BENUE TRIBUNAL: Four Exhibits Admitted Against David Mark - Politics - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › BENUE TRIBUNAL: Four Exhibits Admitted Against David Mark (919 Views)
| BENUE TRIBUNAL: Four Exhibits Admitted Against David Mark by sayyid(op): 7:06am On Aug 01, 2015 |
The National Assembly Election Petition
Tribunal sitting in Makurdi, the Benue State
capital, has admitted four exhibits from the
subpoenaed Independent National Electoral
Commission’s (INEC’s) witnesses in a
petition by Mr Daniel Onjeh of the All
Progressives Congress (APC) challenging the
return of Senator David Mark by the INEC.
The former Senate president was declared
winner of the Benue South election held on
March 28, having defeated Mr Daniel Onjeh.
Mr Yakubu Nachamada one of the witnesses
from INEC, could identify five documents,
which Onjeh sought to tender, but the
Peoples Democratic Party’s (PDP’s) counsel
Chris Alechenu, objected to the permissibility
of one of them
The document in question is a letter dated
July 27, authorising the INEC worker to be a
witness in the suit which did not originate
from the party.
Alechenu said the letter could only be
tendered in evidence either through the INEC
chairman, the resident electoral commissioner
or the writer of the letter which the witness
was not.
“The witness is not the writer, addressee and is
not even copied in the letter. So, the letter
cannot be tendered through him.”
Mr. Kenneth Ikoni, counsel to Mark, also
concurred with the views of the PDP counsel
and admonished the court not to accept the
letter as an exhibit.
Onjeh’s counsel, Tunji Oso, while urging the
court to discountenance the objections raised
by the respondents’ counsel, said the
document can be linked to the witness as
there are relevant and sufficient evidence
suggesting this.
He cited the Nigerian Weekly Law Report , page
17 (G-H) saying that “a document linking a
witness to an evidence can be tendered with or
without the consent of the writer or addressee.
The Chairman of the tribunal, Justice
Mosunmola Dipeolu, however, ruled that the
document was vital to the appearance of the
witness in court and admitted the document
in evidence as Exhibit PA.
The Card Reader Accreditation Data was also
admitted in evidence. The Card Reader
Accreditation Data that concerned elections in
the senatorial district reflecting the polling
units were generated from the INEC website
and was presented in court by Mr Yakubu
Nachamada.
The receipt for the certification of documents
was also admitted in evidence.
Oso saw his application to tender the
subpoena by the tribunal for the two
witnesses from INEC to testify in court turned
down.
Counsel to the PDP had pleaded with the
court to reject the admissibility of the order
on the grounds that it was already the
document of the court, stressing that the
court does not need it as an evidence.
The tribunal’s chairman, Justice Dipeolu
concurred with the respondents’ counsel and
rejected the ruled in favour of the PDP’s
counsel and adjourned the case for the
continuation of trial. www.naij.news/504428-benue-tribunal-four-exhibits-admitted-david-mark.html |
| Re: BENUE TRIBUNAL: Four Exhibits Admitted Against David Mark by heykims(m): 7:08am On Aug 01, 2015*. Modified: 7:31am On Aug 01, 2015 |
Mark had been doing it and going scot free under previous administrations, I hope he meets his doom this time around. As if there's no more reasonable person in the constituency, u going to the Senate for the 5th time, na ur birthright? |
| Re: BENUE TRIBUNAL: Four Exhibits Admitted Against David Mark by adioolayi(m): 7:11am On Aug 01, 2015 |
David Mark has been silent for sometime now...Could it probably mean he is sensing any Danger of losing his seat? |
| Re: BENUE TRIBUNAL: Four Exhibits Admitted Against David Mark by kuuljay(m): 7:13am On Aug 01, 2015 |
is this witch hunting too? |
| Re: BENUE TRIBUNAL: Four Exhibits Admitted Against David Mark by Tolexander: 7:27am On Aug 01, 2015 |
heykims:5th time, 1999, 2003, 2007, 2011and 2015. All the same, it doesn't mean if he's been in the Senate for long. The question is, has he been representing his district right? |
| Re: BENUE TRIBUNAL: Four Exhibits Admitted Against David Mark by heykims(m): 7:30am On Aug 01, 2015 |
Tolexander:Thanks brother, modified.. First question should have been "had he been legitimately winning those elections?" |
| Re: BENUE TRIBUNAL: Four Exhibits Admitted Against David Mark by wilybebsy(m): 7:31am On Aug 01, 2015 |
Wailerz be like APC propaganda |
| Re: BENUE TRIBUNAL: Four Exhibits Admitted Against David Mark by mentorandfriend(m): 7:32am On Aug 01, 2015 |
I hope he looses that seat. It will go a long way in strengthening the will of the people; that their votes count. I know for sure that Benue people voted APC in all strata of governance in the state. Where did David Mark come from? |
| Re: BENUE TRIBUNAL: Four Exhibits Admitted Against David Mark by Tolexander: 7:35am On Aug 01, 2015 |
heykims:that is a very good question bro! |
| Re: BENUE TRIBUNAL: Four Exhibits Admitted Against David Mark by sammyj: 8:15am On Aug 01, 2015 |
David is a goner. If found wanting should be send parking and maybe jailed for stolen mandate !!! ![]() |
| Re: BENUE TRIBUNAL: Four Exhibits Admitted Against David Mark by dayo23(f): 8:16am On Aug 01, 2015 |
Okay |
David Mark's Victory Upheld By Benue Tribunal • David Mark: Counsels Close Case, Benue Tribunal Set To Announce Date Of Judgment • Saraki: Tribunal Admits 3 Exhibits & PA Testifies Against Him In Court • 2 • 3 • 4
PHOTOS: Senior British Military Officers Visit To DHQ • Fayose Accuses Fayemi Of Betraying APC, Tinubu • Abacha Almost Killed Me, Says Obasanjo
