₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,331 members, 8,522,410 topics. Date: Saturday, 21 November 2026 at 08:10 AM

Toggle theme

Overpraising The Prophet ﷺ In Islam! - Islam (4) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Islam › Overpraising The Prophet ﷺ In Islam! (3035 Views)

1 2 3 4 Reply (Go Down)

Re: Overpraising The Prophet ﷺ In Islam! by TV01(m): 1:06pm On Oct 18
GreenCovering:
By constantly remembering God in all his inactions and actions. Thus he attained to the highest level of closeness to God and he was, as a result, granted a visit to witness Divine Presence in heaven while he was alive as a human being as declared by the holy Qur'an:
This is at best an opinion. Please root it in religious text or in history so that it can be examined. It is in ee.slam that a narrative has to be contrived to buttress every claim. Claims which themselves are often lacking evidence or clear writ. For me, it fails to hold , fails to convince.

GreenCovering:
Glory be to the One Who took His servant ˹Muḥammad˺ by night from the Sacred Mosque to the Farthest Mosque whose surroundings We have blessed, so that We may show him some of Our signs. Indeed, He alone is the All-Hearing, All-Seeing.
Qur'an 17:1
When did this happen? Please identify the mosques in question. Was it a physical or out of body experience?

Then he approached and came closer, and was at a distance of two bow-lengths or even closer
Qur'an 53:9

GreenCovering:
No other prophet of God has attained this status in their prophetic missions according to Islam.
According to ee.slam, which describes The Lord Jesus Christ as "sinless" and as the "Messiah"? According to ee.slam, which claims authorship of all the previous scriptures, which all point to and are fulfilled by the Lord Jesus Christ. Without the whiff of a mention or prophecy of anyone by the name of Muhammed?

GreenCovering:
Being at the pinnacle of spiritual state attainable by mankind means he has, by this constant remembrance of God and making God his central focus in all he does, attained such a spiritual status that saw him transcend all the heavenly bounds attainable by men and prophets and angels to the point that only God Almighty can speak of.
More opinion, further contrived narrative. Required to elevate Muhammed and justify his claims and the status his adherents ascribe to him.

GreenCovering:
Allahu ta'ala has never declared the Prophet Muhammad a sinner neither has he ever declared himself a sinner. Rather he operates within the guard rail of always seeking forgiveness from God as an act of supreme humility, gratitude, and a way to teach the Muslim community the best practice to approach God to purify your deeds or to seek forgiveness. One cannot claim goodness before God. Rather you protect your good works by asking forgiveness from God for your shortcomings even if your ways are pure. Thereafter He will raise you in ranks, status and influence because of your unblemished good works.
Works based acceptance by God?

Contrast this with the in-depth exposition of The Lord Jesus Christ as Holy, As a High Priest & Intercessor called by God Himself. How despite being sinless, he attained to the authorship of salvation to those who believe in Him by what he undertook on their behalf and the sacrifice He made for them. I never cease to be amazed by the fullness of the Christian scriptures. The detail,
comprehensiveness, how joined up and how much sense they make. I find all of this missing in the ee.slam.ic Scriptures.

Called by God
Hebrews 5:5 - So also Christ did not glorify Himself to become High Priest, but it was He who said to Him: “You are My Son, Today I have begotten You.”
Hebrews 5:6 - As He also says in another place: “You are a priest forever According to the order of Melchizedek”;
Hebrews 6:20 - where our forerunner, Jesus, has entered on our behalf. He has become a high priest forever, in the order of Melchizedek.
Hebrews 7:28 - For the law appoints as high priests men in all their weakness; but the oath, which came after the law, appointed the Son, who has been made perfect forever.

A fitting High Priest
Hebrews 2:14 - Inasmuch then as the children have partaken of flesh and blood, He Himself likewise shared in the same, that through death He might destroy him who had the power of death, that is, the devil,
Hebrews 2:17 - Therefore, in all things He had to be made like His brethren, that He might be a merciful and faithful High Priest in things pertaining to God, to make propitiation for the sins of the people.
Hebrews 7:26 - For such a High Priest was fitting for us, who is holy, harmless, undefiled, separate from sinners, and has become higher than the heavens;

Obedience and the things He suffered to become the Autor of Salvation
Hebrews 5:8 - though He was a Son, yet He learned obedience by the things which He suffered.
Hebrews 5:9 - And having been perfected, He became the author of eternal salvation to all who obey Him,

I don't have to put together a just so story, or a nicely penned narrative to justify any claims. It's all there. Detailed, perfect, as is my Lord & Saviour Jesus Christ.

A faith that claims to be the continuation of Judaism and Christianity, fails to mention priesthood, propitiation, the requirements for being a mediator, the blood, the sacrifices or any of the other major themes. It merely points to a figure who has no connection, lineage, witnesses, no miracles or scripture to attest, just claims and artful narratives. I can't buy that. Sorry, not sorry.


TV
Re: Overpraising The Prophet ﷺ In Islam! by Kukutente23: 1:23pm On Oct 18
GreenCovering:
By constantly remembering God in all his inactions and actions. Thus he attained to the highest level of closeness to God and he was, as a result, granted a visit to witness Divine Presence in heaven while he was alive as a human being as declared by the holy Qur'an:


Glory be to the One Who took His servant ˹Muḥammad˺ by night from the Sacred Mosque to the Farthest Mosque whose surroundings We have blessed, so that We may show him some of Our signs. Indeed, He alone is the All-Hearing, All-Seeing.

Qur'an 17:1


Then he approached and came closer, and was at a distance of two bow-lengths or even closer

Qur'an 53:9

No other prophet of God has attained this status in their prophetic missions according to Islam.



Being at the pinnacle of spiritual state attainable by mankind means he has, by this constant remembrance of God and making God his central focus in all he does, attained such a spiritual status that saw him transcend all the heavenly bounds attainable by men and prophets and angels to the point that only God Almighty can speak of.




Allahu ta'ala has never declared the Prophet Muhammad a sinner neither has he ever declared himself a sinner. Rather he operates within the guard rail of always seeking forgiveness from God as an act of supreme humility, gratitude, and a way to teach the Muslim community the best practice to approach God to purify your deeds or to seek forgiveness. One cannot claim goodness before God. Rather you protect your good works by asking forgiveness from God for your shortcomings even if your ways are pure. Thereafter He will raise you in ranks, status and influence because of your unblemished good works.
Where is Isa now?
Your claim that only Muhammad has ascended to heaven is not based on the Qur'an at all
Re: Overpraising The Prophet ﷺ In Islam! by GreenCovering:
TV01:
...
Omnipotence would be demonstrated and inferred rather than taught. I shouldn't have too, but here goes,

1. The Lord Jesus Christ claimed universal authority - Matthew 28:18
This so called claim occurred after the supposed resurrection of Jesus which according to Islam does not exist. It's a complete hogwash. This is strengthened by the conflicting accounts of the aftermath of the crucifixion even in your bible.

TV01:
2. The Lord Jesus Christ demonstrated authority over nature - Mark 4:39
We have stories of companion of the holy prophet Muhammad (s.a.w.) and other muslim saints who calmed seas, walked over water or saved sinking ships but we don't refer to these people as omnipotent. Their call to God were simply accepted by God at that point as far as Islam is concerned.

TV01:
3. The Lord Jesus Christ demonstrated authority over demons - Mark 1:27
Something alfas in your neighbourhood are doing effectively on a daily without carrying microphone to hoodwink people?

TV01:
4. The Lord Jesus Christ demonstrated authority to forgive sins - Mark 2:5-7
"There is no Muslim who is afflicted with illness or any hardship except that Allah removes his sins just as a tree sheds its leaves."1
— Sahih al-Bukhari 5660 & Sahih Muslim 257

Perhaps this is what Jesus was referring to. That is, the man was in distress already and has the mercy of God. But the envious scribes were quick to be accusative of him.

TV01:
5. The Lord Jesus Christ demonstrated authority life and death - John 11
Many muslims saints attained this feat too. Again, Islam treats them as prayer answered.

TV01:
6. The Lord Jesus Christ demonstrated authority over nature - Mark 4:39
Repeated

TV01:
7. The Lord Jesus Christ demonstrated authority to grant life - eternal life - John 10:28
Generally people accept faith and believe in God so that they have eternal life in Paradise. So how is this verse you quoted any more special than that? But if you want to use this as a proof for omnipotence then let me share this with you in Islam: There are people the holy Prophet Muhammad has mentioned by name that they have already made Paradise while they were still living on earth. That is, nothing is going to change that forever. Do we then call him omnipotent because of this? No. Rather, it is the privileged revelation to him by God that let him know this. Even your bible scholars call that verse the verse of the good shepherd. How does that mean omnipotence. Is shepherding showing omnipotence? So your own understanding is skewed.

Moving on. The concept of Miracle in Islam is broader than what you have listed above. In Islam, there are miracles that are considered anecdotal and there are miracle that are considered universal. Anecdotal miracles are considered localised and restricted to the time and people where they occurred. Everything you have listed fall into this category. None of the so called miracles can be attested to by anyone again today beyond the places and times where they occurred.

As a result they are usually subject to dispute, doubt or even rejection. Whereas for universal miracle, it is witnessed from the time that it happened and will continue to be witnessed by all who are living till the end of time. The holy prophet Muhammad (s.a.w.) is blessed with both categories of miracles. My point is built around the universal miracles:

Have you ever wondered why since the first time the holy Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w.) performed salat, it has remained so till the present day and so shall it remain till the day of judgment? Today over 2 billion people the world over perform the same salat that he did that first time, at the same exact times that he performed them, of the same numbers and using the same set of Divine words. That is an example of a universal miracle. No other prophet of God commands this influence on humanity. And it is going to remain so till the world comes to an end. He also gave us the Holy Qur'an, same book wherever you go in the world. And it shall remain so till the day of Judgement. No version this or version that, or a type for one group and another type for another group. These are some of the common and obvious examples to start with. Essentially his worships became natural laws. Have you ever wondered this?
Re: Overpraising The Prophet ﷺ In Islam! by TV01(m): 1:05pm On Oct 21
GreenCovering:
This so called claim occurred after the supposed resurrection of Jesus which according to Islam does not exist. It's a complete hogwash. This is strengthened by the conflicting accounts of the aftermath of the crucifixion even in your bible.
Please! Nothing is ee.slam is verfied by historical or non-ee.slam.ic sources. Nothing that can contradict the Torah or the Gospel, or that was previously unnown.

GreenCovering:
We have stories of companion of the holy prophet Muhammad (s.a.w.) and other muslim saints who calmed seas, walked over water or saved sinking ships but we don't refer to these people as omnipotent. Their call to God were simply accepted by God at that point as far as Islam is concerned.
As in fables, tale by moonlight, just-so stories. Nothing attested to or historically affirmed by non-ee.slam.ic sources. Nothing near-term of scientifically validated. Nothing!

GreenCovering:
Something alfas in your neighbourhood are doing effectively on a daily without carrying microphone to hoodwink people?
Nothing! No current or historical records.

GreenCovering:
"There is no Muslim who is afflicted with illness or any hardship except that Allah removes his sins just as a tree sheds its leaves."1
— Sahih al-Bukhari 5660 & Sahih Muslim 257

Perhaps this is what Jesus was referring to. That is, the man was in distress already and has the mercy of God. But the envious scribes were quick to be accusative of him.
Nope! Hadiths are not contemporary or even near-term to the ee.slam.ic prophet or his lifetime. Not catalogued with academic rigour or scientifically validated, and mostly composed to strengthen political and factional claims. Not accepted by all moose.slims and often disputed, or used tactically to buttress other fabricated narratives

GreenCovering:
Many muslims saints attained this feat too. Again, Islam treats them as prayer answered.
Muslim saints - lol!

GreenCovering:
Generally people accept faith and believe in God so that they have eternal life in Paradise. So how is this verse you quoted any more special than that? But if you want to use this as a proof for omnipotence then let me share this with you in Islam: There are people the holy Prophet Muhammad has mentioned by name that they have already made Paradise while they were still living on earth. That is, nothing is going to change that forever. Do we then call him omnipotent because of this? No. Rather, it is the privileged revelation to him by God that let him know this. Even your bible scholars call that verse the verse of the good shepherd. How does that mean omnipotence. Is shepherding showing omnipotence? So your own understanding is skewed.
The prophet of ee.sla did not know his own end. How could he have foretold others huh
Chapter 46 verse 9 - Say, "I am not something original among the messengers,1 nor do I know what will be done with me or with you. I only follow that which is revealed to me, and I am not but a clear warner."

GreenCovering:
Moving on. The concept of Miracle in Islam is broader than what you have listed above. In Islam, there are miracles that are considered anecdotal and there are miracle that are considered universal. Anecdotal miracles are considered localised and restricted to the time and people where they occurred. Everything you have listed fall into this category. None of the so called miracles can be attested to by anyone again today beyond the places and times where they occurred.
The works of The Lord Jesus Christ (All Authority Be Unto Him - AABUH) were attested to by non-Christian sources.

GreenCovering:
As a result they are usually subject to dispute, doubt or even rejection. Whereas for universal miracle, it is witnessed from the time that it happened and will continue to be witnessed by all who are living till the end of time. The holy prophet Muhammad (s.a.w.) is blessed with both categories of miracles. My point is built around the universal miracles:
Nope - he hmself said he was only a messenger. In the Quran, when he was asked to perform a miracle to witness his claims, he repeatedly says that he was sent with none, and gives the reason. Any claims in the wholesale bogus hadiths, was to buttress false claims and problematic lack of witness. The koran for you;

They say, “Why hath not a sign been sent down unto him from his Lord?” SAY, “Signs belong unto the Lord: and as for me, I am but a plain preacher. Al Ankabut 29:48

The unbelievers say, “Why hath not a sign been given by his Lord? Nay, but thou art only a Warner; and unto every people there hath been given a guide. Al Ra’d 13:8

And when thou dost not show unto them a sign, they say, “Why hast thou avoided to bring it?” SAY, “Verily, I follow that only wherewith the Lord hath inspired me.” This (revelation) is a witness from your Lord, a guide and a mercy to the people that believe.
Al Araf 7:204

And nothing hindered Us from sending (thee) with miracles, but that those of old time gave them the lie Bani Israel 17:58
GreenCovering:
Have you ever wondered why since the first time the holy Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w.) performed salat, it has remained so till the present day and so shall it remain till the day of judgment? Today over 2 billion people the world over perform the same salat that he did that first time, at the same exact times that he performed them, of the same numbers and using the same set of Divine words. That is an example of a universal miracle. No other prophet of God commands this influence on humanity. And it is going to remain so till the world comes to an end. He also gave us the Holy Qur'an, same book wherever you go in the world. And it shall remain so till the day of Judgement. No version this or version that, or a type for one group and another type for another group. These are some of the common and obvious examples to start with. Essentially his worships became natural laws. Have you ever wondered this?
Not miracles, rituals, catechism. Also answered above.

You do a nice line in sweet fables, but no truth. Such sweetness rots souls.


TV
1 2 3 4 Reply

40 Benefits Of Sending Salawat On The Prophet (ﷺ) By Imam Ibn Al-qayyim Al-jawzi • Why Prophet Muhammad ﷺ Is Ranked Number One By Michael Hart! • 40 Benefits Of Sending Salawat On The Prophet (ﷺ) By Imam Ibn Al-qayyim Al-jawzi • 2 • 3 • 4

What Is The Definition Of A Muslim According To The Quran Or Hadith? • Happy Moulud Nabbiyi To All Muslim Ummah. • Nobody Can Corrupt The Bible