₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,307 members, 8,522,313 topics. Date: Friday, 20 November 2026 at 10:56 PM

Toggle theme

Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas - Christianity Etc (2) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas (357 Views)

1 2 Reply (Go Down)

Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by honesttalk21: 8:09pm On Oct 03
Kobojunkie:
Wrong! There was no original Gospel of Barnabas. Rather, there was an Epistle of Barnabas, which was rejected as it was written in the 2nd century; it had no direct connection to the disciples of Jesus Christ of Israel. 😒😒

2. Barnabas, the apostle of Jesus Christ of Israel, lived and died before the end of the first century. The other Barnabas purported to have written the Epistle of Barnabas in the 2nd century, is not the same man, or reference to the same man. Also, a good read of the letter itself reveals it was literally a propaganda article, most likely compiled by a non-Jewish writer of that time.😒😒
Please don’t confuse the Epistle of Barnabas with the Gospel of Barnabas. They’re different. The Epistle is an anonymous Greek Christian text, likely composed between the late first and early second centuries and maybe as late as 130 CE. The writer takes on a teaching role, but there’s no solid proof he was actually Barnabas, Paul’s companion. Early Christians didn’t just toss it aside either. Clement of Alexandria leaned on it heavily, treating it with significant authority. It even made the cut for Codex Sinaiticus in the fourth century. That inclusion doesn’t mean everyone accepted it as canonical, though.

The Decretum Gelasianum lists a Gospel of Barnabas among apocryphal works, but that’s not the same book we have today. The surviving version comes down to us via a sixteenth-century Italian manuscript and an eighteenth-century Spanish one. Scholars generally date it to the medieval period. One influential study even pins the Italian text to the fourteenth century.

Sure, the Epistle is polemical. It fiercely argues against Jewish interpretations of Scripture. Calling it propaganda by a non-Jewish writer goes too far, though. We can’t establish that with certainty. The author’s identity and background are still unknown. Labeling him non-Jewish is an interpretation, not a demonstrable fact.
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Kobojunkie:
honesttalk21:
Please don’t confuse the Epistle of Barnabas with the Gospel of Barnabas. They’re different. The Epistle is an anonymous Greek Christian text, likely composed between the late first and early second centuries and maybe as late as 130 CE. The writer takes on a teaching role, but there’s no solid proof he was actually Barnabas, Paul’s companion. Early Christians didn’t just toss it aside either. Clement of Alexandria leaned on it heavily, treating it with significant authority. It even made the cut for Codex Sinaiticus in the fourth century. That inclusion doesn’t mean everyone accepted it as canonical, though.
The Decretum Gelasianum lists a Gospel of Barnabas among apocryphal works, but that’s not the same book we have today. The surviving version comes down to us via a sixteenth-century Italian manuscript and an eighteenth-century Spanish one. Scholars generally date it to the medieval period. One influential study even pins the Italian text to the fourteenth century.
Sure, the Epistle is polemical. It fiercely argues against Jewish interpretations of Scripture. Calling it propaganda by a non-Jewish writer goes too far, though. We can’t establish that with certainty. The author’s identity and background are still unknown. Labeling him non-Jewish is an interpretation, not a demonstrable fact.
Wrong! There was never a previous Gospel of Barnabas. Why? Because records have it that THE Gospel of Barnabas was written around 1400- 1600 years after Jesus Christ of Israel and his disciples lived. 😒😒

The list, Decretum Gelasianum, does not dispute this fact at all. If I were to write a Gospel today -- say, the Gospel of Bartholomew --, which is on that list. That would in no way suggest that such a book existed sometime in the past.😒😒
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by MaxInDHouse(m): 9:50pm On Oct 03
Anything as long as it supports the Arabian guy goes with you!🥱
honesttalk21:
Please don’t confuse the Epistle of Barnabas with the Gospel of Barnabas. They’re different. The Epistle is an anonymous Greek Christian text, likely composed between the late first and early second centuries and maybe as late as 130 CE. The writer takes on a teaching role, but there’s no solid proof he was actually Barnabas, Paul’s companion. Early Christians didn’t just toss it aside either. Clement of Alexandria leaned on it heavily, treating it with significant authority. It even made the cut for Codex Sinaiticus in the fourth century. That inclusion doesn’t mean everyone accepted it as canonical, though.

The Decretum Gelasianum lists a Gospel of Barnabas among apocryphal works, but that’s not the same book we have today. The surviving version comes down to us via a sixteenth-century Italian manuscript and an eighteenth-century Spanish one. Scholars generally date it to the medieval period. One influential study even pins the Italian text to the fourteenth century.

Sure, the Epistle is polemical. It fiercely argues against Jewish interpretations of Scripture. Calling it propaganda by a non-Jewish writer goes too far, though. We can’t establish that with certainty. The author’s identity and background are still unknown. Labeling him non-Jewish is an interpretation, not a demonstrable fact.
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by honesttalk21: 9:52pm On Oct 03
Kobojunkie:
Wrong! There was never a previous Gospel of Barnabas. Why? Because records have it that THE Gospel of Barnabas was written around 1400- 1600 years after Jesus Christ of Israel and his disciples lived. 😒😒

The list, Decretum Gelasianum, does not dispute this fact at all. If I were to write a Gospel today -- say, the Gospel of Enoch --, it would probably also end up on that list. That would in no way suggest that such a book existed sometime in the past.😒😒
If the Decretum Gelasianum, a list from around the 6th century, names a Gospel of Barnabas, how does your Gospel of Enoch show that the listed work never existed? A sixth-century list can't be naming a book written centuries later. And would writing a Gospel of Enoch today prove that no earlier Gospel attributed to Enoch ever existed?

I agree the surviving Gospel of Barnabas is medieval and not apostolic. But does its late date establish anything beyond the date of that manuscript? The Decretum gives neither the earlier work's contents nor its relation to the medieval text, so what evidence lets you merge the two?

So isn't the real question not was the surviving Gospel late? but what proves the listed Gospel of Barnabas never existed as a separate work?
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by honesttalk21: 10:10pm On Oct 03
MaxInDHouse:
Anything as long as it supports the Arabian guy goes with you!🥱
Have I stated acceptance of the veracity of the original statement? Why do you think that means anything? I am only letting the op know what is and isn't but you see an opportunity to engage me so engage.
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Kobojunkie: 10:18pm On Oct 03
honesttalk21:
➜If the Decretum Gelasianum, a list from around the 6th century, names a Gospel of Barnabas, how does your Gospel of Enoch show that the listed work never existed?
➜ A sixth-century list can't be naming a book written centuries later. And would writing a Gospel of Enoch today prove that no earlier Gospel attributed to Enoch ever existed?
➜ I agree the surviving Gospel of Barnabas is medieval and not apostolic.
➜ But does its late date establish anything beyond the date of that manuscript? The Decretum gives neither the earlier work's contents nor its relation to the medieval text, so what evidence lets you merge the two?
➜ So isn't the real question not was the surviving Gospel late? but what proves the listed Gospel of Barnabas never existed as a separate work?
1. Aside the list, the very first mention of the Gospel of Barnabas came in the 1600s. The list, which dates back to the 500s, claims such a book existed, but we have no evidence that it did. 😒😒

2. It can't. However, a list is also not proof that it did. I had originally meant writing a book called Gospel of Bartholomew, which is included in the list instead of Gospel of Enoch. 😒😒

3. It is not medieval. It was literally written less than 500 years ago, most likely in the 1600s. 😒😒

4. Nor does it provide evidence that such a text even existed at the time of the writing of the lists by the Catholic organization. 😒😒

5. These are terrible questions to ask given what we have or know. 😒😒
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by honesttalk21: 10:29pm On Oct 03
Kobojunkie:
1. Aside the list, the very first mention of the Gospel of Barnabas came in the 1600s. The list, which dates back to the 500s, claims such a book existed, but we have no evidence that it did. 😒😒

2. It can't. However, a list is also not proof that it did. I had originally meant writing a book called Gospel of Bartholomew, which is included in the list instead of Gospel of Enoch. 😒😒

3. It is not medieval. It was literally written less than 500 years ago, most likely in the 1600s. 😒😒

4. Nor does it provide evidence that such a text even existed at the time of the writing of the lists by the Catholic organization. 😒😒

5. These are terrible questions to ask given what we have or know. 😒😒
You started with never existed and ended at a list is not proof that it did. That's unknown, not never existed, and I'm fine leaving it there. I'm not here to hand you what to believe. Whatever you decide to accept, you can find it yourself. The resources are within your reach.
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Kobojunkie:
honesttalk21:
➜You started with never existed and ended at a list is not proof that it did. That's unknown, not never existed, and I'm fine leaving it there.
➜ I'm not here to hand you what to believe.
➜ Whatever you decide to accept, you can find it yourself. The resources are within your reach.
Wrong! I started by pointing out that the very first reference that revealed the existence of such a book came in the 1600s, not in the 500s. And it was to the book that had been circulating at the time, the one we have today, which we know was likely written in the 1600s.
Gospel of Barnabas is a 17th-century text that retells the life of Jesus from an Islamic perspective, portraying him as a human prophet rather than the Son of God and naming Judas Iscariot as the one crucified in his place.
The reference was made in the Spanish Morisco manuscript, which was written by an Islamist by the name.
The earliest known mention of a Gospel of Barnabas appears in a 1634 manuscript written in Tunis by Ibrahim al-Taybili, a Morisco (a forcibly baptized Muslim of Spanish origin).
A list is a list and not proof of existence. 😒😒

2. Nor should you be here making stuff up because you found a list. 😒😒

3. You shouldn't accept anything without evidence. And again, a list is not proof of existence. 😒😒
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by MaxInDHouse(m): 11:22pm On Oct 03
honesttalk21:
Have I stated acceptance of the veracity of the original statement? Why do you think that means anything? I am only letting the op know what is and isn't but you see an opportunity to engage me so engage.
If i should ask you questions about your Muhammad now it's going to turn to stories upon stories.
That's the funniest thing about you Muslims, you quickly jump into the comment section to talk about Jesus or his disciples quoting what the Bible say but your own Muhammad has no real story to follow.

Father, mother, wife, children and followers are all confusing stories so that different story books were written about the same man some you people call strong while some you call weak.

Is that what you think about the Bible?🙂
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by honesttalk21: 12:10am On Oct 04
Kobojunkie:
Wrong! I started by pointing out that the very first reference that revealed the existence of such a book came in the 1600s, not in the 500s. And it was to the book that had been circulating at the time, the one we have today, which we know was likely written in the 1600s.
The reference was made in the Spanish Morisco manuscript, which was written by an Islamist by the name.
A list is a list and not proof of existence. 😒😒

2. Nor should you be here making stuff up because you found a list. 😒😒

3. You shouldn't accept anything without evidence. And again, a list is not proof of existence. 😒😒
Aside the list' is the whole disagreement. You can't set aside the one piece of evidence against your claim and keep the claim. The Decretum Gelasianum, likely sixth century, lists a Gospel under the name of Barnabas, and the Greek List of the Sixty Books, a separate and later list, has one too (https://ccat.sas.upenn.edu/rak/courses/735/Parabiblical/lists.htm). So your first mentioned in the 1600s is true of the surviving text and false of the title.
I agree a list is not proof the work existed, and I never said it was. I'm not defending the surviving book or claiming it's the same work. No evidence it existed supports unknown, not never existed.
So which is your claim? Is it that the surviving text first appears in the 1600s, which we agree on, or that nobody referred to a Gospel of Barnabas before then, which two earlier lists contradict?
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Kobojunkie: 12:20am On Oct 04
honesttalk21:
➜Aside the list' is the whole disagreement. You can't set aside the one piece of evidence against your claim and keep the claim. The Decretum Gelasianum, likely sixth century, lists a Gospel under the name of Barnabas, and the Greek List of the Sixty Books, a separate and later list, has one too (https://ccat.sas.upenn.edu/rak/courses/735/Parabiblical/lists.htm). So your first mentioned in the 1600s is true of the surviving text and false of the title.
I agree a list is not proof the work existed, and I never said it was. I'm not defending the surviving book or claiming it's the same work. No evidence it existed supports unknown, not never existed.
So which is your claim? Is it that the surviving text first appears in the 1600s, which we agree on, or that nobody referred to a Gospel of Barnabas before then, which two earlier lists contradict?
For the umpteenth time, one: the argument was never on whether such a title existed but whether such a book ever existed. Two: a list is not evidence of the existence of a book or books. The first mention and reference to the actual book came not long after the book that we have today came into existence, and this was about 500 years ago.😒😒
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by honesttalk21: 1:44am On Oct 04
Kobojunkie:
For the umpteenth time, one: the argument was never on whether such a title existed but whether such a book ever existed. Two: a list is not evidence of the existence of a book or books. The first mention and reference to the actual book came not long after the book that we have today came into existence, and this was about 500 years ago.😒😒
Fine, you are right but let's put your claims side by side. At 8:14pm Oct 03, you say 'There was never a previous Gospel of Barnabas.' At 10:18pm Oct 03 you say 'we have no evidence that it did.' The first is a claim of non-existence. The second is a claim about the limits of the evidence. They are not interchangeable.

I agree a catalogue entry doesn't prove the earlier Gospel existed, and I haven't claimed it's proven. But the entry's limits don't prove it never existed either, so your 8:14pm statement needs more than 'a list is not proof.'

So which are you defending? A) The surviving Gospel of Barnabas is a late work. B) No earlier Gospel attributed to Barnabas ever existed. If A, we agree. If B, where is the evidence of non-existence, as opposed to the absence of surviving evidence?
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by Kobojunkie: 2:05am On Oct 04
honesttalk21:
➜Fine, you are right but let's put your claims side by side. At 8:14pm Oct 03, you say 'There was never a previous Gospel of Barnabas.' At 10:18pm Oct 03 you say 'we have no evidence that it did.' The first is a claim of non-existence. The second is a claim about the limits of the evidence. They are not interchangeable.
I agree a catalogue entry doesn't prove the earlier Gospel existed, and I haven't claimed it's proven. But the entry's limits don't prove it never existed either, so your 8:14pm statement needs more than 'a list is not proof.'
So which are you defending? A) The surviving Gospel of Barnabas is a late work. B) No earlier Gospel attributed to Barnabas ever existed. If A, we agree. If B, where is the evidence of non-existence, as opposed to the absence of surviving evidence?
Stop spitting obvioius nonsense! Again, a list is not evidence of the existence of a book or books! 😒😒
Re: Was Muhammad Mentioned In The Gospel Of Barnabas by honesttalk21: 2:23am On Oct 04
Kobojunkie:
Stop spitting obvioius nonsense! Again, a list is not evidence of the existence of a book or books! 😒😒
Is nonsense what you call reminding you of your previous statements? Is it the reminder or your statements now?
I'm not claiming the list proves the book existed, so you're answering something I didn't say. You've also moved from 'not proof' to 'not evidence,' which is a stronger claim than you made at 10:18pm.
My question is about your 8:14pm Oct 03 statement that 'There was never a previous Gospel of Barnabas.' That is a claim of non-existence, and 'a list doesn't prove it existed' doesn't get you there. So which are you arguing:

1) we can't establish from the surviving evidence that an earlier Gospel existed,

or

2) we know it never existed? If 1, stop saying 'never.' If 2, give the evidence of non-existence."

Simple.
1 2 Reply

The Key Of Barnabas: How To Be Born Again. • Why Is Prophet Muhammad Mentioned Only Four Times In The Quran ? • What Will Happen To Those Who Died Without Hearing The Gospel Of Jesus? • 2 • 3 • 4

Have You Entered Into This Personal Discipleship Training? • Opportunities. • A Typical Vision 2020 Church