₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,307 members, 8,522,313 topics. Date: Friday, 20 November 2026 at 10:55 PM

Toggle theme

Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas - Christianity Etc - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas (357 Views)

1 2 Reply (Go Down)

Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by HacheNoire(op): 10:08pm On Oct 02
I was today years old when I learnt this!

Over to you Christians, what’s your take?

Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Kobojunkie:
HacheNoire:
I was today years old when I learnt this! Over to you Christians, what’s your take?
The Gospel of Barnabas has been shown to have been compiled in the 1400-1600s, only a couple of hundred years after the Quran and its numerous Hadiths were written and compiled? The book is suggested to have been written by an Imam who had read the Bible, or maybe a convert from Christianity to Islam who had little to no exposure to the Old Testament.😒😒😒

Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by RealityKings1: 10:24pm On Oct 02
Don't confuse yourself

Something that was written in 16th century AD.
And Mohammed was 632 AD. That means it was written well after Mohammads death.
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Kobojunkie: 11:07pm On Oct 02
RealityKings1:
Don't confuse yourself Something that was written in 16th century AD. And Mohammed was 632 AD. That means it was written well after Mohammads death.
And it was intentionally written by a dubious soul to suggest that Mohammed's fairy tale could somehow be connected to the Gospels. You can easily tell because it included mentions of Mohammed's tale of his name being mentioned by Adam. That is how terrible it is. 😒😒
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by RealityKings1: 11:14pm On Oct 02
Kobojunkie:
And it was intentionally written by a dubious soul to suggest that Mohammed's fairy tale could somehow be connected to the Gospels. You can easily tell because it included mentions of Mohammed's tale of his name being mentioned by Adam. That is how terrible it is. 😒😒
People try to twist themselves into history unfortunately, their head and legs don't always fit in grin
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by HacheNoire(op): 11:29pm On Oct 02
Kobojunkie:
The Gospel of Barnabas has been shown to have been compiled in the 1400-1600s, only a couple of hundred years after the Quran and its numerous Hadiths were written and compiled? The book is suggested to have been written by an Imam who had read the Bible, or maybe a convert from Christianity to Islam who had little to no exposure to the Testament.😒😒😒
So we can say it’s not a Christian book right?
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Kemical23(m): 11:48pm On Oct 02
Two silly brothers bring this Christianity and Islam..
The man who brought Islam is very wicked and dangerous person while the man who brought Christianity is emotional and deceitful..
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Kobojunkie:
HacheNoire:
➜So we can say it’s not a Christian book right?
A book that dates over 1400 years after Jesus Christ of Israel, most likely written by a non-Israelite and an Islamist somewhere in Spain, is most definitely not a part of the collection of books that belong in Israelite Scripture let alone the covenant made by the YHWH of Israel only for the Israelites. That is what I can tell you of this. 😒😒
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Kobojunkie: 11:49pm On Oct 02
Kemical23:
➜Two silly brothers bring this Christianity and Islam.. The man who brought Islam is very wicked and dangerous person while the man who brought Christianity is emotional and deceitful..
What brothers? 😒😒
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by HacheNoire(op): 11:52pm On Oct 02
Kobojunkie:
A book that dates back over 1400 years after Jesus Christ of Israel, by a non-Israelite and an Islamist somewhere in Spain, is most definitely not a part of the collection of books that belong in Israelite Scripture, let alone the covenant made by the YHWH of Israel only for the Israelites. That is what I can tell you of this. 😒😒
I was researching your statement and happens to be true. The only false flag is that, he was Jewish and the Catholics and Anglican’s recognize him.
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Kobojunkie: 12:00am On Oct 03
HacheNoire:
➜I was researching your statement and happens to be true. The only false flag is that, he was Jewish and the Catholics and Anglican’s recognize him.
You are not making any sense. The author of the book is unknown. So, how could you claim he was Jewish? Even if we are to assume he were indeed Jewish, how would it change anything about the fact that his book was never considered as part of Israelite scripture? The Talmud, for instance, was written by Jews, yet not a single word of it is considered part of Israelite Scripture.😒😒

Also, the Catholics and Anglicans have never been the authority as far as Israelite Scriptures, all of which predate both organizations by hundreds of years. So, why are you dead set on doing this to your brain? 😒😒
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by HacheNoire(op): 12:07am On Oct 03
Kobojunkie:
You are not making any sense. The author of the book is unknown. So, how could you claim he was Jewish? Even if we are to assume he were indeed Jewish, how would it change anything about the fact that his book was never considered as part of Israelite scripture? The Talmud, for instance, was written by Jews, yet not a single word of it is considered part of Israelite Scripture.😒😒

Also, the Catholics and Anglicans have never been the authority as far as Israelite Scriptures, all of which predate both organizations by hundreds of years. So, why are you dead set on doing this to your brain? 😒😒
So if the Talmud was a lead, then Jesus himself was not recognized in the Talmud and present day Jewish doctrine. Does the Talmud lead you stated also fly?

Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Kobojunkie: 12:12am On Oct 03
HacheNoire:
➜So if the Talmud was a lead,
➜ then Jesus himself was not recognized in the Talmud and present day Jewish doctrine.
➜ Does the Talmud lead you stated also fly?
The Talmud was never a lead! I used that example to show you that not just any book written by Jews or Israelites made the list as far as Israelite Scripture is concerned. The book known as the Talmud was compiled beginning around the time the Jews were in Babylon, that is, at least 400 years before Jesus Christ of Israel, yet it never made it into Israelite Scripture. Israel was warned against the lying scribes of Israel writing their own ideas into the mouth of YHWH. 😒😒

2. The Talmud was never standard, even though it does mention Jesus Christ of Israel in false light, being the book written by the lying scribes of Israel that it is. 😒😒

3. Again, the Talmud was never a lead! 😒😒


The image you have there does not have anything to do the author of the so-called "Gospel of Barnabas."
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by HacheNoire(op): 12:16am On Oct 03
Kobojunkie:
The Talmud was never a lead! I used that example to show you that not just any book written by Jews or Israelites made the list as far as Israelite Scripture is concerned. The book known as the Talmud was compiled beginning around the time the Jews were in Babylon, that is, at least 400 years before Jesus Christ of Israel, yet it never made it into Israelite Scripture. Israel was warned against the lying scribes of Israel writing their own ideas into the mouth of YHWH. 😒😒

2. The Talmud was never standard, even though it does mention Jesus Christ of Israel in false light, being the book written by the lying scribes of Israel that it is. 😒😒

3. Again, the Talmud was never a lead! 😒😒
So the baseline should be the Ethiopian Bible since Barnabas never had a book there.

But then, if it is the baseline, why then some of the present in the Ethiopian Bible are missing in the generally accepted Bible?

I am learning and not fight, I just want to get to the roots of how to include and defend in future encounters when I have to make valid points.
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Kobojunkie: 12:23am On Oct 03
HacheNoire:
➜So the baseline should be the Ethiopian Bible since Barnabas never had a book there.
➜ But then, if it is the baseline, why then some of the present in the Ethiopian Bible are missing in the generally accepted Bible?
➜ I am learning and not fight, I just want to get to the roots of how to include and defend in future encounters when I have to make valid points.
1. The baseline of Israelite Scripture remains the manuscripts, all of which date back to the period before the 1st century AD. The different translations of the manuscripts out there are just that: translations of the books of Israelite Scripture. 😒😒

2. Again, the baseline for all Israelite Scriptures is the manuscripts that date to the period before the destruction of Jerusalem and Judea, before the 1st century AD. 😒😒

3. The different translations out there are merely works that draw mostly from the manuscripts of Israelite Scripture.😒
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by HacheNoire(op): 12:31am On Oct 03
Kobojunkie:
1. The baseline of Israelite Scripture remains the manuscripts, all of which date back to the period before the 1st century AD. The different translations of the manuscripts out there are just that: translations of the books of Israelite Scripture. 😒😒

2. Again, the baseline for all Israelite Scriptures is the manuscripts that date to the period before the destruction of Jerusalem and Judea, before the 1st century AD. 😒😒

3. The different translations out there are merely works that draw mostly from the manuscripts of Israelite Scripture.😒
I am not a religious person so your narration is confusing me.

Can you spell out clearly in like 3 clear sentences. Like why the books of Barnabas is invalid and why some sect recognize him while others deny.

I want specific pointers I can hold on to.
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Kobojunkie: 12:35am On Oct 03
HacheNoire:
➜I am not a religious person so your narration is confusing me.
➜ Can you spell out clearly in like 3 clear sentences. Like why the books of Barnabas is invalid and why some sect recognize him while others deny. I want specific pointers I can hold on to.
I am not a religious person either. I hate religion, though I accept it has a place in the lives of people and nations. '😒😒

2. I already did that in my first comment to you. No Christian or Judaic sect recognizes the Gospel of Barnabas because they are aware that the book was written and that its existence was mentioned sometime in the 1600s. 😒😒
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by HacheNoire(op): 12:43am On Oct 03
Kobojunkie:
I am not a religious person either. I hate religion, though I accept it has a place in the lives of people and nations. '😒😒

2. I already did that in my first comment to you. No Christian or Judaic sect recognizes the Gospel of Barnabas because they are aware that the book was written and that its existence was mentioned sometime in the 1600s. 😒😒
Where does Catholics and Anglican fall in your description?

Because, if a catholic or Anglican should join the discussion, they will also have points to nullify your stance.
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Kobojunkie: 12:49am On Oct 03
HacheNoire:
➜Where does Catholics and Anglican fall in your description?
➜ Because, if a catholic or Anglican should join the discussion, they will also have points to nullify your stance.
fall in what description? Both of those do not recognize the so-called Gospel of Barnabas. 😒

2. Points to nullify: what stance? Again, the Gospel of Barnabas has no basis in Israelite Scripture. Also, none of the organizations you mentioned has such texts included in their compendium of books of Israelite texts. 😒😒
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by JovialJune(f): 1:11am On Oct 03
Kemical23:
Two silly brothers bring this Christianity and Islam..
The man who brought Islam is very wicked and dangerous person while the man who brought Christianity is emotional and deceitful..
Jesus that existed 600 years before Muhammed is who you call brothers?

Are you high on something?
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Kemical23(m): 2:07am On Oct 03
JovialJune:
Jesus that existed 600 years before Muhammed is who you call brothers?

Are you high on something?
and you are a witness.
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Dtruthspeaker: 4:32am On Oct 03
HacheNoire:
So we can say it’s not a Christian book right?
Have you seen any Christian quote this book as authority?

Nope

In fact today is the first time i am seeing/hearing of this
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Dtruthspeaker: 7:52am On Oct 03
JovialJune:
Jesus that existed 600 years before Muhammed is who you call brothers?

Are you high on something?
The guy is loo as you can see from his response to you.
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Dtruthspeaker: 7:55am On Oct 03
Kemical23:
and you are a witness.
When you said what you said, were you a witness?

It is clear God has cussd you to be ma...
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Ubenedictus(m): 8:29am On Oct 03
HacheNoire:
Where does Catholics and Anglican fall in your description?

Because, if a catholic or Anglican should join the discussion, they will also have points to nullify your stance.
Its a Gnostic text. Not Catholic or Anglican
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by MaxInDHouse(m): 12:30pm On Oct 03
Walahi talahi some people just like talking trash.

How can a Barnabas who never lived in the time of Jesus be one who tells what happened during the time of Jesus?🥱
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by StoryHaven: 1:29pm On Oct 03
Kemical23:
Two silly brothers bring this Christianity and Islam..
The man who brought Islam is very wicked and dangerous person while the man who brought Christianity is emotional and deceitful..
Many are mad few are roaming the streets.

When you read some comments, you dont need a soothsayer to tell you the state of mind of the comment poster.
grin
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by honesttalk21: 5:48pm On Oct 03
HacheNoire:
I was today years old when I learnt this!

Over to you Christians, what’s your take?
It may seem interesting though I first came across this book in 2000/2001 with some sense of intrigue. However the original Gospel of Barnabas appears among rejected apocrypha in the 5th-century Decretum Gelasianum and the List of the Sixty Books as the church fixed its canon by weighing apostolic authority; even though Barnabas was an apostle and Paul's colleague, the only surviving text is an the 16th-century work, and any link to the earlier one is unproven.
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Kobojunkie: 6:26pm On Oct 03
honesttalk21:
➜It may seem interesting though I first came across this book in 2000/2001 with some sense of intrigue. However the original Gospel of Barnabas appears among rejected apocrypha in the 5th-century Decretum Gelasianum and the List of the Sixty Books as the church fixed its canon by weighing apostolic authority;
➜ even though Barnabas was an apostle and Paul's colleague, the only surviving text is an the 16th-century work, and any link to the earlier one is unproven.
Wrong! There was no original Gospel of Barnabas. Rather, there was an Epistle of Barnabas, which was rejected as it was written in the 2nd century; it had no direct connection to the disciples of Jesus Christ of Israel. 😒😒

2. Barnabas, the apostle of Jesus Christ of Israel, lived and died before the end of the first century. The other Barnabas purported to have written the Epistle of Barnabas in the 2nd century, is not the same man, or reference to the same man. Also, a good read of the letter itself reveals it was literally a propaganda article, most likely compiled by a non-Jewish writer of that time.😒😒

1 2 Reply

The Key Of Barnabas: How To Be Born Again. • Why Is Prophet Muhammad Mentioned Only Four Times In The Quran ? • What Will Happen To Those Who Died Without Hearing The Gospel Of Jesus? • 2 • 3 • 4

Have You Entered Into This Personal Discipleship Training? • Opportunities. • A Typical Vision 2020 Church