₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,344,980 members, 8,514,811 topics. Date: Saturday, 07 November 2026 at 12:42 PM

Toggle theme

Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? - Christianity Etc - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? (681 Views)

1 Reply (Go Down)

Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by imagrg(op): 6:13pm On Jul 08, 2024
The Bible made me understand that Ishmael was Abraham's first son and that he(Abraham), was to sacrifice his first son to God as an offering for his faithfulness and obedience to the Will of God.

The Bible says it's Isaac that was to be the sacrificial lamb but the Quran says it's Ismael.

If you ask my opinion, I would take sides with the Islamic injunction about this story for two reasons:

1. That Sarah after all she suffered to have that child, she wouldn't have allowed Abraham to even attempt sacrificing Isaac for any reason but could frame up Ishmael for the sacrifice for fear of him being the beneficiary of Abraham's wealth after his death.

2. That Ishmael was actually Abraham's first son in spite of his purported illegitimacy.

What do you think?
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by Coolsat(m): 6:18pm On Jul 08, 2024
It was Ishmael, Isaac wasn't even born then else how will God ask him to sacrifice his only son if Isaac has been born by the time of the sacrifice.
It's logic
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by Greatzeus(m): 6:21pm On Jul 08, 2024
It's simple and common sense
Where did the story of Abraham attempt to sacrifice his son Isaac from? The Holy Bible. Which was written hundreds to a thousand years before Christ.
Where did the story of Abraham attempt to sacrifice his son Ishmael from? The Holy Quran. Which was written 600 years after Christ.
Now use your head and open mind and answer this question yourself. Peace✌️
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by imagrg(op): 6:22pm On Jul 08, 2024
Well defined!
You hit the head on the nail! grin
Coolsat:
It was Ishmael, Isaac wasn't even born then else how will God ask him to sacrifice his only son if Isaac has been born by the time of the sacrifice.
It's logic
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by Coolsat(m): 6:24pm On Jul 08, 2024
imagrg:
Well defined!
You hit the head on the nail! grin
watch them come to twist it to suit their narrative. Sometimes we should make use of our senses
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by Kez11: 6:37pm On Jul 08, 2024
The story is just a myth
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by muyico(m): 6:45pm On Jul 08, 2024
Coolsat:
It was Ishmael, Isaac wasn't even born then else how will God ask him to sacrifice his only son if Isaac has been born by the time of the sacrifice.
It's logic
yeah! U re right!
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by RealityKings: 6:47pm On Jul 08, 2024
Greatzeus:
It's simple and common sense
Where did the story of Abraham attempt to sacrifice his son Isaac from? The Holy Bible. Which was written hundreds to a thousand years before Christ.
Where did the story of Abraham attempt to sacrifice his son Ishmael from? The Holy Quran. Which was written 600 years after Christ.
Now use your head and open mind and answer this question yourself. Peace✌️
After giving birth to Ishmael, the son of Abram, Hagar and her son are banished from the house of Abraham (at the request of Sarai)
Abraham had already sent Hagar and the son away long before the sacrifice was demanded of him.


I wonder What kind of Bible are Imagrg is reading sef?
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by MaxInDHouse(m): 7:10pm On Jul 08, 2024
Abraham never saw Ishmael as his son from day one because Hagai wasn't his legitimate wife that's why he doesn't care what Sarah will do to the slave girl and her pregnancy.

Secondly when God promised Abraham that his children will become many throughout the earth he wanted to accept that Ishmael was the promised child but God told him that it's not Ishmael but Isaac the child to be born by his legitimate wife! Genesis 17:18-21

Hagai herself has been told by God's angel that Ishmael will breed terrorists and not the type of children that will produce the fruit of faith! Genesis 16:11-12

So when Sarah demanded that Hagai and her son be sent away Abraham was told to let go of the child since he's not the promised child that will produce the fruit of faith! Genesis 21:8-14

The lineage that has ever produced prophets mentioned in the Quran itself is that of Isaac there was never one single prophet from the lineage of Ishmael!

So when the scriptures say Abraham's only child it was evident that the child in question is the one promised to him because that's the promise that led him out of the land of his ancestors he surely knew Ishmael couldn't be his only child after all it's now evident that the delay came due to Sarah's barrenness his impotency on his own part. Genesis 25:1

It's that heritage Jacob bought from Esau with a bowl of stew the promise of the fruit that will save mankind from their sins {Genesis 12:1-3} which is Jesus Christ! Isaiah 9:6
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by advanceDNA: 7:42pm On Jul 08, 2024
imagrg:
Well defined!
You hit the head on the nail! grin
...no wonder fake pastors tell u pple all manner of rubbish and u guys don't bother to check
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by advanceDNA: 7:47pm On Jul 08, 2024
Coolsat:
watch them come to twist it to suit their narrative. Sometimes we should make use of our senses
Lol...... How are u using ur head?? grin
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by Coolsat(m): 7:54pm On Jul 08, 2024
advanceDNA:
Lol...... How are u using ur head?? grin
Don't engage me rudely. Swerve
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by advanceDNA: 9:04pm On Jul 08, 2024
Coolsat:
Don't engage me rudely. Swerve
U triggered already?? No vex angry

Me I just wanted to know how u used ur head in this matter....
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by Figh1990: 8:33am On Jul 09, 2024
Both religious texts portray Abraham as a prophet of great faith and obedience to Uno Online. There are some differences in details throughout the stories, including the sacrifice.
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by KnownUnknown: 11:27am On Jul 09, 2024
Coolsat:
It was Ishmael, Isaac wasn't even born then else how will God ask him to sacrifice his only son if Isaac has been born by the time of the sacrifice.
It's logic
Funny how “logic” did not lead you to the correct conclusion that the story is a depraved fairy tale.
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by KnownUnknown: 11:29am On Jul 09, 2024
MaxInDHouse:
Abraham never saw Ishmael as his son from day one because Hagai wasn't his legitimate wife that's why he doesn't care what Sarah will do to the slave girl and her pregnancy.
The deplorable protagonists of the Hebrew fairy tales never fail to horrify and amuse me.

Then abrahamic types cite these scumbags as the epitome of morality. Lmao what a joke?!
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by MaxInDHouse(m): 11:36am On Jul 09, 2024
KnownUnknown:
The deplorable protagonists of the Hebrew fairy tales never fail to horrify and amuse me.
Then abrahamic types cite these scumbags as the epitome of morality. Lmao what a joke?!
Who told you Abraham is the epitome of morality?
Well if you must know morality depends on the geographical location you come from what is called morals in one geographical location may be evil in another.
What the Bible say about Abraham is that he was upright in the face of the God who created all things! smiley
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by MightySparrow: 10:29am On Oct 20
Can anyone give a Quranic verse that supports Ismael?

Islam or Lieslam is a confusion.

Yahweh is not Allah;
Allah is not Yahweh.
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by Kobojunkie: 8:13am On Oct 22
imagrg:
● The Bible made me understand that Ishmael was Abraham's first son and that he(Abraham), was to sacrifice his first son to God as an offering for his faithfulness and obedience to the Will of God.
The Bible says it's Isaac that was to be the sacrificial lamb but the Quran says it's Ismael.
If you ask my opinion, I would take sides with the Islamic injunction about this story for two reasons:
1. That Sarah after all she suffered to have that child, she wouldn't have allowed Abraham to even attempt sacrificing Isaac for any reason but could frame up Ishmael for the sacrifice for fear of him being the beneficiary of Abraham's wealth after his death.
2. That Ishmael was actually Abraham's first son in spite of his purported illegitimacy.
What do you think?
Accepting one narrative means you not only have to reject in entirety the other version of the story but also completely accept that the rest of the book that contains the rejected narration is rendered invalid by your choice. 🤔🤔
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by Cancri: 10:21am On Oct 22
MightySparrow:
Can anyone give a Quranic verse that supports Ismael?

Islam or Lieslam is a confusion.

Yahweh is not Allah;
Allah is not Yahweh.
exactly, I keep saying this, the Christian God and Muslim God are not thesame, purely different entity.
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by MightySparrow: 6:26pm On Oct 23
Cancri:
exactly, I keep saying this, the Christian God and Muslim God are not thesame, purely different entity.
You see am so?
Islam is all confusion.
Re: Who Did Abraham Actually Want To Sacrifice To God? Isaac Or Ishmael? by MightySparrow: 6:27pm On Oct 23
MaxInDHouse:
Abraham never saw Ishmael as his son from day one because Hagai wasn't his legitimate wife that's why he doesn't care what Sarah will do to the slave girl and her pregnancy.

Secondly when God promised Abraham that his children will become many throughout the earth he wanted to accept that Ishmael was the promised child but God told him that it's not Ishmael but Isaac the child to be born by his legitimate wife! Genesis 17:18-21

Hagai herself has been told by God's angel that Ishmael will breed terrorists and not the type of children that will produce the fruit of faith! Genesis 16:11-12

So when Sarah demanded that Hagai and her son be sent away Abraham was told to let go of the child since he's not the promised child that will produce the fruit of faith! Genesis 21:8-14

The lineage that has ever produced prophets mentioned in the Quran itself is that of Isaac there was never one single prophet from the lineage of Ishmael!

So when the scriptures say Abraham's only child it was evident that the child in question is the one promised to him because that's the promise that led him out of the land of his ancestors he surely knew Ishmael couldn't be his only child after all it's now evident that the delay came due to Sarah's barrenness his impotency on his own part. Genesis 25:1

It's that heritage Jacob bought from Esau with a bowl of stew the promise of the fruit that will save mankind from their sins {Genesis 12:1-3} which is Jesus Christ! Isaiah 9:6
Which is more legitimate: Hagar son or keturah's
1 Reply

Who Was Sacrificed By Abraham Isaac Or Ishmael • Who Did Abraham Try To Sacrifice? • Isaac Or Ishmael: Who Did God Command Abraham To Offer As A Sacrifice? • 2 • 3 • 4

Dream Interpretation, Counseling, Word Of Knowledge Etc • Real Love!! • Soap And Salvation