₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,392 members, 8,522,784 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 November 2026 at 02:46 AM

Toggle theme

Hypothetical Question - Christianity Etc - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › Hypothetical Question (297 Views)

Poll: What would the community most likely conclude after reading the Bible independently?

They would recognise it as the word of their Creator and become Christians. 0% (0 votes)
They would find it an interesting collection of stories but question its supernatural claims. 0% (0 votes)
They would consider it strange mythology, filled with contradictions and unbelievable accounts, and reject it as true stories. 100% (1 vote)
This poll has ended

1 2 3 4 5 Reply (Go Down)

Hypothetical Question by Roycemadeit(op): 8:03am On Nov 03
Imagine an isolated English-speaking community that has never encountered Christianity. They have no churches, missionaries, pastors or prior knowledge of the Bible.

One day, a Bible mysteriously lands in their community. They discover it, read it from Genesis to Revelation and interpret it without anyone teaching them what to believe or telling them that it is God's word.

What do you think would be the most likely outcome?
Re: Hypothetical Question by MaxInDHouse(m): 8:54am On Nov 03
Roycemadeit:
Imagine an isolated English-speaking community that has never encountered Christianity. They have no churches, missionaries, pastors or prior knowledge of the Bible.

One day, a Bible mysteriously lands in their community. They discover it, read it from Genesis to Revelation and interpret it without anyone teaching them what to believe or telling them that it is God's word.

What do you think would be the most likely outcome?
Imagine a community that has never experienced cooked food but always eating whatever they they could see raw.
If pounded yam and vegetable soup should MYSTERIOUSLY land in their midst what do you think they will do with it?

Funny atheist!
Dear Mr Atheist, books are taken from place to place and it's those who knows it's value that carries it to different places after spending a lot to print it so stop deceiving yourself with childish nightmares!😂
Re: Hypothetical Question by Roycemadeit(op): 9:42am On Nov 03
MaxInDHouse:
Imagine a community that has never experienced cooked food but always eating whatever they they could see raw.
If pounded yam and vegetable soup should MYSTERIOUSLY land in their midst what do you think they will do with it?

Funny atheist!
Dear Mr Atheist, books are taken from place to place and it's those who knows it's value that carries it to different places after spending a lot to print it so stop deceiving yourself with childish nightmares!😂
.
You've actually made my point without realising it.

If pounded yam and vegetable soup mysteriously landed in a community that had never encountered either, how would they know what they were, how they were prepared, or whether they were even meant to be eaten?


You said someone would have to explain their value to them. Exactly! So, you can think logically but when it comes to your religious beliefs, you become Pinky?

Now apply that same reasoning to the Bible. If people need someone to tell them that the book is God's word, explain its stories, defend its contradictions and convince them of its divine authority, then how exactly does the book independently establish that it is the word of God?

That is precisely what my poll is asking. Not how Christianity spreads through missionaries, printing presses and evangelism, but whether people would independently recognise the Bible as divine revelation without prior religious instruction.😂
Re: Hypothetical Question by Templee333(m): 10:39am On Nov 03
MaxInDHouse:
Imagine a community that has never experienced cooked food but always eating whatever they they could see raw.
If pounded yMYSTERIOUSLY land in their midst what do you think they will do with it?

Funny atheist!
Dear Mr Atheist, books are taken from place to place and it's those who knows it's value that carries it to different places after spending a lot to print it so stop deceiving yourself with childish nightmares!😂
to spend money printing bibles is a financial mistake
Re: Hypothetical Question by StillDtruth: 9:09pm On Nov 03
You are being very fully for you have experienced how it is.

For when all the books in Literature in English eg Animal farm, Macbeth, The Concubine, Trials of Brother Jero, Hamlet etc were first dropped on you to read, you could never ever understand them, especially when they were talking about societies you know nothing about.

And you were already speaking English and yet you could not understand them.

So, you yourself are an example of the outcome of reading a book you can not understand without guidance because it is talking about something foreign and alien to your local society

So in the end this is still another rubbish thread and there is still no way to make sense of your silly antiGodism and antiChristianism
Re: Hypothetical Question by Roycemadeit(op): 9:19pm On Nov 03
StillDtruth:
ou are being very fully for you have experienced how it is.

For when all the books in Literature in English eg Animal farm, Macbeth, The Concubine, Trials of Brother Jero, Hamlet etc were first dropped on you to read, you could never ever understand them, especially when they were talking about societies you know nothing about.

And you were already speaking English and yet you could not understand them.

So, you yourself are an example of the outcome of reading a book you can not understand without guidance because it is talking about something foreign and alien to your local society

So in the end this is still another rubbish thread and there is still no way to make sense of your silly antiGodism and antiChristianism
.
.
This is why I say you don't have personal agency, you are running on programming. Ogbeni, vote and confront your foolishness

Person when they believe animals talk, suppose believe animal farm na true story na
Re: Hypothetical Question by Dtruthspeaker: 9:40pm On Nov 03
Roycemadeit:
.
.
This is why I say you don't have personal agency, you are running on programming. Ogbeni, vote and confront your foolishness

Person when they believe animals talk, suppose believe animal farm na true story na
See person wey open mouth ask rubbish question dey yarn apata dey talk OFF POINT now I don remind am how hin dey look like lama when dem drop sweet books on top hin head for literature in English, yet hin no understand Jack.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

You thought you found something intelligent only for me to show you that you are talking rubbish 🤣🤣🤣.

Which is why you are crying because you found that you have no answer 🤣🤣🤣 that you had to resort to fallacy of ad hominem and talking off point about animals talking in Animal farm is True when nobody ask you.🤣🤣🤣
Re: Hypothetical Question by FayaBall: 10:12pm On Nov 03
Roycemadeit:
.
.
This is why I say you don't have personal agency, you are running on programming. Ogbeni, vote and confront your foolishness

Person when they believe animals talk, suppose believe animal farm na true story na
This is disgraceful. I thought you would have given a brilliant counter only for you to resort to blackmail. What a shame.
Re: Hypothetical Question by Roycemadeit(op): 7:29am On Nov 04
FayaBall:
This is disgraceful. I thought you would have given a brilliant counter only for you to resort to blackmail. What a shame.
.
..
Why would I give a counter when they have already blackmailed themselves by surrendering their supposedly "God-given brains" to defend a collection of writings as unquestionable truth?

And here is something y'all disgracefully overlook: if a book is supposedly written or inspired by an omniscient God, intended to reveal himself and guide all humanity, why does it require endless interpretations, theological explanations, apologetics and competing denominations to establish what it actually means? Why do people read the same supposedly divine message and arrive at contradictory doctrines, each claiming to have understood God's intention? grin

If I pick up a book to learn something, I should be able to understand what it communicates, not spend my life trying to understand what it supposedly means, only to discover that another person has an entirely different interpretation. Dtruthspeaker comparison with literature actually misses the point. Shakespeare and Achebe were human authors writing literature, not an infallible omniscient God supposedly communicating universal truths to humanity.

If God wanted humanity to know something, surely he was capable of communicating it without creating thousands of competing interpretations and religious divisions. At some point, you have to ask yourself but I know y'all won't because you run on programming...
Re: Hypothetical Question by Roycemadeit(op): 7:43am On Nov 04
I wasn't even a Literature student, but I've always loved reading. I would save money from my lunch allowance to buy novels, visit libraries and raid my uncles' bookshelves whenever I travelled to the village. I've read books like The GodFather, Chances, The Testament by John Grisham, Shakespeare and countless others.

And it wasn't just novels. When I exhausted the books available, I moved to history. I read about the Yoruba people, the Benin Kingdom, the Songhai Empire, Dahomey, ancient Greece and Rome. Some of these were history textbooks my uncles had used in secondary school, which I brought back to Lagos and read for myself.

Interestingly, during one two-month vacation in JSS 2, having exhausted the novels available to me, I spent much of the time reading the Bible. I read extensively through the Pentateuch, wrote down questions as I encountered things I couldn't reconcile, and returned to Lagos expecting answers from my Sunday school teachers. Many times, they had none. Some simply told me to ask God when I got to heaven.

This idea that someone who questions the Bible must be incapable of understanding literature is rather amusing. I've read fiction, history and religious texts. I understand the difference between literary symbolism, allegory, historical accounts and claims presented as facts.

The problem was never that I couldn't understand what I was reading. It was that I kept asking questions about what I had read, and the people teaching it couldn't answer them, so they turn to interpretation, blackmail and retelling... Abel Damina is a pastor but just like the Adventist, he is not really a true Christian 😂
Re: Hypothetical Question by MaxInDHouse(m): 9:17am On Nov 04
Roycemadeit:
If pounded yam and vegetable soup mysteriously landed in a community that had never encountered either, how would they know what they were, how they were prepared, or whether they were even meant to be eaten?[/b]
So someone who knows about it must explain and surely it must be one who brought it.
That's the point!
Re: Hypothetical Question by Roycemadeit(op): 10:55am On Nov 04
MaxInDHouse:
So someone who knows about it must explain and surely it must be one who brought it.
That's the point!
..
.
Just as one used it to enslave people for years in the name of God and God did nothing...

Re: Hypothetical Question by Dtruthspeaker: 11:03am On Nov 04
Roycemadeit:
.
..
Why would I give a counter when [they have already blackmailed themselves by surrendering their supposedly "God-given brains" to defend a collection of writings as unquestionable truth?

And here is something y'all disgracefully overlook: if a book is supposedly written or inspired by an omniscient God, intended to reveal himself and guide all humanity, why does it require endless interpretations, theological explanations, apologetics and competing denominations to establish what it actually means? Why do people read the same supposedly divine message and arrive at contradictory doctrines, each claiming to have understood God's intention? grin

If I pick up a book to learn something, I should be able to understand what it communicates, not spend my life trying to understand what it supposedly means, only to discover that another person has an entirely different interpretation. Dtruthspeaker comparison with literature actually misses the point. Shakespeare and Achebe were human authors writing literature, not an infallible omniscient God supposedly communicating universal truths to humanity.

If God wanted humanity to know something, surely he was capable of communicating it without creating thousands of competing interpretations and religious divisions. At some point, you have to ask yourself but I know y'all won't because you run on programming...
You don't have any reasonable valid counter to give that is why you resorted to abuse (ad hominem fallacy)

And because you still did not have anything to say, you now had to moved post to raise another argument on "interpretation" to find something to say 🤣🤣🤣

You must be working in NIPOST EMS. 🤣🤣🤣
Re: Hypothetical Question by Roycemadeit(op): 11:31am On Nov 04
Dtruthspeaker:
You don't have any reasonable valid counter to give that is why you resorted to abuse (ad hominem fallacy)

And because you still did not have anything to say, you now had to moved post to raise another argument on "interpretation" to find something to say 🤣🤣🤣

You must be working in NIPOST EMS. 🤣🤣🤣
.
..
grin. You are just ridiculous 😂... Someone had to tell you about God using a book not God telling you about himself... Just as your ancestors were taught about their place as slaves using the Slave Bible

And yet I have no validity? Aren't you the one who ought to supply a counter?
Re: Hypothetical Question by StillDtruth: 12:30pm On Nov 04
Roycemadeit:
...This idea that someone who questions the Bible must be incapable of understanding literature is rather amusing. I've read fiction, history and religious texts. I understand the difference between literary symbolism, allegory, historical accounts and claims presented as facts.

The problem was never that I couldn't understand what I was reading. It was that I kept asking questions about what I had read, and the people teaching it couldn't answer them, so they turn to interpretation, blackmail and retelling... Abel Damina is a pastor but just like the Adventist, he is not really a true Christian 😂
This explains why you bend things you read and respond to here.

It's clear that you read but never understand. You are that kid in primary school who did not understand " brighter grammar" and could not answer the comprehension questions in intensive English.

They say it is called Hyperlexia.

So, even now you have gotten older and grown up you still haven't changed despite all the reading you forced yourself to do, you still dod not understand

This explains your antiGod and antiChristian fixation.

See how you bent my simple statement here

I said "...in Literature in English eg Animal farm, Macbeth, The Concubine, Trials of Brother Jero, Hamlet etc were first dropped on you to read, you could never ever understand them, especially when they were talking about societies you know nothing about..."

Yet see how you interpreted and bent it to 'This idea that someone who questions the Bible must be incapable of understanding literature is rather amusing'...

How my statement take bend reach like dis? 🤣🤣🤣
I shock 🤣🤣🤣

But now I understand,

AI Overview
Reading words without grasping their meaning is often described as hyperlexia (when someone can read words well above their age level but struggles with comprehension) or a breakdown in reading comprehension

Illusion of Competence:
You recognize the words on the page and feel like you know what is happening, but your brain has not actually processed or stored the core concepts
Re: Hypothetical Question by Dtruthspeaker:
Roycemadeit:
..
grin. You are just ridiculous 😂... Someone had to tell you about God using a book not God telling you about himself... Just as your ancestors were taught about their place as slaves using the Slave Bible

And yet I have no validity? Aren't you the one who ought to supply a counter?
First, since you couldn't supply a counter, you moved post to "interpretation".

I replied that you moved post to interpretation and the next thing you do is to move post again this time to complain about "God using a book to talk to me" . 🤣🤣🤣

And you say you are rational and logical? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

It is obvious you are going Ⓜ️.∆.D 🤣🤣🤣

That's why you work in NIPOST 🤣🤣🤣😆
Re: Hypothetical Question by Roycemadeit(op): 9:16pm On Nov 04
Dtruthspeaker:
First, since you couldn't supply a counter, you moved post to "interpretation".

I replied that you moved post to interpretation and the next thing you do is to move post again this time to complain about "God using a book to talk to me" . 🤣🤣🤣

And you say you are rational and logical? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

It is obvious you are going Ⓜ️.∆.D 🤣🤣🤣

That's why you work in NIPOST 🤣🤣🤣😆
.
.
The original question remains unanswered: would a community with no prior exposure to Christianity independently recognise the Bible as God's word simply by reading it?
Re: Hypothetical Question by Dtruthspeaker: 11:29pm On Nov 04
Roycemadeit:
The original question remains unanswered: would a community with no prior exposure to Christianity independently recognise the Bible as God's word simply by reading it?
The thread shows it's been answered even using you as the guinea pig 🤣🤣🤣
Re: Hypothetical Question by MaxInDHouse(m): 8:12am On Nov 05
Roycemadeit:
Just as one used it to enslave people for years in the name of God and God did nothing...
That's where you got it wrong because it's not necessarily that the person in whose hand you first saw it knew anything about it.
Someone may find it and think of how to use it for the wrong purpose that's why you need to know what it should produce just as the food we eat when you misuse it and got harmed it doesn't mean the food is poisonous rather you don't know how to make the best use of it.

Take for example the JWs have used the same book to unite people throughout the world and make a global family of peace loving worshipers just as it was written in the Bible book of Isaiah 2:2-4 and repeated at Micah 4:1-3
This is what the world needs and organizations have been trying to achieve this through lots of programs like OLYMPIC, FIFA, UNESCO, UNICEF just to mention a few but today only the organization using this same book (BIBLE) has successfully made it possible!🙂
Re: Hypothetical Question by Roycemadeit(op): 9:18am On Nov 05
MaxInDHouse:
That's where you got it wrong because it's not necessarily that the person in whose hand you first saw it knew anything about it.
Someone may find it and think of how to use it for the wrong purpose that's why you need to know what it should produce just as the food we eat when you misuse it and got harmed it doesn't mean the food is poisonous rather you don't know how to make the best use of it.

Take for example the JWs have used the same book to unite people throughout the world and make a global family of peace loving worshipers just as it was written in the Bible book of Isaiah 2:2-4 and repeated at Micah 4:1-3
This is what the world needs and organizations have been trying to achieve this through lots of programs like OLYMPIC, FIFA, UNESCO, UNICEF just to mention a few but today only the organization using this same book (BIBLE) has successfully made it possible!🙂
.
..
The book can be used for virtually anything, just like a knife. You can use it to cut vegetables or kill someone. The same Bible people use to promote peace has also been used to justify slavery, oppression and violence

The fact that Jehovah's Witnesses have built a global religious community around it doesn't prove divine authorship or guidance. It proves that human beings can organise themselves around a shared book and interpretation. Ultimately, it is humans who decide what is right or wrong about its application. God or the book itself doesn't speak up, correct anyone or independently direct its readers.


P.S: Might you be suggesting that other Christian denominations don't have peace loving worshippers?
Re: Hypothetical Question by MaxInDHouse(m): 6:29pm On Nov 05
Roycemadeit:
It proves that human beings can organise themselves around a shared book and interpretation.
Na wah for atheism!😂
Now present another book that has been used to achieve the same purpose or another organization that has successfully achieved this!🥱
Re: Hypothetical Question by Roycemadeit(op): 8:52pm On Nov 05
MaxInDHouse:
Na wah for atheism!😂
Now present another book that has been used to achieve the same purpose or another organization that has successfully achieved this!🥱
.

.
P.S. A constitution, for example. Human beings have used constitutions to organise societies, establish common principles, protect rights and hold people accountable. Do we now need to attribute that achievement to divine inspiration too? 😂
Re: Hypothetical Question by focusNig: 9:00pm On Nov 05
Roycemadeit:
.
You've actually made my point without realising it.

If pounded yam and vegetable soup mysteriously landed in a community that had never encountered either, how would they know what they were, how they were prepared, or whether they were even meant to be eaten?


You said someone would have to explain their value to them. Exactly! So, you can think logically but when it comes to your religious beliefs, you become Pinky?

Now apply that same reasoning to the Bible. If people need someone to tell them that the book is God's word, explain its stories, defend its contradictions and convince them of its divine authority, then how exactly does the book independently establish that it is the word of God?

That is precisely what my poll is asking. Not how Christianity spreads through missionaries, printing presses and evangelism, but whether people would independently recognise the Bible as divine revelation without prior religious instruction.😂
How are students convinced that the knowledge in a book can make the Doctors and Engineers?
Re: Hypothetical Question by Roycemadeit(op): 9:17am On Nov 06
focusNig:
How are students convinced that the knowledge in a book can make the Doctors and Engineers?
.
.
it is knowledge not belief
Re: Hypothetical Question by MaxInDHouse(m): 2:57pm On Nov 06
Roycemadeit:
P.S. A constitution, for example. Human beings have used constitutions to organise societies, establish common principles, protect rights and hold people accountable. Do we now need to attribute that achievement to divine inspiration too? 😂
Can you walk at night in the midst of people who organized the highlighted system?

Can you walk up to anyone in the same community confident that they will house you because their so called "CONSTITUTIONS" have molded them?

Well among Jehovah's Witnesses throughout the world i can do all of that.

Funny atheist!😂

They are ORGANIZED yet you're scared to walk at night and they are even using weapons to keep their so called CONSTITUTIONS!
Re: Hypothetical Question by LordReed(m): 3:25pm On Nov 06
Roycemadeit:
Imagine an isolated English-speaking community that has never encountered Christianity. They have no churches, missionaries, pastors or prior knowledge of the Bible.

One day, a Bible mysteriously lands in their community. They discover it, read it from Genesis to Revelation and interpret it without anyone teaching them what to believe or telling them that it is God's word.

What do you think would be the most likely outcome?
I assume they would have books and know what fiction is. In such a scenario they would think it was a good compilation of fictional works.
Re: Hypothetical Question by Roycemadeit(op): 5:41pm On Nov 06
LordReed:
I assume they would have books and know what fiction is. In such a scenario they would think it was a good compilation of fictional works.
.
.
Exactly, just as the bible is fictional
1 2 3 4 5 Reply

• 2 • 3 • 4

Divine Purpose • Repent Today! The Kingdom Of God Is At Hand! • Daily Spiritual Digest: False Evidence Appearing Real (FEAR)