₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,346 members, 8,522,500 topics. Date: Saturday, 21 November 2026 at 11:41 AM

Toggle theme

Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished - European Football (EPL, UEFA, La Liga) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Entertainment › Sports › European Football (EPL, UEFA, La Liga) › Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished (13310 Views)

Poll: What do you think should be done for such costly mistakes going forward?

The match affected should be replayed 30% (58 votes)
The officials responsible for such errors should be retired permanently or face a longer match ban 29% (57 votes)
Human referees should be phased out gradually and let Robots+AI take charge 7% (14 votes)
I am okay with this present punishment 32% (62 votes)
This poll has ended

1 2 3 Reply (Go Down)

Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by Mattswaggz(op): 8:47am On Sep 16
Video assistant referee Matt Donohue has paid the price for his catastrophic error at Old Trafford. He has been removed from officiating duties for this week's upcoming round of Premier League matches.

A spokesperson for the professional referees' committee said: "Matt Donohue and Blake Antrobus have not received any appointments for this week's matches following the Manchester derby on Sunday."

The spokesperson added: "The decision, taken by the head of the referees' committee Howard Webb and the management team, comes with the announcement of the latest appointments for match referees, meaning that the video assistant referee and the assistant video assistant referee in the Manchester United and Manchester City match will not officiate any match until at least after the international break."


Within a few minutes of the final whistle, Webb rang Donohue to demand an explanation. The former teacher is a Tottenham fan from Essex who moved to Manchester for university a decade ago and still lives there.

Shortly after 9pm on Sunday, the professional referees' committee published an official clarification of the incident.

Their spokesperson said: "The video assistant referee did not realise the potential impact of his position, and he should have recommended a review of the footage via the pitchside screen."

He continued: "Manchester United were contacted this evening to acknowledge what we consider an error of judgement, and a comprehensive review of the incident will be conducted."

Webb accepted this was human error. Even so, he saw the need to act decisively.


Premier League officials believe Webb's proactive response helped to address the crisis. The review is expected to be swift and to deliver clear, strong recommendations to prevent a recurrence.

"The Sun" confirm the Premier League has no plans to lodge any formal objection with Webb and the referees' committee, believing that publicly taking responsibility for the error was an important and open step.

Donohue and Antrobus will now sit out all officiating duties until at least 11 October.
https://www.goal.com/en/news/a-swift-punishment-var-referee-pays-the-price-for-his-mistake-in-the-manchester-derby/blte79ace6ecf12d3f3

Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by Mattswaggz(op):
Medicine after death.....Even me that was a spectator knew that the goal shouldn't have stood because even if Haaland was onside, Enzo that was offside interfered with play hence, the goal shouldn't have stood yet more than one professional referee handling VAR want to make us believe they didn't see it and now see what they're calling punishment. grin.

Seriously, the premier League needs to do better about these blatant referee/VAR errors and inconsistencies.....for a league that prides itself as the best in the world....fair and consistent refereeing should be the least of things we should expect from them. undecided.
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by Sonnobax15(m):
lipsrsealed
EPL and their waYo cha angry

Imagine that uselexxxx history united who couldn't break through the defence of a 10 man's man city team is the one crying wolf here , instead of them to bury their head in shame angry
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by Gbadugbakun(m): 12:24pm On Sep 16
Why can't they just award 3 points to manu and stop all these story so that we will rest.

Because even if the dash them the 3 point they still won't finish top 10. So why all the arguments. undecided
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by Militant1: 12:25pm On Sep 16
fair is fair, game is game
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by motymop: 12:25pm On Sep 16
Medicine after death...they are fond of that
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by phenomental40(m): 12:25pm On Sep 16
Bribery and corruption at play here
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by lawyer(m): 12:26pm On Sep 16
Only 2 weeks punishment for an action that could cause Manchester United to be relegated at the end of the season? Not fair!angry But as an Arsenal Fan, Matt Donohue is a hero and should have his statue built at the Emirates for doing a great service to Humankind grin grin grin grin
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by WorkTheTalk(m): 12:29pm On Sep 16
Corruption everywhere. Just a damage control. The goal cannot be reversed.
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by UkoAnnang(m): 12:29pm On Sep 16
shocked

That's nothing provide that Manchester United lost points in that match.

2026/2026 season is Manchester United woeful season to relegation and then into oblivion
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by Reloadedisraelp: 12:29pm On Sep 16
Gbadugbakun:
Why can't they just award 3 points to manu and stop all these story so that we will rest.

Because even if the dash them the 3 point they still won't finish top 10. So why all the arguments. undecided
this is how u guys started last season and we finished 3rd ....mk una nor worry our good days are coming.. cool
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by Starz825(m): 12:29pm On Sep 16
This stuff was as clear as the sky

But no, wrong decisions will be passed cos some dingus are making money off it

Na bet go spoil epl football
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by MartinCorridon: 12:31pm On Sep 16
The red card should have been issued to Foden and Bruno too

So 2 don divide 4 = 2 🤷
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by Usmanovic95(m): 12:32pm On Sep 16
Calling for a replay is the only way to remedy the situation. How can you rob people just to start apologizing and not return what you stole from them?
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by Reloadedisraelp: 12:33pm On Sep 16
Starz825:
This stuff was as clear as the sky

But no, wrong decisions will be passed cos some dingus are making money off it

Na bet go spoil epl football
I sure say the assistant referee play bet and maybe na e last game. grin
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by smallsmall: 12:34pm On Sep 16
Mattswaggz:
Medicine after death.....Even me that was a spectator knew that the goal shouldn't have stood because even if Haaland was onside, Enzo that was offside interfered with play hence, the goal shouldn't have stood yet more than one professional referee handling VAR want to make us believe they didn't see it and now see what they're calling punishment. grin.

Seriously, the premier League needs to do better about these blatant referee/VAR errors and inconsistencies.....for a league that prides itself as the best in the world....fair and consistent refereeing should be the least of things we should expect from them. undecided.
These arrogant Referees are ruining English Football.
The spontaneous joy one gets from seeing a beautiful goal scored, is no longer there.
One Muppet Referee or VAR sitting somewhere will just ruin the whole thing.
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by allen113: 12:34pm On Sep 16
Waste of punishment, 10 against 11 and man u couldn't register one goal. Useless team grin
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by CollectMoney: 12:35pm On Sep 16
Person wey don cash out. grin
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by yomi531(m): 12:35pm On Sep 16
lawyer:
Only 2 weeks punishment for an action that could cause Manchester United to be relegated at the end of the season? Not fair!angry But as an Arsenal Fan, Matt Donohue is a hero and should have his statue built at the Emirates for doing a great service to Humankind grin grin grin grin
City is looking very strong this season u know abi? I expect an Arsenal fan like u ,to be on man utd's side in this issue. They're gonna give Arsenal a long run for their money. U should be worried bros
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by kinzd(m): 12:35pm On Sep 16
Noisy Neighbours have done theirs lemme ask what if the VAR decision have favoured Man united will Webb really intervene?
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by fasho01(m): 12:35pm On Sep 16
Fair enough punishment as results cannot be reversed post match

Painful but we move
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by smallsmall: 12:37pm On Sep 16
Reloadedisraelp:
this is how u guys started last season and we finished 3rd ....mk una nor worry our good days are coming.. cool
The fact that Man-U could not beat a 10-Man Mancity, shows how low that team has got.
You can just see that they lack imagination, lack belief in themselves, they lack the fighting Spirit and wont go beyond the lower ten position of the Table, at the end of the day
,
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by fredoooooo:
They're deceiving you people ..
When are they going to punish Howard Webb.. and the other refrees that help united.
What of the refree and the VAR official 2 weeks ago that allow united first goal vs Ipswich ..
Corrupt system ... ojoro united
grin cheesy grin
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by frankson1(m): 12:37pm On Sep 16
Bobo juice. Very inconsequential punishment undecided
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by frankson1(m): 12:38pm On Sep 16
smallsmall:
The fact that Man-U could not beat a 10-Man Mancity, shows how low that team has got.
You can just see that they lack imagination, lack belief in themselves, they lack the fighting Spirit and wont go beyond the lower ten position of the Table, at the end of the day
,
I'm sure you're among those who escaped from YABA LEFT.
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by Reloadedisraelp: 12:39pm On Sep 16
smallsmall:
The fact that Man-U could not beat a 10-Man Mancity, shows how low that team has got.
You can just see that they lack imagination, lack belief in themselves, they lack the fighting Spirit and wont go beyond the lower ten position of the Table, at the end of the day
,
and yet we still top ur team last team.
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by iichidodo: 12:43pm On Sep 16
People think it's the fault of VAR whereas it just three or two blokes sitting around a video screen...
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by tnerro1(m): 12:43pm On Sep 16
If dem manage score one goal, shey e for reduce all this nonsense
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by opera1(m): 12:46pm On Sep 16
Gbadugbakun:
Why can't they just award 3 points to manu and stop all these story so that we will rest.

Because even if the dash them the 3 point they still won't finish top 10. So why all the arguments. undecided
Even if they dash Manchester United 6 point, dey will still be at the bottom table
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by davillian(m): 12:47pm On Sep 16
Mattswaggz:
Medicine after death.....Even me that was a spectator knew that the goal shouldn't have stood because even if Haaland was onside, Enzo that was offside interfered with play hence, the goal shouldn't have stood yet more than one professional referee handling VAR want to make us believe they didn't see it and now see what they're calling punishment. grin.

Seriously, the premier League needs to do better about these blatant referee/VAR errors and inconsistencies.....for a league that prides itself as the best in the world....fair and consistent refereeing should be the least of things we should expect from them. undecided.
Person way they for ask to clean the whole seats for next match
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by Kalulu44: 12:48pm On Sep 16
kinzd:
Noisy Neighbours have done theirs lemme ask what if the VAR decision have favoured Man united will Webb really intervene?
Has the intervention giving man United the 3pts
Re: Matt Donohue: The VAR Referees For The Manchester Derby Has Been Punished by Jayhome24: 12:48pm On Sep 16
I knew Football is about to be messed up the moment over pamper Argentina bitch started, the moment Messi must always have his way in world cup, the moment the sour face Trump started interfering in football matter and so on I knew this beautiful sport need urgent reform orelse..........
1 2 3 Reply

Derby County Vs Manchester United. FA CUP: (0 - 3) On 5th March 2020 • Chelsea Vs Derby County: Carabao Cup (3 - 2) On 31st October 2018 • Manchester United VS Derby County: Carabao Cup (7 - 8 On Pens : 25-09-2018 • 2 • 3 • 4

Leicester City Vs Manchester City 0 - 2 On 3rd April 2021 • Brighton and Hove Albion Vs Arsenal (0 - 0) On 2nd October 2021 • Brest Vs Nice: 4 - 1 (Full Time)