithiumite:
The problem with atiku supporters like yourself is your inability to be able to think things through properly........your 700k barrels you are quoting for Saudi Arabia,which I really doubt......Saudi produces about 7m barrels per day with a population less than a quarter of ours.

Nigeria does just 1.7m bpd and you want to take out 440 according to you for a population of over 200m people, pls do the maths,do you know how much govt will be bleeding in revenue?

Atiku should come out and tell us,how much he thinks Nigeria earns and how much his so called subsidy will cost........also there is no way you can introduce subsidy without dictating how much dangote will sell his petrol which is totally against the PIA bill......if you tamper with it,you will drive away investments in that sector,thats job losses,revenue losses,,oil theft and smuggling all in one.
Whatever Oil is for all of us If we can't get it for free let us buy it cheaper.
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by Wotowotoman: 10:17am On Sep 16
Educationalserv:
so because some dull people don't know how to tackle corruption in oil industry we 200m Nigerians will now suffer
Ahib, you don buy Dangote shares? 🤔
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by Svoboda(m): 10:24am On Sep 16
Osgilliat:
Atiku still doesn’t get it. He knows he has messed up with his declaration of bringing back subsidy now he is trying to twist the narratives. He shouldn’t be talking about supporting local refineries he should be talking about how he plans to curb fuel smuggling to other countries if he is to bring back subsidy. Because smuggling is the biggest issue in the subsidy regime.
Because there's smuggling the citizens have to pay for governments negligence and incompetence in protecting our borders?
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by IkeOnyia:
I expected the leaders of oil producing states of the Niger Delta to be at the forefront of opposition to the return of fuel subsidies because they are the ones who are cheated in that scam.
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by Olannposi: 10:51am On Sep 16
This will appeal to people with little or no foresight, who are unable to think deeply about the consequences.
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by yemre: 10:55am On Sep 16
Osgilliat:
Atiku still doesn’t get it. He knows he has messed up with his declaration of bringing back subsidy now he is trying to twist the narratives. He shouldn’t be talking about supporting local refineries he should be talking about how he plans to curb fuel smuggling to other countries if he is to bring back subsidy. Because smuggling is the biggest issue in the subsidy regime.
Yes, he can twist his narrative because he is aware of the level of gullibility of some people who lack brains of their own but just jump on whatever aligns with what appeals to them.

He would bring back subsidy, explain how and he started saying he would make the fuels refined in Nigeria. Is dangote refining his fuel in Japan or Dubai? And is dangote the only one with a refinery license?

Abeg make he shift.
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by denitro(m): 11:09am On Sep 16
Lithiumite:
The problem with atiku supporters like yourself is your inability to be able to think things through properly........your 700k barrels you are quoting for Saudi Arabia,which I really doubt......Saudi produces about 7m barrels per day with a population less than a quarter of ours.

Nigeria does just 1.7m bpd and you want to take out 440 according to you for a population of over 200m people, pls do the maths,do you know how much govt will be bleeding in revenue?

Atiku should come out and tell us,how much he thinks Nigeria earns and how much his so called subsidy will cost........also there is no way you can introduce subsidy without dictating how much dangote will sell his petrol which is totally against the PIA bill......if you tamper with it,you will drive away investments in that sector,thats job losses,revenue losses,,oil theft and smuggling all in one.
Suppose Nigeria's crude is worth $80/barrel internationally.

An importer buys crude from Saudi Arabia for $80, refines it abroad, and brings the petrol into Nigeria.

Nigeria then subsidizes the imported petrol.

Old Subsidy:
Nigeria had be using public money to make imported petroleum cheaper for Nigerians even though the crude used to produce that petrol generated no Nigerian upstream oil revenue.

That's the structural difference in what Atiku is proposing

In simplified form:

OLD MODEL

🇸🇦 Saudi crude → foreign refinery → Nigeria → government subsidy → Nigerian consumer

while potentially separately:

🇳🇬 Nigerian crude → international market → oil revenue to Nigeria

The two transactions aren't automatically connected.

Now compare that with Atiku's proposed production subsidy

This is where his proposal is conceptually different.

Instead of:

Foreign crude → foreign refinery → import petrol → Nigerian government subsidizes imported petrol

the proposed model would be closer to:

Nigerian crude → Nigerian refinery → domestic petrol → production subsidy → Nigerian consumer

That creates a potentially different fiscal relationship.

Imagine Nigerian crude has a market value of $80, but the government makes eligible domestic refineries able to obtain it at an effective $68 under the subsidy mechanism.

The government is effectively supporting domestic refining by $12/barrel.

But the crude is still being processed inside Nigeria.

So you could potentially have:

Nigerian crude → Nigerian refinery → petrol

rather than:

Saudi/other foreign crude → foreign refinery → imported petrol.

And that's why the argument about the subsidy needs to distinguish what is being subsidized.

Old subsidy

Subsidize the consumption/imported product.

Atiku's stated proposal

Subsidize domestic production/input.

Those are economically different mechanisms.

And importantly, the existence of the Dangote refinery changes the situation from the historical period when Nigeria had very limited functioning refining capacity. Reuters currently reports that Dangote's refinery is a 700,000-barrel-per-day facility and has reached full capacity.

The really interesting question

Your argument can therefore be reduced to this:

Why should Nigeria subsidize petrol produced from foreign crude and refined abroad when it can instead use a production subsidy to make Nigerian crude available to Nigerian refineries at a supported price?
Re: Atiku Defends Subsidy Return Plan by Axis313(m): 11:20am On Sep 16
Lithiumite:
The problem with atiku supporters like yourself is your inability to be able to think things through properly........your 700k barrels you are quoting for Saudi Arabia,which I really doubt......Saudi produces about 7m barrels per day with a population less than a quarter of ours.

Nigeria does just 1.7m bpd and you want to take out 440 according to you for a population of over 200m people, pls do the maths,do you know how much govt will be bleeding in revenue?

Atiku should come out and tell us,how much he thinks Nigeria earns and how much his so called subsidy will cost........also there is no way you can introduce subsidy without dictating how much dangote will sell his petrol which is totally against the PIA bill......if you tamper with it,you will drive away investments in that sector,thats job losses,revenue losses,,oil theft and smuggling all in one.
People that recently buy Dangote refinery shares will never vote for those that base their campaign on subsidy reintroduction because it will adversely affect their profits, infact if subsidy is brought back Dangote refinery shares will plummet.
1 2 3 Reply

Tinubu Defends Subsidy Removal, Vows Inclusive Economic Reforms • Atiku Defends Corps Member Over Viral Tinubu Criticism • Petrol Subsidy ‘return’: NNPCL, IMF Disagree Over N8.43trn Loss • 2 • 3 • 4

NNPC Vehemently Denies Fuel Subsidy Report • Why Jonathan Can't Save Soludo, Despite Intense Lobby By Ndigbo, S/east Govs⁠ • Dollarization Of The APC Primaries: How Amaehi Vanquished Atiku #saibuhari